Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/267796669
CITATIONS READS
6 402
1 author:
Paul Cheung
National University of Singapore
43 PUBLICATIONS 235 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Paul Cheung on 02 April 2015.
Paul CHEUNG
National University of Singapore
185
Paul CHEUNG
With hardly any natural resources other than growing industries. The government projects
her strategic geographic location, Singapore's most included the setting up of the Industrial Training
precious resource for economic development is her Center to help the large numbers of young female
people. This recognition has been the key in the workers to acclimatize themselve to factory life, the
formulation of Singapore's educational policy and Light Industries Services Unit with United Nation
the charting of the educational and manpower Development Project assistance to provide the
development programmes over the last three electronics industry with supporting services and to
decades. The development of the educational system train workers, and the Singapore Institute of
has also been closely linked to Singapore's economic Management for the promotion of management
development objectives and plans. training. In order to accelerate technical and
vocational training, a Technical Edcuation
General Education in The Early Years Department was organised within the Ministry of
Education in 1968 to administer technical education
When Singapore attained self-government in and industrial training programmes.
1959, economic conditions were poor. There was Several industries also implemented their own
high unemployment and the entrepot-based training and apprenticeship programmes. To enable
economy provided little growth prospects for them to select the most effective training methods,
sustained economic development. Job creation then the government provided some financial assistance.
was the overriding objective when the government A "quick start" approach was adopted and
embarked on the road to economic development supported by the Economic Development Board
through an ambitious industrialisation programme. under the Industrial Development Scholarships
However, this broad objective of massive job Scheme. Under this scheme, financial assistance was
creation made difficult the introduction of a detailed provided to multinational corporations to send their
and well-defined educational policy. The key personnel abroad for in-plant training. A pilot
educational policy then focused largely on providing scheme for overseas industrial training was also
free and universal primary education, making introduced, whereby apprentices were attached to
secondary education more widespread, encouraging reputable companies in Germany and Switzerland
vocational and technical education, and expanding for long-term training. On completion of their
tertiary education. training, these apprentices returned as fully-trained
workers.
Post-independence Emphasis on Technical Education By the early 1970s, the economic situation had
and Training improved and the economic strategy shifted towards
promotion of more sophisticated industries and high
Singapore's economic situation suffered a economic growth. This greatly increased the need
set-back soon after independence was achieved in for manpower with the necessary skills and
1965. Singapore had to contend with the continuing technological capabilities. The Technical Education
effects of the confrontation with Indonesia when it Department was converted into an Industrial
joined Malaysia in 1963. The economic problems Training Board in 1973, as the national authority
resulting from suspension of trade with Indonesia for the coordination and promotion of all forms of
were aggravated by Singapore's separation from industrial training at skilled level. Concomitantly,
Malaysia in 1965 and the British decision in 1968 to enrolments at the Singapore Polytechnic, Ngee Ann
withdraw its military base from Singapore. In order Technical College and University of Singapore were
to address these problems and push for faster expanded to meet demands for technical and
economic development, strategies were adopted to professional manpower.
promote export-oriented industries and develop Greater efforts were also made to expand
trade, financial and technical services. technical education at secondary level. A dual
The Economic Development Board was system developed, whereby students could pursue an
established to spearhead the economic development academic or vocational education in secondary
plans. It was instrumental in initiating and schools. Secondary one and two students in the
organising a number of training programmes to academic stream were required to do a minimum
meet the increasing need for skilled workers by the amount of workshop practice. For those who were
186
Educational Development and Manpower Planning in Singapore
in secondary technical schools, they received an to pre-mature school leaving was not the only form
academic education with a technical emphasis. of educational wastage. Wastage also arose from
rather than training in individual trades or crafts. failure to achieve expected standards, repetition of
The emphasis on vocational arid technical grades and poor employment prospects for school
education resulted in a remarkable increase in leavers.
student enrolment, The number of secondary school The problems in the educational system were
students in the technical stream rose from 12,000 in identified by a top-level, government study team
1971 to 18,000 by the end of the 1970s. During the which was formed in 1978 to review the education
same period, enrolment expanded significantly from system. Though the education system has so far
6,000 to 14,500 in the vocational and technical been able to support economic development, the
institutes and from 5,500 to almost 10,000 in the high incidence of educational attrition created fears
polytechnics. that the system might gradually fail to meet the ever-
increasing demands for a skilled and professional
Better Coordination of Higher Education workforce.
