Bibliometric Analysis

First Author1, Aidi Ahmi 2,1*, Third Author3

1
Faculty of Economics and Business, Universitas Airlangga, Jl. Airlangga 4-6 Surabaya, Indonesia
2
Tunku Puteri Intan Safinaz School of Accountancy, Universiti Utara Malaysia 06010 UUM Sintok, Kedah, Malaysia
3
Affiliation of the third author

*Corresponding author E-mail: aidi@uum.edu.my

Abstract

Purpose –

Design/methodology/approach –

Findings –

Research limitations/implications –

Originality/value –

Keywords:

1. INTRODUCTION

Background….

Problem statements…

Objectives/aims of the paper…

Research Questions…

The rest of this paper is structures as follow… The next section…

2. LITERATURE REVIEW

2.1. Bibliometric Analysis

2.2. Past Studies

 Table X. Summary of previous studies
Domain/Search Data Source & Bibliometric Attributes
Author TDE
Strategy Scope Examined
Junior and “fintech” or “fintechs” Emerald, 1,749 - Type of publications
Cherobim or “fintec*” ProQuest, - Source title
[17] Science Direct,
Scopus, Web of
Science and
Google Scholar
Wu [18] fintech-related Web of Science 885 - Journal rank by total citations
(2015-2017) - Keywords distribution
Still et al. ‘fintech’ Web of Science 110 - Frequency of paper
[19] (January 1, 1980 - Co-occurrence of terms based
and May 24, on titles and abstracts
2018)
Liu, Li “financial technology”, Web of Science 629 - Publication trend
and Wang “finance technology”, (1995 to 2017) - Paper classification
[20] “fintech”, “fin-tech” and - Highly cited journal
“e-finance” - Active institutions
- Core authors
- Citation network and
clustering
- Co-citations analysis
- Co-cited keywords
Li et al. internet financ* or Web of Science 2,887 - Co-word
[21] online financ* or (2008-2018) - Co-citation networks
electronic finance* or e-
financ* or internet-
based financ* or internet
banking or online
banking or electronic
banking or e-banking or
internet-based banking
or internet bank or
online bank or
electronic bank or e-
bank or internet-based
bank or
Martínez- “peer-to-peer lending” Web of Science 237 - Publications per year
Climent, or “peer to peer (2008-2018) - Highest country
Zorio- lending” or “equity - Productive journals
Grima and crowdfunding” or - Authors productivity
Ribeiro- “equity crowd-funding” - Type of publication
Soriano
[22]
TDE=Total documents examined

3. METHODS

3.1. Search Strategy

 Topic E-Commerce

Database: Scopus
Scope & Coverage Search Field: Article Title
Time Frame: All
Language: All
Topic Source Type: All
, Document Type: All
Scope
&
Eligib
ility Keywords & Search TITLE("ecommerce" OR "e-commerce" OR "e commerce"
String OR "electronic commerce") AND ( LIMIT-TO
( DOCTYPE,"ar" ) ) AND ( LIMIT-TO
( LANGUAGE,"English" ) ) AND ( LIMIT-TO
( SRCTYPE,"j" ) )

Date Extracted 25 July 2020

Record Identified & n = 4656

Screened
Scree
ning
Record Removed n=0

Record Included for

Inclu Bibliometric Analysis n = 4656
ded

Figure 1. Flow diagram of the search strategy.

Source: Zakaria et al. (2020), Moher et al. (2009)

3.2. Data Analysis

3.3. Tools

…
3.4.
4. RESULTS

4.1. Documents Profiles

...

Table X. Document Type

Document Type Total Publications (TP) Percentage (%)
Article 402 63.6
Conference Paper 97 15.3
Book Chapter 50 7.9
Note 6 0.9
Review 43 6.8
Editorial 2 0.3
Book 27 4.3
Short Survey 1 0.2
Undefined 1 0.2
Total 632 100.00

...

Table X. Source Type

Source Type Total Publications (TP) Percentage (%)
Journals 402 69.3
Conference Proceedings 100 17.24
Book Series 50 8.62
Books 27 4.7
Trade Publications 1 0.17
Total 580 100.00

Table X. Languages
Language Total Publications (TP)* Percentage (%)
English 600 97.30
German 1 1.08
Portuguese 3 0.81
Chinese 1 0.27
French 4 0.27
Italian 9
Russian 6
Spanish 8 0.27
Total 371 100.00
*one document has been prepared in dual languages

