Professional Documents
Culture Documents
www.bitbookwala.in
BIT BOOK WALA
www.bitbookwala.in
International Marketing
Text and Cases
www.bitbookwala.in
About the Authors
Prof. Justin Paul is with Nagoya University of commerce and business, Japan. He
has been a visiting professor, speaker, trainer and consultant to many institutes and
companies in the Asia-Pacific region. He has been serving as a Ph D examiner, director
on the board of studies of institutes and reviewer of reputed journals. He has served
as Department Chairperson at IIM Indore and as Associate Professor at IIFT,
New Delhi.
A consistent rank holder, he holds two masters degrees, two PG diplomas and a
doctorate from IIT Bombay. He has also received national awards for research papers
and case studies. He has hands-on experience of working with two commercial banks and has been recognised
Mr. Ramneek Kapoor is a well-known management trainer and author in the areas of
sales, marketing and soft skills. He has had a varied and rich experience with many
national and multinational companies in the area of sales and marketing management
for 28 years. He has conducted workshops in leading organisations including B.S.N.L,
Life Insurance Corporation of India, Piramal Healthcare, Caparo Group and many
others. Currently he is the Principal of Omegan School of Business, Indore.
Mr. Kapoor has been associated with Indian Institute of Management, Indore for
their management development programme on export-import management and international marketing for three
years. Besides, he is also actively involved with many other management institutes of India as a visiting and
adjunct faculty. He has presented many papers related to sales and marketing in various national and
international seminars. He is the author of Fundamentals of Sales Management, published by Macmillan India
Limited.
www.bitbookwala.in
International Marketing
Text and Cases
Justin Paul
Nagoya University of Commerce and Business, Japan
and
Indian Institute of Foreign Trade, New Delhi
Ramneek Kapoor
BIT BOOK WALA
Omegan School of Business, Indore
McGraw-Hill Offices
New Delhi New York St Louis San Francisco Auckland Bogotá Caracas
Kuala Lumpur Lisbon London Madrid Mexico City Milan Montreal
San Juan Santiago Singapore Sydney Tokyo Toronto
www.bitbookwala.in
Published by the Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited,
7 West Patel Nagar, New Delhi 110 008.
ISBN-13: 978-0-07-063588-3
ISBN-10: 0-07-063588-9
Information contained in this work has been obtained by Tata McGraw-Hill, from sources believed to be reliable.
However, neither Tata McGraw-Hill nor its authors guarantee the accuracy or completeness of any information
published herein, and neither Tata McGraw-Hill nor its authors shall be responsible for any errors, omissions, or
damages arising out of use of this information. This work is published with the understanding that Tata McGraw-Hill
and its authors are supplying information but are not attempting to render engineering or other professional services. If
such services are required, the assistance of an appropriate professional should be sought.
Typeset at Tej Composers, WZ-391, Madipur, New Delhi 110063, and printed at Avon Printers, 271, FIE, Patparganj
Delhi 110 092.
Cover Design: K Anoop
Cover printed at: SDR Printers
RQLQCDLYRQDCQ
www.bitbookwala.in
Preface
International Marketing became an important area of specialisation in the 1990s. With the kind of
interest this subject was attracting, a well written textbook, comprehensively covering all the aspects
of international marketing was required. We have tried to fulfill this requirement through
International Marketing: Text and Cases. This book is unique in terms of pedagogical features,
templates that integrate topics such as business environmental factors into marketing functions in the
global context.
Although this text undoubtedly has more case studies and examples from India, Sri Lanka, Middle
East, Japan, efforts have been made to give equal treatment to all regions and countries, so that it
proves to be useful to everyone across all borders.
BIT BOOK WALA
This book is distinguished by the unique approach that it takes while dealing with the subject.
While the usual approach is to treat international marketing as a series of loosely related topics, in this
book the topics revolve around international marketing functions, channels and practices. We have
included boxed exhibits and figures across the chapters. The case studies are written from real life
perspectives. These have been included at the end of important chapters as well as at the end of the
book.
There is also a companion website of this book which has instructor resources containing
powerpoint slides.
With the process of globalisation gathering momentum, understanding the world and international
marketing has become an imperative for survival and success for all the companies in all nations.
The case studies included in this book are written not to indicate effective or ineffective handling
of situation by the management, but for academic use in classrooms. The responsibility for any errors
is ultimately ours.
We express our deep gratitude to the McGraw-Hill team—Mr Biju Kumar, Mr Tapas Maji, Ms
Anubha Srivastava, Ms Medha Arora and Ms N K Deepa for their help in completing this book.
Please send your comments and suggestions at justinpaul@hotmail.com, mail@drjustinpaul.com
and ramnik123kapoor@rediffmail.com.
www.bitbookwala.in
vi Preface
Acknowledgements
I would like to thank my parents Mr P V Poulose and Mrs Annie Poulose, wife Dr. Festi and brother
Santosh for their constant support. My humble gratitude to Dr S P Parashar (Director, Indian
Institute of Management, Indore), Prof. Praful Agnihotri (Indian Institute of Management, Calcutta),
Prof. Omprakash Gupta (Prieri View A&M University, USA), Prof. Jatin Pancholi (Middlesex
University), Mr Yatinder Agrohoi, Mr Sudarshana Reddy and Mr Pradeep T K (Indian Institute of
Management, Indore) for their help.
JUSTIN PAUL
I am grateful to my parents for all their blessings from the heavens above. I would like to thank my
wife, Alka, daughter Neha and son Ankit who have always been very supportive in all my
endeavours. I am also grateful to Mr Rummy Chhabra, Mr Surinder Khullar, and Mr Jal B Khodaiji
for their support and encouragement from time to time.
RAMNEEK KAPOOR
www.bitbookwala.in
Contents
Preface v
www.bitbookwala.in
viii Contents
www.bitbookwala.in
Contents ix
www.bitbookwala.in
x Contents
References 118
Websites Visited 119
Suggested Further Readings 119
Objective Type Questions 120
Review Questions 121
www.bitbookwala.in
Contents xi
Diversity 165
Degree of Certainty 165
Control Mechanism 166
Objective Type Questions 168
Review Questions 168
Case Study 169
10. Market Entry Modes—JV, M & A, Strategic Alliance and Subsidiaries 173
Section 1: Modes of Global Market Entry and Strategies 174
Section 2: Joint Ventures 174
How to Build Successful Joint Ventures? 175
Benefits and Limitations of International Joint Ventures 175
Legal Forms of Joint Ventures in the World 175
Section 3: International Joint Ventures in China 176
Section 3: Global Mergers and Acquisitions 182
Examples 182
Section 4: International Strategic Alliances 183
Section 5: Subsidiaries 186
References 187
www.bitbookwala.in
xii Contents
www.bitbookwala.in
Contents xiii
Section 4:
BIT BOOK WALA
International Competitive Environment 233
Grey Market 233
Mechanics of Grey Marketing 233
Section 5: Dumping 234
Section 6: The International Political and Legal Environment 237
Transfer Pricing 237
Cost-based Transfer Pricing Strategy 238
Market Based Transfer Pricing Strategy 238
Negotiated Transfer Pricing Strategy 238
Government Regulations and Transfer Pricing 239
Duty and Tariff Used for Protections 239
Joint Ventures and Transfer Pricing 240
Section: 7 The International Economic and Financial Environment 240
Volatility of Exchange Rates 240
Inflation and International Pricing Strategy 242
Counter Trade 242
Types of Counter Trade 243
References 244
Websites Visited 245
Suggested Further Readings 245
Objective Type Questions 246
Review Questions 248
www.bitbookwala.in
xiv Contents
www.bitbookwala.in
Contents xv
www.bitbookwala.in
xvi Contents
UAE 307
Kuwait 308
Sultanate of Oman 308
Yemen 309
Conclusion 309
References 309
Objective Type Questions 310
Review Questions 310
www.bitbookwala.in
Contents xvii
www.bitbookwala.in
Visual...
Learning Objectives
Every chapter begins with chapter
objectives which tell the reader
what he will find in the chapter and
what he will gain from it.
Case Studies
In order to help the reader in un-
derstanding the real world of
international marketing, the is-
sues to be understood and the
problems to be resolved therein,
Case Studies have been provided
liberally in the text. These cases
are live examples from the indus-
try or first-hand experiences by
authors.
www.bitbookwala.in
Walkthrough
Boxed Examples
Important practices and proce-
dures in international marketing
have been highlighted as boxed
items. These would help the stu-
dents understand the conceptual
and procedural issues of this
area.
References/Websites
Visited/Suggested Fur-
ther Readings
These tell the reader where mate-
rial has been taken from and, to
the interested reader, where he
should look for more indepth
knowledge into the subject.
www.bitbookwala.in
Walkthrough
Objective Type Questions
A set of questions given at the end
of the each chapter will be very use-
ful to the reader, especially when
examinations are approaching.
Companion Website
(Student Edition)
Students can test their knowledge
by clicking on answers on the
website. Their score will be
generated automatically. They can
even email the result sheet to the
instructor.
www.bitbookwala.in
Walkthrough
Objective Type Questions
A set of questions given at the end
of the book will be very useful to
the reader, especially when ex-
aminations are approaching.
Index
A detailed index at the end of the
book will help the reader in locat-
ing the entries in the right context
in an accurate manner.
www.bitbookwala.in
BIT BOOK WALA
www.bitbookwala.in
Chapter 1
Learning Objectives
The reader should be able to
• understand the concept of international marketing vis-à-vis domestic market-
ing
• identify, understand and explain the evolution process and stages of interna-
tional marketing growth of a firm
• explain the reasons for firms/manufacturers/service providers for taking to
international marketing
• identify the environmental and firm-specific motivating factors that propel the
international business decisions of a firm
• describe and explain a firm’s orientation and philosophy towards international
marketing
• identify, understand and explain the challenges that firms face during the
growth of their international marketing activities.
www.bitbookwala.in
2 International Marketing–Text and Cases
U ntil a few years ago, the international market had been an avenue to absorb the spillover from extra
production. The entrepreneur used to look at exports only if he could spare part of his production after
meeting the national domestic demand. The economic environment had witnessed an overpriced,
overprotected and cartel-pampered industry, which did not find it attractive to pursue lower opportunities
abroad. However, with the economy opening up its doors to international manufacturers and marketers the
scenario changed radically. The liberalised economy also provided consumers internationally acclaimed
brands at competitive prices. Such competition from abroad, on his home turf virtually awoke the entrepreneur
from his ensconced slumber to fight back global competition on an equal footing by raising its own standards
to internationally accepted levels. Today, international markets offer unlimited opportunities to companies like
Infosys, Wipro, Videocon, Ranbaxy, Dr. Reddy’s Labs, Asian Paints and many others. As a result, these firms
now look at international markets to gain global competitiveness through technological advancement, superior
marketing strategies and continuous product and service innovations. This chapter will introduce the reader to
the concept, scope and process of international marketing. It will analyse why a firm takes to international
marketing and the various challenges and evolutionary stages it has to pass through before it can be called a
truly global organisation. The chapter will also provide an understanding of the firms’ orientation towards
international marketing.
SECTION 1:
INTRODUCTION
There are 192 countries in the world, each offering an independent yet interdependent market to manufacturers,
www.bitbookwala.in
Concept and Process of International Marketing 3
companies like Ranbaxy led the industry in setting up their plants abroad. Tyre majors like Apollo and CEAT
used to operate primarily as domestic companies till they set up plants in Sri Lanka and South Africa. Today,
many Indian manufacturers are adopting the strategy of offering counter competition to multinationals in either
their own countries or in countries on which they heavily depend for marketing their products. The following,
Table 1.1 demonstrates the growth of world exports for the past 50 years.
SECTION 2:
INTERNATIONAL MARKETING—A DEFINITION
International marketing is a miniscule part of world trade, as it may not contain all the flow of different nations.
Similarly, international marketing activities like outsourcing to own subsidiaries in different countries for job
work may not form part of the international trade statistics. International marketing, in fact, may be defined as
“the process of focusing firm’s resources on international marketing opportunities whether while competing
within the domestic market against other international companies or even when the firm goes beyond national
frontiers to market goods and services”. It is on this account that Hess and Cateora have defined international
marketing as “the performance of business activities that direct the flow of goods and services to consumers
and users in more than one nation.” Thus, it offers an opportunity to a firm to prepare itself to meet the
challenges of catering to different needs, wants, behavioral patterns and perceptions of consumers and users
in various countries, only when it markets the products under its own brand umbrella. In case bulk exports are
reprocessed and repackaged by another firm situated abroad, it may not be called International Marketing.
www.bitbookwala.in
4 International Marketing–Text and Cases
Some of the bulk exports from India, such as tobacco, tea, spices, processed leather and cut and polished
diamonds, etc., may not be covered under international marketing as these are reprocessed and repackaged
abroad. However, these converted products will form a part of international marketing for the firms situated
abroad that undertake the reprocessing and export.
The American Marketing Association defines international marketing as “the multinational process of
planning and executing the conception, pricing, promotion and distribution of ideas, goods and services to
create exchanges that satisfy individual and organisational objectives”, thereby bringing within its ambit
markets situated across the world. As a result, an international firm not only has to satisfy its corporate
objectives but it has also to bring about customer satisfaction through coordinated efforts spanning different
countries.
Another definition of international marketing states that it is “the process that allocates company resources
without regard to national frontiers.” According to yet another definition, “international marketing is simply an
attitude of mind, the approach of a company with a truly global outlook, seeking its profits impartially around
the world, home market included, on a planned and systematic basis” (ibid p.4).
Thus, when a firm decides to go international, it has to take into account the attitudinal changes that may be
required to move out of the comfort zone offered by the known and tried domestic markets. International giants
www.bitbookwala.in
Concept and Process of International Marketing 5
like General Motors, Mitsubishi, Microsoft, Exxon, Unilever, Mitsui, Sony and Panasonic must have also faced
such obstacles when they decided to go international and achieve global dominance in their respective
industries. Today, these companies are registering not only growth in their sizes and output but they are also
earning profits several times the size of the GDP of many small developing nations.
SECTION 3:
A COMPARISON OF DOMESTIC MARKETING WITH
INTERNATIONAL MARKETING
Some of the comparative advantages and disadvantages of both marketing systems remain similar. The firms
undertaking international or domestic marketing follow the same basic principles of marketing, i.e. they adhere
to the rules for selecting products that are designed on the basis of customers’ needs, fix the price band
according to the segment they want to cater to, look for logistics and distribution channels necessary to reach
the end consumer in cost effective ways and, finally, in order to generate necessary demand, these companies
also undertake country-specific promotional efforts for international marketing. Yet, at times, international
marketing poses problems to the firms at their different levels of operational efficiency. Such hurdles make
international marketing more challenging than domestic marketing.
Cultural Environment
The cultural environment poses yet another challenge to marketers at the international level. Differences in the
customs and traditions followed by different communities around the world can lead to situations where
communication with the consumers, users and customers can be misinterpreted. The variation in semiotics,
values, ideas, attitudes, beliefs, assumptions and traditions pose a challenge to the international marketing
manager. The manager must identify similarities and disparities in cultures and take steps for adaptations in
www.bitbookwala.in
6 International Marketing–Text and Cases
different countries. That will avoid waste of time and cost. Hence, firms select the right kind of personnel for
international postings and arrange for proper training for them to understand: (a) How to address the target
audience. (b) Which approach should be adopted for which country, i.e. hard sell or soft sell (e.g., in United
Kingdom, the soft sell is appreciated, whereas in Germany, the hard approach may be appropriate.) (c) What
should the marketer emphasise abroad, the price, the quality or will both be necessary at the same time, in
addition to any other factor? Many cultures are price sensitive, whereas some others may be status and quality
conscious. (d) How to react to unexpected circumstances. (e) How to transfer one experience to another in
order to add values to the brands abroad?
Competitive Environment
Taken in the right spirit, competition can spur an organisation to excellence. At the same time, however, it can
be dispiriting if the opponents indulge in tactics, for instance they may employ strategies to block channels of
distribution, devise prohibitive trading contracts, resort to negative advertising policies and either suddenly
raise prices or lower them. Such tactics can either force them to retreat or to become aggressive in their
approach. Pepsi and Coke have often indulged in similar fierce competitive fights, not only between themselves
but also against the local soft drink manufacturers of some countries.
SECTION 4:
STAGES OF INTERNATIONAL MARKETING—
AN EVOLUTIONARY PROCESS
BIT BOOK WALA
Depending on their internal circumstances, external influences, current focus strategies and future expansion
plans, companies may have different degrees of involvement and commitment to international trading and
marketing. It will be pertinent to note the stages that various companies pass through before they evolve into
international marketing organisations. A limited number of companies take off directly as international
marketing companies as a deliberate strategy. Even when they start as export-oriented units, they primarily
remain exporters only and seldom get into direct marketing activities abroad. They may outsource their
marketing activities to other firms abroad, to handle the marketing of their products and services. Such firms
take much longer time to become truly international marketing organisations.
Domestic Company
www.bitbookwala.in
Concept and Process of International Marketing 7
In the evolutionary process of international marketing, a firm may have to pass through the following
stages:
Birla Tyres has carved out a niche for itself in the international arena. About 30% of its
BIT BOOK WALA
total production is currently being exported to 43 countries across the globe.
The company registered an export growth of 18% during 2002-03, and its products are
well accepted in the domestic and export markets. The company exports 30% of its
production, against the industry average of 20%, to more than 43 countries, including
Bangladesh, Vietnam, Middle-East, Africa, Philippines, Afghanistan, South Africa and
North America, etc., by offering quality products. These are backed–up with aggressive
marketing policies, which are based on customers’ needs and requirements, and
converting them into a performance standard for the company.
Source: http://www.birlatyre.com/
www.bitbookwala.in
8 International Marketing–Text and Cases
2. Warren J. Keegan, Global Marketing Management, Seventh Edition, Pearson Education Singapore Pvt. Ltd. New
Delhi, 2002.
www.bitbookwala.in
Concept and Process of International Marketing 9
The true distinction between a global or local outlook can be derived from the philosophy or approach
adopted by each company, for which it will be appropriate to analyse the orientation and attitude adopted.
SECTION 5:
INTERNATIONAL MARKETING ORIENTATION
The management’s thinking, philosophy and guiding principles towards the internationalisation of the
company’s operations will decide the level of involvement of the firm’s resources, including its marketing
activities and talents. On the basis of the EPRG framework, i.e. Ethnocentric, Polycentric, Regiocentric and
Geocentric, Wind Douglas and Perlmutter have analysed a company’s approach towards such global
opportunities.3
Ethnocentric Approach
Metro Tyres, Hero Cycles and Atlas Cycles develop their products on the basis of the requirements of local
customers. Their research and development lays emphasis on developing high quality products to cater to the
discerning domestic customer but, at the same time, these firms look towards the export markets only as an add-
on and an extension of the local market. In their management philosophy, domestic technology, strategies and
even personnel are far more superior to foreign operations and are a perfect fit for foreign operations as well.
Such firms are highly domestic centralised and look at the exports marketing division as an add-on to their
domestic turnover. Such companies use many practices to push their products to other countries either directly
or indirectly.
Polycentric Approach
BIT BOOK WALA
The marketer here believes that each market is unique and needs to be addressed individually and differently.
The plans are devised to operate through individually established businesses, i.e. either by wholly-owned
subsidiaries or through marketing subsidiaries, separately in each country, allowing complete autonomy to
units to operate as separate profit centers independent of head office. Such firms conduct their own business
research, plan their own product adaptation, price positioning and promotional strategy to suit local needs.
Ford Motors, Toyota, Suzuki and General Motors, all develop locally adapted models of their automobiles to
suit each country’s consumer-specific needs. Under the polycentric approach, however, a firm may not be able
to take advantage of the economies of scale. Research also may not lead to any kind of international customers,
resulting in higher end cost to consumers.
Regiocentric Approach
The marketing firms here segment the markets on the basis of regional similarities, for example economic,
political, cultural and even geographic similarities, in order to cater to a large size of potential consumers. Just
as India, Bangladesh and Pakistan, along with other smaller nations like Bhutan and Nepal, etc., could form one
group, China and Japan could be the other group. Europe forms a different rigeocenter for many companies.
Both, Pepsi and Coke cater to such segments as single markets and accordingly, while devising their product
and promotion policies, national boundaries hold no meaning. The approach is to ensure that the regional
3. Howard Perlmutter, The Tortuous Evolution of the Multinational Corporation”, Columbia Journal of World
Business, January –February, 1969.
www.bitbookwala.in
10 International Marketing–Text and Cases
office coordinates all local marketing activities to achieve its objectives through independent local units.
Goodyear International, the tyre major, too operates on regiocentric basis, where its regional offices handle and
coordinate some of the activities of Asian-Pacific countries. Europe forms another region, while the other parts
of the world are divided into Latin America, Middle-East and Africa. North America also serves as a separate
region.
Geocentric Approach
The entire world is perceived as a single market and, in their quest to become world leaders, manufacturers offer
homogenous, identifiable and often interchangeable services and products in order to integrate them for
worldwide operational efficiency. Such manufacturers often extend the benefits of similar but low cost products
and services worldwide. Companies in the insurance sector, banking sector and food chains, such as
McDonald’s, Pizza Hut and Cookie Man, offer similar ambience worldwide in their offices and establishments.
Cookie Man, McDonald’s and Pizza Hut even go to the extent of offering similar taste to customers even as they
use local produce and manpower to prepare their burgers, pizzas and coffees.
www.bitbookwala.in
Concept and Process of International Marketing 11
SECTION 6:
MOTIVATING FACTORS OF INTERNATIONAL MARKETING
With the shortening of distances in global economy due to development of means of communication and
travel, interdependence amongst nations on each other has increased many folds. In the international
marketing scenario, today, no country can afford to remain aloof or exclusive. Cable television has enlightened
consumers about the difference in the standards of living amongst the haves and the have-nots, amongst the
developed, the developing and the yet-to-develop economies. Such awareness offers tremendous scope for
companies to go international to find shelf space in all kinds of economies and to improve their realisations. If
Bajaj Auto wants to go out and sell its motorcycles to the French, it may not mean merely dumping its surplus
production. When competition starts to have an impact of its profits in the domestic market, it may mean getting
better product prices from the export market. Similarly, if Hero Cycles wants to set up a manufacturing hub in
China, it will mean facing competition from the Chinese manufacturers on their own home turf, under conditions
that will be familiar for Chinese manufacturers and not to Hero Cycles. The motives for taking fast strides in the
international market may vary from economic to attaining competitive edge. Some of these are mentioned
below:
(i) Competitive edge
(ii) Worldwide integration of economies
(iii) Technology edge and Infrastructural development (e.g. telecom, transportation)
(iv) Growth in Purchasing Power
(v) Emergence of demanding consumers
Firm specific factors: BIT BOOK WALA
(i) Capacity utilisation and economic advantages
(ii) Product life cycle extension
(iii) Experience transfers and benchmarking
* Bridgestone is a Japanese multinational. They established production unit in places like Indore in India.
www.bitbookwala.in
12 International Marketing–Text and Cases
manufacturers access markets without tariff or quantity barriers and, moreover, the transition of the old
economic order of closely held economies of China and other communist countries to the market economy has
given access to multinationals like Unilever, P&G and others. Unified Germany has become one market, which,
eventually, led to a common European market. North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) and South
Cone Common Market (MERCOSUR) are other examples of such alliances. ASEAN and SAARC may not yet
have become close-knit like Europe but the day is not far when these associations will also offer common
customs and other formalities to international trade. Given the fact that each sovereign country today is
receptive to trans border trade by privately-held companies, subsidiaries established abroad will not only soon
have access to common markets but to other parts of the world as well.
3. Technological Edge Technology advancement and breakthrough brings about upgradation of
standards of living. Technology has standardised manufacturing processes, resulting in large-scale
productions offering economies of scale. The manufacturers can today afford to be competitive in any part of
the world. The motorcycles produced by Honda Unicorn in India can compete with other motorcycles across
the world. China has gone further and, in fact, its production levels offer it the highest scale of economies.
Similarly, transportation and telecom have brought the countries of the world even closer. The multi-modal
transportation giants have taken away all the problems of exporting and offer their services virtually at the
doorsteps of international marketing firms. The establishment of dry ports in many parts of different counties,
where the containers move from the exporter’s town itself, adds to the convenience. It has brought down the
cost of transportation considerably.
The establishment of telecommunication networks, mobile telephones, the Internet and web cams have all
contributed to faster and safer international business. Electronic signatures on the Internet have eliminated
BIT BOOK WALA
many unnecessary paper-processing delays, encouraging the international marketing firms to establish their
connections worldwide. The denizens of seven seas of the world today have become one globalised village’s
residents, each within reach of a flick of a finger.
www.bitbookwala.in
Concept and Process of International Marketing 13
www.bitbookwala.in
14 International Marketing–Text and Cases
4. Purchasing Power: The purchasing power of large Asian nations like China, India and Japan has
grown manifold. The middle class of India offers the largest market of haves to the marketers of the world.
China’s foray into privatisation and allowing private FDIs has led to open foreign trade with China. At the same
time, aggressive export and international trading bring home the much-needed dollars, which are then
ploughed back into product and infrastructure development
Indian economy saw the emergence of local multinationals, which attained multibillion dollar turnovers
through outsourcing of business processing and which then offered huge wealth to local manufacturers. The
emergence of auto component manufacturers, call centers, software development organisations and health and
medical development centers all are examples of an economic upsurge. Infosys, Wipro, Convergys and Persistent are
only a few names of the firms that have helped the Indian economic upsurge through their dollar earnings.
Emergence of Demanding Consumers The global media has brought world-class products into
people’s living rooms and bedrooms. Today, young people in all corners of the world listen to the same music.
They watch IFFA awards at the same time as they watch MTV awards. The consumer is exposed to all
international brands, such as Nike, Levi’s, LG mobile phones, Motorola phones and many other such products,
which are now available simultaneously in many countries of the world. This consumer education has brought
in a natural demand for common and most sought after brands, virtually motivating marketing firms to start their
own distribution worldwide. Shopping malls, retail chains and franchises are all falling over each other to cater
to this discerning, knowledgeable and willing-to-spend consumer. Pizza Hut, McDonalds, Cookie Mans,
Barista, L.L. Beans and many other international chain food stores all find a consumer whose taste buds are
demanding international delicacies.
2. Product Life Cycle (PLC) Extension This can only be a short-term strategy. Many times,
products on the verge of declining trends on the PLC may get a new lease of life by opening up of new markets
internationally. Sometimes even at the introductory and growth stages of PLC a company may like to recover
the high cost of product development by offering the same to international markets, till others catch up with it.
The cold drinks and beverages industry of United States got a new lease of life in the early 80s, when both Pepsi
and Coke moved into many Asian countries. Similarly, cigarette manufacturers were able to revive their
fortunes when they ventured into China and Eastern Europe, after their economies opened up.
www.bitbookwala.in
Concept and Process of International Marketing 15
BUSINESS PROFILE
Domestic International
Consumer Consumer
Oil & Gas Oil & Gas
Electronics Electronics
Full spectrum
Gas Distribution Mexico
Multi-brand, OEM
Exploration in
NELP (new) Poland
they may not open up all international fronts in one go but they may learn their lessons in one economy before
they move on to the next. The experiences earned are utilised in establishing new businesses at a low cost and
in lesser time. Some of the retail majors like Wal-Mart (US) and Metro A.G. (Germany), which are entering India
now, will stand to gain a lot with their experiences worldwide. International companies have information
systems that scan case studies of different companies across the world, which can then be used as benchmarks
while setting up new businesses.
COCA-COLA—EXPERIENCE TRANSFER
The year 1993 saw Coca Cola losing its market
share in the US beverage market, shrinking from
63.3 percent of soft drink sales in 1984 to 58.8
percent, entailing a net loss of US$ 2.4 billion
in potential retail sales. That is the time when
the company decided to take advantage of
balancing good potential markets (as against
the shrinking market of US) by spreading out to
different markets across the globe. Even though
the US soft drink market is the biggest in the
www.bitbookwala.in
16 International Marketing–Text and Cases
www.bitbookwala.in
Concept and Process of International Marketing 17
WEBSITES VISITED
1. http://www.imf.org/
2. http://www.wto.org/
3. http://www.birlatyre.com/
4. http://www.ranbaxy.com/
5. http://www.ge.com/en/
6. http://www.videoconworld.com/
7. http://www.mhhe.com/justinpaul
www.bitbookwala.in
18 International Marketing–Text and Cases
www.bitbookwala.in
Concept and Process of International Marketing 19
REVIEW QUESTIONS
1. Define the concept of international marketing. Discuss the challenges that firms face in
international marketing.
2. List out the evolutionary stages of a firm’s growth from domestic to global entities, with
special reference to any of the Indian firms.
BIT BOOK WALA
3. What is the EPRG model? Point out the difference between the polycentric and geocentric
approaches of a firm.
4. What are international business environment motivators? How does economic upsurge
help in globalisation? Explain with examples.
5. What are the firm-specific motivators for going international? Explain.
6. How does a product life cycle help in internationalisation? Point out various stages of
internationalisation while drawing the product life cycle.
7. Visit the web page of Wipro to understand business volume spread over the globe?
Explain the company’s orientation towards internationalisation with the help of the EPRG
model.
Case Study
www.bitbookwala.in
20 International Marketing–Text and Cases
industry across the entire region”. The opening up of the Indian economy and the subsequent
access to satellite television redefined not only the viewing experience for millions but also
brought in a vast opportunity for media moguls to generate unheard sums of profits from the
Indian market. The entertainment industry could now provide more people with greater choice than
ever before. STAR set new standards in content, production and variety. It is hard to dispute
STAR’s claim of ‘setting the pace of media in Asia’, as it broadcasts 40 services in seven languages
and reaches more than 300 million viewers in 53 countries. Over 173 million people watch STAR
every week. (Source: STAR website).
The successes of the STAR TV network has been achieved by making programmes in Indian
languages, such as Hindi, and by localising content as well as adapting local family culture and
values in its programme content.
In order to analyse the runaway success of the STAR network in India, it is important to
understand the national Indian television network, which, with the coming of new communication
technologies and opening up of global markets, had been subjected to massive changes since the
early 1990s. “As with many other sectors of the Indian economy, the gradual deregulation and
privatisation of television transformed the media landscape in a country which had one of the most
regulated broadcasting environments among the world’s democracies” (Price and Verhulst, 1998;
Page and Crawley, 2001). In the early 1990s, there was no television industry worth the name in
India, which, until 1991, had just one state-controlled channel, Doordarshan, which was little more
than a mouthpiece of the government of the day and offered boringly monotonous and
unpalatable programmes. The opening of the broadcasting skies brought in more than 300 digital
BIT BOOK WALA
channels. Some joint ventures with international broadcasters also joined the league.
This opening of the satellite network and exposure of Indian viewer called for new programme
content that could satisfy local cultural feelings in addition to his remaining in touch with ever
growing global entertainment forays. Thus, from news to game and chat shows, from soap operas
to ‘reality TV’ - which have been provided by a burgeoning television industry that was mainly
global, a kind of discontent had prevailed amongst mass viewers.
Indian television was spreading its wings in five continents during this time. In the United Arab
Emirates, the vast majority of the population consists of foreign workers from the Indian sub-
continent, making the oil-rich Gulf region a key target for television networks based in India. In
Britain, for example, Indian channels - Zee, Sony, STAR Plus, B4U (Bollywood for You), which are
available on Sky’s digital network - have dedicated viewerships. Indian television companies are
increasingly finding a niche within the lucrative US market, where the Indian diaspora comprises
one of the richest strata of society. Of the nearly two million people of Indian origin living in the US,
the investment firm Merrill Lynch estimates that there are 200,000 millionaires. They have an
average income of over $60,000, compared to the national average of about $39,000, making them
America’s wealthiest immigrants (Rajghatta 2003). India’s rapidly expanding economy and a pro-
market government, coupled with an established satellite network, made the Indian market an
extremely attractive proposition for transnational broadcasters (Pendakur and Kapur, 1997).
According to the trade press, in 2004 there were nearly 390 million television viewers in India, with
cable and satellite penetration reaching more than 48 million homes and growing annually at the
rate of 10 per cent (Satellite and Cable TV, April 2004).
www.bitbookwala.in
Concept and Process of International Marketing 21
As a global player, STAR TV suffered an initial setback when it failed to read Indian viewer as
hungry for copies of programmes based on American and western culture. Hence, it saw its
objectives of TRP remaining much below expectations.
However STAR’s market value and viewership rating in India grew rapidly and changed its
fortunes for the better ever since its flagship channel, STAR Plus launched Kaun Banega
Crorepati, an Indian version of the successful British game show Who Wants to be a Millionaire,
hosted by India’s best-known film star, Amitabh Bachchan. Along with it, STAR also launched a
number of Indian programmes that depicted the Indian family drama, soap operas like Saas Bhi
Kabhi Bahu Thi and Kahani Ghar Ghar Ki and Kumkum, etc.
Once the Hindi channels started doing well, channels catering to strictly English viewership
also picked up in total tariff rating.
In 2004, almost 10 years after its launch in India, STAR claimed to be broadcasting its
programmes to more than 31 million homes in India, with 90 percent Indian content, through a
product mix of all its channels.
Thus, while the STAR network started out with mainly American and western programmes, it
took the strategic decision to adapt, rationalise and finally localise its programming to suit the
variety of cultural and linguistic tastes of the diverse Indian market. As the following table, Table
1, shows, the STAR network-led channels, whether entertainment, sports or information, dominate
the cable and satellite market, by placing itself within the top three slots.
STAR’s adaptation to Indian culture and language, however, did not prevent it from maintaining
international digital quality of its technically superior broadcasting and relaying of programmes as
compared to some of the national and regional channel networks.
(Source: Adapted from: Taming the Dragon and the Elephant: Murdoch’s media in Asia, Daya
Thussu; http://www.wacc.org.uk/wacc/publications/media_development/2004. This is a substan-
tially modified version).
www.bitbookwala.in
22 International Marketing–Text and Cases
References
1. Price, Monroe and Stefaan Verhulst (Eds), (1998), Broadcasting Reform in India: A Case
Study in the Uses of Comparative Media Law, Oxford University Press; Page, David and
William Crawley (2001) Satellites Over South Asia: Broadcasting, Culture and the Public Inter-
est, Sage)
2. Rajghatta, Chidanand (2003) ‘Merrill estimates 200,000 NRI millionaires in US’ Times of
India, 14 May.
3. Pendakur, Manjunath and Jyotsna Kapur (1997) ‘Think Globally, program locally:
Privatization of Indian national television’, pp. 195-217, in Mashoed Bailie and Dwayne
Winseck (Eds), Democratizing Communication? Comparative Perspectives on Information
and Power, Hampton Press.
4. Satellite and Cable TV, April 2004.
Websites Visited:
1. http://www.wacc.org.uk/wacc/publications
2. http://www.startv.com.
www.bitbookwala.in
Chapter 2
Learning Objectives
The reader should be able to understand and explain
• the implications of WTO Agreements
• how the WTO facilitates the international marketing function.
www.bitbookwala.in
24 International MarketingText and Cases
W orld Trade Organisation was established on the basis of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade
(GATT). Seven rounds of negotiations occurred under the GATT before the eighth round, known as the
Uruguay Round, began in 1986. It concluded in 1995 with the establishment of the WTO. The GATT principles
and agreements were adopted by the WTO, which was responsible for administering and extending them.
Unlike the GATT, the WTO has a substantial institutional structure.
The Marrakesh Agreement, signed in Marrakech, Morocco, on April 15, 1994, established the World Trade
Organisation, which came into being upon its entry into force on January 1, 1995. The Marrakesh Agreement
developed out of GATT, which it includes, but it supplemented it with several other agreements on such issues
as trade in services, sanitary and plant health measures, trade-related aspects of intellectual property and
technical barriers to trade. It also established a new, more efficient and legally binding means of dispute
resolution.
WTO aims to increase international trade by eliminating trade barriers, both tariff and non-tariff, and by
providing a platform for the negotiation of trade and to their business. Currently, it boasts of a membership of
more than 150 countries.
WTO decisions, such as adopting agreements and their revisions, are officially determined by consensus.
The advantage of consensus decision-making is that it encourages efforts to find the most widely acceptable
decision. Apart from hosting negotiations on trade rules, one of the principal functions of the WTO is to act as
an arbiter of disputes between member countries through its Dispute Settlement Body. Unlike most other
international organisations, the WTO has significant powers to enforce its decisions through the authorisation
of trade sanctions against members who fail to comply with its decisions.
This chapter has been co-authored by Prof. Justin Paul, B. Arun Kumar, Deepak Balan, Sagar Sunil, Sandeep Kumar
Mishra, Sandeep S. and Syed Ashref.
www.bitbookwala.in
WTO and Implications on International Marketing 25
have become more deregulated, there has been a major change in the way in which and the speed with which
knowledge is disseminated. This has had profound impact on organisations, often in a way that national
governments find uncomfortable and that some social and political groups find threatening. Although there are
criticisms about the WTO, optimistic view about globalisation is about creating a new set of competencies that
enable a company to utilise resources on an optimal basis to meet differentiated customer demand cost-
competitively without regard for geography. It is about getting an organisation into a position of doing
business in any market it chooses.
1. Arun Goyal, WTO in the New Millennium, Academy of Business Studies, New Delhi, 2001
www.bitbookwala.in
26 International MarketingText and Cases
As a direct result of the development of affordable computing capacity, a whole new range of organisational
forms has emerged. A globally competitive firm is one that competes not on the basis of its products alone but
on the basis of its network and the value chain of which it is a part.
For example, a very high percentage of the final value of the modern ‘Boeing’ aircraft is outsourced. The
comparative advantage of Boeing, its value-add and, hence, its return on assets derive from its knowledge and
skills ranging from basic R&D through engineering design and logistic system management to complex final
assembly. The Seattle-based company, Boeing controls but does not undertake fabrication of components and
sub-assemblies. These products come from elsewhere. The ‘elsewhere’ is becoming global, and the new core
competency in managing sophisticated I.T. systems enables Boeing to control the whole of its supply chain.
SECTION 2:
THE MARKETING SCENARIO
World Trade Organisation offers marketers the opportunity of reaching a much wider range of consumers than
ever before. This makes some aspects of marketing easier and others more difficult. In an increasingly
integrated business environment, the emphasis moves from an individual to a collaborative marketing platform.
It has been observed that different corporate activities globalise at different rates, and the product
requirements and standards of nations change very slowly in comparison.
The concept of ‘global localisation’ now drives a company’s marketing worldwide. While the basics—core
technology, design, branding—are global, the final product specification, promotion, mix, customer support
are undertaken just as if the company is regional. Behaviours are converging, albeit at a slow rate. The influence
BIT BOOK WALA
of history and cultural differences remains significant. However, the impact of the information revolution is
such that there is convergence and it is beginning to accelerate. The percentage of localisation is expected to
slowly decline over time.
Working out the physical channels to market is not enough. Marketers now need to understand the
informational channels to market. This is because the theoretical ‘consumer sovereignty’ has become reality
with flooding of the imported items in the market.
Customer value can be derived from any element or combination of elements, not just on the final product
package. Marketing is about identifying where value-adding conversions can take place and how and why
Technologies/systems
Finance Logistics
Customer Sustained
Base
Delight Customer
Materials
Satisfaction
R&D Structure/culture
Learning
www.bitbookwala.in
WTO and Implications on International Marketing 27
customers develop and change their views about what constitutes value. This takes place against a
background of increasingly collaborative relationships rather than the traditional dealings.
WTO and globalisation cannot remove the aspects of the marketing mix that are set to remain internationally
heterogeneous. Therefore, as business becomes increasingly global, the question of managing the information
is becoming more critical in marketing. Asymmetry of information is often the critical factor that gives rise to
competitive advantage, at least over the short-term period.
The new market environment is characterised by significantly greater global mindset. All this gives rise to an
additional set of challenges that business leaders generally face but especially in the marketing function.
Managers need to abandon national allegiances and this can happen only when top company management
modifies its own views and installs a set of processes and structures that relate to the emerging reality of the
business and not to past practice. Globalisation extends choice on both the supply and demand sides of
business relationships. It not only opens up more markets to a company but it also opens its markets to more
competitors. This provides a more fluid marketing environment in which an organisation can ‘hedge’ its
markets and customers in order to maximise returns and minimise risk and uncertainty.
WTO agreements enable the minimisation of this risk and uncertainty through minimising interference by
non-economic factors. They aim to bring to the companies the required fluidity to be able to compete fairly.
Product
WTO rules have a bearing on both tangible and intangible products attributes. Regarding tangible attributes,
WTO rules deal with product specifications (norms and standards), labelling and products content (foreign
content and rules of origin). Decisions about intangible attributes may also be affected by WTO rules on
patents, copyrights, trademarks, designs and geographical indications.
Decisions about tangible attributes for industrial products are affected by rules spelled out in the
International Marketing Agreement on Technical Barriers to Trade (TBT). Rules relating to labelling are to be
found in TBT. The TBT Agreement introduces dispositions that were not included in the previous GATT code.
While GATT covered only standards and norms affecting only the product itself, the TBT Agreement covers
process and production methods that have an impact on product characteristics as well.
It is often required that imported products meet certain norms in order to protect the health and safety of the
population and for the protection of the environment. The TBT Agreement states that these compulsory norms
must not be applied in a way that results in unnecessary obstacles to trade, and that they must be based on
scientific evidence.
2. Jean Emile Denis (2003) Making International Marketing Decisions under WTO Rules, Thunderbird International
Business Review, Vol 45(2), March-April, Page 185-210.
www.bitbookwala.in
28 International Marketing–Text and Cases
Foreign Market
Selection & Analysis l GATT
l GATS
l TRIPS
Entry Mode l TRIMs
- Market Access Conditions Decisions
- Sectorial & Regional
Agreements
Formulation of International
Marketing Strategies
Segmentation
Targeting
Positioning
International Marketing
- Distribution Strategies
- Product Strategies
- Pricing Strategies
Fig. 2.2 The International Marketing Process of the Firm & the WTO System3
3. This diagram is a modified version of the figure sourced from Jean Emile Denis’s (Professor, University of Geneva,
HEC) Paper—Making International Marketing Decision under WTO Rules, Thunderbird International Business,
Review, March-April 2003, Vol 45(2), 185-210. Reprinted with permission from the author.
www.bitbookwala.in
WTO and Implications on International Marketing 29
Product specifications have traditionally been a major headache for traders and have often been used by
governments as a powerful tool to control import. The new WTO rules bring considerable clarity in this area.
They will facilitate trade and, as a result, promote international competition. Because of its reliance on
internationally accepted standards, it may lead to increased product standardisation in product design and
production processes.
There is no specific rule dealing with packaging or labelling, although the agreement on TBT makes it clear
that packaging, marking and labelling requirements should not constitute unnecessary barriers to trade.
Exporters are often requested to adjust to local practices. As a result, they may incur additional costs that may
deter them from exporting. Such practices are acceptable as long as they are not applied in a discriminatory
manner. The agreement on Rules of Origin may have a significant marketing impact on the possible country-of-
origin effects. They will provide a competitive advantage to products identified as originating from countries
with a well-established and positive national image. This may be a valuable asset to exporters not only of
branded consumer goods but also of nationally reputed manufactured goods.
The value of a product does not depend exclusively on its performance or physical characteristics. Much of
its value to the consumer resides in his or her perception of price, brand name and geographical origin. This has
been well demonstrated empirically in a large number of countries, particularly with regard to the impact of
branding on product value and to the effect that country of origin has on consumer preferences. Marketers are
well aware of these advantages and try to build up the value of their products through carefully crafted
branding strategies that involve costly communication campaigns. Opportunistic competitors appropriate or
plagiarise well established brand names or unduly claim geographical origins that do not belong to their
products, thereby granting themselves illegitimate marketing advantages. The Agreement on Trade-Related
BIT BOOK WALA
Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) provides traders with some degree of protection in these
respects.4
The Agreement requires WTO members to grant each other both national and the Most Favoured Nation
(MFN) treatment in intellectual property protection for trademarks patents and copyrights as well as for
‘geographical indications’.
Price
Pricing depends on numerous factors, which fall into four categories: costs, demand, competition and
regulations, including the WTO rules. WTO rules are targeted at practices that restrict pricing decisions in the
conduct of international transactions. Compared to other international marketing decision areas, there are a
rather large number of WTO rules that impinge upon pricing. They include the determination of the price of a
good when it is assessed by customs authorities, the determination of price in relation to dumping and
subsidies, and transfer pricing in multinational firms.
Before the WTO regime, GATT registered many complaints to the effect that customs applied arbitrarily and
unduly high customs values. Also, it was not possible to estimate in advance the duty that would be applied to
products. The Agreement on Customs Valuation (ACV), which was adopted during the Uruguay Round,
intends to address these problems and indicates how goods are to be valued by customs authorities. The
methods of valuation are based on the price of similar products, in reference to other sales prices or to
production costs or on the basis of a combination of both prices and production costs. Perhaps as importantly,
the agreement spells out which valuation practices are unacceptable. These include valuations based on
comparisons with prices of competing products, export market prices or choice of the higher price when two
4. See Krishna Rao (2005)—WTO: Text and Cases, Excel Books for more information on TRIPS.
www.bitbookwala.in
30 International Marketing–Text and Cases
methods are used. Customs may reject prices but they must give an opportunity to importers to justify their
claims.
The agreement on Pre-shipment Inspection (PSI) provides guidelines designed for protection against
practices by the inspection companies acting on behalf of governments. According to PSI, physical inspection
should be carried out in the exporting country and, if not possible, in the country of manufacture. The PSI
Agreement provides stricter discipline in their determination of the value of goods exported. It also provides a
new institutional mechanism for handling complaints regarding alleged arbitrary decisions by inspection
companies. It may also reduce the level of customs-related corruption
Firms may want to set the export price at a lower level than the normal price with a view to gaining market
share or access to a new market. It is a rather common practice in exporting. The WTO does not condemn
dumping but it is not allowed only if it causes or threatens to cause material injury to an industry or if it delays
the establishment of a domestic industry in a member country. The agreement on Anti-Dumping Practices
(ADP) states that if dumping is demonstrated, and if it results in an injury or threat of injury, the importing
country may impose an anti-dumping duty. Exporters may avoid anti-dumping duties by undertaking to
increase their export prices. Called ‘price undertakings’, these are allowed only after the investigating
authorities have issued a preliminary determination of injury as a result of dumping. Anti-dumping duties may
not be imposed for more than five years and should be terminated earlier if they are no longer warranted.
Complaints are to be handled by the Dispute Settlement Body (DSB) of the WTO.5
A firm deciding to fight an anti-dumping action should be prepared to cope with the usual legal hazards:
heavy legal fees, alien scrutiny over its accounting, pricing and managerial practices, considerable time and
human resources devoted to the defence of the case, and the additional discomfort of losing the case. Exporters
BIT BOOK WALA
should be very cautious and watch closely the situation in the importing countries. They should pay attention
to local competition with regard to their marketing performance and profitability. If domestic competitors face
difficulties, the temptation to lodge anti-dumping actions increases. In these circumstances, exporters might
judiciously consider increasing their prices before being investigated.
Most governments subsidise a few sectors of their economy. Since subsidies may have serious trade
distorting effects, GATT has attempted, in the past and during the Uruguay Round, to limit their use and ill
effects. The WTO treatment of subsidies depends on whether the goods exported are industrial or agricultural
products.
Under GATT, government are allowed to return to exporters the duty that they paid on imported inputs that
are being re-exported in exported products. The same principle applies to indirect taxes charged to exported
products like sales taxes, value-added tax and excise tax. Exporters should take advantage of these measures
with a view to lowering their export prices and of making their products more competitive. Usually, only
experienced exporters take advantage of these measures. One reason for this may be that separate records have
to be maintained and because of the administrative burden it represents, it is often perceived as too heavy to
make duty remission an attractive proposition to exporting firms.
Promotion
Promotion, also referred to as the communication mix of a firm, includes advertising, personal selling, sales
promotion, direct marketing as well as export promotion services provided to the exporting firms by
governments.
5. See Justin Paul, International Business, Prentice Hall of India for more information on Dispute Settlement Body.
www.bitbookwala.in
WTO and Implications on International Marketing 31
The issue of staff working abroad is dealt within the General Agreement on Trade in Services (GATS) in the
WTO framework.
The freedom to transfer staff abroad in the service industries remains quite limited because commitments
made under GATS by members have been selective. Only a few countries have granted free access to foreign
professionals without commercial presence.6 Yet, GATS should be seen as a first step towards further
liberalisation in the transfer to foreign markets of staff in general and sales personnel in particular. In future,
there will be a greater opportunity for firms to transfer and rotate their sales personnel in order to enable
effective personal selling.
Direct selling is selling to customers without using distribution intermediaries. It includes mail ordering and
the sale of goods and services by electronic means. At the Geneva Ministerial Conference held in May 1998, a
Declaration on Electronic Commerce (DEC) was adopted to examine all trade-related issues relating to
electronic commerce. Members agreed to continue the current practice of not imposing customs duties on
electronic transmissions. The declaration is not yet binding and, hence, electronic commerce is not yet ruled by
WTO.
Marketing communication tools like advertising, public relations and sales promotion are not specifically
dealt with in any of the various WTO agreements. This is because WTO agreements address problems relating
primarily to trade barriers affecting exporting and importing operations. They do not predominantly concern
activities that take place in the marketing of products or services like advertising or public relations once
products or services have passed borders. However, under the National Treatment (NT) Clause, services that
have entered other member markets should receive a treatment equitable to the treatment granted to like
domestic products or services. As a result, any marketing communication activity undertaken by an exporting
BIT BOOK WALA
firm in member countries, such as advertising, public relations or sales promotion for the marketing of imported
goods or services, should not be constrained any more than the communication activities of like domestic
products or services.
Place
In marketing terms, place refers to the convenience that a firm can offer to its customer by locating its products
and services closer to the place of its consumption. The main aim of WTO, which is to remove trade barriers, is
aimed at ensuring that a firm is able to operate in as many markets as it would want.
GATT has, to some extent, ensured that barriers to location of merchandise are unrestricted by discouraging
quantitative restrictions. Anti-dumping provisions ensure that weak markets are protected to some extent from
unfair practices. GATS aims to address the service-related issues like staff working abroad.
With the advent of the Internet, it has become very easy for companies to trade across boundaries. The
Internet has also enabled companies, especially those in the service industry, to locate offices across the globe
to take advantage of cheaper labour and to make use of a 24-hour workday. Hence, it becomes all the more
important for firms to protect their trade-related intellectual properties. The agreement on TRIPS addresses this
issue.7
National Treatment Clause implies that a foreign firm should be treated on par with its domestic competitor.
This enables the firm to offer its products and services in an equitable environment. The WTO has, thus, aimed
at removing all the impediments in the progress of globalisation.
6. See Arun Goyal (2001), WTO in the New Millennium, Academy of Business Studies for more information
on GATS.
7. Visit www.wto.org for more information on the TRIPS Agreement.
www.bitbookwala.in
32 International Marketing–Text and Cases
SECTION 3:
OTHER FACTORS
There are various options a firm may consider when entering a foreign market. The WTO rules deal directly only
with the establishment of sales offices or subsidiaries, licensing foreign direct investment and indirectly with
distribution in general.
There is no specific WTO rule dealing with the setting up of a sales organisation in a foreign country for the
marketing of either consumer or industrial products. There are, however, rules on the trading of services. These
rules are contained in GATS. The terminology used therein is “commercial presence”, which means any type of
business or professional establishment within the territory of another member for the purpose of supplying a
service, and includes the creation or maintenance of a branch or representative office. The basic rule is that
such an establishment should be granted national treatment by members unless specified in their Schedule of
Commitments, i.e. the listing of the concessions they granted to other members.8
This does not guarantee that an exporter of a service will be automatically granted the right to establish a
commercial presence by another GATS signatory. The type of service involved may not be covered by the
agreement. Besides, the Schedule of Commitment of the target country may include limitations to market access
or to national treatment for any given service category. The exporter of a service must check if the service to be
exported has been included in the Schedule of the target country, and what specific commitments that country
has made. In principle, such inquiries should not prove too difficult to conduct because signatories are obliged
to make their policies transparent by making relevant information on their import regime accessible to members.
In addition, GATS signatories must have established a national enquiry point that service exporters may
BIT BOOK WALA
address for information on their policies on trade in services
Licensing is often chosen as a means of entry when firms cannot export or proceed through foreign direct
investment either because of entry barriers or because the firm’s resources are limited. Firms that consider
entering a market through licensing are often afraid that they might not be able to protect their technological
know-how from unfair practices in foreign markets. As a result, they may refrain from transferring licensing
rights to foreign firms. However, under TRIPS, whether they like it or not, they may well be obliged to transfer
these rights to private local parties selected by the government of that country.
The main objective of the TRIPS Agreement is to protect the ownership rights of firms. The principle of
national treatment is reaffirmed, and countries are required to extend the MFN treatment to foreign nationals.
This requires that trade regulations should be applied to foreign goods or services without any discrimination
against any exporting member countries. The TRIPS Agreement also lays down rules under which a country
may be allowed to authorise a local firm to use a patent when its foreign owner demands unreasonable terms.
In other words, a government is allowed under the TRIPS Agreement to proceed with compulsory licensing
subject to several conditions. In particular, the compulsory license shall be used predominantly for the
domestic market and the patent owner shall be paid adequate compensation.
A firm that does not want to market the goods produced under a given patent, either by exporting or through
local direct investment, should be aware that if it does not want to transfer know-how through a licensing
agreement, it might nevertheless be forced to do so. It may then be better to negotiate licensing conditions with
a local firm rather than to be forced to accept compensation terms that may not be as advantageous, even if they
are adequate.
One more important aspect is the one related to direct investments. Considerable liberalisation has taken
place over the last decade regarding direct investment. Many constraints used to be imposed on foreign
investors in contradiction to such GATT principles as national treatment and quantitative restrictions. The
8. B. L. Das, WTO-Guide to the Framework for International Trade, Bookwell, New Delhi.
www.bitbookwala.in
WTO and Implications on International Marketing 33
Uruguay Round Agreement on Trade-Related Investment Measures (TRIMs) identifies measures that are not
acceptable and reiterates that TRIMs that distort trade flows are not allowed.
Prohibited measures include trade-balancing import requirements, restricted access to foreign exchange and
domestic sales requirements. The TRIMS Agreement is limited in scope, and a limited number of trade related
investment requirements may still be imposed by members, such as the proportion of equity to be held by local
investors or demands for the transfer of up-to-date technology. Firms considering investment in a foreign
market should, therefore, investigate the exact commitments that have been made by these countries.
The agreement has made investment abroad easier and the power of host countries to subject foreign
investors to demanding performance requirements has been greatly reduced. However, the commitments are
contingent upon the development policies and objectives of host governments as well as on their right to
regulate in the public interest.
SECTION 4:
CONCLUSION
WTO rules and regulations, when viewed from a firm’s perspective rather than that of a trade policy, show that,
in international business, only a limited number of rules affect the marketing mix decisions. Product and pricing
are the decision areas most affected by WTO, followed by entry modes/distribution and marketing
communication. However, organisations are usually unaware of the opportunities or threats they face as a
result of the implementation of the WTO rules. This is even more so in developing countries, where admission
to the GATT/WTO has been more recent, and where firms have not been traditionally active in international
business. BIT BOOK WALA
Firms should be more attentive to WTO developments. They should be more involved in the design of
national trade policies and as lobbyists when their governments are negotiating agreements.
WTO rules make the international business environment more transparent and predictable. WTO and its
predecessor, GATT, are major factors in the expansion of world trade. Over the years, the coverage of the
system has expanded, rules have been clarified and, to a certain extent, protectionism has been checked. The
result is an international marketing environment that is more open and competitive than ever before.
This chapter is only an overview of the important implications. A number of issues can still be considered.
In particular, two types of considerations have not been discussed, the preferential treatment granted to
developing and to least-developed countries and the unfinished work on many issues like rules of origin or
trade in agriculture. International marketers should keep themselves informed about these developments, as
they may have a significant impact on their performance in foreign markets.
REFERENCES
1. International Business, Cherunilam, Prentice Hall of India
2. International Business, Sharan, Pearson Education
3. International Business, Justin Paul, Prentice Hall, Third Edition
4. Taking International Marketing Decisions under WTO Rules, Jean-Emile Denis http://
cat.inist.fr/?aModele=afficheN&cpsidt=14392202
www.bitbookwala.in
34 International MarketingText and Cases
www.bitbookwala.in
WTO and Implications on International Marketing 35
REVIEW QUESTIONS
www.bitbookwala.in
BIT BOOK WALA
www.bitbookwala.in
Chapter 3
Learning Objectives
The reader should be able to understand and explain
• the process of internationalisation of a firm
• the strategies of companies that are successful in the international markets
www.bitbookwala.in
38 International MarketingText and Cases
SECTION 1:
INTERNATIONALISATIONREASONS AND STRATEGIES
M any companies have established a strong global presence by way of exporting, joint ventures, strategic
alliances and establishing subsidiaries. Some companies have become true multinationals and generate
a major share of their revenue from global functions.
Three macro factors seem to underlie the trend towards greater internationalisation. They are:
(i) The decline in trade barriers
(ii) Removal of restrictions on foreign investment
(iii) The technological change, particularly the dramatic developments that have occurred in recent years
in communications, information processing and transportation technologies.
This chapter looks at the global market entry strategies of some Indian companies like Ranbaxy, Dr. Reddy’s
Laboratories, Aurobindo Pharma and the Tata Group.
INTERNATIONALISATION: STRATEGIES
In a business, firms follow generic strategies: cost leadership, differentiation.
Each business must develop a competitive strategy focused on its own domestic
market1. In pursuing this strategy, the home country of operation is often the most
1. See Justin Paul (2007), International Business, Prentice Hall, 3rd Edition, www.phindia.com/justinpaul
www.bitbookwala.in
Emerging Trends & Internationalisation of Firms 39
important source of competitive advantage. The resources and capabilities of the home
country frequently allow the firm to pursue the strategy into markets located in other
countries. The generic strategies under this category are:
(a) International Cost Leadership Strategy: An international cost strategy is likely to
develop in a country with a large demand. Operations for such an industry are centralised
in the home country and obtaining economies of scale is the primary goal. Outsourcing
of low-value-added operations may take place, but high-value-added operations are
retained in the home country. Accordingly, products are often exported from the home
country.2
(b) International Differentiation Strategy: Firms based in a country with advanced
and specialised factor endowments are likely to develop this strategy.
In order to be a leader in this category, a firm has to continue to differentiate its
product in ways that are attractive to the mass market. Firms may differentiate their
products and services through physical characteristics or they may also differentiate in
the minds of the consumer.
SECTION 2:
RANBAXY LABORATORIES
BIT BOOK WALA
INTERNATIONALISATION STRATEGIES3
Ranbaxy Laboratories Limited was registered in India in 1961. Dr. Parvinder Singh joined Ranbaxy in 1967. He
was appointed as its Joint Managing Director in 1977 and elevated as the Managing Director in 1982. He rose
to the position of Vice Chairman & Managing Director in 1987 and took over as Chairman and Managing
Director in 1993. With his bold and new ideas Dr. Singh made immense contribution to the company.
Ranbaxy began manufacturing formulations in 1962. It went public in 1973. A multipurpose chemical plant
was set up to manufacture pharmaceutical products at Mohali (Punjab), in India. Ranbaxy formulated its export
strategy on the basis of the opportunities that came its way in 1975. In 1977, Ranbaxy had its first international
joint venture in Lagos (Nigeria). In 1983, a modern dosage forms facility at Dewas (MP), in India, was
developed. In 1985, the Ranbaxy Research Foundation was established. Stancare, Ranbaxy’s second
pharmaceutical marketing division, also started functioning.
In 1987, production started at the modern plant at Toansa (Punjab). In 1988, Ranbaxy’s Toansa plant got US
Food and Drug Authority (FDA) approval. In 1990, Ranbaxy was granted a patent for Doxycyline in the US.
Internationalisation Ranbaxy had always been very outward looking as a company. It recognised that
if 99 percent of the pharmaceuticals market lay outside India, tapping the international potential was always
something bigger than just meeting export commitments. Ranbaxy had foreseen that the future business
scenario would be based on worldwide product-based intellectual property rights.
www.bitbookwala.in
40 International Marketing–Text and Cases
Ranbaxy repositioned itself in 1992 and, to make internationalisation a success, the following changes were
carried out in the organisation:
i. Bringing a change in the exports mindset.
ii. In 1992, six to eight months were spent studying what Ranbaxy Laboratories really wanted to be. Three
clear elements emerged.
• First, it was decided that the company will not look at diversification into unrelated or areas but that
it will stick to its core area of pharmaceuticals.
• Second, it stated its intent to be an multinational company. This implied a focused and rapid
expansion into foreign countries.
• Third, it clarified that it will be a research-based company, which meant that it wanted to discover its
own proprietary innovative drugs to leverage in the era of worldwide intellectual property rights.
Growth Challenges, Phases and Strategies In 1970s and 1980s a lot of criticism was
encountered within and outside the company. E.g. it’s a tough industry, it’s pharmaceuticals, it’s only the West
which can discover and make high-quality pharmaceuticals, the Indian image is poor, Indian quality is average,
the “made in India” label is unattractive, you cannot sell an Indian product in the United States and not even
in some of the underdeveloped countries etc., were the often quoted criticisms.
The Indian pharmaceutical industry has long struggled with an international image that has collectively
labelled its members as trespassers of Intellectual Property Rights. Ranbaxy Laboratories was serious about its
image as an ‘international’ player and fought hard and long against the stigma attached to Indian firms.
BIT BOOK WALA
In 1992, Ranbaxy Laboratories entered into an agreement with Eli Lilly & Co of USA for strategic alliance in
India, to market select the latter’s products. In 1993, a joint venture was set up in China and was called Ranbaxy
(Guangzhou China) Limited.
In 1994, Ranbaxy Laboratories established its Regional Headquarters in London (UK) and Raleigh (USA).
Ranbaxy’s Global Depositary Receipts (GDR) got listed on the Luxembourg Stock Exchange. Thus, 1994 was a
very important year in the growth phase of the company.
In 1995, Ranbaxy Laboratories acquired Ohm Laboratories, a manufacturing facility in the US. And, the FDA
approved, state-of the art new manufacturing wing at Ranbaxy’s US subsidiary, Ohm Laboratories Inc., started
functioning.
In 1997, Ranbaxy Laboratories crossed a sales turnover of Rs.10,000 million, with its exports reaching an all
time high of Rs.5,000 million. In 1999, Bayer AG, Germany and Ranbaxy signed an agreement for an
International Strategic Alliance, where Bayer obtained exclusive development and worldwide marketing
rights to an oral once daily formulation of Ciprofloxacin, originally developed by Ranbaxy. It was Ranbaxy’s
strategy to market its products globally through this alliance.
In 2000, Ranbaxy acquired Bayer’s Generics business in Germany, which was trading under the name of
Basics. It also forayed into Brazil, the largest pharmaceutical market in South America and achieved global sales
of US $ 2.5 million in that market.
In 2001, Ranbaxy took a significant step forward in Vietnam by initiating the setting up of a new
manufacturing facility with an investment of US $ 10 million (Green Field Venture). It achieved a turnover of US
$ 600 million for the year 2001. At the same time, its subsidiary, Ranbaxy USA crossed sales of US $ 100 million,
becoming the fastest growing company in the US.
In 2003, Ranbaxy received The Economic Times Award for Corporate Excellence for ‘The Company of the
Year, 2002-2003’. Ranbaxy and Glaxo SmithKline Plc (GSK) accelerated their discovery programmes through a
global alliance for drug discovery and development.
www.bitbookwala.in
Emerging Trends & Internationalisation of Firms 41
In 2004, Ranbaxy began operations in France as a generic company after acquiring a wholly owned
subsidiary RPG (Aventis) SA. The company joined the elite club of Billion-Dollar Companies, achieving global
sales of US$ 1 billion in February 2004.
In 2005, Ranbaxy’s anti-malarial molecule successfully completed POC Phase II studies. It was launched in
Canada. It opened a third state-of-the-art R&D facility on its Gurgaon campus to focus on NCE discovery
research . Ranbaxy’s joint venture with Nippon Chemiphar in Japan (Nihon Pharmaceutical Industry Limited)
launched Vogseal for diabetes, the first product of the joint venture. In the same year it acquired the generic
product portfolio from EFARMES of Spain (18 drugs for sale in Spain).
Moving into Gear Mr. Malvinder Singh assumed charge as Managing Director and Chief Executive
Officer in January 2006. His global sense of enterprise made him to go for an ‘aggressive overseas acquisition’
strategy for expansion, instead of growth through the organic route. Accordingly, 2006 was an eventful and
relentless expansion year in the history of Ranbaxy, during which it acquired the following:4
March 21, 2006 Ranbaxy’s US arm bought patents, trademarks and automated manufacturing
equipment from Senetek for its disposable auto injector for self-administration of parenteral drugs for
anaphylactic shock.
March 27, 2006 Ranbaxy’s Italian subsidiary acquired the unbranded generic business of Allen, a
division of GlaxoSmithKline, to complement its own pipeline for the Italian market.
March 29, 2006 Ranbaxy acquired 96.7 percent of the Romanian drug maker Terapia from Advent
BIT BOOK WALA
International for $324 million (Rs.1,522 crore). Combined with Ranbaxy’s own operations in Romania, the
Terapia acquisition created Romania’s largest generics firm.
March 30, 2006 Ranbaxy acquired the generics company, Ethimed, a top ten player in Belgium. It
provides Ranbaxy a base from where to manage and expand its operations in the Benelux countries: (Belgium,
The Netherlands and Luxemburg).
July 18, 2006 Ranbaxy’s Spanish subsidiary purchased the Mundogen generics business of
GlaxoSmithKline in Spain. The acquisition beefed up Ranbaxy’s product portfolio in the country.
RANBAXY’S WORLD
Ranbaxy, at present, has manufacturing operations in more than a dozen countries and its products are
available in over 125 countries. The company has an expanding international portfolio of alliances, joint
4. Compiled from Business Today, September 10, 2006.
www.bitbookwala.in
42 International Marketing–Text and Cases
ventures and representative offices across the globe, with a presence in top markets of the world like USA,
Japan, China, Mexico, Canada, Brazil and South Africa. Similarly, it has a presence in 22 of the 25 European
Union countries, including Germany, France, Italy, UK and Spain.
SECTION 3:
DR. REDDY’S LABORATORIES: GOING GLOBAL AND
GROWING MULTINATIONAL
Dr. Reddy’s Laboratories is one of India’s leading drug manufacturers. The company, established by Dr. K. Anji
Reddy in 1984, develops and manufactures generic and branded pharmaceuticals and bulk pharmaceutical
ingredients. Later, it started manufacturing formulations and enhanced its trust on entering the international
market with exporting methyldopa in 1986. On continuation of its path towards success, the company obtained
its first USFDA5 approval in 1987. With the acquisition of Benzex Laboratory Private expanding its bulk actives
business, the company grew further in 1988.
Dr. Reddy’s Laboratories (DRL) Grow Globally During the 1990s, the company consolidated
its position in the domestic formulation market through product as well as acquisitions. By the late 1990s, Dr.
Reddy’s Laboratories transformed itself into a global pharmaceutical powerhouse with its research and export
strategy. Dr. Reddy’s Laboratories has world-class expertise in development and manufacture of
pharmaceutical intermediates, bulks actives and finished dosage. It is in a position to provide high quality and
cost effective products to the international market, including Europe, Japan and the US, etc. It was in 1990, Dr.
BIT BOOK WALA
Reddy’s Laboratories exported Norfloxacin and Ciprofloxacin to Europe and to the Far East.
By spreading its arm to export field company entered into the export business to Russia first time in 1991.
In 1993, Dr. Reddy’s Research Foundation was established at Miyapur in Andhra Pradesh. It filed 18 product
patents around the world for novel lead compound, largely focused on anti-cancer, anti-diabetes and
guidelines segments and popular for under-parent drugs, broad-basing its therapeutic presence.
This integrated unit is involved in analytical research, process chemistry, clinical research, pre-clinical
biology, area such as intellectual management and conference facilities, drug delivery in organic synthesis and
natural products chemistry.
Milestones
In 1984, the company was set up by Dr. Anji Reddy in India.
In 1986, Dr. Reddy’s entered international markets with exports of Methyldopa
In 1987, it obtained its first USFDA approval
In 1990, Dr. Reddy’s exported Norfloxacin and Ciprofloxacin to Europe and the Far East
In 1991, company commenced formulation exports to Russia
In 1994, Dr. Reddy’s Laboratories made a GDR issue of US$ 48 million
In 1995, DRL established a joint venture in Russia
Licensing Strategy in 1997 Dr. Reddy’s Laboratories licensed anti-diabetic molecule, DRF 2593
(Balaglitazone) (In 1997 and DRF 2725 Regaglitazar in 1998) to Novo Nordisk. Became the first Indian
pharmaceutical company to out-license an original molecule.
www.bitbookwala.in
Emerging Trends & Internationalisation of Firms 43
In 1999, Dr. Reddy’s Laboratories acquired 45 percent stake in American Remedies Limited.
Foreign Subsidiary in 2000 Reddy US Therapeutics, a wholly owned subsidiary, was established in
Atlanta, USA, to conduct drug discovery. With its merger with Cheminor Drugs Limited (CDL) and with its
acquisition of American Remedies Limited (ARL), the company became India’s third largest pharmaceutical
company after Ranbaxy and Glaxo.
