You are on page 1of 7

Article: TME200151 Date: January 24, 2012 Time: 17:12

Advanced Emergency Nursing Journal


Vol. 34, No. 1, pp. 75–81
Copyright 
C 2012 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins

Hypothermia in the Trauma Patient


How Vital Is This Sign?
Christopher D. McLarty, MSN, ACNP-BC, CEN, TNS

Abstract
Recognizing the adverse impact that trauma has on a patient’s overall well-being and hemodynamic
stability is key to successful management and improved outcomes for this patient population. It
is well established that trauma is accompanied by deadly pathophysiological sequelae, referred to
as the “trauma triad.” This triad is characterized by hypothermia, acidosis, and coagulopathy. This
triad is cyclic and, moreover, each element of the triad builds upon one another to exacerbate the
next. Hence, evidence demonstrates that it is important to recognize the cycle and intervene early
to reduce or prevent negative outcomes. Key words: advanced practice, hypothermia, trauma,
trauma triad

T
RAUMATIC INJURY is a significant those deaths occurring later in life. The life
threat to the well-being of Americans. years lost indicator measures the projected
As reported by the Centers for Disease years of life lost by the patient due to a partic-
Control and Prevention (CDC), of the 123.8 ular cause of death in proportion to the total
million emergency department (ED) visits life years lost due to premature mortality of all
recorded for 2008, a total of 42.4 million visits causes in the population at large (Finklestein
were injury related (CDC, 2008). In terms of & Alam, 2010). In fact, unintentional injury is
economic burden, trauma costs the U.S. econ- the leading cause of death for persons aged 1–
omy $406 billion a year, a sum that accounts 44 years and is considered the fifth most com-
for both health care costs and lost productiv- mon cause of death for all ages (CDC, 2008).
ity (Finklestein & Alam, 2010). Health care providers and dedicated clini-
Life years lost is a term used to measure the cians work tirelessly to save trauma patients.
impact of trauma on society. This measure Regardless of what particular level of trauma
takes into account the age at which deaths center a physician, nurse, or other provider
occur, giving a greater weight to deaths oc- works in, trauma basics share a common ap-
curring at younger ages and lesser weight to proach involving primary and secondary sur-
veys. Needless to say, just the mere presence
Author Affiliations: Division of Trauma and Emer- of vital signs in a trauma patient portends a
gency Surgery, The University of Arizona Medical Cen-
ter, Tucson, Arizona; and AeroCare Medical Transport better outcome for the patient. However, of
Systems, Scottsdale, Arizona. those vital signs, which require particular at-
Disclosure: The author reports no conflicts of interest. tention? No doubt, nonlabored respirations,
Corresponding Author: Christopher D. McLarty, MSN, a normal sinus rhythm, and a normal blood
ACNP-BC, CEN, TNS, Division of Trauma and Emer- pressure are all positive signs that bode well
gency Surgery, The University of Arizona Medical Cen-
ter, 1501 N Campbell Avenue, Tucson, Arizona 85724 for the patient. What consideration should
(christopher.mclarty@gmail.com). be given to the patient’s temperature? Is it
DOI: 10.1097/TME.0b013e3182437d01 necessary to maintain core temperature for

75

Copyright © 2012 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Article: TME200151 Date: January 24, 2012 Time: 17:12

76 Advanced Emergency Nursing Journal

every patient? Furthermore, what is con- inhibited, leading to development of coagu-


