Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2022
Volume: 6
Pages: 1000-1008
Document ID: 2022PEMJ396
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.7394228
Manuscript Accepted: 2022-02-12
Psych Educ, 2022, 6: 1000-1008, Document ID: PEMJ396, doi: 10.5281/zenodo.7394228, ISSN 2822-4353
Research Article
Abstract
The purpose of this study was to examine and understand the perspectives of self-identified atheists
and non-religious individuals living in religious families. The focus of this study is to learn more
about the living experience of adults who do not have religious or spiritual beliefs, but who live with
or are supported by a family with sacred religious beliefs. Thus, the researcher delved into the
historical background of phenomenology to determine and understand the process of phenomenology.
The study revealed the following structural themes: rejecting the infallibility of deities and religion,
atheism leads to knowledge, life away from despair and liberation from chains, captive by
misconception, the toxicity of generational and cultural stigmatization, in the process of being an
atheist, and the downside of being an atheist.
Introduction that was released as the lead single off his first studio
album, England Keep My Bones, on July 26, 2011.
With hardly any context, it covers the issue of self-
"God is dead. God remains dead. And we have killed acceptance for identifying outcasts (Zuckerman,
him." (Nietzsche, 1888), a well-known German 2007). The song became an emblem for atheist
philosopher recognized for his critiques of traditional populations' representation, empowerment, and
European ethical beliefs, said this. Nietzsche's most identification, like in the situation of the notable author
notable work is his critique of morality, "On the Christopher Hitchens, who declared himself an atheist
Genealogy of Morality," (Nietzsche, 1888) in which he by expressing these words in one of his publications.
focused on the psychological examination of a Fundamentally, this song is about being proud of the
significant moral idea. He had a profound influence on achievements that humankind has produced rather than
modern intellectual history. Nietzsche claimed that not condemning or thinking that it was made by someone
only did the conventional moral commitment lack the else who has divine power, notably "God," for our
base that we thought religion possessed, but that it was failures and achievements (Goldstein, 2010).
also inconceivably mortal (Kaufmann et al., 2017). His
oratory intellect astounded his audience, as he was Even though atheism is not new, Filipinos are wary of
adamant in his conviction that Christianity's moral it, particularly because they were conquered by
responsibilities were nothing more than an implausible Spaniards who imposed Christianity on our culture and
belief and a psychological need (Fitzgerald & Barry, beliefs. Atheism isn't just about not believing in any
n.d.). God; it's also about suspending judgment on whether
or not there is one, even if that implies a lack of
The term "atheist" has been a topic of contention theistic conviction(Draper, 2017). Atheists in
among researchers, with an apparently complicated philosophy aren't only people who don't believe in a
and changing definition (Brewster et al., 2014). transcendent creator; they're also those who are
Atheism has traditionally been described as the despair adamantly opposed to it (Vargas, 2016).
of one or more gods (Smith, 1979), but other scholars
have extended the term to include distrust in the Being an atheist in the Philippines means moving
supernatural. Atheists are also involved in this away from the sociable expectations of belief in
position. The word "atheist" does not mean believing religion and God to be socially deemed "others" in a
that gods or gods clearly do not exist (Hwang, much more religious socio-cultural environment
Hammer, & Cragun, 2009). (Smith 2010). Words such as "non-religious,"
"agnostics," and "atheism" are constantly used
“There is no God, No heaven, and no hell. There is no interchangeably, but Campbell makes a difference,
God, We're all in this together. There is no God, So stating that non-religion does not necessarily mean
ring that victory bell.” (Turner, 2016). Frank Turner's hostility to belief and theology. (Campbell, 1972:22).
"Glory of Hallelujah" is an unashamedly atheist song Indeed, as Campbell points out, there are some "very
our current society, allowing us to recognize that there thus should be tackled in today's culture, letting us to
are things that would explain the existence of "god" or acknowledge that there are aspects apart from religious
"spirit" in a scientific discussion other than biblically doctrines that might justify the presence of
speaking. This theory basically attempted to clarify the supernatural entities in a scientific manner.
concept of realism using rationality rather than faith in
something for which there is insufficient empirical Social Constructivist Theory
evidence. This idea is not intended to cause conflict
between religious and atheist people; rather, it is Human learning and knowledge are formed by human
intended to assist in the scientific understanding of engagement and are communal rather than isolated
how God, the universe, and even humans exist in this experiences, according to social constructivism
world. It was only used to describe the side of (Vygotsky, 1978). According to social constructivism,
scientific studies to obtain information about the all knowledge occurs because of human connection
existence of the real thing. and interaction skills, and is thus a shared, if not
individualized, experience. Rather than just viewing
Psychosocial Development Theory the environment, information is a product of different
social systems and connections.