Listing, Licensing and Joint Venture in 2001 It became the first Asia-Pacific pharmaceutical
company, outside Japan, to list on the New York Stock Exchange. It was listed with the symbol ‘RDY’ on April
11, 2001. On April 26, 2001, Dr. Reddy’s Laboratories (DRL) unveiled its new corporate identity and philosophy,
reinforcing its commitment to bring hope to life through meaningful research. DRL out-licensed DRF 4158 to
Novartis, for up to US$ 55 million upfront payment.6
Acquisition (Overseas) Strategy in 2002 DRL conducted its first overseas acquisition – BMS
Laboratories Limited and Meridian Healthcare in UK Nordisk.
In 2003, Dr. Reddy’s Laboratories announced a 15-year exclusive product development and marketing
agreement for drugs with Leiner Health Products in the US.
www.bitbookwala.in
44 International Marketing–Text and Cases
The company aims to become one of the top ten generic companies in the US.
• Dr. Reddy’s Laboratories focuses on the design, development and production of cost-
effective drugs for markets around the world.
• The company is involved in a number of strategic alliances with companies and
universities in India and the US.
www.bitbookwala.in
Emerging Trends & Internationalisation of Firms 45
SECTION 4:
AUROBINDO PHARMAS INTERNATIONAL
EXPANSION STRATEGIES
P. V. Ramaprasad Reddy and K. Nityananda Reddy promoted Aurobindo Pharma Limited as a private limited
company in 1986, with a small capital of Rs.10 lac. The company commenced production in 1988. It became a
public limited company in April 1992. Now, Aurobindo Pharma Limited is the largest manufacturer of semi-
synthetic penicillin in the continent and the fourth largest in the world. The company is among the top five
pharmaceutical companies in India, with integrated facilities to manufacture bulk drugs, antibiotics, antivirals,
antidepressants, antifungals cardiovascular, macrolides, CUS, CNS, antiallergic and gastroenterologicals. Today, the
company’s products are serving consumers in India and over 100 other countries.
BIT BOOK WALA
The company’s R&D strength lies in developing intellectual property in the area of non-infringing
processes and in resolving complex chemistry challenge by developing new drug formulations, new drug
delivery system and by applying new technologies for better processes.
Aurobindo Pharma Grows Global Aurobindo Pharma Limited has a significant presence in a large
part of the world.
1998: Subsidiary Strategy Aurobindo Pharma Limited set up two wholly owned subsidiaries in the
US and Hong Kong. The company invested $2,00,000 in the US and $1,50,000 in the share capital of Aurobindo
Pharma (Hong Kong) Pte Ltd.
2000: Joint Venture Strategy Aurobindo Pharma set up two joint ventures for formulations in the
U.S, with an investment of $12 million.
2003: Joint Venture Strategy Aurobindo Tongling (Datong) Pharmaceuticals Ltd., China, a joint
venture between Aurobindo Pharmaceuticals Limited and Shanxi Tongling Pharmaceuticals Co. has set up for
manufacture.
Aurobindo Pharma has established a number of wholly owned subsidiaries, joint ventures and
representative offices at strategic locations to take advantage of available opportunities and to improve the
business value chain.
These units are presently established business interests, creating the necessary infrastructure and alliances
and are being readied to handle volume business. They also ensure stability in source of supplies and
consistent quality. The marketing linkages will give the necessary capability to reach customers much faster.
www.bitbookwala.in
46 International MarketingText and Cases
www.bitbookwala.in
Emerging Trends & Internationalisation of Firms 47
LEARNINGS
It is worth noting that Indian pharmaceutical companies have emerged as true multinationals. They have
acquired the flagship products of some of the leading firms in the world and have entered into strategic
alliances with multinationals like Bayer AG, GSK and Merck, etc. A major share of the revenues of leading Indian
companies comes from their foreign operations. On the basis of recent developments, one can expect more
aggressive expansion activities in the pharmaceutical sector in the future.
REFERENCES
2. Annual Reports, (1995-2005), Ranbaxy
3. Annual Reports, (1995-2005), Dr. Reddy’s Laboratories
4. Annual Reports, (1995-2005), Aurobindo Pharma
5. Paul, Justin, (2007), International Business, Prentice Hall, 3rd Edition
6. Paul, Justin, (2006), Business Environment, McGraw-Hill, 2nd Edition
7. Primary information from the companies
8. Business Today, September 10, 2006, pp.66-7.
www.bitbookwala.in
48 International MarketingText and Cases
REVIEW QUESTIONS
Case Study
www.bitbookwala.in
Emerging Trends & Internationalisation of Firms 49
“Tata’s acquisitions till now can be called safe, at least in terms of investment,” a senior analyst
tracking the Group said. Corus is almost six times bigger than Tata Steel in revenues and three times
in production.
It also goes a step beyond Tata Steel’s earlier acquisition of NatSteel of Singapore in ’04 and
Millennium Steel of Thailand. “The previous two acquisitions gave Tata Steel presence across at
least seven countries in South-East Asia, a huge market for value-added steel products. It (the
acquisition) was more to increase geographical presence than to increase capacity,” said the
analyst.
The takeover of Corus by Tata Steel has led to its prominence in the global steel industry in
terms of reach and production. If successful, the post-deal entity will be the fifth largest steel
company in the world and the second biggest company in India in terms of turnover.
“Tata Steel had missed out on the opportunity, grabbed by LN Mittal, in the 1990s. Now, backed
by increased cash flows, considerable reserves of raw materials and leveraging the group’s cash
box, Tata Steel knows it’s now or never,” said an industry observer.
Interestingly, other group companies like Tata Motors, Tata Chemicals and Tata Tea have also
come through tough times and now are making cross-border moves. About a decade back, just 5
percent of the group’s turnover came from overseas operations. It increased to 20 percent in ’03
and is now 30 percent. If its multi-billion dollar acquisitions plans are any an indicator, 50 percent
doesn’t seem to be too far.
Source: The Economic Times
www.bitbookwala.in
BIT BOOK WALA
www.bitbookwala.in
Chapter 4
Learning Objectives
The reader should be able to understand and explain
• the criteria and strategies to be formulated for country analysis and selection
• how to measure the market size
• the meaning and scope of the international market mix.
Hitul Poladia, Raju Ranjan Singh, Vitesh K. Giri and Neeraj Verma helped in collecting the material for this chapter.
Authors Justin Paul and Ramneek Kapoor are thankful to them.
www.bitbookwala.in
52 International Marketing–Text and Cases
SECTION 1:
INTRODUCTION
T he process of penetrating and then selling in an international market is a difficult one. In fundamental
terms, entering a new country-market is like a start-up situation, with no sales, no marketing infrastructure
in place and little knowledge of the market. Despite this, companies usually treat this situation as if it were an
extension of their business, a source of incremental revenues for existing products and services.
Companies often pursue this new business opportunity with a focus on minimising risk and investment—
the complete opposite of the approach usually advocated for genuine start-up situations. From a marketing
perspective, although the principles are same, environmental differences often cause them to be applied
differently.
International marketing is different from home-country marketing. International marketing, as opposed to
marketing in a single country, takes place in an environment of increased complexity and uncertainty, in areas
as varied as consumer behaviour and government regulation. This suggests that the differences between
domestic and international marketing are differences of degree rather than underlying differences of kind.
SECTION 2:
COUNTRY EVALUATION AND SELECTION
Since companies seldom have enough resources to take advantage of all international opportunities, they must
carefully choose how to commit their human, technical and financial resources.
BIT BOOK WALA
Managers often ask, “Where can we best leverage our already developed competencies?” and “Where can
we go to best sustain, improve or extend our competencies?”1
Choosing a country to set up sales offices, franchisees and production units, etc. should be based on the
following conditions:
i. A geographic strategic location plan must let a company respond to new opportunities in different
locations.
ii. Scanning techniques that are based on broad variables that indicate opportunities and risks enable
managers to compare prospective country locations and to choose.
iii. Managers should take into consideration the business environment, the conditions in a host country
that could significantly affect the success or failure of a foreign business enterprise.
iv. Managers should make investment decisions only after weighing opportunities and risks; the factors
that have the most influence are market size, ease and costs, resource availability and red tape.
v. Market size and sales potential is probably the most important variable for manager’s use while deter-
mining whether to make an investment and where. A technique for making rough estimates of market
size is to base projections on similar or a complementary product, for which sales data are available.
vi. Within a regional trading group, companies may choose the country with the lowest corporate tax.
vii. Companies should compare the degrees [and costs] of red tape needed to operate in prospective
countries.
viii. Few techniques that can be used by companies to compare potential projects include discounted cash
flow, net present value, and internal rate of return.
www.bitbookwala.in
Country Analysis, Selection, Market Size and Marketing Mix 53
SECTION 3:
COUNTRY RISK ANALYSIS
It is often possible for companies to reduce risk by insuring. When operating abroad, a company usually faces
greater uncertainty than at home because the foreign operations have to be conducted in relatively less familiar
environment.
Competitive Risk
Companies may develop strategies to find countries in which there is least likely to be significant competition;
efforts will have to be taken to get the best partners, best locations and best suppliers.
Companies may gain advantages in locating where competitors are because the competitors have performed
the costly task of evaluating locations so that a follower may get a ‘free ride’.
Political Risk
Managers use three approaches to predict political risk: analysing past patterns, using expert opinion and
examining the social and economic conditions that might lead to such risk.
There is no general consensus as to how political instability can be predicted; different nationalities of
companies may perceive risks to be different for the same locales, generally because of differences in their
familiarity with the locales.
If there is a great deal of frustration in a country, political parties may disrupt business by calling general
BIT BOOK WALA
strikes and destroying property and supply lines; frustration is dissatisfaction as a result of unfulfilled needs,
i.e., aspirations.
SECTION 4:
MARKET RESEARCH AND CONSUMER BEHAVIOUR
Companies undertake research to reduce uncertainties in their decision processes, to expand or narrow the
alternatives they consider and to assess the merits of their existing programmes.
A company can seldom, if ever, gain all the information because of time constraints and the costs of
collecting and processing information; managers should estimate the costs of data collection and compare
them with the probable payoff from the data in terms of revenue gains or cost savings.
Using samples based on available information, a company can draw fairly accurate inferences concerning
market-segment sizes and locations; the available information from competitors’ public financial reports and
behavioural studies, a company can devise questionnaires or do some test marketing by using a selected
sample so that responses reflect the behaviour of the larger target group to whom the company plans to sell.
In many countries, business is conducted under a veil of secrecy, consumers’ buying behaviour is a matter
of speculation and market intermediaries are reluctant to answer questions.2
2. F.A. Goldstein, International Marketing Research – Myth or Reality? European Research 15, No. 2 (May 1987):
94-98.
www.bitbookwala.in
54 International Marketing–Text and Cases
Market Potential To determine the market potential, a company has to first estimate the possible sales
of the category products for all companies and then estimates its own market share potential. The techniques
used to determine the market size are the same as used domestically. The major indicators are:3
• Present income
• Population
• Growth rate in income and population
It has been found that:
• The product demand changes with increasing income levels (per capita income).
• Countries whose economies are growing experience a growing demand for products.
• Regression analysis can be done on the data collected for the consumption of a given product in
countries at different income levels to project sales.
This technique generally gives good fits, but there are certain factors, other than the per capita income, that
affect demand for some products in some countries. The main reasons are:
Obsolescence of Product Consumers in developing countries do not necessarily follow the same
pattern as consumers in higher income countries.
Costs If costs of essential products are high, depending on their per capita income, consumers may spend
more than what is expected. If costs of non-essential products are high, consumers will spend less than expected.
Normal Goods have a positive income elasticity of demand. So, as incomes of the consumer rise, the
demand at each price level is greater.
Necessities have an income elasticity of demand of between 0 and +1. Demand rises with income, but
less than proportionately. Often, this is because we have a limited need to consume additional quantities of
necessary goods as our real living standards rise. The examples of this would be the demand for fresh
vegetables, toothpaste and newspapers. Demand is not very sensitive at all to fluctuations.
Luxuries, on the other hand, are said to have an income elasticity of demand > +1. (Demand rises more
than proportion, to a change in income).
Inferior Goods have a negative income elasticity of demand. Demand falls as income rises. In recession,
the demand for inferior products might actually grow.
Within a given market, the income elasticity of demand for various products can vary and, of course, the
perception of a product must differ from consumer to consumer. The market for overseas holidays is a great
example (tourism).
What is a necessity for some people might be a luxury for others. For many products, the final income
elasticity of demand might be close to zero. In other words, at best, there is a very weak link between
fluctuations in income and spending decisions.
www.bitbookwala.in
Country Analysis, Selection, Market Size and Marketing Mix 55
Substitution Consumers in a given country may more conveniently substitute products or services than
consumers in some other countries. While cars have a large transportation role in the U.S., they are impractical
to drive in Japan. As a result, cars there serve more as a status symbol or as a means of personal indulgence.
The Japanese support the mass transportation systems like railways and buses.
Income Inequality Where income inequality is high, the per capita income figures are usually low. But,
there are people in the middle and upper income groups who have substantial income to spend. One such
country is India.
Cultural Factors and Taste Countries with similar incomes may have different preferences for
products and services because of values or tastes.
Given all the above factors, projecting the potential demand perfectly is not possible. However, a workable
estimate of sales can be made.
GAP ANALYSIS Gap Analysis is a tool for estimating a company’s potential sales by identifying market
segments it is not serving adequately. If a company’s sales are lower than the estimated market potential, it
means that the company has potential for increased sales. 4
Usage Gap
Distribution Gap
(Represents sales lost to
customers who distribute
where company does not)
B
Different companies may have to modify their marketing programmes because of the different gaps.
Competing in world markets required careful preparation and analysis. This requires evaluation of global,
regional and national demands and gaps5
4. Kumar (2005), International Marketing Research, Prentice Hall of India, 2004.
5. John S. Hill (2005), World Business, Thomson South Western, Page 129.
www.bitbookwala.in
56 International Marketing–Text and Cases
India is a relatively poorly penetrated market for motorcycles compared to other developing countries.
Countries like Indonesia and Vietnam, which have similar or lower per capita incomes, have much higher
motorcycle penetration. This is the reason why the Delhi based Hero group is moving internationally.
SECTION 5:
THE INTERNATIONAL MARKETING MIX
Establishing linkages across marketing mix elements is critical in a competitive environment, where product
i. Product Policy
There are five common product policies: product orientation, sales orientation, customer orientation, strategic
market orientation and societal orientation.
Product Orientation: With product orientation, companies focus primarily on production, with little
analysis of consumer need. This approach is used internationally for
• Commodity sales, where there is little need for differentiation.
• Passive exports that serve to reduce domestic surplus.
6. This is an original write-up based on the ideas given in the books, Global Marketing Strategies, Jeannet and
Hennessey, International Marketing, Subhash C. Jain and Global Marketing, Keegan.
www.bitbookwala.in
Country Analysis, Selection, Market Size and Marketing Mix 57
Customer Orientation: When the company operates according to its sales orientation, the product is
held constant and the sales location is varied. In contrast, in case of customer orientation, the country is held
constant and the product is varied. As the company wants to penetrate the markets in a given country because
of the country size, growth potential, proximity etc. In such cases, suppliers depend upon on the buyers to
determine what the final customers want.
www.bitbookwala.in
58 International Marketing–Text and Cases
a significant part. ”A critical issue for international marketing is the extent to which the
products and the Harley image need to be adjusted to meet the needs of overseas
markets. Harley’s image is rooted in American culture, and thus seems central to their
appeal to European and Asian customers. “The US and Harley are tied together,” says
Hugo Wilson of Britain’s magazine. “The guy who’s into Harleys here is also the guy who
owns cowboy boots. You get a Harley and you’re buying into the US mystique.” At the
same time, the composition of demand and the customer profile is different in overseas
markets.
Europe is the focal point of H-D’s overseas ambitions, simply because it is the second
largest heavyweight motorcycle market in the world. Europe is also a huge challenge for
H-D. Unlike in the US, H-D has never had a major position in Europe and it must fight to
take market share from the established leaders in the heavy bike segment: BMW, Honda,
Kawasaki and Yamaha.
The European motorcycle market differs significantly from the American market in that
70 percent of the heavy motorcycle market is for performance bikes (such as the popular
Japanese high-power, racing-style bikes), while the touring/cruiser bikes such as those
Harley makes, account for only 30 percent. European buyers tend to be knowledgeable
and highly style conscious. Also, European roads and riding style are different from the
US. As a result, Harley has modified some of its models to better meet the needs and
tastes of its European customers.
BIT BOOK WALA
Another example could be bicycles in China and USA. While the same bicycle might be sold in China and the
U.S., it might be positioned as a serious means of transportation in the former and as a recreational tool in the
latter.
Societal Marketing Orientation Companies with societal marketing orientation give serious
consideration of potential environmental, health, social and work-related problems for being successful in
those markets.
(i) Legal Reasons are usually related to safety, health protection and environmental issues. These may
cause changes in packaging of a product. Automobile companies have to limit emissions according to
pollution control norms in different countries. There may be many more regulatory issues. Also, there may be
differences in some product standards, according to which the company might have to do some product
alterations.
For example, appliances made for the U.S. and Europe must run on different voltages. A major problem was
experienced in the European Union when hoses for restaurant frying machines could not simultaneously meet
the legal requirements of different countries.
www.bitbookwala.in
Country Analysis, Selection, Market Size and Marketing Mix 59
(ii) Cultural Reasons Cultural and religious differences limit the standardisation of a product offering
on a global basis. For example, food and clothing, etc.
Alteration Costs Every product alteration has a cost. Some alterations are very low cost and yet have an
important influence on demand. For example, packaging.
However some alterations can be costly. Therefore, before taking a decision, a company must always
compare the cost of an alteration with the cost of lost sales from no alterations. One strategy could be to
compromise between uniformity and diversity.
Extent and Mix of the Product Line In reaching product line decisions, a company should
consider the possible effects on sales and the cost of having one product as opposed to a family of products.
• Narrowing the product line allows for concentration
• Broadening the product line may gain distribution economies
Product Life Cycle Considerations Product life cycles may differ by country.
BIT BOOK WALA
When one market has been saturated, it may be possible to continue growth in another market. For example,
while somewhere between one-third and half of American homes now own a computer, the corresponding
figures for even Europe and Japan are much lower. Therefore, many computer manufacturers see greater growth
potential there.
ii. Pricing
Proper pricing is very important for gaining sales as well as profits.
Kellogg’s, a global brand in its category of foods, conducted trials for its cornflakes when it first entered
the Indian market but was unable to sustain repeat purchase because of its high prices, which were almost
100 percent over the existing competitive brands.
Pricing is more complex internationally than domestically because of following factors:
• Different degrees of government intervention
• Greater diversity
• Price escalation for exports
• Changing values of currencies
• Differences in fixed versus variable pricing practices
• Retailers’ strength with suppliers in company to company sales
www.bitbookwala.in
60 International MarketingText and Cases
The WTO permits countries to establish import restrictions at a price lower than what is charged to
consumers in the exporting country. This makes it difficult for companies to differentiate through pricing. Japan
has actively lobbied the WTO to relax its regulations, which generally require firms to price not lower than their
average fully absorbed cost (which incorporates both variable and fixed costs).
Greater Market Diversity Country to country variation creates natural segments and a company sets
different prices for different countries on the basis of competitive situation and stage of product in the PLC. A
company may exercise considerable pricing discretion by using the following strategies:
• A skimming strategy
• A penetration strategy
• A cost plus strategy
On the basis of its brand equity and target markets, a company has to choose one of the above strategies
very carefully. The example below explains the failure due to wrong pricing strategy.
Heinz, the globally known ketchup brand, entered the Indian market, where Kissan and Maggi are well
established and with which consumers were familiar. Though the brand may have had a superior offering in
terms of product attributes, there was a need to create brand awareness and then link the brand’s attributes to
the name of the brand. Advertising through a well-planned positioning strategy was required to bring the
brand within the ‘consideration set’ of consumers. The penetration of the category (ketchup) is low, in the
order of 2-3 percent. The Heinz advertising campaign mentioned that the brand was synonymous with the
category of ketchup in a market where consumers were unfamiliar with the brand. Besides, the brand followed
an up-market skimming pricing strategy, of pricing the offering higher than the competitive offerings.
BIT BOOK WALA
While advertising may have been prioritised by the brand as a prerequisite for its ‘start-up’ strategy, the
brand had probably assumed that consumers in India are familiar with the brand and would associate it with the
category (which could be true of other markets in the world). Further, pricing the product high in a country
where there is a need to sell and create a market need not have been a priority. A lower priced variant
introduced with an innovative recipe drawn from traditional foods could have made a better impact on
consumers. The brand later introduced a sales promotion, which was followed by the strongly entrenched
brands in the category. The priority of the brand should have been a low-priced variant, positioned to create a
trial for the brand and expand the market.
Price Escalation in Exporting If standard mark-ups occur within distribution channels, lengthening
the channels or adding expenses somewhere within the system will further increase the price for the consumer.
In such a case, the price generally goes up by more than transport and duty costs.
Thus, to become competitive in exporting, a company may have to sell its product to intermediaries at a
lower price to lessen the amount of escalation. It should determine what price would help to maximize profits.
Currency Value and Price Changes In case of highly volatile currencies, pricing can be difficult.
Pricing decision must consider the replacement costs. If not, the company will be making only paper profits and
will not be able to adjust to inflation.
Two other pricing problems occur because of inflationary conditions:
• The receipts of funds in a foreign currency, which when converted, buy less of the company’s own
currency than expected
• The frequent readjustment of prices necessary to compensate for continuing cost increases
www.bitbookwala.in
Country Analysis, Selection, Market Size and Marketing Mix 61
When companies sell similar goods in multiple countries, price differences among the goods must not
exceed by much the cost of bringing them in from a lower priced country. Or, a spill over in buying will occur.
In barter, the seller takes payment in some product produced in the buying country. For example, when
Lockheed was an independent firm, it accepted Spanish wine in return for aircraft, and sellers to Eastern Europe
have taken their payment in ham.
Fixed versus Variable Pricing The extent to which manufacturers can or must set prices at the retail
level varies substantially by country. There is also substantial variation in whether, where and for what
products consumers bargain in order to settle on an agreed price.
Company to Company Pricing Dominant retailers with clout can get suppliers to offer them lower
prices. This, in turn, enables them to compete on being the lowest cost retailers.
iii. Promotion
The types and direction of messages and the method of presentation may be extremely diverse, depending on
the company, product and country of operation.
The Push-Pull Mix Factors that help determine the mix of push and pull among countries are:
• Type of distribution system
• Cost and availability of media to reach target markets. For example, access to TV and radio
• Consumer attitudes towards sources of information
BIT BOOK WALA
• Amount of consumer involvement in making a decision varies by country because of income levels
• Price of the product compared to incomes
• Amount of contact between salespeople and consumers
• Government regulations in terms of advertising.
Thus, push is more likely when
• Self-service is not predominant
• Advertising is restricted
• Product price is a high portion of income
• When the distribution system is more tightly controlled, push is more likely.
whereas pull is more likely in a self service situation.
Standardisation of the Advertising Programme The savings that result from having
standardised advertising are great. Standardisation also yields better quality at local levels. Companies can
rapidly enter different markets with the same advertising agency, taking good ideas from one market and
quickly introduce them in other markets.
Complete standardisation of advertising is sometimes not possible due to translation, legality and message
needs.
Translation When a company is going to sell in a country where a different language is spoken and
understood, translation is usually necessary. Some messages play on words and simply don’t translate well.
Sometimes, direct translation is not possible as what is an acceptable word in one place may seem obscene at
another place.
www.bitbookwala.in
62 International MarketingText and Cases
Legal Varying national views on consumer protection, competitive protection, promotional civil rights,
standards of morality and nationalism put legal constraints. What is legal in one country may be illegal in other
country.
For example, large supermarket chains are not allowed to advertise on TV in France. In some European
countries, for example, it is illegal to price discriminate between consumers and, thus, coupons are banned. In
some places, it is illegal to offer products on sale outside a very narrow seasonal and percentage range.
Message Needs Message needs may differ from country to country, depending upon the PLC and gap
analysis.
Media Media requirement may also vary in different countries. An average American is exposed to several
hundred advertising messages a day. TV advertising is losing its effectiveness because of the growing
advertising clutter, the increasing number of channels, the availability of zapping mechanisms and reduced
watching of television by certain groups. Thus, marketers must consider other methods of getting consumers’
attention.
Brand Acquisitions Much international expansion takes place through acquisition of companies in
foreign countries that already have branded products. The acquiring company may either continue with the
existing brand name of the acquired brand or may try to consolidate the acquired brands to reduce its
promotional budget.
Country of Origin Images Products of some countries tend to have a higher quality image than those
from other countries. Companies depending upon the image choose to put labels.
The main challenge is to find new ways to capture attention and position a brand in the consumer’s mind.
Public relations and word-of-mouth marketing are playing a growing role within the marketing mix to build and
maintain brands.
Difficulty of Standardisation Within the marketing mix, for several reasons, companies find
distribution one of the most difficult functions to standardise internationally.
Distribution reflects different country environments.
• As distribution norms differ among countries, the distribution function may vary substantially among
countries
• There are many factors like citizens’ attitudes towards owning their own stores, cost of paying retail
workers, labour legislations and efficacy of the postal system, etc., that influence the type of distribu-
tion of goods in a country
• The distribution is difficult to change.
www.bitbookwala.in
Country Analysis, Selection, Market Size and Marketing Mix 63
Choosing Distributors and Channels A company may tie up with other companies for its
distribution function or it may handle the function on its own. Distribution may be handled internally when:
• Volume is high
• Companies have sufficient resources
• Prices or technology are high or when there is complex after-sales servicing
• There is a need to deal directly with the customer due to the nature of the product
• The customer is global
• Company wants to gain a competitive advantage.
www.bitbookwala.in
64 International Marketing–Text and Cases
transportation, reliable communication, such as mail, phone, fax and the Internet, is also essential to allow for
the flow of goods.
REFERENCES
1. International Marketing, R. M. Joshi, Oxford Higher Education.
2. International Marketing, Keegan, Pearson.
3. International Business, Justin Paul, Prentice Hall.
REVIEW QUESTIONS
1. From the point of view of International Marketing, discuss the criteria for country
analysis.
2. Discuss the facts of the international marketing mix.
GAME
OBJECTIVE QUESTIONS
True or False
1. Interior Goods have a negative income elasticity of demand.
2. DELL, Computer Company is known for its online ordering proposition, internationally.
3. Products of some con...tend to have a higher quality image than those from other countries.
Multiple Choice
1. Common criteria for selection of distributors include
(a) Financial Strength (b) Good connection with Customers
(c) Extent of its other business (d) All of these
commitments (e) None of these
2. Common Product policy include
(a) Product Orientation and Sales Orientation only
(b) Product orientation, Sales orientation, Customer orientation, strategic market orien-
tation, societal orientation
(c) None of these
(d) Customer orientation and Societal orientation only
www.bitbookwala.in
Chapter 5
International Marketing:
Research and
Opportunity Analysis
BIT BOOK WALA
Learning Objectives
The reader should be able to understand and explain
• the definition and concept of international marketing research
• reasons why firms undertake international marketing research
• the scope and ambit of international research
• the steps involved in the process of international marketing research and con-
straints felt thereof
• the sources of international marketing research information, i.e. secondary data
and primary data
• sales forecasting methods and techniques.
www.bitbookwala.in
66 International MarketingText and Cases
SECTION 1:
INTRODUCTION
I nternational marketing research is basically a collection and analysis of information about a product or
service in the international market, from a sample of individuals and organisations. This information relates to
their behaviours, characteristics attitudes, opinion, possessions, needs, and aspirations. Generally, such
international marketing research will include research on consumers, industry, psychological, demographical,
economical and political investigations, observations and panel studies. In fact, from product design to
packaging to retailing to advertising and selling in the multi-country and multi-cultural markets, an international
marketing firm must continuously seek information that can help it find answers to guide it in an alien
atmosphere. International marketing research, thus, becomes a basic tool for decision-making. Before
launching a product in the domestic market, just as a manufacturer has to gather, analyse and evaluate the
information pertaining to the need for the product, consumers’ attitude and preferences towards already exiting
substitutes, total industry potential, expected sales volumes and values, the comparative price its market can
bear and lots of other demand determinants variables, such as the economic scenario, the cultural differences
amongst different communities residing within the country , its legal, moral and ethical aspects and the direct
and indirect elasticity through the domestic marketing information system the company has set up, in the same
way the manufacturer needs to evaluate and adopt information while planning to sell in multi-domestic and
multi-country markets. Because of the unknown characteristics of foreign markets, international marketing
firms need to get into the market research seriously.
In this chapter, an attempt has been made to understand the need for marketing research for internationally
www.bitbookwala.in
International Marketing: Research and Opportunity Analysis 67
subject at the global level. The discussion will also take into account varied cross-cultural, cross-country and
cross ethnic issues that sway and influence research decisions.
SECTION 2:
WHY DO FIRMS CONDUCT INTERNATIONAL
MARKETING RESEARCH?
The objectives of international marketing research may vary from firm to firm and from country to country
because the factors that influence the market scenario are dynamic in nature and may keep on changing as the
economy of different countries gets affected by national and international incidents. Similarly, while
manufacturers may be familiar with the cultural, political and ethnic nature of their home country through the
information system adopted at home, it is not necessary that this system will be equally familiar with the other
world marketing systems, cultures, politics, economies, customers and their consumption patterns,
preferences and other idiosyncrasies. Manufacturers may have to constantly monitor and evaluate the
different forces and trends that could affect the smooth operation of international demand and supply,
resulting in either in massive consolidation of success in the global market or it may mean failure and having to
start the operations all over again. Thus, setting up of the market information system at the international level
becomes the first need and basis of international marketing research.
The heavy outlay of costly mistakes made due to lack of adequate and appropriate
marketing research at the international level can be seen in the way the Chinese firms are
BIT BOOK WALA
paying a gigantic price for entering the Western markets without proper home work. Their
foray into the West began when consumer electronic giant TCL took over the loss-making
German TV brand Schneider. The assumption was that they will have a profitable
beginning into the Western market. TCL had also acquired Thomson of France, thereby
becoming the largest maker of televisions in the world. But it became clear soon that TCL
had not conducted its research, as it should have. Schneider had not been the preferred
brand for many years. Similarly, the European electronic market had already been facing
price competition of very low margins; often resulting in net losses as well. The Chinese
management, which was entering these markets for the first time, could not understand
the fragmented market of Europe. Similarly, when BenQ, the Taiwanese cell phone maker,
announced its intentions of closing the German plant it had bought from Siemens just a
year ago, because its market share had shrunk from 5 percent to 3 percent, it became
clear that the market research conducted had not given solutions to BenQ to fight out
the costs and market complexities of business in European markets.
Adapted from: Stefan Theil, “Cultural Confusion, The Week, October 16, 2006, Pp.42-43.
http://www.newsweekinternational.com/
From the above two references, it becomes clear that international marketing research is a very complex
activity because organisations may not come across the kind of issues they face in their home territories
elsewhere in the world. Through secondary research and primary surveys, an international company may seek
answers to some of the following questions and problem areas:3
3. Kumar V (2003), International Market Research, Prentice Hall of India may be referred for more information.
www.bitbookwala.in
68 International MarketingText and Cases
1. Identifying and understanding the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats in existing and
emerging markets vis-à-vis the in-house references pertaining to
(a) PRODUCTS - whether to extend the same line of products or to have an extension. Or, should the
products be altered according to country-specific requirements. The demand estimates for its
products vis-à-vis the competition, the market responsiveness to its products as against the
locally made products and also against the products and services imported.
(b) PRICING in terms of self-criterion, existing, emerging and expected competitions in countries
across the world. How the cost, laws, rulings, regulations, interest rates, banking systems, ex-
change rates, taxes and balance of payments of its host / target country will affect the pricing
strategies.
(c) DISTRIBUTION and logistics, which could be profitable to the firm at the same time. This must
mean providing satisfaction to customers. The corporate business strategies, the plans and the
functional systems adopted in various countries.
(d) PROMOTION that could not only make a noise but could be a real perception building exercise for
the organisation in the minds and preferences of the customers spread in different countries. The
system must give out the communication media, its reach, availability and cost of channels to
spread into the targeted segments, availability of financial, human and psychical resources and
their required qualitative levels.
2. Understand the complexities of consumer behaviour all across the designated countries, under condi-
tions specific to that country alone.
SECTION 3:
INTERNATIONAL MARKETING RESEARCH
As discussed in the introduction to this chapter, international marketing research is deep and analytical. This
study becomes a basic tool for decision-making, as it involves scanning of data, collected either personally by
the human resources employed by the firm or by the outside agencies, either contracted by this firm or an earlier
firm that had faced similar problems in its approach to this particular project or problem.
Thus, international marketing research has rightly been defined as “systematic designing, gathering,
recording, and analyses of data about problems related to marketing of a product or services in more than one
country by a firm operating globally”. The definition clearly states that this is a kind of research that crosses
international boundaries and whose universe and protagonists may come from across different nations,
cultures and economic and political set ups. The firm could have had similar research going on in different
countries at the same time or it can be conducted sequentially at later times in the other parts of the world. Such
a huge exercise obviously presents its own challenges and limitations in the form of different decisions thrown
www.bitbookwala.in
International Marketing: Research and Opportunity Analysis 69
up by the research findings. A firm has to adapt one that suits it the most and which can only come after
reconciling the differences involved in multi-location, multi-cultural, multi-political, multi-lingual, multi-legal
and multi-personnel aspects, as each factor assigns its own outlook to the research involved.
Country Profile To prepare a comprehensive picture of a country or countries in which the firm proposes
to operate or expand its already existing operations. International marketing research will help in country
screening and selection once the firm is able to match the available data with that of self-reference criterion and
check the viability of the proposal financially, physically, ethically, politically and economically. The research
BIT BOOK WALA
team may initially do this after analysing secondary data available through the published figures of the country
concerned. The sources of secondary data will be discussed separately in this chapter.
Profile of Industry Marketing research will be needed to prepare a comprehensive report on the
industry to which the firm belongs, or in which the firm proposes to diversify. The manufacturing capacities, the
sales potentials, the future growth expectations, the earlier bottlenecks, the industry trends, the market
characteristics particular to that country, the competitive strength and weaknesses of the related industry, will
all have to be studied. The research methods will vary from studying and analysing secondary data to concept
testing and conducting research on focus groups. The international markets have often been subjected to
volatile changes due to rapid technological changes in developed countries, shortening product life cycles,
international takeovers and mergers, diversifications and gains or losses in the product market shares.
International marketing research will have to study all this through the concepts of focus groups, direct
surveys and secondary data analyses. While it will be easy for it to get the necessary data in developed
countries, where storage of data and information is better organised, it will be a tough task for any marketer to
acquire such information in underdeveloped or developing countries, where no formal systems to store data
exist or even if the information is available it will have been put together for a different purpose.
International Customer Profile This can also be called a research into a buyer’s mind and the
external factors affecting preferences, behaviour, attitudes, likes and dislikes. Brand awareness of the firm’s
products and services and also that of the competition is studied through this research.
4. Oded Shenkar and Yadong Luo (2004), International Business John Wiley & Sons, Singapore, Page 127.
www.bitbookwala.in
70 International MarketingText and Cases
Similarly, firms may study niche markets by identifying different segments available across the globe. Such
segmentations enable the marketer to focus its resources to that particular group rather than stretching its
abilities all across the world.
International Product Profile The firms planning to go international generally will have some
product or service being successfully marketed in the home country and, it is possible, the company may be
exporting the same to select countries. However, this does not mean that the firm is successful in the
international market. In order to establish its credentials, the firm’s research will have to evaluate its offers and
BIT BOOK WALA
products mix in the light and environment of targeted markets situated in different countries and the objectives
set up by the firm. The firm will have to conduct primary surveys either all across or by select and identified
groups in controlled markets. This will help the firm in giving acceptable names, identities and brands to its
products in different countries.
The meanings attached to different brands and their usage may vary across different cultures and their
correct presentations can only be achieved if the international marketer is aware of the hidden as well as the
apparent need of the international customer.
Similarly, consumers’ tastes and habits will have to be established by product testing through international
marketing research and the firm has to ensure its products conform to local tastes.
When Pepsi Co Foods International decided to launch its Cheetos snack food brand in
China, it undertook an extensive product testing there. The survey indicated that the
customers did not like too much cheese in snack food and, as a result, Pepsi Co had to
replace the taste of cheese with that of cream and steak. The new flavour introduced
resulted into larger sales volumes.
Source: Helen Johnstone, ‘Little Emperors Call the Shots’, Asian Business, September 1996,
vol.32, No.9, pp 67-8
The colours, symbols, material and the size of packing and packaging, in addition to the information given
on the outer cover, may vary from nation to nation and each culture will assign its own meaning to different
kinds of packing. To ensure that it conveys the correct meaning to the users, a firm will have to undertake its
own design studies for its literature and publicity materials.
www.bitbookwala.in
International Marketing: Research and Opportunity Analysis 71
Product packaging design studies will highlight to the firm the extent of acceptability of its material by the
customers across different countries or whether it has to introduce changes and alterations in its packaging
and packing.
A hand tools manufacturer from India booked a big order of supplies to Japan. The
importers there assured him that they would be placing similar orders in future as well.
But, for some reason, the Japanese orders did not come through and, in fact, many of the
importers wanted to get out of the import contract.
On his next visit to Japan, the manufacturer found out why. The packaging he had
used was too simple in design and it had been done in single color. He could not
understand why a hand tool, which ultimately had to be sold to an automobile mechanic
or, at best, to a small machinery store should be packaged in an attractive, multi-
coloured customised box. Then, his local distributor presented a pen to him, which was
elegantly wrapped in a multi-coloured gift-wrap. The distributor casually asked him to
hazard a guess as to how much the pen would have cost. On having been told the actual
value of the pen inside and the perceptive value Japanese attached to the outer
packaging, the hand tool manufacturer understood that he too had to revamp his
packaging to suit the same taste.
A firm may have a subsidiary operating in a specific country and, in order to avoid similarities, the firm’s
BIT BOOK WALA
international packaging may have to bear a different look altogether. For example, Nestle chocolates or
Cadbury’s products, which are generally available in all countries, through local manufacturing and marketing
subsidiaries, will definitely have a localised flavour, packing and taste, whereas the one exported by the
company’s international marketing head quarters will have completely different packaging and colours in order
to distinguish it from the others. The colours particularly convey different meanings to consumers of different
countries. For instance, green colour is associated with abundance and prosperity in the Muslim countries but
it is also associated with disease in some parts of the world.
Similarly, the size and material used in packaging plays its role in some countries. Some of the international
brands selling beer in India, to date, have not been able to popularise beer cans because the Indian consumers
like to hold the refrigerated glass bottle in their hands, just to check if it is chilled enough to consume. The
tinned can does not feel chilled in the consumers’ hands.
In order to understand the actual needs, requirement and delight levels of the foreign consumers, test
marketing of products and services may be undertaken by the international marketer under product research.
This kind of testing can ultimately iron out all deficiencies prevailing in any component of the marketing mix.
Such test marketing may involve testing new product performance and consumer response in a controlled area
of a region or a country.
International Distribution and Logistics Profile International marketing is very different from
marketing of products within the home boundaries of a firm. For international marketing, a firm will have to
undertake a complete analysis of the local customs, traditions, legal rules, regulations, contractual bindings,
understandings and agreements within different nations on the import and export of goods and services.
Similarly, even though the firm resorts to incoterms for import/ export to market within different countries, to
have an effective and cost efficient logistical policy, it will have to familiarise itself with different terms and
www.bitbookwala.in
72 International Marketing–Text and Cases
conditions, language, excise and other conditions. Timely deliveries, safety of material and reach through the
appropriate channels to the best satisfaction of ultimate customers becomes the hallmark of getting a winning
edge over all sorts of competition. An international marketing firm’s research plan must look into the cultural
variables that can influence the purchase patterns and subsequent distribution systems.
The geographical distribution of potential within multi-country limits may vary from region to region and it
is possible that the firm may not find it feasible to get into all regions at once. Hence, the research will have to
identify and find an answer to the problem of reaching all the nooks and corners, or a selective area, and find the
right and efficient channels to move the goods and services, i.e., as industries and firms globalise, so
managements must increasingly analyse industries and competitors on a worldwide basis.5
5. John S. Hill (2005), World Business: Globalization, Analysis and Strategy, Thomson South Western.
www.bitbookwala.in
International Marketing: Research and Opportunity Analysis 73
Channel coverage and their effectiveness can become the major cost add-on factor in distribution of fast
moving consumer products. Avon, Olivetti and Amway have adopted the route of selling directly to the actual
consumers by way of individual distributors, who move into select societies.
Similarly, Hindustan Uni Lever Ltd is establishing a direct distributing strategy in some states in rural India.
Their rural vans are covering remote villages to cater to the rural needs.
Distribution research will have to focus on where to put up the manufacturing plants, warehouses and
stockyards, etc., particularly in industrial products and consumables, where the industrial inventory levels
have been following the ‘Just In Time’ ( JIT) policy to bring down the cost of components. Market researchers
will have to consider and evaluate their feasibility and suggest a way out. Distribution research will also
analyse the financial as well as physical capacity and capability in addition to government rules, regulations,
commission norms and other legal, fiscal contractual obligations that may differ from country to country.
Proctor and Gamble’s commercial on Camay beauty soap caused quite a furore and
embarrassment for the firm. The advertisement commercial showed a man walking into the
bathroom, where his wife was taking her bath. This advertisement could not possibly have
conducted detailed research into the bathing habits of the Japanese. The privacy of a
wife in the bathroom in a Japanese household is considered absolute and the husband
must respect that also.
Adapted from: Alecia Sway, Soap Opera, the inside story of Proctor and Gamble. New York,
Random House 1993 p 268
www.bitbookwala.in
74 International MarketingText and Cases
Such an intrusion on a wife’s privacy may not be considered offensive in the Western culture but not so in
Japan. Similarly, in order to adopt a particular promotional strategy, a firm will need a thorough research into the
different aspects of personal selling, for instance whether to entrust the entire work to the distributor staff, hire
its own staff abroad or to deploy a team from the head office and home country. The answers to all these
questions, and many others, will have to be obtained through international marketing research.
International Pricing Profile It will be a major blunder for any international firm to transfer home
country price to another country, by simply converting the local currency value into foreign currency. It is not
necessary that a packet of 20 Classic cigarettes, costing Rs. 70 in India, should be converted to equivalent
currency value in the U.S. The international price fixation is not merely an exercise in demand or supply or cost
plus profit, as it may be done in domestic market. It has to comprehensively understand multi-country market
potentials, sales potentials, multi-country sales forecasts and cost analyses thereof. A firm also has to
understand the impact of international price elasticity, competitive pulls and pressures, from international
competition and also the issues concerning trade agreements, tariff duties, customs, currency ups and downs,
economy inflationary pressures and the perceptual impact of pricing, etc. The cultural context on international
pricing will have to be researched. Products considered value for money in one culture may either be too
expensive or useless for the price fixed in another culture, as their uses could differ. Similarly, in Western
culture, profit earning is not seen to be bad. In fact, high pricing may result in a positive perception for the
product, whereas in emerging markets and many Islamic countries, excess profitability may not be appreciated
and may mean cheating the customer. Maximum retail pricing may vary from culture to culture, and country to
country. Bata shoes has, to date, been pricing its shoes in odd numbers, with prices ending with a figure of 9 or
99 and not making it to the next digit, as that tends to increase the unit sales. In the Chinese-dominated cultures
BIT BOOK WALA
and countries, the number 8 has a significant meaning, as its local pronunciation tallies with wealth (8).
Researchers will have to analyse and evaluate the impact of conveying of product through multiple channels
on the international pricing, as commissions will have to be paid at each level even though they may take into
account only the fair amount being paid, which will add to the price for the end consumer.
SECTION 4:
CONDUCTING FORMAL MARKETING RESEARCH
The process of international research – The international marketing research process is not different from the
local domestic research that the firm may have conducted to understand its customers, their biases and
favourites, their needs, aspirations and desires. Information about customers remains the most critical factor in
both the research processes. However, it is not so easy to conduct this research at the international level in
spite of continuous flow of an in-house marketing information system set up by the firm. This information
system may act as an additional tool but the firm will have to employ an altogether different process of
marketing research to address the problems pertaining to a particular project, objective or assignment at the
international level. It will require systematic gathering, collection and analyses of data, either through the in-
house marketing information system or an outside agency specialising in international marketing research will
have to be assigned the task of conducting the necessary process on behalf of the organisation in various
countries earmarked for the research project. In both the situations, the steps followed are generally the same
as discussed below.
• Identifying and Defining the Research Problem.
• Developing and Formulating a Research Plan.
• Determining Information Extent and Need.
www.bitbookwala.in
International Marketing: Research and Opportunity Analysis 75
• Collecting Data.
• Analysing Data and Interpreting Results.
• Finalisation of Report and Presentation.
a. Identifying and Defining the Research Problem International marketing research, like any
other research, starts off by identifying the actual problems to be addressed in the entire process. Once the
problem has been identified and clearly defined, it becomes easy to reach a consensus on the objective of the
research. Since it may involve resources and personnel on a very large scale, the researcher will have to evolve
a system that could differentiate the symptoms from the actual problem. Just as in the human body a doctor has
to diagnose the root cause of fever, because fever may not be the actual disease, the market researcher should
isolate and identify the root cause from the actual problem.
1. Exploratory Research For this, the market researcher may have to get into exploratory research that
can provide the relevant dimensions of the actual problem. It may also suggest the information and tools that
may be required to solve this problem. For example, while conducting an exploratory research into the sales
drop of large sedan cars in a particular market, the research concluded that it is not the car that created the
problem but the non-availability of enough parking space in people’s houses that actually necessitated their
buying smaller vehicles. Thus, many times, exploratory research may present another problem to be identified
and investigated.
2. Descriptive Research This may be needed to describe a situation and get the hypothesis proposed
by exploratory research. The descriptive research will have to include observational and statistical techniques
b. Developing and Formulating a Research Plan Before starting, the international marketing
firm’s research team will have to work out a blueprint for the research that will identify the budgetary
provisions, requirements, information sources and their cost to the organisation in terms of preparing data
collection instruments, reaching those instruments to the protagonists, survey methods and personnel
involvement and analysis systems to be adopted, etc. The time period for each activity will have to be spelt out
to obtain best benefits for the costs involved. Thus, while formulating a research plan, the firm must have
answers to the following problems:
1. How can the firm benefit in value (dollar/rupee terms) by collecting this information and interpretation?
2. How much will this information cost in terms of dollars/ rupees?
3. How much will it cost the organisation in dollar /rupee terms in the long run if this data is not collected?
The international marketing research plan will also specify whether the firm will have to go into the direct
data collection exercise. Or, if there will be enough data available through the in-house information system, or
through an earlier research carried out by other agencies for similar problems.
www.bitbookwala.in
76 International MarketingText and Cases
The following figure, Fig. 5.1, presents a graphic description of the steps involved in international marketing
research process
c. Determining Information Extent and Need After defining the research problem, the next
step is to determine how much information would suffice to reach some conclusive evidence to solve the
problem. The cost of research being quite high, the extent of information gathered must remain within
predetermined limits of time, universe and geographical boundaries. For example, while conducting research, a
major midsize car manufacturing company will have to determine whether it needs to survey the entire
population of the country in which the research project is on or will it suffice to conduct a survey in one
particular region. It will have to specify again whether all population members of the region will be covered or
only people falling within certain age groups, income categories and professions will be the target universe.
The researcher will have to devise a conscious strategy that can ensure that self-reference criteria will not be
allowed to colour the research process or the findings. It has been often observed that self-culture, values,
customs norms and behaviour always get into the researcher’s observation and they eventually creep into the
final analysis also. As far as possible, home country norms, values, beliefs and cultural variants should be
analysed and, if it is felt that their influence will alter the meaning and definition of the entire research process,
they should be kept in mind.
Collecting Data Once the extent and need of the research problem has been determined, after
identification and definition, the research team will be in a position to pinpoint the source of information from
Secondary
Collecting Data
Primary
Analysis of Data
Evaluation/interpretation
Presentation
www.bitbookwala.in
International Marketing: Research and Opportunity Analysis 77
the necessary data can be collected. Usually, the first step is to look for the data within the firm’s own network
of information, which could be the firm’s own offices, sales team and associates. This is known as internal
secondary data. In order to widen its field of knowledge for better analyses of problem, the firm will still have to
look at the data collected by other agencies. This data will be called external secondary data. The firm’s
objective and problem get better defined and identified after the market research team has analysed the
secondary data. This data will clearly indicate whether further research is required and if primary data should be
collected through personal interviews and surveys, which amount to primary research.
Secondary Data Secondary data is data that has been collected by someone else for a similar or
dissimilar situation or problem at an earlier time, not for the problem at hand. In fact, today, knowledge banks all
over the world, whether on the Net or within the confines of government libraries, databanks, online
professional, and user-provided keyword access agencies, commerce and trade-related development agencies,
etc., are replete with the secondary data. However, whether the data available is relevant to the current research
problem will have to be decided by the research firm.
In the developing and emerging economies of the world, knowledge management has become the keyword
and most commercial organisations, embassies, trade representatives, chambers of commerce, ministries of
industry and trade, etc., provide vast sources of data. In the emerging economies, however, this data may not
be classified properly and the verification of accuracy may call for another litmus test for the international
marketing research.
In the developed countries, however, comprehensive statistics are available. For example in United States,
the National Trade Data Bank, maintained by the U.S. Department of Commerce, offers a wealth of data on their
BIT BOOK WALA
website, http://www.stat-usa-gov concerning export opportunities and marketing guidelines, etc. Similarly,
organisations like the United States Department of Commerce can help researchers by providing country-
specific reports. Japan and many other countries like the United Kingdom, France and Germany too have a vast
source of data collected through research conducted by agencies deployed by their governments. The top 10
firms engaged in global marketing, advertising and opinion research are from these European countries. By
charging a subscription fee, these agencies offer huge resources of secondary data.
Many publications, magazines and journals related to international industry, trade and commerce also carry
out their own surveys in countries across the world, and a wealth of knowledge can be accessed through these
publications.
Again, international agencies like the World Bank, The Organization For Economic Cooperation And
Development (OECD), The International Monetary Fund ( IMF) and many arms of United Nations actively
gather information on economic, social and demographical development in their member countries. Published
reports for the last many years are available from these agencies. Trends can be ascertained on international
economic, social and political situations anywhere in the world over by studying these reports.
www.bitbookwala.in
78 International Marketing–Text and Cases
through a fresh survey because not much was likely to have changed in the respondents’ living standards a
couple of years later. However, validation of secondary data is absolutely essential, even if it is used by the
same firm.
External Secondary Data Sources The sources for secondary data vary from the independent
research agencies to government information arms, to the information sources provided by international
development agencies and associations. A few examples of external data sources are listed below.
International Marketing Research Firms AC Nielson Corporation, Cognizant Corp., The Cantar
Group Limited U.K., Information Resource Incorp U.S., GFK AG. Germany, The Arbitration Company
U.S., MRB-India etc.
International Agencies Data Management United Nations, OECD Trade Stastics, United Nations
Statistics Year Book, United Nations Monthly Bulletin of Statistics, International Monetary Fund, World Bank
Project Reports, Internatiobnal Banks and their Country Specific Project Reports.
Country Related Specific Data Management Embassies, high commissions and their trade
representatives, trade journals of high commissions, associations of trade and industries, directorates and
ministries of trade, commerce and exports.
Publications Publications on various industries by government sources and industry associations,
publications on taxations, fiscal levies, publications on economic developments, trade journals, national and
international newspapers’ archives, almanacs, statistical year books, encyclopaedias, industry chambers of
BIT BOOK WALA
commerce, trade association press bulletins, the Cambridge information group’s findex containing 90 industries
and 13,000 reports. The economic intelligence units, EIU country data in print and online, global market
information database can also be purchased online. It contains 330 product consumer studies in 49 countries.
Challenges to Management of Secondary Data A firm may not be able to get comprehensive
secondary data to meet all the necessary information. In fact, many published reports will have been written by
people who are simply compiling demographic and other details for commercial and economic profits. Their
presentation and cataloguing will require more work by the research team, which has to isolate and pinpoint the
required information from mountains of unnecessary data. This may lead to uncalled for expense and time for
sifting the exact information. The data collected presents the following shortcomings to the international
marketing researchers:
Availability It has already been discussed that all countries may not have the exact data readily available.
The systems adopted for data collection may not be scientific or logical across the board.
In the absence of government rules and regulations for registration of births and deaths in the developing
and underdeveloped countries, the population census itself may not be correct. It is often seen that in
countries like India, Pakistan, Bangladesh and many other African countries, the actual date of birth, etc., are
not known and that births are simply registered by approximate details given by elders. The census is
conducted every ten years, which, again, is too long a gap to get the true picture. The tendency to avoid sales
tax, excise and other local levies, also leads to the suppression of useful data. Unaccounted wealth does not
give the accurate picture of a country’s gross national product and gross domestic product. In India, the Right
to Information Act has been legislated only this year but in many other economies in underdeveloped
countries, no information is provided by the government agencies on the methods adopted, sample selection
and systems followed for processing of data.
www.bitbookwala.in
International Marketing: Research and Opportunity Analysis 79
Accuracy and Reliability The international market research team may not be in a position to reach
confident decisions unless it is sure of the accuracy of the data it has collected. The accuracy and the reliability
will depend upon the seriousness of the agency that had collected this secondary data in the first place.
Political exigencies, international aid considerations and to justify the availability of funds from the
government revenue sources many agencies tend to present either an exaggerated picture or a dismal situation,
depending on the circumstances. Poor economies will often exaggerate poverty and deprivation, whereas
developing economies may exaggerate their growth and the gross domestic product. Dictators and one-party
nations will inflate their success stories and growth rates. Even in democratic countries, the governments in
power will present a picture of better economy, better harvest, better industrial products and lower price
increase index, etc., if the elections are close at hand. The success of Indian five years plans started showing
results in the fag end of last decade. The literacy rates projected by many countries are quite unreliable. In fact,
the data collected directly by the government agencies and by the agencies funded by the governments should
be carefully examined, allowing for margins and space for wilful, deliberate manipulations and unintentional
errors.
Comparability of Secondary Data Each country may adopt different methodologies to collect and
tabulate data in the absence of any standardised global yardstick. The definition of standards of living may
vary from country to country. What could be an upper income group in India could become middle or lower
middle-income group in a developed country like United States. Again, a below-the-poverty line yardstick of
United States could actually become lower middle class in India. Hence, it is quite difficult to compare the data
collected by different countries. The nomenclature and the terminology may differ from country to country. The
A World Bank study undertaken to estimate the bilateral trade between India and
Pakistan indicated the potential at $1.85 billion per year. Some other researches are more
optimistic. The Indian Council for Research on International Economic Relations
(ICRIER) estimated $6.5 billion, while a State Bank of Pakistan study had worked out the
potential of trade at $5.2 billion. Informal estimates by the Karachi Chamber of Commerce
made in 2004 put the potential at $10 to 15 billion. The wide range in estimates partly
reflects the difference in estimating the unofficial trade.
Source: Business India, November 19 2006, Page 103, Great Opportunities
International marketing researchers will have to validate the data through the following check list:
1. What was the original problem/objective for which this data was collected?
2. What were the methods used/ yardsticks fixed for collecting and collating this data? Consistency of
methods.
3. Did this data form a part of the actual research conducted or is it merely based on survey reports to
support a decision already taken?
www.bitbookwala.in
80 International MarketingText and Cases
Primary Data International firms do not get into research so easily, unless they find enough secondary
data to reach conclusive evidence to the problem.
Primary data collection exercise is costly, time consuming and may not always prove cost beneficial. But,
whenever and wherever international firms get into direct marketing research, they have to collect primary data
for a specific project, to be analysed directly by the researcher team, which can then use the findings to address
the problem on hand. Thus, primary data pertains to “collecting information for first time for a specific project”.
Since such information is being collected for the first time, a cost benefit analysis must be undertaken
simultaneously and after the researcher is convinced of long-term benefits accruing to the firm, the approach to
be adopted for primary data collection can be finalised.
Primary Research Approaches An international marketing research firm may either use qualitative
research at the primary level or even a quantitative approach can be undertaken to gather data about the
research project. Survey research through a questionnaire sent by e-mail, personal interview, telephonic
interview or electronic surveillance is conducted by the firm to understand field data, for example analysing
BIT BOOK WALA
market shares, estimating sales potentials, finding impact of marketing and advertising strategies, etc.
Similarly, personal interviews with individuals and focus groups are the some tools that firms use to collect
primary qualitative information.
Some of the approaches adopted by international marketing researchers to collect primary data to undertake
research are discussed here.
Focus Groups Large-scale quantitative data involves getting into the research at the field level, spending
huge sums of money, time and effort. Many firms prefer to conduct exploratory research with select groups by
way of joint interviews, depth interviews and observational enquiry.
In the focus group interview method, the interviewer or the moderator conducts loosely structured free
flowing open discussion about the problem with a small group of 10 to 12 people.
Focus group interviews can bring forth opinions of the target audience on both qualitative as well as
quantitative objectives. Such groups can be forerunners for the later, quantitative and in-depth research to be
conducted on a larger scale. Such groups can also be exhorted to voice their thoughts, perceptions and
suggestions on product performances and future changes and expectations from the products under research,
etc.
The members of the group are recruited from predetermined sub-segments of the universe under research,
on the basis of the common characteristics decided by the researcher. These could be either from certain
geographic region, ethnic background, age factor, income congruity, social similarities, educational and
cultural bonding, or ownership of certain products and consumers of services, etc.
Electronic surveillance units can be placed in the adjoining room to observe the visible and not visible
behaviour patterns to draw conclusions.
Although the focus group research is undertaken in domestic market research too, the ability of the
moderator in the international and multi-country marketing research becomes crucial in organising and
www.bitbookwala.in
International Marketing: Research and Opportunity Analysis 81
handling group activity. Hence, well-trained moderators, who are familiar with the local language, cultural
sensitivity and social norms for addressing mixed groups of people are required. They must understand the
very fabric of social, cultural, affinity towards individualism, groupism or collectivism. Even the status
conscious behaviour of social groups can affect the response of a subject in a group activity and the moderator
must be in a position to elicit the true response from the audience and extract the correct meaning and results.
For example, being more outgoing and extrovert, people in the West can frankly express their pleasure or
displeasure on any issue without any reservations, whereas societies in the East are more conservative, which
prevents people from being so open and free. They will be quite hesitant to share their true thoughts. Similarly,
it is difficult in purdah-dominated societies of the Middle East, Pakistan, Malaysia and parts of China to obtain
any kind of response from the female population, unless the moderator happens to be a woman familiar with
their culture.
In-depth Interview Researchers organise personal, one on one, and private interviews with the sole
object of exploring and discovering consumer attitudes, motives, likes and dislikes more closely. Such an
interview is generally handled through unstructured questionnaires. To help the interviewee not feel any kind
of pressure or duress, the interview is generally held in a familiar atmosphere.
In-depth interviews present challenges similar to the one discussed in group interviews. Cultural habits of
shying away from strangers, unknown men not being allowed inside the house to meet women and holding
back true feelings pose greater challenges in this kind of research. In such a situation, the interviewer should
be from similar culture, preferably someone known to the family or, if a translator is involved, the translator
should also be from a similar culture, familiar with the norms observed in the social set up and milieu of the
interviewee.
BIT BOOK WALA
Field Survey Research As discussed, field survey research is conducted by contacting the respondent
through personal, telephonic, postal or e-mail questionnaires.
Such a survey is based on the assumption that the respondents are literate enough to understand the
questions posed and will respond. Sometimes such questionnaires or telephonic interviews are accompanied
by incentives in order to tempt the respondents to answer each question. Such methods can be used
extensively for larger surveys and can be taken across different frontiers, cultures and countries for effective
comparisons.
Designing a Questionnaire A questionnaire is the prerequisite to gather primary data whether in person,
by mail or over the telephone. However, it poses a big challenge to the international marketer to design a
questionnaire that could spell out the correct meaning of the question asked across different cultures,
countries and personalities and elicit the required response from people of multi-country origin. This survey
has to be compared with the response received from many parts of the globe. Hence, measurement issues need
to be addressed in the beginning itself. The market research team will have to predetermine the measurement
equivalence otherwise the results will not be rendered in the true meaning in which the answers to questions
were provided by the respondents.
Translating Questionnaire The questionnaire prepared by the market research team will be in the
language of the home country and will need to be translated to the language of the country in which survey is
being conducted. If it is a cross-country survey, further translation may be required into many other languages.
Even within the same country, the language and dialect may change like it does in India, where the dialect and
pronunciation change every 100 kilometres. Careful translation will save the researcher from many
embarrassments later.
www.bitbookwala.in
82 International MarketingText and Cases
Back Translation and Parallel Translation Back translation is a two-way method in which the
translator from the country other than the master questionnaire language will translate it into his language and
then, from the translated version, back into the original language. For example, an English version of the
document will be translated by a person who knows Hindi for research in India and then a person who is fluent
in English and Hindi will translate it back into English. This process is continued till the original version is
matched word to word, ironing out any lacunae in translation.
In the translation, many multi-lingual persons are used till the exact version is arrived at, which is then vetted
by experts for use in the field.
Ensuring Scalar Equivalence An international marketer must be aware of the approach different
cultures will take to the questions posed. A questionnaire designed to get simple, one-word answers will not
help to completely get to the actual response.
Similarly, when using scalar questions, a clear set of instructions needs to be appended to the questionnaire
to avoid any kind of confusion. The respondents may not to like to answer all the questions if they are asked
for their opinion on simple scale with opposite words like good, bad, worst or best. However, if a few more
details could be added to the questionnaire, explaining the real meaning of the question asked, it would become
easy for the respondent to respond correctly.
In a Likert scale questionnaire, a researcher will have to (draw out the comparative scales)
adjust the scale to make a cross-country research meaningful. The westerners while may
condemn or appreciate anything vociferously the Asians on the other hand tend to take
Again, in countries where literacy rates are still very low as compared to developed countries, the questions
should not be open-ended. Lenghty questionnaires should also be avoided. In fact, specially designed visual
scales, which can, for example, show happiness or displeasure, can be used.
A pretest of the questionniare, on a smaller scale, will help the researchers avoid pitfalls of blunders.
www.bitbookwala.in
International Marketing: Research and Opportunity Analysis 83
1. It is not important for me to know which brand of air conditioner I will purchase.
2. I often visit showrooms selling air conditioners.
3. I obtain knowledge about air conditioners from the print media.
4. I watch television advertisements to get information about air-conditioners.
5. Whenever any manufacturer offers schemes on air conditioners, I visit their
showrooms to get details..
6. Companies do not provide after-sales service.
7. After-sales service plays a big role in my selection of an air conditioner.
8. Companies can still give better discounts on air conditioners..
9. Gifts mean charging a higher price for air conditioners.
10. The gift attracted me to this air conditioner.
www.bitbookwala.in
84 International MarketingText and Cases
Challenges to Sampling Sampling presents similar challenges to the international market researcher
team when it takes to the field survey. The first challenge is the lack of basic data for approaching its universe.
A basic demographic data, containing lists of people and citizens of a country, residents of select towns,
updated telephone directory, address books and mailing lists are not available in a majority of underdeveloped
and yet to develop countries. Social, economical, cultural and financial data is not maintained in many countries
by the authorities. Excepting modern, developed towns, where streets and houses have well-defined numbers,
old towns in almost all countries, in South America, Pakistan, India or England, do not carry any city maps,
street or house numbers. Postal mails are sent by approximated addresses. However, such handicaps may not
be noticed in the emerging market of China, where cities are divided into administrative districts, administrative
streets and resident committees.
Lack of adequate and updated records of census, age break-ups, income divisions, earnings and
educational standards make sampling an extremely difficult task in these countries.
Lack of basic infrastructure, such as telephones, postal efficiency and transportation, make sampling a
daunting experience for the research team.
Even though the language used in two different countries may be the same, different meanings are attached
to social family units. While in eastern cultures of Pakistan and India, a family even today means a large unit,
consisting of a joint family, extended family and even a retinue of servants, a family in western countries like the
U.S. and many parts of Europe, a family will usually only consist of a wife, husband and children. Similarly, while
unmarried couples are relatively unknown in the eastern part of the world, such a union in many western
countries is a deemed legally valid family unit.
Thus, preparing a sampling plan in a multi-country research is a very tough and daunting task for any
BIT BOOK WALA
international research team and require flexibility in making adjustments as the local cultures, living habits and
the localised conditions demand in order to make the best out of the data and sample support available.
Contacting Respondents Once the sampling procedure has been finalised, the surveying team has to
decide on the vehicle required for contacting the respondents for the research. The respondents selected can
be contacted on telephone, through the postal service and in person and the survey can also be organised
through the Internet. However, all these methods can change from country to country and no single method
will suffice for all countries. Even within the boundaries of a single country, the survey team may have to utilise
multiple methods to make sure they reach the required quantity of sample universe to get authentic results.
Due to non-availability and inadequate infrastructure in rural and remote areas, telephonic contact is limited
in many countries. At the same time, local cultural habits in the use of telephone act as a restrictive force in
getting the survey completed. In many Muslim and conservative countries, telephone cannot be used during
the day because the ladies of the house may not attend to a call from a stranger. In modern towns like Delhi, New
York and Mumbai, again, the telephone may not be of much use during the day if both husband and wife go out
to work. Culturally too, many people do not open up on telephones to strangers. Germans refuse to give details
to a voice on the other side if they do not know the person fully. In China too, executives and managers are
reluctant to talk and discuss business matters on the telephone and prefer a face-to-face discussion.
Cost efficiency of the method and means deployed for data collection play a major part in international
marketing surveys. In underdeveloped and yet-to-develop countries, the lack of basic infrastructure, such as
transportation, communication, postal network and Internet, make many a proposal of survey prohibitively
expensive, urging the surveying to adopt shortcuts to complete the research. In countries like Bangladesh,
Nepal, parts of India, Russia, Pakistan, Brazil, Nigeria and many other small countries in Africa, mail never gets
delivered on time, making the survey redundant in such circumstances.
www.bitbookwala.in
International Marketing: Research and Opportunity Analysis 85
Contact through Internet Internet today is growing rapidly in almost all parts of the world. It is
available to almost 600 to 700 million users across 200 countries of the world, out of which two-third users are
situated in the United States.
In many emerging markets and economies like India and China, and also in developed countries like Japan,
Germany, France and other European countries, researchers have used the Internet to find out about the
opinion of unknown respondents by conducting opinion surveys, e-mail surveys and panel website surveys
In e-mail surveys E-mails are sent to unknown addresses with questionnaires, which are to be filled up by the
respondents and returned. The challenge here lies in exhorting the addressee to reply to the questionnaire
because, usually, millions of e-mails end-up as Spam and junk mails. In order to avoid this, the surveyor
generally attaches another incentive like the offer of an electronics game or a free CD, etc., to the questionnaire.
Website surveys These are undertaken when a website receives hits from unknown visitors. The site navigates
the hits to a questionnaire about their identification and also other relevant details required by the surveyor
and then lead to the survey page on the website. Only after answering the survey questions will the visitor be
allowed access to the information in the website.
Many surveyors approach the respondents through a pop-up, which appears as an advertisement
snapshot while the respondent is navigating through the website. However, some browsers can block these
pop-ups.
Panel website surveys are undertaken when the website has its own select group of people as a sample
universe, who have been recruited on the basis of an eligibility criteria fixed by either the website or by the
requirement given by the surveyor. Such members of the panel receive the questionnaires by e-mail. And, for
BIT BOOK WALA
each questionnaire that they respond to, the members get paid in kind or cash. Consumers’ survey panels have
been established all over the world.
Challenges to Internet Research Not all samples selected by the research team are connected to the
Internet and are, therefore, limiting in its very nature the qualitative representation of the universe. The survey
team will not have the first-hand knowledge of the sample members that the questionnaires are addressed to.
Again, the Internet penetration is still at its infancy in many developing and underdeveloped countries and,
with lack of databases in these countries, the research team has to take the help of regular mails to access the
identified respondents. Internet access and free availability of servers poses another hazard to such surveys.
Thus, to realise the full value of the amount spent, the research team has to rely on a multi-model approach
for reaching out to their universe and adopt the system and methods in a multi-mix for an ideal survey.
SECTION 5:
COLLECTING, ANALYSING AND INTERPRETING DATA
This is the final stage of international marketing research, as the teams, having understood the requirements
and necessary inter-culture adjustments of a multi-country research project, are now ready to gather the
primary data. It will though cost a lot of time, money and effort to the firm to undertake such a massive activity.
At this stage too, research teams will face and may have to overcome various hurdles, as getting answers
from first-time respondents and non-responsive respondents will take plenty of cajoling and inspirational
tricks on the surveyors’ part to get the necessary attention from people.
The recruitment and training of field surveyors is also a daunting task. The research team will have to ensure
that the field staff itself has understood the spirit of each question and keeps the answers free from personal
www.bitbookwala.in
86 International MarketingText and Cases
bias. It becomes all the more difficult if the field surveyors are not familiar with the local culture and language.
The necessary courtesy, as required and dictated by the local culture, will definitely get the surveyor access to
the inner circles and will help in completing the assignment.
The qualitative aspect of fieldwork should not be sacrificed for the sake of quantitative completion of
targets assigned to the field staff. A lowly paid field staff may not actually undertake the entire survey and will
get into short cuts to fill up the questionnaires. Such allowances will have to be looked into by the international
marketing manager before analysing the data collected.
A proper pre-recruitment background of having conducted such surveys, further training about the special
needs of the current project and adequate supervision of the field staff will keep the survey free from interview-
related bias and cultural misunderstandings.
Proactive and Interactive A computerised system will permit international researchers to remain in
touch with the head quarters and generate on-the-spot reports, without having to refer to their offices and
programmers each time. They can get even the software amended or altered without getting back to the parent
country, which leads to great saving in terms of time and revenue to the international marketing research
organisation.
