Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Luciano SEGRETO
Hubert BONIN
Andrzej K. KOZMINSKI
Caries MANERA
and
Manlred POHL
(eds.)
¿
P.I.E. Peter Lang
i! ICCA
INSTITUTE FOR CORPORATE
CULTUREAFFAIRS e.V. KOZMINSKI UNIVERSITY
Preface ·····-------------
The papers ofthis book were first presented ata Conference organised
by the ICCA in Warsaw, in March 2007, with the support of the
Kozminski University of Warsaw.
No part of this book may be reproduced in any form, by print, photocopy, microfilm
or any other means, without prior written permission from the publisher. All rights
CHAPTIRl. 1.:"
reserved. Competiti>e
Perer .\fis.
© P.I.E. PETER LANG S.A.
Éditions scientifiques intemationales
Brussels, 2012
1 avenue Maurice, B-1050 Brussels, Belgium
www.peterlang.com; info@peterlang.com
ISBN 978-90-5201-793-8
D/20 12/5678/19
CHAPTER 4. Lham~
Printed in Germany
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data.
European business and brand building 1 Luciano Segreto ... [et al.] (eds.). CHAPTER 5. A Reas~
p. cm.
Papers presented at a conference organized by ICCA in Warsaw, in Mar. 2007.
Includes bibliographical references. ISBN 978-90-5201-793-8
l. Brand name products-Europe- Congresses. 2. Branding (Marketing)--Europe- Hubert Bonfn
Congresses. 3. Corporate image- Europe- Congresses.
I. Segreto, Luciano. II. Institute for Corporate Culture Affairs. CHAPTER 6. The _-L~~
HD69.B7E97 2011 658.8'27094--dc23 2011042023
CIP also available from the British Library, GB.
Bibliographic inforrnation published by "Die Deutsche Nationalbibliothek" CHAPTER 7. The T -~ ~
"Die Deutsche Nationalbibliothek" lists this publication in the "Deutsche Brand Building o
Nationalbibliografie": detailed bibliographic data is available on the Internet at
<http://dnb.de>.
CHAPTER8
This is a frrst approach to the issue and is broadly dependent on extensive interviews
with many persons concemed with the history of the furn. I am very grateful to al! of
them.
From 2005 to 2009, its ranking was 77, 73, 64, 62 and 50. See http://www.interbrand.
comlbest_global_ brands.aspx.
187
European Business and Brand Building
were about to run. Given that the only capital available to the founders
of the small workshop was what they could raise by their own means,
Confecciones Goa began operating as a modest manufacturer of a very
limited range of ladieswear, selling its products to local haberdasheries
and retail outlets. 3 Just in case the business failed to get off the ground,
Amancio Ortega initially kept his job in the shirt-makers where he
worked.
Confecciones Goa recorded moderate growth in the following
decade, and by around 1973 it already had sorne 90 female workers,
almost all ofwhom were young single women, who were employed in a
new factory that the Ortega farnily had built on the outskirts ofthe city,
in A Moura. The prernises left vacant by Confecciones Goa, within the
city itself, now housed a new farnily business, Samlor, which employed
58 people and made ladies' jackets and trousers. 4 At that moment,
Amancio Ortega was the registered owner of Goa, whilst his brother ran
Samlor. 5 These were, therefore, two small family businesses that
purchased their fabrics from severa! suppliers in Catalonia and, lacking
their own retail outlets, sold their ladies' garments through a network of
sales reps working on comrnission to dedicated stores, large
supermarkets and retail chains, such as Simago, Pryca and Continente. 6
The Ortega brothers were still a long way from being Spain's largest
clothing manufacturer, which at that time was Induyco, a company in
the El Corte Inglés Group, Spain's largest chain of department stores. 7
Yet even in the Galicia region, Goa and Samlor were a long way behind
Dresslock or Regojo, with this latter company having not only two Iarge
factories in Redondela and Zamora, but also an extremely large network
of workshops working for them. 8
The 1970s saw far-reaching changes in Spain's industrial clothing
market, which up until that time had been located mainly in Catalonia,
R. Tijeras, Las sagas del poder, Barcelona, Plaza & Janés, 199&. L. Alonso Alvarez,
"Vistiendo a tres continentes. La ventaja competitiva del grupo Inditex-Zara",
Revista de Historia Industrial, No. 1&, 2000. C. Sánchez, Dinero fresco. La nueva
aristocracia económica que ha desplazado a las grandes familias, Madrid, Ediciones
Temas de Hoy, 2003 . Pilar Ortega, Amancio and Antonio sister had also runa small
haberdashers in the same city since 1962.