The first five developmental stages of Sigmund Freud
were extended by Eric Ericsson to psychosocial This research study was driven by social constructivist
developmental theories. Ericsson, a 20th-century theory and an atheist personality construct. Social
psychologist, and psychoanalyst, wrote in 1959 an constructivism is a paradigm in which people endeavor
eight-step life-cycle theory based on the idea that the to comprehend the world they live in by attempting to
environment can have a significant impact on self- define, justify, or somehow compensate for that as
awareness, adaptability, human growth, and identity. well, particularly whereby everyone’s specific
Proposed. Ericsson, in his psychosocial theory, says viewpoint generates personal perceptions for specific
that egoistic personality is achieved by facing goals objects or situations (Gergen B., Creswell, 2012).
and difficulties during the eight developmental stages When applied to this study, this theory will reveal one
of the life stages. Two conflicting emotional impulses, of the most possible reasons for atheism among atheist
known as opposite trends, characterize each Filipinos who live within a religious household. Their
psychosocial stage and result in disasters that need to subjective and spiritual convictions, which are now
be addressed. Any crisis must be dealt with as soon as unexplainable by scientific thinking, may have
possible. Otherwise, a person's psychological well- trumped their socially constructive standpoint.
being will be at risk.
The adult's perspectives are personal interpretations
When applied to this study, Erikson's psychosocial that are mediated from contact with others as well as
theory provides insights into the relationship between historical and cultural conventions in this research.
atheism and adulthood. And the experience of Utilizing social constructivist theory, this study is
becoming an atheist. The ego strength of devotion that designed to be wide and comprehensive, allowing each
arises from the crisis of victorious identity allows respondent to make their personal understanding of the
individuals to show an adult belief that has evolved experiences. The area of developmental psychology
beyond the previous type of belief of an adult. The places a high importance on the form of interpersonal
experience of an atheist or non-religious individual connection and the respondents’ own backgrounds and
living in a religious family is properly understood by views will impact the understanding of this certain
considering the key elements of a psychosocial phenomenon.
perspective. This theory sheds light on the experience
and developmental complexity of religious adults, and The Law of Three Stages Theory
this study understands how atheistic or non-religious
adults understand their beliefs in religious A concept proposed by Auguste Comte, a French
households. philosopher. The “Law of Three Stages” is one of his
most important contributions to the field of
Furthermore, this theory will aid this study, especially sociological philosophy. He thought that if a mine kind
the respondents, in understanding how atheism progressed, it would become or dependent on
impacts a person's experience from a psychosocial mathematical and scientific proof rather than
standpoint. This concept will indeed offer the greatest philosophical and face-based conviction. The famous
justification for why atheists identity arises even theory by Comte is an instance of his findings for
though they are living in a religious household and social theories. According to Comte, the beings mind,
individual humans, all information, and the world are predicated on the idea that persons are rational and
grow in three successive phases. It is also one of the capable of evaluating their decisions using a self-
most fundamental principles of human organization, efficacy assessment. The individual will pick the
influenced by Turgot, Condorcet, and Saint- conduct that optimizes their profit or reward. It's
philosophical Simon's notions. possible that certain atheists consider this theory
analysis while deciding whether their religious family
The three phases of personal and psychological growth members will disgrace them.
are defined by the law of three stages. People and
culture must coordinate their feelings, thoughts, and Decision-Making Theory
actions. Our nature is divided into three distinct
components. Feelings, thoughts, and behaviors. And The Decision-Making Theory was first presented in
when applied to this research study, this theory will Herbert Simon’s renowned book, Administrative
describe the process of atheism in society today and Behavior, which was first published in 1947. It
the decrease of religious belief to the growth of suggests that decisions are important in our lives
imperial data by research when utilized in the study because one bad decision can have negative
paper. According to rationalism, God is not personally consequences in our lives. This research will be based
responsible for all phenomena. Pure reasoning insists on Herbert’s decision-making theory since we will
that God is an Abstract being. Metaphysical investigate how atheists evaluated their beliefs,
philosophy holds that the world's events are guided ultimately resulting in atheism.
and determined by an abstract power or force.
