Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
The study sought to assess Bachelor of Secondary Education major in English working students’ oral
and written communication competence. The descriptive-correlation method was employed in this
study. The study involved 14 working students from College of Sciences Technology and
Communications’ Bachelor of Secondary Education major in English. For the quantitative part,
relevant data for this research were gathered through the researchers’ self-made 50-item oral
communication competence and 50-item written communication competence test with a table of
specifications (TOS). For the other data gathering instrument, the researcher used error analysis to
determine the oral and written communication challenges of the BSEd major in English working
students in terms of their submitted oral and written output. Results showed that student have varied
part-time jobs to support their family and studies financially. Majority of the students are in the
thorough level in written and acceptable level oral communication competence. In the content
analysis of the oral and written communication of the respondents, there were 28 recorded
grammatical errors and eight lexical errors in students’ output. A flexible learning module was
developed in response to the findings of the study.
job while studying. Being a part-time instructor competence, they can express ideas to others; and
handing major subjects in Bachelor in Secondary write and edit memos, letters, and complex technical
Education major in English, the researcher wanted to reports clearly and effectively.
come up with a study that could provide relevant and
timely findings on the status of oral and written As defined by Prabavathi and Nagasubramani (2018),
communication competence of BSEd English working written and oral communication is used daily in
students. The findings would provide research-based meetings, lecture halls, and exams. More than just
data for policy recommendations on the appropriate clearly speaking the language, communication skills
flexible programs that students needed. involve active listening and excellent presentation and
writing capabilities.
As a result, teachers and other educators at all levels of
education should encourage not only written In a well-recognized survey, oral and written
communication skills but also oral communication communication is one of the four competencies that
skills because students might have inherent difficulties employer’s value most. The other three are critical
with task s that in clu de oral and written thinking and problem solving, teamwork and
commu nication. collaboration, professionalism, and work ethics
(National Association of Colleges and Employees Job
Finally, the researcher also plans to develop a flexible Outlook, 2019). For working students, they can use
learning module containing lesson guides, activities academic skills to improve their work performance
and other tasks that could help them cope with their too. In most workplaces, employers highly appreciate
studies while they work. efficient communication skills (Yusuf, Yunus &
Mohamed, 2018).
Research Questions
Working students may sacrifice their time for sleep
The study sought to assess the Bachelor of Secondary and school activities. On the other hand, it can teach
Education major in English working students’ oral and them to wisely use their learnings when they decide to
written communication competence. Specifically, the work in the real world. It helps them to mature and to
study sought to achieve the following research realize they need a job and an education to succeed in
questions. the real world. It also helps them to decide what type
of business they want to get in the future (Arceo,
1. What are the part-time jobs of the BSEd English Dunca & Tena, 2014).
working students?
2. What is the level of oral and written communication The most often used oral communication forms use in
competence of BSEd English working students? class and at work are informal discussions, listening
3. What are the common oral and written and following instructions, and informal conversations
communication errors committed by BSEd English (Oteyza, Balmoria, & Sabularse, 2017), while written
working students in terms of grammatical and lexical communication documents include letters, emails, and
components? reports (Addams & Allred, 2015). Moreover, verbal
4. Based on the study's findings, what course plan can communication uses body language and tone of voice
be developed to help working students cope with oral to express meaning and tone; written communication
and written communication? relies on grammar, punctuation, and word choice.
(Addams & Allred, 2015). Thus, it is vital to reach a grammar errors are preposition, question, article,
desirable position in career paths such as job plural form of nouns, subject-verb agreement, and
recruitment, routine work, promotion, and tense. More so, the usage of decapitalization, different
advancement. types of fonts and colors, and the occurrence of
spelling mistakes were the main typographical features
In Ahmed's (2019) findings, she stated that identified (Mohammad, 2015).
communication is more than just sending and
receiving messages. The following are the benefits of Further, Castillo, Cadavido, Alonzo and Red (2015)
improving oral and clarifying misunderstandings, found out that the written communication errors of the
avoiding miscommunication, improving productivity, Department of Education elementary and secondary
reducing mistakes and errors, solving tension and teachers in their locality include letter format and
conflict, and promoting relationships and trust. It structure. Another list of communication errors was on
allows workers to formulate concepts, provide morphological, lexical, syntactical, and mechanical
transparency, and encourage collaboration and trust to features.
contribute to growth and development (Hutton, 2014).