4
Historical Archive of the Kingdom of Galicia (AHRG), lnstitutional Administration
ofSocio-professional Services (AISS) , File 55.&90.
AHRG, AISS, File 52.966.
L. Alonso Alvarez, op. cit.
Fomento de la Producción, Las 1.500 mayores empresas españolas en 1973,
Barcelona, 1975.
X. Carmona Badía and J. Nadal Oller, El empeño industrial de Galicia. 250 años de
historia, A Coruña, Fundación Barrié de la Maza, 2005 .
188
Xoán Carmona Badía
189
European Business and Brand Building
tailor's shops or were the sons and daughters of the owners, to embark
upon the production of mass-produced fashion. Such was the case of
Caramelo, Roberto Verino, Unicén and Adolfo Domínguez, who were
the frrst of these Galician industrialists to become widely known.
A second factor that in all likelihood contributed to the success of
these businesses was the lengthy downturn in the labour market that
began in Galicia around 1976 and persisted almost until 1993. The loss
of jobs and the difficulty in fmding one were especially acute in the
districts ofFerrol and Vigo, with the female population being the hardest
hit. 12 Galicia's two largest clothing companies, which we referred to
earlier, namely, Dresslock and Regojo, went into temporary receivership
in 1973 and 1978, respectively, making both entire workshops and
individual seamstresses redundant. 13 The shrinking labour market had
two major ramifications. The frrst was to increase the supply of female
labour, which in certain districts was highly skilled in dressmaking,
prepared to work for low wages, and even had the necessary equipment.
The second effect, at a time when Spain was moving from dictatorship
to democracy, was to generate a favourable attitude amongst local insti-
tutions towards anything that involved creating jobs. This meant the
availability of public premises and subsidies, especially when coopera-
tives were involved. Entrepreneurs therefore found the way open for the
arrangement of an outsourcing system for the most labour-intensive
activities, thereby enabling them to optimise the relationship between
those undertaken within their own factories and those carried out in
subcontracted workshops, cooperatives and in many cases even through
home work in the manner of the Verlagssystem. 14
This favourable economic scenario became even more so during the
second half of the 1970s due to political change, which meant not only
replacing dictatorship with democracy but also a clear generational shift
in which the new political, economic and professional elites sought to
shrug off the unimaginative style of dress used by the supporters of
General Franco's former regime. Accordingly, new businesses sprang
up with the remit not only to put fashion within the reach of female
pockets but also to fmd new styles and more informal designs for
menswear. 15
12
X. Vence Deza, Capitalismo e desemprego en Galicia, Vigo, Edicións Xerais, 1986.
13
Fomento de la Producción, op. cit., and X. Carmona (ed.), Empresarios de Galicia,
Vol. 2, Santiago, Fundación Caixa Galicia, 2009.
14
M.X. Rodríguez Galdo, E. Pis Sánchez & M.T. Costa Campí (eds.). Evaluación del
potencial de desarrollo endógeno de Galicia, Santiago, Xunta de Galicia, 1992.
15
For the influence of sociological and politica1 changes on fashion, see L. Welters and
P.A. Cunningham (eds.), Twentieth-Century American Fashion, Oxford-New York,
Berg, 2005.
190
Xoán Carmona Badía
This was the context within which Amancio Ortega too k two of the
decisions that would lie at the heart of his subsequent transformation
into the market leader in the sector: introduce his own outlets for the
distribution of his clothing items and extend his production range so as
to minimise his dependence on outside suppliers.