Arising from the study team's report, a new
It is clear from the foregoing that education and educational system has been introduced since 1980.
manpower training in Singapore are carried out The fundamental principle of this new system is that
both within and outside the formal educational streaming is necessary to avoid the unacceptable
system by the public and private sectors. With attrition rates of the past. Streaming is carried out at
several government agencies having a direct interest both the primary and secondary levels, with
and involvement in educational development and provisions for lateral transfers between streams.
manpower planning and training, a central During the decade of the 1980s, primary school
coordinating body became necessary. The Council pupils were streamed into three courses of study at
for Professional and Technical Education was the end of primary three. Two of the courses which
established in 1979 to provide better coordination prepared the pupils for the primary school leaving
among the various government agencies. Its main examination. Fast learners took another three years
objective is to ensure that an adequate supply of to complete their primary education while the slower
trained professional, technical and skilled manpower learners did so in a longer period of five years. The
is available for Singapore's continued economic third course was a non-academic course designed for
development and restructuring. The Council for the less academically inclined students who acquired
Professional and Technical Education makes basic literacy and numeracy for another five
periodic projections and recommends annual years in preparation for pre-vocational training at
enrolment targets and the corresponding staffing vocational institutes,
and financial requirements for tertiary and At the secondary level, streaming started right
vocational/technical institutes. at the beginning when pupils entered secondary one.
They had the choice of academic courses designed to
Major Restructuring to Reduce Educational Wastage match their learning abilities and interests. Faster
learners completed their secondary education and
While the expansion of capacity in. the various sat for the Genera! Certificate of Education
educational institutions provided an increasing Ordinary Level examinations at the end of four
supply of skilled and professional manpower, an years. Slower learners took five years to prepare for
issue that quickly assumed critical dimensions was the General Certificate of Education Ordinary Level
the considerable wastage in the educational system examination.
that evolved during the 1960s and 1970s. This was That the educational system put in place in
because a single system of education was imposed on 1980 has been successful in raising educational
children with varying academic abilities and learning achievements is evident from the increasing
rates and the educational progression and retention percentage of passes at Primary School Leaving
policies resulted in high attrition rates. In the late Examination, and General. Certificate of Education
1970s, the attrition rates were 29% at primary level Ordinary and Advanced Level, Table 1 shows the
and 36% at secondary level. Education attrition due trends since 1980.
187
Paul CHEUNG
188
Educational Development and Manpower Planning in Singapore
00
Universities e
~o
UNIVERSITY o
.e
EDUCATION 00 O
O
GCE 'S.
>.
H
Polytechnics/ 13
POST ITE 18
EDB Institutes Junior
SECONDARY Institutes of Technology 17
Colleges 11
EDUCATION
16
GCE O-level
'ssssss/ss/ss/sssssss*
10
Normal (Academic)/ 15
Normal (Technical) Special/Express 9
SECONDARY course 14
course 8
EDUCATION 4 years
4 years 13
7
12
Orientation Stage
P5-P6 11
with different language streams
10
PRIMARY
EDUCATION
1
9
Foundation Stage
P1-P4 8
7
National Examination
189
Paul CHEUNG
At the secondary level, pupils undergo either key feature of the changes is that most pupils will
four or five years of secondary education with have at least ten years general education up to the
different curricular emphases. The majority of pupils secondary level. Another important change is the
are streamed into the Special or Express courses, introduction of a new Normal (Technical) course in
both of which lead to the General Certificate of secondary schools.