Flexibility A computer will provide access to managers from not only the head quarters but even
managers from the other countries where similar projects are being conducted can access the network, work out
required averages, do data sorting, data simulation, data projections and data presentations, etc. .It will also
provide the necessary flexibility to arrange and store information in paperless offices, as otherwise the task of
preparing, storing, sorting and retrieving such huge information on primary and secondary data will
necessitate the hiring of complete secretarial services, which will further add to the cost of operations.
3. Refer William R Dillon , Thomas J. Madden , And Neil Firtle, Marketing Research In A Marketing Environment,
Irwin 1953
www.bitbookwala.in
International Marketing: Research and Opportunity Analysis 87
Research Orientations The system has to be equipped with software that can diagnose earlier trends,
pinpoint deviations from these trends, identify problems and give future analogies and projections.
SECTION 6:
ASSESSING INTERNATIONAL MARKET SIZE AND
SALES POTENTIAL
One of the basic tasks of international marketing research is to bring out the answer to the question: “Do we
have enough potential for our product or services to enter this country? Will there be enough space to play and
make the venture profitable and sustainable for a long-term plan of the firm?” Although fairly accurate details
of estimated market sizes for various products are available with the standardised internationals marketing
research firms and some government agencies of the developed countries, marketers have to understand the
market size by adopting different research methods and surveys because the data is either not available or, if
available, it has not been updated in terms of the latest logistics and statistics. In such circumstances, the
international marketing managers can employ the following procedures or approaches to guesstimate market
sizes and potentials.
Analogy Method This refers to the technique adopted by the research team to project estimated figures
for a market on the basis of the assumption that the behaviour, purchase patterns and purchasing capacities for
a particular product or service for people at similar levels of economic development and progress in two
different countries will eventually work out to be the same and, hence, the sales potentials should also be
BIT BOOK WALA
similar. The market researcher here establishes a relationship between the demand for a particular product by
standardising an indicator for both the economies and countries. For example:
• To estimate the expected adoption rate of motorcycles in India, it will be appropriate to understand and
identify the rate of new adopters in China, which is better developed and where the manufacturing of
two wheelers had passed through similar economic activities. Both economies have passed through
similar transitions from purely agriculture-based activities to urbanisation of middle-level towns and
cities and creation of new employment opportunities in these towns. This will be called country
performance analogy.
• Similarly the researcher can also undertake product development and production adoption analogies
for two different countries by assuming that, since the product development for one particular item is
similar in both countries, the ratio of adoption to related product will also be similar.
• For instance, if Videocon wants to estimate the market size for its DVD players in Sri Lanka, for the base
country the firm will pick up Bangladesh, where it has been marketing its products for many years. The
firm has a complete database available on its television as well as DVD sales in that country. The ratio
of DVD sales to the sales of televisions, it is assumed, will be similar in both the countries.
The demand for Videocon DVD players and the number of Videocon colour TVs in use in Sri Lanka = the
demand for Videocon DVD players and the number of Videocon colour TVs in use in Bangladesh. The demand
for DVDs can be estimated on the basis of the following equation relationship:
Demand for Videocon DVD players in Sri Lanka = Videocon colour TVs in Sri Lanka
(Videocon DVD demand in Bangladesh / Videocon colour TV in Bangladesh) By collecting figures from both
the countries, the company can work out the actual demand for their products in Sri Lanka.
www.bitbookwala.in
88 International MarketingText and Cases
Based on this ratio, an estimate can be arrived at for the DVD demand in Sri Lanka. Thus, estimating the
market potential on the basis of the analogy method refers to the use of a single factor index with a correlation
value collected from one country and applied to the other target country.
Continuity Extrapolation and Time Series Models Future market demand and behaviour are
predicted based on the basis of past projections, whereby it is assumed that future demand will be similar to
that of the past, barring the impact of more recent developments. This method is also known as Continuity
Extrapolation, which attempts to project the last increment of sales changes into the future. This is done either
on absolute value basis or on a percentage basis. This method recognises the fact that today’s sales activities
will flow into future activities and that last year’s sales have extended into this year’s sales.
The method assumes that the influence of the past affects the present and, similarly, the present will have an
impact on the future.
BIT BOOK WALA
For example, if the demand of midsize cars in Europe had grown by 10 percent last year, the application of
continuity extrapolation will assume the growth in demand by 10 percent again this year. Hence, the total
potential will read as 110 percent of last year’s demand, though the adjustment of negative or positive factors
may alter this. For example, if a competitor has established a new factory in Europe or a new car has been
introduced, which will add to the production, that addition will have to be taken into account. The demand
projection will now read as 110 percent + addition of the new car. This is, however, a self-limiting approach; it
does not take into account various factors that could affect the market and demand sentiments and direction of
change.
Time Series Analysis This theory is based on the assumption that, at the international level, each
business undergoes different cyclical patterns and trends. These trends could be long run changes (T),
cyclical changes (C), seasonal variations (S) and irregular and unexpected factors (I). The time series analysis
is based on the assumption that these elements are combined in the following relationship
Demand =T*C*S*I
The four basic elements are then projected. This is done by extrapolating the trends with adjustments for
cyclical and seasonal factors. The irregular factors are acknowledged but not forecast separately.
Most forms of time series analysis use a moving average or exponential smoothing to analyse and project
demand and it is best used for long run forecasts.
Econometric Models Use different deterministic factors of the economy that can directly or indirectly
have a bearing on the market demand. For example, to predict demand for beer in Netherlands, an international
www.bitbookwala.in
International Marketing: Research and Opportunity Analysis 89
firm had applied autoregressive moving average model4. The firm had used temperatures, price, consumer
expenditures, and company advertising expenditures as variables. However the firm’s analyses pointed out the
fact that an expense on advertising may not be able to predict the exact change in demand as each company will
be making investments on advertising and it is difficult to isolate the impact of one advertising budget in such
a crowded market.
Continuity extrapolation, time series and econometric models are possible when past data is readily
available, which is rare in most of the developing and underdeveloped countries. Hence, an international
marketer will have to make use of a combination of different qualitative as well as quantitative methods to reach
a conclusive decision. Some more methods available to international marketers are explained below.
Jury of Expert Opinion This is the simplest and oldest approach to demand forecasting. The basic
premise is to appoint a jury, panel or committee of experts on international business from the home country as
well as from the country/countries targeted for international marketing. Each member drawn from different
streams and countries is asked to submit an estimate of the projected demand, along with a written justification
of the assessment submitted. These assessments are then pooled and analysed at a group meeting. The
variation is synthesised through the collective judgment of these experts. Such a procedure for forecasting
international demand is simple to handle and does not cost organisation too much. The members of the jury
panel are aware of the handicaps and advantages of the firm in all countries under discussion; hence, they will
not put too many demands on the organisation. Their forecast will definitely keep limitations of their own
company in their minds.
Limitations of This Method The reliability of this kind of forecast is limited to the experience of the
BIT BOOK WALA
people involved in international marketing. Their mindset, their apprehensions and expectations will definitely
colour the sales or demand forecast. For example, ambitious executives may give the firm going international a
very aggressive plan, whereas a conservative executive will tend to undermine the market forces in other
countries. In fact, a combination of more than two or three methods will be required for a reliable forecast.
The Delphi Technique This is a modified version of the jury opinion developed by Rand Corporation.
Experts from the home country and from other countries, where research and potential assessment has been
going on, give their estimates and expert forecasts on market performance. These forecasts are compiled and
returned for second and third opinions, till a consensus on demand forecast is reached. Thus, this system
sieves and perfects the opinion of the jury members till every one agrees to the same level. The opinion of
groups as well as individual does matter in Delphi technique, but they do not exert undue influence in
modifying each other’s viewpoint.
Such frequent transferring of opinions and experts may involve large expenses. Even logistically, it is not
possible to collect experts from all the countries where a firm is operating at one place. Such a massive exercise
should be undertaken only when online facilities are available with all experts. Besides, executives who may be
busy handling other international assignments may not respond to the organisation’s calls for estimates and
this loss of time may negate the very purpose of such an exercise.
Sales Force Forecasts International salespersons know their territory best, more so if the sales force
is local staff based in the countries abroad where the firm has its operations. In such a situation, the field staff
will be familiar with the local cultural norms, festivals and main buying seasons and off seasons, etc. Besides,
4. Refer Philip Hans Franses, “Primary Demand for Beer in Netherlands: an Application of Aramex Model Specifi-
cation,” Journal of Marketing Research, May 28, 1991, Pp240–245.
www.bitbookwala.in
90 International MarketingText and Cases
they will also be well versed with the trade norms, trade channels, stock levels, purchase patterns and, finally,
their moods and priorities. Hence, the members of the sales team are the best judges to forecast the expected
sales. If they are expatriates, the firm can make best use of their judgments only after getting them trained in the
trade norms, culture and systems of the home country.
This demand forecast will also take into account the discussions and plans the force must have worked on
with their trade channels. The aggregate of the entire sales force’s forecast for different countries becomes the
combined demand forecast for the firm; in addition, the international marketing manager may apply finishing
touches to the plans submitted by the salespersons.
But the method is fraught with the following deficiency:
The salespersons may colour the forecast on account of their moods and highs and lows, that is if they are
elated with the performance of the recent past, their target setting is bound to be overaggressive. But, in case
they have not been doing well in the recent past, the international marketing manager may have to pull them out
of the depressive forecast they have submitted. As such, the salespersons may not understand the intricacies
of future events affecting their demand, which could prove faulty and costly for the firm.
The Actual Buyer Demand Industrial products, service products and products for which demand is
based on well defined derived systems, the buyer’s actual demand can be forecast through their potential
purchases. Industrial consumers will always have well defined and pre-planned demand for industrial
consumables, raw materials, and capital goods, as their production plans are set much in advance and they
keep their vendors well informed about any change or alteration expected in their production plans. The
international sales force should do well to remain in touch with their customer regularly to keep record of their
BIT BOOK WALA
past, current as well as future intentions. Such records will help the firm build up a forecast for their industrial
customers.5
Retails Stores Audit and Point of Sales Scan Projections: Many international research
companies in Europe, the U.S. and in some of the emerging markets, where shopping malls are growing by the
day, record sales and movement of goods data from the tapes and scanners attached to the billing counters.
Transactions for the day are recorded and analysed for each product. Information can be obtained on the
movement of goods, on consumer preferences for size, packing and for many other activities, for example
instant reaction at the point-of-purchase discount sale offers, schemes, point-of-purchase display
effectiveness. In addition, such scanners are also used to record details of the sales made throughout the week
to find out the shares of different brands and, thus, reach a conclusion on the market shares of different
companies. Such scanners are not allowed by many stores in order to maintain the privacy of their customers.
In such an event, companies like AC Nielsen, Gfk, and a few others have their own customer panels that are
issued identity cards, which they have to present when they make their purchases in designated stores, thus
enabling the store to record the data of select customers. More and more customers are encouraged to become
members of such panels by offering them discounts and points accumulation, etc., which are later redeemed
against their future purchases.
Home scanners are adapted to record the day’s shopping by a selected panel of customers at their own
homes, on the scanners provided by the research firms. Japanese customers are more inclined to swap their
purchases against the scanners provided at their homes as they tend to shop all over the town and do not
remain restricted to the designated stores. In addition, Japanese stores and shopping malls are reluctant to
allow outside firms to set up any information collecting tools in their super markets.
5. Ramneek Kapoor, Fundamentals Of Sales Management, Macmillan India ltd., Pp. 236-237.
www.bitbookwala.in
International Marketing: Research and Opportunity Analysis 91
Besides, many other electronic and communication devices, such as home scanners, TV viewing people
meters and short message services, getting the information attached to the products posted back on the
website of the firm, are examples by which the marketing research firms collect data about customers and
products for forecasting future product positioning, business strategies, plans and sales forecasts.
The international marketing research is undertaken by research teams to identify opportunities in the market
place, point out the shortcomings or the scope for improvement in the current product, price, or promotional
tools adopted by the firms and their competitors and eventually help the personnel involved in the system to
achieve the objectives set up by the corporate team.
SECTION 7:
MANAGING INTERNATIONAL MARKETING RESEARCH GLOBALLY
One of the key tasks of an internationally operative firm that is involved in marketing research is to determine
how to control its research operations in order to obtain the desired results from the efforts, time and money
spent. The firm will have to answer the following three essential questions to reach a decision:
1. Who should conduct market research?
2. Can such a massive research operation be conducted with the in-house staff and resources alone or
will an international agency be necessary?
3. How should the global marketing research operations be co-ordinated so that interests of all groups,
i.e. the home country management, the host country requirements and the subsidiary plans are met
Selecting an International Research Agency International firms may have their own senior
executive heading their research department but they will still prefer employing local host country agencies to
help them in their multi-nation operations. This also will ensure an efficient and well-informed system of
marketing research as the field personnel, local management staff and the trade personnel are better informed
than the managers from the head quarters. The establishment required for conducting research of such a
massive size will otherwise mean recruiting permanent staff in each country, which many organisations can ill-
afford. Besides the labour laws, etc., make it quite cumbersome to have a temporary staff on the firm’s roll in
each country and disband them after the research is over.
The selection of the research agency may be left to the discretion of local management or subsidiary, but
since the research project involves more than one country, it is generally decided by the headquarters in
discussion with the local management of the country.
The local agency will only be in a position to take care of local coordination of the research project with other
entities, such as government agencies for permissions, etc., as in many countries there has been an increasing
control on consumer privacy. Laws are being passed in many countries, protecting consumers from unsolicited
calls and e-mails. The Supreme Court in India has passed orders banning unsolicited short services messages
and calls on mobile phones of common people. There has been some government action recently in China too
against marketing research agencies, those who violated rules.
Local agencies will also be helpful in obtaining and tapping multiple sources for secondary data, if required.
Besides, the research by outside agents will ensure no personal bias and self-reference criterion are allowed
to interpret and implement the findings. The comparison between the findings of an outside agency and that of
www.bitbookwala.in
92 International Marketing–Text and Cases
the firm’s employees will always ultimately tell the firm’s research department whether it is moving in the right
direction.
Besides, these local agencies will be familiar with the language, nuances, cultural equivalences and cultural
norms of maintenance etc., which will means spending less time and money on retraining personnel for
conducting research. The firm, however, will have to establish a comprehensive screening and selection
procedure to ensure that the research agency is in a position to deliver the required services.
The local offices of the firm, the regional authority and the director of research at the head quarters will have
to pay personal attention to day-to-day coordination between different agencies.
The head quarters will have to establish time, procedure, reporting relationship and hierarchy within the
organisation and outside. The budget for research will have taken care of the agency’s professional fee and, as
such, the cost factor at this stage should not become a constraint unless the agency charges are way beyond
the earlier appropriations. The following is a proposed route chart that an international firm can adopt for
reaching the ultimate consumer, for whom the entire effort of research is being directed:
The multiple options research route chart above offers a multiple options to the international firm whose
managers will have to pick one option. The distance between the firm’s head quarters and the research project
country has some role to play in this. In case the two countries are close and the firm can manage cultural
barriers and the language parlance, the shortest route of option A seems to be the best possibility. In the event
of completely unknown territories, the firm will find it better to follow either route C or D, to ensure that the
language, translation, retranslation and the cultural nuances are not only presented in the right spirit to the
consumer but the analyses is also carried out by the researchers in the correct spirit and findings presented to
the decision makers correctly.
REFERENCES
1. David Ricks, Big Business Blunders, Dow Jones 1983.
2. Alecia Sway, Soap Opera. The inside story of Proctor and Gamble, Times Books 1993.
3. Stefan Theil, “Cultural Confusion, the Week, October 16, 2006, Pp.42-43.
www.bitbookwala.in
International Marketing: Research and Opportunity Analysis 93
4. Kim Thy Balin, “Du Pont Lycra Goes Global” Sporting Goods Business, March 28, 1999
vol. 32 no.5 p 16.
5. Helen Johnstone, ‘Little Emperors Call the Shots’, Asian Business, September 1996, vol.
32, No. 9, pp 67-68.
6. Alecia Sway, Soap Opera, the inside story of Proctor and Gamble. New York, Random
House 1993 p 268.
7. Business India November 19 2006, Page 103, Great Opportunities.
8. C.K. Corder, “Problems and Pitfalls in Conducting Marketing Research in Africa” Betsy
Gelb Ed., Marketing Expansion in a Shrinking World, Proceedings of American Marketing
Association Business. Conference, Chicago AMA, 1978 pp 86-89.
9. William R Dillon, Thomas J Madden, and Neil Firtle, Marketing Research in A Marketing
Environment, Irwin 1953.
10. Philip Hans Franses, “Primary Demand for Beer In Netherlands: An Application Of
Aramex Model Specification,” Journal of Marketing Research, May 28, 1991, pp 240-245.
11. Ramneek Kapoor, “Fundamentals of Sales Management, Macmillan India Ltd, pp 236-237.
12. International Marketing, Cateora Graham, Cultural Barriers Page 234 Publisher Tata
McGraw-Hill.
WEBSITES VISITED
BIT BOOK WALA
1. http://www.newsweekinternational.com
2. www.stat-usa-gov
3. www.economist.com
4. Www. wsj.com
www.bitbookwala.in
94 International MarketingText and Cases
5. Kapoor Ramneek, Planning For Future, Sales Forecast, “Fundamentals of Sales Manage-
ment”, Macmillan India Ltd, Pp 230-238.
6. Mullen Michael R., “Diagnosing Measurement Equivalence In Cross National Research”,
Journal of International Business Studies, 26, Third Qr. 1995, Pp. 573-596.
7. Stanat, Ruth, “Tracking Your Global Competition”, Competitive Intelligence Review,
Spring 1991, Pp.3-5.
8. Sharer, Kevin, “Top Management’s Intelligence Needs, An Executives View of Competi-
tive Intelligence”, Competitive Intelligence Review, Spring 1991, Pp. 3-5.
9. Steenkamp, Jan Benedict E.M., “Assessing Measurement Invariance In Cross National
Consumer Research”, Journal of Consumer Research, 25, No. 1 1998 Pp. 78-91.
10. Cateora Graham, “International Marketing”, Cultural Barriers, pp. 234, Tata McGraw-
Hill.
1. Which of the following are the major objectives of international marketing research?
(a) Products. (b) Pricing.
(c) Distribution. (d) Promotion.
(e) All of these.
BIT BOOK WALA
2. Which one of the following is not a kind of international marketing related research format?
(a) Exploratory Research. (b) Descriptive Research.
(c) Causative Research. (d) Clinical Research.
3. Point the odd one out in the statement “Secondary data is a data that has been collected by“
(a) Some one else for similar or dissimilar situation.
(b) By research agencies for problem at earlier times.
(c) For the firm for current problem at hand.
(d) Government agencies for publication.
(e) Databanks.
4. Which of the following will not form part of primary research data?
(a) Focus Groups. (b) In Depth Interview.
(c) Field Survey Research. (d) Questionnaire.
(e) Prepublished demographic data.
5. The two basic sampling procedures adopted by the researchers generally are known as
(a) Probability sampling and non-probability sampling.
(b) Exploratory sampling. (c) Convenience.
(d) Judgment sampling. (e) Deliberate sampling.
6. In which system of assessing International Market Size and Sales Potentials, International re-
search companies in Europe and U.S. record sales and movement of goods data from the tapes
and scanners attached to the billing counters?
(a) Retail Stores Audit and Point of Sales Scan Projections.
www.bitbookwala.in
International Marketing: Research and Opportunity Analysis 95
REVIEW QUESTIONS
1. Define international marketing research. What are the major objectives of international
marketing research?
2. Define secondary data. How will you validate secondary research data?
3. Outline the basic steps of international marketing research process for an international
project.
www.bitbookwala.in
96 International MarketingText and Cases
4. What do you understand by the term questionnaire? What constraints will you come
across while preparing a questionnaire for multi-country research?
5. Define back translation and parallel translation with the help of examples.
6. Explain sampling in international marketing research.
7. What do you understand by the term scalar equivalence? Explain with the help of ex-
amples from international marketing research process.
8. What is international sales forecast? Explain any two methods that an international firm
can employ to forecast sales.
www.bitbookwala.in
Chapter 6
Learning Objectives
The reader should be able to understand and explain
• what culture is and explain how it affects the international marketing environ-
ment around the globe
• the elements that form the culture of any society
• what cultural adaptation is and how the international marketer effects a cultural
adaptation
• what globalisation of cultures is and how an international marketer can bring
about a change in his strategies to suit the global culture
• the role religion plays in formation of culture and how it affects international
marketing
• cultural variance in terms of different value norms and dimensions and how a
marketer will adapt to these variations.
www.bitbookwala.in
98 International Marketing–Text and Cases
Mr. Vijayratne, a Sri Lankan Businessman, had his first opportunity to visit Russia as a
representative of a trade delegation. He was there to seek some technical assistance in
the area of agricultural labor management. “Russians are a very polite people,” he had
been tutored before his arrival. One of interpreters explained that a gentleman will pour
the limonad (type of juice) for the ladies and show other courtesies.
Toward the end of his three-week trip he was invited by his young Russian host and
friend and his lovely wife out to dinner. At the end of a wonderful meal the lady asked if
he would like a banana. He politely declined and thanked her, and explained he was most
satisfied with the meal. But the whole while his mind was racing: “What do I do? Do I offer
her a banana even though they are as close to her as they are to me? What is the polite
thing to do?”
“Would you like a banana?” he asked the house lady.
“Yes,” she smiled, but made no attempt to take any of the three bananas in the fruit
basket.
“What now?” he thought.
“Which one would you like?” he fumbled.
“That one,” she pointed at one of the bananas. So all the while thinking about Russian
politeness he picked the banana, lady had pointed at and peeled it half way and handed
BIT BOOK WALA
it to her. Smiles in his hosts’ faces told him he had done the right thing. After this
experience he spent much time letting the world know that in Russia, the polite thing is
to peel the bananas for the ladies. Sometime during his third trip, he was politely
disabused of his notion.
“Oh no, Vijayratne,” a Russian graciously corrected him. “In Russia, when a man peels
a banana for a lady it means he has a romantic interest in her.” How embarrassed he felt.
And he had been proudly telling everyone about this tidbit of cultural understanding.
SECTION 1:
INTRODUCTION
T he world economy is in the middle of globalisation. For last one decade or so, each country has been
opening its doors and welcoming foreign multinationals and corporate organisations from developed
countries and emerging economies to set up bases. At the same time, they want manufacturing and trading
corporations and business firms from their own countries to move out and spread around the world, whether it
is through mega mergers, franchising, setting their own subsidiaries or just about getting a foothold through
trading itself. China’s Huanei (through telecommunications equipments), American Wal-Mart (through mega
malls), India’s Tata Sons (through tea and steel) and India’s Infosys (through IT and business outsourcing) are
entering hitherto unknown markets of the countries around the world. Russian steel giant Evraz bought over
Oregon Steel Mills in the United States. The largest nickel producer from Russia wants to buy the nickel
division of OM group of Cleveland Ohio.
www.bitbookwala.in
Cultural Factors and Environment 99
Similarly, the Japanese are also not far behind in making their forays into India, Vietnam and many other parts
of the world. This kind of internationalisation had been the mainstay of GE, PEPSI, COCA COLA, IBM,
PROCTOR AND GAMBLE, KFC, MICROSOFT and a host of other multinationals from Japan, such as
PANASONIC, SUZUKI, HONDA, etc.
Besides skill and management techniques, these companies will require cultural sensitivity towards the
countries they are entering, in order to build their brands and gain acceptance in these countries. If ignored,
cultural sensitivity can result in the kind of disaster that Proctor and Gamble faced when the company first
ventured out into the Japanese market in 1973. The Japanese consumers had been bombarded with American
products, American way of selling, American way of managing and American strategies by P&G with scant
regard to local needs, local culture, local social norms and local living habits, This resulted that Proctor and
Gamble suffered huge losses till 1987, until it eventually understood the local culture and started playing the
marketing game the same way as Japanese do. Japan soon became the second largest foreign market for
P&G.
In the same way, P&G’s success in China can be attributed to the fact that the expatriate Chinese in U.S. are
not different from their counterparts back home. P&G was able to understand the Chinese culture from the mini
China towns established in United States. These firms gain knowledge about the different cultural values of
each country they are getting into, understand the importance attached to smaller nuances and then work out
their finer marketing strategies to succeed.
This chapter discusses how culture, thus, plays a large and very important role in marketing. In trying to
understand the needs of consumers from different countries, international marketers will have to study
consumers not only through their geographical and historical background but also through their cultural
BIT BOOK WALA
background, to understand what is acceptable in their environment. They will have to understand what
colours, symbols, letters, language, signs, photographs, scenes, backgrounds, religious norms and social
customs will be acceptable to these international clients because in international markets no two cultures from
two adjoining and adjacent countries could be similar. In countries like India, where dialect and dress codes
change from one state to another, a marketer may have to understand the fabric of cultures within a culture to
get a better understanding.
In this chapter, we will try to understand what culture is, what makes culture and focus on different cultural
influences that are exerted on consumer behaviour and on a marketing firm’s international ambitions. We will
study how strong individual characters are formed due to cultural impacts in different nations and as marketers.
How strategies can be altered to address these cultural differences.
SECTION 2:
DEFINING CULTURE
Culture is the way people lead their lives. Just as fish cannot live without water, a man without culture will feel
suffocated. It is the environment in which human beings breathe familiar smells from their childhood, listen to
old lullabies from their grandparents and sing the same songs when they put their own children to sleep.
Culture pervades a man’s life when he adopts a familiar way of eating his daily bread. Indians eat their food with
their hands and some of them may lick their fingers too, whereas Chinese use chopsticks to eat noodles. An
Englishman, on the other hand, may scoff at the idea of using hands for putting morsels into his mouth. He may
not relish his food until a fork and knife are given to him. All this forms a part of culture, which pervades all forms
of living standards. It can be seen in the dress codes of each society. If a kimono is a Japanese lady’s gown, a
sari an Indian lady’s preferred dress and a skirt for an English lady, it could be blasphemous to expect all such
www.bitbookwala.in
100 International MarketingText and Cases
dresses worn openly in a society where burkha is prevalent and the lady has to cover herself from head to toe
in the presence of strangers. Culture influences the saving and spending patterns of a society. For example, in
spite of low returns, in Japan though savings abound in post offices (9 percent) and banks (2 percent in
nationalised banks). Investment in stocks is not considered a viable or better return alternative. In the United
States, however, more than half the population owns stocks. The work culture too differs from country to
country. A U.S. resident, despite a five-day week, would love to get additional rest days and holidays and the
opportunity to go on a pleasure trip abroad. The Japanese, on the other hand, may have to be lured away from
their work place by offers of incentives to take a break. Such is their addiction to wok or love for duty.
1. Geert Hofstede, Culture’s Consequences, 2nd edition, Thousand Oaks, CA Sage 2001.
2. Greet Hofstede, “Culture consequences comparing values, behavior, institutions, and organizations across the
nations” 2nd edition, Sage Publications CA2000.
3. Melvin Herksokvitz, Man and His Works p 634.
www.bitbookwala.in
Cultural Factors and Environment 101
SECTION 3:
CORRELATES OF CULTURE
The main constituents of culture that make each culture identifiable and separately distinct are as under:
1. Ecology or Geography This means the way a individual accepts the process of ecological factors
in a society, the flora and fauna, wildlife, climate, temperatures, topography, natural resources, rivers,
mountains, plains, minerals and other such gifts of God. Such preservation of resources, their utilisation and
development for human needs and their protection, and for all species on the earth, speak of the culture of that
society. How these geographical or ecological factors are distributed amongst the haves and have-nots,
amongst the developed and the yet-to-develop is the very thread of culture.
Ecology also affects the history, economy of nations, and the consumer behaviour. Like professor Phillip
Parker reports, “geography has deep influence on history, economics, and consumer behavior”; he further
adds “strong correlation exists between the climate and the per capita gross domestic product of countries”.4
2. Heritage Historical facts have a very strong impact on technological developments, social institutes,
cultural fabric, social norms, attitude towards new innovations and acceptance of the times in which these were
developed. History speaks of the impact of architecture on Indian buildings and on the construction industry.
The industrial revolution of the 18th century affected the social fabrics of Great Britain. the historical wars,
fought with the invaders, the Mughals and British rulers of India have all been reflected in the heritage of
society and the cultural values that the society has imbibed from these invaders who settled down in the
country. Again heritage can be seen in the literature of ancient times, which have influenced the cultural
BIT BOOK WALA
evolution of societies across the world. In Asia, Buddhism preached the ideal of tolerance and peace, shaping
peace loving individuals. The message of renunciation by the great thinkers encourages people to live a
content life and not simply chase symbols of material success. In the USA, on the other hand, the American
Declaration of Independence brought out a sense of individual freedom, where the welfare of individual scores
over the concern for the nation as a whole. History becomes evident in China, where despite the growing
consumerism, the communism in thought and policy making of the rulers prevails even after many years of
Mao’s departure. Heritage and inheritance, thus, affect every culture, be it the German pride of being a superior
and stronger nation or the Mongolian influence of being a nation of warriors and survivors in many other
central Asian cultures.
3. Social Fabric The social fabric includes religion, family, institutes of education, the social
organisations, the thinking of philosophers, the ruling elite and the ruled multitudes. The social fabric of a
culture speaks of interpersonal and intra-personal relationships the society members maintain with each other.
Casteism, love of family, love of neighbourhood, tolerance of strangers, accommodation of others by selfless
behaviour, love for one’s own religion, and respect for other faiths and beliefs is what constitutes a society’s
behaviour. These behaviour patterns run from generation to generation.
In societies where close-knit social institutes like family, clan and tribe still exist, it becomes easy for
international marketers to plan and direct advertising efforts on joint promotions. In the eastern cultures, family
values are derived from small group norms, which are extended to the enlarged family of the locality, or
immediate neighbourhood, to the entire village. In India every unmarried girl or boy from the same village is
treated like the members of one single family, assuming a filial relationship amongst them. A family in the West
www.bitbookwala.in
102 International MarketingText and Cases
would mean the immediate family only. It does not extend beyond the relationship through blood. Dating
someone in the neighbourhood is quite common there.
Casteism is quite evident in marital relationships. Honour killings exist in Pakistan, where a girl can be killed
for marrying into a rival tribe. Similarly, in India, when the nation has attained a literacy rate of 64 percent, inter-
caste marriages are not accepted in many parts of the country. Some kind of a caste system prevails even in
professional life, where a higher caste will not take up the professions that are associated with lower castes.
The West, on the other hand, has evolved into a caste-less society, without any bias, where only the culture of
work prevails. An international marketer has to be fully aware of all such differences in a society.
Ideals of culture are governed by religious and social associations, for instance by preachers and politicians
(through governance) and by the media and business organisations.
SECTION 4:
ELEMENTS OF CULTURE
The definition of culture states it as the sum total of values, rituals, symbols, beliefs and thought processes.
Whether international or domestic, marketers have to be aware of, and make special use of the knowledge of
these elements while designing their products, selling strategies, channel management, and advertising and
sales promotion campaigns.
Cultural Values
In a society, values sustain the behaviour of individuals as well as groups. Values are learned and unlearned
BIT BOOK WALA
from personal, social and cultural interactions and experiences. These value have been defined as “enduring
beliefs about a specific mode of conduct or desirable end state; they guide the selection or evaluation of
behavior, are ordered by the importance in relation to one another to form a system of value priorities”.5
Individuals imbibe values from the culture they belong to, i.e. the family unit, the immediate neighbourhood,
teachers, religious practitioners and politicians. In modern times, values are also imbibed from the media. The
print media, television and films play a large part in influencing the minds of individuals. For instance, the best
way for a first-time visitor to learn about the American way of life would be to read about the American culture
in books and magazines and through films and television. This is where the acculturation of an individual
begins. It is not the unlearning of one’s own values but the assimilation of American ones, which one can
gather by interaction and adaptation. For example, an Indian may grow up in a joint family and learn that one
must take care of one’s parents when they grow old. An American, on the other hand, may learn that personal
success, personal freedom and personal achievement are more important in life. Average Americans start
working in their teens and move out of their parental home quite early in life. In Pakistan and India, however, it
is acceptable for children to stay at home for their entire lives.
Strategies for Dealing with Cultural Differences Once an organisation dealing in multi-
country locations has identified differences in cultural values, it must understand fully what steps its
executives should adopt and what steps can prove detrimental to business. All such possibilities will be taken
up for discussion here.
5. Milton J. Rokeach, The Nature of Human Values, The Free Press 1973 and Jan Benedict E. M. Steenkamp, Frankel
Ter Hofstede and Michael Wedel, a Cross Cultural Investigation into the Individual, and National Cultural Anteced-
ents of Consumer Innovativeness, Journal of Consumer Research, April 1999, Vol. 63, Pp 55-69.
www.bitbookwala.in
Cultural Factors and Environment 103
Each culture has its own set of acceptable and unacceptable individual as well as social behavioural norms.
These are the set of rules that dictate what is morally, ethically and socially correct for that particular society.
The same set of rules may not be applicable to outsiders. When entering a new foreign country, or even when
devising a strategy in its current country of operation, marketers must understand these dos and don’ts.
In fact, host cultures always do not expect foreigners to adjust to them. International
companies have sometimes succeeded in introducing new products, technologies and
operating procedures to foreign countries with little adjustment. That’s because some of
these introductions have not run counter to deep-seated attitudes or because the host
society is willing to accept foreign custom as a trade-off for other advantages. For
example, Bahrain has permitted sale of pork products (otherwise outlawed by religious
law) as long as they are sold in separate rooms of grocery stores, where Muslims can
neither work nor shop. Often, local society looks on foreigners and its own citizen
differently. For example, Western female flight attendants are permitted to wear jeans and
T-shirt in public when they stay overnight in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia, even though the local
women cannot. Similarly, Western female managers in Hong Kong say local people see
them primarily as foreigners, not as women.
These set of do’s and don’ts are also referred to as cultural imperatives, cultural exclusives and cultural
adiophora, which marketers must adhere to, to ensure their survival and continuance in multi-country markets.6
BIT BOOK WALA
These expectations may not be handed over by any culture in a set of instructions but a shrewd and capable
international marketing manager will keep on updating and adapting to such behavioural norms while
interacting with the locals abroad. This process is known as acculturation, where one acquires the norms,
rituals and ethics of foreign culture while working abroad.
Imperatives These are the set of norms that ensure that business is conducted in the same way that
locals do. For example, giving due regard and respect to seniors and elderly is a way of life in India, and it is
expected that business partners, even from abroad, will also follow similar norms. People address each other in
formal relationships by affixing respectable words either before or after the name, but in America every one can
be addressed by their first names. Again, while introducing oneself on a business call, one may attach one’s
surname with the first name. For an American, however, the first name suffices. In many European countries,
while conducting business, people will address each other by their last names. The obedience and adherence
to government authority, rules and regulations are acceptable norms in any society, but more so in eastern
cultures where even petty officials expect to be treated as the seal of authority of the government. And, it is in
the interest of businesspersons to know such petty officials because, otherwise, they can create problems for
the smooth flow of business. Such a situation may not prevail in the West.
Again, imperatives can be seen in the way a society treats its women, whose status in each country differs.
In certain societies, such as those of China, Nepal and Bhutan, women may be at the forefront of business
negotiations. In some Muslim dominated areas of the world, the segregation of women from males is a way of
life. In many countries, women conduct business with their bodies, faces and heads covered behind a veil.
They may not accompany their business clients for lunch or dinner and may not invite or accept invitations to
social get-togethers unless a member of their family is accompanying them.
www.bitbookwala.in
104 International MarketingText and Cases
Cultural Exclusives Refer to activities that only locals may perform and which foreigners are not
expected to follow. Touching the feet of elders and seeking their blessings is a common practice in India but a
foreigner is hardly expected to follow the custom. Similarly, devout Muslims will offer prayers five times a day,
even at their place of work, just as devout Hindus will worship their deities before beginning the day’s work.
This may seem strange to a foreigner who may be more used to praying in private or in a church.
Cultural Adiophora These are the local customs that, whether they’re followed by foreigners or not, do
not affect the business relationship. Eating with hands and greeting each other with folded hands are a couple
of examples of adiophora. In case a foreigner were to eat with his or her hands, it may not raise eyebrows and
will be accepted as normal gesture.
SECTION 5:
THE NATION AS A CULTURE
The nation provides a workable definition of a culture for international marketing, where similarity among
people is both a cause and an effect of national boundaries. It is an acceptable fact, however, that within the
borders of a nation, dissimilarities can prevail. National identity is perpetuated through the rites and symbols
of a country and a common perception of history results from the preservation of national sites and documents,
etc. These shared attributes do not mean that everyone in a country is alike. Nor do they suggest that each
country is unique in all respects. In fact, nations usually include various subcultures, ethnic groups, races and
classes, some of which transcend national boundaries. Therefore, managers find country-by-country analysis
difficult because no two citizens of a country are alike. On the contrary, there are too many variations in some
BIT BOOK WALA
countries even though a nation is a legal and constitutional unit, serving different interests of various
demographic and geographical entities. All these entities, when put under the marked geographical and
constitutional boundaries, give a nation its identity. By identifying these similarities or dissimilarities within
different nations, an international marketing firm has to conduct its business by aligning itself as per the
requirements of each nation.
However, a nation legitimises itself by being a mediator of the different interests. Each nation possesses
certain human, demographic and behavioural characteristics that constitute its national identity and that may
affect a company’s methods of conducting business effectively in that country.
The concept of a nation is much broader and bigger than the concept of a state. States have artificial
boundaries but the concept of a nation extends beyond the physical demarcation of a country. This is the
reason for the unification of Germany, wherein the nation concept lead to the breaking up of the man-made state
boundaries.
This section will discuss some of the attitudes and values that affect business behaviour amongst nations,
and which can tell a marketer what products to sell, how to organise finance, staff and then manage and control
operations. Just as the researchers define cultural variables differently, attaching different names to slightly
varying and sometimes overlapping attitudes and values, there are numerous ways of relating marketing to
culture. Some of these are presented below:
Social Systems
Every culture values some people more than it does others, and such distinctions dictate a person’s class or
status within that culture. In business parlance, this might mean valuing members of managerial groups more
highly than members of production groups. The social stratification varies from country to country, and a
www.bitbookwala.in
Cultural Factors and Environment 105
person’s ranking is partly determined by individual factors and partly by the affiliation to the given groups.
These affiliations could be ascribed group memberships, i.e. determined by birth (like those based on gender,
family, age, caste and ethnic, racial or national origin) or the acquired group memberships, which are the
affiliations not determined by birth (those based on religion, political affiliation and professional and other
associations). In eastern countries, a marketer may find that such stratification is quite prominently exhibited in
almost all segments, be it caste, gender, political affiliations or even religious beliefs and faiths. In fact, within
the same religion, affiliations may vary from being a sanatani Hindu, an Arya Samajist to a Jain Hindu in India.
Even in the West, Protestants and Catholics are examples of stratification.
These stratifications affect the buying and living habits of people. These social stratifications affect the
business relationships within that country. Some characteristics and group memberships that influence a
person’s ranking within the country of origin are listed as follows:
Caste versus Performance Orientation People in the U.S. value performance so highly that the
legislative and judicial actions aim to prevent discrimination on the basis of sex, age and religion, even though
such legislation is not fully effective. Whichever factor has primary importance, seniority or humaneness, will
influence a person’s eligibility for certain positions and compensation. That may not be true for all nations. In
many countries, ethnic groups and religious preferences exist – in India, for instance, the caste factor can
influence the determination of employment or even education opportunities for different caste groups within
the same culture groups. Malaysia had employment quotas for three ethnic groups – Malays, Chinese and
Indians - so as to protect the employment opportunities for Malays.
Within the ambit of performance orientation, the orientations towards the time management, the value of
Gender Orientation Difference in attitude towards males and females. In China and India, there is a
strong preference for males due to two factors – government and economic restrictions on family size and
desire to have a son to perpetuate the family name, respectively. The result is the practice of aborting female
foetuses and killing of female babies. Even in countries in which women constitute a large proportion of the
working population, differentiation still exists in the type of jobs that are regarded as male-only positions and
the ones that are regarded as female-only positions. For example, in the US, women fill a higher percentage of
administrative and managerial positions than in Japan. The fact is that in all the countries where the prime
source of employment is agriculture, people prefer a male progeny for fear that the inheritance of land will move
away from the family the moment a girl child is married into another family.
Age-based Groups Many cultures assume that age and wisdom are correlated. In the US market,
however, after the 1980s, it is believed that youth has a professional advantage and this has resulted into poor
employment rates for TV script writers beyond the age of 30. Even in India, currently call centres and business
www.bitbookwala.in
106 International MarketingText and Cases
process outsourcing companies are going for young people. The international marketing manager will have to
be aware of the age factor.
Family-based Groups In some societies, the family is the most important group membership. In
societies where there is low trust outside the family, such as in China and southern Italy, small family-run
businesses are more successful than large business organisations. As large scale operations are often
necessary for many products, the difficulty of expanding the family-run businesses retards the development of
these companies.
Occupation The perception of what jobs are the ‘best’ varies somewhat among different countries. This
perception usually determines the number and the qualification of people who will seek employment in a given
occupation. For example, university professors are more influential as opinion leaders in Korea and Japan than
in the US and UK. Another important difference is that citizens in some countries, like Belgium and France,
desire to work as entrepreneurs rather than for an organisation. In the US, transient occupations such as baby
sitting, delivering newspapers and delivering groceries are jobs that go to teenagers, whereas in poor countries
the same are filled by adults.
Materialism and Leisure Max Weber observed that the predominantly Protestant countries were the
most economically developed and he attributed this to an attitude that he labelled as “the Protestant ethic”.
Adhering to this view, people preferred to transform productivity into material gains than into leisure time.
Some societies take less leisure time than others, which means they work longer hours, take fewer days for
holidays and vacations and spend less time and money on leisure. As an example, the Japanese take less leisure
BIT BOOK WALA
time than people in other wealthy countries like the US and across Europe. However, most people today
consider personal economic achievement to be important, regardless of whether they live in wealthy or poor
countries.
Expectation of Success and Reward Another factor that differentiates a person’s behaviour
towards working is the perceived likelihood of success and reward. Compared with the penalties of failure,
people usually work harder at any task when the reward for success is higher. In the Western culture, the
emphasis is on immediate rewards and the commercialisation of every activity is too rampant, whereas in
Eastern societies, many times, the work one takes up does not necessarily take into account commercial
expectations or instant results.
Assertiveness The average interest in the career success varies substantially among different
countries. According to a study that compared the attitudes of employees from 50 countries, employees with
high masculinity score were those who admired successful achievers, had little sympathy for the unfortunate,
and preferred to be the best rather than at par with others. They had a money-and–things orientation than a
people orientation, a belief that it is better ‘to live to work’ than ‘to work to live’ and a preference for
performance and growth over quality of life and environment. Similarly, countries differ in the degree that the
individuals are assertive, confrontational, and aggressive in their relationship with others. These attitudinal
differences do not explain why local managers typically react in different ways from country to country,
sometimes in ways that an international manager may neither accept nor wish. Examples could be given of local
managers who give preference to developing an amiable and smooth relationship with suppliers than with
establishing objectives of reducing costs and speeding deliveries. Another example could be found in
managers who lay more emphasis on the organisational goals of employee and social welfare over the
company’s priorities for growth and efficiency.
www.bitbookwala.in
Cultural Factors and Environment 107
Need Hierarchy This is basically a well-known motivation theory (propounded by the late A.H.
Maslow), of human motivations that explores universal cultural motivators of human behaviour.7 On the basis
of this, the international marketer can actually work out the kind of response his products and advertising
campaigns will receive from the country’s average citizen. According to this, people will try to fulfil the lower-
order needs sufficiently before moving on to higher order. The order of needs from lower to higher is
physiological (food, water and shelter, etc.), security, affiliation, esteem and finally self-actualisation. The
‘Hierarchy of Need’ theory is helpful in differentiating reward preferences and spending patterns of people in
different countries. In a poor country, people spend a large part of their earnings on food and shelter.
Elsewhere, other needs, such as status symbol purchases, luxuries and much leisure activities get priority in the
spending list since food and shelter have already been taken care of. Such analysis helps international
marketers identify which motivation factors should be addressed in their campaigns.
Culture Variance This refers to the dimensions on the basis of which Hofstede had identified
differences amongst cultures. As discussed, no two cultures can be alike and that each culture evolves over
time, changing its basic outlook either through its reaction to socio-economic changes that may have
presented a new alternative for cultural growth or the change can also come as a result of imperialistic
tendencies of governments that impose legal sanctions against the established practices. All cultures can be
classified on the basis of a number of differences and dimensions. Each dimension distinctly separates the
nation’s cultural character, as given out by Hofstede in his four-point differentials theory.
Power Distance This refers to the interpersonal relations and intra-personal relationship, which are
based on the power equation formations in the hierarchical set up at work. In each society, the distance
BIT BOOK WALA
between the socially powerful and those who’re not so powerful, by way of either job status, social status,
wealth status or religious status, varies. In America, for example, people address each other by their first names
and the vertical distance between the superior and junior is covered by the seniors by exhibiting solidarity with
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
Malaysia Mexico Arab India Brazil Thailand United Great Sweden Austria
Countries States Britain
County
Source adopted from Geert Hofstede, Culture’s Consequences: International Differences in Work Related
Values, Sage Publications, Beverly Hills CA, 1980.
7. A.H. Maslow, “A Theory of Human Motivation”, In Readings in Managerial Psychology, Eds. Harold J. Levitt and
Louis R. Pondy. Chicago, University of Chicago Press, 1964, Pp. 6-24.
www.bitbookwala.in
108 International MarketingText and Cases
the juniors by way of friendly and approachable behaviour, by joining the ranks for games, eating food together
and removing work-related distance by occasionally engaging in activities meant for the junior positions. In
other cultures, however, the distance between the superior and the subordinate is deliberately marked. As in
India seniors prefer to be addressed by the formal epithet attached to their position. It is many times considered
against the disciplining if a senior tries to bridge the gap between the two positions or if a junior overshoots his
position and gets too friendly with a senior. In fact, juniors are neither involved in decision-making nor are they
made privy to important discussions. Hence, it is important for an international marketer to understand this
power equation to follow the correct hierarchical pattern in calling on clients. It is often seen that where power
distance is high, people prefer autocratic or paternalistic management style and when it is low, they prefer
consultative style of management. The cultural inheritance of a nation will determine the style adopted by the
current population. In the world, wherever despotic kind of rulers existed they established vertical
relationships with their subjects and other court underlings. A spirit of independence triggered through the
American Declaration of Independence and flattened the vertical difference, as the welfare of an individual
became the hallmark of relationship.
Individualism versus Collectivism Individualism refers to the humans’ preference to fulfil their
own interest and desire before they think of the larger social group or even the interests of the nation. These
attributes of individualism spell out low dependence on the organisation and a desire for personal time,
freedom and challenge. On the other hand, features of collectivism are loyalty and may call for dependence on
organisational support and vice versa. In countries with high individualism, self-actualisation will be a prime
motivator and in countries with high collectivism, the provision of safe environment (security need) will be a
prime motivator. The degree of individualism and collectivism also influences how employees interact with their
BIT BOOK WALA
colleagues. For example, the concept of family in countries like China and Mexico includes not only the nuclear
family (a husband, a wife and minor children) but also vertically integrated families (several generations) and,
perhaps, horizontally extended ones (aunts, uncles and cousins). Where collectivism is high, companies find
their best marketing successes when emphasising advertising themes that express group (rather than
individual) values.
Uncertainty Avoidance Each society has its own system of facing the every day life. In some
cultures, people feel comfortable within the zone of the familiar and the tried and trusted. For them the
unknown, unfamiliar, untried and the uncertain means raising their discomfort level. As a result, they do not like
to try the new and the innovative. However, in societies wherever uncertainty avoidance is low, people will go
for the new and different, as it holds the charm of the hidden for them, which they will like to explore. Such
characteristics of consumers can help international marketers to design products and features keeping in view
the risk avoidance or the daring to try the new and untried. In countries characterised with high uncertainty
avoidance, few consumers are willing to take the risk of trying a new product first. This is a very important
consideration for companies to choose where to launch their new products. In fact, in the West, people
generally have low uncertainty avoidance. Hence, the saving patterns are also low and the spending patterns,
accordingly, are very high because people like to live for the present. In countries that have been under
communist regimes for long, uncertainty avoidance will be very high as the basic necessities were assured by
the communist policies of the erstwhile governments. Their exposure to the new world outside the closed
regime, however, is gradually changing the cultural traits and they are opening up to new foods, clothes and
fads, etc.
Masculinity vs. Femininity A nation that has strong paternalistic affiliations and is masculine in
nature will have assertiveness at the base of all dealings and living styles. Such cultures will emphasise the
www.bitbookwala.in
Cultural Factors and Environment 109
symbols related to the material gains of life, such as wealth, material success and achievement of ambitions,
competitiveness and cut-throat rivalry in professional relationships. Such cultures can be traced in Australia,
America, Canada and Great Britain, where boldness in every aspect of life is clearly visible. On the other hand,
Scandinavian countries like Sweden and Norway where maternal instincts of the culture are more apparent, a
gentle nurturing of relationships, dealings and living styles are the hallmark. More number of women are there
in the workforce (jobs) in countries where faminine culture is predominant. International marketers will
accordingly devise their marketing communication strategies, keeping in view the masculine or feminine
characteristics of the nations. In the case of countries and markets falling under the femininity zone, the brand
and the corporate image will have to be steered towards the caring and mothering kind of feelings, whereas
customers and clients in masculine dominant markets may be motivated by bold appeals such as achievement,
competitive edge and the feeling of having arrived in their respective societies.
Trust In countries where trust is high, cost of doing business tends to be lower because the managers do
not have to spend time seeing every possible contingency and then monitoring every action for compliance in
every business relationship. Instead they can spend time investing and innovating.
Future Orientation Countries also differ in the extent to which individuals live for the present rather
than the future because they see the risks in delaying gratification and investigating for the future. Where
future orientation is higher, companies may be able to better motivate workers through delayed compensation,
such as retirement programmes.
Fatalism Countries where people believe in fatalism, that every event is inevitable, fail to accept the basic
BIT BOOK WALA
cause-and-effect relationship between hard work and achievement of goals, i.e. they fail to understand that
they have to work hard to achieve goals and take responsibility for performance. For example they may be
reluctant to buy insurance. Conservative and fundamentalist societies tend to view occurrences as “the will of
God”.
SECTION 6:
LANGUAGE AS AN ELEMENT OF CULTURE
Language is a unifying force in the face of diversity in many countries. For example, Hindi is a unifying force in
India where there are more than 20 languages and 200 dialects. Spreading of culture is greatly facilitated if there
is commonality in language. The language diversity makes it difficult for companies to integrate their
workforces and to market their products on a truly national level, as each dialect, nuance and complexity may
differ from culture to culture. International marketers will have to understand both the written and spoken
language and also the non-verbal language to communicate effectively with the targeted audience.
International marketers can run their business more smoothly in countries sharing the same language
because expensive and time-consuming translation is unnecessary. In this respect English is the most
important language (apart from the primary language in a country) for use in international business. However,
even in the English language, meanings attached to communicative and non-communicative gestures and
symbols may vary from culture to culture, for example the American English is totally different from the British
English.
Spoken and Written Language: Translating one language directly to another can be quite a task for the
marketer, making international marketing communication difficult. First, some words do not have direct
translation. Second, the languages and the common meaning of words are constantly evolving. Third, words
www.bitbookwala.in
110 International MarketingText and Cases
mean different things in different contexts. Finally, grammar and pronunciation are complex and a slight misuse
of vocabulary may change meanings substantially. Wrong choice of words is usually a big source of
embarrassment. Poor translation may have tragic consequences, as the meaning conveyed may not be the
same as the intended meaning. For example, the trunk of a car in United Kingdom becomes its boot in United
States, which can also be understood to mean a shoe in India. Therefore, every marketer will have to go through
the process of back and parallel translation to ensure the meaning of the communication is as it is originally
designed. Otherwise, marketers will have to use multi-languages in brouchers, literature and packaging
designed for international markets. This may not be possible as far as the visual media is concerned because
the space may not permit the use of so many languages. In India, where so many dialects and languages within
languages prevail, the appropriate use of Hindi and English will suffice in the north and east of the country but
southern India may not be able to understand the correct meaning of the portions in Hindi. This is where the
marketer will have to make use of two to three languages, as also in European markets, where language changes
within a short distance. Besides English, marketers may have to use French, German and any other local
language pertaining to the third nation, such as Italian, Dutch or Russian, wherever the products are being
marketed.
www.bitbookwala.in
Cultural Factors and Environment 111
Cultural upbringing plays its part in the ways people like to convey the messages of their speech and body
language. In low context cultures, there is no extra or underlying meaning attached to the spoken statement
because the words will truly convey what is meant in the true spirit. In cultures of the West, such as Germany,
Australia, Switzerland and Canada, the speaker’s verbal communication is loaded with full statement and
meaning of the sentence. The receiver does not have to look or ask for any other meaning. In such a situation
business also must be done through explicit forms and contracts so that no extra contractual obligations and
expectations are developed between the two parties. In high context cultures, however, besides the spoken
word, body language, gestures, shaking of the head and hand, each convey some meaning. And, to understand
the full meaning of the spoken and unspoken gestures and communication, it is better to understand the person
on a personal level too as a mere official relationship may not be sufficient to help develop the required levels
of understanding and trust. Countries in southern Europe are high-context cultures, that is, most people
believe that the peripheral information is crucial to decision-making and infer meaning from things said
indirectly. Similarly, in the Middle East, India and many other eastern countries of high-context cultures,
personal words, personal relationships and mutual trust are as important as the written contract. People value
the unwritten understandings as much as they value the written words. When managers from two cultures
meet, the low-context individuals may think that the high-context ones are inefficient and waste time. The high-
context individuals, on the other hand, may feel that the low-context ones are too aggressive to be trusted and
create an atmosphere of distrust, which could be damaging to the interests of both parties to the contract. In
dealing with international contracts, therefore, a marketer will have to find a solution to accommodate both
kinds of requirements because even firms can have managers from high- or low-context cultures.
Information Processing
BIT BOOK WALA
Although all cultures categorise, plan and quantify information, some cultures order and classify information
differently from others. For example, in the U.S., telephone directories are classified as per the last, name of a
person, whereas in Iceland, entries are classified as per their first, or given, names. One needs to understand the
different ordering, classifying and codifying systems to perform efficiently in a foreign environment.
Cultures also differ in the manner in which they handle people. For instance, the approach is called mono-
chronic in north Europe. In such cultures, people prefer to work sequentially, i.e. they like to finish with one
customer before dealing with another. Conversely, the poly chronic people in southern Europe are more
comfortable when working simultaneously on many tasks.
Similarly, some cultures tend to focus first on the whole and then on the parts, whereas others do just the
opposite. Likewise, some cultures will determine the principles before they try to resolve small issues
(idealism), while other cultures will focus more on details rather than principles (pragmatism). Therefore, an
international marketer cannot have the same yardsticks to deal even with his own staff, who come from different
nationalities. Some degree of adaptation will have to be called for at both the ends, i.e. the expatriates will have
to make some adjustments while the employer will have to understand the cultural background and make
allowances in performance standards. When it comes to dealing with the customers, however, it is necessary
for the marketer to understand the cultural approach and align strategies accordingly.
SECTION 7:
RELIGION AS AN ELEMENT OF CULTURE
Religion gives meaning and sustenance to a society’s existence. Through fear and belief of the supernatural, it
defines a society’s value system, attitudes and hopes. It provides the reason to multitudes in this world to
www.bitbookwala.in
112 International MarketingText and Cases
Muslims perform an evening prayer called tarawih, the night before the holy fasting month of
Ramadan begins, at Faisal Masjid in Islamabad, Pakistan on Sunday, Sept. 24, 2006. During the
BIT BOOK WALA
day, observant Muslims refrain from eating, drinking and smoking during the Ramadan period.
http://pakpics.wordpress.com/
bravely face the problems of life and then come together as groups to form a distinct culture and civilisation.
Many religions of the world teach mankind different ways of leading their lives; some preach simplicity in every
aspect of life. Just as Hinduism and Buddhism propagate a life of renunciation, a life that teaches and shows a
path to salvation, there are other religions that teach the practical ways to wisdom. Protestants are taught to
work hard and live frugally so that economic emancipation of mankind can be maintained; this in a way also
leads to the beginning of capitalism in the world. Similarly, Islam is a religion that teaches the ways of every day
living, actually specifying the day-to-day living and social etiquettes. It also prohibits the charging and
calculation of interest. Islam talks about the relationship between men and women, advocating maintenance of
marriage codes and divorce systems. It also specifies when to work and when to pay obeisance to God,
specifying that a devout Muslim must offer namaz five times every day. Judaism propagates the emancipation
of human soul through education and removal of ignorance. This has lead to the industrialisation and
commercial development of the western world, even though as a religion Judaism has had to pay a massive
price.
Again religious preaching plays a large role in shaping the consumption behaviour of a society. Purchase
patterns, value calculation, individualism, totalitarianism, social hierarchical systems, family affiliations,
cultural values, family norms, the status of women, the status of the old and infirm, the institution of marriage,
the judicial systems and even the jurisprudence and the criminal code of conduct and the penal codes, all find
their origin in the religions of the world.
Religion also determines the food habits of its followers. For example Hinduism, Buddhism, Jainism and
many other small sects of eastern religions teach sympathy towards other living creatures of the world and,
www.bitbookwala.in
Cultural Factors and Environment 113
therefore, encourage vegetarianism. Islam forbids the eating of pork and consumption of alcohol by its
followers, just as Hinduism forbids beef. When McDonalds opened its restaurants in Bangalore (India), it had
to face stiff opposition from some of the Hindu radical groups, who alleged that the French fries were fried in
animal fat. The multinational fast food retailer had to convert veggie burgers as per the Indian taste. Similarly,
Kentucky Fried chicken too had to face strong resistance from Hindu fundamentalists. Even in Israel, fast food
restaurants offer vegetarian food to customers without compromising on the kosher requirements of these
customers.
The following is an example of Hindu vegetarianism, propagated by religious preachers and saints in India.
www.bitbookwala.in
114 International Marketing–Text and Cases
imbalance. Many doctors in Delhi believe that 160 types of ailments prevalent in the
world are due to consumption of non-vegetarian food. In Delhi alone, six lakh patients
are suffering from epilepsy, a dreadful disease, the major cause of which is non-vegetarian
food. Latest researches have shown that such food is responsible for many serious
diseases, such as, heart ailments, paralysis and cancer. Shri Ramesh Chandra, Working
President of Bharatiya Gyanpeeth, mentioned that vegetarianism is not just a mode of
eating but it is a scientific way to a healthy life and that is why more and more people are
switching over to vegetarian food in the western countries. It is painful to observe that
in a country like India, which has throughout been having a vegetarian culture, is now
moving more towards non-vegetarianism.
Source: Ahimsa Times, November 2002 issue.
The systems of official working days, the calendar of week days, annual calculation of the festivals, holy
days and the auspicious beginning of business contracts are all governed by religious beliefs. In western
countries, based on Christian belief, Sunday is when people take a break from work. It’s the weekly holiday and
kept free for visiting the church for prayers, etc. In Islamic countries, Friday being the holy day of Islam, all
businesses and offices are kept closed on that day. A global business player will have to keep track of the
religious festivals and events and national, regional and local cultural occasions while planning his business
meetings, regular working of the show rooms, shops and offices.
www.bitbookwala.in
Cultural Factors and Environment 115
example, if Christmas is the most popular festive season in western countries, of equal importance are Diwali in
India for Hindus, Eid for Muslims all over the world, and Chanukah for the Jews of the world. These are also the
festivals when trade and sales are at their peak.
SECTION 8:
CULTURAL DYNAMICS
Individual and societal values and customs evolve over time. Culture is dynamic in nature and, in order to
ensure its survival, borrows from everyone and anyone that comes in contact with it. That is why literacy, the
Internet, credit cards and the plastic money culture have been able to make inroads into hitherto conservative
and closed societies. Culture change may come about through choice or imposition. Change by choice may
take place as a reaction to social and economic changes that present new alternatives.
Change by imposition, sometimes called cultural imperialism, occurs, for example, when countries introduce
their legal systems into their colonies by prohibiting established practices and defining them as criminal. The
introduction of some, but not all, elements of an outside culture is often called creolisation, indigenisation or
cultural diffusion.
The business of international sales, marketing and advertising induces change in cultures, and
governments have often limited such business to protect their national cultures. However, such protection is
less successful as people access foreign information through better international communications.
www.bitbookwala.in
116 International MarketingText and Cases
like the kite festival in Gujarat, the bhangra dance of Punjab, Bihu of Assam and Pongal of Tamil Nadu, while
adapting its global communication strategy through the local cultural environment and advertises in Gujarati,
Punjabi, Assamese, or Tamil. “A language offers a wide range of proximity towards the local mass. The word
‘Thanda’ has rocked almost all parts of India and thereon we see the global brand, Coke penetrating the Indian
Market”.8
Such campaigns and strategies of some of the global giants exhibit that there is no such cultural takeover.
Rather, it is the adaptation of global to the local need. In Asia, three-quarters of the music market is locally
produced. Coca-Cola accounts for less than two of the 64 fluid ounces that an average person drinks a day. For
every McDonald’s outlet in the UK, there are six Indian restaurants. While greater exposure to Western culture
in the non-Western world is a fact, the ability of people to adapt cannot be underestimated. An interesting
counter-current is underway, with people in different parts of the world defending their local cultures and, at the
same time, seeking to diffuse them more broadly.
In other words, globalisation does bring out the distinction and the local flavour of each culture to energise
local identities. As G. Pascal Zachary, a senior writer at the Wall Street Journal observes: “More people in many
parts of the world are expressing their distinct social and cultural traditions than at any time since the dawn of
European colonialism 500 years ago”. The emergence of international news channels in Arabic (and soon in
French) is a notable manifestation of this trend toward the global diffusion of local and national cultures. In this
sense, globalisation is a powerful force for increasing cultural exchanges and mutual understanding. The
multiplication of ethnic restaurants in Western cities, and the spread of Western food courts in the East, is an
example of how globalisation offers unprecedented choice. International marketing and the process of
globalisation involve the intermingling of people of different nations and cultures. Such globalisation exposes
BIT BOOK WALA
all nations and their inhabitants to new ways of thinking and new ideas.
The communication revolution also plays a vital role in promoting cultural enrichment and raising political
awareness in general. Easy access to the Internet means that governments, even less democratic ones, have to
abandon their monopoly on the flow of information. The globalisation of communication is indeed providing
many people with more freedom than they previously enjoyed.
“...the fundamental source of conflict in this new world will not be primarily ideological or primarily
economic. The great divisions among humankind and the dominating source of conflict will be cultural. Nation
states will remain the most powerful actors in world affairs, but the principal conflicts of global politics will
occur between nations and groups of different civilisations. The clash of civilisations will dominate global
politics.”9
Huntington defines a civilisation as “the highest cultural grouping of people and the broadest level of
cultural identity people have.... It is defined by both common objective elements, such as language, history,
religion, customs, institutions, and by the subjective self-identification of people.” In doing so, he divides the
world into major cultural groups, including Western, Confucian and Japanese, Islamic, Hindu, Slavic-Orthodox,
Latin American and African civilisations.
At the core of his thesis is the notion that, with the end of global competition over economic ideology, the
fault lines of world conflict now almost all lie along rifts between these great cultures. Huntington sees these
notions of cultural identity as so primal that he believes that, ultimately, they will take precedence over the
secular, unifying forces of economic globalisation.
www.bitbookwala.in
Cultural Factors and Environment 117
Reaffirmation of Local Culture In contrast to these homogenising effects, some people would
argue that international marketing activities of the multinational conglomerates can also reinforce local
BIT BOOK WALA
cultures. In India, for example, satellite TV permits an increase in the number of regional channels, many of
which can and do telecast Indian content (refer to case study on the Indianisation of Star TV in the Chapter 1).
This gives an average Indian new opportunities to identify with regional ties. Similarly, global companies have
to take into account the culture of all the countries where they conduct operations or sell products. This can
also enhance cultural awareness.
Many observers have speculated that the homogenising effect of globalisation on national cultures, in fact,
tends to produce a reaction among people which leads them to want to reaffirm their own local traditions. Thus,
there are temples and rituals in foreign countries, like the famous Swaminarayan Temple in UK and USA. The
ISKON movement is present in almost all the countries of the world and the same Krishna consciousness
amongst its followers. Thanks to the Internet, cyber poojas can now be conducted anywhere.
www.bitbookwala.in
118 International MarketingText and Cases
“Let us suppose that the great empire of China, with all its myriads of inhabitants, was
suddenly swallowed up by an earthquake, and let us consider how a man of humanity in
Europe, who had no sort of connection with that part of the world, would be affected
upon receiving intelligence of this dreadful calamity.... If he was to lose his little finger
to-morrow, he would not sleep to-night; but, provided he never saw [the Chinese people
killed by an earthquake], he will snore with the most profound security over the ruin of a
hundred millions of his brethren, and the destruction of that immense multitude seems
plainly an object less interesting to him, than this paltry misfortune of his own.”10
The advent of global information tools has changed all this disassociation. In today’s world, where
information is the key word, it does not take long to get informed about any happy or sad event taking place in
even the remotest part of the world, thereby refuting the implication of Adam Smith’s statement in the current
global scenario. Globalisation has changed this culture dynamic, in quite powerful ways. In today’s world,
foreign policy decisions are sometimes driven by television images beamed around the world by satellites
showing famine or fighting in other nations. In this context, globalisation enables a newscaster to humanise an
event that has take place overseas. As Adam Smith might have observed, seeing images of starving children
and other human suffering on television creates a much more powerful emotional reaction in an observer than
reading about the same event in a newspaper.
If this indifference about people in foreign countries, as noted by Adam Smith, is very different today, it is
partly so due to the media and partly due to the attempts of marketing efforts to globalise. Foreign policy
BIT BOOK WALA
decision-makers have discovered that press coverage of wars, famines and other events overseas can have a
powerful impact on popular opinion at home. Public outrage over atrocities or sympathy over suffering can
generate significant public pressure on governments to respond. This is also visible in foreign consumer
culture positioning, when the advertising shows a happy-go-lucky foreigner youth on MTV, enjoying with a
bottle of Coca Cola in hand one day and showing concern against the spread of AIDS across African nations
in a serious discussion another day. This can win many hearts across the globe. That is why Sociology
Professor Peter Berger has noted that a global network of foundations, academic networks, non-governmental
organisations and some governmental and multinational agencies (such as the UN system and development
agencies), have become transmission agents for what they perceive to be positive cultural values.11 This group
spreads its ideas through mass communication, think tanks, educational systems, development projects, the
legal system, and other mechanisms of international organisations.
REFERENCES
1. Geert Hofstede, “Culture’s Consequences”, 2nd Edition, Thousand Oaks, CA Sage 2001.
2. Geert Hofstede, “Culture Consequences Comparing Values, Behavior, Institutions, and
Organizations Across The Nations” 2nd Edition, Sage Publications CA2000.
3. Melvin Herksokvitz, “Man and His Works”.
www.bitbookwala.in
Cultural Factors and Environment 119
www.bitbookwala.in
120 International MarketingText and Cases
6. Harris Philip R. And Robert T. Moran, “Managing Cultural Differences: High Perfor-
mance Strategies For A New World Of Business, 3rd Edition, Houston, Gulf Publishing
Company, 1991.
7. Hofstede, Geert, “Cultural Constraints in Management Theories”, Academy of Man-
agement Executive, 7, No. 1, 1993.
8. Warren J. Keegan, “Global Marketing Management”, Seventh Edition, Pearson Educa-
tion, 2007.
9. Rakesh Mohan Joshi, “International Marketing” Oxford University Press 2005.
10. Dana-Nicoleta Lascu, “International Marketing – Managing Worldwide Operations in a
Changing International Environment”, Atomic Dog Publishing U.S.A, Biztantra 2003.
11. Cateora Graham, International Marketing, Tata McGraw Hill 2005.
www.bitbookwala.in
Cultural Factors and Environment 121
REVIEW QUESTIONS
1. What do you mean by cultural norms and values? Use examples to explain how different
cultures have different norms and values.
2. “Religion is the foundation of all culture formation”. Explain with the help of examples.
3. Define culture. Explain what the main constituents of culture are.
4. Discuss nation as an element of culture. What cultural elements differentiate one nation
from another? Use examples to explain.
5. How does language become an element of culture? As a marketer, how will you read the
silent and non-verbal language of nations to devise your marketing strategy? Explain
with the help of examples.