sidered to be a normal temperature range? lopathy (Mallet, 2002).
Finally and most importantly, does hypother- Volume loss and decreased availability of
mia have an independent effect on the oxygen lead to inadequate cellular perfusion.
outcome? These changes in cellular perfusion induce
anaerobic metabolism at the cellular level, in-
creasing lactic acid production, which leads
PATHOPHYSIOLOGY
to profound metabolic acidosis. Although aci-
Physiologically, the impact of hypothermia dosis has little effect on clotting under con-
alone is significant. When hypothermia oc- ditions of normothermia, it intensifies the
curs in the setting of trauma, it has been noted adverse effects of hypothermia and syner-
that a “core temperature decrease of 0.3 ◦ C is gistically worsens clotting times (Dirkmann,
associated with as much as a 7% increase in Hanke, Görlinger, & Peters, 2008). Working
oxygen consumption” (Moore, 2008, p. 62). independently of one another, “hypothermia
Hemorrhage commonly accompanies trauma primarily inhibits thrombin generation in the
and reduces a patient’s circulating blood vol- initiation phase, whereas acidosis severely
ume. This results in decreased availability of impair thrombin generation in the propaga-
oxygen for cellular aerobic metabolism. In tion phase” (Martini, 2009b, pp. 207–208).
the presence of traumatic injury and hem- In the presence of trauma, hypothermia in-
orrhage, the excess oxygen consumption in- hibits the synthesis of fibrinogen, thereby pre-
duced by hypothermia further compromises venting the formation of fibrin, while acidosis
the patient’s ability to maintain cellular func- contributes to advanced fibrinogen degrada-
tion. Moreover, the increased oxygen con- tion. This quickly results in ineffective clot-
sumption combined with the reduced circu- ting, leading to a state of coagulopathy. As
lating volume further disrupts electrophysio- a result, this defense against blood loss is
logical signaling and inotropic properties of compromised, further contributing to the vi-
the heart (Moore, 2008). This results in a fur- cious cycle. In addition, much like hypother-
ther reduction in systemic oxygenation and mia, increasing acidosis resulting from anaer-
tissue perfusion. obic metabolism not only affects the clotting
Hypothermia also has a direct detrimental cascade but it also has detrimental effects
effect on the hematological system, specif- on myocardial performance, reducing cardiac
ically hemostasis. Vascular injury frequently effectiveness, increasing oxygen debt, and ex-
accompanies trauma and results in activation acerbating this detrimental pathological re-
of the clotting cascade both to stem blood sponse (Martini, 2009a).
loss and to initiate vascular repair. Early in In summary, trauma alters fibrinogen
the clotting cascade, platelets provide pri- metabolism in a variety of ways that accelerate
mary hemostasis, or initial closure of the vas- fibrinogen breakdown and allow for further
cular injury. This is followed by activation of coagulopathy-facilitated volume depletion.
clotting factors that function as part of the ex- Hypothermia inhibits fibrinogen synthesis
trinsic clotting pathway to provide secondary and increases oxygen consumption, which
hemostasis. This process initiates a more sub- leads to anaerobic metabolism and metabolic
stantial repair to the tissue through the for- acidosis. In turn, acidosis accelerates fibrino-
mation of fibrin. The intrinsic and extrinsic gen breakdown and disturbs cardiac electro-
pathways eventually merge into the common physiological signaling, which compromises
pathway, resulting in platelet aggregation and cardiac function. Independently and collabo-
fibrin substantiation of the clot. In the pres- ratively, hemorrhage, hypothermia, and aci-
ence of hypothermia, both the intrinsic and dosis lead to what is referred to as the trauma
extrinsic pathways of the clotting cascade are triad of death (Figure).

Copyright © 2012 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Article: TME200151 Date: January 24, 2012 Time: 17:12