Table X. Subject Area

Subject Area Total Publications (TP) Percentage (%)
Engineering 106 9.0
Social Sciences 221 18.8
Environmental Science 35 3.0
Medicine 193 16.4
Energy 6 0.63
Computer Science 79 6.7
Arts and Humanities 38 3.2
Earth and Planetary Sciences 11 1.15
 Business, Management and Accounting 208 17.7
Mathematics 13 1.36
Economics, Econometrics and Finance 89 7.6
Agricultural and Biological Sciences 8 0.84
Nursing 36 3.1
Materials Science 8 0.84
Physics and Astronomy 9 0.94
Decision Sciences 22 2.31
Health Professions 17 1.78
Biochemistry, Genetics and Molecular Biology 4 0.42
Psychology 47 4.0
Chemical Engineering 10 1.05
Multidisciplinary 5 0.52
Immunology and Microbiology 1 0.11
Chemistry 3 0.32
Neuroscience 2 0.21
Pharmacology, Toxicology and Pharmaceutics 4 0.42

4.2. Publication Trends

...

Table X. Year of Publication

Year TP NCP TC C/P C/CP h g
2013 40 11.62 2309 164 164 4 4
2014 32 7.30 447 261.43 261.43 15 28
2015 34 8.65 510 23.79 27.37 19 43
2016 36 7.03 642 14.17 17.84 23 50
2017 30 5.14 656 8.62 12.77 23 39
2018 43 8.38 801 5.88 8.80 20 31
2019 44 5.95 888 2.26 4.57 13 19
2020 47 3.24 984 0.55 2.19 5 8
2021 56 1240
2022 49 1618
2021 16 11.62 555 0 0 0 0
Total 371
Notes: TP=total number of publications; NCP=number of cited publications; TC=total citations; C/P=average citations per
publication; C/CP=average citations per cited publication; h=h-index; and g=g-index.
 70 1200

60 1000
50
800
Total Publications

Total Citations
40
600
30
400
20

10 200

0 0
9 1 5 3 5 7 9 1 3 5 7 9
1 97 1 99 1 99 2 00 2 00 2 00 2 00 2 01 2 01 2 01 2 01 2 01

Year

Figure X. Total Publications and Citations by Year

4.3. Publications by Authors

Table X. Most Productive Authors

Author’s
Affiliation Country TP NCP TC C/P C/CP h g
Name
Bonde, J,P. University of Toronto Hong Kong 35 12 270 15.88 22.5 5 16
University of
Iavicoli,s. Malaysia 35 12 270 15.88 22.5 5 16
Washington
The University of
Jensen,J.H. North Carolina at Hong Kong 23 12 270 15.88 22.5 5 16
Chapel Hill
Universiteit van
Flachs, E.M. Malaysia 19 12 270 15.88 22.5 5 16
Amsterdam
National Institute for
Kramer, D.M. . Occupational Safety Hong Kong 17 12 270 15.88 22.5 5 16
and Health
Lavoi-
La Trobe University Malaysia 17 12 270 15.88 22.5 5 16
Tremblay, M.
University of
Punnett, L. Hong Kong 16 12 270 15.88 22.5 5 16
Montreal
Rod, N.H. Työterveyslaitos
Malaysia 16 12 270 15.88 22.5 5 16
Rondinone,
Western University Hong Kong 16 12 270 15.88 22.5 5 16
B.M.
Skakon, J. Karolinska Institutet Malaysia 15 12 270 15.88 22.5 5 16
Notes: TP=total number of publications; NCP=number of cited publications; TC=total citations; C/P=average citations per
publication; C/CP=average citations per cited publication; h=h-index; and g=g-index.

...

Table X. Number of Author(s) per document

Author Total Publications Percentage
Count (TP) (%)
1 206 18.68
2 296 26.84
3 284 25.75
4 175 15.87
5 67 6.07
 6 42 3.81
7 9 0.82
8 7 0.63
9 1 0.09
10 2 0.18
11 1 0.09
21 1 0.09
22 1 0.09
26 1 0.09
0* 10 0.91
Total 1103 100.00
*Conference review document. No author is listed.

4.4. Publications by Institutions

...

Table X. Most productive institutions with minimum of five publications

Affiliation Country TP NCP TC C/P C/CP h g
University of Toronto Taiwan 14 16 229 9.54 14.31 7 15
University of Washington USA 13 17 318 13.83 18.71 6 17
The University of North Carolina
China 13 13 246 15.38 19.92 7 15
at Chapel Hill
Universiteit van Amsterdam Malaysia 12 12 691 49.36 57.58 7 14
National Institute for
Malaysia 12 8 21 1.62 2.63 3 4
Occupational Safety and Health
La Trobe University Hong Kong 8 9 49 3.77 4.22 5 6
University of Montreal Australia 7 5 13 1.18 2.60 2 3
Työterveyslaitos Taiwan 7 6 199 19.9 33.17 5 10
Western University USA 7 7 441 44.10 63.00 5 10
Karolinska Institutet China 6 16 229 9.54 14.31 7 15
Notes: TP=total number of publications; NCP=number of cited publications; TC=total citations; C/P=average citations per
publication; C/CP=average citations per cited publication; h=h-index; and g=g-index.