The Ortega family's frrst steps in the field of retailing, all taken in
the city of A Coruña between 1971 and 1975, were somewhat erratic
and only relatively successful. In 1971, they opened a shop called Sprint
that sold clothes products from various provenances and then another
that also sold records, books and other leisure items. lt is only from
1975 that mention can be made of the Zara retail model, with the
opening of a clothes store under this name, dedicated to the sale of items
of clothing. These were supplied largely by other manufácturers, given
that in-house products still made up only a very small range, which was
furthermore restricted to ladieswear. 16 lt was precisely this situation that
led to the joint decision to enlarge both the production range for clothing
items and the number of self-owned retail outlets under the Zara name.
Regarding the increase in production, the frrst decision taken by the
Ortega brothers was to move Goa to Sabón, a new industrial estate that
was being developed just outside the city, and use the old site to open a
new factory dedicated to the manufacture of men's pyjamas, thereby
embarking upon the production of clothing items for this customer
segment. In order to open this new life dedicated to menswear they
established a partnership with two people with extensive experience and
knowledge of the business, Isidore Bermathou and José Antonio
Vázquez Sánchez, who had been the technical and commercial directors,
respectively, at Pressman, a medium-sized factory in Vigo dedicated to
the manufactures ofmen's and ladies' wear. The former, who trained as
a textile engineer in Paris, was also an expert in the commissioning of
factories of this kind. Together they formed Confecciones Noite in
1976, a company that would soon extend its product range from
pyjamas to men's and children's dressing-gowns, and soon after that to
track suits, with this latter line being almost untouched by Spanish
manufacturers and one that would be extremely successful.
Confecciones Noite supplied these three product lines in men's and
children's wear to several distributors, with a significant amount being
exported, especially to Mexico, the Middle East and France, and
amongst its customers in this country were chains such as Printemps and
even Galeries Lafayette.
16
J.M. Castellano, "Una ventaja competitive: el factor tiempo. El caso lnditex-Zara",
Papeles de Economía Española, No. 56, 1993.
191
European Business and Brand Building
Soon after this, the Ortega brothers applied the same business
strategy to begin manufacturing shirts, which they undertook around
1979. On this occasion, the partners were again two people who had
already worked in the clothing sector, Rogelio García Vigo, who had
done so in a well-known and modem shirt factory in A Coruña,
Manufacturas Nogueira, and Enrique García Amil. The company,
Confecciones Píos, soon became a major shirt manufacturer. As with .
Noite, the Ortega brothers held a slight majority of its stock, with the
minority holding being shared between the other two partners. With
Noite and Fíos they increased their own range of clothing, always
expanding towards products related to the ones they were already
turning out (from ladies' dressing gowns to men' s and children's, from
ladies' nightdresses to men' s pyjamas and shirts) and with a minimum
outlay of family funds, thanks to the option of resorting to new partners
and bank loans.
As well as having their own workshops, like Goa and Samlor, these
fmns began to build up a network of subcontracting relationships with
home-based seamstresses and smalllocal workshops 17 to which in sorne
cases they contracted the sewing and fmishing (checking, labelling,
etc.), and in others only sorne of these tasks. Each one of the companies
set up an independent network abiding by the rule of not competing for
subcontractors with other members of the gro up.
In step with the growth in the number of production plants and the
enlarged product range, the Ortega brothers opened two shops in
A Coruña and a further three in other cities in Galicia: Vigo, Lugo and
Orense. This meant that by 1979 they now had six of their own retail
outlets located in the region' s main cities. 18 Nevertheless, the growth in
production in the 1970s far outpaced that of the distribution network,
whereby in 1979 production still prevailed over distribution in the
group. Yet a sea change had already come about in the business group' s
strategy. The increase in production and the enlargement ofthe range of
clothes made by the group ' s new manufacturing companies would
enable the retail outlets to gradually become the sole sales points for
their output, although for the time being they still sold to third parties.
This meant that the vertical integration policy, which is widely
considered to be one of the keys to the group's subsequent
competitiveness, was already partly in place in the late 1970s, although
it would not be completed untillater.
17
X.R. Blanco and J .F . Salgado, Amancio Ortega: de cero a Zara, Madrid, Editorial La
Esfera de los libros, 2004, p. 50.
18
lnditex. Initial public stock offering of Industria del Diseño Textil, S.A. April 2001 ,
chap. IV, p. l.