January–March 2012 r Vol. 34, No. 1 Hypothermia in Trauma 77

LITERATURE REVIEW
Mizushima, Wang, Cioffi, Bland, and Chaudry
(2000) conducted a key study in which the
effect of hemorrhage was evaluated using a
rat model. This experimental model permit-
ted the assessment of cardiac performance
and organ blood flow following induced hem-
orrhage in the animals under conditions of
normothermia, hypothermia, and rewarming.
Differences (p < 0.05) were determined by
use of a one-way analysis of variance followed
by Tukey’s test. Findings revealed that both
the maintenance of normothermia during
hemorrhage as well prolonged hypothermia
following successful resuscitation resulted in
Figure. The cyclical trauma triad presents with reduced left ventricular performance, car-
each factor exacerbating and compounding upon diac output, and suboptimal blood flow in
the next. various organs. On the contrary, the results
demonstrated that rewarming a previously hy-
METHODS
pothermic patient to a normothermic state
A review of literature was conducted to ex- during resuscitation significantly improved
amine studies that evaluated the influence of overall cardiac performance, cardiac output,
hypothermia on the outcome of the trauma and end-organ perfusion (Mizushima et al.,
patient. The selection of literature for this re- 2000). These data demonstrate a correlation
view was completed with due consideration between a subject’s temperature and the sub-
of quality indices. Multiple CINAHL, Ovid, and ject’s improved physiological function and
PubMed searches were performed using key- overall recovery once rewarming occurs fol-
words including but not limited to trauma, lowing trauma. In this animal model of injury,
hypothermia, trauma triad, rewarming, pre- hemorrhage was experimentally induced.
hospital trauma care, and trauma outcomes. Although this is not typical of the human
The primary searches were limited to those trauma patient who would usually suffer spon-
studies published within the past 10 years taneous, multisystem traumatic injury, the
preceding initial research, with queries later study provides a well-controlled model to
expanded to cover the past 20 years in an ef- evaluate the effect of body temperature and
fort to include classical works. For inclusion, rewarming on cardiovascular outcomes. In ad-
articles were required to be published in a dition, the level of precision in measurement
reputable, peer-reviewed nursing, medical, or of the experimental animal’s hemodynamic
scientific journal. Preference was given to pri- function relative to trauma and associated hy-
mary research. Studies were evaluated on the pothermia lends to the rigor of study design
basis of population, noted citations, sample and hence the validity and trustworthiness of
size, rigor of the research design, and data the results.
analysis and interpretation. All works cited The second study by Wang, Callaway,
were deemed to contribute in a meaningful Peitzman, and Tisherman (2005) used a ret-
and relevant manner to understanding the rospective, cross-sectional design in which
relationship between hypothermia and out- a convenience sample of trauma cases from
comes in trauma patients. On the basis of Pennsylvania’s statewide trauma registry was
these selection criteria, findings from four key evaluated. The primary study outcome was
studies are reviewed and discussed in the fol- death at hospital discharge. The variable of
lowing text. note was hypothermia, which was defined as

Copyright © 2012 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Article: TME200151 Date: January 24, 2012 Time: 17:12

78 Advanced Emergency Nursing Journal

body temperature less than 35◦ C upon ad- can confound the results. Yet, the large sam-
mission. The findings revealed a direct cor- ple size is a notable strength of this study
relation between admission hypothermia in (Martin et al., 2005).
the trauma patient and mortality. That is, hy- The fourth and final primary research study
pothermia in patients upon admission was in- reviewed was authored by Taylor et al. (2008)
dependently associated with increased rate of and evaluated intravascular rewarming in the
mortality in both the full cohort and a sub- hypothermic patient. Data were collected ret-
set cohort limited to those patients with re- rospectively by reviewing the records of pa-
ported “severe head injury.” For the full co- tients treated with the CoolGard system at a
hort, the odds ratio for fatality to occur was Level I trauma center in Texas from May to Oc-
3.03, with a 95% confidence interval (range tober 2007. Patient temperature, rewarming
= 2.62–3.51). For the head injury subset, the data, demographic, injury pattern and sever-
odds ratio for fatality to occur was 2.21, with ity, laboratory values, transfusion status, and
a range of 1.62–3.03. The study results were outcomes were collected and reviewed. The
adjusted for age, severity, and mechanism of patients’ mean core temperature noted at the
injury, and the recorded route of temperature initiation of rewarming was 33.6 ± 1◦ C, and
measurement and the findings remained con- the mean rate of rewarming was 1.5 ± 1◦ C
sistent, which strengthen the conclusion that per hour. Despite rewarming measures, six of
hypothermia independently increases risk for 11 patients died: two (18%) expiring of acute
mortality due to posttraumatic injury. Despite exsanguination and four (36%) of unsurviv-
the fact that this study employed a retrospec- able traumatic brain injuries. In addition, one
tive analysis of a convenience sample, the patient developed a deep vein thrombosis at
large sample size and significant confidence the site of the femoral catheter and experi-
interval add to the validity of the results and enced a nonfatal pulmonary embolus.
conclusions.
A third related study by Martin, Kilgo, Of the five survivors, four had rewarming initiated
Miller, Meridith, and Chang (2005) used exist- early in the course of treatment, either in the ED
ing data to evaluate the effect of hypothermia or operating room. Only one fatality, due to non-
survivable brain injury, occurred in a patient whose
on mortality using a convenience sample ac-
rewarming began prior to ICU arrival. Of note, the
cessed from the National Trauma Data Bank. A two patients with the lowest ED arrival temper-
cross-sectional correlational design was used. atures, both with extensive penetrating injuries,
Findings showed a correlation between core had intravascular rewarming begun immediately
body temperature and mortality, such that as and survived. (Taylor et al., 2008, p. 122)
patients’ core temperature decreased, their
mortality rate increased. Mortality rate was The research team concluded that based
39% at a core temperature of 32◦ C, and this upon their findings, the data demonstrated
correlation remained constant at lower tem- that active intravascular balloon-catheter re-
peratures. Of these patients, 477 (59.5%) with warming demonstrated an effective and es-
admission core temperatures less than 32◦ C sentially automated technique for the timely
survived. Logistic regression analysis revealed treatment of hypothermia in trauma patients.
that hypothermia significantly and indepen- This study was chosen to highlight the po-
dently contributed to patient mortality even tential for improved outcome because it re-
when adjustment was made for confound- lates to proper identification and management
ing variables such as unavoidable environ- of hypothermia in the trauma patient. From
mental temperature extremes. Limitations to the perspective of study rigor, utilization of
the study include use of records that origi- one particular rewarming device adds to the
nated from numerous trauma centers, which study’s reliability in that there should be no
increases the chance for variability in care as variation attributed to different devices. Al-
well as inconsistencies in data entry, which though this study is valid and has potential to