Metaphysical thought rejects the concept of a concrete People are life choices when they move their purpose
God. Positive or scientific knowledge is founded on for conduct beyond norms, religions, and feelings to
facts, which are obtained via observation and subjectivity. This hypothesis would offer a significant
experience. This theory will help the researchers justification behind why atheists develop and thus
determine the reason behind shifting to atheism despite should be tackled in our modern civilization. Self-
the fact that they live in a religious household; and this choices are the growing dominance of self-
will be very useful in understanding the aspects and determination in contemporary life. This concept will
perspective of adult Filipino atheists. also help the study, namely the co-researchers,
understand how self-decision influences adult atheist
Self-Efficacy Theory experiences and beliefs.
methodologies used by researchers to examine lived Second Step: First Reflection - Textual Themes: The
experience. This comprises the researchers' study significance units or core concepts were established at
design, which demonstrates the phenomenon or how it this step to characterize the narrative's qualities in the
would be solved. Personally identifiable information, first iteration. This was said in a single word, phrase,
such as ideas and beliefs, is acquired from informants or sentence. It was appropriately delimited and
or respondents for the research. Which can provide a assigned a topic. The interpretation of the co-
better understanding of the elements that influence the researchers of the emblem was incorporated as a
participants' sentiments and opinions regarding a literary subject during first analysis.
certain topic.
Third Step: Second Reflection – Structural Themes:
Co-Researchers The researchers will then expand on the interpretation
established by connecting and merging the textual
The co-researchers chosen to participate were themes of the co-researchers based on similarities,
determined under the specific criteria below: closeness, or common organizing principle to build a
structural theme. There may be times when themes
A Filipino citizen living inside Metro Manila City. intersect due to their interwoven character, in which
Consented willingly to be interviewed and included
one is linked to the others and to the whole. As a
in the research study.
Ages between 21 to 40 years old. result, themes with comparable meanings and
An atheist residing in a religious household connections will be blended into one.
Shall classify as atheist, non-believer, irreligious,
secular, and agnostics or an individual who do not Fourth Step: Third Reflection: The researchers
have faith and believe in divine powers. derived several ethical concepts or Fundamental
Insights/Postulates from the first and second phases of
Ways of Gathering Lived Experiences contemplation, which when synthesized produced
elements of the Eidetic Insight.
In the area of this research study, lived experience is
defined as a person's perceptions and interpretation of Ethical Considerations
their own experiences, alternatives, and possibilities,
as well as how they shape one's understanding Before proceeding to the interview, the researcher
perspective. Patterns, common behaviors, challenges, created an informed permission form to distribute to
and barricades are revealed by lived experience among all of the chosen participants, which ensured the
people who have had similar experiences. The data of anonymity and confidentiality of the co-researchers'
this research will be collected using a storytelling information. The goal of the study that the researcher
approach. wanted to achieve was also listed on the consent form.
It also includes the researcher’s criteria for
The storytelling method is a way of gathering determining whether co-researchers are qualified to
information and reflecting on it that usually involves participate in the interview. The researcher also
an interview or a question-and-answer style, with notes assured that the participation in the research is
or audio and video recording. There must be voluntary.
significant trust between the co-researchers and the
researchers recording the story so that co-researchers The researcher also assured that the participants have
are willing to be open and know how their story might the right to refuse or withdraw at any moment. The
be used. The method is suggested as a valuable way in researcher included his contact information in the
which to gain insights into adult atheists’ stories about consent form so that participants may contact him if
services and processes, to show effects, demonstrate they had any questions regarding the research. In
innovation and support the data study. consideration to the location and safety of both the
participants and researcher, the interview was
First Step: Gathering of Lived Experiences: The conducted online using Google Meet.
researchers transcribed each co-lived researcher's
experiences, which they obtained from them. The
researchers assigned the interview a title that Results
encapsulated the story's major point or theme after
transcribing it. They additionally requested that each
co-researcher provide an emblem that represented Structural Theme 1: Rejecting the infallibility of
themselves in their experience. deities and religions
Many people today are rejecting the infallibility of Structural Theme 4: Captive by misconception
religions and deities due to the rise of modernization.
