You are on page 1of 10

Life Sciences Practice

What are the biotech


investment themes that
will shape the industry?
From 2019 to 2021, venture capitalists plowed $35 billion into
biotech companies with advanced platform technologies that
could transform the industry.

by Olivier Leclerc, Michelle Suhendra, and Lydia The

© Who_I_am/Getty Images

June 2022
The past three years have seen a boom in venture (Exhibit 1). Despite recent dips in the valuations of
capital (VC) funding in the biotechnology sector. newly public companies and a slight decline in VC
Our research shows that VC companies invested in funding over the past four quarters, VC companies
2,200 biotech start-ups worldwide in 2016; by 2021, continue to plow money into biotech.2 The
that number had grown to 3,100.1 We also found that exuberance of these seasoned early-stage investors
biotech companies raised more than $34 billion signals that they see the potential for significant
globally in 2021, more than doubling the 2020 total breakthroughs in how drugs are discovered,
of $16 billion. targeted, and delivered. Start-ups with cutting-edge
platform technologies—which constitute a base
In the biotech sector, VC funding peaked in the or infrastructure on which other therapies can be
first quarter of 2021 and has declined slightly since developed—have benefited the most.

Web 2022
VCBiotechFunding-V1-Ex1to3
Exhibit
Exhibit 1 of13

Venture capital biotech


biotech funding
funding peaked in the first quarter of 2021 has
2021 and has
slightly declined since.
slightly declined since.
Capital raised by privately funded biotech companies at seed to series C,1 total investment, $ billion

9.1 8.9
8.3 8.5
7.6

4.9 4.8
3.9

2.7
2.1 2.2 1.9
1.5

Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1
2019 2020 2021 2022
1
Deals >$10 million in seed to series C in privately held companies during 2019–21; filtered for “biotechnology” industry; excludes contract and research
services, industrial biotechnology, and food/agriculture.
Source: McKinsey analysis based on PitchBook, Inc., data; has not been reviewed by PitchBook analysts

1
Unless otherwise noted, all figures in this paper were derived from our original research.
2
Nikou Asgari, Hannah Kuchler, and Jamie Smyth, “Biotechs face cash crunch after stock market ‘bloodbath,’” Financial Times, February 9, 2022.

2 What are the biotech investment themes that will shape the industry?
We analyzed VC and private-equity funding from products, research tools, and contract research and
seed to series C in privately held biotech companies services companies.
with deal sizes greater than $10 million from 2019
to 2021. For historical context, we also analyzed
seed and series A deals in 2017 and 2018. We Investment in next-generation
categorized companies by their differentiating biotech platforms
platform technologies; for biotech companies From 2019 to 2021, VC companies invested more
working in multiple therapeutic areas on various than $52 billion in therapeutic-based biotech
platforms, we categorized them first by platform and companies globally. Two-thirds of that went to start-
then by therapy type. Our analysis excluded medical ups with platform technologies (Exhibit 2).

Web 2022
VCBiotechFunding-V1-Ex1to3
Exhibit
Exhibit 2 of23

More than two-thirds of venture capital


capital biotech
biotechfunding
funding from
from 2019
2019to
to2021
2021
went to start-ups
went to start-upswith
withplatform
platformtechnologies.
technologies.

Seed to series C1 VC funding in privately held biotech companies, 2019–21, $ billion

Cell therapy 2.0 Next-generation


gene therapies

7.7 7.6
34.6 Precision Machine Validated but New Small
Platform-based medicine learning– “undruggable” delivery molecules 0.8
therapeutics enabled drug targets methods Other
discovery biologics

4.5 4.4 4.0 2.3 3.4


Immuno-oncology Neurological Infectious Immunology Other
disorders diseases
0.9
17.2 Metabolic
Other diseases
0.8
therapeutics 4.6
Cardio-
Other oncology vascular 0.6
Aging
2.4 2.9 2.5 0.5 2.1

Note: Figures may not sum, because of rounding.


