Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Michael Armstrong
There could be any number of reasons for the difference but the major factor is
most likely to be the ways in which the respective managers managed their teams.
This is because, essentially, the role of managers is to get things done through
people. To do this they:
see that the members of their teams understand what they are expected to
do and then ensure that they do it;
ensure that people with the right skills are in the right jobs and that they
perform well in exercising their skills in those jobs;
exercise leadership;
motivate their staff;
treat people right – that is, fairly and with respect and consideration;
deal effectively with the problems that inevitably arise in managing people.
‘Managers promote efficiency, follow the rules and accept the status quo, while leaders
focus on challenging the rules and promoting effectiveness.’ (Bennis, 1989)
‘Managers plan, budget, organize and control, while leaders set direction, manage change
and motivate people.’ (Kotter, 1991)
‘Management merely consists of leadership applied to business situations.’ (Hersey and
Blanchard, 1998)
What do you think?
But whether you are managing or leading or both, it can be hard. There are the
pressing demands from above to deliver results. Managers carry out their work on
a day-to-day basis in conditions of turbulence and variety. It may not be clear what
they are expected to do or how they are expected to do it. They have to be
specialists in ambiguity. Unexpected events ambush them – stuff happens.
Decisions lead to unforeseen consequences. And they spend a lot of their time
dealing with people who can be difficult, unpredictable or uncooperative.
Perhaps it is the managing people aspect of a manager’s work that provides the
greatest challenge. How can line managers ensure that their team members are
‘on board’ and stay on board? How do they get willing cooperation rather than
grudging submission? These and other questions will be addressed in later
chapters of this book but one approach to dealing with them is given below.
Words of wisdom
‘As a manager, I try frequently to reinforce with my team members that they are setting
standards for themselves and then to initiate open discussion of what those standards
may be, encouraging the team to reflect on both strengths and weaknesses.’ (Brinker,
2017)
Exercise 1.1
The line manager’s role
Conduct an investigation to establish the most typical features of a line manager’s role. The
investigation can be carried out by reviewing your own work if you are a manager or a team leader
and over three or four days analysing what you do under such headings as:
planning ahead;
communicating with superiors, colleagues or customers;
organizing the work;
making decisions;
dealing with members of your team, eg giving instructions, reviewing performance, training
or handling grievances, personal problems or problems of performance or discipline.
If you are not a manager try to get your own line manager to do this analysis for their job. When
you have completed the analysis consider what it tells you about the manager’s role.
Summary points
Managers:
Words of wisdom
‘In this new era, people need to be treated and respected as precious human capital,
more essential to an organization’s effectiveness than its financial capital. People can
now be the primary source of a company’s competitive advantage in most businesses.
To put it bluntly, how people are treated increasingly determines whether a company
will prosper or even survive.’ (Lawler, 2003)
Words of wisdom
‘Respect is necessary to work with people. By “people” we mean employees, supply
partners and customers… We don’t mean just the end customer; on the assembly line
the person at the next workstation is also your customer.’ (Katsuaki Watanabe, Toyota
CEO; from Stewart and Raman, 2007)
Words of wisdom
The five factors that affect perceptions of procedural justice:
Exercise 2.1
Treating people right
Think of any examples from your own experience where you believe that you were treated unfairly
by your manager. If you can recall any, consider the circumstances and explain how you think the
situation should have been dealt with.