192
Xoán Carmona Badía
During the first half of the 1980s, the group's productive structure
continued expanding, until by 1986 it had seven manufacturing
companies, three of which were new and owned by Amancio Ortega, 19
who by then had emerged as the veritable driving-force behind the
business, and 49 self-owned retail outlets under the Zara banner, a name
that was beginning to gain in popularity in Spain's major cities. By that
time, the product range had already extended to knitwear and the most
common items in men's, ladies' and children's wear, in sorne cases
through the building or purchase of new pocket-sized factories in
Galicia itself, and in others by contracting factories that had previously
worked for other retailers.
In this second stage of the group's expansion in production, a
decisively important factor was that the extemal network of contractors
was joined by a large number of cooperatives that contracted with the
factories. These cooperatives, dotted around Galicia and in most cases
promoted by clergymen and local authorities, began mainly from 1983
to be part of the structure of the division of labour that had been
operating up until then and in which outside workshops performed the
most intensive tasks (sewing, assembling), whilst the pattem design,
cutting and colour design were carried out in the main workshops in A
Grela and soon after in Arteixo, which were also responsible for quality
control, labelling and packing. 20 By 1988, the largest cooperative
networks, formed at the initiative of two churchmen, one in A Coruña
and the other in the coastal town of Corcubión, already had
68 cooperatives in which 1,357 people worked. 21
This meant that by the mid-1980s, the manufacturing structure was
extremely flexible, basically consisting of three echelons. The frrst of
these, in which strategic decisions were taken, was controlled directly
by the Ortega family, with Amancio at the head. The second was made
up either by those production companies in which the Ortega family
operated with other partners, albeit always maintaining control of the
company, as in the aforementioned cases of Confecciones Noite and
Fíos, or by those plants in which the family were the sole owners. They
19
These were Nikole, Choolet and Trisko. See Fomento de la Producción, Las 2.000
mayores empresas españolas en 1986, Barcelona, 1987.
20
Regarding the importance of the cooperatives in the sharp growth recorded in the
1980s, see P. Alonso Logroño, and R. Rodríguez González, "Territorio en mutación:
la industria textil-confección como factor de desarrollo local en Galicia", Anales de
Geografia, No. 25, 2005 and R. Herranz, R. and D. Hoss, "División del trabajo entre
-- ·::r La centro y periferia. Cooperativas e industrialización difusa en Galicia", Sociología del
Trabajo, No. 11, 1991.
21
X. López Neira y R. Dosil, "O cooperativismo. Un medio eficaz na promoción do
emprego", Encrucillada. Revista Galega de Pensamento Cristián, No. 56, 1988.
193
European Business and Brand Building
22
According to Fábrega, sales to third parties had already ceased by 1986, see
F. Fábrega, Zara. El modelo de negocio de lnditex, Madrid, Editorial Claves de
Gestión, 2004, p. 27.
194
Xoán Carmona Badía
23
Benetton, the only company with more retail outlets than the Spanish group, around
6,000, has franchised most ofthe stores that display its brand and does not own them.
See Benetton Group, Annual Report, 2008.
24
According to the annual reports of the two companies, in 2008 Inditex posted a
turnover of$14.8 billion as opposed to the $14.5 recorded by The Gap.
195
European Business and Brand Building
= = ·¡;;"' ..><:....
;>..
"'=
<!)
"'
<!)
~ ~
< "'=
"'=
";( c.. :a
Brand
m
c..
ªo
p...
~ ....
~'«
<!)
:E
E
....
<!)
tl
~
"'= ¡.....= ~
m
~
"' u
......
Zara' s success has inspired numerous books and articles that seek to
explain it. In an article published in 2000, Luis Alonso set out to provide
an overview of sorne of the views that were being expressed
accordingly. The first of these was the flexibility of its manufacturing
system, which is due to a higher level of vertical integration than its
competitors, its logistics system, which means it can rapidly adapt its
offer to changes in demand with minirnal inventory costs, and fmally,
the decentralisation and autonomy enjoyed by each of the group's
chains. Such flexibility means rninirnising the time elapsed between the
product' s design and its fmal display at the point of sale, reducing it to
20 per cent ofthe normal figure for the sector. Accordingly, "whereas its
competitors require on average six months to design the product and a
further three to manufacture it and deliver it to the point of sale, Zara
takes between three and four weeks in the first case and a week in the
196
Xoán Carmona Badía
25
Alonso Alvarez, op. cit., p. 175.