6. Define the term cultural imperatives, exclusives and cultural adiaphora. What dos and
don’ts will you follow as a manager for an international marketing firm if you are sent to a
new foreign country? Explain with the help of examples.
www.bitbookwala.in
BIT BOOK WALA
www.bitbookwala.in
Chapter 7
Learning Objectives
The reader should be able to understand and explain
• how world political environment affects international marketing
• why sovereignty and interdependence of nations is essential for international
marketing
• various kinds of government and the way countries are being ruled and gov-
erned internationally
• the political risks involved in international business
• how a firm can assess vulnerability to political environments across the world
and take preventive measures to avert it.
www.bitbookwala.in
124 International MarketingText and Cases
SECTION 1:
INTRODUCTION
T he business of firms that are involved in international marketing is affected by the environment in which
they operate. It is beyond the explicit control of international firms to control this environment. They have
to subject their plans, growth strategies and day-to-day functioning to the economic systems, fiscal policies,
procedures and laws enacted by the governments that rule these nations. Although the opening up of the
economies worldwide has brought the nations closer to each other, it has also brought along with it
vulnerability to the financial and economic freedom of smaller nations. These nations, while they would like to
enjoy the fruits of internationalisation of firms, trade and finance, their rulers, business lobbies and other
pressure groups would like to protect their own interests by taking recourse to the laws of the land. The
opening up of world economies in such circumstances means that an economy allows free operations to
international businessmen, subject to their adhering to local rules, regulations and managing the delicate
balancing act with their home country governments. International companies like Coca-Cola and Pepsi faced
this recently in India, where political compulsions of many state governments encouraged them to ban their
products in their states. IBM and Coke had to move out of India in the early 1970s, when the ruling party at the
centre decided to oppose the multinationals operating in India. Many other companies have not only lost their
business in countries like Rwanda, Uganda, Burundi and Bosnia, even their assets have been looted and
plundered. Similarly, multinationals worldwide expose their assets, business strategies and even expatriate
employees to the mercy of the local authorities, social and consumer associations. These firms face legal,
ethical and political challenges to their survival all across the globe on a daily basis, as their managers find out
what is allowed by the foreign governments and what is forbidden by the laws of the land. Political expediency
BIT BOOK WALA
facilitates the growth of business for these firms when politicians take decisions favouring imports and exports,
and the same politics acts as deterrents when they impose barriers in the shape of embargoes, tariffs and anti-
dumping duties.
Companies face multi-political systems all over the world. While they have to cope with the whims and
fancies of dictatorial attitudes of rulers in some nations, they also get a warm welcome in development-oriented
countries. In such countries, the sovereign or the politically elected governments welcome international trade
and foreign direct investment to upgrade the living standards of their multitudes. The instability of political
www.bitbookwala.in
Political Factors and Environment 125
systems of nations due to recurrent elections, upheavals of the existing governments by civil wars, court
rulings and other internal and external conflicts make the business of multinationals quite unpredictable. In
such circumstances, an international firm needs to protect its interests by familiarising itself not only with the
economic systems but also with the political systems, political environment and the laws of the land.
This chapter will focus on different political and legal environments that have a direct and indirect bearing
on the international business operations of the firm.
SECTION 2:
POLITICAL ENVIRONMENT
No business, whether at home or abroad, can be set up without assessing the ramification of the prevailing
political environment. The politicians of the home and host countries, both affect and influence business in all
its forms. Whether domestic or international, the political schools of thought can lobby for or against a
business, irrespective of whether they are in power or out in the opposition. Multinational firms face labour
leaders, environmentalists, non-governmental organisations and social activists for one reason or the other,
and the firms have to wriggle their way through and juggle to stay in the good books of the opponents as well
as the favourites. Many times, international firms will have to harbour and harness political bosses and
opponents to make them initiate new rules, regulations and amendments in the existing rule books so that the
firms can run their business smoothly. It cannot be called political corruption or nepotism. It is simply hedging
against the future uncertainties of doing business in an environment where those in power can make or mar a
business by changing sides.
BIT BOOK WALA
POLITICAL EXPEDIENCY: WAL-MART
“The goal of China’s unions is to build a harmonious
society.”
Wal-Mart who had not permitted its 1.3 million U.S.
employees to organise a union, announced it would allow
its workers in China to unionise. Wal-Mart has fiercely
opposed American workers’ attempts to unionise, in one
case, closing a meat-cutting division after ten butchers
voted to unionise. Nu Wexler, a spokesman for Wal-Mart
Watch, says the company “is applying an inconsistent
double standard. In the U.S., they aggressively fight
unions in their stores. But if unions are a barrier of entry
to an emerging market, Wal-Mart is willing to flip-flop on its position.”
Labour experts Oded Shenkar of Ohio University and Richard W. Hurd of Cornell both
suggest, in Bloomberg News’s coverage of the announcement, that the retailer probably
agreed to allow unions under pressure from the Chinese government. “ We find that the
political environment of both the home as well as host country (countries) become the
most critical factors in implementing and influencing a firm’s decision of moving capital
and investments to any part of the world.( http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/
content/article/2006/08/09/AR2006080901924.html)
www.bitbookwala.in
126 International MarketingText and Cases
“When Pepsi and Coca Cola faced public wrath through the disclosures by an activist of non governmental
organization in India about heavy doses of pesticides in their respective soft drinks, the international firms
were cornered for a while but a strategy to cater to a few social activists lobbyists and political influencers
extracted a statement from the Central Government representatives on the floor of the Parliament in favour of
the soft drink giants”. Similarly, such lobbying had been used earlier on the floor of the house when the then
environmental and health authorities had given a clean chit to mineral and distilled water manufacturers on the
same issue. Multinational firms face such issues all over the world. Such risks do not necessarily exist in host
countries alone but are present in home countries as well. Political scenarios and political lobbying can affect
business of international firms at home too. Companies can face embargos from governments for taking their
business to another country, especially one that may have fallen foul of the international community, for
example North Korea and Cuba. American companies like Pepsi, Coca Cola, IBM, McDonald’s and Kentucky
Fried Chicken (KFC) have, in fact, faced the wrath of consumers and political repercussions from many
countries, whenever the United States administration has tried to impose restrictions and embargoes on
business relations with other countries, either by banning complete exports or by restricting imports quantity
on select items , or changing tariff structures, etc. Many American firms, therefore, try to adopt a different
approach to pacify and please the public, consumers and law makers in the host country and dissociate
themselves from the repercussions of the variations in the changing attitudes of their government. The
instance of Wal-Mart allowing formation of unions in the workforce of its China operations, as against the
policy adopted in U.S. where the firm has been opposing any kind of group organisation of its employees, is a
case in point where the firm has been influenced by the local politics of the host country.
This chapter deals with a detailed and comprehensive assessment of political environment and its essential
features.
BIT BOOK WALA
Political Systems and Global Business Global economic interdependence has dramatically
affected the ways in which countries and businesses relate to one another. The challenge of global competition
today has caused numerous and profound changes in the political environment in which businesses must find
their way and, consequently, the ways in which nation states act and react to each other. As a result, no single
country can be immune to the impact of such fundamental change. An independent state territory today also is
a political map, demarcating the boundaries between countries as clearly as ever. But on a competitive map, a
map showing the real flows of financial and industrial activity, those boundaries have largely disappeared.
Through this flow, all human beings of the world have become global citizens, and so have the international
firms and multinational companies that want to sell products and services all over the world.
The risks and benefits associated with global business are both very real. This vastly increased importance
of trans-national business opportunities not only permits but also invites nations’ efforts to exert influence
over others as an extension of the home country political systems and their foreign policy.
The United States, certainly, has not been hesitant to apply sanctions in order to further
its interests. In fact, it has rather liberally used sanctions in this regard. Between 1993
and the present, the US applied sanctions 61 times against 35 countries. This has been a
popular option ‘of choice’ for the US decision makers. These have often been then applied
as an alternative to military action as, for example, against Iran and Libya for their
perceived efforts at supporting terrorism, or against Iraq in an effort to dissuade it from
invading Kuwait. As indicated above, however, there is considerable debate about the
www.bitbookwala.in
Political Factors and Environment 127
effectiveness of these sanctions. One study showed that of the 150 examples of sanctions
imposed during this century, “... only one in three made even a modest contribution
toward the intended goal”. Moreover, sanctions are not without economic effect on the
country imposing them. They can, in fact, be an ‘expensive’ option. For example, it is
estimated that the application of sanctions cost the US in 1995 alone $15 to $19 billion
in lost export revenues. The U.S. trade embargo of Cuba, as an economic extension of the
U.S. foreign policy, seems not to have been successful. It has not caused Castro to leave
office, nor has it forced an abandonment of the communist form of government in Cuba.
The continuation of the embargo does not appear to offer high prospects for success. In
fact, by doing so, it seems that the U.S. will merely continue to impoverish the Cuban
people, alienate its allies and trading partners, and cause its own businesses to be in a
poor competitive position when Castro eventually does leave office.1
An Independent and Sovereign State At the base of all political systems of the world lies the
very foundation of an independent nation. A state that has its own legal entity free from any external or foreign
power control whether political, legal or economic, a state that enjoys full legal and constitutional control on its
geographical territory and is free to enter into any kind of trade agreement with other nations is called an
independent sovereign state. This is a state where citizens’ rights are subject to the laws enacted by the
political and legal system of the established constitution. These citizens are governed by the country laws,
even if they reside outside the boundaries of the state. Even foreign businessmen and firms citizens and
BIT BOOK WALA
visitors must abide by and respect the legal rights of this state to govern their actions when they enter its
boundary. There are more than 192 independent nations in the world today, each enacting its own industrial
policy labour laws, trade laws and fiscal taxation laws. These governments decide whether to encourage local
investments outside the country or to welcome foreign direct investments within the country, whether its
citizens will have the rights to build property or assets outside the national frontiers or the foreign nationals,
firms and businessmen will be permitted to build up their assets within this country.2
www.bitbookwala.in
128 International Marketing–Text and Cases
development. However nations and sovereigns keep a hawk’s eye on their rights of independence and
sovereignty. That is why we can see nations often objecting to certain clauses of WTO, riders being attached
to foreign direct investments and many a nations insisting on local nationals compulsorily being on board of
multinationals. “There is an increased level of visible distrust of multinational firms across the world calling for
creation of codes of conduct for them”.3 Countries react to any action of multinationals that seem to be an
infringement upon their sovereignty and independence. A move by the United States to cut business of
European exports of non-essential items like cheese, perfumes, soaps and accessories by imposing tariff
barriers evoked a strong protest from Europeans against American multinationals like McDonald’s and Coca
Cola.
Issue of Home Country vis-à-vis the Host Country International firms operating in
different countries have to strictly adhere to the laws and regulations of the home country from which they
originate and the host country in which they operate. That is why companies will have to be aware of the
political problems that can arise due to conflict of interests of both the countries. Normally international firms
will avoid direct entry into countries that are hostile to their home country and may adopt a circuitous route
of indirect franchisee from the host country. But the risks still remain, when sweeping public, political, cultural
or economic changes take place in host countries. There are examples of sweeping political upheavals in
countries like Cuba (1960), the Iraq and Iran war, the Gulf war, and the latest war against Iraq by U.S. and its
allies have cost billions of dollars of destruction of multinational companies’ business opportunities and
assets.
The day-to-day functioning, policy making, local NGOs and political parties, ideologies, both in home
BIT BOOK WALA
country and host country do affect companies’ business prospects abroad.
The U.S-China relationship and the swings of coming closer and yet going apart have
been quite a clear example of how relations between two countries impact international
business. The U.S.-China business relationship had been re-established under the Nixon
administration in the mid-1970s, urging the Chinese government (which had been
following a closed-door policy till then) to open its doors for direct foreign investments.
The joint ventures, entered into by Chrysler of United States, Volkswagen of Germany, and
Peugeot of France became the major beneficiaries. But relationship soured again between
the two countries when the United States government openly criticised China’s violation
of human rights in the Tiananmen Square incident in 1989. The trade relations
accordingly have felt the same strain again. The relationship started normalising again
when China entered the WTO, when the United States offered permanent trade relations to
China. This promises a bright business environment to U.S. multinationals again.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sino-American_relations.
A multinational management, thus, has to be in the complete know and grip of what is happening in its home
country politics and how it will affect its host country politics and vice versa. Similarly, they must be in a
position to assess the political winds of change in their host country and how these changes will affect the
relationship between two countries. A change from Labour to Democrat or from right to left wing can alter
3. S. Prakash Sethi, Setting Global Standards; Guidelines for Code of Conduct in Multinational Corporations.
(Hoboken N J: WILEY 2003).
www.bitbookwala.in
Political Factors and Environment 129
complete philosophy and thinking of the government and the foreign relation policy of the countries, directly
jeopardising the interests of multinational business.
SECTION 3:
TYPES OF GOVERNMENT AND POLITICAL ECONOMIC SYSTEMS
The legal and economic systems of a country are determined and imposed by the political systems and political
sanctioning of a country. This constitutional (or unconstitutional/arbitrary) authority can be measured for any
country on two dimensions as these dimensions will eventually help a firm design and direct its marketing
strategies for different countries. The first dimension is the degree to which they give importance to
collectivism, that is the emphasis on common good for all through the state, as against the welfare of the
individual. The second dimension looks at their being democratic or totalitarian. A detailed discussion on all
systems of governments follows:
1. Collectivism vs. Individualism The term collectivism when used in political parlance refers to a
political system that stresses the primacy of the collective goal over individual goals and the needs, welfare and
benefits of a society as a whole are given more importance over that of an individual. Individual rights in such
a system are curtailed to the extent that they should not be contrary to the common good of society. Societies
also get affected as per the systems adopted by politics. In the West, there is greater emphasis on
individualism. People like their individuality and freedom in countries like Great Britain, Australia and Germany.
Their fulfilment of personal advancement, progress ability are stressed more than anything else. In the East,
however, individual rights have been subjugated to collective goals. Hence, societies in Asia prefer common
BIT BOOK WALA
goals to individual goals. The recent trend of opening up of economies, however, is bringing out the
individualism in these societies too. Perhaps this is so because “culture tends to evolve from collectivism to
individualism as countries become industrialised and individuals express their own identity”.4 The collectivism
today has been coined as a new mantle of socialism.
2. Socialism Traces of socialism can also be seen in Plato’s philosophy. The Greek philosopher had
argued in The Republic that “individual rights should be sacrificed for the good of the majority and that
property should be owned in common”. In the modern context, socialism has been advocated by Karl Marx,
who propagated the view that “few benefit at the expense of many in a capitalist society, where individual
freedoms are not restricted”. He opined that while capitalists gain considerable wealth, the majority of the
workers, who earn their wages by working for capitalist, will be reduced to subsistence level. He, therefore,
advocated state ownership of the basic means of production, distribution and exchange (tools used by
capitalists) to ensure no exploitation of the labour class takes place and that workers are fully compensated for
their labour by the state. Socialism, thus, is a system that advocates government ownership and control of
industry considered critical to the welfare of the nation.5
3. Communism vs. Social Democrats Early 20th century saw the emergence of a new kind of
communism, which believed that socialism could be achieved only through a violent revolution and totalitarian
dictatorship. The social democrats, on the other hand, held the view that socialism could be achieved by
democratic means and that dictatorship and totalitarianism was not in favour of public good. The early 1970s
4. Harry C Triandis, “The Self and Social Behavior in Differing Cultural Contexts” Psychological Review July 1989,
Vol. 96, Page 506-520.
5. Joseph A Schumpeter, Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy/New York Harper And Collins 1947.
www.bitbookwala.in
130 International MarketingText and Cases
saw the world polarised into communist states and socialist states: the former Soviet Union, Eastern European
nations like Poland, Czechoslovakia and Hungary, besides Asian countries like China, Cambodia, Lagos,
Vietnam and African nations like Angola, Mozambique were all under communist rule. In addition, Latin
American nations of Cuba and Nicaragua were also governed by communism. By the mid-90s, however,
communism collapsed. The Soviet Union was the first to fall and the 15 constituencies of republics declared
themselves nominal democracies. Eastern Europe too saw communism retreating. The Eastern bloc countries
opened up. East Germany was unified with West Germany and a common democratic Germany was formed.
Even though individual political freedom in China is curtailed, the nation is moving away from communism
today.
Social democracy reached its zenith in quite a few nations like Australia, France, Germany, Great Britain,
Norway, Spain and Sweden, where social democratic parties have been in power for a long time. India’s move
of nationalisation and building up of public sector enterprises from telecommunication, railway, airlines,
electricity, gas, oil and steel and even higher education had been modelled on the British system, where public
good rather than personal gain has prevailed. The state-owned enterprises created a monopolistic
entrepreneurship for the governments, eliminating all kinds of competition from within and outside the country.
This closeness meant that the public had to pay for the inefficiency of government machinery by way of higher
taxes and higher prices for goods and services. As a result, the trend started a reverse journey in many of the
nations. A number of western democracies voted social democratic parties out of power in late 70s and early
80s. A new breed of political parties, committed to free market economies emerged in the Great Britain and
Germany. These parties, such as the Conservative Party of England and Christian Democratic Party of Germany,
started selling government-owned and managed enterprise to private owners. Although India was late in
BIT BOOK WALA
following suit, many public enterprises have been hived off by the government to private entrepreneurs in past
decade or so.
Individualism The propagators of individual freedom believe that every man should have freedom to
pursue his economic and political aims and that the welfare and interest of the individual should take
precedence over interest of the state. Rather, the sole focus of the state should be to ensure individual freedom
and individual economic and political welfare. Aristotle, the Greek philosopher (384-322BC), had advanced this
theory that was exactly opposite and contrary to Plato’s theory of collectivism. This theory believes that
private ownership for society good is desirable. According to Aristotle, since private property will be nurtured
by individuals, it will stimulate more growth and progress; he further opined that community property receives
little care by those who administer it. Hence, free enterprise will be more productive for a nation’s development.
This philosophy of individualism has been followed by protestant trading nations of England, and Netherlands
in 16th century, when individual wealth seekers spread out around the world to look for new opportunities of
private enterprise and trading. East India Company, discovery of America and the Portuguese traders’
discovery of India were each the outcome of private and individual efforts to seek new pastures of trade around
the globe.
Many British philosophers advocated and refined the concept of individualism, for instance David Humes
(1711-1776), Adam Smith (1723-1790), and John Stuart Mill (1806-1873) and, in recent years, Milton Friedman, all
have championed the philosophy of individualism. The very foundation of United States of America’s
independence had been laid by the thought of individual freedom and self expression. The only curb on an
individual’s self expression by the authority of the state can be in terms of protection of others’ rights to self
expressions and freedom, which, in turn, allows and guarantees each living human complete control over
thought, expression, action and individuality, so long as it does not harm the rights of others.
www.bitbookwala.in
Political Factors and Environment 131
This way the welfare of the society is well preserved and protected because when an individual’s economic
and political freedom is guaranteed, his pursuit of wealth and knowledge increases manifold for society’s own
development.
Individualistic societies and cultures like the United States, Great Britain and Australia, have influenced in
more recent years the revolutions of Eastern Europe and the former Soviet Union. It has also found acceptance
in countries in the Middle East and South Africa.
Democracy and Totalitarianism In democratic states, the government is elected by the people and
is administered and run by the representatives of the people or by the people themselves directly. A true
democracy will have a multi-party system. These parties and elected representatives will run the government
on behalf of the people of the country, as per the law enshrined in the constitution of the country. A typical
democracy will have the following protective and safety measurements guaranteed by the constitution:
1. An individual’s right to freedom of expression, opinion and organisation.
2. A free media.
3. Regular and periodical elections in which all eligible citizens are allowed to vote.
4. Universal adult suffrage.
5. Limited and fixed term for elected representatives.
6. Fair judicial system, which is independent of executive.
7. Non-political state bureaucracy.
8. Non-political law enforcement agencies and armed forces.
9.
BIT BOOK WALA
Free access to information related to the government (for example, Right to the Information Act in India).
Totalitarianism Totalitarian country, whether based on one philosophy, one tribe or one political party
denies its citizens all those guarantees on which democratic nations thrive, for example the right to freedom of
expression and organisation, right to vote and elect their own government and free media. On the contrary,
repressive measures are used to keep the citizens in check from revolting or expressing their opinion against
those in power. Even bureaucracy is a rubber stamp of the totalitarian government. All the countries governed
by communist regimes, who believed socialism can be achieved through dictatorship, supported
totalitarianism. Soviet Union’s failure, as discussed earlier, brought the retreat of communists from all these
countries, even in China.
Religious Totalitarianism This is found in many states where religion sanctions the power of the state
through a single party, individual or group. The dictatorial attitude flows through the laws established by the
majority religion of the land and day-to-day life is also governed by religious fundamentals. Islamic states of
Iran and Saudi Arabia are totally based on religious totalitarianism. Pakistan too, to some extent, mixes religion
with the powers of the armed forces in running the country. It is worth noting that approximately 99% people in
those countries belong to the Islamic religion.
Tribal Totalitarianism It has been based on one tribe rule in many African countries like Zimbabwe,
Tanzania, Uganda and Kenya. Different tribes have been ruling these countries, drawing their power from tribal
laws established by customs and traditions of centuries. One family or one particular tribe seizes power from
the people and, irrespective of the fact whether the majority is with them or not, rule over the country. This is
the most repressive form of government where those who oppose it are, many times, deprived of right to life
also. History of many African nations is replete with stories of mass massacres and subjugation of the
opponents of the ruling tribe.
www.bitbookwala.in
132 International MarketingText and Cases
Right Wing Totalitarianism Occurs when political freedom of the people is curtailed even though
economic freedom is allowed. The rulers of fascist Germany, Italy, South Korea, Taiwan and Philippines have all
been governed by right-wing extremism through military dictatorship, even though majority of these countries
are committed to true democracies now. Even in Latin America, till early 1980s, the right-wing dictatorship
prevailed through the military.
SECTION 4:
POLITICAL RISKS IN INTERNATIONAL MARKETING
When an international firm crosses its home country borders, it exposes itself to many perceived, well assessed
risks as well as unimagined, unknown risks of political ideologies, political loyalties and political affiliations of
different countries, governments, tribes and authorities. These risks can vary from losing complete business
assets through confiscation to facing a hostile consumer attitude, to competing against a well-protected industry
in the host country through price protections, patent laws and territory or business segment protections.
Similarly, many other government actions, such as exchange controls and restrictions, licensing requirements,
equity sharing rules and regulations, domesticating the foreign equity and product manufacturing contents,
meeting with the non-governmental organisations specifications and standards, all pose political risks to the
business functioning of international firms, ultimately telling on their bottom and top line performances.
International firms do get advance signals and can smell and sense the beginning of such risks but once the
resources have been committed, it gets too late to pull out of their business.
Indications of Political Risks The firm’s public relations activities, business monitoring executives
BIT BOOK WALA
and liaisons agents who handle dealing with host governments can predict if a country is getting too risky
simply by keeping track of business reports in financial periodicals and newspapers published locally as well
as abroad, such as The Economist and Wall Street Journal, The Exchange Rate Publications and Currency
Indicators, which can tell about the impending fall of economies. Besides, the firms themselves can keep on
regularly monitoring the following elements of different countries to keep an eye on business activities and
environmental changes.
Economic Performance of the Country Nothing else leads to unrest in a country as much as
economic backwardness. People who are underemployed, poorly fed and are deprived of the basic necessities
get restless with unemployment figures going up or inflation rates jumping up exorbitantly. A firm can assess
how the country has been meeting its commitments in servicing foreign debts, internal loans, maintaining hard
currency and balance of payments systems.
Political Stability Political ideologies bring out the vulnerability of international firms. It is not possible
for a firm to take sides with any political pole yet, many times, politicians, who were in opposition till yesterday,
immediately take out their wrath on the previous government’s policies. International businesses too fall a prey
to such witch hunting. The companies can get affected and even thrown out by such political storms, although
few countries have changed their international policies with change in government. In India when Narasimha
Rao’s government had introduced changes in the government fiscal policy and opened the economy to bring
in more foreign direct investments into the country, the government that followed, that of Atal Behari Vajpayee,
followed virtually the same policies and continued the process of growth. Similarly, Italy has had practically a
new government every year after World War II but its business policies have not been changed. In fact, an
international firm must undertake a complete study of political integrity of the country it wants to operate in,
which can show how many times policies of governing the country and managing business have changed with
www.bitbookwala.in
Political Factors and Environment 133
each successive change of government . In African countries, however, where tribal and ethnics continue
fighting against each other, international firms face highly unstable political policies yielding threat to their
business every time a new ruler takes over. In Central and Eastern Europe, such instability has been witnessed
in Serbia, Bosnia, Herzegovina, Croatia and others, whereas Germany has always witnessed a smooth change
over, where two extremes, Conservatives at one time followed by a government believing in socialism, have
been ruling from time to time.
Besides change of governments, internal turmoil creates an equally unstable political scene for international
firms. The Tamil separatists of Sri Lanka, the extremists in the north-east in India, the political riots of Indonesia,
the Kurds and Iraqi’s turmoil, the mujahideen of Pakistan, all prevent expansion of international business as
foreign direct investments to these countries get blocked. A recent World Bank study indicates that 47 nations
of sub-Sahara African region attracted less than $2 billion annually in direct investments. Similarly, Sri Lanka
also attracted a very low foreign direct investment due to ethnic strife continuing for so many years.
Spirit of Nationalism The world is opening up. Each country wants to become a part of the global
expansion of business and employment opportunities, those that international firms bring along with the
investments they make abroad. The country has to provide and promote an atmosphere of global citizenship to
all those expatriates who come and join the workforce but, at the same time, retaining its pride in cultural
heritage and history. However, strong feelings of nationalism with slogans like Be Indian, buy Indian’ or ‘Buy
www.bitbookwala.in
134 International MarketingText and Cases
American’, as echoed in the early 1980s in America for textile and automobiles or rejecting American apples as
happened in Japan, poses political threats to international organisations across frontiers. It is seen that
wherever nationalism has been strongly voiced, along with the ‘sons of the soil’ theory, foreign business has
always suffered, leading to MNCs deciding to stay out of the country. Such a move has often been adopted in
order to promote local business and keep foreign goods out of the country. The countries that believe in this
dictum, that foreign goods can cause local businesses to shut down, adopt many repressive and detrimental
measures against foreign companies by way of tariff impositions, quantity restrictions and other such barriers.
Nationalisation of industry is the extreme step any country can take against international business.
The ‘Swadeshi Movement’ in Bengal heralded a new age in our national history. Swadeshi
was instantly identified as the highest form of patriotism and Swadeshism became the
cradle of New India. It was an intensely spiritual movement and aimed at the
emancipation of India in every sense, of every Indian. With fervent national calls for the
boycott of British goods, schools, courts and administration came stirring appeals for
embracing Swadeshi in all spheres of life, in terms of indigenously manufactured goods,
national education, language, literature and above all Swaraj, or political freedom,
became the life-breath of the nation.
Adapted from the News Today Special Story by V Sundaram, http://www.newstodaynet. com/
2006sud/06aug/2308ss1.htm
Populations that are concentrated regionally, who populate not only cities but the
BIT BOOK WALA
surrounding rural areas and who constitute the predominant population in their region
are far more likely to be engaged in sustained rebellion against the state than dispersed
or urban groups that have no regional base in which they are the predominant groups
demographically. Groups whose ancestors lived in the region in which they now live and
who constitute the predominant population of the region have a regional base. When
groups that have a regional base face demographic pressures through internal migration
they become likely candidates for rebellion. These groups are called the ‘sons of the soil’.
Adapted from “Sons Of Soil, Immigrants And Civil Wars’ James D Fearson, David D. Laitin,
Stanford University. http://iicas.ucsd.edu/papers/GTCconf/soil11.pdf
Political Risks in International Marketing Business can manage many inherent risks in any new
enterprise it is assumed that any calculated business risk is managed by most of the firms. But any risk that is
not necessarily induced by unfair competition, laws of demand and supply substitution of elasticity of demand
or natural disasters is a risk that is brought upon the firms by man-made frontiers too.
There are risks related to economic and fiscal policy framed by the governments of the home country,
foreign countries and political ideologies. Thoughts and theories a country follows can shift overnight with a
change in rulers and even a small unrest can engulf the entire nation, resulting in civil wars. The international
firms have to ensure protection and safety of their business interests and properties. An international firm has
to keep its eyes open to the ground to predict any small change or action by the host country leading to bigger
crisis onwards.
Risks Related to the Governments Trade Policies There are many ways in which the
government of the host country can prevent business expansion plans of a foreign company or even
www.bitbookwala.in
Political Factors and Environment 135
jeopardise its existing business activities. The government can impose exchange control, prevent repatriation
of funds to another country, suddenly impose restrictions on imports by way of quotas, tariff barriers or
stipulate export conditions in return on international firms. Trade barriers, such as sanctions, economic boycott
and suspension of diplomatic relations, can also be imposed by the home country of the firm, forcing the firms
to close business in the country. China’s trade policy has seen many ups and downs, hot and cold winds with
Indian firms, so much so that during the visit of the Chinese president to India, Indian firms, Indian press and
the Indian Diaspora had to make a representation to the Chinese premier to re-examine his government policy
towards Indian imports and Indians firms desirous of carrying on business in China.
www.bitbookwala.in
136 International MarketingText and Cases
Risks Pertaining to Economic Policy Local taxes are not the only options a foreign government
can take to make life difficult for an international firm. The local taxes and their impact can still be offset by the
operating efficiencies of the international firm to some extent, as their economies of scale obviously are much
higher than the localised, country-specific competitors. However, firms express their helplessness when
countries and state governments resort to extreme measures of taking over the firm’s business by way of
confiscation, expropriation or nationalisation. Firms have faced such extreme measures at the hands of Milton
Obote (who had nationalised 60 percent of British companies in the 1960s) and Idi Amin (who had thrown out
Asian businessmen after confiscating their business assets) in Uganda, Islamic Revolutionary Party in Iran,
where Ayatollah Khomeini led the revolution, and Fidel Castro in Cuba. Similarly, Coke too faced such a
situation in India in 1978, when the international firm had been asked to transfer 60 percent of its equity holding
to Indians and declare the contents and formula of Coke. The Coke management preferred leaving Indian
shores for good.
Confiscation of International Firms Assets An international firm dreads the situation where
its property, assets and business are forcibly taken over and confiscated by the host country government. Yet
this has happened in many countries. Khomeini’s taking over of power from the Shah of Iran spelt doomsday
for international firms, as their properties and businesses were confiscated by the Islamic Revolutionary
Council. In such extreme conditions, no compensation is paid to the firm for leaving its assets behind.
Expropriation of Firms Assets When governments in the interest of local people and industry
seize the firm’s investments in the host country and offer a nominal compensation for the same, such expropri-
ated assets are then managed by the public sector agencies as nationalised units. Oil companies like Shell, Esso
BIT BOOK WALA
and few others were expropriated by the Indian government in the 1950-1960s, when it was decided to
nationalise the oil producing and distribution activities in the country. Similarly in Cuba, Brazil, Afghanistan
and east European countries, such havoc has been played with many international firms.
Private companies were expropriated in Cuba in 1959-67, after the Cuban revolution of 1959. These
companies (largely U.S. owned) were offered basic compensation, which was rejected by the United States.
Egyptian President Gammal Abdel Nasser nationalised the Suez Canal Company on 26th July, 1956,
provoking the United Kingdom, France and Israel to launch a combined attack on Egypt, which was stopped by
the U.S. and the former Soviet Union.
Nationalisation of Business Assets When the governments for the cause of social benefits
decide to move the property and assets of business from private hands to government-sponsored public
sector undertakings or agencies, it is called nationalisation. In the interest of national benefits, countries have
nationalised electricity generation and distribution, telecommunication systems defence-related productions,
road transport, oil production and distribution, banking sector and means of other transports like the railways
and airlines. Such national interest is not challenged even in the international courts, as long as a valid reason
and an adequate compensation is handed over by the country.
• Many countries are in the process of privatising the nationalised industries, after having realised that
private sector manages the assets better than the public sector.
• The Egyptian share in the Suez Canal Company was bought out by the British Government in 1875.
• A key issue in nationalisation is whether the private owner, more so if it happens to be an international
firm or business, is adequately compensated for the value of the assets nationalised. The controversy
arises when there is no compensation or when the compensation is unreasonably below the market
value of the nationalised assets. Such a step by a government can be called expropriation.
www.bitbookwala.in
Political Factors and Environment 137
On May 1 2006, newly elected Bolivian leader Evo Morales announced plans to nationalise
the country’s natural gas industry; foreign-based companies were given six months to
renegotiate their existing contracts. (Adapted from Wikipedia, the free encyclopaedia)
“When Mr. Evo Morales became President in January, he pledged to lift his country out
of poverty. Bolivia, one of the poorest countries in South America, has suffered from
colonial (Spanish) exploitation and then from rapacious multinationals. Mr. Morales, a
former coca grower and a member of the country’s indigenous Aymara community,
promised nationalisation of mines. Apart from gas, the country’s rich mineral reserves
include tin, zinc, lead, silver, gold and wolfram. On the dusty roads of a campaign trail,
the well-dressed executives of energy companies earning high salaries and declaring
lavish dividends can look like blood-suckers of national assets who are denying
prosperity to the poor. How simple would it be once in power—take back these assets and
let the poor benefit! Unfortunately, the reality is more nuanced.
So Mr. Morales announced a nationalisation of the country’s gas industry on May 1,
and gave foreign companies 180 days to sign new deals giving the government majority
control or leave the country. Soldiers were dispatched to take control. The markets were
upset and papers predicted the end of foreign investment in Bolivia. Unlike the old style
nationalisations when the government took over full control, Bolivia wanted the
companies to stay and continue to operate under more stringent conditions. An earlier
law had raised the state’s share to almost 50 per cent of production through higher taxes
and royalties.
BIT BOOK WALA
Market Realities Soften Bolivian Nationalisation. C. Gopinath, Business Line, Nov.13, 2006.
Domestication
Domestication refers to the host country insisting on the following:
1. Using locally manufactured raw material for manufacturing products of international firms. When
Suzuki had joined hands with Maruti to manufacture cars in India, the 100 percent Indianisation of the
car over a period was the stipulated condition in the collaboration contract. Developing Indian ven-
dors to provide indigenous parts had been the major responsibility of Maruti officials in 1984-1986, in
order to ensure compliance of the government’s requirements of indigenising the complete Maruti to
Indian manufactured components. Similarly, the Indian motorcycle industry, which initiated the two-
wheeler revolution in India with its 100c.c. bikes, brought the initial lot of two-wheelers to the country
in semi-knocked down conditions. The industry has been completely indigenised over a period, after
it developed Indian vendors to meet the component requirement of the two-wheeler industry in the
country.
2. Even the European community has a local content requirement of 45 percent for all foreign-owned
manufacturing firms in Europe. This is acceptable if it is done to encourage development of local
industry and provide employment opportunities. However, many times, such a policy tell on the health
of an international firm if it is forced to adopt substandard indigenised products at uncompetitive rates,
to accommodate local interests.
3. Gradual transfer of ownership and management of international firms to local managers. In many
Middle East countries, a business license can be issued only to a local citizen and, where involved, a
www.bitbookwala.in
138 International MarketingText and Cases
foreign partner can only have a minority stake in the partnership. Thus, a foreign company per force is
required to seek a local partner and pay a hefty license fee to run business in these countries. Besides,
ownership equity is reduced to a minority stakes as a rule of law.
4. Not permitting repatriation of funds and profits above a certain limit and insisting on profits being
deployed back in the local industry. Sometimes, the host country may face a severe foreign exchange
crunch, or when the country notices the flight of capital by multinationals and foreign firms, the
country can impose foreign exchange control rules and regulations. India had FERA operative in the
country, which restricted foreign exchange transactions in the country. It is only now, under FEMA,
under the new exim policy, that full convertibility has been allowed. In addition, the countries can also
extend controls to the imported products by imposing tax. Heavy taxes are imposed on products
classified by the host countries as luxuries but they may take a more lenient approach to products that
are considered necessities.
Diplomatic Severances and Political Sanctions Pakistan and India have on many occasions
suspended diplomatic relations with each other, called back their high commissioners and, at times, even closed
embassies and high commissions and consulates in each other’s countries. Such conditions obviously spell
doom for international firms situated in either country. The U.S. has also used sanctions against different
countries, including Cuba, Libya, Iraq, and Iran, but it has done equal harm to the firms originating from the U.S.
or from the allied countries.
www.bitbookwala.in
Political Factors and Environment 139
Washington agreed that the United States and North Korea would respect each others’
sovereignty, exist peacefully together and take steps to normalise their relations.”
Four days later, the U.S. treasury department imposed sweeping financial sanctions
against North Korea, designed to cut off the country’s access to the international
banking system, branding it a “ criminal state” guilty of counterfeiting , money
laundering and trafficking in weapons of mass destruction.
Adapted From: North Korea’s Nuclear Gamble, Selig S. Harrison, The Newsweek, October16,
2006, P.31. Http/ www.newsweekInternational.com
www.bitbookwala.in
140 International MarketingText and Cases
Sometimes, the small issues of workforce retrenchment can blow out of proportion due to
the cudgels taken up by militant labour, social and political activists, causing
embarrassment to international firms. Honda had to face the wrath in their scooter
manufacturing plant in north India, when disciplinary action against a few workers led to
protests and, subsequently, into police action, causing not only grievous injuries to the
workers in a police lathi charge, but it also resulted in a production loss of eight to ten
days for the Honda factory.
http://www.blonnet.com/2006/04/12/stories/2006041203780100.htm
Australia, Europe and many other countries, by attacking the computers of government agencies and
multinational corporations.
In fact, cyber terrorism has made life easy for international terrorists whose words of hatred, and
instructions to their followers around the world, can be relayed so easily. Although governments of the world
are seized of this problem, and each country is planning to implement cyber crime prevention laws, international
agencies will do well to coordinate with each other to ensure they move faster than the criminals on the Net to
provide a safe and secure business environment to international firms.
Exercise
India primarily exports, labor-intensive manufactured goods, such as gems and jewelry, handicrafts, textile
product, etc. and imports items such as petroleum, raw materials, and metals. Analyse the impact of the
following events.
www.bitbookwala.in
Political Factors and Environment 141
REFERENCES
1. “The Times”, August 5, 2006.
2. “The United States-Cuba Relationship A Time for Change”, Colonel Ralph J. Capio, USA
Fand Christopher J. Capio.
3. Changing Concepts of Sovereignty: Can The United Nations Keep Pace, Muscatine IA;
the Stanley Foundation, 1992 Page 7.
4. Harry C Triandis, “The Self and Social Behavior in Differing Cultural Contexts”
Psychological Review July 1989, Vol.96, Page 506-520.
5. Joseph A Schumpeter, Capitalism, Socialism And Democracy / New York Harper and
Collins 1947.
6. The Newsweek October 16, 2006, George Wehrfritz, Growth or Happiness? pp. 44-45.
7. The News Today Special Story by V. Sundaram.
8. Sons of Soil, Immigrants and Civil Wars, James D Fearson, David D. Laitin, Stanford
University.
9. Business India, December 2006.
BIT BOOK WALA
10. Wikipedia, the free encyclopaedia
11. Market Realities Soften Bolivian Nationalisation. C. Gopinath, Business Line, Nov. 13,
2006.
12. “Myanmar Crumbling Kit”, Asia Week, March 2001, P.8, And “Catastrophe”,
www.economist.com, March 20, 2003.
13. North Korea’s Nuclear Gamble, Selig S. Harrison, The Newsweek, October 16, 2006,
p. 31.
14. Rhea Gala, Isis Press Release 03/05/05.
WEBSITES VISITED
1. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/articl
2. http://www.airpower.maxwell.af.mil/airchronicles/cc/cuba2.html
3. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sino-American_relations.
4. http://www.newstodaynet.com/2006sud/06aug/2308ss1.htm
5. http://iicas.ucsd.edu/papers/GTCconf/s.oil11.pdf
6. http://www.blonnet.com/2006/11/13/stories/2006111300020900.htm
7. http://www.asiaweek.com/asiaweek
8. http://www.economist.com/index.html
www.bitbookwala.in
142 International MarketingText and Cases
9. http//www.newsweekInternational.com
10. http://www.i-sis.org.uk/IBTCF.php
11. http://www.blonnet.com/2006/04/12/stories/
1. Amine, Lyn S. “The Need for Moral Champions in Global Marketing.” European Journal
of Marketing, 30 (May 1996):81.
2. Epstein, M.J., and M.J. Roy. Strategic Learning through Corporate Environment Man-
agement: Implementing the ISO 14001 Standard, INSEAD’s Center for the Management
of Environmental Resources (1997).
3. Howell, Llewellyn D. and Brad Chaddick, “An Assessment of Three Approaches to Politi-
cal Risk”, Columbia Journal of World Business (fall 1994): 71-91.
4. Ohmae, K. “Putting Global Logic First.” Harvard Business Review (January/February
1995): 119-125.
5. Ohmae, Kenichi. The Borderless World. New York: Harper Perennial, 1991.
6. Robock, Stephan H., and Kenneth Simmonds. International Business and Multinational
Enterprises. Homewood, IL: Irwin, 1989.
7. Root, Franklin R. Entry Strategies for International Markets. New York: Lexington
Books, 1994. BIT BOOK WALA
8. Samuels, Barbara C. Managing Risk in Developing Countries: National Demands and
Multinational Response. Princeton, NJ: Prinston University Press, 1990.
9. Vagts, Detlev. Transnational Business Problems. Mineola, NY: The Foundation Press,
1986.
1. The term collectivism when used in political parlance refers to a political system that stresses the
primacy of
(a) Collective goal. (b) Individual goal.
(c) Selective goal. (d) all of these.
(e) None of these.
2. The social democrats held the view that socialism could be achieved by
(a) Democratic means. (b) Dictatorship.
(c) Totalitarianism. (d) all of these.
(e) None of these.
3. Social democratic parties have been in power from time to time in these countries.
(a) Australia and France. (b) Germany and Great Britain.
www.bitbookwala.in
Political Factors and Environment 143
7.
BIT BOOK WALA
(e) Welfare and interest of all is important.
Expropriation of Firm’s Assets refers to the situation when an international marketing firm’s
assets are
(a) Controlled by the host country government.
(b) Decontrolled by the host country government.
(c) Seized by the host country government against nominal compensation.
(d) Confiscated by the host country government without compensation.
(e) Released by the host country government.
8. Domestication refers to the situation when host country insists on
(a) Using locally manufactured raw material for manufacturing products of international firms.
(b) Gradual transfer of ownership and management of International Firms to Local Managers.
(c) Not permitting repatriation of funds and profits above a certain limit and insisting on profits
being deployed back in local industry.
(d) Fixing up the local content of raw material requirement of certain percentage for all foreign
owned manufacturing firms.
(e) all of these.
9. When the governments for the cause of social benefits decide to move the property and assets
of business from private hands to government sponsored public sector undertakings or agen-
cies it is called
(a) Nationalization of Business Assets.
(b) Confiscation of International Firm’s Property.
www.bitbookwala.in
144 International MarketingText and Cases
REVIEW QUESTIONS
www.bitbookwala.in
Chapter 8
Learning Objectives
The reader should be able to
• understand how legal systems of the world affect international marketing
• differentiate between home country, host country and international laws
• differentiate between common law, code law and theocratic law
• explain international dispute settlement procedures.
www.bitbookwala.in
146 International MarketingText and Cases
SECTION 1:
INTERNATIONAL LEGAL ENVIRONMENT: AN INTRODUCTION
T he legal environment of a country pertains to the rules, laws and the constitutional provisions that
regulate the behaviour of the citizens, residents of the country and business and other entities, along with
the process by which countries enforce the laws and provide redressal systems to all for their grievances. The
legal system of a country is of immense importance to not only local business organisations but also to
international business firms. The laws of a country regulate business practices, define the manner in which
business transactions are to be executed and set down the rights and duties and obligations that each party to
business must adhere to. The legal environments of countries differ in significant ways, in relation to the type
of government a country has adopted. In the chapter on International Political Environment, which deals with
the kinds of governments a country can opt for, an oblique reference was made to the legalities of rights and
duties a country’s government allows to its citizens, depending on the constitutional authority adopted by the
country. The political systems define the legal systems too, like they give shape to the economic policies of the
state. Such political systems and the governments construct and define the legal framework to do business. If
a country has opted for a democratic set up, it becomes evident that the laws of the country will also be pro
individual, whereas in a totalitarian state the legal rights of the state will overrule the importance of the
individual and rules governing common business by public sector agencies will be laid down.
This chapter will focus on the basics of different legal systems of the world that affect the international flow
of business and marketing. It will also discuss the laws that affect an international marketing organisation in its
home country, in the countries where its business and marketing network are set up and also in countries where
SECTON 2:
LEGAL FRAMEWORKS
Internationally, business gets affected by three main legal frameworks when it spreads into multi-country
operations:
(a) International Laws International bodies comprising different country memberships set up and
regulate their rules and regulations with mutual consent. Such rules are common for every one and each
member country must agree to abide by the same. Such international laws refer to the agreements, treaties,
conventions, understandings (for example, WTO) and resolutions reached between the counties on trade,
protection of physical and intellectual property, protection of life and liberty of each other’s citizens when
they’re away on business and visits to each other’s territory and many other issues in the political and
economic sphere. Though such laws cannot be enforced by any individual constitutional authority of one
specific country, they come into force because international law bodies enforcing them are created by member
countries with common welfare in mind and, hence, they agree to abide by it. The international law enforcement
bodies authorised by all member signatories adopt the redressal procedures established by such agreements.
www.bitbookwala.in
Legal Aspects and International Marketing 147
Common to such practice are law on international sale of goods (uniform law on sales and uniform laws on
contract for international sale of goods).
(b) Host Country Laws International marketing firms will abide by the laws of the country in which
they operate. For example French firm TOTAL must abide by the trade and business practices laws of India for
all its marketing operations within the Indian territory. These laws are not the same as the company is subjected
to in its country of origin. The same company while doing business in France is subjected to the French
commercial laws.
(c) Home Country Laws The laws and rules and regulations laid down by each government in its
own country become the home country laws for all companies and businesses originating from that country.
For example, even though Pepsi and Coke have operations in many countries, for them the laws of their home
country, the United States, are as important, and some times more important, than those of the host country,
even though they may be registered for their other country operations externally. Thus home country’s laws
bind all originating companies all over the world. The United States companies must abide by all three types of
laws: International Bodies Rules and Regulations, Laws of the United States covering the International Trades
and Practices and Host Country Laws that will govern their day-to-day operations. These companies will also
be subjected to home country laws pertaining to dealings with that host country and other common laws, like
Anti-Trust Regulations, Anti-Corruption Laws and the U.S. Corporate Governance Rules and Regulations, as
applicable to firms abroad.
This discussion focuses on some basic differences in the legal systems and how their differences affect
international trade and commerce. The discussion will also include contract laws and the laws governing
BIT BOOK WALA
property rights, with main focus on patents, copyrights and trade marks. In international marketing operations,
firms as well as nations are equally concerned about their products’ safety to end user and to the environment.
They are equally serious about the liabilities that may arise on account of product failures/ commitments.
Hence, the discussion will also include laws governing product safety and product liability.
SECTION 3:
DIFFERENT LEGAL SYSTEMS
The world over, countries ascribe to three main legal systems, i.e. Common Laws, Civil Laws and Theocratic
Laws.
Common Law This is based on traditions, precedents and customs followed for centuries in a country.
Tradition refers to a country’s legal history, precedent to the legal cases and the decisions given by the courts
of law in the country in the past and the manners and ways in which laws have been applied to specific
situations historically by the courts of law. Common law has its roots in the English common law. Even the
United States law system is based on the English common law. Majority of the Commonwealth countries,
including Australia and Canada, share this system of law. Common law “seeks interpretation through the past
decisions of the higher courts which interpret the same statutes or apply established and customary principles
of law to a similar set of facts,”1.
Civil Law Also known as code law, this is based on a very detailed set of laws that are organised into
codes. These codes specify what constitutes legal behaviour. Code law or civil law has its roots in the Roman
1. Phillip R. Cateora and John L.Graham, International Marketing, New Delhi, Tata McGraw Hill 2001, p 167.
www.bitbookwala.in
148 International MarketingText and Cases
law and more than 80 countries of the world, including Germany, France, Japan, Russia, most of Europe, Latin
America, China, Taiwan and South Korea operate with this civil law system. The judicial courts rely upon the
detailed written legal codes rather than interpretation of tradition, precedent and customs. The courts under
this system do not have much flexibility, as compared to the courts of common law system. The judicial and
legal interpretation, as in common law, are not resorted to because written laws do not need definition but
application by the courts.
Theocratic Law This system is based on religious teachings, as they are enshrined in the religious
scriptures. Islamic law, Sha’riat, is the most widely practiced religious legal system in today’s world. It is based
on morality rather than commercial requirement of human behaviour in all aspects of a person’s self and social
life. Islamic law is based on the Holy book of Islam the Koran and on interpretation of the practices and sayings
of Prophet Mohammad. It also follows the writings of scholars and teachers of Islamic scholarship, who
derived rules by analogy from the principles established in the holy Koran. The basic foundations of Islamic
law remain unaltered even after many centuries because they have been derived from the holy book and are
acceptable to all devout Muslims. Even though Islamic jurists and scholars constantly debate the application
of Islamic law to the modern world, their debates are only scholastic deliberations. However, to keep pace with
the advancement of life , many Muslim countries have a blend of common law and civil law system along with
the Shari’at law.
Islamic law is not necessarily confined to moral behaviour. Its practices are applied to commercial and
business dealings too, which can definitely affect an international firm’s dealings in an Islamic country. For
example, the purdah system ordains segregation of sexes, meaning women must not interact with strangers
(men) and this applies to business relations as well. The Shari’at law also prohibits the consumption of
BIT BOOK WALA
alcoholic products and pork, etc. The law ordains praying five times each day and to fast for month during
Ramzan. All these practices can affect the operations of a firm in Islamic countries in North Africa, Middle East,
Pakistan, Bangladesh, Malaysia, Indonesia, parts of India and many other regions of world.
Another important factor to be considered is the treatment of interest earnings in Islamic law. The payment
or receipt of interest under any condition is considered sinful and is banned by the Koran. Many Islamic states
have already declared the calculation of interest unlawful. In the 1990s, Pakistan federal Shari’at law court, the
highest law making body in the country, declared interest against the tenets of Islam and therefore illegal. It
directed the Pakistan government to amend all financial laws of the country and prohibit application of interest.
In 1999, the Pakistan Supreme Court ruled that Islamic banking system should be enforced in the country after
July 2001. Islamic banks are found in addition to Pakistan in many parts of the Gulf states, Egypt and Malaysia
and collectively they manage assets beyond $ 300 billion by Islamic banking practices.
Contract Law and its Application in Different Legal Systems While marketing their
products and services internationally, the usage of contract by firms is quite essential as they are frequently
entering into contracts and agreements with various allies, partners, franchisees and other service providers all
over the globe. The firms may have to enter into such contracts for collaborations, technical consultancies, and
distribution of their products and services. Hence, these firms need to look at all contracts minutely and
sensitively. The approach to contract law is widely different in common law and code (civil) law. A contract can
be defined as a document that specifies the conditions under which the exchange agreement has to take place
and assigns the rights and obligations of each party signatory to this contract. All business transactions
mentioned above are regulated and implemented by some form of contract, which is enforced and governed by
some contract law of different legal systems. International firms may have to resort to the contract law if either
of the signatories, e.g. the firm itself or the other partner, feels aggrieved due to violation in letter or spirit of the
contract agreement.
www.bitbookwala.in
Legal Aspects and International Marketing 149
Under the common law in many countries, a firm may have to spell out the details in the contract, with all
contingencies, clauses and penalties, etc., specific for non-compliance and non-enforcement, even though the
judges under the common law system have greater flexibility in interpreting the dispute to the contract in the
light of circumstantial evidence and prevailing situations. Under common law, it takes much longer to settle a
dispute. In countries governed by code laws, however, different codes spell out the legalities of contractual
obligations and the contract is generally drawn on the basis of these codes only. Hence, it is not necessary to
draw out detailed contingencies. It is important for the international marketing managers to understand which
law the country of operations is following and then draw up the contract and seek redressal accordingly.
Jurisdiction When contract disputes arise in international marketing, there is always a question as to
which country’s legal provisions become applicable on that dispute and which court’s law can provide quick
redressal, i.e. international law, home country law or host country law. Again, it may so happen that the firms will
agree at the time of formation of the contract itself about the jurisdiction of the court. The sales contract or any
other contract drawn by both the parties may specify, subject to jurisdiction of courts for example a French
firm entering into contract with Indian partner may specify all disputes arising out of this contract will be
subject to Paris jurisdiction. In that case, the signatories may file suits in a court in Paris. Even if the firm files
a case or legal complaint outside, in a third country, laws applicable for settling such a dispute in Paris will be
resorted to in this case.
However, in the absence of any such stipulation, the question is, which law will govern the dispute: (1)
where the contract was entered into? (2) where the contract has been executed? In the international commercial
scenario, dispute settlement system for settling issues between two different nationalities exist even though
SECTION 4:
INTERNATIONAL DISPUTE SETTLEMENT PROCESSES
Litigation in common or civil courts can cause bad blood between the parties in dispute because both, the
buyers and sellers, can ill afford to earn a bad name for themselves for non-compliance of contracts. It can affect
a firm’s business prospects with other international clients too. Hence, companies will usually try to reach an
amicable settlement through informal processes, be it informal conciliation or arbitration by involving a
(uninterested to the cause) third party.
1. Mediation This is also known as conciliation. It involves a third party that tries to settle the dispute
between two aggrieved firms by resolving their differences. The third party’s patient hearing of the problem
may suggest alternative ways out of the dispute and for reaching a compromise. Such compromises can be
referred to or quoted in any court of law, should any of the parties not agree to the solution. This process of
dispute settlement helps maintain future business ties in international trade too. Since the interests of both the
aggrieved and the complainant parties are taken care of in a softer manner, these are preferred by Chinese
businessmen, who seldom like to lose a good business prospect.
www.bitbookwala.in
150 International MarketingText and Cases
2. Arbitration In order to enter arbitration for dispute settlement, companies may agree to appoint a third
party as a referee, or an arbitrator, whose decision will be acceptable to both the parties. The arbitration process
involves referring to either domestic country-specific arbitration rules or to the rules of any agency involved in
the international arbitration process. The International Court of Arbitration, under the aegis of International
Chamber of Commerce in Paris, is quite active in such dispute settlements. It has standardised the rules and
procedures to administer arbitration, which have been adopted by a majority of the independent countries and
their arbitration courts. Besides the chambers of commerce, a few other active arbitration commissions and
councils are:
(a) Inter-American Commercial Arbitration Commission
(b) The Canadian-American Commercial Arbitration Commission
(c) London Court Of Arbitration
SECTION 5:
OTHER LEGAL ISSUES
Property Rights Legally, the term property means a resource over which an individual or firm or a
business holds a legal title, which they are then said to own. Here, resources do not refer only to a building,
land, machinery, equipment, capital and minerals alone. It also means inventions, trademarks, brands, ideas and
a firm’s registered name, which are all covered under intellectual property. Each individual or firm’s property
rights are upheld in different countries under the legal systems they operate within. The definition and the
protection that laws provide may not be enforced in many countries. Hence, an international firm should be well
BIT BOOK WALA
aware of the legal definition of private as well as public property rights in each country they want to do
business with and the protection provision offered by the laws of the land. Property rights may get violated in
two ways, through private action and by public action, i.e. by the governments themselves or by the
representative agencies of the country’s government.
Private Action This refers to theft, piracy, blackmail, encroachments, fraud, etc., by individuals or
groups of offenders. Such crimes can occur in any part of the world, including the home country of the firm, but
how the law of the land differs from country to country.
The action may be swift and quick in the U.S., Germany and England and many other European countries but
it may take ages to get the case sorted out in the civil and criminal legal procedures of many other parts of the
world, where the corrupt police system and lackadaisical attitude of the judiciary can frustrate a complainant. It
has happened in many parts of the world where the governments and law enforcement agencies have provided
scant protection to both domestic as well as foreign organisations. Many tea companies in the North-East in
India have borne the brunt of kidnapping and extortions by extremists, as is evident by the news report
reproduced below:
Assam police deny bias in targeting, in the case of tea companies, “while we posses the
information and we lack direct evidence against them.” Ever since the incidents of
Assam-based tea companies funding militants such as the United Liberation Front of
Asom and the National Democratic Front of Bodoland became public, the Tatas have
claimed they are being singled out by the state administration. Little investigation has
been carried out against other tea companies, they charged. Some of the other tea
companies named by the Assam police who had allegedly financed extremists are
www.bitbookwala.in
Legal Aspects and International Marketing 151
Goodricke and Williamson Magor (formerly MacNeill & Magor). The controversy has caused
a furor in the Rs 22 billion tea industry in Assam. A top police source confirmed that the
Williamson Magor group had provided the maximum funding to the outlawed groups. He,
however, added that although some of the money was given under compulsion, a sizeable
amount was given voluntarily to buy peace.
Williamson Magor has 50 tea estates in the Brahmaputra valley alone, producing 50
million kilograms of tea per year. Police sources informed that payments to the militants
— both as ransom as well as regular quarterly payments — were finalised by the company’s
top management. The police may summon the head of the Williamson Magor group to
unearth the “clandestine” deals.
“We can understand the compulsion of ransom paid to secure the release of abducted
executives, but what about the Rs 1.3 million to Rs 1.4 million being paid quarterly to
the militants? There were no immediate compulsions to Magor and they are paid rather
voluntarily to buy peace,” the sources added.
Source: Extracted and adapted from the rediff on the net by Syed Firdaus Ashraf.
Similarly, successful businessmen in Russia have to pay protection money to the mafia or face violent action
from them. 1995-96 saw hundreds of businessmen killed in Russia because they did not pay this protection
money. Businessmen in United States too had been harassed by the mafia in the early 1930s, when their grip
over Chicago was virtually complete. The history of Japan in this field is also similar, where the yakuza charged
BIT BOOK WALA
protection money from the food and entertainment industry. Mumbai’s protection rackets and kidnapping in
northern and eastern parts of India speak volumes about the nexus between the police and the criminals, as in
many other countries too. Such conditions can prevail in any country and international firms need to know the
weapons and the strengths of the law enforcement agencies in providing protection.
Public Action This refers to the situation where law makers themselves, their agents and representatives,
bureaucrats and members of public bodies, local members of legislative assemblies indulge in law-breaking
activities, such as extortion, confiscation of legal property of others, encroachment and other resources
gobbling activities. This is done by dangling the threats of action, citing government rules and action to the
firms or by indulging in heavy taxation, introducing ceiling laws, bringing in licensing procedures,
redistribution of wealth to the have-nots, etc. This is also done by appropriating the firm’s property into state
ownership without compensation or handing over the property to another owner without compensating the
earlier owner. Again corruption, nepotism and demanding gratification, bribes, undue favours seep into every
society, be it a democratic country, monarchy or dictatorship - the White House, the Royal Dutch family,
Japanese politicians, Indian leaders, bureaucrats, Pakistani government and army officers, police departments,
revenue departments, of all countries. If the Bofors gun can raise eyebrows in India, the Watergate scandal can
question Nixon’s honesty and Suharto’s demands in Indonesia, all countries can have some form or the other
public corruption. What matters for the international firm is to understand the stand law takes in the event a firm
approaches it for redressal. In many countries corruption is treated illegal and public vigilance departments
take or initiate action, whereas in many others it becomes a way of life and the loot continues.
Anti Corruption Laws These laws are instituted by countries to prevent business organisations from
using unethical means to wield undue influence over those who control the flow of business activities in the
country. Such authorities as government officers, public servants, elected representatives and law makers, who
www.bitbookwala.in
152 International MarketingText and Cases
can decide the fate of government contracts, business deals, and civil and military policies of the country are
susceptible to many undue favours in the shape of gifts, share holdings, hard cash within and outside their
country from the business community of the world. Their decisions can alter the competitive advantage,
favouring a company over its business rivals. To prevent such a situation, anti-corruption laws modulate the
code of conduct of public servants in international deals and also for business within the country. Any
www.bitbookwala.in
Legal Aspects and International Marketing 153
violation is strictly dealt with in many nations. Many government heads themselves encourage institution of
corrupt practices. In a World Bank survey conducted in 69 countries, covering 3,600 companies, it was found
that more than 40 percent of them had paid bribes to secure favours. This figure jumped to 60 percent in the
former Soviet Union. Although in industrially developed counties only 15 percent had to resort to corrupt
practices to get business, it is a telling situation where no country is free from corrupt ways. The European
Bank for Reconstruction and Development, a bank that encourages investments in the former Soviet Bloc, has
often regretted the widespread corruption in these countries and calls such bribe-seeking a deterrent to foreign
investments.2
Foreign Corrupt Practices Act The United States had passed the foreign corrupt practices act in
the 1970s, following revelations that U.S. companies had given bribes to government officials in foreign
countries in order to get lucrative contracts. The law makes it illegal to bribe a foreign government official for
obtaining or maintaining a business that can be influenced by a foreign official. This law requires all public
traded companies, whether or not they are involved in international marketing, to keep detailed records that will
allow auditors to determine whether a violation of act has occurred. In 1997, almost along the same line, the
trade and commerce ministers of the member states of Organisation for Economic Cooperation and
Development (OECD), an association of the world’s 30 most powerful economies, adopted the convention on
combating bribery of foreign public officials in international business transactions. The convention makes it
obligatory for the member countries to make the bribery of foreign public officials a criminal offence. However,
this act is also not a foolproof anti-corruption device, as the same act in circumferential words allows expenses
known as facilitating or expediting payments. The OECD convention also follows suit and permits what is
called grease payments or speed payments for performing routine duties in expediting business of the
BIT BOOK WALA
government departments. Bribes in the form of small payments to officials to speed up the issuance of permits,
licenses or processing paperwork and, in addition, getting clearances from the dockyards, etc., are facilitated
by the foreign firms. The law enforcers consider these payments of gratification less offensive and are
considered gifts to petty foreign government officers.
The Protection of Intellectual Property Intellectual property is the most vulnerable property of
any firm to protect, as duplicity and counterfeiting of products, misuse of popular brands, undue advantage
from the popularity of internationally well-accepted products by adopting similar sounding phoney names,
etc., are some ways that violators of intellectual property adopt all over the world to make billions of dollars.
The billions of dollars spent on research can all go waste should there be one small leakage of inventions in the
pipeline by a multinational. Hence, international firms need to be aware of the intellectual property laws and
regulations adopted by countries all over the world, in addition to the international institutional protection
systems available to the firm in case of violation in either the host country or even a country in which it does
not have any operations but still the business gets affected due to such pilferages and violations.
Internationally, losses attributed to the violations of intellectual property rights in different industries, e.g.
pharmaceuticals, software, industrial inventions, entertainment and publishing may run into many billion
dollars. A rough estimate of the losses by the software industry alone amounts to more than $12 billion and in
pharmaceutical $11 billion. The entertainment industry suffers an estimated loss of $ 10 to $ 12 billion annually.
(ibid). The threat from the piracy on the Internet, the unauthorised downloads and also the hacking of the sites
by unauthorised access may run into another billion dollars or so.
2. Jack G. Kaikati, George M.Sullivan,John M . Virgo, T.R. Carr and Katherine S. Virgo, “The Price of International
Business Morality: Twenty Years under the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act,” Journal of Business Ethics, Vol.26.
No.3, August 2000, Pp.213-222.
www.bitbookwala.in
154 International MarketingText and Cases
Intellectual Property refers to property that is the product of intellectual activity, e.g. computer software, a
screenplay, a literary work, a music score, an industrial invention, or a chemical formula for a drug, a formula for
any other chemical invention, etc. Ownership over these intellectual properties is established by patents,
copyrights and trademarks.
A Patent grants the inventor of a new product or new process exclusive rights for a defined period for
manufacture, use or sale of that invention.
Copyrights are the exclusive legal rights of authors, composers, playwrights, artists and publishers to
publish and distribute their works as they deem fit.
Trademarks are the designs, names and brands often officially registered by which merchants,
manufacturers and the producers designate and differentiate their works and products from others, e.g. Calvin
Klein and Christian Dior in clothes or Channel Five, Eu de cologne perfume. In the high technology knowledge
economy of 21st century, intellectual property contributes huge economic values to business as knowledge can
now be converted into digital form and can be copied and distributed at a very low cost all over the globe. At
such a stage, institutionalising and implementations of intellectual property laws play a crucial role in ensuring
equitable and justified rewards to the inventors and originators of new ideas, inventions, designs and efforts.
Only such laws will ensure that human efforts to get breakthroughs in technology and science will continue.
The protection of intellectual property rights differs from country to country. While many countries have
very stringent laws to deal with the offences, the will to enforce such laws is missing. Such is the case with
many countries out of a list of 164 signatories who have signed the Paris Convention for the Protection of
Industrial Property, a landmark international agreement to protect intellectual property. It is obvious that weak
implementation by the state authorities encourages piracy, counterfeiting and fake copies, leading to the theft
BIT BOOK WALA
of billions of dollars of intellectual property.
China and Thailand have been the worst offenders recently in Asia. Pirated versions of computer software
are freely available in China. Similarly, counterfeit copies of Rolex watches, Levi Strauss jeans, videotapes and
computer software can be found on the streets of Bangkok. Piracy and forging are quite rampant in all parts of
the world in music and entertainment industry. The International Federation of Pornographic Industry claims
that one-third of all CDs and cassettes around the globe were illegally produced and sold in the year 2002,
costing the industry over $ 4.6 billion in terms of revenue.
The computer software industry also suffered a lax enforcement attitude of law implementers and the losses
of this industry on account of piracy ran as high as $14 billion. As per the Business Software Alliance, a
software industry association, in 2002 some 40 percent of all software applications used in the world were
pirated. The worst region was Eastern Europe, where the piracy was as high as 71 percent. In China, the piracy
rate in the same year was as high as 92 percent and the loss to the industry amounted to almost $2.5 billion,
jumping from $450 million just five years ago. In the United States, the losses from piracy can go up to $ 2.5 to
$3.00 billion.
The impact of software piracy can be seen when the official pricing of the original Microsoft Office
Professional is compared with that of the pirated version.3 In Lebanon, the official original version is priced at
$200, as against which the pirated version is available for as low as $ 7.
Trade Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) Protection from the
infringements of copyrights can be granted only by the respective countries if they are alert and diligent in
dealing with cases of violations of individual rights. International firms too will have to be vigilant about the
counterfeits, poor copies and duplicates of their products and brand marks being marketed by impostors all
3. James Schofield, “Beating Piracy Proves To Be No Soft Touch”, Financial Times, 1 April, 1999, P.7.
www.bitbookwala.in
Legal Aspects and International Marketing 155
across the world and take up the necessary steps at the highest levels of their own governments and also the
host governments. Such lobbying will have to be managed at all international forums to ensure that their
intellectual property rights are safeguarded. The firms should also fight all possible court cases to ensure that
laws are actually utilised by the respective courts of the country. Many times, it is seen that in the absence of
a complaint, the necessary legal actions are not pursued. It is due to lobbying by many international firms that,
for the first time, the world trade agreement included intellectual property rights within the ambit of The General
Agreement on Trade and Tariff in 1994. Under the new arrangement, a fresh agreement has been signed by the
member countries of WTO, wherein a council of the World Trade Organization is overseeing enforcement of
much stricter regulations concerning intellectual property rights. This new agreement is known as Trade
Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights or TRIPs. The regulations under TRIPS make it mandatory for
WTO members to grant and enforce patents lasting at least 20 years and copyrights lasting 50 years. Advanced
nations had to comply with the rules within the first year of having signed this agreement. Poor countries where
the implementation of protection rights would have been a bit difficult had been given five years to enforce
these laws and the backward nations had been given 10 years to ensure legislation of intellectual copyrights.
These firms will have to fight it out for their rights themselves, by taking recourse to legal provisions already
available in different countries. The firms can also boycott the countries where the record of safeguarding
copyrights and patent rights is not very encouraging. The firms will also have to ensure the counterfeit
versions of their products are not allowed to spread all over the world, particularly in the home country of the
firm and the country where their products are preferred. Such a legal battle may take a long time but it pays to
fight for patent rights ,as can be seen from the grit shown by Pfizer in China.
BIT BOOK
PFIZER WINS WALA
VIAGRA RULING IN CHINA
U.S. drug maker Pfizer has won a landmark legal battle in China, with a local court
upholding the validity of the patent for Viagra and ordering two Chinese companies to
pay compensation for infringing on the registered trade mark.
The Beijing No. 1 Intermediate People’s Court ordered Beijing Health New Concept
Pharmaceuticals and Jiangsu-based Lianhuan Pharmaceutical to stop sales and
production of blue rhomboid pills similar to Viagra and pay Yuan 600,000 ($76,726) to
Pfizer.
Pfizer sued the two companies in September 2005, claiming “Weige” the Chinese name
of Viagra, which they sold and produced, infringed on the registered trade mark of
Viagra.
Source: News Adopted from the Economic Times, 29 December, 2006
Anti-Trust Laws Home and host countries, both, would like to prevent their industry from getting
monopolistic and anti-competitive, as such anti-consumer association virtually acts as a blockade for fair
competition and leads to undue exploitation of the general consumer. It also acts as an unfair barrier for a
country’s industrial and trade development. Such protective measures are generally adopted by the host
country’s trade and industrial association to create barriers for the foreign firms in the shape of mergers of
competitors to form bigger conglomerates or even adopting price cartels, distribution cartels and
manufacturing cartels. In Japan, it has been quite noticeable, as it is in India too, that the local industry of many
products had adopted unfair trade practices. In order to ensure a fair competitive strategy, the countries
www.bitbookwala.in
156 International MarketingText and Cases
legislate the anti-trust laws. In India, the Monopoly and Restrictive Trade Practices Act (MRTP) is one such act
that prevents the formation of monopolies and cartels. The United States was the first to legislate and
implement its anti-trust laws on firms originating in the United States and also on those trading abroad.
Similarly other countries are also enacting such legislations.
REFERENCES
1. Phillip R. Cateora and John L.Graham, International Marketing, New Delhi, Tata McGraw
Hill 2001, p 167.
2. News from www.rediff.com, by Syed Firdaus Ashraf.
3. Business Standard, Ahmedabad, 29 December, 2006, Amy Kazmin, Bangkok.
4. Jack G. Kaikati, George M.Sullivan, John M. Virgo, T.R. Carr and Katherine S. Virgo, “The
Price of International Business Morality: Twenty Years under the Foreign Corrupt Prac-
tices Act”, Journal of Business Ethics, Vol. 26. No. 3, August 2000, Pp. 213-222.