1
Deals >$10 million in seed to series C in privately held companies during 2019–21; filtered for “biotechnology” industry; excludes contract and research
services, industrial biotechnology, and food/agriculture.
Source: McKinsey analysis based on PitchBook, Inc., data; has not been reviewed by PitchBook analysts

What are the biotech investment themes that will shape the industry? 3
VC investors appear focused on emerging Six biotech platform technologies
technologies that can tailor treatments to individual with transformative potential
patients and deliver them to the target site with In each biotech platform that has received
great accuracy. Six platforms are generating investment interest, emerging tools have the
significant investor excitement: potential to address challenges and push current
technical boundaries (Exhibit 3).
— Cell therapy 2.0 can more precisely address
diseased tissues or cells or address a wider Cell therapy 2.0
range of disease (such as solid tumors). As of 2021, approved cell therapies3 have
generated more than $2 billion in sales, and the
— Next-generation gene therapies can edit and market is expected to reach $20 billion by 2026.
modulate DNA and RNA and have the potential Since the first chimeric antigen receptor (CAR)
to cure genetic diseases. T cell therapy was approved in 2017,4 they have
revolutionized the treatment of hematologic
— Precision medicine can diagnose conditions malignancies, achieving unprecedented efficacy.
earlier than other diagnostic tools can and tailor New cell therapy technologies and techniques offer
therapies to patients’ specific genetic profiles. the potential to address diseases with significant
unmet needs (such as solid tumors, which represent
— Drug discovery enabled by machine learning more than 90 percent of adult cancers5) and
(ML) can cut through vast swaths of data to nononcological conditions.
speed the discovery and development of
new drugs. However, some significant challenges (including
safety) that cell therapies face have hindered
— Strategies are being developed for broader use. The inflammatory cytokine release
“undruggable” targets, including hard-to-hit syndrome sometimes associated with CAR T
proteins and hard-to-treat diseases. cells, for example, can cause side effects ranging
from flu-like symptoms to organ failure and death.
— New delivery methods can send novel therapies Current autologous cell therapies (that is, therapies
to the entire affected tissue precisely and safely. using cells obtained from the patient) require
lengthy treatment that can give a disease time
to progress. Scientists are studying new ways to
harness and modify patients’ cells, and from 2019
to 2021 VC companies stepped up funding of these
second-generation efforts.

3
“Facts about cellular therapies,” AABB—Association for the Advancement of Blood & Biotherapies, accessed May 23, 2022.
4
“CAR T cells: Timeline of progress,” Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, accessed May 23, 2022; Shannon L. Maude et al.,
“Tisagenlecleucel in children and young adults with B-cell lymphoblastic leukemia,” New England Journal of Medicine, February 1, 2018,
Volume 378, Number 5, pp. 439–48.
5
“Solid tumor research,” Thermo Fisher Scientific, accessed May 23, 2022.

4 What are the biotech investment themes that will shape the industry?
Web 2022
VCBiotechFunding-V1-Ex1to3
Exhibit 3 of 3
Exhibit 3
Venture capital
capital funding
fundingininbiotech
biotechcompanies
companieswas
wasdriven
drivenby
byinnovative
innovativeplatform
technologies.
platform technologies.
Seed to series C1 VC funding in privately held biotech companies, by platform technology, 2019–21,
$ billion

7.7 7.6
Cell therapy 2.0 Next-generation gene therapies

Innate immune cells Other T cell therapies RNA-based Other viral-vector


modalities technologies
and editing

1.3
Precision control
of cell therapy
1.7 2.2
Novel Other nucleic acid
1.1 nucleases technologies
In vivo Other
cell therapy 0.4 0.1
0.9
Other
Non-nuclease
stem cell
editing and
therapies
modulation
0.9 4.0 0.7 2.0
Early disease
detection
Target
identification
New small-
molecule
Improved
capsids 0.8
binding sites Small
molecules