26
X.H. Vázquez Vicente, "O segredo do éxito", in http://www.vieiros.com/nova.
php?id=15630&Ed=1 [Accessed: 23.03.2011].
27
See for instance the cases prepared by N. Frairnan, M. Singh for the Columbia
Business School (2002) or the one by P. Ghemawat and J.L. Nueno for the Harvard
Business School (2003).
28
K. Ferdows, M.A, Lewis and J.A.D. Machuca, "Rapid-fire Fulfillment'', Harvard
Business Review, November 2004.
197
European Business and Brand Building
29
M. Tungate, Fashion Brands. Branding Style from Armani to Zara, London and
Philadelphia, Kogan Page, 2005. N. Tokatli, "Global Sourcing: insights from the
global clothing industry - the case of Zara, a fast fashion retailer", Journal of
Economic Geography, 8, 2008.
30
N. Kumar and S. Linguri, "Fashion Sense", Business Strategy Review, Summer 2006.
198
Xoán Carmona Badía
N&B, Noite and Fíos were used to label menswear. Testifying to the scant
importance the Ortega brothers gave to this mark of identification during
their frrst years as manufacturers is the fact that they didn't apply to the
Spanish Patents and Trademarks Office to register their frrst trademark
until 1974, when they did so for the Sarnlor brand, to be followed by
Noite three years later. The designers were the owners themselves, who
based their work on irnitating other models and on their own experience
within the sector. Their aim was to sell designer clothes similar to those
on display in more exclusive stores, albeit for a more affordable price.
Zara is, therefore, in its origins, a very different case to ltalian
fashion, where there was an existing textile industry that saw ready-to-
wear as a way of expanding its market, in which designers licensed their
creations to companies that were already up and running and where,
generally speaking, the cooperation between designers, industrialists and
institutions played an important role.31 In that context, and in most cases,
the brand was the designer's own. Yet in the Spanish case, the textile
industry was located in Catalonia, twelve hundred kilometres away from
A Coruña, and the only relationship between it and Zara's initial
development involved suppliers and customers, as it was the Catalan
companies that supplied Amancio Ortega with fabrics. Galicia had no
tradition in accessories either, and the isolation Franco imposed on Spain
had blocked any form of contact with the process of Americanisation
that had swept through Europe in the post-war years and helped ltalian
fashion to gain a foothold in the US market. Here, therefore, the focus
was to be on the domestic market.
Finally, even well into the 1980s neither the institutions in Galicia
nor those in Spain overall made any attempt to assist the development of
the fashion industry. lt was only in 1984, andas part ofthe policies on
industrial restructuring, that the Ministry of Industry set up the Centre
for Fashion Design and Development (Centro de Promoción y Diseño
de Moda) and drafted its frrst Fashion Design and Development Plan
(Plan de Promoción y Diseño de Moda), for the purpose of contributing
to the intemational projection of Spanish fashion by supporting catwalks
such as Cibeles in Madrid or Gaudí in Barcelona and by helping the
sector in disparate other ways. 32 Yet by that time the new Spanish ready-
31
E. Merlo, Moda italiana: storia di un 'industria dall'Ottocento ad oggi, Venezia,
Marsilio Editare, 2003 . E. Merlo, "Tuming Fashion into Business: The Emergence of
Milan as an Intemational Fashion Hub", Business History Review, Vol. 80, No. 3,
2006. S. Saviolo, "Brand and Identity Management in Fashion Companies", SDA
Bocconi School of Management, Working Paper No. 66, 2002.
32
"La promoción de la moda española en el exterior: el papel del INFE (Instituto
Nacional para el Fomento de la Exportación)", Información Comercial Española,
No. 606, 1984. See also IPMark, No. 272, 1986.