5. James Schofield, “Beating Piracy Proves To Be No Soft Touch”, Financial Times, 1 April,
1999, P. 7.
6. The Economic Times, Ahmedabad, 29 December, 2006.
7. Charles Hill, International Business, McGraw-Hill.
8. Justin Paul, International Business, 3rd Edition.
BIT BOOK WALA
WEBSITES VISITED
1. http://www.rediff.com/news
2. www.uspto.gov
3. www.european-patent- office-org
www.bitbookwala.in
Legal Aspects and International Marketing 157
5. Kaikati, Jack and Wayne A. Label, “The Foreign Anti Bribery Law: Friend Or Foe?”
Columbia Journal of World Business (Spring 1980) Pp. 46-51.
6. Neimanis. G.J. “Business Ethics in Former Soviet Union: A Report”, Journal of
Business Ethics, 16, February 1997, Pp. 357-362.
7. Slomanson William R., Fundamental Perspectives on International Law, St. Paul, MN.
West Publishing 1990.
8. Vernon Raymond “The World Trade Organization: A New Stage in International Trade
and Development”, Harvard International Law Journal, 36 Spring 1995, Pp. 329-340.
1. Internationally any business gets affected by three main legal frameworks. These legal frame-
works are
(a) International Laws. (b) Host Country Laws.
(c) Home country laws. (d) None of these.
(e) All of these.
2. The worlds over countries ascribe to three main legal systems. These legal systems are
(a) Common Laws. (b) Civil Laws.
(c) Theocratic Laws.
(e) All of these.
BIT BOOK WALA (d) None of these.
www.bitbookwala.in
158 International MarketingText and Cases
REVIEW QUESTIONS
1. How do legal systems of the world affect international marketing? Differentiate between
home country, host country and international laws.
2. What are common law, code law and theocratic law? Differentiate, with examples, from
countries following these laws.
3. Explain international dispute settlement procedures. Why would an international firm
prefer conciliation rather than arbitration? Explain with the help of examples.
4. What kind of intellectual property does an international firm possess? What steps will
you take to protect the intellectual property of your firm?
5. What do you mean by jurisdiction in international marketing disputes? How does a
marketer decide which system will be applicable to his business functioning?
www.bitbookwala.in
Chapter 9
Learning Objectives
The reader should be able to understand and explain
• the modes of global entry
• the problems and prospects of international franchising and licensing.
www.bitbookwala.in
160 International MarketingText and Cases
SECTION 1:
INTRODUCTION
T his chapter discusses the structure, framework and strategies for collaborative arrangements, as well as
the problems and challenges of going global by way of licensing franchising etc.
Some of the operating modes that a company may adopt in a foreign country as market entry mode are
wholly-owned subsidiaries, partially-owned subsidiaries, joint ventures, alliances, licensing, franchising,
management contracts and turnkey operations. There could be various reasons for a collaborative arrangement
in general, such as spread and reduce cost, specialise in competencies and avoid or counter competition. Some
of the related motives are to gain specific assets, overcome legal constraints, diversify geographically and to
minimise exposure in risky environments.
Overcome Legal Constraints Many countries limit foreign ownership and, therefore, foreign
investment companies can only enter into the franchising, licensing and alliances in those countries. The
BIT BOOK WALA
company in question often has a host of restrictions before it can enter into another country. Collaborative
agreements help organisations protect themselves and reduce the risk of Intellectual Property Rights
violations, which occur as a matter of course in foreign counties that have poor enforcement and strong piracy
cultures, as in India and China.
Diversify Geographically The companies are going international with the intention of diversifying
into different countries and to overcome the problems of different business cycles.
Minimise Exposure to Risky Environments Companies may choose to minimise the risk of
loss/seizure of assets abroad by sharing these with a local company.
SECTION 2:
MARKET ENTRY MODES: FRAMEWORK AND STRUCTURE
There are various forms of collaborative arrangements. Licensing is one example. In licensing, the capital
commitment is lower than that of a joint venture. Finding a desirable collaborative partner is another important
issue. In case of technology transfer, it may be difficult to find a partner who can match the company’s
performance and expectations. In this case it is usually easier to transfer resources within a subsidiary.
Franchising is another way of expanding overseas, with less investment by the parent company.
www.bitbookwala.in
Market Entry Modes, Framework, Structure and Strategies 161
INTERNATIONAL LICENSING
Under a licensing agreement, the licensor company grants rights to intangible property (license) to another
company for a limited period, which may be limited to one company. The intangible referred to here includes
patents, inventions, formulas, processes, designs, patterns, copyrights for literary, musical or artistic
compositions, trademarks, trade names, procedures and systems. The licensee pays royalty in exchange.
Licensing may be adopted when the volume of products is not large enough to warrant the establishment of a
separate facility for manufacturing or production. The licensor is obliged to furnish technical information. Such
an arrangement exists in which technology changes are very frequent, such as in the semiconductor market.
In some countries, the licensor has often asked for higher royalties in case the licensee starts exports of the
product. In most cases the transfer of technology or grant of license also involves consultation and other fees.
In certain cases, the newest technology may be longer lasting and, hence, more useful in terms of benefits to
the licensee. In some cases, however, the new technology may be worthless in case it does not succeed and is
a failure.
The transfer of technology may not always pertain to a totally different collaborator. In some cases, the
BIT BOOK WALA
transfer may be directed towards the subsidiary as this is regarded as a separate legal entity by law. Licensing
is common in manufacturing industries.
INTERNATIONAL FRANCHISING
Franchising is a specialised form of licensing. Here, the franchiser sells an independent franchisee the use of
intangible property (say a trademark) essential to the franchisee’s business and also operationally assists the
business on a continuing basis, say through sales, promotion and training.
As part of the continuing relationship, it offers economies and standardisation through central purchasing.
A franchiser and a franchisee act almost like a vertically integrated company because the parties are
interdependent and each produces part of the product that ultimately reaches the consumer.
The advantages of franchising are:
• Good locations can be secured through franchising.
• Government or legal restrictions can overcome through franchising because, otherwise, it is difficult to
get operating permission (countries with the restrictions on Foreign Direct Investment)
• Reduces the potential risks of directly operating overseas.
The disadvantage is that the acceptance of the franchising concept depends very much on the existence of
awareness, education, quality and brand building exercises.
Success for a domestic franchiser comes from three factors: Product and service standardisation, high
identification through promotion and effective cost controls
The dilemma here is that the more globally a product is standardised, the potentially lower its acceptance in
a foreign country.
www.bitbookwala.in
162 International MarketingText and Cases
MANAGEMENT CONTRACTS
Management contracts are the means by which a company may transfer a part of its management personnel to
assist a foreign company for a specified period for a fee. Thus, with management contracts, the host country
gets the assistance it wants without needing FDI and the management company receives income without
having to make a capital outlay.
TURNKEY OPERATIONS
Turnkey operations are a type of entry mode in which one company contracts another to build, complete,
ready-to-operate facilities. Turnkey operations are most commonly performed by construction and industrial
equipment companies and they are often commissioned by a government agency. This works based on the
build, operate and transfer basis.
The size of the contracts in turnkey operations is often very big, to the tune of hundreds of millions of
dollars, which means a few large companies account for most of the international market.
SECTION 3:
GLOBAL MARKET ENTRY MODES: PROBLEMS AND CHALLENGES
Many companies’ global market operations breakdown primarily because partners
• view the arrangements different
•
• BIT BOOK WALA
have different objectives for the franchisee/licensee etc.
disagree on control issues or fail to provide sufficient direction
• perceive they contribute more than their counterparts do.
Different partners in the collaboration give different importance and management attention to the collaborative
arrangement. Some of them are more active than the others. But, when things go wrong, the active partner
blames the less active one for its lack of attention and the less active one blames the more active partner for
making poor decisions. The difference in attention is primarily due to different sizes of the partners.
Differing Objectives Companies enter into collaborative arrangements in the international market
because they have complementary capabilities but their objectives may evolve differently over time. Common
instances being:
• One partner wants to reinvest earnings for growth, the other wants to receive dividends
• One partner may want to expand the product line and sales territory, the other may see this as compe-
tition for its wholly-owned operations
• One partner may wish to buy or sell from the venture, the other may disagree with the prices
• There may be different views among the partners in terms of performance standards
Control Problems A number of factors may influence the control methods. These include:1
• Communication systems - have heavy influence on control mechanisms - electronic control measures
may not always be available
www.bitbookwala.in
Market Entry Modes, Framework, Structure and Strategies 163
• Distance - the greater the distance, the bigger the physical and psychological differences
• The product - the more technological the product, the easier it is to implement uniform standards
• Environmental differences - the greater the environmental differences, the greater the delegation of
responsibility and the more limited the control process
• Environmental stability - the greater the instability in a country, the less relevance a standardised
measure of performance has
• Subsidiary performance - the more a subsidiary does or reports a non-variance, the less any likelihood
of interference from the headquarters
• Size of international operators - the bigger and greater the specialisation of the headquarters staff, the
more likely will extensive control be applied.
Partners Contributions A partner’s ability to contribute technology, capital or other assets may
diminish over time compared to the other partner’s ability. This weak link may cause a drag on the collaborative
arrangement, resulting in difference of opinion between the partners.
Moreover, there is a danger that one partner will use the other partner’s contributed assets, enabling it to
become a competitor.
Differences in Culture Differences in culture are primarily on two accounts, national culture and
corporate culture. Companies differ by nationality in how they evaluate the success of their operations.
• US companies tend to evaluate performance on the basis of profit, market share and specific financial
benefits.
BIT BOOK WALA
• Japanese companies tend to evaluate primarily on the strategic importance of the operation.
• European companies rely more on a balance between profitability and achieving social objectives.
Differences in corporate cultures may also create problems within the joint ventures.
For instance, one company may be accustomed to promoting managers from within, while other may open
the searches to outsiders. One may use a participatory management style, other may be authoritarian. One may
be entrepreneurial and the other risk averse.
Since the external environment changes, a company needs to continually re-examine the fit between foreign
collaboration and its strategy. The important issues are:
• How companies change their operating forms.
• How they find and negotiate with potential partners.
• What contractual provisions are most important.
• How they need to assess performance.
Dynamics of Collaborative Arrangements For a company, the cost of switching from one form
to another (say from licensing to wholly-owned) is normally very high.
Organisational tension may develop internally as a company’s international operations change and grow.
Various profit centres may perceive that they have rights to the sales in a country that the company is about to
penetrate. Legal, technical and marketing personnel may have entirely different perspectives on contracts.
In these circumstances, decisions and performance may be evaluated with a team approach. As companies
enter more collaborative arrangements, they get better performance from them. They have to choose partners
carefully and learn how to achieve better synergies.
www.bitbookwala.in
164 International MarketingText and Cases
Finding Compatible Partners It is necessary to evaluate the potential partner not only for the
resources it can supply but also for its compatibility to work with the other company. Partners can be found:
• Through monitoring journals and participating in technical conferences.
• Through social activities.
• By building a rapport with other managers and consequent introductions.
• By increasing own visibility through advertisements and trade fairs, etc.
Contractual Provisions It is not possible to anticipate all points of future disagreement and include
coverage of them in a contract, yet provisions should outline
• How to terminate the agreement if parties do not adhere to the directives.
• Methods for quality testing.
• Geographical limitations on an asset’s usage.
• Management control guidelines.
• BIT BOOK WALA
Future commitments of partners.
SECTION 4:
CONTROL STRATEGIES
Companies often have some concerns when they do try to market their product abroad, like:
• Where the decision-making power resides.
• What would be the reporting structure to headquarters.
Behind these concerns, the more fundamental concern is that of control. Control is more than just
ownership of voting rights. It is management’s planning, implementation and evaluation of performance to
ensure that the organisation meets its objectives.
Control keeps a company’s direction or strategy on track. Control is needed so that individuals would not
make decisions that endanger the entire company. For example, Allied Irish Banks (AIB) allowed its US
branches to operate independently, with hardly any control from the headquarters in Ireland. One of its foreign
exchange traders at US dealing room lost $730 million before AIB became aware of it.
There are several factors that make control difficult and in the international strategies alliance, licensing and
franchising
Some of the factors can be specified as follows.
Distance
In today’s world, because of the advancements in communication technology, it is cost efficient to
communicate with almost any corner of the world. Yet, the geographic distance and cultural disparity
separating countries increase the time, expense and the possibility of error in cross-national communications.
www.bitbookwala.in
Market Entry Modes, Framework, Structure and Strategies 165
Diversity
Differences in market size, competition, nature of the product, labour cost, the currency and a host of other
factors differentiate operations among countries. The task of evaluating performance or setting standards to
correct or improve business functions is extremely complicated.
Degree of Certainty
Control implies setting goals and developing plans to meet those goals. The industry-based data are less
complete and accurate for some countries. Also, political and economic conditions are subject to rapid change
in some locales. These factors make planning error prone.
Although these factors make control more difficult in the international context, managers still try to ensure
that foreign operations comply with the overall corporate goals and philosophies.
The aspects of the international control processes that the marketing manger should bear in the mind are:
strategic planning, decision-making process, mechanism and special situation.2
A company must adapt its resources and objectives to different and changing international markets, and
this takes planning.
(i) Strategic Planning Strategic Planning must weave a company’s objectives and capabilities with its
internal and external environments. Planning requires continuous reassessment.
The first step is to develop long-range strategic intent, an objective or mission that will hold the
organisation together over a long period, while it builds global competitive viability. Some companies would
www.bitbookwala.in
166 International MarketingText and Cases
Company will have to rank alternatives so they can easily modify as resource availability changes. This is
the next step in planning, which is implementation of strategy.
Strategic plans outline major commitments, such as what businesses the company will be in and where, and
they are less subject to re-evaluation. Operating plans formulate short-term objectives and the means to carry
them out. Although input for strategy formulation comes from all the departments, only the top-level
management can see the company’s worldwide activities and, hence, is in a better place to plan changes in
international policies.
Companies grow in size as their product lines increase in numbers. And, as they grow more dependent on
foreign operations, control becomes more complex. New structures continue to evolve to deal with this
complexity.
(ii) The Decision-making Process The higher the managerial level at which managers make
decisions, the more they are centralised. The location of decision-making may vary within the same company
over time, as well as by product, functions and country.
Some conditions favour the location of decisions in one place or the other. Basically, companies should
choose the location on the basis of a combination of the following three trade-offs:
• Balancing pressures for global integration versus for local responsiveness.
• Balancing the capabilities of its headquarters.
• Balancing the expediency versus the quality of decisions.
Companies going global through franchising and licensing etc., need to be locally responsive. Few issues
have been discussed here.
BIT BOOK WALA
CONTROL MECHANISM
Various factors influence how much control a company needs at different stages of internationalisation.
The following are the mechanisms by which a company can hold control in foreign markets.
1. Corporate Culture All the companies have certain common values that its employees share. These
constitute its corporate culture and form a control mechanism that is implicit and helps enforce the company’s
mechanisms. The incompatibility of organisational cultures is detrimental to the acceptance of knowledge,
which MNEs need to transfer from operations in one country to operations in another, to gain competitive
advantage.4
To a great extent, the degree of control that corporate headquarters imposes on the selection of top
managers for foreign subsidiaries may dictate how much formal control over the subsidiaries’ operations
corporate personnel feel is necessary.
2. Written Reports Reports are another control mechanism. Headquarters need timely reports to
allocate resources, correct plans and reward personnel. Decisions on how to use capital, personnel and
technology continue without interruption. So, reports must be frequent, accurate and up-to-date to ensure that
the objective of the multinational company in the other countries is met.
Written reports are more important in international settings than in a domestic one because the managers of
subsidiaries have much less personal contact with managers above them. Corporate managers miss out on
much of the informal communication that could tell them about the performance of foreign operations.
4. Daniels, Sullivan and Radebough, International Business, 12th Edition.
www.bitbookwala.in
Market Entry Modes, Framework, Structure and Strategies 167
MNEs use reports to identify deviations from plans that could indicate problem areas. The focus of the
reports may be to monitor short-term performance or long-term indicators that match the organisation’s
strategy
3. Comparability Different costs between licensing /franchising may prevent a meaningful comparison
of their operating performance. For example, the ratio of labour to sales for a subsidiary in one country may be
much higher than that for licensing /franchising in another country, even though unit production costs may not
differ substantially. So, the management must ensure that it is comparing relevant costs.
4. Information Systems Apart from the information needed by headquarters to evaluate the
performance of franchising /licensing, additional information is needed to plan, take action and share to
improve performance. This might include:
• Information generated for centralised coordination like cash balances. Information on external condi-
tions, such as analyses of local, political and economic conditions, so that the headquarters can plan
where to expand and constrict operations.
• Information for external reporting needs, such as to stakeholders and tax authorities.
5. Special Situations Special situation such as acquisitions, joint venture , and changes in strategies
create control problems.
1. Acquisitions Acquisition can lead to more geographic responsibilities and markets, as well as new lines
of business. Another control problem occurs when the acquiring company’s culture is very different from that
of the acquired one. BIT BOOK WALA
Attempts to centralise certain decision-making, or to change operating methods, result in distrust,
apprehension and resistance to change on the part of the acquired company.
2. Joint Venture Under Joint Venture arrangement a Foreign Company invites an outside partner to share
stock ownership in the new unit.5 The particular participation of the partners may vary with the foreign
company accepting either majority or minority stake. Ownership sharing limits the flexibility or corporate
decision-making. There are administrative mechanisms that enable a company to gain control even with a
minority equity interest. These mechanisms include spreading the remaining ownership among many
shareholders, contract stipulations that board decisions require more than majority, dividing equity into voting
and non-voting stock.
Legal Framework (Branch and Subsidiary) Companies may choose among legal forms that
affect their decision-making, taxes, maintenance of secrecy and legal liability. Most choose a subsidiary form
which is considered as a separate legal entity in many foreign countries.
When establishing foreign operation, a company has to often decide between establishing a branch or a
subsidiary. A foreign branch is a foreign operation, not legally separate from the parent company. Branch
operations are possible only if the parent company holds 100 percent ownership. A subsidiary, however, is an
FDI that is legally a separate company. The parent company controls a subsidiary through its voting stock and
through the control mechanisms. Because a subsidiary is legally separate from its parent company, legal
authorities in each country generally limit liability to the subsidiary’s assets. The concept of limited liability is
a major factor in the choice of the subsidiary form.
www.bitbookwala.in
168 International MarketingText and Cases
Types of Subsidiaries A company establishing a subsidiary in a foreign country can usually choose
from a number of alternative legal forms. In addition to differences in liability, forms vary in terms of:
• The ability of the parent company to sell its ownership
• The number of stockholders required to establish the subsidiary
• The percentage of foreigners who can serve on the board of directors
Prof Justin Paul acknowledges the data and information provided by Vineet Verma, Ashutosh.P., Kaustaub Sant, Atul
Kochhar and Krishna Kumar.
www.bitbookwala.in
Market Entry Modes, Framework, Structure and Strategies 169
Case Study
Cisco Systems
Cisco is an excellent example in successful application of international collaborative strategy. It is
the world’s largest supplier of data networking equipment and the leading global supplier of
computer networking solutions. Cisco views partnership as an essential component of strategic
growth. It has a network of alliances the world over, ranging from India to Norway and from Canada
to Brazil.
The other benefits of alliances are de-risking, limiting of capital outlay, cost effective market
expansion, additional gain in experience, process improvement and exposure to worldwide
standards of best competitive practices. Cisco has 150 employees to oversee the alliance
formation. Though the company initially tried to form alliances only with culturally similar
organisations, it later tried to form alliances with the help of a system that would enable translation
of different languages.
There are a host of partners with which Cisco working well for marketing abroad. Such mutually
beneficial alliance also enhances the brand value of the partnering company.
www.bitbookwala.in
170 International MarketingText and Cases
Tata Incorporated: This company was established in 1945 as the representative office of the Tata
Group in the United States, Canada and Latin America. Headquartered in New York, it specialises
in all facets of global trading as well as the information and financial flows related to its lines of
business. Besides, Tata Inc., sources capital goods, machinery, spares and operating consumables
for the Tata companies in India.
Tata Precision Industries: Established in 1972, Tata Precision Industries was promoted by Tata
Motors, Tata International AG and the Development Bank of Singapore. The company specialises
in high-precision machining, engineering plastic moulded parts and tool design.
Tata International AG: Tata International AG is the international investment and holding company
of the Tata Group. With the combined strength of its subsidiary, Tata AG and its associate, Tata
Enterprises (Overseas) AG, headquartered in Zug, Switzerland, promotes and invests in various
enterprises and projects overseas.
Tata Africa: Tata Africa has a significant presence in almost all the major industrial sectors of
Africa. From automobiles to hospitality, steel to information technology, Tata Africa and its
associated companies are delivering quality products and world-class services to the African
market and its people.
The following is a list of the sectors in which the Tata companies have a presence in Africa:
Engineering
Chemicals
Through its engineering division, Tata Africa caters to South Africa’s chemicals industry.
Services
Tata Africa has a significant presence in the services sector, which includes hospitality.
www.bitbookwala.in
Market Entry Modes, Framework, Structure and Strategies 171
Hospitality
Tata Africa made a splash in the African hospitality sector when Tata Zambia, the Taj Pamodzi is
managed by the Taj and offers guests the best of leisure and business amenities.
www.bitbookwala.in
BIT BOOK WALA
www.bitbookwala.in
Chapter 10
Learning Objectives
The reader should be able
• to learn about the modes of global market entry as strategies
• to analyse modes and strategies with special reference to:
i. Joint ventures (JV)
ii. Global mergers and acquisitions (M & A)
iii. Strategic alliances
iv. Subsidiaries.
www.bitbookwala.in
174 International Marketing–Text and Cases
SECTION 1:
MODES OF GLOBAL MARKET ENTRY AND STRATEGIES
The following are the various ways through which firms can enter the global market:
1) Exporting
2) Licensing and Franchising
3) Strategic Alliances/Joint Ventures (JV)
4) Mergers and Acquisitions
5) Subsidiaries
The following are their characteristics in brief:
In this chapter, the prospectus and consequences of the various global market entry modes, as above, have
been illustrated by way of examples from:
A) Joint Ventures in China
B) Strategies of the Birla Group
C) Strategies of the Tata Group
D) Strategies of the Mittal Steel
E) Strategies of Cisco Systems
SECTION 2:
JOINT VENTURES1
There are good business and accounting reasons to create a joint venture (JV) with a company that has
complementary capabilities and resources, such as distribution channels, technology or finance. In a joint
venture, two ‘parent’ companies agree to share capital, technology, human resources, risks and rewards in a
formation of a new entity under shared control.
1. Prof. Justin Paul has co-authored two sections in this chapter with Mr. Rajendra Sardesai, Mr. Akshay Jain, Mr. V.
Seshasai, Mr. Pradeep Joshi and Mr. Prashant Pathak.
www.bitbookwala.in
Market Entry ModesJV, M & A, Strategic Alliance and Subsidiaries 175
www.bitbookwala.in
176 International MarketingText and Cases
b) Partnerships Partnerships can take two forms, limited and general. With a general partnership, the
partners share operating responsibility and each one is liable for the debts of the others. A limited partnership
is comprised of one or more general partners who assume operational responsibilities for the partnership and
one or more ‘limited partners’ who serve as passive investors. The general partners are usually subject to
liability to the same extent.
c) Limited Liability Companies A limited liability company is a relatively new legal form that, is
emerging as the most common vehicle for conducting joint ventures. An LLC offers to its ‘members’
(analogous to stockholders of a regular corporation) the protection from liability afforded in the corporate
structure while affording the same tax treatment as a partnership in which income and expenses are passed
through the partners. Unlike limited partnerships, limited liability companies offer protection to members
who participate in the management of the entity as well as investors. To be taxed as a partnership, rather than
a corporation, an LLC that has more than one member has merely to elect this status.
SECTION 3:
BIT BOOK WALA
INTERNATIONAL JOINT VENTURES IN CHINA
Despite the attractiveness of China’s business and foreign investment environment, the country is not an easy
place to do business. Foreign businesses that seek to enter the Chinese market must consider a wide range of
strategies and business structures—each with its own advantages and disadvantages.
Since China’s World Trade Organisation (WTO) entry and the government’s relaxation of investment
regulations, foreign investors have been choosing to establish more wholly foreign-owned enterprises
(WFOEs). These WFOEs cannot be used in every sector because the government requires Chinese company
participation or control in some sectors. In such cases, foreign companies have to consider a joint venture
structure. Even when they are not required, joint ventures can benefit foreign investors when a Chinese
partner has certain strengths—such as central or local government support, brand reputation, land, licenses,
distribution, and access to suppliers—that reduce start up costs and improve the foreign investor’s chances of
success
In China, most joint ventures are equity joint ventures (EJVs), though some investors establish
cooperative (or contractual) joint ventures (CJVs). EJVs and CJVs are similar in many respects. The
government approval process, approval authorities, format of agreements, tax breaks, legal standing, laws
and authorities for dispute resolution are identical. The general management structure and governance
procedures are also virtually the same.
But these joint ventures differ in functional ways. The CJV parties’ profit, control, and risks are divided
according to negotiated contract terms. In contrast, an EJV’s profit, control and risk are divided in proportion
to the equity shares invested by the parties.
Author Dr. Justin Paul acknowledges the information shared by the paper presenters during Shanghai Forum, 2007
organised by Fudan University in May. The papers presented were useful for preparing this section.
www.bitbookwala.in
Market Entry ModesJV, M & A, Strategic Alliance and Subsidiaries 177
The following cooperative joint venture (CJV) cases illustrate potentially useful strategies that may apply
to companies in other industries as well.
www.bitbookwala.in
178 International MarketingText and Cases
exploration and contract revision, the contract was modified to give SKN the right to
acquire 77.5 percent of the silver and gold project. SKN will earn its stake by funding the
exploration and development and making cash payments over four years, with a first year
minimum contribution of $750,000. HPGGB has a 22.5 percent interest on the basis of its
contribution of the mineral rights (exploration permits) covering the project. After SKN
has earned its 77.5 percent interest, contributions to fund the exploration and
development of the project will be made pro rata. The share capital of HPGGB, the Chinese
property owner, may be diluted to no less than 10 percent if it elects not to make cash
contributions.
An SKN representative explained that CJV structures are attractive for mining projects
because the Chinese parties typically do not contribute working capital. To attract foreign
investors, the Chinese side contributes the right to use, but not own, the property (Land in
China is owned by the state). After 25 to 30 years the foreigners walk away.
An EJV structure is unsuitable in this sector because foreign investors usually require a
share of profit period that is higher than their share of investment to compensate for their
risk during that time.
www.bitbookwala.in
Market Entry Modes—JV, M & A, Strategic Alliance and Subsidiaries 179
The CJV required a detailed agreement and, coupled with all the ancillary agreements
and a clear licensing agreement, e-Smart believed that this detail helped to protect its
technology. According to a company spokesperson,
“All of the agreements mentioned made it very clear that the technology was not being
transferred and that the ownership remained in our hands alone....While the CJV is often
more time-consuming and complex to negotiate in the beginning, it is this complexity
that is its main benefit. You are forced to think through all of the possible problems that
may occur in the future and deal with them up front. The result is a smoother relationship
with your partner(s) and a good blueprint for the operation of the CJV.”
Question: Discuss the rationale for establishing joint venture as an international market
entry mode in the context of co-operative and equity Joint Venture?
CASE STUDY
JOINT VENTURES BY INDIAN BUSINESS GROUPS: CASE OF BIRLA GROUP
JOINT VENTURES
www.bitbookwala.in
180 International MarketingText and Cases
The company contributes to almost 43 percent of the production share in the Indian
market and has a capacity of 34,000 mtpa. This positions the company as the world’s
largest plant for hollow and solid core insulators for the Original Equipment Manufacturer
(OEM) segment.
BNI products are exported to 34 countries in Europe, America, Middle East, Africa and
China. Exporting 50 percent of its total sales, BNI has been very proactive in gauging
changing customer needs and adapting its product range to meet high quality standards.
Some of BNI’s customers are multinationals like Siemens, ABB, Areva and leading national
power utilities.
The marketing rights for the Indian market are acquired by Indian Rayon, while the
rights for international markets are held by NGK, Japan. The company’s manufacturing
facilities are located in the states of West Bengal, at Rishra, and Gujarat, at Halol.
Tanfac Industries Ltd. TIDCO (Tamil Nadu Industrial Development Corpora-
tion) Tanfac is one of India’s largest suppliers of fluorine chemicals. Incorporated in the
year 1972, it is a joint sector company promoted by the Aditya Birla Group, Pilani
Industries & Investment Corporation Ltd. (PI&ICL) and Tamil Nadu Industrial Development
Corporation (TIDC).
Its plant and facilities are spread over 60 acres in the chemical complex at Cuddalore,
about 200 km from Chennai, India. Tanfac is engaged in the manufacture of inorganic
based chemicals, such as aluminium fluoride, with a capacity of 15,000 TPA, and
BIT BOOK WALA
hydrofluoric acid with a capacity of 14,000 TPA.
Inorganic fluorine based chemicals have vital applications in industries like aluminium
smelting, petroleum refining, refrigerant gases, steel re-rolling, glass, ceramics, sugar,
fertilisers and heavy water, etc. Organic fluoro chemicals are used as intermediates in the
manufacture of pharmaceuticals and agrochemicals. Tanfac focuses on a variety of
specialty fluorides, which are developed and manufactured depending on specific
requirements of customers.
Tanfac exports its products to countries across the globe, including Australia, New
Zealand and South East Asia and Africa.
Birla Sun Life Asset Management Company Ltd. Birla Sun Life Asset Management
Company Ltd.—the investment manager of Birla Mutual Fund—is a joint venture between
the Aditya Birla Group and Sun Life Financial Services of Canada.
Birla Sun Life AMC provides investors a spectrum of 18
investment options, which include diversified and sector-
specific equity schemes, balanced and monthly income
funds, a wide range of debt and treasury products and two
offshore funds.
Birla Sun Life Mutual Fund today has emerged as one of India’s leading mutual funds,
with over Rs.90 billion in assets under management, including two offshore schemes, and
an investor base of around 400,000.
Birla Sun Life AMC is India’s first asset management company to be awarded the coveted
ISO 9001:2000 certification. The proof of its relentless commitment to high quality in
www.bitbookwala.in
Market Entry Modes—JV, M & A, Strategic Alliance and Subsidiaries 181
www.bitbookwala.in
182 International Marketing–Text and Cases
SECTION 3:
GLOBAL MERGERS AND ACQUISITIONS
The rationale for global mergers and acquisitions can be specified as:
a) Saving of time in establishing the production and marketing set-up in foreign countries. If a firm
incorporates its own establishments, it would naturally consume more time.
b) To purchase an established brand in that country and expand the sale of the acquirer’s brands in the
foreign country.
c) To control a larger market share of the product globally. For example, Mittal Steel’s acquisitions of
Arcelor Company in Europe.
Examples
(a) Cisco Systems Acquisition of Arroyo Video Solutions On September 13, 2006, Cisco
Systems® announced that they have completed the acquisition of privately-held Arroyo Video Solutions, Inc.,
a leading provider of next-generation solutions for on-demand television and related consumer services.
By acquiring the Arroyo Solution, Cisco a US company is now in a position to deliver a highly extensible
platform for video-on-demand today and the emerging time-shifted services in the future. The integration of
the Arroyo platform into the Cisco IP-NGN (Next Generation Network) architectural framework enables
carriers to accelerate the creation and distribution of network delivered entertainment, interactive media and
advertising services across the growing portfolio of televisions, personal computers, mobile handsets and
BIT BOOK WALA
emerging-media capable devices.
With this transaction, Arroyo products are now integrated into the Cisco Cable & Video Initiatives Group,
within the service provider organisation led by Michelangelo A. Volpi, Cisco senior vice president and
general manager, routing and service provider technology group.
(b) Citigroup It has more than 1,200 corporate finance staff and 350 M&A specialists on five
continents involved in the most significant deals in the marketplace. Through strengths that include effective
negotiation, product-neutral financing, precise execution and industry expertise, the organisation has been
involved in the largest and most complex deals in the marketplace. As a result, it is consistently ranked among
the top tier of advisors in local, regional and global markets, when it comes to mergers and acquisitions.
(c) Mittal Steel Arcelor Mittal has emerged as the world’s number one steel company, with 330,000
employees in more than 60 countries. The company, incorporated in 2007, brings together the world’s leading
steel companies, Mittal Steel and Arcelor. (Merger of Arcelor with Mittal led to the formation of a new company)
Arcelor Mittal is the leader in all major global market segments, including automotive, construction,
household appliances and packaging, with leading R&D and technology, as well as sizeable captive supplies
of raw materials and outstanding distribution networks.
With an industrial presence in 27 countries across Europe, the Americas, Asia and Africa, Arcelor Mittal
has a balanced geographic diversity within all the key steel markets, both developing and developed.
The Arcelor Mittal proforma revenue in 2005 showed combined revenues of 62.2bn euro (77.5bn$) and an
approximate production capacity of 113 million tonnes, which represents about 10 percent of the world’s
crude steel output.
www.bitbookwala.in
Market Entry Modes—JV, M & A, Strategic Alliance and Subsidiaries 183
SECTION 4:
INTERNATIONAL STRATEGIC ALLIANCES
Strategic alliances are agreements between firms in which each commits resources to achieve a common set of
objectives. Companies may form strategic alliances with a wide variety of players: customers, suppliers,
competitors, universities or divisions of government. Through strategic alliances, companies can improve
competitive positioning, gain entry to new markets, supplement critical skills and share the risk or cost of
major development projects, without taking equity stakes.
To form an international strategic alliance, companies should:
• Define their business vision and mission in order to understand how an alliance fits their objectives
• Evaluate and select potential partners on the basis of the level of synergy and the ability of the firms
to work together
• Develop a working relationship and mutual recognition of opportunities with the prospective partner
• Negotiate and implement a formal agreement that includes systems to monitor performance.
Strategic alliances are formed to:
• Reduce costs through economies of scale
• Get access to new technology
• Inhibit competitors
• Enter new markets
• Improve research and development efforts
• Improve quality BIT BOOK WALA
One of the fastest growing trends for business today is the increasing number of strategic alliances.
According to Booz-Allen & Hamilton, strategic alliances are sweeping through nearly every industry and are
becoming an essential driver of growth. Alliances range in scope from a business relationship based on a
simple contract to a joint venture agreement.
For small businesses, strategic alliances are a way to work together with others towards a common goal
while not losing their individuality. Alliances are a way of reaping the rewards of team effort and the gains
from forming strategic alliances appear to be substantial.
But it isn’t just profit that is motivating this increase in alliances. Other factors include an increasing
intensity of competition, a growing need to operate on a global scale, a fast changing marketplace and
industry convergence in many markets. For example, in the financial services industry, banks, investment
firms, and insurance companies are overlapping more and more in the products they supply. Especially at a
time when international marketing is becoming the norm, these partnerships can leverage growth through
alliances with international partners. Rather than take on the risk and expense that international expansion can
www.bitbookwala.in
184 International Marketing–Text and Cases
demand, one can enter international markets by finding an appropriate alliance with a business operating in a
marketplace a company wishes to enter.
A strategic alliance is essentially a partnership in which companies combine efforts in projects, ranging from
getting a better price for supplies by buying in bulk together to building a product together, with each
providing part of its production. The goal of alliances is to minimise risk while maximising the leverage and
profit.
An alliance is simply a business-to-business collaboration. Another term that is frequently used in
conjunction with alliances is establishing a business network. Alliances are formed for joint marketing, joint
sales or distribution, joint production, design collaboration, technology licensing and research and
development. Relationships can be vertical between a vendor and a customer, horizontal between vendors,
local or global. Strategic alliances are becoming a common tool for expanding the reach of a company.
SAP Solutions For more than a decade Intel and SAP have worked together to optimise
BIT BOOK WALA
the performance of SAP Solutions on Intel®-based architecture, from the backend to the
mobile client. Today Intel and SAP continue to develop new usage models that extend the
value of core business applications.
Oracle Solutions By combining Oracle and Intel® technologies, they have created a
powerful, standards-based service-oriented enterprise that speeds implementation and
helps drive business transformation. Oracle and Intel work closely together to ensure
exceptional performance and compatibility between their products and optimise their
solutions to meet customer requirements. These joint efforts improve the performance
and cost-effectiveness of Oracle solutions running on Intel-based server platforms.
SAS Solutions By delivering innovative business intelligence solutions that are easy to
deploy and provide solid return on investment, Intel and SAS help companies use their
data to make smart business decisions.
www.bitbookwala.in
Market Entry ModesJV, M & A, Strategic Alliance and Subsidiaries 185
MILAN, September 13, 2006—Italtel, one of the leading companies providing solutions,
products and services for Next Generation Networks (NGN) and Next Generation Services
(NGS) and Cisco Systems announced today the signing of a new agreement to extend their
strategic technology and commercial alliance, with an expanded market coverage beyond
Europe, Middle East and Africa to include the Latin America region.
Since signing the original strategic alliance agreement in early 2005, Italtel and Cisco
have worked together on joint technology solutions for service providers focused on
optimisation of network infrastructures, multimedia communication services for the
consumer segment and hosted and managed unified communication services for the
business segment.
Recent successful deployments include BT-Albacom, Belgacom, EITC (du) in the United
Arab Emirates, Telecom Italia and Telekomunikacja Polska, among others.
As part of the extended agreement, Italtel has identified a set of solutions to help
service providers deliver fixed-mobile converged services and embeded intelligence in the
network to accelerate service creation and reduce operational costs.
The extension of the agreement to support the Latin American market resulted from
successful joint activities, including implementation of VoIP infrastructure in Brazil and
Argentina for fixed and wireless service providers with the goal of optimising and
expanding existing networks.
The Yankee Group expects the aggregate market for Next Generation Network
www.bitbookwala.in
186 International Marketing–Text and Cases
The two companies will continue to cooperate on the development and marketing of
joint solutions based on the Italtel Softswitch and Cisco IP Technologies. Italtel and Cisco
joint solutions include Multimedia carrier-class IP communications, hosted and managed
Unified Communication Services, Service and Network Control Solution, IMS (IP Multimedia
Subsystem) Solution, and Next Generation Operational Support System (NG-OSS).
Telecom Italia successfully implemented the Cisco and Italtel solution to deploy hosted
and managed Unified Communications services. Several large enterprises, particularly in
the finance sector, have decided to deploy these services.
Strong demand is expected for hosted and managed Unified Communication Services in
the enterprise market as well as in the public sector over the next three years. Telecom
Italia is also considering the Cisco and Italtel joint solutions for the delivery and
management of innovative services and fixed and mobile convergence.
Source: Financial Times, Milan Frankfurt Editions, Sep 13, 2006
SECTION 5:
SUBSIDIARIES
Reason The basic purpose of the subsidiaries, as compared to other forms as stated above, is to have more
and direct control on the overseas operations. Subsidiaries can be established either by way of acquisition or
Greenfield investment.
BIT BOOK WALA
CASE
Cisco, US Company Setting up Subsidiary in Turkey
Cisco Systems to Invest Up to US $275 Million in Turkey Over Next Five Years ANKARA,
Turkey, and SAN JOSE, Calif., September 26, 2006 - Cisco Systems® today announced a
significant investment initiative in Turkey totalling up to US $275 million over five years.
This announcement was made by John Chambers, President and CEO of Cisco Systems,
during his visit to Central and Eastern Europe and highlights the growing importance of
Turkey in the global emerging markets.
Chambers discussed Cisco’s investment plans in Turkey with Prime Minister Recep Tayyip
Erdogan while in Ankara today. Chambers’ meeting with the Prime Minister focused
primarily on enabling Turkey to better compete globally through the adoption of
information communications technology (ICT) and improved education.
“Technology is able to drive the productivity and standard of living for communities and
countries on a global basis, and Turkey understands the critical importance and
transformative impact technology can have on businesses, governments, societies and the
overall economic growth of the country,” said Chambers. “Cisco’s announcement about its
investment in Turkey supports the country’s entrepreneurial focus and e-transformation
initiatives, which are focused on establishing a more connected country and skilled
workforce in order to increase productivity and foster innovation, and are vital for Turkey
to sustain the same rate of growth it has enjoyed over the past four years.”
Cisco Systems’ five-year investment plan for Turkey allocate investments in the
following areas:
www.bitbookwala.in
Market Entry Modes—JV, M & A, Strategic Alliance and Subsidiaries 187
REFERENCES
1. Joshi, Rakesh Mohan (2005); International Marketing, Oxford University Press.
2. Justin Paul (2006); International Business, Prentice Hall
3. Justin Paul (2006); Business Environment, McGraw-Hill Education
WEBSITES VISITED
1. www.mhhe.com/justinpaul
2. www.phindia.com/justinpaul
www.bitbookwala.in
188 International Marketing–Text and Cases
1. The main two reasons for the failure of joint ventures are ___________ .
2. Arcelor Mittal is the number one steel company in the world, with 3,30,000 employees in
more than ___________countries.
3. When the mode of entry for companies is a joint venture, their intentions will be
___________ .
4. On Sep, 13 2006, Cisco Systems completed the acquisition of privately held _________
company.
5. The basic purpose of the formation of a subsidiary is ___________ .
6. Business cooperation offer completed protection to their ___________ from liability for
the debt of the company.
REVIEW QUESTIONS
Case Study
www.bitbookwala.in
Market Entry ModesJV, M & A, Strategic Alliance and Subsidiaries 189
1. Why does airlines enter into strategic alliance each other in the international segment?
2. Do you think that the alliance is a marketing strategy?
www.bitbookwala.in
BIT BOOK WALA
www.bitbookwala.in
Chapter 11
Learning Objectives
The reader should be able to
• explain different products with special reference to customer needs and differ-
entiate between industrial and consumer goods
• identify different dimensions that make a product an international product,
with special company illustrations
• explain the process of new product development in international markets and
address the international diffusion process
• explain the international product life cycle and identify international market-
ing strategies adopted by companies at each stage.
www.bitbookwala.in
192 International MarketingText and Cases
SECTION 1:
INTRODUCTION
T he world over, customers of goods and services have different needs, aspirations, and levels of
satisfaction. What is quality for one in a product may not be satisfaction driven to the other buyer of the
same product. What attribute of a product can become a selling point to one buyer nation may not be so
attractive to buyers from other countries. These selling points may become negative selling points if included
in the sales story and may create aversion to the product if emphasised. An international marketer faces
challenging situations when it comes to offering his products and services to customers across his own
national borders. It is not necessary that the product line that a company offers in its home market will be
accepted in another country with the same content and packaging. The competitive demands, attitudes,
beliefs, interests, opinions, associations and value expectations differ from nation to nation and cultural
variations too have their own impact in leading the customers to decide on the acceptance or rejection of a
product package offered by the manufacturers. Such dynamism of international markets keep the
manufacturers on their toes and lead them to innovate on their existing product and marketing mix to cater to the
ever changing taste and demand scenario in the international market place. This chapter will discuss the
product policy and planning strategies of the international marketing firms. An attempt will be made to
understand how international marketing firms coordinate their efforts during different stages of a product’s life
cycle, i.e. from innovation to maturity to decline, and the steps they take in managing the product portfolio both
in domestic as well as foreign markets.
The product is the most crucial factor in any marketing activity. This product can be a service wrapped in
DEFINING A PRODUCT
A product in marketing parlance can be defined ‘as a bundle of physical, psychological, tangible, and
intangible, present and future attributes that put together bring satisfaction or benefits to the buyer beyond the
price paid by him.’1 Customers look for satisfaction beyond the value of the price paid for that product. In order
to give them that feeling, marketers around the world develop their advertising communication on the basis of
these tangible and psychological attributes of their product. However, a product could mean different things to
www.bitbookwala.in
International Product Policy, Planning and Strategy 193
different organisations. An international organisation with a seller’s attitude would look at a product as the
ultimate manifestation of the resources deployed to produce what a customer will buy. An organisation for
which the customer comes first will look at a product as a bundle of benefits meant to satisfy a customer’s wants
and earn profits therefrom. This means that for different customers a car will convey a different satisfaction
level, depending on the perception that customer builds up in his mind for a particular brand of car. While a mid-
sized car is known for fuel efficiency and steering convenience, a large automobile like a Mercedes could
represent luxury and a certain status.
Consumer Products
These products satisfy a customer’s need and do not require further processing. These are products that are
inherent with the utilities that customers look for in a product. These come with other elements, such as
guarantee, warranty, installation facilities, after-sales services and many other packages that act as motivators
BIT BOOK WALA
for inducing customers to make a purchase.2
Products have also been classified by traditionalists into three categories on the basis of buyers’ behaviour
and on the purchase action of its consumers. These categories are:
1. Convenience products – These are meant for day-to-day living and basic survival and are bought on
instinct, for example food items, medicines and toiletries, etc.
2. Shopping products – These are purchased after thorough planning in advance, where the customer
may have a preconceived and predetermined brand and budget in mind. Since it involves relatively
higher expense, it may need influence of other factors too.
3. Specialty products – These are products that are specially designed and manufactured to cater to a
specific demand of customers, for example a specially designed, tailor-made dress, or a custom-made
sports car, a specially designed and custom-built furniture item, etc. All these will fall under the
category of specialist goods, where how a customer perceives the benefit in the product is more
important in designing the products and the communication attached to the product in the market
place.
SECTION 2:
PRODUCT PLANNING IN INTERNATIONAL MARKETS
Product planning basically refers to the process of determining the length and depth of the product line to be
offered in the target international markets. The length will specify the number of products to be offered and the
depth will relate to the various shades to be adopted for the same product in different international markets.
2. Fundamentals of Sales Management, Ramneek Kapoor, Macmillan India Limited Page 34-35.
www.bitbookwala.in
194 International Marketing–Text and Cases
However, in order to understand how a company’s product grows from just a local product to national brand
and, eventually, into a global entity we will have to have a brief look at the development and growth chart of a
product’s life cycle in its entirety.
Local Products
When a product is available in a town or, at best, in a region of the nation state, it will be known as local product.
For example, MTR Spices was originally a regional and local brand when it was being marketed only in the
markets in southern India and the consumption by the customers from a few states there took care of entire
production, leaving little scope of exports to other regions of the country.
National Products
Campa Cola was introduced by the Pure Drinks Group in the Indian markets when Pepsi and Coca Cola were not
being marketed in India, during the 1970s and 1980s. Coca Cola had moved out of India due to a change in
government policy. Since Campa Cola was confined to only Indian boundaries, it will be apt to call it a national
product.
Campa Cola was a soft drink brand manufactured until 2000. It was a market leader in
some regions for a period spanning several years until the advent of the foreign players
Pepsi and Coca Cola after the liberalisation policy of the Government of India in 1991.
Similarly, multinational firms may also have a product specific to one particular market. When Dabur India
offers ‘Real Fruit Juices’ and Godrej markets ‘Appy’ in the Indian market, without promoting the same brand
internationally, we will refer to them as Indian national products, i.e. a product that is sold and marketed only
within the confines of a national state. The manifestations of such products are that they have a very limited
growth potential both technically and commercially.
International Products
The products that are sold across many countries are called international products. Suzuki, Japanese brand
automobiles are truly international players because, besides their own country, they have a presence in Asia
and United States too. Similarly, Honda and Hyundai technologies, though available under different local
affiliations across many nations, can be truly called international brands. International firms in today’s financial
markets, where acquisitions are the order of the day, do not necessarily have to put up green field projects to
become international. Mergers, takeovers and international alliances help companies to emerge as leaders
overnight in other countries. Mittal Steel became global after acquisitions of Arcellar and achieved the status
of number one steel manufacturer in the world.
www.bitbookwala.in
International Product Policy, Planning and Strategy 195
Global Products
True global products are always marketed in global markets, in all continents, and in every country like Pepsi,
Coke, Nestlé, Cadburys and Sony are the brands that inspire trust and loyalty of consumers all over the world.
Phillips, National Panasonic, BMW, Renault, Mercedes, Kodak and Xerox are guided by the same strategic
principles. They create the same perception across continents by universal positioning of their products, even
though the marketing mix deployed by them may vary from country to country. Pepsi and Coke have become
household names all over the world even though differentiating their tastes as per local adaptation of tastes in
different countries. When Pepsi introduced Tropicana juice around the world, it had developed a taste to suit
different customers across the globe. Such global similarities exert pressures on companies’ resources to
develop products that can adapt themselves to different global conditions prevailing amongst nations. Thus,
it calls for committing huge resources to research and development, but companies have found that the returns
from the global acceptance of their products have more than met their investments. Besides fashion, food and
beverages, the automobile industry is another industry fast emerging as a global entity with R&D developing
technology to suit each country’s need of pollution control and safety measures even though the cars
produced in different countries will have fixtures and body designs as per the laws applicable in their home
countries, where their plants are situated.
We will have to differentiate a global product from a global brand. The global product does not have to carry
the same name in all the countries and the perception about it may also differ from country to country. This
raises a question: should global organisations have a global product with the same global brand to make it
universally acceptable or should they make adaptation of global product to various countries’ needs and
culture without specifically giving it a global standardised name? Or, should they simply select the best
suitable product from the available product mix and extend the same to other parts of the globe, in order to gain
advantage of economies of scale and capitalise on the customer loyalty earned from ethnic customers who
have moved abroad?
www.bitbookwala.in
196 International MarketingText and Cases
SECTION 4:
PRODUCT EXTENSION
Companies here extend the same product marketed successfully in the home country to other parts of the world
without many modifications. Such a move is often adopted when enough loyalty has been earned by the
product in the home markets and companies can depend on the similarities of tastes and product use
conditions by a large segment of customers abroad. Generally, the food and beverages industry has been
adopting this line of extension wherever the laws of the land do not insist on significant modifications to the
products. MTR spices and their other products, Mother’s Recipes pickles, particularly Pachranga Pickles, are
marketed in many countries abroad to cater to the Indian ethnic population settled there. Similarly, some of the
rice polishing and packing companies like Satnam Overseas, owners of Kohinoor brand of rice and LT
Overseas, owners of Dawat Rice sell various varieties of Indian rice to take care of the palate of the non-resident
Indians settled across different countries. These firms are basically ethnocentric in their approach and adopt
their own niches in foreign countries to sustain a large chunk of business. However, the globalisation of
economies has opened wonderful opportunities for geocentric companies, which, as a deliberate strategy,
adopt standardised products for global promotions to grow into large international conglomerates just like the
Pepsis and Cokes of the world have grown. Global product standardisation will be dealt with separately, in the
following paragraph.
Advantages of Standardisation
1. Builds up a global brand and product image
2. Economies of large-scale productions help achieve an economic cost
3. Global marketing mix can be developed at an optimum cost.
www.bitbookwala.in
International Product Policy, Planning and Strategy 197
Prohibitive Adaptation Costs Product adaptation to suit individual tastes and preferences of each
nation and country will mean reconverting the product once it has been standardised for one country. Such a
move will involve making investments on alternate product manufacturing systems to meet the new customers’
needs or to alter the promotion and communication strategy. Unless the returns are quite attractive from such
adaptations, companies will not be very keen to adapt the product or the communication strategy.
Emergence of Global Customers The world economy has witnessed phenomenal growth of
means of communication, travel and transportation. Coupled with this, economies have opened up and the
globalisation of emerging nations has created a global customer profile. This type of identical global customers
can be found in all corners of the world. Their tastes, preferences, needs, aspirations for achieving similar
standards of living and dreams of better future all converge into a global niche of common identified
segmentation of sizeable market universe. Such a large segment of identical customers offers a vast
opportunity to international marketing firms to standardise their products and communication strategies. MTV,
Levi’s jeans, McDonalds, Pizza Hut, Kentucky Fried Chicken, Café Coffee Day are accepted as popular
products by the ‘global customers’.
Country of Origin It has been a tradition to associate and ascribe excellence of quality of certain
products to their original innovation sources or country of origin. Swiss watches command respect even
though the Japanese watch industry is well known for its precision-based technology. Germany is always a
preferred destination for heavy machinery and capital equipment. Italy and France will always be associated
with the fashion and wine industries. While India has made a mark in the software industry, China has emerged
a strong contender for supplying hardware to the computer industry. Such perceptions of country of origin and
BIT BOOK WALA
specialisation result in better acceptance of products and services and profit returns from customers. This also
works well for international marketing firms because it saves effort and expense on building up new identities
to compete with rival firms based in countries of origin.
Product Adaptation
A product that is being very well accepted in a home country may not get the same response in another
country. As a result, firms may have to initiate some action to adapt the product to suit the conditions in that
particular country. These adaptations are necessary due to the following:
1. Global variations in physical conditions, such as geography, topography, weather, climatic conditions,
availability of logistical support, earning systems and means of livelihood, per capita income and
standards of living of the inhabitants of the country, etc.
2. Varying cultural manifestations, consumer tastes and perceptions, usages, purchasing patterns, con-
sumptions and satisfaction drivers.
3. Various levels of competition and the competitive strategies adopted by the other international market-
ing firms around the globe.
There can be several examples of how products have been adapted and modified to suit the conditions
prevailing in different parts of the world. When Mattel Toys launched in India, it carried only the American
version of the Barbie doll. Today, however, in order to lure Indian children, the American toy maker offers dolls
that are replicas of Indian brides. Similarly, when Barbie was introduced in Japan, there was not much response
to the American Barbie. When it was modified to look like an oriental girl, however, the sales of Barbie soared
to almost 15 percent of total international sales.3
3. Stoner and Wankel, Management, Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, N.J., 1986, p.653.
www.bitbookwala.in
198 International MarketingText and Cases
International marketing firms undertake massive and extensive research abroad to understand the changes
and modifications necessary in their products to suit those conditions. When the aviation industry saw
declining trends in the United States in early 1970s, Boeing and Airbus Industrie adapted the larger aircrafts to
the needs of Third World countries (where the runways and other landing facilities were not as developed as
in the West). The length and width of the wings were reduced for shorter landing runs and more thrust was put
in the engines for quicker take-offs, extending the lifecycle of the product.
Multinational firms undertake massive research projects to understand the kind of changes needed to adapt
their products to the needs of foreign markets. Such needs could vary from a new design to altogether new
products. Owing to a change in technology, it could also be a sudden shift from earlier usage patterns to new
styles, necessitating modifications to suit new requirements.
Product Communication Strategies A product can be marketed abroad only with the help of a
communication strategy, which is what conveys the promotional theme to consumers abroad, allowing them to
form perceptions about the product, spelling out, in turn, the quantitative and qualitative sales for the
manufacturers. Keegan has identified five major product communication strategies international marketers can
chose from to convey the message to customers in different foreign markets.4
4. Keegan, Global Marketing Management 7th ed. Pearson Education- Prentice Hall, 2007. Pp.372-375.
www.bitbookwala.in
International Product Policy, Planning and Strategy 199
addition to profit realisation. Yet, such a strategy will not offer an opportunity to maximise profits, which can
come through diversification and adaptation of product to international needs.
As the McDonald’s company entered new markets, it showed flexibility with respect to the
local preferences. In Germany, McDonald’s serves beer with meals. In Israel, the first kosher
McDonald’s opened in Jerusalem in 1995. In Arab countries, the restaurant chain used
Halal menus. In 1996 McDonalds entered India where they offered the Maharaja Mac,
made with lamb rather than beef.
”Schlosser, Eric. “Fast Food Nation”. Haroeer Collins Publishers, 2002.http://www.animal
frontline.nl/macdonalds-eng.php)
www.bitbookwala.in
200 International MarketingText and Cases
This strategy involves modifying both the product as well as the communication in the international markets
to meet the tangible as well as intangible needs of customers in all countries. Such a move is also known as dual
adaptation strategy. This strategy is adopted when the conditions of use as well as the conditions related to
environments differ from country to country. The product will have to be differentiated from one country to
another country to ensure that it fulfils different purposes in each country where it is being marketed. For
example, because Americans like to store enough food for the week at home, they prefer deep freezers to
standing refrigerators, the kind that are being marketed in India. So, naturally, American households require
larger storage space. An Indian manufacturer planning to enter the American market, therefore, will have to
manufacture deep freezers and change the communication strategy accordingly to suit the perceptive needs of
American customers. This strategy calls for long-term budgetary provisions, as it will definitely be a time
consuming and expensive work out to convert both the product as well as communication strategy in different
countries. Today, however, international markets are offering huge potentials to marketers, making such an
exercise worthwhile for international marketing firms.
SECTION 5:
NEW PRODUCT INVENTION/DEVELOPMENT
Many firms have experienced that all products cannot be modified or communication strategies be adapted to
cater to an ever-increasing customer profile across the globe. Besides, as Keegan has noticed, lesser
developed countries will find it difficult to afford the expense involved in modifying the existing production
facilities. The customers from these countries also cannot afford to either buy the existing product line or go for
Source: Adapted from “Blue Ocean Strategy: How to Create Uncontested Market Space and Make
Competition Irrelevant” W.Chan Kim, Renee Maubourgne, Harvard Business School Press pp. 18-19
www.bitbookwala.in
International Product Policy, Planning and Strategy 201
of tangible and intangible satisfaction. This point of view has been exemplified by the authors of Blue Ocean
Strategy, when they talk of providing value addition to the customer and the entrepreneurs by way of value
innovation to the already crowded product mix kitties of competitors. Under value innovation, many times, an
international marketing firm will have to preferably look around the comparative substitutes to identify the
innovations that can provide value benefit to the firm, as also its customers. The strategy advocates value cost
trade off for circumventing competition, which can otherwise bleed the strengths of the marketing firm in many
ways, such as cost of fighting and meeting the competition by spending on advertising budgets and price
adjustments.
Thus, marketing firm can bring up the value (against price paid) to the customers and bringing down the cost
of manufacturing an innovative product to meet his similar needs that he had been satisfying from the existing
competitive products. For example, in India, the introduction of Maruti cars by the Indo Japanese joint-venture
Maruti-Suzuki can be cited as the best example of value innovation i.e. the introduction of 800 cc cars
revolutionised the entire passenger car industry. Again, Honda’s 100cc bikes in the Indian market, in
collaboration with the Hero group, brought about a total change in the two-wheeler industry of Indian
automobiles. (Honda belongs to Japan, Hero is an Indian company).
Sunlight washing powder, manufactured by Unilever as an alternative to Surf range of detergents, can
definitely be called an invention of a new product at reduced price yet enhanced value to the customers of
developing countries.
The firms with marketing focus are always on the look out to introduce new and innovative products to keep
their marketing ability a step ahead of their competitors. Otherwise, with the introduction of newer and
developed versions of existing products, their products and services will become obsolete. Besides,
companies have to keep track of the consumers’ dynamic demands and preferences, which keep changing with
the change in their standards of living and exposures to exponential media coverage from all corners of the
world.
www.bitbookwala.in
202 International MarketingText and Cases
New product development, however, involves risks as the unknown and unpredictable
market environments do add to the potential risks associated with the uncharted waters.
The marketers, therefore, have to be very careful while introducing new products in
international markets. For example, when Kellogg’s had introduced corn flakes in southern
states in India, little did it realise that, owing to their eating habits, customers prefer idli
dosa (local cereal-based preparations) over anything else. The result is that Kellogg’s
corn flakes have still has not caught the fancy of customers and is still struggling in many
other parts of India too.
Similarly, when McDonald’s had initially opened up an outlet in New Delhi, India, in the
early 1980s, Indian customers were still not ready to accept fast food culture and the menu offered at
McDonald’s, at best, was treated as snacks for an outing. The company had to shut shop and move out, along
with Coca Cola, thus suffering considerable losses. It is only when the economy opened up again and the
Indian customers had access to international media that their tastes changed and McDonald has today become
a big success.
The examples above however should not deter the international marketing firms from introducing new and
innovative versions of their products, provided enough research has gone into deciding the features and the
value additions this product version will offer to the customers.
www.bitbookwala.in
International Product Policy, Planning and Strategy 203
by the organisation vis-à-vis the perceived value for money deliverance by the new product or it may
be little too early in the product lifecycle to gain an acceptance in that country.
3. Market may not be fully developed yet to accept a highly advanced product due to lack of information
on the new technology, or other logistical and after-sales service support may be missing from the
market place.
4. Restrictions can be imposed either by the home country or by the host country in test marketing new
innovative products if these pertain to food, pharmaceuticals or even other genres like chemicals and
pesticides, etc.
5. The international marketing firm has not conducted a market survey related to market potential vs.
demand, purchasing power, purchasing parity and the conversion readiness of the customers to
accept newer and finer patterns of the product. As is evident from the extract from the Times of India
article, in such cases international marketing firms end up paying a heavy price in terms of product
failures or delayed responses.
www.bitbookwala.in
204 International MarketingText and Cases
5. David Leonhardt, “It was a hit in Buenos Aires-so why not Boise?” Business Week, September 7, 1998, vol. 3594,
pp.56-57.
www.bitbookwala.in
International Product Policy, Planning and Strategy 205
ensure early establishment of the product in the already overcrowded markets. Product positioning and the
ingredients involved in international product positioning will be discussed separately in this chapter.
The international firm will evaluate product feasibility against the self-reference criterion of the firm’s own
resources, technology, manufacturing and marketing capabilities.
Market Testing
It will be appropriate to test the product in selective markets under simulated and controlled conditions for a fair
estimate of the performance of the product before launching it commercially. This is a risky venture because the
competitors can sabotage the whole game plan. However, simulated and controlled test marketing can be done
without giving any such opportunity to the competition. Such test marketing can give answers to customers’
perception about the price, packaging, promotional media and positioning of the product against the
competition.
6. Wyner, “Product Testing”, pp46-48.
7. Robert S Doscher, “How to Create New Products,” Target Marketing, 1994, vol 17, no.1, pp 40-41.
www.bitbookwala.in
206 International MarketingText and Cases
In a simulated test market, various tests, such as the LITMUS test for consumer durables, ASSESSOR test
used for packaged goods, BASES for food and health and cosmetics and ESP used for packaged goods, can
become effective tools for assessing the marketability of the new product.8
To undertake simulated testing, many times, products are offered directly to selected customers, without
the middlemen, and their views and experiences are reviewed /checked periodically. Such a test drive has often
been offered by car manufacturers across two-three countries simultaneously. This allows the organisation to
understand consumers’ actual experience with their technology on the road-worthiness of the car they are
about to launch commercially. Currently, Nissan has been conducting similar tests on their fuel-cell powered
cars in Japan and for another X-TRAIL FCV with a 70 MPa (10,000 psi) storage cylinder that supports an
increased range of more than 500 km. (311 miles tests are on in Canada, as is evident from the following extract
from the company’s website.)
8. For more details on these tests please refer to Kevin J. Clancy and Robert S. Shulman, “It’s Better To Fly A New
Product Simulator Than Crash The Real Thing” Planning Review, July / August 1992, Vol 20 No. 4 Pp 10-16.
www.bitbookwala.in
International Product Policy, Planning and Strategy 207
www.bitbookwala.in
208 International MarketingText and Cases
User Attributes
Products serve different purposes in different markets. For example, an air conditioner could be, besides
cooling temperatures, a status symbol for the buyers in the Third World countries because very few people can
afford this machine in poor nations. The same machine, however, is considered a necessity in developed
countries. Firms will have to differentiate brand promotion from country to country and, in the process, incur
heavy costs on advertising and other brand building campaigns. Barring the cultural variations of colours,
symbols, attached local meanings to names and local variants of translations, global positioning is easy to
build up for the international firms like Pepsi, Coca Cola , McDonald’s, Lux and Surf, etc. These global
corporations have developed a unified and unique global positioning strategy to encash association with
better quality, international high technology and being in line with the latest from developed countries. The
American way influences young cultures in all countries today and, relying on this attitude, companies
position their products accordingly, addressing the need for freedom of choice. Again, ‘Japanese high
technology’ attracts people everywhere. Products like Sony, Suzuki and Honda are some brands that have
been associated with world-class technology by consumers around the world. It will be inappropriate for these
multinational corporations to think of any another name in any country of the world.
10. Row Johnson and William O. Winchell, Marketing and Quality Control, American Society for Quality Control,
Milwaukee, 1989.
www.bitbookwala.in
International Product Policy, Planning and Strategy 209
Technology Compatibility
A product’s design developed under one technology for a country may not work in another unless the designs
are made compatible for all kinds of usages under different technologies too. For example, differences in electric
voltage, which may vary from 110 volts to 220 volts to be run on frequency of 50Hz to 60 Hz. In India we have
frequency of 50 Hz and electric current of 220 volts, whereas in United States the electric current operates on a
frequency of 60 Hz at 110 to 120 volts. International firms have to ensure products are acceptable and usable
under varying conditions of different technologies. Similarly, automobile manufacturers have to take care of the
right-hand drive or left-hand drive while positioning their products abroad. Mobile phone technology too
faces a similar problem when it comes to marketing products internationally. Bluetooth technology in many
places is catching on, while some of the countries still remain on GSM technology. Within the United States,
three different technologies of cell phone are in use. European standards of pollution control and fuel
emissions, Euro I and Euro II, have to be adhered to by the car manufacturers of India while marketing cars to
European and other countries.
www.bitbookwala.in
210 International MarketingText and Cases
Statutory Provisions
International product designs are also influenced by the laws and regulations of the countries where the
products are going to be marketed. The firms will have to implement necessary statutory features, such as
safety standards, health standards, quality certifications standards, ISO, Bureau of Quality Standards, etc., in
order to ensure their products are allowed to be sold across different countries.
Cultural Factors
Cultural influence cannot be ignored while designing the packaging. The customs, traditions, colour
combinations, the styles of writing and even the packaging materials used will have to take care of religious and
culture philosophy and beliefs of different countries. The impact of culture on international marketing has been
discussed in the chapter ‘Cultural Environment’.
Point-of-Purchase Features
International marketing has been witness to exponential growth of retail activities worldwide. In most of the
western countries, as also in the developing countries in the east, wider exposure is given to the products in
super markets and shopping malls, where the point-of-purchase salesman hardly gets any role to play . It is the
packaging and labelling that has to attract the customer. The packaging, therefore, has to be attractive enough
to perform the task of point-of-purchase salesman and act as a product hoarding to create a favourable sales
impression.
www.bitbookwala.in
International Product Policy, Planning and Strategy 211
Environmental Features
International marketing firms will have to take into account the weather, climatic conditions, availability of air
conditioned stores or open stores, other storage conditions available in different countries and the in-transit
handling of packaging. The retail store handling of the package, before it is finally sold off, will also be kept in
mind. The packaging should be such designed in such a way that it is able to withstand the stress and strains
of handling under extreme conditions.
Product Features
A unique advantage offered by a product, as against the normal run-of-the-mill features, will certainly
accelerate the process of its adoption. Similarly, the offer and the product must be in compatibility with the
actual need of the customer. The newness must offer a fair trail to the customers. For example, a new fruit juice
offered by Pepsi will have to be released in sampling sachets in the markets where it is being launched.
When Nestle had launched Maggi Noodles’ new flavours in India, the firm had put up stalls serving small
helpings of cooked noodles at retail stores and supermarkets, shopping malls and other public places to offer
a trial taste to the customers, (who research had indicated) were young children who would generally
accompany their mothers to these stores. This helped the multinational spread their product message to the
actual users in no time.
12. Everest M Rogers, Diffusion of Innovation, 3rd edition, The Free Press, New York, 1983, pp 2-13.
www.bitbookwala.in
212 International MarketingText and Cases
new and innovative.13 The spread of a new product and innovation is faster in high-context cultures. For
instance, the better developed and highly industrialised countries in the west, with high per capita income
levels, will take to a new innovation faster, as compared to the countries of the east, majority of which are still
in the developing or emerging stage. In Japan and South-East Asian countries, the spread of new product is
faster as against the speed at which a new product will be adopted in India and the other countries of Asia.
Similarly, in the United States, Canada and the Scandinavian countries, customers will take to a new innovation
a little faster than they will in the low-context countries. These cultural differences have been explained by
drawing interrelationship between context and product spread in the following manner:
We will refer to the countries where the international marketing firm introduces its new product first as the
lead countries. The countries that take to the new product after it has been accepted in lead countries will be
referred to as the lagging countries. By referring to the above culture context analysis conducted by Wills,
A.C.Smith and others, international marketing companies can adopt their strategies on product launch
accordingly. It has been observed that after the product has been accepted in the lead countries, the speed of
new products spread is much faster when the same is introduced in the lag countries. The consumers of lag
countries learn from the experiences of customers of the lead countries, where the product must have attained
some level of success already. In fact, the later the product or service is introduced in the lag country, the faster
will be the adoption rate.14 A classic example is that of the spread of scanners in Europe, Japan, Australia and
Latin America. The information about the usage of retail store scanners and their success in obtaining
information on retail customers and sales data in the United States had resulted in quick and rapid spread of
scanners in the countries mentioned above.15 Product diffusion or the product spread in a modern marketing
environment (where the information can be reached through the Internet in as little as a second), hardly
distinguishes amongst the lead country or lag country. Worldwide product launches have been held by
13. Wills, A.C. Samli, and L. Jacobs, “Developing Global Products And Marketing Strategies: A Construct And A
Reach Agenda,” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, Vol.19 Winter 1991, Pp. 1-10.
14. Hikarazu Takada and Dipak Jain “Cross – National Analysis of Diffusion of Consumer Durable Goods in Pacific
Rim Countries,” Journal of Marketing, 1991, Vol.55, No.1, Pp 48-54.
15. Jai Shankar Ganesh and V. Kumar, “Capturing the Cross National Learning Effect: An Analysis of an Industrial
Technology Diffusion,” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 1996, Vol.24, No.4, Pp.328-327.
www.bitbookwala.in
International Product Policy, Planning and Strategy 213
countries like Pepsi, Coke or Nestle while introducing a new taste or a new ingredient into their food and
beverage items.