4.5. Publications by Countries

Table X. Top 20 Countries contributed to the publications

Country TP NCP TC C/P C/CP h g
United States 265 340 7404 15.73 21.79 41 77
United Kingdom 127 90 367 1.83 4.08 9 14
Spain 125 87 1177 9.27 13.53 20 32
Brazil 64 55 1623 21.08 29.51 16 40
Portugal 52 39 246 3.84 6.31 7 13
Germany 48 36 209 3.60 5.81 7 12
Italy 46 33 520 10.20 15.76 11 22
France 39 29 353 7.06 12.17 10 18
Japan 34 34 386 8.04 11.35 8 19
Australia 33 25 201 4.28 8.04 7 13
Norway 27 20 61 1.65 3.05 4 6
Greece 26 12 113 3.53 9.42 3 10
South Korea 26 19 333 11.10 17.53 8 18
Austria 24 13 30 1.07 2.31 3 4
China 21 11 47 2.04 4.27 4 6
 Country TP NCP TC C/P C/CP h g
India 21 13 85 4.25 6.54 3 9
Turkey 19 16 223 11.15 13.94 9 14
Canada 18 14 117 5.85 8.36 6 10
Malaysia 18 12 287 16.88 23.92 4 16
Ecuador 15 3 7 0.5 2.33 2 2
Switzerland 11 6 111 7.93 18.50 4 10
Belgium 10 9 31 2.38 3.44 3 5
United States 265 5 28 2.33 5.60 3 5
United Kingdom 127 6 30 3.00 5.00 4 5
Spain 125 6 80 8.00 13.33 4 8
Brazil 64 7 186 18.60 26.57 6 10
Notes: TP=total number of publications; NCP=number of cited publications; TC=total citations; C/P=average citations per
publication; C/CP=average citations per cited publication; h=h-index; and g=g-index.

4.6. Publications by Source Titles

...

Table X. Most active source titles

Cite SNI
SJR
Source Title TP TC Publisher Scor P
2020
e 2020
Journal of Information Systems 19 85 American Accounting N/A N/A N/A
6 Association
International Journal of 17 34 Elsevier B. V. N/A N/A N/A
Accounting Information Systems
New Dimensions of Business 11 69 Springer 2.44 0.9 1.25
Reporting and XBRL 2
International Journal of Digital 10 40 University of Huelva 1.78 0.46 1.09
Accounting Research 5 4 9
Ceur Workshop Proceedings 9 1 Sun SITE Central Europe N/A N/A N/A
International Journal of Disclosure 8 38 Palgrave Macmillan 1.06 0.28 0.71
and Governance 3 3
Journal of Emerging Technologies 8 33 American Accounting 3.53 1.08 1.99
in Accounting 2 Association 5 5
Lecture Notes in Computer 8 21 Springer Nature 4.07 1.41 2.35
Science Including Subseries 0 9 4
Lecture Notes in Artificial
Intelligence and Lecture Notes in
Bioinformatics
International Journal of 7 49 Emerald Publishing 7.72 2.32 3.79
Accounting and Information 2 Limited 3 7
Management
Lecture Notes in Information 7 43 Springer Nature 0.97 0.21 0.81
Systems and Organization 9 9
Issues in Accounting Education 6 0 American Accounting 0.51 0.22 0.45
Association 1 4
Accounting Horizons 5 13 American Accounting 0.43 0.15 0.50
 Cite SNI
SJR
Source Title TP TC Publisher Scor P
2020
e 2020
6 Association 5 3
Decision Support Systems 5 10 Elsevier B. V. N/A N/A N/A
International Journal of E Business 5 5 IGI Global 0.00 0.10 0.10
Research 2 1
Notes: TP=total number of publications; TC=total citations; CiteScore = average citations received per document published
in the source title; SJR = SCImago Journal Rank measures weighted citations received by the source title; SNIP = source
normalised impact per paper measures actual citations received relative to citations expected for the source title’s subject
field.