Copyright © 2012 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Article: TME200151 Date: January 24, 2012 Time: 17:12

January–March 2012 r Vol. 34, No. 1 Hypothermia in Trauma 79

impact nursing practice, future studies should injury. In fact, a previously referenced study
employ a larger sample size and enroll sub- concluded that not only is hypothermia a sig-
jects from multiple centers so as to improve nificant factor in patient outcome but “hy-
general applicability and confidence in the pothermia is independently associated with
conclusions drawn. This should be accom- increased adjusted odds of death after major
plished prior to universal implementation of trauma” as well (Wang et al., 2005, p. 1300).
this practice. Patients with traumatic injury frequently
The physiological effects of primary hy- sustain significant blood loss and their care
pothermia are well documented, and most often includes aggressive fluid resuscitation.
clinicians understand the impact that hy- While infusing large volumes of intravenous
pothermia can have on a patient. In fact, the fluids and blood products into the patient, the
care of the patient with primary hypother- efficient trauma team also concurrently strips
mia is typically well understood by those victims of any clothing to complete very nec-
experienced in emergency care. For exam- essary primary and secondary trauma surveys.
ple, one study reported a mortality rate of Moreover, temperatures in the ED and oper-
17.1% in patients presenting with the chief ating room are typically 21◦ C–22◦ C (Taylor
complaint of primary hypothermia without et al., 2008). Collectively, this culminates in
other injury (Martin et al., 2005). This is re- conditions that almost make hypothermia in-
lated to the significant multiorgan system ef- evitable. In fact, it has been documented that
fects attributed to hypothermia, including de- “mild (33◦ C–35◦ C) to moderate (30◦ C–33◦ C)
pressed cardiac function, which decreases hypothermia frequently occurs during fluid
perfusion and gives rise to shock. Further- resuscitation of trauma victims” (Mizushima
more, hypothermia leads to myocardial ir- et al., 2000, p. 58). The same study further
ritability, which can precipitate potentially emphasizes, “Studies have shown that hy-
fatal arrhythmias (Peng & Bongard, 1999). pothermic trauma victims have a higher mor-
Although these same physiological changes tality rate than those patients who are kept
can occur in the patient with no injuries, warm” (Mizushima et al., 2000, p. 58). Related
the patient with a significant traumatic injury studies recommend that hypothermic trauma
is more vulnerable and should therefore be patients be rewarmed rapidly (Gentilello &
protected to the best of the trauma team’s Rifley, 1991).
ability. Interventions as basic as keeping the pa-
Traumatic injury, by nature, puts a patient tient covered have been used for years and
at significant risk for heat loss. In fact, hy- assumed to be sufficient in many situations.
pothermia accompanies injury subsequent to If more intervention is thought to be neces-
exposure, which increases heat loss from con- sary, warmed blankets as well as warmed in-
duction and convection; also, decreased mo- travenous fluids have been used (Ireland et al.,
tor activity further reduces heat production 2006). Such measures do assist in preventing
(Moore, 2008). Traditionally, hypothermia is further heat loss, but the question is whether
defined as a core temperature less than 35◦ C they are sufficient to adequately rewarm the
(American College of Surgeons, Committee injured patient. As previously mentioned, one
on Trauma, 2008). However, in a study that method of more aggressive rewarming now
surveyed 96 trauma team members includ- being evaluated is intravascular rewarming,
ing both nurses and physicians found that whereby a central catheter is introduced into
36.4% incorrectly identified break point for the femoral vein. The rewarming device uses
hypothermia as either 33◦ C or 34◦ C (Ireland a balloon tip that circulates warmed fluid
et al., 2006). This is concerning because cur- in a closed loop fashion to deliver heat to
rent literature readily identifies hypothermia the bloodstream. In addition, the balloon de-
as a significant determinant of the outcome of vice has the capacity to monitor the patient’s
a patient presenting with significant traumatic core temperature. According to Taylor et al.