199
European Business and Brand Building
to-wear clothing industry had already found its own feet and, what's
more, the gap between the larger and smaller companies was now a
barrier to collective action. Zara is not therefore the result of a liaison
between designers and industrialists, nor is it the result of institutional
support or of the cooperation of institutions, but rather it is the outcome
ofthe endeavour of a family and their team of collaborators to capitalise
upon their own abilities and the prevailing circumstances.
B. 1978-1991: the creation ofthe Zara brand
The frrst major turnaround in Zara' s history was when it jumped onto
the bandwagon of design and the popularisation of fashion that was in
vogue in Spain during the :first years of the recession in the 1970s. The
owners of the little Goa business joined a movement that had its
maximum exponent in Galicia and which besides the birth of Zara
fathered companies such as Caramelo, Antonio Pemas and Adolfo
Dominguez. The sudden appearance of this new fashion at affordable
prices in Spain in the 1970s took place under the name of "moda
gallega", Galician fashion, and Zara clearly bene:fited from this move-
ment, although it always kept away from all the sector's organisational
and promotional activities, such as the group Galicia-Moda, formed in
1983 under the auspices ofthe regional govemment (Xunta de Galicia),
the organisation of the Luar fashion show or the Galician Textile
Association (Asociación Textil Gallega), founded in 1991.33 In fact,
even before these institutional campaigns, the frrst boost to the sector' s
image had been given by Adolfo Dominguez with a successful
advertising campaign launched in 1979 with the motto "la arruga es
bella" (wrinkles are beautiful) and with the popular US TV series Miami
Vice being involved in the creation ofthe wardrobe. Adolfo Dominguez
targeted a higher price segment than Zara, and his becoming the
standard bearer for the sector had a major bearing on the success of
"moda gallega". In the early 1980s, all the clothing originating in
Galicia had that feel-good factor of providing fashion at an affordable
price for the frrst time in Spain. In order to be part of this new move-
ment that popularised fashion, an identity and a brand were required.
Amongst all the trademarks they had been using, and of which we have
seen that only two had been registered, the Ortega farnily business opted
33
As part of this movement, a magazine called GALICIA MODA was published and
the Asociación Textil de Galicia paid for a supplement in Vogue. The first Luar
fashion shows, held in Vigo, were attended by Caramelo, Florentino, Unicen,
Pressman and other Galician designers, and Harrod's and Galeries Lafayette were the
invited guests. The movement was part of a series of cultural and artistic events, in
which even rack music hada special part to play. In fact, Vigo, together with Madrid,
hosted one of the most significant movements in the Spanish musical scene in the last
third ofthe 20th century, the so-called "movida".
200
Xoán Carmona Badía
for the frrst time for a trademark that would henceforth identify not only
the retail outlets but also the majority of the products it manufactured.
With this in mind, it adopted the name of one of its retail outlets, Zara,
and applied it across the board to a range of products that was starting to
grow sharply. The Zara brand was registered accordingly at the Spanish
Patents and Trademarks Office in June 1978. Zara gradually began to
gain ground within the labelling of the group' s manufactured products,
and in the early 1980s the head-offices called upon Noite, Fíos and other
plants to stop using those brands on their labelling and start using Zara
on their products.
Table 4. First applications to the Spanish Patents and Trademarks Office
Samlor 31/1 /1974
Noite 4/2/1 977
Zara 19/6/1978
Nikole 8/1111978
Goasam, S.A. 6/11 /1979
Confecciones Fías, S.A. 27/08/1980
Choolet 28/7/1982
Goa de Goasam 26/3/1985
Zintura 4/7/1985
Source: www.oepm.es.
34
J. Cerviño, Marcas internacionales. Como crearlas y gestionarlas, Madrid, Pirámide,
2002.
35
C. Monllor, Zarápolis, Barcelona, Ediciones del Bronce, 2001 , pp. 199-200. Blanco
y Salgado, op. cit., p. 54.
201
European Business and Brand Building
36
As late as 1991 the magazine Eco, when comparing it to other Galician fashion
producers defmed Zara as a producer of "cheap fashion", Eco, No. 47 (1991).