Escobar-Mamani and Gómez-Arteta, (2020) found out
Prabavathi and Nagasubramani (2018) discussed that despite policies aimed at developing
working students’ difficulties in communicating their competencies, the expected results have not been
needs and ideas, products, and services in terms of achieved, and deficiencies have been found in
issues and problems encountered. Unfortunately, some communication development skills since most
do not have the professional impact they need to get participants do not yet demonstrate optimal speaking,
ahead in today's corporate world. listening, reading, and writing skills.
Further, Neeley et al. (2012) enumerated the adverse Evidence suggests that writing is a basic workplace
effects of having low communicative competence. communication medium (Yunus & Haris, 2014 in
According to them, insufficient language skills can be Yusuf, Yunus & Mohammed, 2018). Workplace
harmful to accomplishing work. They also claimed writing in English is an essential part of the current
that language use inefficiencies could cause loss of global workplace (Rajprasit, Pratoomrat & Wang
information, added work, loss of learning 2015); however, it is a complex task to perform
opportunities, and disruption of the collaborative (Johnson, 2020).
process. The surveys reveal that the lack of sufficient
language skills can cause financial losses through, Consequently, writing skills are more challenging to
among other reasons, lost contracts and incorrect develop than other skills since they are more
deliveries (Prabavathi & Nagasubramani, 2018). demanding and are not regarded as a merely
individually oriented, inner-directed cognitive process,
In Mohammad's (2015) study, he observed that written but as much as an acquired response to the discourse
communication, such as email messages, belonged to conventions within communities (Swales, 1990, p. 4,
chains or threads. On-going communication emails in Hanane & Sidoni, 2018). The present studies on low
between respondents were hard to comprehend. communication competence were also consistent with
Moreover, the email sent did not require recipients to the Philippine setting findings. Low academic
respond, which is not suitable for sending productivity due to insufficient knowledge and skills is
communication emails. one of the academic issues students faced (Pestano,
2017).
Further, between colleagues, the demonstration,
explanation, and instruction of English tasks seem to Further, a study found out that Filipino students were
be a significant challenge. In terms of the language o b s e r v e d to h av e a v a r i ed a cc en t wh en
used in meetings, students had trouble leading a communicating, poor grammar conveyed within a
discussion and sharing their opinions (Rajprasit & message, linguistic barriers range from use of jargon to
Hemchua, 2015). Due to a lack of linguistic resources actual language, low feedback, and lack of appropriate
and low strategic and sociolinguistic competence, the training suited to their needs (Hussain, Othman, Gabr
intended message may not be communicated, leading & Aziz, 2018).
to communication breakdown (Gan, Rafik-Galea &
Chan, 2017). However, Mahmud et al. (2019) enumerated the
similar findings of Aragon, Jimenez and Valle (2014),
Ting, Mahadhir and Siew-Lee (2010) found out in the Carlisle, Bhanugopan and Fish (2011) and Dessie and
error analysis of oral interactions that five common Ademe (2017), Dhar (2015), Oppenheim and
Weintraub, (2017), Seidle, Fernandez, & Perry, 2016; In their study, Castillo, et.al (2015) recommended that
Sung & Choi, 2014; Ubeda-Garcia, Marco-Lajara, a proposed flexible learning program must be adopted
Sabater-Sempere, & Garcia-Lillio, 2013, claiming that as their curricular priority. Specifically, English
students’ skills can adequately be improved through proficiency activities will improve not only
training, which results in achieving better personnel’s communication but also their capacity on
organizational and human resource outcomes. They preparing school reports, narratives, and the like.
also highlighted the importance of adequately
assessing training needs analysis in delivering The success of programs, outputs, and intervention
appropriate training programs. processes rely on communication and cooperation
inside the organization. Here, the workplace may turn
Indeed, the environmental setting plays a big part in into knowledge-intensive innovation centers in which
students' development. Pettersen (2016) concluded that collaborative work, networking, and transformative
geographical location plays a crucial role in creating a learning are key concepts being observed (Keisala,
common ground for communication and social Kovalainen, Majakulma, & Pitkänen, 2018).
integration among them since a core dimension in
knowledge work is social interaction. That is why As a synthesis of the literature mentioned earlier, the
schools should devise appropriate development authors presented the work and academic benefits of
programs for them. oral and written communication competence, activities
requiring oral and written communication. There were
Upskilling is the process of acquiring new and relevant similar and contrasting findings, and these were the
competencies needed today and years to come gaps that further call for in-depth research.