Copyright © 2012 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Article: TME200151 Date: January 24, 2012 Time: 17:12

80 Advanced Emergency Nursing Journal

(2008), a study using this intravascular equip- requires education of pre-hospital care
ment reported the average rewarming rate to providers inclusive of air and ground staff
be 1.5◦ C/hr. Despite the fact that the technol- who care for patients prior to arrival at
ogy is relatively new and the study had a very the trauma center. In addition, it is impor-
small sample size (N = 11), it seems that this tant to review and reinforce the significance
may be a promising technology for rewarming of temperature monitoring and hypothermia
trauma patients (Taylor et al., 2008). management with all trauma team members.
Finally, equipment procurement and the cre-
ation and implementation of algorithms to
DISCUSSION AND IMPLICATIONS
prevent and treat hypothermia should be con-
As is evident by the data previously discussed, sidered as a part of an institution’s standard
core temperature in the trauma patient is a trauma care practices.
very vital sign. Although it is important to fo-
cus on ensuring adequate breathing and cir-
culation of the critically injured patient, the CONCLUSION
physiological and metabolic damage that hy- All aspects of care of the trauma patient are
pothermia can cause must also be considered. important and no part of the primary or sec-
When rewarming should begin and just how ondary assessment, including a patient’s tem-
aggressive rewarming measures should be are perature, should be overlooked. Providers
still a matter of debate; however, the data con- must understand the impact of hypothermia
sistently show that rewarming that is safe, ef- as a part of the trauma triad of death if the
fective, and efficient would serve the patient cyclic events are not interrupted quickly and
best (Mizushima et al., 2000). It is essential to effectively. Accomplishing this requires edu-
ensure that nurses and physicians have fun- cated staff members who recognize the signs
damental knowledge of the normal limits for and symptoms of compromise in the trauma
core temperature, the methods of taking and patient and who effectively align their prac-
recording accurate core temperatures, and an tice with current evidence. Patients who have
understanding of appropriate interventions to incurred traumatic injury are a vulnerable pa-
improve overall quality of care and patient tient population. As patient advocates, nurses
outcomes. Beyond that, protocols to prevent must work to ensure that the patient is cared
and treat hypothermia should be addressed at for to the utmost of the health care team’s
an institutional level in order to empower the ability in an effort to ensure the best possible
trauma team to effectively combat hypother- outcome.
mia and related sequelae.
Dissemination of findings is an integral part
of the research continuum, ensuring that ev- REFERENCES
idence translates to patient care. These prac- American College of Surgeons, Committee on Trauma.
tice changes facilitate improvements in stan- (Ed.). (2008). Advanced trauma life support for
dards of practice, which ultimately and most doctors: Emergency management of severe trauma
importantly improve the patients’ outcomes. (EMST) Faculty manual. (8th ed). Chicago, IL:
As previously reviewed, hypothermia in the Author.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Ambulatory
trauma patient is a critical problem and it and Hospital Care Statistics Branch. (2008). National
is clear that the traumatically injured pa- hospital ambulatory medical care survey: 2008
tient almost immediately becomes at risk for emergency department summary tables. Retrieved
heat loss. Consequently, it is may be con- from http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/ervisits.htm
Dirkmann, D., Hanke, A. A., Görlinger, K., & Pe-
cluded that patient temperature preservation
ters, J. (2008). Hypothermia and acidosis syn-
and related interventions should begin with ergistically impair coagulation in human whole
pre-hospital care and be maintained and/or blood. Anesthesia & Analgesia, 106(6), 1627–1632.
augmented from that point forward. This doi:10.1213/ane.0b013e31817340ad