4.7. Citation Metrics

Table X. Citations metrics

Metrics Data
Papers 4972
Number of Citations 91556
Years 52
Citations per Year 1760.69
Citations per Paper 18.41
Citations per Author 37876.55
Papers per Author 2363.6
Authors per Paper 3.11
h-index 127
g-index 220

4.8. Highly Cited Documents

Table X. Top 20 highly cited articles

Cites
No. Authors Title Cites
per Year
1 Review: A review of culture in information 192.18
Leidner, D.E.,
systems research: Toward a theory of 1146
Kayworth, T.
information technology culture conflict
2 Fosso Wamba, S., 92.31
How 'big data' can make big impact:
Akter, S., Edwards, A.,
Findings from a systematic review and a 1010
Chopin, G., Gnanzou,
longitudinal case study
D.
3 Coe, N.M., Dicken, P., Global production networks: Realizing the 73.67
984
Hess, M. potential
4 Dalenogare, L.S., 50.7
The expected contribution of Industry 4.0
Benitez, G.B., Ayala, 870
technologies for industrial performance
N.F., Frank, A.G.
5 Wormuth, M., What are the sources of exposure to eight 803 52.89
Scheringer, M., frequently used phthalic acid esters in
Vollenweider, M., Europeans?
 Hungerbühler, K.
6 Tabak, R.G., Khoong, Bridging research and practice: Models for 38.91
E.C., Chambers, D.A., dissemination and implementation 787
Brownson, R.C. research
7 Towards sustainable smart cities: A review 67.08
Silva, B.N., Khan, M.,
of trends, architectures, components, and 772
Han, K.
open challenges in smart cities
8 Panagioti, M., 51.57
Panagopoulou, E.,
Bower, P., Lewith, G.,
Controlled interventions to reduce burnout
Kontopantelis, E.,
in physicians a systematic review and 637
Chew-Graham, C.,
meta-analysis
Dawson, S., Van
Marwijk, H., Geraghty,
K., Esmail, A.
9 Bakıcı, T., Almirall, E., A Smart City Initiative: The Case of 38.28
620
Wareham, J. Barcelona
10 Mobile 3D mapping for surveying 73.78
Siebert, S., Teizer, J. earthwork projects using an Unmanned 587
Aerial Vehicle (UAV) system
11 Theorell, T., 40.94
Hammarström, A.,
Aronsson, G., A systematic review including meta-
Träskman Bendz, L., analysis of work environment and 572
Grape, T., Hogstedt, depressive symptoms
C., Marteinsdottir, I.,
Skoog, I., Hall, C.
12 Kecklund, G., Health consequences of shift work and 15.69
563
Axelsson, J. insufficient sleep
13 Distributed leadership in organizations: A 32.89
Bolden, R. 553
review of theory and research
14 Economic and social upgrading in global 63.78
Barrientos, S., Gereffi,
production networks: A new paradigm for a 535
G., Rossi, A.
changing world
15 Kniffin, K.M., COVID-19 and the workplace: Implications, 531 49
Narayanan, J., Anseel, issues, and insights for future research and
F., Antonakis, J., action.
Ashford, S.P., Bakker,
A.B., Bamberger, P.,
Bapuji, H., Bhave, D.P.,
Choi, V.K., Creary, S.J.,
Demerouti, E., Flynn,
F.J., Gelfand, M.J.,
Greer, L.L., Johns, G.,
Kesebir, S., Klein, P.G.,
Lee, S.Y., Ozcelik, H.,
Petriglieri, J.L.,
Rothbard, N.P.,
Rudolph, C.W., Shaw,
J.D., Sirola, N.,
Wanberg, C.R.,
 Whillans, A., Wilmot,
M.P., Vugt, M.V.
16 Varieties of liberalization and the new 44.75
Thelen, K. 528
politics of social solidarity
17 Psychosocial safety climate as a precursor 38.36
Dollard, M.F., Bakker, to conducive work environments,
516
A.B. psychological health problems, and
employee engagement
18 Allen, J., Balfour, R., 52.7
Social determinants of mental health 503
Bell, R., Marmot, M.
19 Institutionalizing dualism: 51.4
Palier, B., Thelen, K. Complementarities and change in France 490
and Germany
20 Review: A review of culture in information 25.32
Leidner, D.E.,
systems research: Toward a theory of 1146
Kayworth, T.
information technology culture conflict

4.9. Top Keywords

...