3.4
Other
biologics
1.8
1.0
Biomarker
discovery 2.1 Biological
Rational 2.0 vehicles
drug design 0.3
Novel Protein
disease degradation Enhanced nano-
targets particles 0.2
Other
1.5 delivery
Precision population 0.5 0.5 methods
health 0.3
Other precision 1.7 Other undruggable
medicines target methods
Lead
validation 0.5
1.0 Other ML methods 0.2 0.9 0.9

4.5 4.4 4.0 2.3


Precision Machine learning Validated but New
medicine (ML)–enabled ‘undruggable’ delivery
drug discovery targets methods

Note: Figures may not sum, because of rounding.


1
Deals >$10 million in seed to series C in privately held companies during 2019–21; filtered for “biotechnology” industry; excludes contract and research
services, industrial biotechnology, and food/agriculture.
Source: McKinsey analysis based on PitchBook, Inc., data; has not been reviewed by PitchBook analysts

What are the biotech investment themes that will shape the industry? 5
Three new approaches stood out among cell for genetic disorders. According to a McKinsey
therapy platforms: analysis of pharmaceutical industry data from
Evaluate, roughly 400 gene therapies are currently
— Innate immune cells. While CAR T cell therapies in development; by 2025, they could comprise
have shown initial success, some start-ups around 20 percent of new product launches. The
are shifting their focus from T cells to innate field continues to evolve, with gene editing enabling
immune cells (such as natural killer [NK] cells permanent and precise genetic deletions and ex
and macrophages) because they may better vivo modifications.
penetrate solid tumors. The growing interest
in innate immunity, primarily in NK cells, was Obstacles to gene therapy remain. For example,
evident from 2017 to 2018, with investments CRISPR-Cas9 gene editing can perform only a
expanding to other cells (such as gamma delta limited range of edits on a limited set of genomic
T cells and macrophages) once NK cells achieved targets because of its limited specificity, activity,
clinical success. and deliverability. And safety concerns persist
about its potential to inflict permanent DNA damage,
— Precision control of cell therapy. VC investors mutagenic effects, or cell death.
are betting that companies harnessing synthetic
biology and complex logic to control cell Biotech companies have increasingly focused
therapies precisely may improve their safety on next-generation strategies, including the
profiles. For example, CAR T cells can kill following, to overcome the challenges of existing
cells they contact, including ones that aren’t gene therapies:
cancerous. Engineered networks of genes,
called “synthetic gene circuits,” can inhibit the — RNA-based modalities and editing. Several
killing of healthy cells, producing better safety start-ups are developing new RNA-editing tools
outcomes. From 2017 to 2018, we saw seed and (such as adenosine deaminase acting on RNA
series A funding for five companies, all of which [ADAR] and CRISPR-Cas13) to make transient
succeeded in completing series B or C rounds edits and avoid harmful double-stranded
from 2019 to 2021. breaks. Another approach is to modulate protein
expression with new classes of RNAs (such
— In vivo cell therapy. The field of in vivo cell as transfer and small activating RNAs). Most
therapy saw almost no dealmaking activity investments in novel RNAs began in 2019, but
between 2017 and 2018. But by 2021, several the success of messenger-RNA-based COVID-
biotech companies were working on ways for 19 vaccines has propelled the entire field.
patients to produce CAR T cells in their bodies
rather than relying on ex vivo manipulation — Novel nucleases. Enabled by AI and enzyme
of extracted cells in distant manufacturing discovery, several biotech start-ups are
facilities. Delivering genetic material and exploring novel Cas nucleases or enzymes (such
instructions directly to a patient’s T cells as Cas12 and CasX), which promise improved
could reduce the logistic and manufacturing efficiency and targeting specificity in CRISPR
complexities that have constrained the uptake gene editing. Investor excitement has grown
of CAR T cell treatments. exponentially; the average VC funding for
nuclease platform companies grew fivefold, from
Next-generation gene therapies an average of $10 million to $50 million, from the
Gene therapies have transformed patient treatment, 2017–18 to 2019–21 data sets.
offering, in some cases, excellent outcomes

6 What are the biotech investment themes that will shape the industry?
Biotech companies have increasingly
focused on next-generation strategies
to overcome the challenges of existing
gene therapies.