37
Ministerio de Industria y Energía, Centro de Promoción de Diseño y Moda, Moda y
diseño: un desafio empresarial, Santander, 1986. Cortefiel's bias was more towards a
middle-aged maJe public; its prices were higher and it had a more austere and
traditional image.
38
J. Bonache and J. Cerviño, "Caso Zara: el tejido internacional", in J.J. Durán (ed.),
Multinacionales españolas. Algunos casos relevantes, Vol. I, Madrid, Editorial
Pirámide, 1996, pp. 54-55 .
39
José María Castellano indicated in 1993 that "Although the products the group
markets have a good quality-price ratio, the fashion component is the basic feature
that defmes them", Castellano, op. cit., p. 404.
202
Xoán Carmona Badía
was to kick off in 1989-1990 with the opening of the frrst stores in the
most emblematic areas in Porto, New York and París, and then continue
in geometric progression over subsequent years. This intemational
deployment was not only a growth strategy to offset the possible
saturation of the domestic market but also a lever for dismissing Zara' s
tag as a cheap clothes brand. Zara began to use signs in its Spanish
stores to announce the cities in which it was opening. The reference to
Paris, New York or other renowned fashion cities and the sites chosen
by the Galician chain in their more evocative areas acted as yet another
lever for escaping from that unfortunate tag. Even the possibility of
setting different prices in each country helped to develop this approach.
The third and last of these strategic approaches was to seek the
segmentation of the market by introducing new brands and self-owned
retail outlets for each one of them; in other words, brand-chains, which
would help to redress the two problems mentioned. This would
contribute not only to combating - as would intemationalisation - the
saturation effect that Zara might experience but also to the goal of
moving up a step for the business group as a whole. The new mix of
brand-chains built up from then on would include sorne that were
positioned in the middle segment or which were defmed not so much in
terms of higher/lower price parameters but rather according to
psychographic or generational ones. 40 Zara thereby embarked upon its
transformation into a multi-brand group by both creating new chains and
acquiring already existing ones.
The first step taken to segment the domestic market was the creation
of Pull & Bear in 1991, which would go on to form its own chain, with
its manufacturing facilities located in the Ferrol area, sorne 40
kilometres away from A Coruña. It specialised in clothing designed for
the young male market. That same year, Inditex bought two-thirds ofthe
stock in Massimo Dutti, a Catalan chain of stores providing men' s
fashion for the middle segment. It had been founded in 1985 by
Annando Lasauca and had a plant in Martorell and an attractive chain of
retail outlets in Spain and Portugal. It would be used as a way of
improving the company' s positioning in quality.41 Lasauca resigned a
few months later and Inditex took over its entire capital.
40
R.S. Tedlow, New and Improved. The Story of Mass Marketing in America, Boston,
Harvard University Press, 1990.
41
Coinciding with the purchase of Massimo Dutti, El País newspaper remarked that
"the Galician company' s aim here is to replace the cheap clothes' image with one
that identifies it with greater quality" (El País, 3/08/1991).
203
European Business and Brand Building
42
J.J. Durán Herrera (ed.), Las marcas renombradas españolas. Un activo estratégico
para la internacionalización de España, Madrid, McGraw Hill, 2002, p. 125.
43
Gene Cabaleiro, a Galician businessman in the sector admitted sorne time later that
"People used to hide their Zara bags, now they show them off. It was time to start
appreciating what we do here" . On this subject, see Monllor, op. cit., p. 189.
204
Xoán Carmona Badía
44
Nonetheless, and as Fábrega indicated (2004), the fmancial reward for the members
of the family - used to the utmost austerity- was also one of the reasons for the IPO
(pp. 48).
45
The change in communication policy regarding the company' s founder and majority
shareholder was truly spectacular. Amancio Ortega began to appear in photos aboard
his luxurious yacht or at race-courses where the most famous jockeys were riding, all
following a pattem reminiscent of the one mapped out by Pat Hudson for British
19'h century industrial tycoons, who after austere beginnings and once their
businesses had become consolidated deemed it necessary to give an irnage of success
to avoid any idle chat, and they did so through a degree of ostentation in externa!
trappings, such as the fme architecture oftheir mansions, well-stocked wine cellars or
owning a stable of purebreds, etc. See P. Hudson, The Genesis of Industrial Capital,
Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 1986.