Table X. Top author’s keywords

Author Keywords Total Publications (TP) Percentage (%)
Human 192 8.4
Workplace 179 7.2
Humans 167 1.7
Article 131 1.6
Innovation 86 1.2
Organizational Innovation 80 1
Occupational Health 78 1
Organization 76 1
Female 68 0.8
Adult 66 0.8
Male 64 0.8
Organization And Management 54 0.8
Middle Aged 46 0.6
Employment 42 0.6
Questionnaire 38 0.6
Health Care Personnel 35 0.5
United States 35 0.5
Organizational Culture 32 0.5
Health Promotion 31 0.5
Psychology 30 0.5

4.10. Co-authorship Analysis

…

4.10.1. Co-authorship by author

Figure X. Network visualisation map of the co-authorship by authors

4.10.2. Co-authorship by organisations

Figure X. Network visualisation map of the co-authorship by organisations

4.11. Co-occurrence Analysis

4.11.1. Co-occurrence analysis of author’s keywords

Figure X. Network visualisation of the author’s keywords

Figure X. Overlay visualisation of the author’s keywords

Table X. Themes of research based on author’s keywords

 4.11.2. Co-occurrence analysis of terms based on title and abstract

Figure X. Network visualisation of a term co-occurrence network based on title and abstract fields

Figure X. Overlay visualisation of a term co-occurrence network based on title and abstract fields

Table X. Themes of research based on title and abstract fields

4.12. Citation Analysis

 4.12.1. Citation analysis by documents

Figure X. Network visualisation map of the citation by documents

5. DISCUSSION

RQ…

Contribution of the study

Future research direction

6. CONCLUSION

Summary –

Limitation of the study –

Future research due to the limitations of the study

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
REFERENCES

Abdul Rahman, N.A., Ahmi, A., Jraisat, L. and Upadhyay, A. (2022). Examining the trend of
humanitarian supply chain studies: pre, during and post COVID-19 pandemic. Journal of
Humanitarian Logistics and Supply Chain Management, Vol. ahead-of-print No. ahead-of-
print. https://doi.org/10.1108/JHLSCM-01-2022-0012 
Ahmi, A., Saidin, S. Z., Mohd Nasir, M. H., & Ismail, Z. (2020). Applicability of Lotka’s Law in
eXtensible Business Reporting Language (XBRL) Studies. International Journal of Advanced
Science and Technology, 29(6), 282–289.
Hassan, S., & Ahmi, A. (2022) Mapping the State of the Art of Scientific Production on Requirements
Engineering Research: A Bibliometric Analysis. International Journal of Information
Technologies and Systems Approach, 15(1), 1-23. https://doi.org/10.4018/IJITSA.289999
Ishak, M. S., Sarkowi, A., Ahmi, A., Abdulrauf-Salau, A., & Memon, S. (2023). Global Research
Trends in School Bullying: A Bibliometric Analysis. Journal of Educational and Social
Research, 13(1), 91. https://doi.org/10.36941/jesr-2023-0009
Kushairi, N., Ahmi, A. (2021) Flipped classroom in the second decade of the Millenia: A
bibliometrics analysis with Lotka’s law. Education and Information Technologies, 26(4), 4401-
4431. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10639-021-10457-8
Mansour, A.Z., Ahmi, A., Popoola, O.M.J. and Znaimat, A. (2021), Discovering the global landscape
of fraud detection studies: a bibliometric review, Journal of Financial Crime, 29(2), 701-
720 https://doi.org/10.1108/JFC-03-2021-0052
Tuyon, J., Onyia, O.P., Ahmi, A., & Huang, C.H. (2022). Sustainable financial services: reflection
and future perspectives. Journal of Financial Services
Marketing. https://doi.org/10.1057/s41264-022-00187-4
Wahid, R., Ahmi, A., & Alam, A. F. (2020). Growth and Collaboration in Massive Open Online
Courses: A Bibliometric Analysis. The International Review of Research in Open and
Distributed Learning, 21(4), 292-322. https://doi.org/10.19173/irrodl.v21i4.4693
Wahyudi, M., Ahmi, A. and Herianingrum, S. (2022). Examining Trends, Themes and Social
Structure of Zakat Literature: A Bibliometric Analysis. Global Journal Al-Thaqafah, 12(1), 40
- 67. https://doi.org/10.7187/GJAT072022-3
Zakaria, R., Ahmi, A., Ahmad, A. H., & Othman, Z. (2021) Worldwide Melatonin Research: A
Bibliometric Analysis of the Published Literature between 2015 and 2019, Chronobiology
International, 38(1), 27-37. https://doi.org/10.1080/07420528.2020.1838534
Zakaria, R., Ahmi, A., Ahmad, A. H., Othman, Z., Azman, K. F., Ab Aziz, C. B., Ismail, C. A. N., &
Shafin, N. (2021). Visualising and mapping a decade of literature on honey research: a
bibliometric analysis from 2011 to 2020. Journal of Apicultural Research, 60(3), 359-
368. https://doi.org/10.1080/00218839.2021.1898789