SECTION 6:
THE CONCEPT OF INTERNATIONAL PRODUCT LIFE CYCLE
Like human beings, products also have a life cycle. They are conceived at a prenatal stage and take birth at the
introductory stage. They grow like human beings, reach a maturity stage and eventually decline in their
acceptance at the market place, till eventually meeting their resting place in the annals of product history.16
International products too pass through four different stages of yielding profits, gaining market shares,
overcoming competition and, finally, succumbing to the competitive pressures or till the international
marketing firms themselves decide to come out with a substitute or innovation. The product life cycle refers to
the four different stages: introduction, growth, maturity and decline. The figure below draws a typical product
life cycle:
Maturity
Growth
Competition builds up Decline
set up manufacturing base
in developing country
Introduction
Introduction Stage
The benefits of innovation, the new technology breakthrough, the new production systems and entering a
virgin field can be taken advantage of at this state. Generally highly developed and industrialised countries will
be introducing new inventions, green field projects as the costs of research and development in developing a
new product will be very high. The firms will initially market these products in the country of origin and, after
having obtained a sizeable adoption rate, will export them to developing countries. The international marketing
firm can adopt either of the two following policies.
A) Skim the Cream The price will be set fairly high, since there will not be much competition at the top
end. The high price will attract consumers at the top of the demand curve. The high price may yield low volumes
but it will pay for the initial investments made on product development, new technology development and the
huge expense incurred on R & D and innovative marketing.
16. Ramneek Kapoor, Fundamentals of Sales Management, Macmillan India Ltd, Pp40-41.
www.bitbookwala.in
214 International MarketingText and Cases
International cell phones manufacturers like Nokia, Motorola and Siemens introduced their products in
Indian market in early 1990s.They took advantage of technology advancement and adopted the policy of
skimming the cream off the Indian markets at the introduction stage. Their products were priced very high for
the Indian consumers.
B) Market Penetration Strategy Could be adopted when the aim is to capture as much market
share as possible before others wake up to the situation.17 Generally in a price sensitive market, where the
customer is not willing to pay a higher price as the product cannot be distinguished from the other existing
products, the low price benefit will attract the users of other products and will spell into large volumes, resulting
in low production cost at the very initial stage.
When Coca Cola re-entered the Indian market in early 1990s, and was then followed by Pepsi, it adopted the
market penetration policy with a low price innovative pack of Rs.5 per bottle, which enabled it to corner a
sizeable slice from other indigenous soft drinks.
Growth Stage The firm will face increasing competition here as the market wakes up to the rapid new
product adoption. Price competition will increase at this stage. The products that are being hit and replaced due
to massive adoption of a new product by their established customer base will react to the situation. They will
take corrective actions with their market price and product mix strategies. The international marketing firm will
continue exporting to developing countries. There will be more emphasis on developing economies of scale in
the production process.
Maturity Stage This is the longest stage in the product life cycle. The firm will notice the sales growth
BIT BOOK WALA
chart of its new product showing stagnating trends. The product profit realisations will be under tremendous
strains due to increase in competition. The international marketing firm will fight the competition through other
promotional mix like advertising, POP material and trade incentives at the maturity stage to keep the demand
and price going.
The firm will set up manufacturing bases in developing countries or source out the major components to
gain price advantage over the competition as the standards of competition will be quantified by now. We
discussed Motorola above and how it adopted the ‘skim the cream’ strategy for the Indian market. At this stage
of maturity, Motorola had moved its European software centre and chip plant to Krakow Poland.18 The
automobile ancillary industry from Japan and United States have been actively setting up bases in India and
China to enter into strategic alliances with the local manufactures to produce viable products at low cost. These
local manufacturers will sell their products to international marketing firms from the developed countries like
the United States to create competition for the firms based in these highly industrialised economies. India is
fast emerging as the back office of many international marketing firms for process outsourcing, as a major cost
saving devise. The software industry is another example of moving manufacturing bases to the developing
economies. Today companies like Microsoft, Motorola, IBM, Cap Germany and Intel have all set up their
process divisions in India and export back the software solutions to United States and other parts of Europe.
Decline Stage The dynamic forces of growth and change in the market place take their toll on these
products too, as they lose their market shares and customers’ perceptions to new introductions. Consequently,
17. Ramneek Kapoor, Fundamentals of Sales Management, Macmillan India Ltd, Pp40-41.
18. Milton Keynes, “Motorola Chooses Poland For New Site”, Corporate Location, European Edition, May/June
1998, P.7.
www.bitbookwala.in
International Product Policy, Planning and Strategy 215
their sales suffer and profitability and contributions from these products come down as the demand declines.
The international marketing firms will try to extend declining product life cycle curve for a while by injecting
fresh appeals and attractions to the product line. But it cannot be sustained for long. The firm will have a look
at the possibility of continuing with the same product only in the developing countries’ market and seek fresh
innovations for the lead and developed economies.
REFERENCES
1. Ramneek Kapoor, Fundamentals of Sales Management, Macmillan India Limited, Pp
34-35.
2. Wikipedia.
3. Stoner and Wankel, Management, Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, N.J., 1986, P.653.
4. Global Marketing Management 7th ed. Pearson Education- Prentice Hall, 2007. Pp.372-
375.
5. Schlosser, Eric. “Fast Food Nation” Haroeer Collins Publishers.
6. “Blue Ocean Strategy: How to Create Uncontested Market Space and Make Competition
Irrelevant” W.Chan Kim, Renee Maubourgne, Harvard Business School Press pp. 18-19.
7. Swaminomics/Swaminathan S. Anklesaria Aiyar, Times of India.
8. David Leonhardt, “It was a hit in Buenos Aires- o why not Boise?” Business Week,
BIT BOOK WALA
December 7, 1998, vol.3594, pp.56-57.
9. Wyner, “Product Testing”, pp46-48
10. Robert S Doscher, How to Create New Products, Target Marketing, 1994 Vol 17, No 1, pp;
40-41.
11. Kevin J. Clancy and Robert S. Shulman, It’s better to Fly a New Product Simulator than
Crash The Real Thing “Planning Review, July / August 1992, Vol 20 No. 4 Pp 10-16.
12. www.nissan.global.com.
13. Harriot Lane Fox, “Global Roll Out for Pepsi Max,” Marketing April 7, 1994, P2.
14. Row Johnson and William O. Winchell, Marketing and Quality Control, American Soci-
ety For Quality Control, Milwaukee, 1989
15. Dana- Nicoleta Lascu, International Marketing, Biztantra, pp119-120.
16. Everest M Rogers, Diffusion of Innovation, 3rd edition, The Free Press, New York, 1983,
pp 2-13.
17. Wills, A.C. Samli, and L. Jacobs, “Developing Global Products and Marketing Strategies:
A construct And A Reach Agenda, Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, Vol.19
Winter 1991, Pp. 1-11.
18. Jai Shankar Ganesh and V. Kumar, “Capturing the Cross National Learning Effect: An
Analysis of an Industrial Technology Diffusion”, Journal of the Academy of Marketing
Science, 1996, Vol.24, No.4, Pp.328-327.
19. Hikarazu Takada and Dipak Jain “Cross – National Analysis of Diffusion of Consumer
Durable Goods in Pacific Rim Countries”, Journal of Marketing, 1991, Vol.55, No.1, Pp
48-54
www.bitbookwala.in
216 International MarketingText and Cases
20 & 21. Ramneek Kapoor, Fundamentals of Sales Management, Macmillan India Ltd, Pp40-41
22. Milton Keynes, “Motorola Chooses Poland for New Site”, Corporate Location, Euro-
pean Edition, May/June 1998, P.7.)
WEBSITES VISITED
1. www.wikipedia.com
2. http://www.animalfrontline.nl/macdonalds-eng.php).
3. www.etfoodprocessing.com/.../images/nnews03.jpg
4. http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/articleshow
5. http://www.nissan-global.com/
6. http://www.nestlefamily.com
www.bitbookwala.in
International Product Policy, Planning and Strategy 217
1. The products have been classified by the traditionalists into these categories based on the
buyer behavior and the purchase action of its consumers.
(a) Convenience products. (b) Shopping products.
(c) Specialty products. (d) None of these.
(e) All of these.
2. A product’s life cycle in its entirety will mean product passing through these stages
(a) Local Product. (b) National Product.
(c) International Product. (d) Global Product.
(e) All of these.
3. Factors that favor standardization of global products are
(a) High Technology Intensive Industry. (b) Prohibitive Adaptation Costs.
(c) Emergence of Global Customers. (d) Country of Origin Trend.
(e) All of these.
4. Large Scale Test marketing as a complete marketing activity is undertaken by the international
marketing firms to understand
(a) Product acceptance as against the competition.
(b) The effectiveness of the promotional strategies adopted.
BIT BOOK WALA
(c) The competitors’ reaction to the new innovation.
(d) To predict expected market share.
(e) all of these.
5. An international firm should pay special attention to these considerations for an international
Products’ Packaging
(a) Importer Specific Instructions. (b) Cultural and environmental factors.
(c) Point of Purchase Features (d) After Use Disposability.
(e) All of these.
6. Product spread in international markets refers to the manner in which a product is
(a) Accepted by customers in different countries.
(b) Marketed in different countries.
(c) Introduced in different countries.
(d) Manufactured in different countries.
(e) Distributed in different countries
7. Connotation of a design of an international product may differ from country to country depend-
ing on these factors
(a) Culture perceptions. (b) Customer preferences.
(c) Technology compatibility. (d) Statutory provisions.
(e) All of these.
8. Product/ Communication Adaptation Strategy as introduced by Keegan in Global Marketing
Management 7TH E. Pearson Education- Prentice Hall, 2007. Pp.372-375 refers to the situation
when
www.bitbookwala.in
218 International MarketingText and Cases
(a) Firm modifies both the product as well as the communication in the international markets.
(b) Only products are modified by the firm.
(c) Communications related to the product is modified.
(d) An extension of product along with the extension of communication is adopted.
(e) New products are introduced.
9. Product Extension/ Communication Adaptation Strategy refers to the situation when
(a) Communications related to the product is modified.
(b) Products are modified by the firm.
(c) New products are introduced.
(d) New communication as well new product is adopted.
(e) An extension of product along with the extension of communication is adopted.
10. Product standardization is the process of marketing a product in international markets
(a) By affecting little change in the basic nature of the product.
(b) By introducing new products.
(c) By altering the basic nature of the product.
(d) By changing product as well it’s positioning.
(e) by changing only the product positioning.
www.bitbookwala.in
Chapter 12
Learning Objectives
The reader should be able to
• understand the basic pricing concepts
• identify the challenges an international marketing firm faces while adopting a
pricing strategy
• address international pricing decisions and strategies of international market-
ing firms
• understand and address threats from grey markets, dumping, exchange fluc-
tuations and other environmental factors while maintaining international mar-
keting pricing strategies.
www.bitbookwala.in
220 International MarketingText and Cases
SECTION 1:
INTRODUCTION
P rice is the currency value a customer is asked to pay for the product or service offered for sale by the seller.
This price determines the profitability, the competitive positioning and the relative quality perception
customers will assume for the product. The price fixation of a product or service is a comprehensive exercise
undertaken by the firms to ensure:
(A) The product competes with like competitive products.
(B) To convey a relationship between the customers’ need and the value perception customers attach to
the product or service to fulfil that need.
(C) To ensure that the manufacturer gets adequately compensated for the inputs (factors of production)
employed in the manufacturing process of the product.
(D) To adequately compensate the distribution channels and middlemen involved in rendering services of
making that product available to the customers at the place and time of their choice and convenience.
Pricing is an exercise for the products to be marketed. Manufacturers make use of three basic factors to fix
their prices. The first factor is the product cost, which includes the basic cost of raw materials, the conversion
cost and the related sales costs. The second factor firm keeps in mind is the competitive products’ pricing
strategies, which will be based on the positioning the firm undertake for its products. The third factor is the
optimum price, which will be determined by the forces of demand and supply.
A firm’s international pricing strategy will additionally be shaped and influenced by many other factors,
such as fiscal and exchange controls of other countries, exchange fluctuations, subsidies provided and duties
BIT BOOK WALA
imposed by other countries’ governments, dumping undertaken by international marketing firms from other
countries and the impact of grey markets or smuggled goods. For achieving a healthy growth in international
markets, a firm will have to coordinate its pricing strategy in such a manner that each factor contributes
positively to the acceptance of a firm’s products in international markets. “Pricing is especially very important
element of international marketing strategy decisions as it determines the stance a marketer will take on the
product positioning, market segmentation, demand management and market share dynamics”1
In international marketing strategy, the price of a product becomes the major factor that influences a
customer’s purchase decision. In earlier chapter on ‘Product decisions’ it has already been discussed that the
country of origin conveys connotations of quality to customers and, many times, customers are willing to pay
a higher price for an imported product even though a competitive and better priced home product can easily be
bought by the customers. While setting product price for international markets, manufacturers have to be extra
careful as the strategy to reach the right price can spell success or failure in the international market place. Even
though the marketing firm has introduced the best of products abroad and has selected the best distribution
channels and the promotion mix, the product will not sell if it has not been priced correctly in the right segment.
A product’s price must reflect the manufacturers’ objective in the market segment he wants his product to
address. It must reflect the quality and the value the costumers of this segment expect to be treated to and,
finally, price the products in a manner that allows enough manoeuvrability to attend to the competitive
reactions and responses to the price in the short and long run. A complete analysis of the factors associated
with the price setting exercise of an international marketing firm will be undertaken in this chapter. The
1. Terry Clark, Massaki Kotabe and Dan Rajaratnam, “Exchange Rate Pass through and International Pricing Strategy:
A Conceptual Framework and Research Propositions,” Journal of International Business Studies, Second Qr. 1999,
Vol.30 No.2, Pp. 249-268.
www.bitbookwala.in
Pricing Strategy and Decision for International Marketing 221
environmental as well as internal challenges that a firm will face in deciding the price levels in international
markets will also be analysed.
This chapter will focus on all the aspects of international pricing strategy an international firm takes into
account while reaching decisions on pricing in international markets.
SECTION 2:
PRICING STRATEGY FOR INTERNATIONAL MARKETS
“Pricing is like a tripod, the three legs being cost, demand and competition. It is no more possible to say that
one or another of these factors determines price than it is to assert that one leg rather than either of the other
two supports a tripod”.2 International marketing firms can be successful in formulating the right price
combinations in various markets only if they are aware of the international consumers’ differences in their
propensity to pay for the products, along with the elasticity that can affect the demand as well as the price in
foreign countries. International marketing firms can decide to have either a universal price the world over or the
price can be lower or higher in international markets, depending on the strategies to be adopted for each
country separately. Two hypothetical situations have been given below.
www.bitbookwala.in
222 International MarketingText and Cases
of Chinese sets actually posed a competition for them, forcing them to reduce their prices. This aspect
will be discussed in detail with the ‘skimming the cream’ strategy adopted by an international market-
ing firm.
• The cost of manufacturing may be cheaper in the home market, as compared to the cost incurred by the
competition in other countries. The outsourcing of production abroad and the economies of scale may
not offer much relief to the international firm if it shifts its manufacturing base abroad.
• The international marketing firm caters to only a limited segment of customers in the home country.
• The customers of other international markets have a higher propensity to pay for the international
marketing firm’s products in their countries.
The strategic options available to an international marketing firm in this regard have been discussed below.
3. Jack Sweeney, “PC Vendors Bend Pricing For Overseas Customers,” Computer Reseller News, January 23, 1995,
No. 614 P.3.
www.bitbookwala.in
Pricing Strategy and Decision for International Marketing 223
result in instant acceptance of the firm’s product from the customers of competitive products and the firm will
be able to penetrate the price-conscious segment of the market immediately. Such a move can be supported
with other marketing mix and promotion elements to ensure that necessary information about the new product
reaches all levels of customers. When Coca Cola and its other brand of soft beverages were reintroduced in the
Indian markets in the early 1990s, the company preferred a launching price of Rs.5 per bottle. A similar move had
been adopted by Pepsi to fight the local competition and once both the multinational firms had been able to
penetrate the market share of the competitive products, they hiked their prices. Sony found that its portable
disc player, which was priced at $600 in the United States, could still gain a better market share if the price was
brought down. The management of Sony decided to cut the price by half and take advantage of the economies
of scale to penetrate the American market. The reduced price, in the range of $ 300, assured larger sales volumes
to offset the price reductions and gain better market share for the product. The figure that follows exhibits the
comparative difference in the basic approach to pricing adopted by a Japanese firm and an American firm. It is
observed that both the firms begin the exercise by referring to the research findings and designing the product
accordingly. However, the Japanese get down to the costing of the product after taking into account the
planned selling price they expect to set up for the product. Working backwards from the planned sales price, the
Japanese firm will always keep the target cost in view while designing a new product.
Product Characteristics
BIT BOOK WALA Product Characteristics
Engineering
TARGET
Supplier Pricing
Design Engineering Supplier Pricing
COST
Manufacturing
If cost is too high,
return to design
phase. Continuous Cost Reduction
Manufacturing
Periodic
Cost Reduction
Source of the Diagram: Michael Robert, “Strategy Pure and Simple: How Winning CEOs Outthink their
Competition” (New York McGraw Hill, 1993) Pp.114-115.
www.bitbookwala.in
224 International MarketingText and Cases
Cost-based Pricing
A manufacturing and marketing organisation’s basic objective will always be to earn extra revenue as profits for
itself, after taking care of the costs incurred in producing and marketing of the services produced by it. As a
result, the cost becomes the deciding factor for any international marketing firm too. Unless the firm is able to
recover the minimum floor cost, it may not be interested in continuing in business for long. The international
marketing firms will generally be determining their export prices after taking into account the cost of produced
goods and add their own profits and other expenses incurred on delivery, freight, insurance and conditions,
etc. The profitability approach will, of course, be supporting such decision by the international marketing firm
but such an action is fraught with the following shortcomings.
• The relationship of cost and price is always in-built. But, many times, the cost of a product may not lead
to the actual price setting. In fact, it may happen the other way round. An international marketing firm
gaining entry into the export market for the first time may take a lead from the competitors’ prices to
determine the cost it should be incurring for manufacturing that product. The international marketing
firm will have to take into account the cost incurred in producing the same product by a competitor and
the price charged by him.
4. Cateora and Graham (2006), International Marketing, Twelth Edition, McGraw-Hill Education.
www.bitbookwala.in
Pricing Strategy and Decision for International Marketing 225
• In case this firm charges a lower price, the products’ perception in international markets might depre-
ciate.
• A lower price setting, based on the lower production costs, will mean offering huge margins to the
importer firm from abroad, which may not be necessary.
• The reverse may happen in case of higher price quotation by the international marketing firm, which
will make its products unwanted by many of the customers in other countries.
• The price setting exercise is quite a comprehensive work out, which will have its beginning in the
corporate objectives of the firm spelt out by the top management in advance. The mission statement
issued by the board of directors will specifically point out and guide the firm through its pricing
decisions at all stages. In addition, the other key factors like competition intensity, demand and supply
situation, consumer needs and preferences, legal and fiscal tax structures and the long- and short-term
pulls and pressures of the dynamic market forces will also have an equal role in determining the price
structures of the firm’s products in international markets.
Fixed Costs
Variable Costs
These are the costs that an international marketing firm will incur once it goes into production. These costs will
vary as the level of production changes. Variable costs can be increased or decreased with the levels of
volumes produced by the firm. The higher the production volumes, the lower will be the incident of variable
costs for each additional unit produced.
Total Cost
The sum total of the fixed cost and the variable cost is called the total cost of producing a product = FC+VC
Total Revenue
Revenue refers to the sales price of the product realised for each unit of production from the domestic/
international market. When the sales price of a single unit is multiplied with the number of units sold, it will give
the total revenue earned through sales or exports of its products in the domestic or international market:
TR = Price per unit x No. of units
The firm will reach a breakeven point when the total revenue earned by the firm will be equal to the total cost
incurred.
Thus Break Even analysis of the revenue income of the firm against the costs incurred will indicate whether
the firm is recovering its cost at particular volumes of sales for the price per unit it is able to recover from the
market place. This equation can be spelt as
www.bitbookwala.in
226 International MarketingText and Cases
BEP = TR = TC
where, TR = Units sold x price per unit
TC = Fixed Cost + Variable Cost.
Breakeven analyses of a firm manufacturing electric irons and exporting them at a price of $10 per iron, when
the fixed cost remains at $ 4000, will be calculated in the following fashion. The variable cost per unit of this iron
manufacturer at this stage is $ 6 per piece.
(1) Exporting price per iron = $ 10
(2) Variable cost per iron = $ 6
(3) Fixed cost = $ 4000
Thus, when the price per unit of iron sold in the international markets is $ 10, the international marketing firm
would have incurred a variable cost of $ 6 per iron. We can now workout the breakeven point (BEP) of desired
production for international market by dividing the total fixed cost with per unit fixed cost.
BEP Production Level = TFC / FC per unit= $ 4000 / $ 4 = 1000 Irons
Thus, 1000 units of irons must be produced and sold in the international market at a market price of $ 10 per
iron to cover the fixed costs as well as variable cost.
This can be explained with the help of the above definition:
BEP = TR = TC
TR = TC
PxQ = TFC + TVC
BIT BOOK WALA
L100xQ = $ 4000 + ($. 6*Q)
$. 4 = $ 4000
Q = 1000 units of irons
In $-value, the BEP will be $. 10x1000 = $.10,000, which will also be the total revenue the firm must generate
to reach the BEP.
The breakeven point can also be explained with the help of the following figure, where the profit starts only
after reaching the breakeven point.
It is observed that TR and TC cut each other at 1000 units and $ 10,000 revenue, which is also the breakeven
point for this manufacturer of irons. He must produce 1000 irons and export them at $ 10,000 ($ 10 for each unit
to recover the total cost.) If he is able to sell beyond $10,000 and above 1000 units, each extra unit sold will add
extra profit to his kitty. However, this is only a hypothetical equation as the market will react to all kinds of
elasticity on the demand curve. A firm can accordingly work out its international price and profit levels by
drawing different positions of breakeven points.5
Such an approach is adopted by the international marketing firm at the initial stages of its international
marketing activities in order to:
• Recover the investment incurred on setting up the international business and the expense for product
research and development from international markets at the earliest.
• When the international marketing firm wants to fully ensure that its profitability levels are maintained
from the day one of its operations, as the firm’s marketing activities and the earnings thereof will be
quite negligible in home country markets.
5. This Exercise has been adapted from “Fundamentals of Sales Management”, Macmillan India Ltd, Ramneek
Kapoor, Pp. 42-46.
www.bitbookwala.in
Pricing Strategy and Decision for International Marketing 227
Total cost
and Revenue TR
16000
Profit
14000
TC
12000
BEP
10000
8000
6000
Fixed Cost
4000
2000
0 200 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000
BIT BOOK WALA Units of Irons
Breakeven Chart
• The international marketing firm wants to simplify its operations and the pricing strategies in interna-
tional markets.
www.bitbookwala.in
228 International MarketingText and Cases
• Sales from the international markets are additional sales and, as such, the price earning from these sales
should not be overladen with the overhead costs, for which they can always turn to domestic markets.
• There is generally a view that these firms will not be able to compete with the superior products on
offers from developed countries, whose perceptions will always be higher than that of the products
from developing countries. These firms believe that price is the only factor that can manipulate market
demand in their favour.
• These firms also believe that a separate segment of the market in the underdeveloped and low national
income countries exists for the products from the developing countries. And, in such low income
segments, price could be the only decisive factor.
For such international firms, earning additional profits can also be the outcome of the Marginal Revenue
(MR) these firms earn for each additional unit sold in international markets. This MR will depict the change in
the total revenue (TR) of the firm every time it sells an additional unit of production to the export market.
Similarly, for producing an additional unit of product for the export market, the firm will be incurring Marginal
Cost (MC), in addition to the earlier total cost being incurred.
The firm can determine if the additional unit produced for international markets is contributing to the profits
by looking at the MR earned from that unit as against the MC incurred. In case MR is greater than MC, the firm
will make profits. However, where the profits decline over a period of time, the firm will have to continue
producing till the point where MR = MC, as beyond that point the MR per unit may decline and the
contributions from additional unit produced will become negative.
The diagram below will indicate the international marketing firm’s position.
Price.
(Exports)
AR
MR
This firm’s average revenue (total sales revenue ∏ number of units sold, or the price per unit) has a sloping
demand curve, which means each additional unit produced will be sold at a cost lesser than the earlier unit.
Such a firm can make profits only where MR = MC. In this case, Price P = Quantity Q, as MR = MC is seen at this
point only. If the firm produces higher / lesser quantity, the MC will be higher and the profits will decline. In a
typical domestic-based firm, for whom international marketing activity will mean more emphasis on price earned
from international marketing, the MR analyses helps in finding out if the firm is making profits from such
international sales.
www.bitbookwala.in
Pricing Strategy and Decision for International Marketing 229
continue till the contributions from each additional unit sold are positive. The moment this contribution equals
cost, the firm will have to keep sales restricted to that level only.
www.bitbookwala.in
230 International MarketingText and Cases
outside agencies, the projections of international sales people and other channels of distribution involved in
distribution of its products abroad. The international price/ product positioning will have the following three
options in relation to competitive products:
Leadership Positioning
This means pricing the product in international markets above the
market price level of other international competitive products.
New Product
Such leadership pricing can be adopted for an innovative product
that the international marketing firm wants to project as superior Existing Products
Price
than other similar products available in the international market.
The target customers in such cases will have to be predefined and
a niche market will have to be created to generate a favourable
and positive customer perception about the product in that
International market demand
market. The innovative products with superior technical
(Figure Adopted from Fundamentals of Sales
breakthrough, the distinctive, superior, tangible and intangible Management, Ramneek Kapoor, Macmillan
advantages that the product has to offer could be placed at a level India, Pp. 42-46)
higher than other international products till other competitive
products catch up with it or a new innovation is introduced in the market. This strategy has been discussed in
the skimming the market cream pricing strategy too within this chapter.
www.bitbookwala.in
Pricing Strategy and Decision for International Marketing 231
This kind of product positioning will not lead to price competition, as it will match the rivals.
SECTION 3:
FACTORS INFLUENCING PRICING DECISIONS
These can also be called the challenges an international marketing firm faces from external factors or its own
internal components when setting international prices. An international marketing firm will have to react to the
BIT BOOK WALA
changes in the legal, political, competitive, economic and financial environment in relation to its international
pricing strategies and address any factorial change that can make its pricing uncompetitive or unbeneficial in
the international markets.
“Auto giants like General Motors, Ford and Hyundai have set base in India. Cellular phone
manufacturers like Nokia, Motorola and LG and car manufacturers like General Motors,
Volkswagen, Federal Mogul, Toyota, Ford and Mico Bosch are using India as a
manufacturing base for car components as well as a base for their R&D facilities to
www.bitbookwala.in
232 International MarketingText and Cases
develop cheap cars. Automobile manufacturers like the Korean company Hyundai Motors
have already made India a manufacturing hub for its small car. The Indian arm of the
world’s second largest car maker – Ford – has emerged as one of the largest exporters of
cars. Tata Motors too has signed up with the UK-based MG Rover Group to export an
estimated 100,000 cars over the next five years.”
Indian Manufacturing Companies Aspire to be World Beaters adite | hubpages.com/hub/
Indian_Manufacturing
Keeping Track of Cost We have seen that the costs of the product play a large role in deciding the
profitability and revenue returns from the product. Any savings made on account of cost reworking can help
the firm focus more resources on fighting competition by other means, in addition to the price of the product.
The international marketing firms with manufacturing bases spread over various parts of the globe will have to
keep track of the rise and fall in the cost of components that go into manufacturing and marketing of the
product. These product components are manufactured in different countries, whereas the final product may be
assembled in some other country. Such assembled products find markets all over the world, where they may
have to compete with products from many developed and developing countries. Therefore, it becomes
important for them to keep track of the competitive market-based prices of their rivals to ensure their products
do not get priced out in international markets. Such market vigilance will help them to get back to the drawing
board and rework the cost and price, if the market competition calls for it. Due to cost competitiveness attained
by many of the industry leaders in their fields, India is becoming the outsourcing hub for I.T. services, back-
BIT BOOK WALA
office support systems and even in pharmaceuticals. Mr. Arun Shourie’s article, published in the Indian
Express on 16th August 2003, illustrates the point.
• The cost competitiveness of Indian goods and services gives India an edge over other countries.
Indeed, the difference between the costs at which India provides services and many commodities of
comparable quality and the cost in the developed world is too vast to affect the competitiveness of the
importing firms and economies. The following are a few glimpses of India’s cost competitiveness in
international markets:
• Indian IT firms provide world class services at one tenth the cost of what the same
services will cost in the United States.
• An MBA degree costs about us $ 5000 in India; in the U.S. an MBA degree will cost
around US dollar 120,000.
• Developing a new automobile model in the United States will cost around US $ one
billion. Indica, Scorpio has been designed, developed and produced totally in India.
They have been acclaimed abroad and found to be up to the international standards.
The cost of designing them is half of what it would have cost in U.S.
• India is highly competitive in medicines and surgery. A bypass surgery in India costs
around Rupees 40000; in the United States it can cost anything above rupees 6
lakhs. The cost of open heart surgery can be anything between rupees 15 lakhs and
35 lakhs as against Rs. 1.5 lakhs to Rs. 5lakhs in the best of hospitals in India.
Source. Arun Shorie, When Sky Is the Limit, the Indian Express, 16th August 2003.
www.bitbookwala.in
Pricing Strategy and Decision for International Marketing 233
www.bitbookwala.in
234 International MarketingText and Cases
manufacturers. Even though the manufacturers may not provide any kind of warranty or after-sales service
assurances on such grey imports yet the low prices attract customers.
The manufacturer may have priced the product substantially higher in the home market. The lower price so
fixed abroad will encourage re-importing the same product from a low priced country.
Due to low tariff rates prevailing in Canada, there is a substantial price difference between the United States
and Canadian markets on automobiles. Since there is not much customs tariff between the two countries, the
distributors from Canada often sell automobiles to customers in the U.S.8.
Grey marketing into the well established products of international marketing firms adversely affects the
sales and the customer perception of the products in all countries. The firms will have to take necessary
precautions to discourage such activities at all levels, either through the distributor of another country or
through the unauthorised channels. The proactive strategy will mean clearly differentiating the product
marking for each country in which goods are sold and specifying the benefit of warranty and guarantee for that
particular country only. The reactive steps could be taking the help of authorities in curbing the illegal trade on
which no taxes are being paid, confronting the traders involved in these activities, getting the goods
confiscated or managing supply chain to control and keep track of inventories of distributors. A proactive and
strategic pricing policy that could adapt itself to the changed scenario at the international market place will
certainly help the firm curb such menace to a large extent.
SECTION 5:
DUMPING
8. International Marketing, Rakesh Mohan Joshi, Oxford University Press, and Pp398-399.
9. Lester Ross and Susan Ning, “Modern Protectionism: China’s Own Anti-Dumping Regulations”, The China
Business Review, May / June 2000, No.3 Pp.30-33.
www.bitbookwala.in
Pricing Strategy and Decision for International Marketing 235
It is interesting to note that the United States Department of Commerce, the department entrusted with the
task of assessing whether dumping has taken place in the US defines dumping as “dumping is said to have
taken place if products are priced only minimally above cost, or at prices below those charged in the exporting
country”. (ibid).
There are numerous instances of countries levying charges of dumping against China, Japan and even
United States. India has been taking various actions against Chinese exporters of different commodities to
restrict the damage caused to a range of domestic industry.
Given below are the instances of imposition of anti-dumping duty on nylon tyres cord, rubber chemicals and
even on automotive tyres by the Indian government authorities against the imports from China.
Similar to anti-dumping duties are the countervailing duties that countries impose to protect their domestic
industry. These duties are imposed on subsidised products imported into the country. The exporter country
government provides such subsidies to their own exporters to encourage exports of a particular industry’s
produce. The subsidies are provided in the shape of aid in the production process or additional aid in the shape
of subsidies on freight, etc., to bring down the cost of distribution.
In the instance of United States and Japan dumping cold steel into Indian markets, the government of India
had decided to impose an anti-dumping duty, varying from US$ 305 to US$ 450 per metric tonne, depending on
the thickness of the cold-rolled steel sheets.
www.bitbookwala.in
236 International Marketing–Text and Cases
In its final findings notification, gazette recently, the Authority held that the subject
goods have been found to be exported from the US and Japan below their normal value,
resulting in dumping. The domestic industry continues to suffer material injury and due
to the likelihood of injury to the indigenous industry as a sequel to the persistent
dumping, the anti-dumping duty might continue to remain imposed. However, due to
the negative injury margin in respect of imports from the EU and Canada, the anti-
dumping duty on EU and Canada might be withdrawn, the Authority said.
As the prices of subject goods have seen volatility during the recent past, the
Authority deems it appropriate to recommend fixed anti-dumping duty, following its
review.
Thus, in the case of firms exporting cold-rolled flat products of stainless steel of width
of 600 mm or more or whether further processed or not from the US, the anti-dumping
duty is $445.69 a metric tonne and in the case of firms exporting from Japan the
recommended anti-dumping duty is $ 305 per metric tonne.
G. Srinivasan, Hindu Business line, internet, edition, Oct, 2006.http://www.blonnet. com/
2005/10/07/stories/2005100702900300. htm.
However countries do find ways and means to circumvent the anti-dumping legislation by modifying their
products and by introducing additional benefits into the products so as to ensure their products are not
www.bitbookwala.in
Pricing Strategy and Decision for International Marketing 237
The existing US law, which has been invoked by the US industry against foreign
imports, allows the US Government to impose tariffs against below-the-market price
products.
But the new amendment, known by its sponsor’s name Robert Byrd, a Democrat senator
of West Virginia, goes beyond and would divert the tariff revenues from the treasury and
award them to the complaining industry.
The complaint alleged that the diversion of tariff revenues amounted to giving the
complaining US industry a subsidy, which is barred by global free-trade rules. It also said
the amended law encouraged US companies to make claims of dumping because they
would receive a “double reward” — less competition from imports and income from
increased tariffs.
Analysts said the revenues from anti-dumping levels could range from $40 million to
$ 200 million a year, but it was uncertain because heavily taxed imports were less likely to
be sold in the U.S. markets, which would bring down any tariff income from them.
The USA has been dragged to the WTO in recent weeks through several complaints by
countries questioning its steel import policy. The EU said it wanted WTO consultations
with the USA to negotiate on import restrictions on steel wire rod and welded pipeline
that the Clinton administration had imposed this year. South Korea had already brought
a complaint against the same measure on Berlin, in Dec 25 (PTI).
Source: The Tribune Online Edition, December 26, 2000, http://www.tribuneindia.com/
2000/20001226/index.htm.
BIT BOOK WALA
SECTION 6:
THE INTERNATIONAL POLITICAL AND LEGAL ENVIRONMENT
Governments all across the world regulate prices and the margins allowed to the international marketing firms.
The wholesaler’s margins, the retail recommended resale prices and the definitions of inclusive or exclusive of
freights rates and the local taxes imposed thereof are some of the measures that the governments of the
countries legislate to keep control over the price manipulations of the international firms. In addition, the
governments can also impose additional tariffs and other duties on imports of products by international
marketing firms in order to provide some kind of breathing space to their home industries. Many of the
subsidies offered in the agriculture sector, cottage industry, small-scale industries are part of such measures
taken by governments to protect infant and emerging industries. The international pricing strategies of the
international marketing firms also get affected by the steps taken by the governments to control inflation,
currency regulations and repatriation of profits to the home countries of international firms. Each such factor
that an international firm will have to grapple with while finalising its international pricing strategy is discussed
below.
Transfer Pricing
Transfer pricing strategy refers to the pricing strategy adopted for intra-firm’s sales whether within the same
borders or outside the state borders but to the same corporate units to which this firm belongs. In other words,
the transfer pricing is a strategy by which a transaction between the buyer and seller belonging to the same
www.bitbookwala.in
238 International MarketingText and Cases
corporate parent takes place. For example, Ford Motors’ subsidiaries may buy or sell to each other in India or
abroad and the pricing strategy for selling Ford Motors products to each other by different subsidiaries of Ford
Motors is known as transfer pricing. “The pricing of products in the process of conducting transactions
between the units of same corporation, within or beyond the national borders of parent company, is known as
transfer pricing and regarded as a legitimate business opportunity by transnational corporations”. 10
Under this strategy, the international marketing firms will try to ensure that the profitability of each unit is
maintained when such an intra-corporate transfer takes place. The international marketing firms will have to
adhere to the local laws, taxes, duties, tariffs and other government regulations while affecting such transfer
pricing strategies. Under such transactions, the products can be priced at cost, at the market-based prices,
known as market based transfer pricing, or even at the negotiated transfer prices, which could be a price in
between the two strategies of cost and market.
10. Messaoud Mehafdi, “The Ethics of International Transfer Pricing, Journal of Business Ethics, December 2000, Vol.
28, No.4, Pp 365-3810.
11. Rakesh Mohan Joshi, International Marketing, Oxford University Press, 2005, Pp.394-395.
www.bitbookwala.in
Pricing Strategy and Decision for International Marketing 239
Agriculture has traditionally been a primary source of economic tension between the
United States and the European Union. The dispute over the EU’s banana regime has been
among the most contentious in recent years. It is also among the more legally and
politically complex. The European Union restrictions on banana imports from the United
www.bitbookwala.in
240 International MarketingText and Cases
States have cost European consumers up to 2 billion a year. United States decided to take
punitive action against these restrictions and imposed 100 percent advalorem punitive
tariff on $191.4 billion worth of imports from European Union. This further aggravated
the burden on the European customers, who had to pay for the restrictive and tariff rate
quota system of the European Union. (ibid)
http://www.asil.org/insights/insigh63.htm
Another example can be seen in the imposition of heavy tariffs on imports of beef in
European countries. The European Union has imposed a complete ban on the import of
hormone-treated beef from the United States; while at the same time it has also imposed
a tariff of 125 percent on beef imports, in addition to offering heavy subsidies to farmers
in E.U... Such double impact costs amount to almost $ 15 million to the European
customers in the prices of beef going up.
Farm Incomes: Myths and Reality by Alan Matthews. Cork University Press
SECTION: 7
THE INTERNATIONAL ECONOMIC AND FINANCIAL ENVIRONMENT
Volatility of Exchange Rates
International exchange markets do not remain the same at all times. International companies have to monitor the
exchange rate fluctuations to ensure they do not unnecessarily suffer uncalled for losses. Vigilance is called for
at all times on the movement of currency exchange rates in different markets of the world. Otherwise,
international marketing firms will find that what was a profitable proposition at the time of entering the import/
export contract, has become a loss-making venture at the time of execution. So how do international firms
handle the price adjustments? The best and the easiest way could be to fix the price of the products in the
12. Collins and Doorley ‘Teaming Up For The 90’s: A Guide To International Joint Ventures And Strategic Alliances:,
Homewood , I.L;Business One Irwin, 1991, PP.212-213.
www.bitbookwala.in
Pricing Strategy and Decision for International Marketing 241
currency of the target markets, where any fluctuation will lead to gain or loss for the seller. This way the
customer remains unaffected, as the exporting firm will have to handle the fluctuations of the home market. The
other way of handling this could be to fix up the price in the home market currency, wherein any change will
have to be borne by the importer. The seller exporter will remain immune from the dynamic nature of the
exchange markets.
International marketing firms, however, do not operate only on short-term basis, affecting change every time
a minor fluctuation takes place in the currency rates. Their agreements for their imports and exports are long-
term contracts, wherein a specially stipulated exchange rate clause will specify up to what extent the change in
exchange rate will not impact the contract either way. For example, a contract may specify that the exchange rate
variation of plus or minus five percentage points will not affect the pricing agreement over the next three month
period. In that case, a small drop or gains will not call for the renegotiation of the established prices. Should
there be greater volatility than specified, the firms will have to sit for review and fix the fresh pricing strategy for
their products.
It has been observed that all international marketing firms have been specifically entering into international
contracts with strong, stable and hard currency. Till the introduction of Euro as a strong viable alternative
currency, the American dollar was considered the safest and the most dependable hard currency. The member
countries to the E.U. have adopted Euro as a single currency for standard of exchange, in addition to the
currency of the country of the seller. As such, all international prices will have two quotations, the standard of
exchange and the national currency of the seller.
International marketing firm will have to adopt the following different approaches to handle the currency
fluctuations and to ensure long-term profits, as well as long-term healthy buyer–seller relationships.
BIT BOOK WALA
In the event of domestic currency being weak, an international marketing firm preferably should:
• Raise sales invoices on foreign importers currency, to get better realisation from the export price.
• As far as possible, adopt full cost international pricing strategy. Marginal cost pricing can be adopted
to penetrate hitherto unexplored markets.
• Expand its own product line and add substantial value addition features to the product.
• Reduce outsourcing from outside the home market and all sourcing/manufacturing should be shifted
to the domestic country.
• Explore export opportunities worldwide, aggressively.
• Purchase supportive marketing services like advertising, logistical and marine insurance, etc., in local
currency of the home market.
Such measures will help the international marketing firm strengthen its position both in domestic as well as
the export markets, as its realisations from conversion will generate additional revenue against foreign currency
conversions.
The international marketing firm will have to resort to the following opposite steps, should the home country
currency get strong:
• The firm should focus its competitive strategy on improving product quality, after-sales service and
other sales supportive activities like timely and efficient logistic services. Such a move will ensure
prevention of competition on price front.
• Encourage a cost reduction exercise all around in the firm to conserve resources.
• Increased productivity will help attain economies of scale.
• Arrange outsourcing/ manufacturing from foreign markets.
• Shift focus on exports to relatively strong currency markets.
www.bitbookwala.in
242 International MarketingText and Cases
• Marginal cost pricing strategy will make the international price an attractive proposition for the buyers
from abroad.
• Defer repatriation of foreign currency funds from abroad.
• Counter trade with weak currency countries.
• Prefer expenditures on supportive marketing activities in local host country currency abroad.
• Raise sales invoices on importers from abroad in their own countries currency.
• Borrowings can be arranged in local host country for expansions, etc.
COUNTER TRADE
Counter trade is the kind of sales transaction in international marketing that involves reciprocal commitment of
exchange of the products or goods of the value for which sales invoice is raised by the seller. No cash payments
of hard foreign currency are involved in counter trade. In the counter trade context, there are three contracts
involved in most transactions. The first covers the underlying business transaction, the second covers the
counter trade transaction and the third covers the protocol or linkage that ties the two together compensatory
BIT BOOK WALA
arrangements. Also referred to as counter trade, reciprocal trade, offset, or counters purchase. A seller of a
product or system (usually a multinational, diversified or decentralised company) is compelled by the buyer
(usually a foreign government) into a direct or indirect reciprocal purchasing relationship as a condition of sale.
“The seller must agree to one of a number of possible arrangements: Local manufacturing of components
related to the product or system (direct); Purchase of unrelated commodities (indirect); Purchase of unrelated
manufactured goods (indirect); Transfer of technology/licensing/investments to the buyer country (direct or
indirect); Create foreign exchange to facilitate original sale. (The seller would “sell” an unrelated product from
buyer country first and then uses the resulting foreign exchange to help the buyer pay for the product or
system.)”13
Developing countries, in particular, face a crunch of hard currency (currency that is acceptable for payment
by any international supplier of goods and services.) Low reserves of hard currency can further deplete if
countries allow outflow of hard currency for payments against imports into the country. In such situations,
importers from the country are forced to adopt alternative mode of payments for their import commitments
through barter and other forms of counter trade.
A typical counter trade exchange, generally, involves an international seller from a developed, industrialised
country and a buyer importer from a developing country, in whose country the scarcity of hard currency has led
to complete governmental control on the conversion and drawing of hard currency. This situation prevailed in
the Indian economy during the early 1990s, when balance of payment had also been adverse due to shortage
of hard currency. Banking finance also was available only for most essential imports. Unessential imports could
be managed only against counter trade. Many governments make counter trade mandatory to control the
outflow of hard foreign currency and maintain balance of payments in their international trade. Counter trade is,
13. http://www.barternews.com/countertrade.htm
www.bitbookwala.in
Pricing Strategy and Decision for International Marketing 243
in fact, on the increase throughout the world and is currently estimated to be around 20 percent of the total
world trade.14
Barter Barter is a centuries old system of exchange of goods and services. It started when mankind had not
invented any standard of exchange to pay each other for the goods and services bartered. It calls for a simple,
non-monetised unit of exchange between two parties. Although there is no money involved, dealing
international firms will calculate the value of goods or services exchanged in one particular currency and then
exchange the goods at par value between the buyer and the seller. Russia has been the biggest barter exchange
economy, with as high as 70 percent of Russian activity depending on barter.15
Clearing Arrangement This arrangement is also known as clearing account. Under this system of
barter, the third party, a broker or even the governments of two countries, act as banks and create trade credits
for respective parties under a mutually signed agreement, wherein both agree to import-export certain goods for
a given period of time. Thus they agree to do against a mutually decided currency. Both parties keep trading
with each other, in agreed upon goods, within the given time frame. Whenever there is an imbalance noticed in
either party’s account, and one country has to make payment to the other to balance the accounts again, swing
credits are paid in the agreed upon hard currency.
Compensation This system of counter trade involves paying the exporter part cash and part in kind by
way of products. The cash payment is made in mutually decided convertible currency. The exporter seller firm
is on safer grounds, especially if the cash component is higher because this firm then does not have to spend
time, effort and money in hiving off the goods received in the exchange deal.
Buyback Arrangements It is a kind of collaborative arrangement where the seller provides technical
collaboration in the form of technical know-how, builds and provides a turnkey plant to the international
customer, along with other capital goods. The seller arranges for the necessary equipment, patents and
licenses, along with the rights to produce and distribute the products. The sellers may be paid in agreed upon
convertible currency, after the commissioning of the plant and the balance payment is deferred to be offset
against the production of the plant over an extended period of time. Such arrangements can be found in Indian
automotive tyres industry, where technical collaborations exist between Continental tyres of Germany and the
Indian manufacturers Metro Tyres, on buyback arrangements. Metro tyres have put up a plant in north India,
with technical know-how from Continental of Germany. Continental has entered into an agreement with the
14. Sam C. Okoroafo, “Determinants Of LDC –Mandated Counter Trade”, International Marketing Review, Winter
1998, Vol.5, Pp.16-24.
15. David Woodruff, Money Unmade: Barter and The Fate of Russian Capitalism, Cornell University Press, 1999.
www.bitbookwala.in
244 International MarketingText and Cases
Indian manufacturer to buy back a part of the production to meet its worldwide exports of two- and three-
wheeler tyres and tubes. (http://www.tribuneindia.com/2006/20060912/biz.htm).
Counter Purchase Counter purchase involves two parallel contracts, involving dealing in two parallel
exchanges. The seller exporter enters into two separate agreements to buy products that are unrelated to its
existing line of international business. These separate contracts will be entered into for different products, each
specifying cash value separately. The seller exporter selects the products it wants to buy back from the list
provided by the importer. These products will then be sold by the exporter into the international market to
recover hard currency payments due from the importer. Such an agreement can be for total imports to be paid
off or it could be part in cash and part in the form of goods. The advantage of this parallel barter is that the seller
gets his cash by selling off goods to another buyer upfront. The famous counter purchase deal between
PepsiCo and Russia spells out the typical counter purchase example. PepsiCo exported its syrup to Russia
against the barter arrangement of Stolichnaya vodka, which it had planned to sell in the United States.16
Offset Purchase This is done generally in large government and public sector undertakings where the
government of the importer country is not in a position to make the payment in hard currency, or even in a
situation where balance of payment issues may be involved. Purchases such as public utilities, defence
equipments, armaments, railway/road/township building equipment, telecommunication projects and river
project equipments, etc, involve huge amounts of hard currency, which is difficult to be procured for
developing countries. Therefore, the seller agrees to accept part of the payment in hard currency and the
balance to be adjusted against sourcing of inputs from the importing country. The seller may also agree to make
investments in the importing country to facilitate manufacturing of such goods. Or, it may enter into a deal to
BIT BOOK WALA
transfer technology to the importing country, or marketing different products sourced in the purchasing
country.17
REFERENCES
1. Terry Clark, Massaki Kotabe and Dan Rajaratnam, “Exchange Rate Pass - Through and
International Pricing Strategy: A Conceptual Framework and Research Propositions”,
Journal of International Business Studies, Second Qr. 1999, Vol.30 No.2, Pp. 249-268).
2. Administered Prices “Hearing Before The U.S. Senate Sub Committee”.
3. Jack Sweeney, “PC Vendors Bend Pricing For Overseas Customers”, Computer Reseller
News, January 23, 1995, No. 614 P.3.
4. Michael Robert, “Strategy Pure and Simple: How Winning CEOS Outthink Their Compe-
tition” New York McGraw Hill, 1993, pp.1214-115.
5. Fundamentals of Sales Management, Macmillan India Ltd, Ramneek Kapoor, Pp. 42-46.
6. Fundamentals of Sales Management, Ramneek Kapoor, Macmillan India Ltd, Pp. 42-46.
7. Indian Manufacturing Companies Aspire To Be World Beaters, Adite Hubpages.Com/
8. Arun Shourie, When Sky Is The Limit, The Indian Express, 16 August 2003.
16. Aschkenasy, “Give And Take” International Business Pp.10-12.
17. Hennar, “Some Empirical Dimensions”, Pp.243-270.
www.bitbookwala.in
Pricing Strategy and Decision for International Marketing 245
WEBSITES VISITED
1. Adite | hubpages.com/hub/Indian_Manufacturing
2. http://www.tribuneindia.com/
3. http://www.blonnet.com
4. http://www.asil.org/insights/insigh63.htm
5. http://www.barternews.com/countertrade.htm
6. http://www.tribuneindia.com/
1. Acvusgil, S Tamer, “Pricing For Global Markets”, Columbia Journal of World Business,
31, No.4 1996.
www.bitbookwala.in
246 International MarketingText and Cases
2. Coopers and Lybrand, International Transfer Pricing, Oxford Shire: CCH Editions Ltd.
1993.
3. Faulds, David J. Orlen Grunewald, and Denise Johnson, “A Cross National Investigation
of Relationship between the Price and Quality of Consumer Products, 1970-1990”, Jour-
nal of Global Marketing, 8, No.1, 1994. Pp. 7-25.
4. Lancioni, Richard, and John Gattorna, “Strategic Value Pricing: It’s Role in International
Business”, International Journal of Physical Distribution and Logistics, 22, No.6 1992
Pp. 24-27.
5. Marn, Michael V. and Robert L. Rosiello, “Managing Price, Gaining Profit”, Harvard
Business Review, 70, No.5 – Octobwer1992, Pp.84-94.
6. Myers, Mathew B. “The Pricing of Exports Products: Why Aren’t Managers Satisfied
With The Results?” Journal of World Business, 32, Nio.3 1997, 277.
7. Nagle, Thomas T., “The Strategy and Tactics of Pricing: A Guide to Profitable Decision
Making”, Upper Saddle River, NJ, Prentice Hall, 1987.
8. Robert, Michael, “Strategy Pure And Simple: How Winning CEOS Outthink Their Compe-
tition”, New York: McGraw-Hill 1993.
9. Seymour, Daniel T., “The Pricing Decision”, Chicago Probus Publishing, 1989.
10. Sinclair, Stuart, “A Guide to Global Pricing”, Journal of Business Strategy, 14, No.3, 1993,
Pp.16-19.
1. The firm can justify keeping its prices higher in home market only if the following factors and
differences are noticeably in favor of keeping higher prices in home country’s market
(a) Labor or the raw material cost is higher in. home country as compared to the international
markets.
(b) Firm as a strategy wants to adopt the market penetration pricing objective.
(c) International markets’ consumers have a lower propensity to pay.
(d) Firm wants to fight the competition by keeping its products’ prices low in the home turfs of
competitors.
(e) All of these.
2. The firm can justify keeping its Home Market Prices Lower than the International Markets only
if following factors are noticeably in such favor
(a) There may not be much of competition available in international markets.
(b) Cost of manufacturing may be cheaper in home market.
(c) International marketing firm caters to only a limited segment of customers at home country.
(d) Customers of other international markets have a higher propensity to pay.
(e) All of these.
3. Standardized Pricing Strategy visualizes the entire international markets as one single unit and
the international marketing firm will devise a policy whereby
www.bitbookwala.in
Pricing Strategy and Decision for International Marketing 247
(a) Market prices for the product remain the same in all the markets
(b) market prices differ from country to country.
(c) Market prices differs in home country.
(d) Market prices differ in other countries.
(e) Market prices differ in all countries.
4. Market Penetration Pricing Strategy refers to the situation when the international marketing firm
adopts a strategy of
(a) Keeping prices lower than the competition.
(b) Keeping prices higher than the competition.
(c) Keeping prices at par with competition.
(d) Not focusing on pricing.
(e) Making prices irrelevant.
5. External Factors affecting Pricing Decisions of an international firm are
(a) International Competitive Environment.
(b) International purchasing parity and Currency exchange rates.
(c) Mechanics of demand and supply curve.
(d) Dumping
(e) All of these and many more.
6. Counter trade is the kind of sales transaction in international marketing that involves
(a) Reciprocal commitment of exchange of the products or goods of the value for which sales
BIT BOOK WALA
invoice is raised by the seller.
(b) Charging similar rates for all goods.
(c) Charging different rates from countries.
(d) Countering the imports from other countries.
(e) Countering exports to other countries.
7. Compensation system of counter trade involves
(a) Paying the exporter part cash and part in kind by way of products.
(b) Compensating for exchange rates fluctuations.
(c) Compensating for lower prices in home market.
(d) Compensating for higher prices in third countries.
(e) None of these.
8. Countervailing duties that countries impose to protect their domestic industry are imposed on
(a) domestic goods. (b) All imported goods.
(c) All exported goods. (d) Grey market goods.
(e) Subsidized products imported into the country.
9. Local Pricing policy of an international marketing firm is based on
(a) The needs of customers from different countries and Customers’ propensity to pay.
(b) Competition available and the price strategies adopted by competitors in different coun-
tries.
(c) Local taxation policies of different countries.
(d) The levels of distribution channels and the cost incurred thereof.
(e) All of these.
www.bitbookwala.in
248 International MarketingText and Cases
REVIEW QUESTIONS
1. Explain the concept of full cost pricing. What components of cost will you include in your
www.bitbookwala.in
Chapter 13
International Distribution,
Marketing Channels
Logistics and Supply Chain
BIT BOOK WALA
Management
Learning Objectives
The reader should be able to
• explain the concept of international distribution and logistics
• discuss distribution and supply management channels in international
markets
• explain and discuss the qualifying criterion, functions, advantages and
disadvantages of middlemen in international supply chain management
• address the challenges in logistics in international marketing.
www.bitbookwala.in
250 International MarketingText and Cases
SECTION 1:
INTRODUCTION
C onsumers in all countries buy goods and services at a place which is conveniently approachable, yet
prominent to provide comparatively higher satisfaction levels as compared to the time, effort, and money
spent by the consumer. Hence the mega task of an international marketer is to manage its logistics, distribution
and supply chain in a way that goods and services reach the customers in the most cost effective and efficient
manner. However in today’s multinational marketing set up all manufacturers cannot handle all the functions of
reaching the product to the ultimate consumer all alone, hence the task of distribution of international level
marketing has become the task of a specialist who can deliver goods to consumers across the countries
efficiently, ironing out the bottlenecks on the borders of the countries and smoothening the deliveries within
stipulated time dead lines.
The selection of middlemen could be a little easier if the manufacturer has the first hand knowledge about the
legal, economic, financial and ethical implications of distribution and logistics. He should also be fully aware of
the channels that could be utilised for his products by either benchmarking a successful competitive strategy
or devising his own direct distribution plans to the end consumer.
However in international marketing, distribution channels are diverse and may vary from one country to
another country and even within countries, there may be different modes and systems required to reach the
products to the final consumers. Under such circumstances a domestic manufacturer has to either take the help
of a third party professional international marketing firm or the manufacturer may decide to get into direct
dealings with the trade channels in order to market his products abroad.
www.bitbookwala.in
International Distribution, Marketing Channels Logistics and Supply Chain Management 251
SECTION 2:
DEFINING DISTRIBUTION
The American Management Association calls the channels of distribution “organized network of agencies and
institutions which in combination perform all the activities required to link producers with users to accomplish
the marketing task”.1 Distribution thus establishes channels that handle
1. the physical flow of goods and related services from the factories of manufacturers to marketing
channels which are easily approachable by the end user and consumers
2. it facilitates the transfer of ownership from the actual manufacturer or the middleman to the ultimate
customer
3. it manages backward flow of the price of the goods realised from the customer to the manufacturers
4. it regulates the flow of information about the product performance and the customer feed back to the
manufacturer and the other agencies involved in rendering services to the customer.
SECTION 3:
DISTRIBUTORS AND CHANNELS
Self Involvement
Multinational conglomerates decide to establish their own channels if they find that:
• the volume of business to be handled is quite high and the middlemen may not have the resources to
BIT BOOK WALA
provide the necessary facilities
• when multinational firm finds that it has enough resources and facilities of its own world wide and
starting operations in another country will simply mean reallocation of some of the resources from the
low point to high point priority area
• when the after sales servicing needs are too complex and only own establishment can justify custom-
ers’ expectations
• the price of product is too high
• the customer is too important and big with global operations
• the competitive strategy demands producer being in direct touch with the customer.
However establishing own channel network involves commitment of resources on a high scale and to
arrange all kinds of distribution facilities will mean add on costs to the customer price. It will also mean cutting
into the margins of the producers and reducing net realisations from the product.
www.bitbookwala.in
252 International MarketingText and Cases
International firms although have passed on the marketing controls to the home country middlemen it can still
establish its own liaison or sales coordination offices at a bare minimum level in other countries in order to
maintain liaison and coordination with distributors abroad. The wholly owned subsidiaries and coordination
franchisees can also be utilised for extending support to home country middlemen abroad.
Export Houses These are export companies specialising in export business rather than domestic sales.
Such export houses are recognised under the Exim Act and are designated different star status based on their
export performance and become eligible for the incentives from government. The export houses may represent
smaller companies of different industries e.g. marines, surgical instruments, hand tools, garments, handicrafts
and many others such items are manufactured by cottage and small manufacturers. They conduct research into
BIT BOOK WALA
the buyer’s requirements abroad, organise trade fairs, exhibitions and importer exporters meets to procure
business. They also undertake the task of preparing export documentation and managing all kinds of export
requirements.
Trading and Merchandising Companies Trading companies and export merchandisers are
middlemen who buy goods and products from the producers of their home countries and as such hold the legal
title to the ownership and possession of the products they represent. Such products may remain under the
brand umbrella of the actual producer or the merchant exporter many a times like to promote their own brands,
but such merchandising companies have to handle the diverse product mix. They also get a complete control
over the marketing mix of the products they represent for international markets.
Japanese export trading companies are another example of trading and merchandising at the international
level. Their marketing activities include finance, distribution, mining, gas exploration, and information trading
at the international level. They also act as investment holding companies. Most of Japanese exports and
imports are controlled by these members of “Keiretsus” families, who have interlocking stakes in the group
companies.2 These trading companies known as “Sogo Shashas” in Japan offer intermediary services,
information, conveyance, and financial assistance. US Exports Trading Companies Act 1982 had been
enacted for formation of such export trading companies in United States. These companies have since risen to
the level of multinational corporations representing smaller firms. These corporations now render exporting
services to these firms all across the globe.
Export Promotion Councils and Corporations In India such cooperative exports exist under
the aegis of government and semi-government agencies. Mineral and Metal Trading Corporation handles such
2. For more details on “Keiretsus” refer The Economist, Japanese Trading Companies – The Giants That Refuse to Die,
June 1, 1999 Vol. 319 No. 1109,pp 72-73.
www.bitbookwala.in
International Distribution, Marketing Channels Logistics and Supply Chain Management 253
exports on behalf of many commodity cooperatives in India. Jute Corporation of India, Tea Board, Spice Board
and Marine Export cooperatives are some of the cooperative associations formed by the member associations.
These cooperatives handle the export functions by providing services of marketing research, enquiry
generation, tender follow up and subsequent logistical support. These corporations also arrange trade fairs,
exhibitions, and exporters/ importers meet within the home countries and abroad too.
Under these cooperative exports, two or more complementary producers join hands and organise export
functions for each other such as a cycle manufacturer like Hero Cycles may export cycles’ spare parts of other
small manufacturers as accompaniment to their exports. This also happens in motor parts trade where an
automobile firm will arrange exports of spares required for after sales service for the automobiles under exports
abroad.
SECTION 4:
DIRECT AND INDIRECT MARKETING CHANNELS
IN A FOREIGN COUNTRY
While the international marketing firms may look for outside agents and seek their services and help within the
home country. It has two options abroad to reach its products and services to the end consumers.
1. Direct entry through its own sales force, sales offices, own retail stores, retail showrooms and retail
franchisee outlets
2. Indirect entry through distributors, stockists, retailers, stores, and whole sellers.
Although both the strategies put strain and stress on the end price to customers and the realisations of the
BIT BOOK WALA
firms’ returns, but the degree of impact may vary depending upon the nature of products and the level of
distribution channels engaged in international marketing. While the number of channels will be limited in
industrial products, in fast moving consumer products and white goods e.g. furniture, fashion designers’
labels and daily needs branded products would require a large network of sales agents abroad to ensure wider
distribution.
Manufacturers Direct Retail Stores Bata shoes, Singer sewing machines, Italian furniture’s
manufacturers preferred starting their own retail stores abroad and reach the customers directly. Many of the
www.bitbookwala.in
254 International MarketingText and Cases
Indian fashion designers have their own label stores abroad. Ritu Beri’s store has been started in Paris. In case
of wider product range such as shoes, beauty products, high priced expensive products manufacturer will
prefer remaining close to the customer to understand and cater to his needs better. Bata shoes have had their
own stores in almost every corner of the world. Heavy machinery manufacturers may establish a showroom as
a show case to provide necessary display to customers’ benefit and obtain market related information from
visiting customers abroad.
Consumer Products
The figure below describes the channels that a manufacturer can strategise for the distribution of consumer
products abroad.
Manufacturer (Consumer Goods)
Own Sales
Representatives
Agents/Stockists/
Door to Door Whole sellers
Whole sellers
Mail Order Catalogue
Retailers Retailers
Direct Exhibitions
Retailers
Network Marketing
Internet
Customers
Consumer Products Distribution Channels
www.bitbookwala.in
International Distribution, Marketing Channels Logistics and Supply Chain Management 255
Franchisees: This is an important mode of entry into the global market. Pizza Hut, McDonald’s, Domino’s,
Coffee shops, KFC have all been established under franchisees arrangements. Max store, Reebok, Nike have
franchisee arrangements all across the globe. Under these arrangements a franchisee makes his own
investments as per the norms set up by the manufacturers, using manufacturer’s brand name logo, shop décor
and advertising umbrella. Walls Stores, Burger Kings, TGT’S Fridays, Baskin Robbins are some of the other
brands that have established their presence and marketing network across many countries through franchisees
network.3
1. The Distributors and Merchant Middlemen They make their own investments in purchasing
import products and thus inherit title to the goods before they distribute it in their home country. The marketing
mix, advertising and sales promotion strategies are decided and controlled by them directly and independently.
The selection criterion of merchant middlemen may vary from company to company but must be undertaken
after thorough research and caution because once such alliance has been arranged and signed, companies in
many countries will have to rely on these firms.
3. Government Designated Agencies In India till the opening up of the economy, imports of
many items were put on the restricted list of quotas and licenses and were managed by government agencies
directly. These agencies undertook the task of redistribution within the country through their own offices and
branches. But current import/ export policy allows everything to be imported and exported unless put on the
restrictive or prohibitive list. This opening of the economy brought in all kinds of marketing opportunities to
international marketers and manufacturers. In many other countries where government agencies control
foreign exchange transactions imports are managed by government corporations and they help exporters from
abroad or their redistribution process by enacting legislative procedures.
Industrial Products Almost follow the indirect selling channels mentioned above like merchant
middlemen, export agents, import agents and brokers, act on behalf of the manufacturers of industrial products
by arranging distribution offices in different countries. These agents could be either stocking points for their
3. Waheeduzzaman A.N.M, ‘Can Modernisation Explain the Consumption of Durables in Emerging Markets? Jour-
nal of Global Marketing, The Haworth Press, Vol 19, No. 314, 2006.
www.bitbookwala.in
256 International MarketingText and Cases
manufacturers and arrange deliveries as and when it is needed by the industrial customer in case of raw material
and consumables. These agents could also be the only liaison representatives arranging customer demand
prototypes and samples, finalising export contracts and follow up of the payments. In such cases there can be
different import and export agencies catering to the after sales needs and spare parts needs of the clients.
Manufacturer
Industrial Custormers
SECTION 5:
DISTRIBUTOR AND MIDDLEMEN SELECTION
QUALIFICATION CRITERION
The process of selecting a distributor abroad will require qualifying a distributor on the criterion set by
international firm to attain its corporate objectives. In case the objective is mere exports the qualification criteria
could be simple export contract and the paying capacity of the importer. The criterion gets complex in case the
international marketing firm has to establish a permanent relationship with marketing agents and ensure
continuous brand building strategy across the globe. In such a situation common criterion for distributor
selection will include:
www.bitbookwala.in
International Distribution, Marketing Channels Logistics and Supply Chain Management 257
Geographical Considerations
Geographic locations of customers while in some countries could be easily accessible; it could be equally
BIT BOOK WALA
difficult in many other parts of the world, adding to not only the cost of logistical operations but also to the
woes of the distributing channels. In many parts of the world, the goods can be reached through air only, which
could be quite an expensive proposal. Again even air facilities may not be fully developed in underdeveloped
countries which means adding to the time and cost by way of unconventional means of transportation. In
United States, most of the states can be serviced through the interstate freeway system; the freeway is further
connected with navigable roads getting into the inhabited townships but in Latin America, where the terrain is
quite inhospitable; areas close to the coastlines are thickly populated. In Europe, countries are interlinked with
each other by a wide network of tunnels. But in African countries and even in Middle East, a multi model
transportation will also include camel backs, adding to transit period and cost of transportation thereof.
Besides the telecommunication network in many parts of the world, is still not developed fully in spite of
internet having made its inroads. The international marketer will have to take into consideration all such
geographical and physical requirements before finalising the global supply chain and distribution management
which is another name given to logistics.
SECTION 6:
INTERNATIONAL LOGISTICS AND GLOBAL SUPPLY
CHAIN MANAGEMENT
The word logistics has been derived from the French word “loger” which refers to the arrangement of supplies
and accommodation of the army troops, in real situation also the refurbishing of supplies to military troops and
its management thereof refers to the logistics. Such exercise is undertaken by the troops in all kinds of peace
and war situations to ensure the soldiers on the fronts are not deprived of the supplies and ammunition at the
most crucial times. Thus logistics will include besides physical distributions of materials, the arrangement of
transportations too.
www.bitbookwala.in
258 International MarketingText and Cases
The term logistics has becomes all encompassing and will include management of global supply chain and
distribution of finished as well as raw materials across the countries and continents. Any firm planning
international marketing has to arrange its global supply chain and distribution in such a manner that it is
efficient, cost effective and makes positive contributions to firms’ overall objectives. A company’s supply
chain consists of the coordination and arrangement of materials, information and flow of funds, beginning from
the suppliers of the raw material to the converters, to the carriers of materials’ ownership, to the ultimate
consumer and its focus on the continuation of the cycles so established. In the process adding value at every
stage of handling by the intermediaries till it finally satisfies a customer’s need. This process brings together
designers of the product, suppliers of the man, machinery and materials, subcontractors, manufacturing
agencies, carriers of finished goods to the customer. Such huge coordination continues through interaction
between different entities engaged in the network. While at the national level it may not be such a huge exercise
but at the international and global level it poses a big challenge to the firms to manage such a wider chain.
Logistics is a part of global supply chain management that organises, plans, conducts and controls the flow,
storage and delivery of information, services and products from the point of raw materials to the point of
conversions and eventually from the point of conversions to the point of consumptions in order to meet,
satisfy and delight a customer’s requirement and need in any part of the globe. To control this process of
customer delight, logistics focuses on the transportation, storage and delivery of material and finished goods.
The supply chain management will include the optimum and efficient handling of the entire process to build up
customer and supplier relationship for future business alliances. A comprehensive logistics strategy should
include the following key elements:
A) customer service requirements
B)
C)
BIT BOOK WALA
plant and distribution center network design
inventory management
D) outsourcing
E) key customers and suppliers relationships
F) business processes
G) information systems
H) organizational design and training requirements
I) performance and evaluation metrics.
SECTION 7:
GLOBAL MANUFACTURING STRATEGIES
In order to achieve global competitiveness and economies of scale an international firm strategises its
manufacturing in such a manner that it not only remains closer to the customer but many a times it prefers to
move the production facilities closer to the elements of production. This is done to:
1. ensure compatibility between companies’ decision to move investments abroad and thereon retain
competitive edge by efficiency, cost competitiveness, consistence of quality and flexibility of opera-
tions to react to genuine customer needs. It is generally believed that a multinational enterprise will
prefer a low cost location, but while it may be true to some extent multi national may not opt for a low
cost location for all its product lines. It will have to take into account the competitive priorities, market
dynamics and its own resource mobilisation capacity to reach such a decision. When Continental A.G.
of Germany wanted to outsource a manufacturing base to India in 2001-2002, it preferred only two and
three wheeler tyres to the Indian continent and not the entire range of automotive tyres.
www.bitbookwala.in
International Distribution, Marketing Channels Logistics and Supply Chain Management 259
2. Multinational manufacturing process of the firm will mean configuring the manufacturing base
whether it could be one centralised facility which will cater to the entire globe or each country (wher-
ever firm intends carrying on its business activities) will have a manufacturing base. The third option
being regionalising the production facilities e.g. Pepsi may have the Indian location for catering to the
South Asian base.