Education Ordinary Level Examination in four Secondly, the improvements introduced by the
years. The rest enter the four-to-five years Normal Review Committee have significant implications on
course which leads to the General Certificate of vocational/technical education. As a consequence, a
Education Normal Level Examination at the end of Vocational and Industrial Training Board Review
four years. Those who perform well go on to sit the Committee was formed to formulate plans for the
General Certificate of Education Ordinary Level restructuring and upgrading of the vocational/
Examination at the end of the fifth year. The others technical training system to meet the needs of
will either go on to vocational training or take up secondary school leavers and the economy. This
employment as the Normal Level certificates are Review has led to the upgrading of the Vocational
recognised by employers. and Industrial Training Board into a post-secondary
Depending on their General Certificate of training institution and more opportunities for
Education Ordinary Level examination results, vocational/technical trainees to progress to further
those who wish to pursue further academic education.
education will proceed to pre-university. Pupils may Thirdly, at the tertiary level, the educational
either apply for a two-year course in a junior college developments are closely linked to the on-going
or three-year course in a centralised institute or review and recommendations of the Council for
pre-university centre. At the end of their Professional and Technical Education. Enrolment in
pre-university course, pupils will sit for the General the polytechnics, National University of Singapore
Certificate of Education Advanced Level and Nanyang Technological University have been
examination. Alternatively, pupils may join the monitored closely by the Council for Professional
technical or commercial institutes under the Institute and Technical Education and fine-tuned yearly. This
of Technical Education, the polytechnics or is to ensure that they produce sufficient numbers of
Economic Development Board training institutes. graduates in relevant disciplines for economic
Pupils who have passed their General restructuring and enhancement of Singapore's
Certificate of Education Advanced Level can opt to technological capability. The result is a rapid,
enrol in the various institutions of higher learning in coordinated expansion of tertiary educational
Singapore. These include the polytechnics, facilities and steady increase in output of graduates
Economic Development Board training institutes in a wider range of disciplines.
and universities. Alternatively, those who aspire to Another important educational development
be teachers can opt for the National Institute of which revolutionizes school organisation and
Education. On the average, a student spends a management in the decade of the 1990s is the
minimum of 16 years to obtain a university formation of independent schools. So far, eight of
education. Typically, he would spend 6 years in Singapore's top secondary schools have opted to
primary school, 4 years in secondary school, 2-3 operate more independently of the Ministry of
years in pre-university and 3-4 years in the Education. The objective of allowing these schools
university. to become independent schools is to enable them to
upgrade their education programme by improving
Educational Changes to Meet Manpower Needs in the their teacher-pupil ratios and introducing enrich-
1990s ment and other programmes for their pupils.
Independent schools have the flexibility to decide
The educational system described above is the curriculum matters, charge the appropriate
result of a number of educational developments educational fees, and recruit and reward teachers.
since 1990. Firstly, the developments at primary By offering a variety of educational programmes
level and secondary levels follow from the and improved infrastructure, such schools raise
recommendations of a Ministry of Education educational standards as they compete not just for
Review Committee which was set up in July 1990. A the best students but also for the best teachers and
190
Educational Development and Manpower Planning in Singapore
191
Paul CHEUNG
192
Educational Development and Manpower Planning in Singapore
2:
In the last ten years, the number of university independent schools and the top 10% in each
graduates has more than doubled from 2,400 in 1982 government and government-aided schools. It
to 6,600 in 1992. More importantly, the proportion ranges from $300 for awards to pupils in the
of engioeering graduates from the universities has government and government-aided schools up to
increased from 15% to 22%. The number of $2,400 per year for awards to pupils in the more
polytechnic graduates also increased, from 3,200 to expensive, independent schools.
8,400. Table 2 above provides some key indicators The Edusave grant is an annual grant of
of polytechnic and university education in about $10,000 provided to each government and
Singapore. government-aided secondary schools for their use in
educational and enrichment programmes for the
Education Endowment Find pupiils.