It is the standard and default to mankind that the only Many atheists are challenged with the popular
way to genuinely believe in things or in reality is to misconception that they are satanists. Atheists have a
see or to perceive. Plethora of people in our problem not only because belief in God allows for a
contemporary life have shunned culture, legends, and more robust discussion of truth, direction, and
other superstitious beliefs, and supernatural beings in morality, but also because atheism has societal
the land, ocean, and sky that the elderly have ingrained consequences. Morality is difficult to describe
in our memories and our behavior itself because of the because so many theories have been presented to
scientific facts, evidence, and proofs that people can explain it as an evolution of social cognition or as a
access everywhere due to the ascension of lo g ical c o n s eq u e n ce . The most co m mon
digitalization. Atheism is like a clash of perspective, misconception is that atheists can morally blame.
they tend to place a higher emphasis on scientific Many people assume that atheists are not moral
discoveries and are less inclined to obstruct scientific compasses and do not consider God, so there is no
advancement for religious grounds, as has been the such thing as a decent atheist, but this is a broad
case in the past. As the basis of today, growing in a generalization with no merit.
reality full of evidence sheds the light to the life of
Structural Theme 5: The toxicity of generational
every person who wants to live radically and
perquisite. and cultural stigmatization
Structural theme 2: Atheism leads to knowledge As Filipinos, it is normal that we instill in ourselves
that family should come first even though it means
Being an atheist will always have the privilege to take sacrificing our dreams and beliefs. However, atheists
yourself in a way where you find awareness. You can managed to break the stigma of following the familial
bring yourself to not get easily fooled with other legacy of shaping your children into following the
people since in the first place you identify yourself as a beliefs of the ancestors. Hence the stigma that atheists
rational person who thinks the best way of coping a face until today shows how the older generation
situation. Becoming an atheist means becoming shaped the mind of the children to the belief that their
religion is the only way to be a good person, the only
fatalistic or seeing reality through the perspective of
truth, and the belief that we should always follow the
practicality. If you are an atheist, you have the option
ways of the Bible even though it really is questionable
of balancing euphoria in which your feelings or
to follow for the modern civilization. In atheism, they
emotions influence how you wish to talk, act, and react
managed to stray from the toxicity of being bound by
without being too restricted since you believe you are
their families' and society's religious beliefs.
no longer in line with the holy bible or have already
abandoned God's presence. Structural Theme 6: In the process of being an
atheist
Structural Theme 3: A life away from despair and
liberation from chains Being an atheist in the Philippines is difficult because
religions make up most of the population. We are
People who are atheists gain a better understanding of
taught what we should believe and how we should
what it means to be fully free. Nothing more, nothing practice it, such as attending church every Sunday,
less. Atheists can think freely, without intervention, reading the Bible, and being a devout follower.
dilution, contamination, or influence, objectively, and Children are constantly taught the virtues of religion,
most importantly, without the voice of a God. It has but as we grow older, we begin to question things on
always to do with our world perspective. If you can our own. The co-researchers have firsthand experience
think without any holy basis, no one should stop to with these issues; they grew up in a religious
have that freedom. Atheists can live meaningful, environment and began to realize how religion and the
moral, and happy lives without God. It's like breaking concept of God limits and shackles people in their
free from the shackles that represent the moral laws, current circumstances. Furthermore, atheists have seen
rules, despair, and beliefs ingrained in us by religion. how unfair religion is to people in life growing up in a
That is, it is not inconsequential, nihilistic, or religious household where they were able to see the
miserable. Atheists can live freely and without despair coins flipped side.
because they know there is no salvation, redemption,
or leniency. Structural Theme 7: The downside of being an
not only glides beyond its darker elements, but also Cultural Membership in American Society.” American Sociological
R e v i e w, vol. 71, no. 2, Apr. 2006, pp. 2 1 1 – 2 3 4 ,
obscures its differentiated value feature. The purpose
10.1177/000312240607100203.
for being an atheist would be not to make others feel
superior or to have a more fulfilling life. The rationale Fitzgerald, P., & Barry, C. (n.d.). Religion and Ethical Decision
for being an atheist is essentially as there is no God, Making. Santa Clara University. Retrieved April 9, 2022, from
https://www.scu.edu/mcae/publications/iie/v9n1/horizon.html
and we would like to dwell in full acknowledgment of
this, embracing the implications even if they make us Friedrich Wilhelm Nietzsche, and Adrian Del Caro. Beyond Good
unhappy. The darker truths of life are worse for us and Evil ; on the Genealogy of Morality. Stanford, California,
Stanford University Press, 2014.
than they were before for someone who has a tale to
talk about how everything turns out in the end and Goldstein, R. (2010). 36 Arguments for the Existence of God: A
only the most horrifying pain is part of a mysterious Work of Fiction. Pantheon Books.
divine design. Despite all the misconception, stigma,
Harappa. “Herbert Simon’s Decision-Making Theory.” Harappa, 21
prejudice, and stereotypes, the resiliency of an atheist June 2021, harappa.education/harappa-diaries/herbert-simons-
is significantly incredible. Their lives revolve on the decision-making-theory/.