3. However, the above two decisions will depend on the firms’ capacity and capability to control the
logistics involved in massive operation of multi location manufacturing. It will involve moving men,
material and machinery from the basic purchase to mid conversions in some factories, to may be
warehousing of intermediaries raw materials, in process material, to semi-finished goods and ulti-
mately, to transportation of finished and ready for sale materials. Unless the firm puts into operation a
foolproof control system, consisting of organisational structure, performance ensuring checks and
balances and eventually performance measurement systems, to optimise achievement of strategies
and objectives, such large scale operations will not be worth implementing.
SECTION 8:
GLOBAL SOURCING
It is not necessary for international firm to put up its own manufacturing facilities every where as it can adopt
global sourcing strategy which will eventually mean: the firm will have to take a strategic decision about the
product line to be outsourced, whether entire product should move out or only critical parts which the outside
vendor is good at manufacturing should be sourced out. The firm will have to take into account the advantages
of outsourcing within own country or in a third location foreign country.4 In any case, the firm stands to gain
BIT BOOK WALA
in the following ways, should it decide to outsource to a third country:
a. Reduction in costs of manufacturing due to lower wage bill for the labour (particularly in third world
countries)
b. Free from labor unionisation and restrictive work rules of own labour
c. Lower investments on land, capital and manufacturing
d. Access to world wide technological developments and third party research facilities
e. Improved logistical support and dependable supply due to factoring of foreign locations along with
domestic production
f. Circumventing the import procedures and arrangements of materials which are available in foreign
countries only; thus adding on many other cost saving devices
g. Multi locational presence generates additional advantages of fighting competition on various foreign
turfs particularly if the competition too has been outsourcing.
4. Allan Afuah (1999), “Strategies to Turn Adversity into Profits”, Sloan Management Review, 40, No. 2, winter
1999: 99-109.
www.bitbookwala.in
260 International MarketingText and Cases
(B) Each firm has its own in built culture in the work force, such splitting of production arrangements may
create cultural barriers
(C) Unless the firm is able to trim down the profit margins expectations of the intermediaries handling
outsourced material it may not be able to get the cost advantages.
(D) The international firm will have to work out long term plans for either reducing dependency on the
outsource agency or otherwise helplessness can be felt should any dispute arise in future between the
two parties. However such a situation will differ from company to company. Japanese and Chinese will
like to continue with the same source for life time and undertake mutual technological and product
development. The firms from United States on the other hand will not undertake long term business
commitments with their vendors, whom they generally keep restricted to their free trade zone areas
from where they can service these American companies with just in time inventories.
We give hereunder the key steps an international firm can undertake to ensure that the process adopted
helps in selecting the best and the most suitable outsource for supplies at the global level.
www.bitbookwala.in
International Distribution, Marketing Channels Logistics and Supply Chain Management 261
Determine the basis and nature of relationship Does the source agency’s geographical location,
with the sourcing agencies. capabilities and capacity, meet our standards? Will
the supplier be able to deliver in spite of all logistical
challenges?
Invite proposals and evaluate. Comparisons at total ownership level will give us
the actual results. Identify the best source in the
long run/ short run.
Negotiate and enter into a contract with the best Will the contract be long term or will it be negotiable
source on mutually agreeable terms and condi- after periodical intervals? Does the contract clearly
tions to build long lasting relationships. mention roles and responsibility for both sides. Have
the performance expectations been clearly stated,
explained and understood by both signatories?
Does the contract specify sharing and owning of
resources, rewards, risks and the unforeseen?
Periodical and consistent re-evaluation of Have there been complete implementation and
agreement, its implementation, current changed cementing of relationship between both the agencies.
circumstances and requirements thereof to build Do we get the world class material? Does the
up additional capabilities. sourcing agency maintains expected standards?
Do the changed circumstances call for revaluation of
BIT BOOK WALA the relationship or
Do we need to change/ upgrade the source?
www.bitbookwala.in
262 International MarketingText and Cases
only or some of the imports will be necessary to give the finished product an international acceptance for all
times till the sources are developed within one’s own home country.
An international firm is always in a dilemma when it comes to developing outsourcing points from abroad.
Should they make every purchase centralised at the main work or should the subsidiaries abroad be allowed to
make their own decisions and develop their own sources? Though both strategies have their own merits and
demerits, companies can derive the benefits of increased production facility control by localising the purchase
and other related decisions, as only then better and timely response to facility needs can be generated. In the
centralised facility the firm can though continue to have better leverage with the suppliers. It can manage to get
better price, schedule and other services. There can also be avoidance of duplication of efforts and the vendors
can be better educated to the needs of the firm as a whole to build up long lasting relationships.
SECTION 9:
INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
The global outsourcing presents a big challenge to a multinational firm and its material management team in
managing to bring down distance, time gap and the political and economical variations and ask every
component of the international supply sources into one single whole. The supply source and the inventory
management purchases by decentralised units must follow a continuous flow in order to keep factories and
stores running as otherwise a breakdown in production stream on the shop floor, a few thousand miles away
can prove quite expensive. It can give a set back to the firm in the current highly competitive scenario, where the
inventories are being managed directly on the production line to feed just in time the requirements of factories
BIT BOOK WALA
around the world. In order to circumvent this kind of situations the global suppliers do maintain their own
warehouses close to the factory gates either directly themselves or by outsourcing inventory management to
third parties. Huge warehousing facilities have of late come up in free trade zones across the world managed by
third party logistic firms; the main function of these firms is to maintain a buffer line of inventories as an
intermediate arrangement.
Most of the original equipments suppliers are moving abroad to follow the manufacturer all around the
world wherever they put up new production facilities. When Japanese car manufacturers like Suzuki, and
Honda have production units in India, Bridgestone the largest equipment supplier too had to put up a factory
in India even though there were enough international level manufacturers available in India. Similarly Toyota
also follows a pattern of taking its original suppliers along to foreign locations to maintain consistent quality
and supply chain. Although all such companies that motivate, lure or force their original suppliers to move
along with them do develop a multiple local vendor institutions support to ensure dependence on more than
one source just in case of breakdowns or any other emergency at the vendors’ end.
www.bitbookwala.in
International Distribution, Marketing Channels Logistics and Supply Chain Management 263
department or it may decide to outsource the management of trans-shipment and transportation to a third party,
outside the firm’s own network.
Such third party intermediaries are equipped with the services to gather necessary details on the logistic
management e.g. details on the routes, freights, shipping details and also the essential surveillance
instrumentation systems, communication technologies, to track the movement of materials across the frontiers.
They also are well familiar with the compulsory documentation at the ports and can take care of official as well
as unofficial requirements. The logistics firms handling international movement of freights are generally well-
equipped to handle complete multi modal need of transportation and they operate worldwide.
Emery Worldwide, a $ 3billion integrated U.S. based logistic firm provides global, air and ocean freight
transportation, logistics management, customs brokerage and expediting services. Its clients list includes
customers from manufacturing, retail, industry and government agencies. . Based in Redwood City, the
company provides services to more than 200 countries through a service outlet network of more than 600
centers around the world.
Iomega, the San Diego, California in the United States one of the many
clients of Emery worldwide, utilizes services of the logistic firm for
freight forwarding and warehousing in Singapore. The zip drive
manufacturer supplies finished products to its Asian customers spread all
over Asia, by maintaining inventory of finished material in the
warehouses maintained by Emery Worldwide. Emery Worldwide also handles inventories of
spares and semi knocked down kits of plastic/metal parts etc, which go into the making
BIT BOOK WALA
of zip drives of Iomega brought into the Emery centers from San Diego and Utah
manufacturing centers. These parts are used into assembly of finished products which are
then supplied by Emery worldwide to customers all over the Asian continent. There are
many such organisations worldwide handling complete logistics solutions for their
clients and the international firms do take the benefits of services offered to optimise
their costs and efficiency for the advantage of their global clients. (Website
www.iomega.com)
SECTION 10:
QUALITY MANAGEMENT
The global operations do present a challenging situation to the international firm to maintain a consistent and
desired levels of quality in and at all levels of the global supply chain network. Even though the firms insist on
global quality assurances certification e.g. ISO 9000, company specific and country specific acceptable quality
level (AQL) zero defects and six sigma; the organisations find it difficult to inculcate the culture that it has been
following at the home country work. Companies like Toyota and Suzuki develop and train the local vendors’
employees by way of posting their own key technical staff and other quality inspectors and trainers at the
factories of suppliers. When Maruti Suzuki5 started manufacturing their cars in India in early 1980s, the Suzuki
technical staff had worked literally on the shop floor along with factory workers on production line to ensure
total quality management which insists on customer satisfaction, employee involvement and continuous
5. Maruti Suzuki is a joint venture company between Maruti India and Suzuki Japan.
www.bitbookwala.in
264 International MarketingText and Cases
improvement in quality seeps deep into the work culture of the new plant and the Indian employee too pick up
the same work culture that Suzuki had been following in all its plant globally.
The global quality assurance statement made by Managing Officer Koichi INA General Motor Global
Production Centre amply spells out the role played in education of local production hands by Toyota
www.bitbookwala.in
International Distribution, Marketing Channels Logistics and Supply Chain Management 265
6. The Authors have prepared this part based on the readings of many articles, particularly journal of Global
Information Management, Idea Group of Publishing, Vol 14, No. 4, October-December, 2006.
www.bitbookwala.in
266 International Marketing–Text and Cases
for spares and components to its suppliers through the information extranet established with its own
information system through the internet, in order to enable them to organise production of parts and deliver as
and when Dell needs it. The customers can also plug in into the Dell system to track and follow their orders
placed for which money has already been paid in advance by them, (see box).
Internet has been revolutionising trade communications across all levels of global supply chain network
even though its speed varies from country to country. Internet saw worldwide growth of users in the 21st
century, leading to trade over the net growing at 75% in the recent year. On-line trade spending also saw an
expansion of 58% during this period. The global trade has been using internet as a source of linking suppliers
from across the globe with the manufacturing bases and to the users and customers all across the world, both
as an intranet system and also as an internet network outside their own systems to speed up the process of
global supply chain and bring down the cost of operations for the ultimate gain to the end customers.
Private Technology Exchange (PTX), an on-line collaboration model that brings together manufacturers,
distributors, value adding resellers and customers to execute on-line trading transactions is the latest addition
to the global supply chain management. Facilitators, the subscribers to the PTX can share information about
demand, production, supply situation and other supply line data etc. The introduction of private technology
exchange has resulted into increased efficiency of the supply chain and resultant reduces costs to the
participants. Ford Motor Company, Ace Hardware, Cisco and many other companies in defense, aerospace,
and motor vehicle manufacturing have been participating in the PTX to manage their global supply chain.
However not all companies can subscribe to fully integrated private technology exchange and such
organisations can always take recourse to the services of the third party logistical providers who handle all
BIT BOOK WALA
tasks such as movement and shipping of goods to storage of inventories, management of electronically
storage of data and follow up with the government authorities for customs and exports formalities. It is because
of the easy availability of support systems by the third parties that global supply chain management system
has come to exist and flourish to its current position.
www.bitbookwala.in
International Distribution, Marketing Channels Logistics and Supply Chain Management 267
REFERENCES
1. Peter D Bennet, Dictionary of Marketing Terms, AMA 1988. p.29.
2. “Keiretsus” the Economist, Japanese Trading Companies – The Giants That Refuse to
Die, June1, 1999 Vol. 319 No. 1109,pp 72-73.
3. ibid
WEBSITES VISITED
1. www.iomega.com
2. http//www. Toyota .co.jp/en/vision/globalisation
3. http://www1.ap.dell.com.
www.bitbookwala.in
268 International MarketingText and Cases
www.bitbookwala.in
International Distribution, Marketing Channels Logistics and Supply Chain Management 269
exporters.
BIT BOOK WALA
turers from the home country for exports liaison and arrange a networking of importers and
(True/False)
(c) Trading and merchandising companies are middlemen who buy goods and products from
the producers of their home countries and as such hold the legal title to the ownership and
possession of the products they represent. (True/False)
(d) The distributors and merchant middlemen abroad make their own investments in purchas-
ing import products and thus inherit title to the goods before they distribute it in their home
country. (True/False)
(e) The process of selecting a distributor abroad will require qualifying a distributor on the
criterion set by international firm to attain its corporate objectives. (True/False)
REVIEW QUESTIONS
1. “A manufacturer can either distribute his products directly or employ third party
services”. Explain the above statement in the light of middlemen available in your home
country.
2. Explain who will you employ for distributing your fast moving consumer products in a
foreign country and why?
3. Explain what criterion you will refer to while selecting middlemen abroad for industrial
products manufactured by your company.
www.bitbookwala.in
270 International MarketingText and Cases
www.bitbookwala.in
Chapter 14
Product Promotion,
Advertising and Building
Brands in Foreign Markets
BIT BOOK WALA
Learning Objectives
The reader should be able
• to understand various tools available for product promotion
• to learn the importance of brand buildings in foreign markets
• to gather international marketing intelligence.
www.bitbookwala.in
272 International MarketingText and Cases
SECTION 1:
PRODUCT PROMOTION AND BUILDING BRANDS
T he opportunities and challenges before a multinational company today are manifold. Globalisation, the
general trend towards free markets has worked both ways. On one hand, it has paved the way for
innumerable opportunities and hold lots of promises. On the other, it has posed new challenges, forcing
corporations to continuously adapt or die. One of the important challenges a multinational faces when it goes
abroad is product promotion. We shall now see the different modes a company can use for product promotion.
First, let us look at the various tools available for product promotion. They are:
1. Sales Promotion
2. Advertising (International)
3. Events and Experiences
4. Personal Selling and Direct Marketing
5. Public Relations
Let us know look at each mode and see how a multinational responds to these challenges in a foreign market.
1. Sales Promotion
Sales promotion refers to a variety of short-term incentives given to encourage trial or purchase of a product or
a service. This is particularly important for any company that enters into a new foreign market for the first time.
In order to gain visibility and win approval of the first purchasers, these initiatives are very essential. These
BIT BOOK WALA
initiatives may typically include coupons, contests, premiums and the like to draw a stronger and quicker buyer
response. The noise that is associated with a product also decides the amount of promotion. In highly
competing markets and countries, all foreign companies have to make their products heard and seen above
others. In such cases, sales promotion comes handy.
Promotion is being increasingly seen by the top management as an effective sales tool. This probably
explains the fact that the advertisement-to-sales promotion ratio has fallen with greater emphasis on promotion.
However, there could be a problem in letting advertising take too much of a back seat to promotions, because
advertising typically builds brand loyalty, on long-term basis. One more thing that a multinational needs to
keep in mind is the perception that is created in the minds of the consumer with a sales promotion. Usually,
when a brand is price promoted too often, the consumer begins to evaluate its credibility and worth. Again this
is a perception that varies across countries and hence companies must keep in mind these things before they
decide a sales promotion scheme in a particular country.
2. Advertising
An important choice that any company has to make when it goes international is whether to go for standardised
advertising or not1. Standardised advertising has significant economic advantages. It lowers the cost of value
creation by spreading the fixed costs of developing advertisements over many countries. The scarce creative
talent also favors this argument. A good example of this is the Marlboro Man.
Prof. Justin Paul co-authored this chapter with Bhavya Kapoor, Namrata T. Poddar, Chakradhar Gade and R. Vimal
Kumar., Kiran Haresh Bhatia, Manan Gupta, Nitin Kumar Dokania and Rahul Prasad have also helped.
1. Subhas C. Jain, International Marketing, 6th Edition, South Western Thomson Learning.
www.bitbookwala.in
Product Promotion, Advertising and Building Brands in Foreign Markets 273
The Marlboro man was part of a tobacco advertising campaign by Philip Morris from the 1960s
to the 1990s for their Marlboro cigarette. The image involved a rugged cowboy or cowboys, in
nature with only a cigarette. The ads were originally conceived as a way to popularise filtered
cigarettes, which at the time was considered a feminine cigarette. This ad proved popular in
almost every major market around the world, and it helped propel Marlboro to the top of the
world market.
However, there are important cultural differences that may make a good message in one country fail
miserably in another. Many companies unfortunately find this hard way once their products fail. Culture
specific messages directed at a given country may be more effective than global messages. Further, the
advertising regulations in a particular country may block the standardisation.
Kellogg could not use a television commercial it produced in Great Britain to promote its
cornflakes in many other European countries. A reference to the iron and vitamin content of its
cornflakes was not permissible in the Netherlands, where claims relating to health benefits are
outlawed. A child wearing Kellogg T-shirt had to be edited out of the advertisement picture
before it could be used in France, because the French law forbids the use of children in product
endorsements. The key line, “Kellogg’s make their cornflakes the best they have ever been”
was disallowed in Germany because of a prohibition of competitive claims.
An appropriate method that most multinationals follow today is that of capturing some benefits of global
standardisation while recognising differences in countries’ cultural and legal environments. By doing so, it
may be able to save costs, build international recognition, and yet customise its advertisements to different
cultures.
www.bitbookwala.in
274 International Marketing–Text and Cases
In 1996, Coca-Cola was one of the major sponsors of the 1996 Cricket World Cup held in the
Indian subcontinent. It was a part of Coca Cola’s international strategy to sponsor major
international events, from the Olympics to the Football World Cup, starting from 1978. The
sponsoring of the Cricket World Cup was not only a ‘soft-sell’ of the product, but also created a
lasting image of Coke in the minds of the average consumer in the cricket crazy-nation–India.
Pepsi, which watched this from the sidelines, sponsored the 1999 World Cup.
www.bitbookwala.in
Product Promotion, Advertising and Building Brands in Foreign Markets 275
Thus, it is learnt that the foreign companies make use of such events to declare their
commitment to the host country’s market. Further, fans of a particular sport develop
strong loyalties to the products endorsed by their stars. The local festivals and
entertainment shows can also be used as a means for building ‘Brand Image’.
In 2004, Thumbs-up was one of the sponsors for the ‘Mumbai Festival’. The
festival was a grand celebration of Mumbai’s culture and its specialties.
Although it was important to Mumbai, the event had very little mileage outside
Mumbai which could be exploited. Still, Thumbs-up sponsored it. Thumbs-up
had a very good market in Mumbai compared to other major cities. This was the
reason the Coca-Cola Company allowed Thumbs-up and not its flagship product,
Coke to sponsor it.
Hindustan Uni Lever’s strategy (subsidiary of Unilever in India) in this regard is worth a
mention. India has a large rural population with 600,000 villages. Nearly 91% of these people
live in villages with a population of less than 2000. Rural retail stores are very small and carry
limited stock. Since low literacy levels and poor cable TV penetration makes television media
ineffective, Hindustan Uni Lever tries to establish a physical presence wherever people
frequently gather in numbers. HLL sales representatives will visit these gatherings, display
their products, explain how they work, gives away some free samples. The backbone, however,
is a rural distribution network that encompasses 100 factories, 7,500 distributors, and an
2. Cateora and Graham, International Marketing, McGraw-Hill Education, 2006, 12th Edition, Page 502
3. Cateora and Graham, ibid
www.bitbookwala.in
276 International Marketing–Text and Cases
estimated 3 million retail stores, many of which are very, very small. A depot in each of India’s
states feeds products to major wholesalers, who then sell directly to thousands of small towns
and villages.
All the investment that went into this has been worth it. Today with increasing purchasing
power, Hindustan Lever is in an advantageous position to sell the most to the rural consumers.
Further, in the future HLL can think of using the same network for marketing all its other
products as well, i.e., when it is ready to be bought by the rural consumer. [HLL has been
renamed as Hindustan Uni Lever Ltd in India]
A pull strategy relies on access to advertising media. In the United States, a large number of media makes it
easy to target a focused group of consumers. The same is true of the Internet where different websites attract
different kinds of users. However, not all nations can boast of such a system. In Scandinavia, for example, until
recently, there were no private commercial television or radio stations that existed; all electronic media were
state-owned and carried no commercials. Hence, a firm’s ability to use a pull strategy is limited by media
availability.
All tobacco and alcohol ads are banned on the Indian media. Until a few years back, the
biggest player in the tobacco market, ITC, had used the sponsorship of major sporting events
as a pull strategy for its products. However, with the Indian Government bringing a ban on
that as well, ITC was forced to come up with innovative ways to make its product known to
the masses. Since it was enjoying a near monopoly in the market it didn’t face serious
problems. BIT BOOK WALA
The optimal mix between push and pull strategies depends on product type and consumer sophistication,
channel length, and media sophistication. Push strategies tend to be emphasised:4
• for industrial products and / or complex new products
• when distribution channels are short
• when few print or electronic media are available.
Pull strategies tend to be emphasised:
• for consumer goods
• when distribution channels are long
• when sufficient print and electronic media are available to carry the marketing message.
5. Public Relations
Public Relations (PR) involves a variety of programs designed to promote or protect a company’s image or its
individual products. It is easy to see why PR management is very important to any multinational company. Each
country has its own set of complex challenges in the form of perceived image amongst people, lobbying power
and defending products that have run into problems. The source and country of origin effects play an
important role in deciding how much attention a company must pay towards Public Relations.
4. Kotler, Philip, and Kevin Keller “Marketing Management”, Pearson Education, 2005.
www.bitbookwala.in
Product Promotion, Advertising and Building Brands in Foreign Markets 277
Products from South Korea tended to be associated negatively with respect to quality by people
in Europe and the US. Hence, when Hyundai, the South Korean automobile company, went to
the United States, it tried to create a good image by using advertisements that favourably
compared the company’s cars to more prestigious brands. (see the advertisement of Santro
Xing car of Hyundai in India given below)
Public Relations is sometimes very crucial when companies have to overcome some huge blows to their
image caused by damaging revelations about the company or lawsuits. The case is best exemplified by
Cadbury’s India.
Mr. Bharat Puri left Asian Paints to join Cadbury as a Director (Sales & Marketing) almost a
decade ago. It was a time when India’s traditionally strongest chocolate brand Cadbury had
received a sound drubbing in the marketplace, because of Nestlé’s Kit-Kat. Getting the share
back and building excitement was a tough challenge. The toughest problem was a highly
publicised incident in which it was claimed that a batch of Cadbury’s flagship brand, Cadbury
Dairy Milk, was infested with worms. The issue is now history. “The sensible thing to do was to
influence what we could. We spoke to consumers, changed packaging in a record 90 days and
bounced back,” Mr. Bharat Puri said.
It did more than just that. It got its biggest celebrity endorser, Amitabh Bachchan, to visit its
labs and test out the process entirely with the scientists. After this, it made a series of
advertisements in which Amitabh Bachchan testifies to the product’s purity and safety. The
new packaging, the new ads all helped turn its product around.
www.bitbookwala.in
278 International MarketingText and Cases
SECTION 2:
INTERNATIONAL MARKET INTELLIGENCE STUDIES
As multinationals turn their attention towards global expansion at the speed of thought based on market size
and increasing purchasing power, all companies have to look at expanding their footprint to sustain and grow
amidst severe competitive pressures. So the survival and growth strategy is to build and compete on a global
scale, expand into new markets and gain a foothold in the underdeveloped or developing markets. In industries
as diverse as automotive, banking or even in services, companies are charting ambitious global growth
strategies. As more and more corporations are embarking on such initiatives, there are several challenges they
face. International market intelligence report is a pre-requisite for companies trying to promote their products
and build brands in the foreign markets.
Europe
The European market is a tough nut to crack, however many foreign companies have made successful entry in
Europe.
The disadvantage of doing business in Europe is compounded by rigid cultural and regulatory
environment. Further, the European Union (EU) is a high-cost and high-taxes market and has imposed the
Distance Selling Directive, in the recent past.
The main provisions of this directive are:
• consumers must be given clear information about the goods or services before buying
• goods must be delivered within thirty days unless agreed otherwise
BIT BOOK WALA
• where consumers notify the supplier in writing or another durable medium that they wish to cancel the
contract, they must be refunded within 30 days all money paid.
The directive does not apply to:
• Business-to-Business contracts
• contracts for the sale of land – although the regulations do apply to consumer rental agreements
• goods or services bought at an auction with an auctioneer.
Historically, standards have been used to effectively limit market access.5 With the expansion of the
European Union eastwards to include Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Rumania etc, the availability of low-cost skills
or India’s famous cost arbitrage will no longer be its Unique Selling Proposition (USP).
European firms also tend to see off-shoring as losing control over the project. There is the general European
inward looking culture that may hinder the efforts of Indian companies trying to get outsourcing deals from the
EU. Moreover outsourcing is an accepted norm in the US as a means for cost saving, whereas Europe with its
strong trade union culture is more resistant to outsourcing as that could mean job losses. Several European
countries apply highly restrictive employment legislation. In countries such as France and Germany such
legislation makes traditional outsourcing arrangements more difficult, and less financially advantageous.
The best way to deal with these conservative attitudes is to invest in an European company and use that as
a front-end to do business with local companies (Foreign Direct Investment in the form of Joint Venture).
In this context, acquiring and/or partnering with companies in this geography may be a better option than
starting operations from scratch. In a landmark development in Indian automobile industry MG Rover Group in
association with Tata Motors rolled out City Rover for the European market.
5. Cateora and Graham (2006), International Marketing, Twelth Edition, page 283, McGraw-Hill Education
www.bitbookwala.in
Product Promotion, Advertising and Building Brands in Foreign Markets 279
This is also precisely what companies such as Dr. Reddy’s, Ranbaxy etc. have done by acquiring companies
in the UK, France and Belgium respectively.
Although the trend towards converging languages into a common language like English has gathered
momentum in the world, the European market represents different countries with their own languages. The
divergence between European countries is a big challenge for foreign companies trying to acquire clients
outside of the UK. Indian software companies face lesser issues in tapping UK-based clients as English is the
medium of communication. Most Europeans prefer to speak in their own languages, which can be quite
uncomfortable for expatriate professionals. Within Europe, the language issue partly explains why the UK
alone accounts for 60 percent of Indian IT exports to the region.
However, the Indian IT companies are still looking towards Europe. Various factors are responsible for this.
Europe accounts for around 30 percent of the global IT services market. Financial services and telecom are the
main sectors that represent huge opportunities for Information Technology companies in Europe.
Many recent developments in European markets and industry structure are responsible for this. For example
in Europe, stock exchanges are required to implement the International Securities Identification Number (ISIN),
for all securities trading. This paves the way to the opportunity for software firms.
Some of the areas which can be tapped by foreign companies are software solutions, telecom software,
mobile and wireless applications, e-business and IT-enabled services.
The list of beneficiaries in the IT sector include not only big companies like Infosys and Wipro but many
other companies like Mastek, Polaris, Blue Star Infotech etc. They have also grown by leaps and bounds in
Europe. For example, Mastek had taken the London Traffic project where they provided the solution for traffic
congestion in London.
BIT BOOK WALA
Another significant factor unique to Europe is their conservative style of doing business. The companies
are very particular about spending on specific projects and are risk-averse, unlike the American way of
conducting business that encourages the spirit of entrepreneurship and is more adventurous in risk-taking.
As European customers prefer dealing with vendors whom they know very well, therefore, foreign
companies have to invest substantial efforts in building relationships with their European counterparts.
Also, the time taken for processing work permits is three times more in most European countries like
Germany and France compared to the United States. European business culture involves much more face-to-
face contact as compared to the US where a lot of business deals get done over electronic means or telephone.
www.bitbookwala.in
280 International Marketing–Text and Cases
synergism serves as a win-win situation for both the aspiring overseas partner and the local company to
penetrate into the market and garner market shares quickly.
Except in the free trade zone and few other thrust sectors, the UAE requires at least 51% local citizen
ownership in all businesses operating in the country as part of its attempt to place its citizens in leadership
positions. This poses a challenge for the foreign companies even if they enter into join ventures with UAE
firms.
Still due to lot of initiatives taken by Middle East governments especially UAE, foreign companies have all
the more reasons to venture into that market. For example, Dubai offers free hold property. The Dubai
Technology Parks objective is aimed at attracting medical, pharmaceutical and research companies to the UAE,
while the Dubai Healthcare City aims to make the UAE the Regional Healthcare Centre and create a niche for
‘medical tourism’. More than 200 factories operate at the Jebel Ali Complex in Dubai, which includes a deep-
water port and a free trade zone for manufacturing and distribution in which all goods for re-export or trans-
shipment enjoy a 100% duty exemption.
Another example of a South Asian company that entered into UAE market is India’s Tata. They have
launched its special blend of tea by the name of its acquired brand Tetley.
As a member of the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC)*, the UAE participates in the wide range of GCC
activities that focus on economic issues. These include regular consultations and development of common
policies covering trade, investment, banking and finance, transportation, telecommunications, and other
technical areas, including protection of intellectual property rights.
Retail, hospitality and processed foods are other booming sectors in the Middle East where foreign
USA
United States of America is often the country of choice for exporters and multinational firms. The world’s most
developed economy has a huge appetite for foreign goods and services, as can be seen from its huge trade
deficits. Since America’s total import payment exceeds total export receipts, they have been in deficit in the
Balance of Trade account.
American firms in their homeland were subjected to criticism in the recent past from their countrymen for off
shoring jobs to developing countries like India. The American government, at the same time cannot restrain its
own companies from outsourcing work to emerge as cost leaders on the global scene. Many companies in the
US today, have their top managers and sales teams in the United States, but design products and softwares in
India, where engineers earn a third of their US counterparts.
For example the IT industry in India has been the main beneficiary in this wave of outsourcing in the US.
Financial services and ITES have also joined the bandwagon. What is important to note is the insight that has
* GCC is a regional economic grouping in the form of Free Trade Area between countries like UAE, Oman etc.
www.bitbookwala.in
Product Promotion, Advertising and Building Brands in Foreign Markets 281
emerged among the Indian entrepreneurs, that it is not important to set up a manufacturing facility or trade in
physical goods to earn dollars. Today outsourcing business can be done from different places in India, based
on the factors like knowledge, skills, and low cost of labourer.
However it is not always possible to conduct business activities over such a long distance. Here are a few
key points that have to be kept in mind by foreign businessmen doing business in the USA.
Economy America’s economy is the world’s largest and is a major driver of the global economy. After nine
years of robust growth, America’s economic bubble burst in 2000, technology shares plunged and the
economy was in recession before the devastating terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001. But the economy
made a comeback and despite a rash of corporate scandals and fears of a recession, growth picked up in 2002
and continued in 2003, 2004 and 2005.
But it is in a less healthy state than is popularly assumed. The high price of oil is fuelling inflation and the
country’s sizeable current-account deficit is a cause for concern. Consumer spending has slowed down. There
has been a continuing weakening of the US dollar, against many currencies in the world during 2005-07.
In this market-oriented economy, private individuals and business firms make most of the decisions. US
business firms enjoy considerably greater flexibility than their counterparts in Western Europe and Japan in
decisions to expand plant capacity, to lay off surplus workers and to develop new products.
Political The US is the oldest continuous democracy in the world. It was established in 1789, although not
all features of the system were as democratic as they are now. The US is a federal system. This means that power
is divided between a Central/National Government and the States. The federal nature of the government is
Legal A strong judicial system ensures equity of justice and the trials are mostly fast and fair. The legal
environment is one of the toughest for businesses as any breach of law can have serious repercussions. In
addition to this, the number of laws such as regulations relating to anti-trust, anti money laundering, corporate
disclosures and environmental regulations are among the most stringent.
Social The United States is a melting pot of cultures from around the world. Even though the immigration
laws are not lenient, the popularity of US as a destination ensures that host of internationals come here as
students, employees and immigrants. The society is highly individualistic and capitalistic. Doing business in
the US could be quite different from the way it is done in many other countries like India, Japan etc. Employees
do not expect long term jobs but good working conditions, they are often the costliest to maintain and are more
tolerant of diversity at workplace. Although every individual company sets certain standards for business
outfits, usually, as a general rule, most of the large multinational enterprises require a more formal dress. Being
on time is a very important rule of business etiquette.
Canada
Canada is the world’s eighth largest economy and is the gateway to the world’s richest market, a market of
400 million consumers and a combined GDP of nearly US$10 trillion. Canada is also a very easy and open market
in which to live and operate. It has a highly skilled work force, a world class infrastructure, an excellent health
care system and a low crime rate. Interestingly, Canada is a melting pot of culture and languages.
Besides, Canada offers highly competitive business costs. On an average, Canada’s costs are 14.5% lower
than the US, with a massive 33.1% advantage over the latter in the area of electronic systems development and
www.bitbookwala.in
282 International MarketingText and Cases
testing. By industry, Canada ranks first in electronics assembly, biomedical R&D, content development and
electronics systems testing. Hence, in comparison to the regional counterparts, costs in Canadian cities are
generally 10-20 percent lower. In addition, Canada is attracting huge foreign direct investments in the area of
biotechnology, advanced telecommunications and multimedia.
There has been a rapid increase in foreign investment in Canada, mostly in the areas of software
development and life sciences.
India and Canada have signed bilateral agreement for co-operation and international trade in five priority
sectors – agribusiness, energy (including oil and gas), transportation, IT and telecommunications and financial
services, science and technology cooperation was the sixth. Given Canada’s evident world class expertise in
several areas of S&T – environmental technologies and clean development mechanisms, quality control
mechanisms, nano technology, and oil and gas exploration and extraction, a large number of bilateral
cooperation options are opening up which might, over time, become very important to countries like India.
India’s major exports to Canada include readymade garments, textiles, cotton yarn, carpets, floor spreads,
gem & jewelry & precious stones, organic chemicals, coffee, spices, light engineering goods, iron & steel
articles, footwear and leather products, rice, cereals, processed foods and marine products.
All this has contributed to Canada being a very attractive place to do business. In fact, many companies
have already started taking advantage of all that Canada has to offer. Recently there has been a rapid increase
in FDI in Canada by foreign software companies with the intent to establish software development centers in
Canada. Indian companies include Tata Consultancy Services, Wipro, Infosys and Satyam. Areas of Indian
investment also include pharmaceuticals, metals, petro chemicals, auto ancillaries, financial services, etc.
State Bank of India has four branches in Canada and ICICI Bank has recently started operations. iGate
BIT BOOK WALA
Global Solutions Ltd plans to expand aggressively in Canada. The company, which has emerged as one of the
fastest growing offshore IT vendors in Canada, has doubled its head count (of its global strength of over 4,200)
in the Canadian market. Another example is VSNL’s acquisition in Canada.
The Tata group controlled VSNL has acquired $240-million Teleglobe in Montreal. With this transaction,
VSNL plans to make Montreal the centre of excellence for their communication network in North America.
Dr Reddy’s Laboratories also entered a multi-product agreement for the development and marketing of
generic products in Canada with Pharmascience Group.
All in all, the future of foreign investment in Canada promises to yield high dividends and contribute to the
growth of companies worldwide.
REFERENCES
1. “International Business”, Charles W.L.Hill, McGraw-Hill
2. “Marketing Management”, Philip Kotler, Kevin Lane Keller, Pearson
3. “Business Environment”, Justin Paul, McGraw-Hill
4. International Business, Justin Paul, Prentice Hall, Third Edition
www.bitbookwala.in
Product Promotion, Advertising and Building Brands in Foreign Markets 283
WEBSITES VISITED
1. http://www.cia.gov/cia/publications/factbook/print/us.html
2. www.globaledge.msu.edu
3. www.economist.com
4. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coca-Cola
5. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marlboro_Man
6. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kellogg
7. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pepsi#Pepsi_in_India
8. http://www.rediff.com/news/2003/oct/03cad.htm
9. http://www.televisionpoint.com/news2006/newsfullstory.php?id=1139575838
EXERCISE
www.bitbookwala.in
BIT BOOK WALA
www.bitbookwala.in
Chapter 15
Learning Objectives
The reader should be able to
• understand the process of personal selling in international marketing
• define and differentiate between home country salesman and an expatriate sales-
man
• address issues related to culture adjustments in international personal selling
• understand the functioning of multinational sales management.
www.bitbookwala.in
286 International MarketingText and Cases
T he process of personal selling has often been associated with the push factor of promoting products to
end customers. It is believed that marketing communication or the process of promotion through means
other than personal selling, help create a pull factor that makes a customer aware of the existence of the
marketing firm’s products. Such a communication brings the customer closer to the products offered by the
marketing firm. The awareness so created generates some level of demand for the product and once the
customer has been attracted by the pull factor, the last push is achieved by the personal selling efforts of the
sales personnel involved in the act of marketing. Infact the act of personal selling is a part of comprehensive
marketing communication plan that a firm whether domestic or international adopts to convey to the intended
markets, messages about the product, services offered in order to make them buy this product or service. In
recent times with each marketing firm taking to a sea of media channels for communicating with their customer
and market, the role of personal selling has become very significant in educating the customer on the
distinctive features and benefits of the product from one firm to another firm. While the official promotional
material conveys a lot about the firm and its product, it certainly lacks the human touch of explanation,
demonstration, persuasion and assurance that a visit from the salesman of the organisation can provide. Many
firms have to pay dearly for not giving due importance to the personal selling aspect of promoting their product
in the international market, as merely publicity brouchers or advertisements directed to faceless customers fail
to generate enough orders for the product. In 1993, General Electric, a multinational giant learnt this by not
getting a contract of $ 700 billions from a Malaysian developer of power generation turbines, when it failed to
send its representative to a personal meeting called by the customer. General Electric, along with Siemens A.G.
was amongst the bidders for the supply of power turbines to YTL Corp, a Malaysian company. The managing
director of YTL Corp. requested to see a senior company representative from both the companies. Siemens A.G.
BIT BOOK WALA
had sent its representative while the General Electric failed to do so. Needless to mention Siemens A.G, was
awarded the contract.1
In this chapter we address issues related to managing personal selling of a product by an international
marketing firm. We will also discuss management of issues related to expatriate employees and organisation of
sales management by international marketing firms.
INTRODUCTION
Salesmanship has been defined as, “the art and science of helping people identify their needs, create desire to
fulfill these needs, find and match the products , services with these needs and desires, with the sole aim to
obtain a minimum level of satisfaction . It also involves fixing up the value of these needs and match these value
levels to the common denominators”.2
Personal selling as such means, the meeting of the customer on one is to one level with the sales personnel
of the firm, in order to understand the needs of the former, evaluate those needs and equate those needs to the
product offered by the marketing firm, and sell the product to the customer. Personal selling establishes a two
way communication with the customer, it establishes a link with the customer for the reasons given above and
it also establishes link with the marketing firm to keep the firm aware of the desires and needs of the customer.
To achieve this kind of relationship between the firm and its customer a sales person has to be deft not only in
the art of selling but also be an adept communicator to ensure the relationship endures for longer periods.
While it becomes easy in the home country to understand the customer and his needs, it is quite challenging
1. Marcus W. Brauchli, “Looking East: Asia on the Ascent, It is Learning to Say No to Arrogant West”, The Wall Street
Journal, 13th April, Pp. A1:A8.
2. Ramneek Kapoor , “Fundamentals of Sales Management” Macmillan India Ltd , Pp. 106-107.
www.bitbookwala.in
Personal Selling and Multinational Sales Management 287
at the international level, as the customer and the marketing firm may belong to different countries and come
from different cultural backgrounds. The international marketing firm tries to cover up this gap by either
training home personnel in the target country’s language, culture and other nuances or the sales personnel
belonging to the target country may be employed. We will try to understand how international marketing firms
try to bridge the cultural divide by training the field sales personnel to have an effective communication
network with the international customers later in this chapter. It is however important to briefly understand the
objectives of personal selling and the process of personal selling.
SECTION 1:
OBJECTIVES OF PERSONAL SELLING
Some of the objectives of personal selling have been defined by William J. Stanton when he observes, “the goal
of all marketing efforts is to increase profitable sales by offering want satisfaction to the market over the long
run. Personal selling is by far the major promotional method or tool to reach this goal. More than ever sales
people today are the dynamic power in the business world”.3
As per this statement of Stanton, personal selling is directed at ensuring long term generation of orders and
profitable sales for the firm and at the same time the act of personal selling offers want satisfaction to the market
(customer) for a long time to come. In other words it ensures continuation of business and demand for the
product offered by the international marketing firm. But the objective of personal selling goes much beyond
merely perpetuating demand. While generation of the demand is the major task of personal selling, it also, in
addition performs the following functions for an international firm:
BIT BOOK WALA
1. It provides an opportunity to the international marketing firm to come face to face with the international
customer for a direct dialogue
2. It provides an opportunity to identify and understand the international customer and his needs, his
aspirations, his expectations, desires from the product manufactured by the international marketing
firm
3. It provides an opportunity to the international marketing firm to help customer identify his need and
provide him information on the availability of the products that can help him fulfill that need
4. It acts as a surveillance and marketing intelligence tool to get information on competition, market
dynamics, product feedback, marketing efforts’ effectiveness and the changing trends of the industry
5. It is a great tool to provide pre and after sales service facilities to the international customer and delight
him by removing his grievance, if any
6. It is the most cost effective method to reach each customer as compared to other tools of sales
promotion
7. It provides an opportunity to the firm to demonstrate the product, explain features of the product,
remove any lurking doubts in the mind of the customer about the product, by providing answers to any
query, objection or doubt raised by the customer
8. Personal selling acts as a supplement to the other promotional tools employed by the international
marketing firm, e.g., advertising, store display, direct mailers , international product exhibition and
many others to get the attention of the customer
9. It actually culminates into the final action of a purchase by the customer and establishes a customer –
seller relationship between the (seller) firm and the buyer (customer).
3. William J. Stanton, Op. Cit. Pp.440.
www.bitbookwala.in
288 International Marketing–Text and Cases
SECTION 2:
THE PROCESS OF PERSONAL SELLING
Process of personal selling is an exercise involving many steps before the salesperson is finally able to make a
sale to the client, whether international or domestic. These steps can be identified as prospecting, preapproach,
approach, presentation and demonstration, handling objections and oppositions, closing the sales call
profitably and eventually following up after the customer’s order has been processed. The actual necessity and
importance of each step may vary from country to country or from region to region. We will have a brief look at
the steps involved in the selling process
Identify the Prospects The sales person at this stage will have to identify the potential purchasers of
the product. He will assess their probability and propensity to purchase the product offered by his marketing
firm. This will mean conducting a market research of a mini scale on the potential customers. For example, if a
manufacturer of air conditioning plant wants to sell his plants in the countries of Middle East, the sales
person representing the manufacturer in Middle East will have to find out which kind of buildings and
industrial projects under construction will be requiring air conditioning plants in the near future. He may
also have to find out if some of the old existing plants need to modernise their air conditioning plants and
whether his firm can meet their needs. Thus he will have to identify the prospects for his product in the target
country through an extensive market survey.
Preapproach This will call for gathering information on the prospect, his problems, and then prepare a
Approach This will refer to the stage when the sales person actually comes face to face with the prospect
to explain about his marketing firm and its products. “In order to get a favourable response from the customer
the salesman has to make sure: (1). the approach is made at the right time, (2). it creates a conducive atmosphere
(3). the prospect receives him in the receptive mind (4). it helps him close the sales eventually”.4
It is important here at this stage that the sales person makes use of the cultural protocol and norms that he
has learnt about the prospect during the prospecting and preapproach stages.
Presentation During the presentation stage the sales person will have to demonstrate the product and
present the story plan to the prospective customer. The prospect at this stage can have many doubts,
objections regarding the product, its usage, its capacity to meet his need, the marketing firm or even the price
of the product. The sales man will have to explain the advantages of his product to the customer. He through
the gentle touch of assurance and confidence building will have to steer the customer towards the eventual
close of the sales call. The objections will have to be handled carefully particularly in a cross cultural
atmosphere where the language, the gestures, the small courtesies, the verbal and non verbal use of language
could be very challenging for both the parties. In many cultures, the presentation may not be complete in one
meeting with the customer and may get extended over many such series of interviews till the prospect
completely gets familiar with the salesman and his company on a personal level.
4. Ramneek Kapoor, “Fundamentals of Sales Management”, Macmillan India Ltd., Pp. 275-276.
www.bitbookwala.in
Personal Selling and Multinational Sales Management 289
Closing the Sales Call This refers to the eventual booking of the order from the prospect and finalising
the sales deal. Once all the objections have been overcome by the salesman and he has won the confidence of
the prospect he can complete his mission of selling the product to the prospect and convert him from the status
of prospect to that of the buyer and the user of his product. “Closing the sales call means the salesman has
been able to obtain the prospects’ agreement to all that he has presented and proposed and that the buyer has
agreed to pay the price for the service or product offered by the salesman on the conditions suggested by the
salesman. This spells success for all efforts the salesman has put in to look for the customer, studying and
identifying his need, presenting a sales story that could relate the product to the need, making effort to
organise demonstration at the place convenient to the customer, satisfying his objections and finally
motivating him to buy.”5
Post Sales Service The salesman’s relationship does not end with the booking of the order alone, he
has to ensure the customer feels satisfied with the purchase decision he has taken, and there is no dissonance
created on any account in the mind of the customer. The salesman will do well to get into many post sales
activities, e.g., calling on the customer to extend thanks for having patronised his marketing firm and ensuring
the product so sold yields the necessary value satisfaction to the customer. He will have to assure the customer
on post sales services of the firm to maintain a life long relationship. “The customer will be retained and the
consistency in repeat purchase will be maintained only if the value yielded by the product exceeds the
perceived and projected value of the prospect”.6
SECTION 3:
BIT BOOK WALA
MULTINATIONAL SALES MANAGEMENT
A multinational sales or marketing firm will have presence in many countries of the world. In some of the
countries it will have its own team handling the sales job directly, yet in many others it may seek an alliance with
its partners, franchisees and outsourced outlets to handle the personal selling job for its product. International
marketing firm’s commitment to the market, the extent of involvement and the orientation it has towards its
international operations will be the deciding factors in determining the (1) the type of sales personnel and (2)
the size of sales team the firm should hire.
A domestic firm primarily engaged into selling in the domestic market with little leanings towards exports will
not be organising any kind of personal selling activities abroad. Such a company will simply leave the task of
selling its product abroad to the exporter middleman or to the person /firm importing its product.
The same way, if foreign based middlemen and intermediaries are engaged by the exporter to promote its
products, it may delegate the main task of personal selling to these intermediaries. Such a firm will have a bare
minimum of its own sales staff situated abroad to lend a helping hand to the middlemen engaged abroad.
However if the international marketing firm has an orientation that spells into regeocentric or geocentric, and
has a substantial presence in many countries of the world it will have to take major decision of recruiting a sales
team. The members of the team could belong to the home country. These members could be the expatriates from
the home country sent abroad on a sales assignment or the firm can engage third country international
expatriates depending on its local needs. The third alternative for the multinational firm is to hire sales staff
belonging to the host country of operations. We will have a detailed discussion on the possibilities of each
hiring process adopted by the firm:
5. Ramneek Kapoor, “Fundamentals of Sales Management”, Macmillan India Ltd., Pp. 313-314.
6. Ramneek Kapoor, “Fundamentals of Sales Management”, Macmillan India Ltd., Pp. 313-314.
www.bitbookwala.in
290 International MarketingText and Cases
Hiring Expatriates for Personal Selling Operations Abroad The multinational sales
management could involve hiring sales personnel abroad who do not belong to the country of operations.
Such sales personnel are called the Expatriates.
Hiring Home Country Nationals Abroad International marketing firms marketing high
technology oriented products and services prefer deputing technical sales staff from the parent company on
sales assignment abroad. Software solutions marketing companies like, Infosys, Wipro, Satyam and a host of
other companies who are involved in high tech business processing solutions send home country nationals on
foreign posting to handle the customer relationship and sales abroad. “In situations in which greater
interdependence exists between an overseas unit and corporate head quarters, firms are more likely to dispatch
home country nationals, this is also true for situations in which complex operations are involved, there is a
greater political risk and there is greater level of competition.7
Challenges to Hiring Home Country Nationals Abroad
1. involves double the expense. The firm will have to maintain the salary and allowances already being
paid for the home country assignment in addition to bear the expense of settling down the employee
abroad with additional salary benefits and other perks, e.g., children’s educational expense, household
hard and soft furnishings, hiring household help, fully paid vacation trips etc
2. poses major challenge on account of cultural barriers to the expatriate employees. Hence the firm will
have to spend on educating and training its employee so selected, in their cultural orientations to-
wards the country of posting
3. maintaining liaison with the political sources, government departments, and other non–governmental
BIT BOOK WALA
agencies can also pose a major challenge
4. maintaining status quo and resettling these employees after their repatriation from abroad is another
challenge the international firms will have to handle.
There have been numerous cases of home country nationals being posted abroad as expatriates. When
Maruti started its operations in collaboration with Suzuki Corporation of Japan, Suzuki had sent a hoard of its
employees to begin operations. Similarly Bridgestone, the tyre multinational company’s operations in India are
headed by a Japanese managing director and the marketing and sales department is also headed by another
Japanese expatriate director.
Hiring Third Country Nationals Abroad International marketing firms can hire third country
nationals working in the same region. They may be hired from a country of their current posting and be sent on
a posting to the country of operations by the international marketing firm. Such employees are the professional
expatriates who have moved out of their own country to settle down in sales career abroad. These
professionals can get acclimatised to different cultures easily as they would have had some posting or
assignment in the country targeted for marketing and sales assignment. International marketing firms operating
in the Middle East have been hiring Indians, Malays, Pakistanis and Phillipino. Similarly in Singapore too, lot
many third country professionals from Asian countries have been hired by international firms.
Hiring Host Country Nationals Many international companies prefer employing local nationals
from the country of operations in order to maintain the culture positioning at the day-to-day operational levels
7. Nakiye Boyacigiller, “The Role of Expatriates in the Management of Interdependence, Complexity and Risk in
Multinational Corporation”, Journal of International Business Studies, Third Qr. 1991, Vol.22, No.3, Pp.357-381
www.bitbookwala.in
Personal Selling and Multinational Sales Management 291
within the company and also with the customers of the host country. Pepsi, Coca Cola, Hyundai, Samsung,
Bridgestone, Goodyear International, Hindustan Levers, Proctor & Gamble and many other international
companies have hired sales personnel from India who have internationally acceptable levels of education.
However many a times the international companies prefer keeping the key positions reserved for nationals of
their own country and only second or third level positions are offered to the locals from the host country. The
expatriates’ managers under such conditions try to utilise the experiences of locals in dealing with many arms
of government and other market customers. The expatriates may not come in direct touch with the outside
customers till they are acclimatised to the local culture and language etc.
SECTION 4:
MANAGING INTERNATIONAL SALES PERSONNEL
International marketing firms can not afford to have simply home country nationals or only host country citizen
as its employees who handle the task of personal selling in different countries. In fact internally the firm will
have to employ many kinds of nationals with different cultures and personalities. The attitude of these
employees towards their jobs, their customers and even towards their employers is governed and influenced to
a large extent, by the cultural exposures they would have had in their own countries. In such a situation the
multinational company will find it difficult to assign territories, establish quotas and define follow up systems.
Imagine if a sales person from the low context culture (where more emphasis is placed on the written
communication) is asked to report to the sales manager who belongs to the high context culture (in high context
culture less emphasis is placed on the verbal and written communication). Personnel from high context will
Recruiting Expatriates with the Right Mind Set It is not possible for every one to work
outside their country of origin, as the work conditions, the work culture will not be the same as the one he is
used to in his own country. International marketing firms will have to ensure they assign foreign posting to
individuals who have the right mind set to work abroad. We give here some of the personality traits, in addition
to the suitable technical and professional skills, companies should look for in individuals selected for an
international sales assignment.
1. Openness and Sensitivity: the individuals so selected must have a high level of openness and sensi-
tivity to others. They must be aware of their own cultural values, and be able to relate across other
cultures. Cultural sensitivity and awareness should be the foremost consideration.8
2. Adaptability and Resiliency: the individuals so selected must be in a position to get acclimatised and
adapted to the other culture at the earliest. In fact the sooner they are able to do it the better it is for the
international marketing firm and its market abroad. High level of resiliency will ensure the acceptance
of others point of views too.9
www.bitbookwala.in
292 International MarketingText and Cases
3. Willingness to Work Abroad: it is obvious only a sales person who has the desire to work overseas
should be selected.10 Any kind of reluctance will become an obstacle in learning about other cultures
and person so selected will look forward for the first opportunity to get repatriated.
Motivation of Expatriates the firms employing the multi cultural and multiple country nationals
adopt various methods and incentives to keep its field sales personnel highly motivated. It is quite difficult for
a firm to point out one single factor that could act as the best motivating factor for an employee to leave the
BIT BOOK WALA
security of the home country and move abroad. The firm will try a combination of cash compensations, early
advancement in career, a chance to get exposed to global management systems etc. to motivate the sales staff
to opt for an opening abroad.
Motivation otherwise proves very complicated to handle as the firm here is dealing with different cultures,
different sources and different philosophies.11
International sales managers while dealing with the subject of motivation will have to keep in mind the
cultural differences of various nationalities employed by the firm. While money could be the motivation for an
expatriate from a developing country to lure him to the idea of a great life abroad. It could certainly not act in the
same fashion for an individual from a highly industrialised country, where the wage levels will already be very
high. The attitude towards money could differ from culture to culture. A European will like to have a large part
as fixed pay or compensation and leave little for the performance incentive. An American could however
believe in his personal freedom to make more money from the performance linked bonus and incentives.
Similarly, while designing other motivational packages, the firm will have to be aware of the cultural attitude
towards the group mentality or individuality. A Japanese sales person will always be keen to have a leaning
towards the group activities and a sense of belonging to the peer group is more important for him than any
other reward. The firm for such an attitude will do well to design motivation scheme for the entire peer group.
Responsibility towards family, getting information on family, ability to communicate with the family on
frequent intervals, arrangements for the education of children in the best schools / higher education institutes
10. Rasmusson, Can Your Reps., Pp.110.
11. James P. Neelankanvil, Anil Mathur and Yong Zang, “Determinants of Managerial Performance: A Cross Cultural
Comparison of the Perceptions of the Middle Level Managers in Four Countries”, The Journal of International
Business Studies, 200, Vol. 31, Pp. 121-140.
www.bitbookwala.in
Personal Selling and Multinational Sales Management 293
etc. are some of the other motivational tools the international firms adopt, to keep its international sales
personnel away from home sickness and depressions of being away from the near and dear ones.
12. Betty Jane Punnett (2004), International Perspectives on Organisation Behaviour and Human Resource Manage-
ment, Prentice Hall
www.bitbookwala.in
294 International MarketingText and Cases
3 Tokyo, Japan 1
4 Hong Kong 9
5 London, United Kingdom 3
6 Osaka, Japan 2
7 Geneva, Switzerland 6
8 Copenhagen, Denmark 8
9 Zurich, Switzerland 7
10 Oslo, Norway 10
11 (tie)
12
BIT BOOK WALA
New York City, United States
St. Petersburg, Russia
13
15
13 Milan, Italy 11
15 Istanbul, Turkey 22
16 Paris, France 12
17 Singapore, Singapore 34
18 Dublin, Ireland 13
19 Sydney, Australia 20
20 Shanghai, People’s Republic of China 30
Mercer Human Resource Consulting 2006 Survey
Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_most_expensive_cities_for_expatriate_employees
Repatriation Expense Moving back to the home country after the foreign assignment has been
completed by the expatriate employee will cost heavily again. The international employer firm usually will cover
all such expense that will help employee settle down in his home country again.
However not all the companies do this for their expatriate employees. The high commissions and the
embassies of the countries along with the international firms arrange for lots of other recreation facilities for the
www.bitbookwala.in
Personal Selling and Multinational Sales Management 295
benefit of these employees. The high commissions run courses in their home country cultures. They also run
schools for the children of expatriate employees. These embassies also arrange for the national, religious and
social functions within their premises in coordination with some of the international marketing firms.
The other issue that can disturb an expatriate is about his future within the organisation after the completion
of foreign assignment. International firms address this question by arranging for training into higher skills etc.
needed for the next position within the hierarchy, which is generally assured to an employee posted abroad.
The companies may also help the spouse of the employee by addressing his or her career related concerns. The
international firms can arrange employment for the spouse within the organisation or may arrange a job with
another company of the group.
Addressing Repatriation Issues Employees when returning from a posting abroad often find that
every thing has changed in their absence. It is not the same office or the same people that they left behind while
going abroad. This happens due to the reverse culture that the employee experiences on his return from abroad.
The employees are virtually treated as very important persons when they are posted abroad. They may
communicate directly with the top management on day to day basis. The protocol and bureaucratic systems of
the home country, however, will virtually expect the employee to follow the established norms. Such an
employee if not treated in the right manner may get the reverse culture shock and adjustment will become
difficult. The family too can experience such reverse shock of not being in a position to adjust to the home
country atmosphere after a high profile living abroad.
International firms can address this kind of alienation by offering a higher position on return from abroad,
making a lateral move to another department along with huge cash incentives and/ or offering resettlement
allowances. Firms also arrange for counselling sessions of such employees by attaching a senior manager as a
BIT BOOK WALA
mentor to the returned employees.
REFERENCES
1. Marcus W. Brauchli, “Looking East: Asia on the Ascent; It is Learning to Say no to
Arrogant West”, The Wall Street Journal, 13th April Pp. A1:A8.
2. Ramneek Kapoor , “Fundamentals of Sales Management”, Macmillan India Ltd , Pp. 106-
107.
3. William J. Stanton, Op. Cit., Pp.440.
4. Ramneek Kapoor, “Fundamentals of Sales Management”, Macmillan India Ltd., Pp. 275-
276.
5. Ramneek Kapoor, “Fundamentals of Sales Management”, Macmillan India Ltd., Pp. 313-
314.
6. Nakiye Boyacigiller , “The Role of Expatriates in the Management of Interdependence,
Complexity and Risk in Multinational Corporation”, Journal of International Business
Studies, Third Qr. 1991, Vol. 22, No.3, Pp.357-381.
7. David M. Noer, Multinational People Management, Bureau of National Affairs, 1975.
8. David M. Noer, Multinational People Management, Bureau of National Affairs, 1975.
9. Rasmusson, Can Your Reps., Pp.110.
www.bitbookwala.in
296 International MarketingText and Cases
10. James P. Neelankanvil, Anil Mathur, and Yong Zang, “Determinants of Managerial Perfor-
mance: A Cross Cultural Comparison of the Perceptions of the Middle Level Managers in
Four Countries”, the Journal of International Business Studies, 200, Vol. 31, Pp. 121-140.
11. Mercer Human Resource Consulting 2006 Survey.
WEBSITES VISITED
1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_most_expensive_cities_for_expatriate_employees
1. Bovet, Susan Fry, “Building an International Team”, Public Relations Journal, August-
September 1994, Pp. 26-28.
2. Honeycutt, Earl D., John B. Ford and Lew Curtzman, “Potential Problems and Solutions
when Hiring and Training a World Wide Sales Team,” Journal of Business and Industrial
Marketing, winter 1996.
BIT BOOK WALA
3. Lewin, Jeffery E. and Welsely J. Johnson, “International Sales Force Management: A
Relationship Perspective”, Journal of Business and Industrial Marketing, Vol. 12, No. 3,
summer 1997, Pp. 232.
4. Ramneek Kapoor, Fundamentals of Sales Management, Macmillan India Ltd., New Delhi.
5. Simon Majaro, International Marketing London, George Allen and Unwin Ltd, London.
www.bitbookwala.in
Personal Selling and Multinational Sales Management 297
www.bitbookwala.in
298 International MarketingText and Cases
REVIEW QUESTIONS
BIT BOOK WALA
1. Briefly describe the process of personal selling.
2. What are the objectives of personal selling in international marketing?
3. Briefly describe three alternatives available to an international marketing firm for
selecting employees for posting abroad. Explain why a company will prefer hiring host
country employees abroad.
4. What is an expatriate sales person? Briefly explain the compensation methods adopted
by international marketing firm for its expatriate employees.
5. Write short notes on following:
(1) Training and culture orientation for international assignment
(2) Repatriation issues
(3) Motivation of expatriates
(4) Third country nationals.
www.bitbookwala.in
Chapter 16
Learning Objectives
The reader should be able
• to understand the geo-political and economic systems in foreign countries
• to get first hand information about rules and legal framework, policy change in
the countries where you have to do business
• to collect information about industries, companies and the market structure with
special reference to Middle East Countries.
www.bitbookwala.in
300 International MarketingText and Cases
SECTION 1:
INTRODUCTION
D oing business with companies from other countries requires knowledge about religion, places, people
etc. The Middle East is a region with numerous opportunities, yet like all markets it carries its own set of
risk factors. Before doing business in the Middle East it is imperative therefore to learn and understand the
business culture, etiquette, legal framework along with the many business and investment opportunities
themselves.
Understanding the Middle East (also Gulf) region’s
unique history, religion and culture significantly
improves the business prospects of today’s traders and
investors. For millennia, these countries have been trade
crossroads between Europe, Asia and Africa, actively
engaging in and facilitating international trade. The Gulf
economies present an array of market types, ranging
from extremely poor Yemen and lower middle income
Iran, to the very wealthy Saudi Arabia, the UAE, Qatar
and Kuwait. Unusual demographic, ethnic and cultural
diversity also influences commercial opportunities.
The outlook for this region, of course depends on how
the price of oil and the production levels of oil will move
SECTION 2:
POLITICS AND ECONOMY
The Middle East had housed some of the most advanced cultures of its time, like the Muslim Caliphate and
the early stages of the Ottoman empire. Today, the region is characterised by strong political tensions, like the
issue of Palestine/Israel, the issue of Kurdistan, the issue of rights to water resources, as well as a number of
smaller, yet important issues like Syrian presence in Lebanon, border disagreements between Syria and
Turkey, between Saudi Arabia and Yemen and the civil rights of Shiai minorities in Iraq and Bahrain.
In the Middle East countries, wealth is unevenly distributed between the countries, with the United Arab
Emirates and Israel offering highest living standards for the entire population and Yemen with the serious
financial problems for its majority of the population.
Dr. Justin Paul, Yatinder Agrohi and Sudarsana Reddy co-authored this chapter.
www.bitbookwala.in
Organising and Doing Business with Other CountriesAnalysis of Middle East Countries 301
Economic Overview
In general, the Middle East region commands abundant natural resources, accounts for a large share of world
petroleum production and exports, and enjoys on an average, a reasonable standard of living. Within this
general characterisation, countries vary substantially in resources, economic and geographical size,
population and standards of living. At the same time, intra-regional interaction is weak, being restricted
principally to labour flows with limited trade in goods and services.
Most Middle East countries have experienced population growth in the recent years. Kuwait, Oman, Qatar,
Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates have registered population growth rates exceeding 3.5 percent in
recent years, while Bahrain has recorded rates below the 2 percent average of the developing countries.
Although the region is plagued by harsh climate, limited groundwater and rainfall and scarce arable land,
it enjoys abundant natural resources. About two-thirds of the world’s known crude-oil reserves lie under this
region, with one quarter located in Saudi Arabia. The region also possesses numerous non-fuel mineral and
non-mineral resources. The region’s natural resources include potash, iron ore, coal, ammonia, urea etc.
Reflecting the various advantages, Middle East region constitutes a sizable economic entity and enjoys a
reasonable standard of living by international standards. Saudi Arabia is the largest economy, accounting for
one-fifth of the region’s total GDP. The highest per capita income countries ( Kuwait, Qatar, and the United
Arab Emirates) enjoy an average per capita GDP of around $15,000.
The region trades mainly with the industrial economies. The countries of the EU are the most important
trading partners. The United States and Japan account for sizeable percent of both the region’s exports and
imports. The region’s oil trade heavily influences these indicators. Oil and oil-related products account for
about three quarters of the region’s exports and about 50 percent of world exports of these products. The
BIT BOOK WALA
United Arab Emirates per capita export, is around $11,000. This region depends on imports of foodstuffs.
Gross food imports of the region accounts for 4 percent of world food imports. All countries are, on an average
net food importers.
The Middle East region enjoys sizable interest income inflows, reflecting a high level of foreign assets.
Finally, in terms of intra-regional capital flows, two distinct groups exist in Middle East: providers of
significant foreign assistance mainly the oil exporters, Kuwait, Qatar, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab
Emirates and recipients. Political considerations have also played an important role in this regard, but private
capital flows have been relatively limited.
Regional Outlook
Changes in the policies have affected the region’s economic outlook and the way trading partners and
domestic and foreign investors view the region.
Peace Process The region is closer than ever to resolving the long-standing Arab-Israeli conflict. This
conflict had adversely affected economic development in certain countries of the region. The conflict had
accentuated macroeconomic imbalances and diverted resources from productive investments in
infrastructure and in the social sectors. By aggravating perceptions of socio-political risks, it has discouraged
investment in certain countries. It has also inhibited efficient regional projects for electricity, water
management and tourism.
The Iraq war had created a great deal of uncertainty in this region but most economies in the region
weathered that storm reasonably well and continued on their growth path since then.
www.bitbookwala.in
302 International MarketingText and Cases
The establishment of a comprehensive, just and durable peace in the Middle East is expected to result in a
significant economic peace dividend, provided it is accompanied by sound economic policies. Of how much
worth the peace dividend is difficult to estimate, but military spending cuts could over time lead to higher
capital formation and less severe resource misallocation. The impact is expected to be large but will probably
materialise with some lag.
Closer Integration with the EU Initiative for close trade links with the EU emphasises the private
sector as an engine of growth and the establishment of a free trade area, initially between the EU and individual
Middle East countries and subsequently between the EU and Middle East as a region. The gains associated
with this initiative would materialise from improved efficiency as a result of growing competition, somewhat
better access to EU markets and improved domestic and foreign investment flows associated with “policy
credibility” resulting from closer integration with the EU.
SECTION 3:
THE BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT
Understanding the Gulf region’s religion, culture and business environment remains critical to doing business
in those countries. Important issues include appropriately using local agents, choosing local investment
partners, understanding the role of chambers of commerce and managing the region’s bureaucratic culture.
Religion
www.bitbookwala.in
Organising and Doing Business with Other CountriesAnalysis of Middle East Countries 303
contractual obligations. However, beyond that, its direct business impact is limited; business law is not usually
cited in religious texts and tends to be government legislated. Nonetheless, legal frameworks are not as well
developed as in western economies and avoiding litigation often is critical to business success.
Legal problems include complying with often complex and ambiguous foreign ownership laws, achieving
intellectual property protection and terminating agency agreements. Consequently, thorough due diligence on
potential partners and use of all available means of dispute resolution, such as negotiation or arbitration, if
problems do arise, are essential.
Demographics
The Gulf economies’ young population create reform pressure and stimulate demand for education, music
products, electronics, information technology and communications, snack foods, travel, housing and
mortgage financing. The population structure in Middle East economies is shown below:
Non-nationals, from the Indian sub-continent, other Middle Eastern states and western economies play
important role in GCC1 workforces and market demand. Expatriates account for about 70 per cent of the
population in the UAE, Qatar and Kuwait and 60 per cent in Bahrain and are significant in most other Gulf
economies. Non-nationals not only do all dangerous and unskilled work, but fill many private sector skilled and
managerial positions.
1. GCC stands for Gulf Co-operation Council (Regional Group for Co-operation between Gulf Countries)
www.bitbookwala.in
304 International MarketingText and Cases
Economic Prospects
• In most Gulf economies, economic growth is lower than workforce growth. Other major reform drivers
are the desire to diversify out of oil, fiscal pressures and declining oil reserves in Oman, Bahrain, Qatar
and Dubai in the UAE.
• Despite modest economic growth over the 1990s, these reform pressures have created new opportuni-
BIT BOOK WALA
ties for foreign firms; fiscal pressures have increased the importance of private finance and privately
provided infrastructure, while the drive to diversify have opened new opportunities in gas, heavy
industry and service sectors. Efforts to boost the employment of Gulf nationals have resulted in the
need for education and skills training.
• In the 1990s, lower and volatile oil prices and failure to open economies and diversify from oil were the
reasons for ‘Gulf economies’ moderate growth performance. However, now the young, rapidly growing
population and massive infrastructure needs of the major oil producers like Saudi Arabia, Iran, UAE
and Kuwait are generating strong pressures for economic reforms. These reforms should help stimu-
late more balanced and robust growth, reduce vulnerability to swings in international oil prices and
expand business opportunities for foreign traders and investors.
• Young, rapidly growing population are creating significant pressures to lift economic growth and
diversify economic activity. As well as providing a huge workforce, they also create a strong demand
for education, health services and infrastructure like roads, water supply and electricity, which the
state traditionally provides in Gulf economies. Demand for new services imposes fiscal pressures on
Gulf governments. This demand creates a major incentive to increase private sector involvement in
infrastructure provision.
• Gulf economies are expanding their service sectors to diversify their economies. Dubai and Bahrain
are setting the pace, with their service sectors accounting for majority of their respective GDPs,
compared to only small per cent in Saudi Arabia. Dubai is the Arabian Peninsula’s premier re-export
centre, servicing the Middle East and Africa. It also is a substantial tourism, financial, exhibition and
conference centre. Bahrain is a major offshore banking centre and like Dubai, targets regional head-
quarters and tourism investment. With a growing imperative to strengthen private sector employ-
ment, all countries are trying to expand their telecommunications, information technology, tourism,
www.bitbookwala.in
Organising and Doing Business with Other CountriesAnalysis of Middle East Countries 305
finance and education sectors. As a part of this process, increasing opportunities should emerge for
foreign service providers.
SECTION 4:
BUSINESS OPPORTUNITIES IN THE MIDDLE EAST REGION
BIT BOOK WALA
Middle East region has enormous assets. It has enormous financial and natural resources, very well developed
infrastructure in most of the countries, heavy investment in education, a strategic location, very close to all
markets, especially European, African and Asian. We can also expect these economies to grow at much
higher rates. This indeed, illustrates that this region provides enormous business and investment
opportunities.
www.bitbookwala.in
306 International MarketingText and Cases
Agricultural Exports Rapid population growth and fiscal pressures limiting the capacity of
governments to expand domestic agricultural subsidies have created more demand for bulk wheat, sugar, and
frozen meat imports. With local incomes rising and air links improving, prospects also are good for higher
value fresh and processed food exports, including dairy products, inputs for the processed food industry and
snacks products.