(Hanane & Sidoní, 2018). Thus, upskilling of students
can be achieved by determining problems and making
Methodology
solutions appropriate to their needs.
Hence, communication skills training will help one The descriptive method was employed in this study in
learn how best to communicate effectively in a wide identifying the level of competence of the working
range of situations and be direct to get the most out of students. It involves the current nature, composition, or
one's dealings with others (Beqiri, 2017). Further, it is processes of events being described, noted, analyzed,
always needed to have feedback to determine the little and interpreted. To find trends in recorded dialogue,
or big problem, which implies that it is needed in researchers utilize content analysis. One can undertake
every communication process (Oteyza, et al, 2018). content analysis by methodically gathering data from a
collection of written, spoken, or visual texts.
In terms of the proposed output, Nakatani's (2010) and
Rabab'ah's (2016) studies found that mastery of Participants
prefabricated expressions can improve written and oral
communication competence. Hence, creating programs The study involved 14 working students from College
and material to address communication problems is of Sciences Technology and Communications’
possible and in need. Bachelor of Secondary Education major in English.
They served as the respondents of the study since they
Comparative studies have found that raising awareness are the ones being handled by the researcher in her
of communicative strategies improves communication MJE-LING- Structures of English class. A purposive
strategy use and oral communication ability (Nakatani sample is a non-probability sample that is chosen
2010; Rabab'ah 2016 in Wei-Chieh, Cassim, Chia- based on demographic characteristics and the study's
Ning & Chen, 2018). With the aid of guidelines and goal. Purposive sampling, also known as judgmental,
materials which promote communication skills, selective, or subjective sampling, is distinct from
improvement can be achieved. convenience sampling.
Likewise, Peña, Rangel & Maciel (2015) found out Instruments of the Study
that there were better efficient indices on task
performance when the participants could have verbal In this study, the researcher engaged in a case study
interaction than when the communication was design. It refers is an in- depth study of one person,
restricted. Further, Addams & Allred (2015) stated that group, or event. According to Yin (2003), data is often
their respondents felt they gained improvements gathered using a variety of methods, including
through the proposed enhancement program. observations, interviews, documents, and video
(continuation Table 3)
(continuation Table 4)
Castillo. A.B., Cadavido, J.S., Alonzo, B.A, Condes, R. C., & Red,
Conclusion M.N. (2015). Written communication errors in English of DepEd
Quezon personnel: basis for written communication enhancement
program. R2A CALABARZON.
As a solution to financial problems brought by Escobar-Mamani, F., & Gómez-Arteta, I. (2020). WhatsApp for the
pandemic, students decided to have part-time jobs development of oral and written communication skills in Peruvian
making them very preoccupied with tasks that could adolescents. Comunicar, 28 (65), 107-116.
interfere their time for studying. Though the study did h t t p : / / d x . d o i . o rg / 1 0 . 3 9 1 6 / C 6 5 - 2 0 2 0 - 1 0
not dig dipper to the relationship of being a working Gan, L. K., Rafik-Galea, S., & Chan, S. H. (2017). Effect of oral
student and its effect to academic performance (oral communication strategies training on the development of malaysian
and written communication competence), the findings english as a second language learners' strategic competence.
International Journal of Education & Literacy Studies, 5(4), 57-77.
revealed that they are eyeing for a more flexible way
http://dx.doi.org/10.7575/aiac.ijels.v.5n.4p.57
of schooling so they could comply with the class
requirements while they work. Keisala, K., Kovalainen, N., Majakulma, A., & Pitkänen, P. (2018).
The role of language and communicative abilities in transnational
Most of the BSEd English working students are in the labor markets: Experiences from Finland. International Journal of
S o c i e t y , C u l t u r e & L a n g u a g e , 6( 2 ) , 5 9 - 7 2 .
Thorough Level when it comes to written https://search.proquest.com/scholarly-journals/role-language-commu
communicative competency while in the Acceptable nicativeabilities/docview/2131576560/se-2?accountid=146485
Level in terms of oral communicative competence.