present moment. Rather than submitting to a divine
Harper, Marcel. “The Stereotyping of Nonreligious People by
force, it is more about how people like to affect Religious Students: Contents and Subtypes.” Journal for the
everyone else around you. "Live quickly, die young" is Scientific Study of Religion, vol. 46, no. 4, 7 Dec. 2007, pp.
a prevalent pitfall. Even if you're not cautious, you 539–552, 10.1111/j.1468-5906.2007.00376.x. Accessed 10 Nov.
might become too impetuous, epicurean, and absorbed 2019.
by the "grass always seems to be better on the other Hwang, Karen, et al. “Extending Religion-Health Research to
side" mindset. Individuals may be unsatisfied with Secular Minorities: Issues and Concerns.” Journal of Religion and
their existence and have goals that seem out of reach. Health, vol. 50, no. 3, 1 Sept. 2009, pp. 608–622 ,
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19862619/, 10.1007/s10943-009-9296-0.
However, if you direct your atheism well, it may be
Accessed 16 Mar. 2022.
highly efficient and gratifying. Life is mostly about
tumbling down, trying to get up, and learning from Kaufmann, Walter. Religion from Tolstoy to Camus. Routledge,
mistakes. And it was about accepting and appreciating 2017.
every aspect of life's path, times when things go well. Maddux, William W., et al. “The Shortest Path to Oneself Leads
Making errors and feeling remorse are not the same around the World: Living Abroad Increases Self-Concept Clarity.”
thing. Atheism gave people the tenacity to fight for Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, vol. 145,
what they wished and to strive effectively even when Mar. 2018, pp. 16–29, 10.1016/j.obhdp.2018.01.002.
the odds were stacked against them. It also encouraged McAdams, Dan P., and Michelle Albaugh. “What If There Were No
them to celebrate their victories, repent, and move God? Politically Conservative and Liberal Christians Imagine Their
forward from their failings. Lives without Faith.” Journal of Research in Personality, vol. 42, no.
6, Dec. 2008, pp. 1668–1672, 10.1016/j.jrp.2008.07.013. Accessed
11 Oct. 2020.
References
Mitchell, T. (2017, May 10). Religious Belief and National
Belonging in Central and Eastern Europe. Pew Research Center.
Anderson, R. Lanier. “Friedrich Nietzsche.” Stanford Encyclopedia Retrieved April 10, 2022, from
of Philosophy, Metaphysics Research Lab, Stanford University, https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2017/05/10/religious-belief-a
2022, plato.stanford.edu/entries/nietzsche/#PrimLiteWorkNiet. nd-national-belonging-in-central-and-eastern-europe/
Accessed 26 May 2022.
Smith, J. (1979.). Comment: Conceptualizing atheist identity:
Bowman, Nicholas A., and Jenny L. Small. “Do College Students Expanding questions, constructing models, and moving forward. .
Who Identify with a Privileged Religion Experience Greater Sociology of Religion, 74(4), 454-463. doi:10.1093/socrel/srt052
Spiritual Development? Exploring Individual and Institutional
Dynamics.” Research in Higher Education, vol. 51, no. 7, 21 Apr. Smith, Jesse M. “Becoming an Atheist in America: Constructing
2010, pp. 595–614, 10.1007/s11162-010-9175-2. Accessed 25 Apr. Identity and Meaning from the Rejection of Theism.” Sociology of
2021. R e l i g i o n , v o l . 7 2 , n o . 2, 2 0 1 1 , p p . 2 1 5 – 2 3 7 ,
www.jstor.org/stable/41288569. Accessed 26 May 2022.
Campbell, Robert. YEARS under the EDITORSHIP of PERE
LOUIS CHEIKHO, S.J. 1972. Turner, Jeff. Atheistic Theist : Why There Is No God and You
Should Follow Him. Charleston, South Carolina, CreateSpace
Creswell, J.W. Qualitative Inquiry & Research Design: Choosing Independent Publishing Platform, 2016.
among the Five Approaches. 2012.
Vargas, Edwin. The New Atheism: Old Militant Scientism with a
Draper, Paul. “Atheism and Agnosticism.” Stanford Encyclopedia of New Name. Academia, 10 Apr. 2016, p. 8.
Philosophy, Metaphysics Research Lab, Stanford University, 2017,
plato.stanford.edu/entries/atheism-agnosticism/#DefiAthe. Woodruff, 2018. (2018). Phenomenological research methods for
counseling psychology. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 2(67),
Edgell, Penny, et al. “Atheists as “Other”: Moral Boundaries and 52. 1728-4457.2003.00255.