— Non-nuclease editing and modulation. The validated disease targets, there remain patient
range of edits possible with conventional subgroups that don’t respond to treatment,
CRISPR-Cas9 gene editing is limited. However, necessitating further identification of unique
novel editing technologies (such as base and disease subpopulations. Finally, translating complex
prime editors, transposases, and epigenetic genetic data into actionable clinical-care decisions
modulators) have the potential to overcome this remains challenging.
challenge with precise epigenetic modulation or
more efficient knockouts and insertions of one To advance precision medicine, numerous emerging
to more than a thousand base-pair sequences. biotech companies are focusing on cutting-edge
While deals from 2017 to 2018 primarily focused technologies, including the following:
on base and epigenetic editing , the wave of
start-ups funded from 2019 to 2021 focused — Early disease detection. While existing
on search-and-replace prime editing and diagnostics search for a few known mutations,
transposases, which use an enzyme to catalyze advanced multiomic tools can scan millions of
the movement of certain types of genes. circulating biomarkers (including metabolites
and epigenetic markers) to detect early signs of
Precision medicine disease. Investors continue to double down on
Precision medicine—an approach to maximizing such tools, with significant follow-up funding and
therapeutics’ effectiveness that uses diagnostics series A investment in companies in this space.
and analytics to consider individual variability in
genes, environment, and lifestyle—has already — Biomarker discovery. Platform technologies
produced breakthroughs, including treatments that can sort through large integrated multiomic
specific to certain gene mutations. Advances in data sets (including those on genomics,
the ability to process enormous amounts of data proteomics, metabolomics, and so forth) could
combined with AI have allowed the field to explode. help companies identify novel biomarkers and
genetic targets for patient subpopulations and
However, there are limits to the broader use of predict patient responses. Most companies
precision medicine to diagnose and treat patients. funded in series A from 2017 to 2018 received
First-generation precision diagnostics can only follow-up series B or C investment and continue
detect known biomarkers and mutations. While to develop their biomarker discovery platforms.
early precision medicines have affected well-