Copyright © 2012 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Article: TME200151 Date: January 24, 2012 Time: 17:12

January–March 2012 r Vol. 34, No. 1 Hypothermia in Trauma 81

Finklestein, R., & Alam, H. (2010). Induced hypothermia Martini, W. Z. (2009b). Coagulopathy by hypothermia
for trauma: Current research and practice. Journal and acidosis: Mechanisms of thrombin generation
of Intensive Care Medicine, 25(4), 205–226. and fibrinogen availability. The Journal of Trauma,
doi:10.1177/0885066610366919 67(1), 202–209. doi:10.1097/TA.0b013e3181a602a7
Gentilello, L. M., & Rifley, W. J. (1991). Continuous arte- Mizushima, Y., Wang, P., Cioffi, W. G., Bland, K. I.,
riovenous rewarming: Report of a new technique for & Chaudry, I. H. (2000). Should normothermia be
treating hypothermia. The Journal of Trauma, 31, restored and maintained during resuscitation after
1151–1154. trauma and hemorrhage? The Journal of Trauma,
Ireland, S., Murdoch, K., Ormrod, P., Saliba, E., Endacott, 48(1), 58–65.
R., Fitzgerald, M., & Cameron, P. (2006). Nursing Moore, K. (2008). Hypothermia in trauma. Journal of
and medical staff knowledge regarding the monitor- Trauma Nursing, 15(2), 62–64.
ing and management of accidental or exposure hy- Peng, R. Y., & Bongard, F. S. (1999). Hypothermia in
pothermia in adult major trauma patients. Interna- trauma patients. Journal of the American College of
tional Journal of Nursing Practice, 12, 308–318. Surgeons, 188, 685–696.
Mallet, M. L. (2002). Pathophysiology of accidental Taylor, E. E., Carroll, J. P., Lovitt, M. A., Petrey,
hypothermia. QJM, 95, 775–785. Retrieved from L. B., Gray, P. E., Mastropieri, C. J., & Fore-
qjmed.oxfordjournals.org man, M. L. (2008). Active intravascular rewarming
Martin, R. S., Kilgo, P. D., Miller, P. R., Meridith, J. W., & for hypothermia associated with traumatic injury:
Chang, M. C. (2005). Injury-associated hypothermia: Early experience with a new technique. Proceed-
An analysis of the 2004 National Trauma Data Bank. ings (Baylor University Medical Center), 21(2),
Shock (Augusta, Ga), 24(2), 114–118. 120–126.
Martini, W. (2009a). Fibrinogen metabolic responses Wang, H. E., Callaway, C. W., Peitzman, A. B., & Tisher-
to trauma. Scandinavian Journal of Trauma, man, S. A. (2005). Admission hypothermia and out-
Resuscitation & Emergency Medicine, 17(1), 2. come after major trauma. Critical Care Medicine,
doi:10.1186/1757-7241-17-2 33(6), 1296–1301.

Copyright © 2012 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.

You might also like