Parallel to the structural changes in Singapore's Continuing Education and Skill Development Fund
education system, the government has established an
Educational Endowment Fund with effect from The success of Singapore's efforts in
1993. Through income earned from the Education restructuring the economy lies not only in producing
Endowment Fund, pupils benefit from three an increasing inflow of skilled entrants into the
different schemes, namely, the Edusave account, workforce but also in nurturing and training the
Edusave scholarship and Edusave grant. Edusave is existing workforce to upgrade their skills and adapt
intended to maximise and equalise opportunities for to rapid technological and structural changes in the
students in government schools so that they can economy. The National Productivity Board has
compete with those in independent schools been actively involved in worker training and
which have more enrichment and extra-curricular continuing education. Training programmes
programmes. designed to raise worker productivity include
An Edusave account is opened for every pupil courses on labour-management relations, manage-
aged six to sixteen. It is credited annually with a sum ment skills and worker's core skills for effectiveness
of money which could be used by pupils to pay and change.
for school-based educational or enrichment pro- Apart from National Productivity Board's
grammes or for the payment of miscellaneous productivity-related training programmes, various
educational fees. The amount credited for a start in continuing education programmes for workers have
1993 is $50 and this may rise to $400 per year. also been launched. These include:
The Edusave scholarship is provided only to the (a) Basic Education for Skills Training pro-
top 25% of secondary one pupils enroled in the gramme, started in 1983, offers opportunities
193
Paul CHEUNG
to workers below 40 years without a Primary 6 Development Grant Scheme, Basic Education for
education to acquire basic knowledge of Skills Training and Worker Improvement through
English and Mathematics. Secondary Education. The latter two are nationally-
(b) Worker Improvement through Secondary driven remedial adult eduation prorammes aimed at
Education programme, launched in 1986, is equipping workers with only primary or no formal
aimed at workers who have completed either qualification with a certain level of literacy and
primary school or Basic Education for Skills numeracy for further training. The Emerging/
Training programme and are keen to sit for Critical Skills Scheme, on the other hand, is a
the secondary school examination at General relatively new scheme introduced by Skills
Certificate of Education Normal level. Development Fund aimed to help companies
(e) Modular Skills Training provides skills venture into emerging or critical skills deemed
training during evenings and weekends for crucial to the continued development of their
workers with at least primary school leaving industries.
examination qualification or 2 years relevant
working experience. Concluding Remarks
(d) Training Initiative for Matured Employees is
designed for older worker above 40 years old Educational streaming has provided Singapore's
who do not have formal educational formal educational system with an inherent
qualification. flexibility that minimises educational wastage.
(e) FAST FORWARD is a home-based worker Streaming at primary and secondary levels allows
education programme for workers without pupils to study courses that are suited to their
secondary education and who have not different abilities and needs. Further, ample
enroled in conventional training programmes. provisions are made in the system for the less
The Singapore government has provided academically-inclined to pursue vocational and
financial support for the various worker training technical education and training at secondary and
and continuing education programmes. A Skills post-secondary levels. The system gives pupils a
Development Fund has been established since 1979 good general education as well as a firm foundation
to provide funds for the subsidised training of to build up the skills and expertise that are necessary
workers. This is to encourage employers to upgrade to meet manpower needs for rapid economic
the skills of their workers. The Skills Development development.
Fund is financed through a levy on salaries of The multi-agency, coordinated approach to
employees earning less than S$ 1,000 per month. The manpower planning and training has also ensured a
levy is paid by employers. In 1980, a total of S$18 steadily increasing supply of the trained manpower
million was committed for training grants. This in specific fields of occupations. At the tertiary level
amount increased by more than three times to S$81 and beyond the formal school system, institutes of
million in 1991. The number of workers who higher learning and various government agencies
benefited from such grants rose from 11,000 in 1980 work in concert to expand the pool of skilled,
to 301,000 in 1985 and further to 408,000 in 1991. technical and professional manpower and to
The schemes implemented by Skills promote educational and skills upgrading. Their
Development Fund since its foundation include the efforts augur well for the enhancement of
Training Grant Scheme, the Emerging/Critical Skills Singapore's technological capabilities.
194
Educational Development and Manpower Planning in Singapore
Dr. Paul CHEUNG is Senior Lecturer of the Development of Social Work & Psychology, National University
of Singapore.
195