What are the biotech investment themes that will shape the industry? 7
— Precision population health. Several biotech — Rational drug design. Start-ups are working to
companies are focused on using insights make their ML models more generalizable so
from complex genomic data to guide disease that they can apply one predictive model across
prevention and treatment decisions. These multiple similar targets. Approaches include
companies simplify and rapidly analyze robotic platforms that learn from experiments
sequencing data that focus on genomic and generative algorithms that can design
variations, offering interpretative services for custom molecules from scratch. Biotech
nonspecialized clinicians. Compared with other companies advancing such technology are
precision-medicine subsegments, this field has just beginning to form, with almost half at the
the highest proportion of late-stage funding, series A stage.
with 80 percent of such companies in series C.
— Lead validation and optimization. Algorithms
Machine learning–enabled drug discovery can scan libraries of billions of molecules across
Advances in ML promise to accelerate drug numerous disease targets to choose those most
discovery and development through computer- suited to clinical development. To address the
modeled simulations that predict molecular lack of high-quality training and experimental
behavior. Rapid advances in this field have enabled data, ML can generate a list of interactions
more effective drug design and optimization. between proteins and the molecules that bind
For example, a breakthrough in protein structure with them and cross-reference that list to
prediction by the open-source AI system select leading candidates. Biotech companies
AlphaFold regularly achieves accuracy developing such technology are relatively small,
competitive with experimentation.6 with the median deal size a little more than
half that of all ML biotech companies (around
However, the translatability of ML models is limited. $17 million versus $32 million).
Challenges include an insufficient number of high-
quality data sets, a lack of generalizability, and Strategies for validated but undruggable targets
uninterpretable algorithms. This situation creates Conventional drug modalities (such as small
opportunities for novel ML approaches that use molecules and monoclonal antibodies) target
sophisticated algorithms and integrated data sets proteins to address disease. However, research
to increase the efficiency and accuracy of the drug suggests that at least 85 percent of disease-
discovery process. associated proteins in the human body are
undruggable—conventional modalities can’t produce
Innovative start-ups have developed novel methods a therapeutic effect, because they have no binding
in three areas: site. In recent years, the biopharma industry has
made progress on this front, and successes in the lab
— Target identification. ML is increasingly used have renewed investors’ interest in delivering drugs
for phenotypic screening and understanding to hard-to-target proteins and hard-to-treat diseases.
disease. Advanced genetic-profiling platforms
can identify new genetic variants or use ML However, beyond identifying binding pockets in
to scan the entire genome for hot spots and the disease-relevant proteins, problems remain.
potential targets. Companies continue to They include resistance to small-molecule drugs
expand the repertoire of identified disease- in proteins with known binding pockets, limited
relevant targets, including proteins, RNA- disease-modifying effects in targets whose protein
splicing sites, and biomolecular condensates. functions aren’t easily altered, lack of validated
This space received roughly 70 percent of series targets, and limited understanding of disease biology.
B and C funding, signaling its relative maturity
and competitiveness.

6
AlphaFold Protein Structure Database, DeepMind Technologies and EMBL-EBI, accessed May 23, 2022.

8 What are the biotech investment themes that will shape the industry?
Biotech start-ups are developing novel platforms to their full potential. For example, the ability of
address undruggable targets and diseases. Three adenoassociated viruses to deliver large cargo
promising approaches are as follows: (such as CRISPR nucleases) in vivo is limited.
Additionally, currently validated vehicles can access
— New small-molecule binding sites. Many only a limited set of tissues. Intravenous lipid
VC-funded companies are focused on advanced nanoparticles, for example, primarily target the liver.
techniques in interactions between proteins Some delivery methods can also trigger the immune
and small molecules and on computational system, leading to adverse events and blocking the
methods to identify previously unknown binding efficacy of the therapy.
sites on proteins that small molecules can
target. The past three years have seen Most drug delivery start-ups are using one of three
increased investment in this approach, which main types of cutting-edge bioengineering:
constitutes more than 50 percent of all funding
in this category. — Improved capsids. Biotech companies are
using rational design and directed evolution
— Protein degradation. An emerging modality in powered by ML to improve knowledge of
disease-causing proteins is protein degradation, existing adenoassociated virus vectors and
which circumvents the need to identify elusive discover new vector capsids (or protective
small-molecule binding sites. The major class is protein shells). While novel-vector companies
proteolysis-targeting chimera (PROTAC), which won the majority of drug delivery funding from
promotes selective protein degradation. 2017 to 2018, the share of deals in the space has
declined since 2019.
— Novel disease targets. Several biotech
companies are advancing the knowledge — Biological vehicles. To improve safety, biotech
of disease biology by developing innovative companies are engineering delivery methods
platforms to identify new targets in hard-to- using the body’s natural signaling system (such
drug illnesses. One approach involves sampling as by using exosomes—extracellular bubbles of
populations that are naturally resistant to those liquid or cytoplasm enclosed by a double layer of
diseases, using advanced analytics to identify lipids—which have the potential to reach almost
protective antibodies, and developing those all tissues). This technology is still young, as
antibodies as therapeutics. shown by the limited number of investing deals
for it from 2017 to 2018. Most deals from 2019 to
New delivery methods 2021 were seed and series A rounds.
Drug delivery has seen significant advances as
more therapies rely on robust vehicles to target — Enhanced nanoparticles. Nanoparticle
disease-specific cells. The lipid nanoparticles used enhancements (such as lipid composition
in messenger-RNA-based COVID-19 vaccines are optimization) can expand the range of tissues
among the most promising of such vehicles. This that a drug can reach. Nanoparticle companies
market is growing exponentially—more than 400 have had relatively small funding rounds of
RNA-based therapies in the development pipeline around $25 million each, around half of the
will require targeted delivery mechanisms. $45 million average deal size in the drug
delivery sector.
Delivery is one of the biggest challenges for novel
drug modalities, and significant scientific and
technical advances will be necessary to realize