Hanane, B. T., & Sidoní L.P (2018). Teaching written
This shows that these students find it more difficult to
communication strategies: a training to improve writing.
write their thoughts than to express them orally. International Journal of Applied Linguistics & English Literature,
7(2), 150-162. http://dx.doi.org/10.7575/aiac.ijalel.v.7n.2p.150
Use of contraction is the most common grammatical
error while wordiness is the most common lexical Hussain, M.A., Othman, A.A.E., Gabr, H.S. & Aziz, T.A. (2018,
December). Causes and impacts of poor communication in the
error found in the document analysis of students’
construction industry. Paper presented at the 2nd International
written and oral output. This shows that the Conference on Sustainable Construction and Project Management –
participants are still confused with the use of “it’s and Sustainable Infrastructure and Transportation for future Cities.
its” when writing. Wordiness is also observed in Aswan, Egypt
writing but is more evident in oral communication. Johnson, M. D. (2020). Planning in L1 and L2 writing: Working
Students tend to use fillers and other words that can memory, process, and product. Language Teaching, 53(4), 433-445.
lengthen their compositions. 4. Since none of the doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0261444820000191
students are in the advanced level, they needed a more
Mahmud, K. T., Ishraat, S. W., & Arif, I. (2019). Impact of training
flexible way of learning to compensate the time they needs assessment on the performance of employees: Evidence from
spent working than studying. Thus, the development of B a n g l a d e s h . C o g e n t S o c i a l S c i e n c e s , 5 (1) doi:
a flexible course plan for working students is needed. h t t p : / / d x . d o i . o rg / 1 0 . 1 0 8 0 / 2 3 3 1 1 8 8 6 . 2 0 1 9 . 1 7 0 5 6 2 7
National Association of Colleges and Employers (2019. The four Literature, 2 1 (3).
ca ree r c o mp e t e n c i e s e mpl oy e r s value mos t. http https://search.proquest.com/scholarly-journals/english-language-am
naceweb.orgNational Association of Colleges and Employers pcommunication-
(NACE) (2020 ). Career readin es s c o mp etencies. international/docview/2257700601/se-2?accountid=146485
https://www.naceweb.org/careerreadiness/competencies/career-readi
ness-defined/ Yusuf, N. K., Yunus, M. M., & Mohamed, A. E. (2018). Workplace
writing in L2 experiences among millennial workforce: Learning to
O’Leary, Z. (2014). The essential guide to doing your research write in English. 3L, Language, Linguistics, Literature, 24(1) doi:
project (2nd ed.). Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications, Inc. http://dx.doi.org/10.17576/3L-2018-2401-11
Oteyza, A.M., Balmoria, B.E., & Sabularse, M. (2018). Wang, J., Chen, C. I., Liu, Y., Barkley, D., & Wu, C. (2020).
Effectiveness of oral and written communication of university Intercultural competences and job satisfaction of expatriates: the
employees. Asia Pacific Journal of Multidisciplinary Research, 6 mediating effect of positive psychological well-being. International
(1), 88-95. Journal of Organizational Innovation (Online), 12(3), 140-155.
http://www.apjmr.com/wpcontent/uploads/2018/01/APJMR-2017.6. https://search.proquest.com/scholarly-journals/intercultural-compete
1.11.pdf nces-job-satisfaction/docview/2334750705/se-2?accountid=146485
Perez-Rubio, B. (2020, November 19). 2020 English proficiency Wei-Chieh Fang, Cassim, F. A. K., Chia-Ning Hsu, & Chen, N.
index: Philippines out of world's top 20 but is no.2 in Asia. The (2018). Effects of reciprocal peer feedback on EFL learners’
Philippine Star Global. http.www.philstar.com communication strategy use and oral communication performance.
Smart Learning Env i ronme nt s, 5 (1), 1 -16.
Prabavathi, R. & Nagasubramani, P.C. (2018). Effective oral and h t t p : / / d x . d o i . o rg / 1 0 . 1 1 8 6 / s 4 0 5 6 1 -0 1 8 -0 0 6 1 -2
written communication. Journal of Applied and Advanced Research,
3 (Suppl. 1)
S29−S32.https://dx.doi.org/10.21839/jaar.2018.v3S1.164 Affiliations and Corresponding Information