205
European Business and Brand Building
The IPO was a resounding success,46 and so too were the processes
of market segmentation and intemationalisation. The introduction of
new retail chains associated with new brands has pursued two lines. A
frrst and main one involves catering for a young public that increasingly
accounts for an ever larger percentage of the demand for clothing
products and accessories. This led to the opening of Bershka in 1998, to
be followed a year later by the acquisition of Stradivarius, a small
Catalan chain, but one with very good ideas. At the same time, the
decision was taken to further the children's fashion line, which up until
then had been part of Zara, by boosting Kiddy's Class/Skhuaban. The
second line involving the creation of new chains focused on women's
lingerie (Oysho) and household furnishing (Zara Home). A recent
inclusion has been the Uterque chain for accessories, and children's
wear has been re-branded under the Zara label. The corresponding table
shows the growth recorded by these chains.
Inditex's growth over this period has focused on expansion abroad,
where the nurnber of stores increased sixfold between 1998 and 2007, as
opposed to fourfold for the group as a whole. Whereas at the beginning
of that period the stores abroad accounted for a third of the total, today
they make up half. It has been this growth in Zara' s intemational
presence, combined with its implicit traditional communication and its
new formal reporting policy that have turned Zara into a global brand.
From the perspective ofthe group's image, the greatest achievement,
however, has probably been its ability to convey the idea that nobody is
as quick at anything as Zara. Arranging two deliveries of clothes per
week, orchestrating stock outages to drive a greater rate of visits to
stores and creating an attractive atmosphere within them have managed
to create this image of immediacy and speed that is the very essence of
fashion. Back in 1993 Castellanos affirmed that the important thing was
not pricing but timing; Zara' s customers share this belief. Thus the cycle
of moving up a step to a higher segment has been fulfilled and it has
been achieved by changing the rules of the game. Gone is the concept of
cheap fashion, in which the advantages of popularisation were offset by
a certain disdain from above, and it has now been replaced by the notion
of Fast Fashion, which has no downside. To a certain extent, it is a
similar phenomenon to the one Pepsi-Cola developed in the 1950s.
Admittedly, it is shared with the other major retailers, but Zara has
managed it better. Along these lines, brand and image have hitherto been
paid little attention when analysing Zara' s success.
46
L. Fernández Fernández and S. Fernández López, "Deseño e impacto dunha OPV no
mercado de valores español: os casos de Inditex e Iberia", Revista Galega de
Economía, Vol. 10, No. 2, 2001.
206
Xoán Carmona Badía
Conclusion
The bulk of the literature on the Zara phenomenon seeks to explain the
reasons for its success in terms of the competitive advantages acquired
over the past twenty years. A large part of it does so by referring mainly to
the final link in the value chain, the stores, or to a series of features of the
communication between the different stages involved in it (flexibility,
speed ofresponse, etc.). All this no doubt explains the Spanish company's
rapid growth and spectacular intemational performance in recent years,
albeit not the mechanisms through which a small company located in a
region far removed from Spain' s textile manufacturing and fashion
centres managed in a very short time to become the country' s sector
leader, as it was by the end of the 1980s. When it comes to interpreting
this frrst chapter in Zara's history, one needs to resort to different
explanations. Here we have stressed, for example, that in its beginnings
Zara was above all a manufacturer, and its initial success was as such, and
not as a retailer. A decisive role in this early success was the ability the
farnily group and its partners showed in building up an extremely
complex network of production units (its own and affiliate companies,
independent workshops, cooperatives, etc.), which was not only a key part
ofthe company's success during the 1970s and 1980s but also involved an
organisational leaming process upon which sorne of the subsequent
advantages would be based.
By linking the brand's evolution to the company' s from the start, we
have seen how today's image of a global brand in which price is just
another one of its defming features, and not the main one, is in fact a
recent development, linked to intemationalisation and the company's
actual growth, and how, in tum, this transformation has been of
considerable irnportance for driving the latter.
CONFECCIONES
207
European Business and Brand Building
Former convent of the order of the Oblates, who hosted the first
clothing cooperative who worked for Zara in the area of A Coruña
208