What are the biotech investment themes that will shape the industry? 9
Achieving long-term benefit from companies struggle to recruit patients for trials.
biotech platform technologies Companies can benefit from enhancing their
Our analysis highlights increasing investment in understanding of disease biology and innovate
several platform technologies that could have a to design unique products that can target
significant long-term impact on drug development. underaddressed diseases.
The convergence of AI and ML technologies with a
greater understanding of biology could make drug — Demonstrating value for cost-constrained
discovery faster and more efficient. However, to healthcare systems. The pharma industry has
benefit from the innovations that VC companies are transitioned toward a model that produces
funding, the biotech industry has several existential innovative drugs at premium prices to treat small
risks to address, including: subsets of patients. For example, while the top
ten blockbuster drugs in 2010 treated more
— Differentiating incremental innovations. than 40 million patients, the top ten in 2020
Given continuous innovation, many start-ups treated 12 million. The prevailing model will no
are improving incrementally on competitor longer be sustainable if the top ten drugs in
technologies. CasX, for example, is smaller than 2030 treat even fewer patients. Companies may
Cas9 for easier delivery and is believed to be less need to pursue a different model, pushing the
likely to trigger an immune response. To compete boundaries of emerging platforms to address
successfully, pioneers will need to generate larger populations. To create products that can
evidence that will differentiate them and show help more patients at lower costs, manufacturing
the value of their products. They can also processes may need to evolve, and R&D may
advocate for a regulatory framework that can need to become more efficient.
assess new technologies even when head-to-
head comparisons in clinical trials aren’t feasible.

— Addressing more intractable diseases. Because With substantial VC investment fueling innovative
of the risks inherent in innovation, many biotech therapies that address unmet needs, the biotech
companies validate their technologies in industry is poised to make lasting changes that
conditions with well-understood mechanisms can overcome the challenges it faces. In the future,
(such as sickle cell disease). However, if many biopharma may be able not only to treat but also to
companies with new platform technologies cure more common diseases and prevent others,
pursue this strategy, new therapies may outstrip touching much larger patient populations at lower
need in diseases with limited patient populations. costs. Technological innovations, coupled with
For example, with more than 30 products in ecosystem solutions, could enable cheaper, safer,
development to treat the approximately 20,000 and more efficacious therapies.
children around the world who are diagnosed
with Duchenne muscular dystrophy every year,7

7
“What is...Duchenne muscular dystrophy: A guide for patients and families,” Muscular Dystrophy Association, February 2019.

Find more content like this on the


McKinsey Insights App

Olivier Leclerc is a senior partner in McKinsey’s Southern California office; Michelle Suhendra is a senior capabilities and
insights analyst in the Waltham, Massachusetts, office; and Lydia The is a partner in the Bay Area office.

The authors wish to thank Emily Capra, Savitri Fouda, Alex Godfrey, Sarah Heath, Serene Hu, Bruce Jia, Brahma Kumar,
Xiruo Li, Leonne Philippen, Ethan Reich, Uday Tripathi, and Tanya Xi for their contributions to this article.

Designed by McKinsey Global Publishing


Scan • Download • Personalize Copyright © 2022 McKinsey & Company. All rights reserved.

10 What are the biotech investment themes that will shape the industry?

You might also like