Minerals and Energy Major projects related to gas pipeline should stimulate the Gulf’s heavy
industry development, boosting demand for alumina and steel making resources from countries like India.
Further expansion of these heavy industries could stimulate Gulf interest in investing in mineral sectors, in
other countries.
BIT BOOK WALA
Services Excellent opportunities also exist for service exports, including building infrastructure,
education, tourism, construction, mining and business services. Indian IT industry has excellent opportunities
in the region with reference to this sector, because of geographical proximity and availability of low cost
skilled labour.
Capital Markets
A dramatic integration and globalisation of capital markets occurred in the first half of the 1990s, providing
some developing countries with access to external financing to supplement domestic resources in funding
investment opportunities. This provides a platform for foreign direct investment flows to “emerging equity
markets” and also provides access by developing countries to bond and equity markets in industrial countries.
In recognition of the need to attract sustainable inflows of private capital and given the potential for capital
markets to finance productive investments, many Middle East countries are emphasising financial sector
reforms (banks and capital markets) to encourage the mobilisation of funds from domestic, regional and
international sources and to minimise the associated risks.
Foreign Investment Due to their huge oil export receipts, GCC economies are traditionally capital
exporters. Abundant capital and restrictive foreign investment regimes had made FDI a much less significant
capital source for the Gulf economies than for East Asia. However, efforts to strengthen growth, diversify
economies and create employment are changing rapidly these restrictive policies.
Remaining constraints on inward FDI to the Gulf economies include caps on foreign ownership outside the
free trade zones, prohibitions on investing in many sectors (particularly oil), restrictions on foreign
participation in key infrastructure, energy and manufacturing sectors and imprecise regulatory frameworks.
www.bitbookwala.in
Organising and Doing Business with Other CountriesAnalysis of Middle East Countries 307
However, Qatar, Oman and Saudi Arabia lead reform efforts and further opening of FDI regimes is likely in the
short to medium term. Prospect of large scale foreign involvement is more in the region’s huge emerging gas
industry than in oil, as regional expertise in the gas sector are less developed. The scale of investment and need
for internationally competitive operations should make foreign investment more attractive than majority state
ownership, the previous approach. Private infrastructure investment opportunities also should expand due to
ongoing liberalisation and massive needs for telecommunications, roads, pipelines construction, railway
construction and electricity and water production and distribution services. Free trade zones also provide
export and distribution opportunities, for companies from Asia, Europe, USA etc.
SECTION 5:
ANALYSIS OF SELECT COUNTRIES OF THE REGION
Saudi Arabia
The modern Kingdom of Saudi Arabia was formed in 1932, following reunification and has been ruled by the
Saudi family since. The ruler manage the day-to-day affairs of government. While the Kingdom is an absolute
monarchy, the ruling family governs by consensus, taking careful account of public sentiment. Oil was
discovered in 1938 and commercial exploitation began after World War II. Saudi Arabia has the world’s largest
oil reserves, 261.5 billion barrels or 25 per cent of the world’s total oil reserve. At current production rates,
proven reserves will last for 75-80 years. Oil revenues allowed successive governments to develop the
Kingdom’s infrastructure, agriculture and industry. Saudi Arabia has been undergoing, since the late 1990s, a
series of structural reforms to improve the market environment for investment, both domestic and
BIT BOOK WALA
international. A number of laws have been passed in the area of financial and banking-sector reform. More
recently, a capital-markets law has been passed to allow the development of deeper capital and diversified
capital markets.
Other prospective reforms include redrawing the tax law, improving stock market regulation, redrafting
labour laws and the mining code and privatising the telecommunications, electricity, petrochemicals and
airline industries. Foreign direct investment has, of course, been encouraged subject to cap in different
sectors. As a result of these reforms, Saudi Arabia has achieved reasonable growth rates. The non-oil sector
has grown at about three-and-a-half to 4 percent per year steadily.
It is expected that, in the coming years, the Saudi economy will do well and provide enormous
opportunities to the investors in financial sector, human resource development projects and non-oil sectors.
UAE
The United Arab Emirates, UAE, gained independence from Britain in 1971; before then, individual emirates
were British protectorates. The UAE has close defence links with other Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC),
states and the United States, Britain and France. Only 20 per cent of the UAE’s population are nationals; the
remainder are expatriates from South Asia (64 per cent), other Middle Eastern countries (15 per cent) and
western countries (1 per cent).
Skilled and unskilled labour shortages among UAE nationals, relatively high wages and ‘no income tax’
attract expatriate to UAE. The UAE has 9.7 per cent of the world’s crude oil reserves and 4.1 per cent of its
natural gas reserves. Dubai accounts for 26 per cent of UAE GDP and is a regional trade centre, with foreign
trade more than double its US$13 billion GDP. The Dubai government aggressively promotes the Emirate as
a regional commercial services and tourism hub and developed the Gulf’s largest free trade zone and port at
Jebel Ali. Dubai benefited from business relocation from Kuwait and Bahrain, during and after the Gulf War.
www.bitbookwala.in
308 International MarketingText and Cases
UAE is one of those countries in the region that has been open for business for some time new. It has chosen
the way of opening its economy for trade, for financial intermediation and for the development, especially, of
trans shipment trade and financial and insurance sectors. And in fact, in this regard the UAE has succeeded to
a great extent.
Growth in the UAE has been highly satisfactory because of two reasons 1) strengthening of the oil market
in the recent past, 2) increased activity related to trade, banking and finance in Dubai and in the United Arab
Emirates as a whole. The United Arab Emirates also has been one of the more diligent countries in terms of
passing legislation and enforcing anti-money laundering and the integrity of its financial and banking system.
And also, UAE has been one of the more transparent countries in terms of sharing the information.
The UAE joined the WTO in 1995. Currently, the UAE is implementing a series of economic reforms,
including improving business laws and intellectual property protection, privatising and opening previously
closed sectors to foreign direct investment, particularly in the utilities sector. The UAE is a rapidly growing
trans shipment point for Europe-Asia cargo and for air-sea cargo combinations. Dubai’s large international
airport hubs the flights of its successful Emirates Airline, Lufthansa has its largest cargo hub outside Frankfurt
in Sharjah. Newly opened airports, free trade zones in Dubai and Sharjah, the continued growth of Jebel Ali and
other traditional free trade zones, and the UAE’s growing role as a regional headquarters, shopping and
distribution centre, would contribute for the expansion of air and sea transport hub activities. Led by Dubai,
tourism is a significant growth industry in these countries.
This open trade culture will further provide opportunities for investors in most of the sectors.
Kuwait
BIT BOOK WALA
Kuwait became an autonomous British protectorate in 1899. Despite affirming Kuwait’s borders a number of
times, Iraq invaded and occupied Kuwait in 1990. In 1991, following widespread Iraqi destruction and
sabotage, the US-led United Nations forces ejected Iraq in Operation Desert Storm. Kuwait has around 10 per
cent of the world’s oil reserves and significant excess production capacity. Petroleum accounts for 40 per cent
of GDP, 89 per cent of export revenues and 78 per cent of government revenues. Between 1991 and 1993,
Kuwait experienced rapid growth driven by reconstruction; after that, real growth returned to 2 per cent per
year until 1998. Since 1999, the Government has undertaken began a reform program designed to reduce
subsidies and privatise health care, telecommunications and utilities. The country seeks to liberalise foreign
direct investment rules, allow full foreign ownership of Kuwaiti projects and find mechanisms to allow
foreign oil companies to operate oil fields in Northern Kuwait. However, considerable resistance in the
National Assembly to these reforms, has slowed down the reform measures.
Sultanate of Oman
Oman has an ancient history as a commercial centre and occupies the choke point of the Strait of Hormuz,
facing Iran, through which two thirds of the world’s oil trade passes. Oman was largely closed to the outside
world and undeveloped until Sultan Qaboos acceded in 1970. He used oil revenues to provide basic
infrastructure and services. In the 1990s, his efforts focused on implementing structural reform and increasing
the private sector’s role, particularly in utilities provision. In 1994, Oman offered the Gulf’s first build,
operate, transfer project, BOT, the Manah power station. Currently, Oman is extending BOT type
arrangements to other infrastructure areas and privatising ports telecommunications, airports, utilities,
banking, insurance and power generation. Further, it is developing a strong regulatory framework in the
electricity sector, allowing competition between generators. Oman is diversifying into the gas and services
www.bitbookwala.in
Organising and Doing Business with Other CountriesAnalysis of Middle East Countries 309
sectors. Liquified natural gas, (LNG), exports began in April 2000, following a US$2.5 billion investment.
Tourism facilities also are being upgraded rapidly and new hotel investment has been eagerly sought from the
private sector.
Yemen
Modern Yemen resulted from the amalgamation of the former People’s Democratic Republic of Yemen (PDRY)
and the Yemen Arab Republic (YAR) in 1990. Before this, the two countries had fought a number of wars. Civil
war erupted in 1994, following attempted secession by the South, which ended with the capture of Aden, and
arrest of former PDRY leaders, thereby confirming unification.
Yemen is a poor Gulf economy, but grew strongly in the mid 1990s when oil production began. It is
undertaking IMF-sponsored reforms to reduce subsidies, control inflation, improve the Government’s fiscal
position and encourage investment. Reflecting its strong economic reform record, the IMF extended
refinancing of US$512 million between 1997 and 2000, which with rising aid inflows, allows Yemen to meet
its external obligations. The port of Aden is undergoing large scale redevelopment, under a 20-year
management contract with the Port of Singapore Authority, which holds 60 per cent equity. The port should
capture significant Europe-Asia container traffic, as it avoids the detour into the Persian Gulf.
CONCLUSION
With enormous natural and financial resources, well developed infrastructure in most of the countries, good
growth rates makes this region a heaven of international business opportunities. Being a strategic located and
BIT BOOK WALA
close to most of the prominent markets with untapped potential makes, this region is more attractive to
investors.
The need to improve modest economic growth rates and to diversify, are likely to drive considerable
structural change in Gulf economies. This would boost international marketing opportunities.
REFERENCES
1. Justin, Paul, Subhash. S. (2005), International Migration and its Impact with reference to
Gulf migration – Some perspectives, Management and Labour Studies.
2. Rashid, Amjad (Ed. 1989), To the Gulf and Back: Studies on the Economic Impact of
Asian Migration, New Delhi, ILO ARTEP.
3. Various articles published in Gulf News and Khaleej Times.
4. Various articles published. in ‘Gulf Business’ magazine
5. Websites of Central Banks and Ministries in Middle East countries
6. www.countrywatch.com
7. Internatiooal Financial Statistics, IMF, 2004.
8. Transcript of a Press Briefing on the Economic Outlook in the Middle East and North
Africa by George Abed, Director, Middle Eastern Department, David J. Robinson,
Deputy Director, Research Department, Abdelali Jbili, Assistant Director, Middle East-
ern Department, and Mohamad Chatah, Advisor, External Relations Department at the
www.bitbookwala.in
310 International MarketingText and Cases
Dubai International Convention Centre, Dubai, United Arab Emirates on September 18,
2003, from Website of IMF.
9. Growth and Stability in the Middle East and North Africa – Summary, from Website of
IMF.
10. WORLD BANK report overview on Middle East And North Africa Region - 2005 Eco-
nomic Developments, from Website of World Bank.
11. Macroeconomic Aspects of the New Demography in the Middle East and North Africa by
Tarik M. Yousef, Department of Economics, School of Foreign Service, Georgetown Uni-
versity, Washington.
www.bitbookwala.in
Chapter 17
Learning Objectives
The reader should be able to
• Understand the role and importance of export documents
• Understand how to prepare each document carefully
• Understand the step by step procedure involved in export business.
www.bitbookwala.in
312 International MarketingText and Cases
SECTION 1:
EXPORT DOCUMENTATION
T he procedural and documentary formalities involved in the import and export marketing are diversely
different from those required for the domestic marketing. In domestic marketing, a firm will have to meet the
specific statutory requirement of the excise and taxation departments of his own country and raise a simple
sales invoice on the customer. In export marketing, however, the agencies involved are too many and the
exporter or importer will have to raise documents to the satisfaction of each organisation separately. The
agencies involved include:
1. The importing organisation that has placed the export order on the marketing firm
2. The statutory, exchange control, customs and taxation authorities of both the countries
3. The port authorities at the port of loading and unloading of the goods meant for import and exports
4. The shipping and warehousing or multimodal agencies involved in the process of moving goods and
material from the point of manufacturing to the ultimate point of delivery as given out in the export
contract
5. The exporting firm will also have to prepare documents meant for the inspection agency if specifically
mentioned by the importer in the export contract if the item is under inspection list.
6. The exporter will have to prepare documents meant for the agencies involved in financial transactions
of releasing payment against the credit created by the importing organisation i.e. the foreign bank and
the local country bank and the bank standing guarantee etc, if involved1
In addition there are many other agencies who would be specifying their own need for different documents
BIT BOOK WALA
to be complied with by the exporter before he gets released his proceeds collected from abroad. Export
documentation to meet the needs of all these agencies constitutes heavy and cumbersome work for the
exporting firms. They will have to do a lot of paper work and procedural formalities. Even though there are
outsource agencies available that can be entrusted the task of preparing these necessary documentations and
handle the procedural formalities. It is absolutely essential for the exporter to understand the importance of
each document which if ignored otherwise can hold back his payment or even get the export contract rescinded
altogether in addition to creating legal complication for the exporter at home or abroad. We will in this chapter
undertake an exhaustive study of documents and procedures which an exporter has to comply with in an export
contract.
Export documentation is important as these play a significant role in regulating the flow and movement of
goods and services in international markets. Each country will have its own prescribed statutory documents to
be filled up by the exporters and importers. Similarly, the signatories to the export contract will specify their own
need of the documents to be submitted along with the shipments. The complexities of such comprehensive
documentation call for the scrutiny of the paper work by the experts in the fields which are available with the
experienced shipping and forwarding agencies in each country, who in addition to the task of moving goods
and commodities also undertake the job of handling these documents for their clients. It is however important
that exporters themselves are fully familiar with the export documentations and procedures so that
unnecessary delay in getting the goods cleared from the ports can be avoided and the goods can be delivered
as per the time schedule mentioned in the export contract.
The export documents can be classified into the following four categories based on the specific functions
performed by each of them:
1. Alan Branch (2000), Export Practices and Management, Thomson Learning, Business Press.
www.bitbookwala.in
Export Marketing Documents and Procedures 313
www.bitbookwala.in
314 International MarketingText and Cases
Proforma Invoice
Refers to the advance copy of the proforma of the invoice sent to the importer to understand how the bill will
finally be prepared for the goods ordered by him.
Invoice
It is the basic document for an export transaction on the basis of which many other documents related to the
exports of goods will be prepared.2 It is the sales bill of the goods ordered by the importer. It contains
particulars related to the customer whom goods are being supplied, his name, address, his bankers details and
import license numbers etc. It also relates the goods to be supplied e.g., the price per unit, the number of units
being supplied by this bill, the total sales value of the invoice, the taxation description and calculation if any,
the terms of sales, packing units, the packing specifications, identification and private markings of the packing,
bill of lading numbers, name of the ship and the intended destination of the goods etc. Though invoices are
signed by the authorised signatory of the exporter, some of the countries insist on their consular’s invoice
which is nothing but an invoice raised by the exporter but signed by the consular of the importer country who
is based in the exporter’s country.
Packing List
The packing list refers to a consolidated statement of the contents packed in each large case and the numbers
of such large cases meant for shipment. Such list will mention the packing date, the name and address of the
exporter, the name and address of the importer, the export order number and date, the contents of the goods in
BIT BOOK WALA
terms of quality and quantity, weight, special handling instructions if any and finally the marking numbers to
identify the consignment. It does not however mention the export price etc., which will be mentioned in the
invoice.
Certificate of Origin3
The certificate of origin as the name suggests certifies the name of the country in which the goods meant for
export have been produced. This certificate is sent by the exporter to the importer, as it will be needed by him
to get the goods cleared by the customs authority of his country. The customs law of the country may have
preferential duty rates for a particular country or the country may have put an embargo on the imports of
specific goods from a particular country. In each such case, the submission of the certificate of origin will be
required. The exporters can approach the chambers of commerce, the export promotion councils and many
other trade promotion associations, authorised by the government to issue such certificates of origin.
www.bitbookwala.in
Export Marketing Documents and Procedures 315
produced from the imported raw material which have undergone sufficient working or processing in India to be
regarded as originating there”.4 In India such a certificate is issued by the following agencies:
(1) Directorate general of foreign trade and all its regional offices
(2) All development commissioners of special economic zones
(3) Export promotion councils
(4) Export inspection councils and agencies
(5) Commodity Boards and Export Authorities
Mates Receipt
The cargo is handed over to the ship only after all formalities by the custom authorities and port authorities
BIT BOOK WALA
have been completed i.e. the examination of the goods by the custom’s authorities, and the payment of port
charges etc., have been paid by the exporter. The captain of the ship issues this receipt which contains
information regarding name of the vessel, berth, date of shipment, description of packages, identification marks
and numbers, condition of the cargo at the time of loading into the ship etc. The mate’s receipt forms the basic
document for issuing the bill of lading and the mates receipt will be exchanged for the bill of lading.
Bill of Lading
The bill of lading pertains to the official receipt issued by the shipping company or their authorised agent for
carrying the goods to its destination. This bill of lading also forms a shipping contract between the exporter and
the shipping company, to deliver the goods in the condition in which these have been received at the port of
loading. The bill of lading is a document that establishes the ownership title to the goods and as such is the
most important document. This document can be freely transferred and endorsed for delivery; hence the
exporters have to be extra careful while obtaining a bill of lading from the shipping company. The bill of lading
is prepared on the prescribed form of the shipping company and contains the following information:
(1) The shipping company’s name and address
(2) Date and place of shipment
(3) The name of the consignor
(4) The name and destination of vessel
(5) The description, quality, and destination of goods
(6) The private markings and numbers
4. Justin Paul, International Business, Prentice Hall of India, Pp. 306-307.
www.bitbookwala.in
316 International MarketingText and Cases
Types of Bill of Lading Different kinds of bill of lading can be issued by the shipping company
depending on the conditions in which goods have been received:
Clean Bill of Lading It is issued when exportable goods have been received by the shipping vessel in
good order and condition and no remarks are necessary on the conditions of the consignment.
Claused Bill of Lading A Bill of lading forms a contract between the shipper and the exporter to deliver
those goods in the like order in which the same have been received. Hence the shipping companies are extra
careful while acknowledging the receipt and issuing a bill of lading. The goods received in lose, badly packed,
soiled or damaged conditions are issued only “claused bill of lading “will carry remarks on the conditions of the
goods in which these have been received by the ship.
Trans-shipment Bill of Lading If shipping company has to use multi modal systems of transportation
e.g. rail, road, air or another shipping company, the ship’s commanding office can issue a through or trans-
shipment bill of lading.
Freight Paid Bill of Lading
BIT BOOK WALA
It refers to a bill of lading the freight for which has already been paid by the
exporter.
Freight Collect Bill of Lading It is similar to freight to pay consignment note issued by a transport. The
freight in such conditions will be paid after arrival of the goods at the destination, by the consignee (importer).
Airway Bill
It is the receipt issued by the airline company or its booking agency for the carriage of goods by air. The air way
bill can also be either freight paid or freight collect bill and the airline agency will clearly mention other charges
if any are to be collected while delivering the consignment.
FINANCIAL DOCUMENTS
Financial Documents in an export contract include Bill of Exchange, Letter of Contract to be opened by an
importer, etc. Since Bill of Exchange has to be prepared by an exporter, we will discuss about it in detail here.
Bill of Exchange
Bill of Exchange is the common system to collect payment in international trade. A bill of exchange is as good
as any other negotiable instrument covered by the Section 5 of the Negotiable Instrument Act 1881. A bill of
exchange is also known as draft, which is drawn by the exporter, calling upon the importer or the purchaser “to
pay or accept obligation to pay a certain sum of money at a fixed future date”. Once this bill of exchange has
been accepted and the drawee (importer) has signed on the face of the bill of exchange, it becomes obligatory
www.bitbookwala.in
Export Marketing Documents and Procedures 317
on the importer (drawee) to arrange for the payment within the specified period of time. The accepted bill of
exchange becomes a tradable instrument like any other negotiable instrument and can be transferred to a third
party too.
Broadly, there can be following three types of bill of exchange. However, for practical purposes, Bill of
Exchange can be classified as (1) sight bill (2) usage bill.
(I) Sight Bill of Exchange Refers to the situation when the drawer has asked the drawee to make
payment against the draft bill of exchange immediately on receipt of the intimation about the document from the
intermediary bank. The importer will be given the shipping documents for getting the delivery of the goods
only after he has paid the sum drawn in the bill of exchange. This also means that the exporter has not allowed
any credit period to the importer and has asked for payment against delivery.
(II) Usance Bill of Exchange When the export contract entered into by the signatories’ parties has
allowed a specific period of credit to the importer , the exporter will draw usance bill of exchange and
accordingly the draft drawn will also mention the credit period allowed by him to the importer. The drawee
importer will accept the obligation after putting his seal and signature on the face of bill of exchange drawn. The
bank will present the documents for collection of payment to the drawee after stipulated period of credit and the
proceeds will be remitted to the exporter by the bank as per the instructions sent along with the draft bill of
exchange.
(III) Documentary Bill of Exchange When the bill of exchange is accompanied by the shipping
documents e.g. bill of lading, marine insurance policy, commercial invoice, inspection certificates, certificate of
BIT BOOK WALA
origin etc., (the documents that can establish title to the goods) it may be called Documentary bill of exchange.
Such documents are handed over either against sight payment or against usance bill of exchange after
acceptance of the same by the drawee importer as the case might be.
The bill of exchange draft can however be used by the exporter for discounting to a bank and collecting
payment thereof or he can also place them as collateral for loans etc., with his bankers. In any case, people don’t
use the term documentary bill of exchange in real life.
SECTION 2:
LETTER OF CREDIT
International trade involves business transactions between exporters and importers who are from different
countries spread across the boundaries of two different sovereign nations. Each of them will have to strictly
adhere to the rules and regulations set by their respective countries. Such a situation makes it quite a risky
business for the seller. He either has to collect his payment for the goods supplied in advance or he has to
negotiate the documents through bank. The third option available to an exporter is to extend clean credit
facilities to his customers abroad. However the bankers all across the world present a fourth viable option to
both the parties involved in the international business i.e. opening a letter of credit. The letter of credit
arrangement offers an easy way out to handle the international payment system for the seller as well as the
buyer from another country.
“A letter of credit is an undertaking by a bank to pay or to arrange to pay for the specified merchandise
provided that certain stipulated conditions are met by the beneficiary”. The letter of credit has been defined by
the international Chamber of Commerce as “an arrangement, however named or described, whereby a bank (the
issuing bank) acting on the request of and in accordance with the instructions of a customer (the applicant to
the credit), to make payment to or to the order of a third party (the beneficiary), or is to pay, accept or negotiate
www.bitbookwala.in
318 International MarketingText and Cases
bills of exchange (drafts) drawn by the beneficiary, or authorise such payment to be made or such drafts to be
paid, accepted or negotiated, by another bank, against stipulated documents and compliance with stipulated
terms and conditions”.
Basic Features of an Import Letter of Credit From the definition above, we can draw out the
following basic features of a letter of credit:
1. It is an undertaking given by a bank to honour a financial commitment
2. It is an undertaking given by the bank on behalf of its importer client
3. It is an undertaking given by the bank to an exporter who may not be a client of the bank
4. The undertaking will be honoured subject to fulfillment of certain conditions by the exporter
5. There is another bank being involved for collection of the sum promised in the letter of credit.
The letter of credit offers a way out to meet certain financial commitments; which is advantageous to both
the seller and the buyer, who otherwise can not decide on either cash payment or a confirmed clean credit
period owing to their unknown dealing characteristics in business transactions. The seller will not be in a
dilemma to send material as the letter of credit ensures him the payment for the goods, he will be sending across
the borders of his own country provided he follows the instructions as given by the importer in the letter of
credit. The importer on the other hand is assured of the dispatch and shipment of material as per his
instructions; even though he may have to take the trouble of opening a letter of credit with his bankers.
Types of Letter of Credit The letter of credit can be classified into following categories based on their
operational features:
1. Documentary Letter of Credit: When the opener of the letter of credit specifies presentation of some
documents to the paying bank along with the draft, it is called documentary letter of credit.
5. For more details, refer to Management of Banking and Financial Services by Justin Paul and Padmalatha Suresh,
Pearson Education.
www.bitbookwala.in
Export Marketing Documents and Procedures 319
2. Assignable (Transferable) Letter of Credit: This kind of letter of credit can be endorsed to and the
rights in the letter of credit can be assigned to a third beneficiary by the main beneficiary either within
the stipulated period or before the expiry of the credit.
3. Non Assignable Letter of Credit: In such a letter of credit the beneficiary mentioned can not transfer
or endorse this credit to some other party (merchant exporter to manufacturer).
4. Revocable Letter of Credit: Such letter of credit can be altered, cancelled, revoked or amended by the
issuing bank without reference to the beneficiary or to the applicant as the rights for such an action
vests with the issuing bank.
5. Irrevocable Letter of Credit: The issuing bank here cannot amend, cancel, or alter the letter of credit as
a firm understanding exists between the bank and the applicant. Unless and until it is specified by the
issuing bank that the letter of credit issued is revocable all letters of credit are deemed to be irrevocable.
6. Sight Letter of Credit: This is also known as the payment/cash credit. The payment against the credit
so created will be paid on presentation of the sight draft by the beneficiary. Such a letter of credit is
useful when the goods are not readily available and the order fulfillment will take little more time. In
such a case whenever the goods are ready for shipment , the documents can be presented to the bank
to encash the sight draft.
7. Acceptance Credit: Under such an arrangement the bank will only accept the draft drawn by the
exporter. Once the bank has accepted this draft, the draft becomes a valid bank acceptance and gains
acceptance as a negotiable instrument. The same draft can now be readily discounted, sold or en-
dorsed by the exporter to either of the same bank or any other third party.
8. Deferred Credit: The payment in this kind of credit becomes due in parts after specified future periods
BIT BOOK WALA
as per the terms of the export contract. Such a credit is created in those situations where the goods are
supplied in different lots and when one lot is ready for the shipment the payment against the deferred
credit created is released by the bank. This can also be utilised by the purchaser to gain some time to
verify the goods shipped and only after he is satisfied, the payment against the credit is released by the
bank.
9. Confirmed Credit: When the letter of credit is confirmed by a bank in the beneficiary’s country, it is
called a confirmed credit. Such confirmation constitutes a legal guarantee and undertaking on the part
of the confirming bank that the credit will be duly honoured by it whenever the draft is presented for
payment by the beneficiary or endorsee on completion of conditions mentioned in the letter of credit
and presentation of stipulated documents.
10. Unconfirmed Letter of Credit: Whenever the credit is not confirmed by any third bank that is a bank
other than the issuing bank it is known as unconfirmed credit. Such a credit carries undertaking of only
of the issuing bank. LC can be advised by a reputed bank in this case.
11. Back to Back Credit: When the credit is opened by the security of another credit it is known as back
to back credit. It is basically a secondary credit opened by a bank to facilitate the shipping of goods
from the local market for a domestic manufacturer who can use the foreign credit to get acceptance of
domestic suppliers and meet his commitment towards exports.
12. Revolving Credit: The exports’ shipments could continue over a longer period of time and to eliminate
the need of opening a new credit every time the goods are ready for shipment a revolving credit is
arranged by the importer from abroad. In the revolving credit, provisions are inbuilt to make another
credit available to the beneficiary as soon as the earlier draft presented to the bank is taken care of by
the applicant. The principle applied here is that the fresh credit is automatically created after the
original credit is withdrawn by the beneficiary. The other system will create a revolving credit only after
the issuing bank reconfirms arrangement of fresh credit.
www.bitbookwala.in
320 International MarketingText and Cases
13. Red Clause Credit: The red clause credit provides for the predetermined advance payment to the
beneficiary against the credit created. It authorises the negotiating bank to release advance payment
to the beneficiary to purchase the relevant goods which go into the making of exportable goods. The
letter of credit sent to the negotiating bank will specify the conditions on which such advances can be
released by the bank.
• An Indian exporter signs an export contract with an importer from the United States
Ø
• The exporter instead of drawing his payment from the U.S. importer directly will request for arranging a
letter of credit. (The importer will not pay in advance, therefore the need for LC arises)
Ø
• The importer from the United States makes an application to his bankers in United States to open a letter of
credit in favour of his supplier from India
Ø
• The application will mention the terms and conditions on which such LC will be opened and the documents
that will be submitted along with draft upon usance or sight
Ø
• The importer will sign a contract with his bank for servicing the LC
BIT BOOK
Ø
WALA
• The bank after opening the letter of credit will inform the notifying bank in India about the availability of such
a credit and will ask the bank in India to confirm the availability of such a credit to the exporter
Ø
• The notifying bank will now inform the exporter about the letter of credit along with the conditions stipulated
to the credit
Ø
• The exporter satisfies himself to the conditions given in the export contract vis-a-vis the conditions
attached to the credit
Ø
• Once the letter of credit is found satisfactory, the exporter proceeds with the manufacturing or making
arrangement of the shipment for exports
Ø
• Once the shipment has taken place, the exporter will prepare export documents to be presented to the
bank; this will include bills of exchange too
Ø
• These documents alongwith the draft will be submitted to the negotiating bank, who will verify all the
documents with the terms set in the LC
Ø
• The negotiating bank will send these documents, bills of exchange etc. to the foreign bank of the importer.
www.bitbookwala.in
Export Marketing Documents and Procedures 321
SECTION 3:
EXPORTS PROCEDURES
The exports procedures refer to the essential steps involved in registering a firm for exports and imports with
the offices of the Director General of Foreign Trade in India. No activity under the Exim Act for export or import
can be undertaken by any individual or organisation until and unless they have obtained an importer- exporter
code from the offices mentioned above.
www.bitbookwala.in
322 International MarketingText and Cases
d. to get an opportunity to interact with state and central government authorities, exporters and importers
from other countries.
www.bitbookwala.in
Export Marketing Documents and Procedures 323
• Spices Board
• Central Silk Board
• Synthetic & Rayon Textiles Export Promotion Council
• Tea Board
• Tobacco Board
• Wool & Woollens Export Promotion Council
Source: http://exim.indiamart.com/reference-directories/export-promotion-councils-india.html
SECTION 4:
IMPORTANT STEPS IN PROCESSING OF AN EXPORT ORDER
1. Inquiry and Offer The exporter may get an inquiry for exports through the trade promotion councils
or a direct request from the prospective importer from another country. The enquiries will contain information
on the details of products and goods required by the importers from abroad. The inquiry will also specify
complete details of the goods e.g., the volume and the value, the grading, catalogues, sizes , weights, the
international standardisations certificates, the expected time of delivery and the mode of shipment along with
the port of destination etc. BIT BOOK WALA
The exporter can obtain more information on the intended importers through the trade promotional councils,
if required.
He must immediately attend to the enquiry by responding through the email and provide details on products
through literature and catalogues etc.
At the outset, the exporter will have to make his offer to the importer in which he will have to submit his
quotation on a proforma invoice and other relevant details like the products to be supplied, their rates, quantity,
quality, value, details regarding the freight, insurance and other charges. He will also quote the time of payment,
the method of payment if letter of credit needed; the conditions of sale, delivery period and other details on
warranty/inspection, approval by the home authorities, certification by the international standardisation
authorities etc.
2. Acceptance and Confirmation of Purchase Order Once the importer has accepted the
offer made to him, he will have to place an order with the exporter. The negotiation if any will take place before
placing of a confirmed order by the foreign buyer. The exporter on his part will have to confirm the acceptance
of the order by immediately conveying his acceptance in writing. He will have to send a proforma invoice in
triplicate to the buyer and ask him to return two copies duly acknowledged and signed by him so that out of
these two signed copies, one copy can be signed by the exporter too and sent back to the importer buyer. This
will signify the confirmation and acceptance of the order by the exporter too and an international contract for
the export order will become binding between both the parties.
3. Export Sales Contract The confirmation and the acceptance of the offer will result into formation
of an export contract between the exporter and importer. This contract will carry details on the terms and
www.bitbookwala.in
324 International MarketingText and Cases
conditions of the international deal. Although there are no specified rules by any competent authority on the
export contracts, but a normal contract will carry details pertaining to details of goods, their quality and
quantity, price per unit and the total value of the contract, validity of prices, delivery/ shipment periods,
packing and forwarding instructions, inspection if needed, terms of payment, insurances and finally
documents and certificates needed to fulfill the documentary requirements.
4. Export Permissions and Licenses There is freedom to export all items unless these items are
banned or put on the restrictive list for which a license will be required from the competent authority. The
exporter will have to check if he needs to get the license issued for the items for which he has received the export
order.
5. Managing Finances for Exports There are various schemes and finances available for pre-
shipment finances. The exporters can check with the banks and export promotion councils of their respective
products as to how to avail these financial assistances.
7. Reserving Shipping Berth Though the leading shipping companies announce their schedules in
leading media papers and daily shipping intelligence news from time to time but generally the task of booking
berth space for cargo is outsourced by shipping companies to the carrying and forwarding agents (C&F
BIT BOOK WALA
agents). These C&F agents work as commission agents and will reserve the shipping space on a commission.
The exporter needs to get in touch with them immediately after the export order has been confirmed and book
the required shipping berth with the shipping company on the port through which shipment will be taking
place.
8. Packing and Marking The importer will specify in the export contract about the standards and
specifications to be followed for the packing and marking of the goods meant for exports. In the absence of any
such instructions the standard practices prevailing in the industry will have to be followed. The Bureau of
Indian Standards have specified ceratin standards for packing of export items, the exporter can get these details
from the bureau. Similarly Indian Institute of Packaging set up by the government of India in 1966 the requisite
know how on export packing standards and the institute have been advising the exporters on these
developments at the international level. The international institutes e.g. the British Standard Institution and the
standard institutions of many other countries have their own packing standards for different items. In addition
the shipping companies will have their own specifications for the packings that can be accommodated on the
shipping berths. The exporter will have to follow these instructions thoroughly in order to avoid facing
rejections at a later stage.
The standardised international markings will have to be followed in addition to the special marking
instructions given by the importer. Generally these markings will include the private marking of the consigner,
the shipping marking of the consignee, the port of destination, measurements, the country of origin and special
handling instructions if any e.g., fragile, handle with care etc. Besides the exporters can also refer to the
recommendations of various international cargo handlers associations and trade associations to understand
the usage of symbols and markings in use for shipment of export cargo. Organisations like International Cargo
Handling Co-Ordination Association and International Trade Forum have framed certain rules to be followed
www.bitbookwala.in
Export Marketing Documents and Procedures 325
by shippers in this regard. These instructions will help the exporter mark his cargo correctly and in accordance
with the practices prevailing.
9. Preshipment Inspection In order to ensure the exporters from India strictly adhere to the quality
expectations and standards of international trade, the government of India had introduced the Export Quality
Control and Inspection Act in the Year 1963. As per this act certain items meant for exports have been put on
compulsory preinspection list and these items can not be exported unless a certificate of preinspection have
been obtained from the Export Inspection Council of India based in New Delhi or from any of their regional
offices situated in Mumbai, Kolkata, Chennai, Kochi or Ahmedabad. But exemptions are given under some
circumstances.
(i) The Consignment Shipment Under this arrangement every consignment ready for export has to
be compulsoril inspected by the inspectors from the offices of the export inspection agencies and only after
clearance from the EIA the consignment can be sent for shipment.
8. http://www.indiadairy.com/zone_importexport.html
www.bitbookwala.in
326 International Marketing–Text and Cases
(ii) Self Certification Scheme Export houses with star status, public limited companies, large scale
manufacturers, international organisations with manufacturing base in India, manufacturers who have set up
their own research and development units along with the testing facilites are given the authority to self inspect
their products and submit a self declaration certificate of having met the required quality standards. The export
unit or the exporter will have to apply to the Directorate Inspection and Quality Control, New Delhi for the
permission of self certificate scheme.
Exemption from Preshipment Inspection Following categories are exempted from the compulsory
preshipment:
• Holders of ISO900/ BIS14000 or any other international quality certification
• Products with ISI mark given by the Bureau of Indian Standards
• In case the export contract has specifically waived off the inspection clause.
Customs Clearance The exporter will be allowed to ship the export order only after he has obtained
clearance from the port customs authority. Although there are Custom House Agents available at each port
who specialise in documentations for customs clearance, it will be important to understand the procedure and
the documentation involved in customs clearance. The exporter or the CHA* will have to submit the following
documents to the customs authorities at the port of clearance:
1. The shipping bill
2. Declaration regarding truthfulness of the statement made in the shipping bill
3. Invoice
4. GR/SDF form
5. Export License in case of restricted goods being exported
6. Quality control inspection certificate/ self declaration
7. Original contract for exports or the export order
8. Letter of credit if applicable
9. Packing list
10. ARE I form
11. The customs authorities can specify any other relevant document for submission.
(We have discussed in details the purpose of each document in an earlier part of this chapter.)
The customs authorities after verification and scrutiny of all these documents will approve the cargo to be
brought in inside the shed for exports at the port. The shipping bill so approved will have to be presented to the
cargo in charge of the steamship company for allowing the goods meant for exports inside the cargo shed.
* CHA stands for Customs House Agent.
www.bitbookwala.in
Export Marketing Documents and Procedures 327
The customs clearance can be arranged at the factory premises too by making an application to the
Assistant Collector of the Customs of that particular industrial area. Similarly the Inland Container Depots too
have the arrangement of customs clearance at the inland container depots from where the goods can be loaded
into the containers after the verification by the customs authorities. However in both such cases the preventive
officer at the port can inspect the sealed containers before these are allowed to be loaded into the ship.
The government authorities have established Inland Container Depots at the places where there is no
international sea port, ie. in India places like Indore, Nagpur, Tughlakabad (near Delhi), Coimbatore to facilitate
multi-modal transport of export/import cargo in containers. The procedures at an ICD can be specified in a box.
GR/SDF Form
This form contains the following information:
1. Name and address of the exporter alongwith the description of goods
2. Name and address of the authorised dealer (bank) through whom the proceeds against the export
supplies will be realised or have been collected
BIT BOOK WALA
3. The details of the commissions and discounts, incentives to be paid to the foreign agent or buyers
4. The complete breaks up of the full export value e.g., break up of the fob, freight, insurance, discount,
commission etc.
Disposal of GR Form
• The exporter or his CHA will be submitting two copies of the GR form to the customs at the time of
shipment
• The value and the particulars of the goods declared in this GR form will be verified by the customs
• Once the shipment has taken place, the original GR form will be retained by the customs and the
duplicate copy will be handed over to the exporter or his CHA. The original will be forwarded by the
customs to the RBI
• The exporter on his part is under the obligation to submit the duplicate copy of the GR form within 21
days of the shipment, to his authorised dealer (bank).
There are other kinds of forms e.g. Statutory Declaration Form (used at the computerised points), the Softex
Form (used in case of export of computers software etc) and the PP Form (used in case of post parcel exports)
the disposal of which will be as under:
A. Softex Form
It is used in respect of exports of computer software, audio/video television software. Three copies of this form
are submitted to the designated officer of the Departments of Electronics, Government of India, based at the
software technology parks of India, or at the free trade zones, or at the export processing zones. The original
copy after certification will be sent to the office of the Reserve Bank, duplicate returned to the exporter and the
third copy is retained by the electronic authority.
www.bitbookwala.in
328 International MarketingText and Cases
Shipping by Sea
We had noticed earlier that the goods are sent to the port shed after they have been scrutinised by the customs
authorities. The retention of the goods at the port-shed involves payment of various charges which are to be
paid to the port commissioner before goods are allowed to be put on board in the vessel.
Once the Preventive Officer of the Customs Department has given the permission for exports, he will issue
a let ship order. Based on this slip of let ship, endorsement is carried by the preventive officer on the duplicate
copy of the shipping bill. The shipping company or the commander of the ship will permit the loading of the
cargo only on production of the shipping bill along with the let ship slip. The master of the ship will issue a
Mate’s Receipt containing information about the name of the vessel, berth, and date of shipment, description
of packages, marks and number and the condition of the cargo at the time of loading.
Based on the details given in the Mate’s Receipt, two copies of the Bill of Lading will be prepared by the
exporter or his agent. These two copies of the Bill of Lading along with the Mates Receipt will be submitted to
the shipping company. The shipping company will be calculating freight on the basis of the measurements or
weight etc given in the mates receipt. On payment of the freight by the exporter, the shipping company will be
issuing duly signed Bill of Lading to the exporter. This Bill of Lading duly signed by the authorised signatory
of the shipping company, establishes the title to the export goods shipped on the vessel.
We have already given the process of loading the goods at the inland container depots in this chapter in an
earlier section.
www.bitbookwala.in
Export Marketing Documents and Procedures 329
Shipping by Air
Shipping by air is advantageous in many cases where the goods are perishable in nature, or seasonal, are high
in cost and less bulky in nature. The shipment by air can be fast, timely and pilferage and theft free. The detailed
discussion on airway bill has already been done in an earlier section of this chapter.
Shipping by Post
The post parcel can be sent for commercial goods to a foreign buyer. The export of goods by parcel post either
for gift purpose or for meeting the commercial export contract are governed by or regulated by the provisions
of the postal notice no. 13, dated 3rd November 1973. This notice is also reproduced in the Hand Book of Export
Import Procedures published every year by the Ministry of Commerce . The exports by post are also governed
by the foreign trade and foreign trade regulations as in force in the country from time to time. It is for the
exporter to satisfy the legal and statutory provisions of the export post parcel and the post office may not hold
any responsibility even in the eventuality of having accepted a parcel for exports. Such parcel if rejected by the
customs will be confiscated and the contents will not be returned.
Shipping by Land
The procedure for export by land routes are similar to the procedure adopted by the sea route. However the
treatment of form ARE I will be slightly different. The excisable goods will have to be presented to the frontier
customs officer once again and resealed and repacked in the presence of the frontier customs officers.
REFERENCES
1. New EXIM Policy 2002-2007 and Handbook of Procedures, 2002-2007, Ministry of Com-
merce
2. Justin Paul, International Business, Prentice Hall of India, pp. 306-307.
www.bitbookwala.in
330 International MarketingText and Cases
WEBSITES VISITED
1. http://exim.indiamart.com/reference-directories/export-promotion-councils-india.html)
2. http://www.indiadairy.com/zone_importexport.html
3. http://cenexcisenagpur.nic.in/Customs/export.htm
4. http://www.tradeindia.com/Service_Providers/Indianserviceproviders/Consulting/In-
surance
5. https://www.ecgcindia.com/Portal/productnservices/guarantees/postshipmentexport/
postshipment.asp
1. Alan Branch (2000) Export Practices and Management, Thomson Learning – Business
Press.
2. Justin Paul (2007), International Business, 3rd Edition.
www.bitbookwala.in
Export Marketing Documents and Procedures 331
REVIEW QUESTIONS
www.bitbookwala.in
332 International MarketingText and Cases
A. Consular invoice
B. Mates receipt
C. Bill of lading
D. Bill of exchange
E. Parties to a letter of credit
Annexure
www.bitbookwala.in
Export Marketing Documents and Procedures 333
Customs examination of the export cargo and sealing of the containers by the proper officer of the
export shed at ICD, Ajni, Nagpur. The explorer shall be handed over duplicate G.R.I. form which will
subsequently be presented to the Bank by the Exporter.
6. Arrival of Export Goods at ICD,: One copy of the processed Shipping Bill will be presented by
Exporter/CHA to the Shed incharge (Exports) for giving space availability certificate and other
formalities. The CONCOR will thereafter give carting permission on one copy of the Shipping Bill.
The Exporter/CHA after arrival of goods presents Shipping Bill to the Goods Arrival Clerk who will
make necessary entries about the arrival of goods in the register maintained for this purpose. On
receipt of the acknowledgement from the Shed In-charge (Export) that the goods have been re-
ceived in the shed, Shipping Bill will be presented to the Appraiser/Superintendent who will give
examination order on the duplicate copy of the Shipping Bill.
7. Examination–I: On receipt of the Shipping Bill the examining officer in the shed will examine the
goods in presence of the exporter/CHA and will give his examination report. In case of Drawback,
Shipping Bill, samples, whenever necessary, will also be drawn in presence of exporter/his represen-
tative. The examination report will be counter-signed by the Appraiser/Supdt. (Exam) who will also
verify the export value on the G.R.I. form.
8. Examination – II: After examining the stuffing of containers will be done only after obtaining
permission from the Supdt. (Exports) by the Manager, ICD. The stuffing of containers will be done
strictly under Customs supervision and CONCOR/CHA or exporters representative of shipping-
line. The stuffing sheets will then be prepared and signed by the exporter/representative of the
shipping-line and jointly signed by shipping-line and shed in-charge.
9. BIT BOOK WALA
A complete record of number of shut out packages and the quantities of goods loaded will be
recorded on the Shipping Bill after the stuffing of container is done. Thereafter the container will be
duly sealed with Customs OTL (One Time Lock) seal. However, the case of shut out cargo Shipping
Bill will be put up to the Assistant Commissioner of Customs.
10. After the Customs copy of the stuffing sheet is presented to the Supdtt. (Exports) he will give the
“Let Export” order on the duplicate copy of the Shipping Bill as also the transference copies.
Simultaneously with stuffing of the goods in container, exporters will prepare in quadruplicate, the
invoice and container-wise packing list/weight specification indicating inter-alias, the number of
packages with marks and numbers, description and total quantity/net weight packed in each con-
tainer along with corresponding Shipping Bill Number. The Appraiser/Supdtt. will certify these
details on the invoice/packing list. The duplicate copy of the Shipping Bill will be retained in the
ICD, and triplicate handed-over to the exporter. The export promotion copy of the Shipping Bill shall
be handed-over to exporter after “Let Export” order has been given by the Customs Officer and the
container has been sealed. The copy will be suitably endorsed by the Customs Officer to the effect
that the goods will be transshipped at the Gate-way port for their destination outside India.
11. The two transference copies of the Shipping Bills will be placed in a sealed envelope and handed-
over to the CONCOR who will be responsible for producing it along with the container to the
Customs Office at the port of exist.
12. A register in Proforma “C” should be maintained by the custodian for the cargo dispatched from
ICD, Ajni, Nagpur, to the Gate-way (Exit) Port and a copy of thereof submitted to Customs Officer.
13. The factory stuffing of the export containers will be allowed after seeking permission from the
Assistant Commissioner of Customs, ICD, Ajni, Nagpur. In such cases the containers will be
www.bitbookwala.in
334 International MarketingText and Cases
stuffed by the exporters under Central Excise supervision and the containers will be sealed with
punch seals (Lead seals) by Central Excise and forwarded to ICD, Ajni, Nagpur for onward trans-
shipment to the gateway ports. On arrival of the container at ICD, Ajni, Nagpur the goods will not
be done only if the seals of the containers are found to have been tempered with or damaged.
14. At the gateway port the container will normally be allowed to be exported under preventive super-
vision on checking the seals without any further examination. Examination will only be done if the
seals of the containers are found to have been tempered with or damaged or on the basis of any
information, doubt etc. The preventive officer who will be inspecting the container, will suitably
endorse two transference copies of the Shipping Bill regarding the fact of shipment in following
manner:-
i. Inspected & found in tact the container bearing the following marks and numbers :- (1) (2) (3)
ii. The customs seals on the above mentioned containers found in tact.
iii. All the containers mentioned above have been shipped under my supervision.
1. In token of having allowed shipment the Preventive Officer at the Gate-way Port would be
required to put his dated signatures with full name/officer seal.
2. At the port of shipment the steamer agent will also file the export manifest in duplicate.
After the shipment of the goods, the concerned officer must send the transference copies
of the Shipping Bill within 24 hours of loading of the goods to the container unit of the
Export Department.
3. Within 24 hours of receipt of the Shipping Bills the container unit will send a telex regarding
BIT BOOK WALA
the fact of shipment mentioned under (i), (ii) & (iii) above to the ICD, Ajni, Nagpur, giving
reference of the Shipping Bill No. to which it pertains. The Container Unit shall then
dispatch one copy of the transference Shipping Bill and one copy of the export manifest
under registered acknowledgment due to the Assistant Commissioner of Customs, ICD,
Ajni, Nagpur within 48 hours of their receipt.
4. The Assistant Commissioner of the Container Unit of the Gate-way Port will ensure that all
the Shipping Bills and manifests have been duly dispatched to the ICD, Ajni, Nagpur. The
second of the transference shipping bill will be retained by the Customs House at the Gate-
way Port.
5. At the ICD, Ajni, Nagpur the export manifest and transference copy of the Shipping Bill,
received from the Gate-way Port, will be co-related with the duplicate copy of the Shipping
Bill and other relevant documents for closure of export manifest and cancellation of bonds,
if any. The transference copy of Shipping Bill will be sent to the Drawback Section for
further action if it is drawback shipment. If there is no drawback claim, the transference
copy of Shipping Bill will be filed with the parent EGM. Thereafter, the EGM will be closed
after audit.
6. Drawback claims may be filed with the Drawback Section in ICD, Ajni, Nagpur within the
stipulated period and in the prescribed proforma. The claim will be processed preaudited by
the special audit team of the Hqrs. and cheques will be issued at ICD, Ajni, Nagpur.
Source: http://cenexcisenagpur.nic.in/Customs/export.htm
www.bitbookwala.in
Chapter 18
Global Issues:
The Internet and E-Commerce
Learning Objectives
The reader should be able to
• understand the significance of emerging issues in international marketing
• understand how internet acts as catalyst to bring the world economies closer
• understand the concept of global e-commerce.
www.bitbookwala.in
336 International Marketing–Text and Cases
INTRODUCTION
T he Internet and E-commerce are global web and tool that have contributed towards the increase of the
international commerce by storm over the last decade or so. These represent enormous opportunity for
international trade and marketing, because networks are great levelers, easy to enter into countries without
violating the traditional territorial barriers, e.g. air, sea or land. In-fact, they dissolve many long-established
barriers to entry of one nation’s, knowledge, technology, products and services into another. The
technological breakthrough into the fields of tele-communication, transportation, telephony and internet
coupled with the nation’s willingness to open their economy for the new light of international integration
through the World Trade Organization have created a single global market place. The distance holds no
meaning in this kind of economic and geographical scenario. The new evolution of outsourcing have started a
trend of making the best of products and services available to the global customer. The tastes and the
preferences of this global customer are changing equally fast. The discerning customer of the emerging world
today wants his products to be customised in the same manner, as is being done in the factories of the highly
developed and technologically advanced countries of the west.
This has brought a new awakening amongst the manufacturers and the international firms to look for value
innovations across their operations, so that the benefit can be passed on to the customers across the globe.
The international firms today are making the best use of the information and communication technology to
understand this newly emerging market and customer even in low income and middle income countries. The
reach of the manufacturer and the knowledge peddlers have gone beyond the boundaries of traditional urban
markets to explore hitherto untouched potentials of rural and semi rural markets in all countries. We will , in this
BIT BOOK WALA
chapter undertake an in-depth study of these emerging new trends and try to understand how internet
and e-commerce play such a vital role in the new international marketing scenario of business to business,
business to customers , customer to business and consumer to consumer flow of knowledge and commerce.
Internet has brought a revolutionary change in the way communication channels were traditionally being
operated in the world of commerce and trade across the globe. Only a decade ago telegraph and telex were the
main stay of quicker communication in the world and otherwise the distance was traversed through the
traditional means of regular postal services through air, land and sea. The breakthrough into the field of
telecommunications, information technology and the availability of World Wide Web has given a new meaning
to communicating with customers across the globe. The role of marketing stands revised with the opening of
two ways communication channels on the net. The unknown customer across the seas has suddenly gained a
familiar face for all international marketers. The distant and only aspired for products and services have
suddenly come within the reach of the flick of a finger. Such is the power of internet and new communication
technology. International marketing today faces the challenge of feeding the right information to the
enlightened customer, whose knowledge base about the competitive products and services has already been
widened by the storehouse of information available on the global search engines like Google and many others.
Under this kind of highly competitive marketing environment it is obvious that the manufacturer and the
marketer both have to redevise their business strategies.
SECTION 1:
ELIMINATION OF DISTANCE AND TIME ZONES
The emergence of Internet and IT enabled services has led to the death of distance. It has completely eliminated
any kind of distance among the nations. The traditional way of international trading would always prefer
www.bitbookwala.in
Global Issues: The Internet and E-Commerce 337
dealings within the proximity of the neighbourhood to save on the costs incurred on transportation and
communication. Trade blocks of nations had traditionally been formed between the neighbouring countries
only, e.g., Asian countries will prefer dealing within Asia. Europe formed a different trade block and countries
from South America ordinarily preferred dealings within the proximate distance. This distance today holds no
meaning, as the advent of new communication technologies, the speeding up of the air transportation systems
and the spread of knowledge through the web world has eliminated all time gaps from the world map. It is a level
playing field so far as the cost of communication is involved. Setting up a web site either in Europe or in India
can attract almost any numbers of hits. Similarly no additional charge is added to the cost of sending an email
either to the next door neighbour or to the person based in the United States. This has led to proliferation of
trade enquiries for the international marketing firms from all across the world. The smallest firm based in any
remote corner of the world today can display its products on the virtual retail market available on the net and
attract customers of any nationality and segment. The customer too can approach a manufacturer sitting in
another continent and order through the internet and pay for it through the internet by using his credit card.
The IT enabled services have brought in new financial systems too in the world of international trade. The
invoices and billings can be communicated on the net and the instant financial transactions have improved the
bottom lines of many companies across the world.
The email and the internet do not recognise any time zone in their systems and operations. You can have
access to a computer across any time zone and communicate freely. This has increased the possibilities of
rendering services to customers from the long distance outsourced service agencies, which has led to the
availability of hitherto unknown sources of employment in middle income and emerging countries.
www.bitbookwala.in
338 International MarketingText and Cases
scales. The traditional dissimilarities of separate segments are giving way to convergence of market into one
international culture. The concept of segmentation has gone beyond the idea of grouping market into
identifiable segment.
www.bitbookwala.in
Global Issues: The Internet and E-Commerce 339
Source: India’s New Opportunity – 2020, All India Management Association, The Boston Consulting Group, 2003, Pp-19.
www.bitbookwala.in
340 International MarketingText and Cases
information technology amounts for almost half of India’s GDP. The IT enabled services have encouraged
many multinational companies to select India as their hub for support systems. India today provides a number
of IT enabled service in the field of health, tourism, accountancy and manufacturing facilities. According to a
NASSCOM’s and McKinsey’s study, “Indian IT and software sector will account for US $ 70 to 80 billion in
revenues, will employ 4 million people and account for 70% of India’s GDP and 30% of India’s foreign exchange
inflow in the near future”.1
Given hereunder is the list of channels of services where India has shown strategic strength in offering
services to international markets
Emergence of Internet
Internet today is widespread in all spheres of international marketing. It has infact introduced to the world a
new and faster way of conducting business known as E-business or E-commerce. The mobile technology has
further developed a wireless and station free mode of conducting business. The wireless mechanisms have
brought in a new kind of customer empowerment, where he can remain in touch with the supplier and conduct
his business from the offices while on the move. It has done away with the requirements of even having a
specifically earmarked space and place for conducting business. Internet had come into offing in the year 1969,
when the US department of defense had introduced Arpanet , which permitted the transfer of electronic
messages ( email) apart from enabling access to remote computers.2
The initial exposure of the internet has been only for military purposes however in 1992, with the
introduction of World Wide Web by Tim Burners Lee at a European institute in Switzerland by the name of
Conseil European Pour La Recherché Nucleaire (CERN), commercial aspects of internet became known to the
BIT BOOK WALA
world. This protocol for the first time exhibited and permitted the graphic use of information on the internet.
This World Wide Web in a way, gave birth to the current usage of internet and www sites across the world. It
is surprising that while radio and telephone took a long time to connect the world, the internet took hardly five
to seven years to access the current network of internet users in major countries. The speed at which it is
further spreading its wings can be assessed from the figures given below:
1. Source: International Marketing, Rakesh Mohan Joshi, Oxford University Press, Pp 688-689
2. Source: Robert Zakon, Info.Asoc.Org/Guest/Internet/History/Hit.Html # Growth, 29 August, 1999.
www.bitbookwala.in
Global Issues: The Internet and E-Commerce 341
500
400
300
200 399 315
100 233
96 33 19 16
0
Asia
Africa
Europe
North America
Latin America
Australia/Oceania
Middle East
Source: http://www.internetworldstats.com/stats.htm accessed on 10.06.2007.
Region Wise Breakup of Internet Users of the World
It can be observed that the spread has been skewed towards Asia, Europe and North America. The actual
power of internet will be felt when it covers up the remaining countries where the spread of knowledge through
the internet is still a far fetched dream for billions of people.
53.5
Europe 50 38.9
Latin America 40
Asia 30
17.3
Middle East 20 10.7 10
Africa 10 3.6
0
1
Source: http://www.internetworldstats.com/stats.htm accessed on 10.06.2007
But even where the number of internet users have been growing, they may be only a miniscule portion of the
total population. We can see that the number of internet users is the highest in Asia (399millions), however, it
is only 10.7% of the total population. In North America a total of 69.7% of total population has been using
internet. The real power of internet will be unleashed when the low income and the poor underdeveloped
economies too get interlinked with the World Wide Web and make commercial use of the potential.
www.bitbookwala.in
342 International MarketingText and Cases
• Internet The largest computer network in the world which links over 130 million
people in the world. By 2003 this number was projected to grow to 350 million users
in the world. (currently only Asia has 339 million users linked to the internet, and
over 1000 million across the world)
• Intranet A computer network that links users in a single company or organisation.
Access to an intranet is limited to authorised users who are company or organisation
members or employees.
• Extranet A computer network that links authorised users. In contrast to the
internet, it is not open to the general public and in contrast to the intranet it is not
limited to members of a single organisation or a company.
• World Wide Web It makes the internet more accessible and easier to use by non
experts. Technically it is a system of hypermedia linking text, graphics, sounds and
video on computers spread across the globe.
• Portals Context suppliers that attract millions of web users with a wide swath of
information, search services, email and chat rooms.
• Web Browser Software used to navigate the hyperlinks that make up the World
Wide Web.
• Virtual Reality Imaginary worlds created by cutting edge computer technology, for
example by wearing special head sets, consumers might get the idea of walking
through the house and visualising and experiencing the rooms before the house is
actually built.
BIT BOOK WALA
• E-Commerce Selling goods and services over the internet [business to consumer
(B2C), consumer to consumer (C2C) and business to business (B2B)]. This is also
sometimes referred to as E–business.
SECTION 2:
E-COMMERCE
E-commerce is also referred to as e-marketing that permits the marketing and commercial transactions, e.g.,
buying, selling, distributing and collection of data, making payment and collecting information through the
electronic media between the businesses organisations and customers. This model has its base in Electronic
Data Exchange (EDI) where the transfer of standardised data between corporations takes place on the
electronic media. EDI has been further empowered by the emergence of a commercial platform on the internet,
wherein the information on the product, display and demonstration of the virtual product, dialogue,
negotiation and the finalisation of the deals are arranged by the electronic media. The emergence of e-accounts,
e-banking and the prevalence of debit and credit cards have facilitated e-payment systems wherein the
customer does not have to virtually get into any kind of paperwork and the debit and credit transaction takes
place on the net. For example, Rediffbooks.com, amazon.com, Ebay.com and host of other such sites conduct
business on the net where they are interconnected to many of the interlinking associated sites and customer
information on their products, prices discount structures, opinions and purchase experiences are shared
amongst millions of users of the net. The publishers of this book McGraw-Hill publishers too have their own
web site, //www.mcgraw-hill.com/, where thousands of books are offered to the customers on the net.
www.bitbookwala.in
Global Issues: The Internet and E-Commerce 343
Similarly e-Banking is virtually the in thing in many developed and emerging countries. In many countries
many banks have already started the operation of customer accounts through the electronic systems. The
customers can access their bank accounts by the use of a secured password on the internet and conduct
business transactions without visiting a branch of the bank. They can issue payment/ collection instructions
to their bankers, secure information on the bank products and have the information sent to their clients by
using the electronic media.
E-Marketing has opened up altogether new systems of conducting business. The companies can organise
their loyal consumer clubs for chat and discussions on the efficacy and effectiveness of their products. They
can seek the opinions of the users world wide about the new product launches, new technologies and socially
active issues that affect business and trade internationally. But that does not mean the e-marketing is only for
approaching a customer. Infact it is finding more usage in attracting business to business transactions.
Forester Research has found a ratio of 5:1 between business to business and business to consumer.3
Types of E-Commerce Models E-commerce can be categorised into four distinct categories based
on the inter exchange of business transactions followed by each commercial activity undertaken on the net.
Business to Business (B2B) E-Commerce When two or more firms undertake transactions using the
electronic network, it takes the shape of e-marketing or e-commerce. The transactions can be intra-firm or
between the firm and the government agencies, for exchange of information, data, and business deals’ details
on the internet. The electronic process of such business transactions shortens the value chain and results into
cost savings for all the parties involved. It also facilitates a greater exchange of dialogue and deliberations
between two parties as the free flow of information from all corners of the world does encourage a healthier
3. Source: E-bussiness, What Every Business CEO Needs to Know, Business Week, 22nd March 1999, Pp-10.
4. Source: James A. Warholic, Internet Marketing B2B Vs B2C, Comparisons for the Twenty First Century, http://
pwebs.net/marketing/articles/marketing-b2b-b2c.htm.
www.bitbookwala.in
344 International MarketingText and Cases
that are most popular on B2C sales include Amazon.com, Dell Computers, Fiction Publishers and many other
such sites put up by the international manufacturing firms directly. People in foreign countries can buy airline
tickets for travel within the United States on www.priceline.com at competitive prices.
In B2C, customers place a lot of emphasis on price comparisons. Customers go shopping online for the best
price possible. What used to take a customer all day of driving around town, comparing one store’s price with
that of another can now be done in a matter of minutes on the internet, jumping from one website to another or
even having all the websites open at the same time for comparisons.
Some international marketing firms handle both the B2B and the B2C models of e-business. For example
large furniture manufacturers and designer furnishings marketers have online service for both the consumer as
well as the corporate buyer. In this type of model, the firm has to handle both the consumer and business
customers from each one’s own different purchase patterns and preferences. This can affect the handling of
online transactions. Individual consumer most likely would want to handle e-commerce with a credit or debit
card, while the business buyer would probably set up an account with the outlet store to keep the business
relationship flowing.
However, the success parameters and the operational dynamics of the international markets (when exposed
to the online markets) are changing at a very fast pace. In order to respond to those changes an international
marketing firm needs to address marketing on a number of different challenging factors. For the B2B a lot of the
manufacturing process has been outsourced overseas to cost effective viable alternatives. This outsourcing
has caused a number of companies to go out of business in recent years, yet at the same time it has also helped
some of them to implement economies of scale and bounce back into the business with a renewed vigour.
Companies that have weathered all kinds of competition and are prospering are using a number of marketing
BIT BOOK WALA
and advertising means available to them. In order to meet the challenge of some B2B companies staying in
business and reaching prospective clients, the internet and their web site is an ideal key for doing businesses
in the twenty-first century. Likewise, B2C companies need to approach this with ever increasing scrutiny and
promptness. After all, they too need to garnish sales by spending their advertising and marketing budgets
wisely, even an online customer needs to be delighted.
Consumer to Business (C2B) E-Commerce The customer here invites proposals from the sellers
and the suppliers to cater to his needs and requirements. The market dynamics are handled and decided by the
customer rather than by the seller. Large government tenders, turn key projects put up their tenders on the
internet and invite international marketing and contracting firms to put forward their bids. This is like open
tender invitation from the intended participants.
Consumer to Consumer (C2C) E-Commerce The formation of community websites, online inter
trading portals and chat rooms are examples of setting up consumer to consumer business. The portals like
rediff and eBay invite person to person trading offers for new and second hand items for sale on line. The web
site bazee.com is another popular website for individual bargain hunters. These portals encourage consumer to
consumer sale offers on their websites to gain the maximum hits and also to set up a virtual bazaar on their sites.
The items offered may vary from second hand books to designer garments, from mobile phones to motorcycles
and fashion accessories. Every thing is virtually available on the net for consumer to consumer selling.
SECTION 3:
THE COMPONENTS OF E-COMMERCE VALUE CHAIN
Harvard University Professor Michael E. Porter had first used the phrase “value chains” to describe a
management approach to the supply chain. But value chain management also has some analogues to the
www.bitbookwala.in
Global Issues: The Internet and E-Commerce 345
internet. Value chains on the internet can represent the components of any given transaction, where the
customer sits at one end and the product or service sits at the other. The components form the middle of the
route that leads the customer to the end point, defines how value is derived from the transaction and split
among the parties contributing to the chain.
The important value chains on the internet can be named as commerce, connectivity and content. But of
these chains, which pieces are important to the process of e-commerce. Let’s look at the business to consumer
(B2C) commerce value chain. Example of ordering a book online, the ISP Earthlink provides connectivity to the
web, Yahoo! delivers content through a homepage, NetGravity’s ad serving technology delivers the banner
advertisement for bookseller Amazon, Net Perceptions’ predictive collaborative filtering engine recommends a
book, Amazon sells the book and UPS delivers it to the customer.
Given hereunder is a list of the intermediaries that form a value chain on the network to provide special
services to the e-commerce.
• Context suppliers
• Sales agents
• Market developers
• Business processors
• Logistics specialists.
Context Suppliers These are the portals that support the use of electronic way bridge to both the
customer and the supplier to get in touch with each other. Their main task is to provide an electronic platform
that can be accessed by the business channels to put up information about their business on the net for the
BIT BOOK WALA
customers’ benefit. The customer also finds it easier to access the electronic channel by the routes provided by
these portals, ISP Earthlink, America Online, Netscape Communicators, Microsoft Explorer. And the search
engines, e.g. Yahoo, Google and Rediff are some of the major context suppliers.
Sales Agents/Data Providers They are those components of the business to consumer commerce
value chains that own the customer and eyeballs which can be converted into transactions. These agencies
provide value to the e-commerce by providing list of the addresses of the potential customers that can be
approached by the companies on the net. These agents will have complete demographic profiles of the markets
on the net, e.g., the age, income, preferences and other data on the customer. They sell these customer data
banks to the intended advertisers and the product/ service suppliers on the net.
Market Developers The internet market owes a lot to these developers who provide an online exchange
to the customers and sellers. The large number of auction sites, online trading sites and online merchandise
sellers all add up to complete the list of market developers. For instance, ebay.com, philatelic auctioneers,
auction agents for electric power industry, amazon.com, auctionwatch.com and Yahoo! etc get millions of hits
on their sites every day bringing buyers and sellers together to generate e-commerce
Buying Agents They are also known as purchase agents, they act as agents for the customers on line to
find the goods, services they are looking for on the net. Their task is to search the net and find the best deals
and the right prices to the purchasers. For example, priceline.com, eximinfo.net, homes101.net,
thealexanderreport. com, googoochina.com, indospan.net, are some of the sites that bring together the buyers
and sellers on the net and perform the services of on line buying and purchasing agents.
Logistics and Business Processing Specialists Online banking, credit cards and debit cards have
been the main stay of financial transactions on the e-commercial selling. These intermediaries are arranging and
managing the transfer of money to the sellers on a nominal service charge.
www.bitbookwala.in
346 International MarketingText and Cases
Similarly physical distribution of goods has to be handled by the intermediaries who have to raise a bill,
make arrangements for the packing and shipping and finally deliver the ordered goods to the customer on the
addresses provided. A complete chain of international distribution experts and operational back office experts
are interlinked by the net to deliver value to the customer. The Business Process Outsourcing industry has
been fast developing in many countries to attend to and extend support to the logistics and business
processing functioning part of the e-commerce value chain.
REFERENCES
1. President Bill Clinton, Global Issues, October 1997, Volume 2, Number 4.
2. International Marketing, Rakesh Mohan Joshi, Oxford University Press, Pp688-689
3. India’s New Opportunity – 2020, All India Management Association: the Boston Con-
sulting Group, 2003, Pp19.
4. E-BUSINESS, What Every Business CEO Needs to Know, Business Week, 22nd March
1999, Pp10.
5. James A Warholic, “Internet Marketing B2B Vs B2C: Comparisons for the Twenty First
Century.
1. http://usinfo.state.gov/journals/itgic/1097/ijge/ijge1097.htm
2. Info.Asoc.Org/Guest/Internet/History/Hit.Html # Growth,
3. http://www.internetworldstats.com/stats.htm
4. http://pwebs.net/marketing/articles/marketing-b2b-b2c.htm
www.bitbookwala.in
Global Issues: The Internet and E-Commerce 347
www.bitbookwala.in
348 International Marketing–Text and Cases
REVIEW QUESTIONS
EXERCISE
Visit www.skype.com, register online and download the software that can be used for
teleconferences and video conferences. Ask your friends/relative, in a Foreign country to get a
skype id like Arjustinpaul@skype and share the id with you. Both of you should use this for talking
each other and share your experience in the classroom.
www.bitbookwala.in
1
Case Study
www.bitbookwala.in
350 International MarketingText and Cases
olcim, the multinational giant in cement industry, entered into a strategic alliance on 20th January 2005,
H with Gujarat Ambuja Cement to make an entry into the growing and emerging Indian market.
A BRIEF ON HOLCIM
Holcim holds the number two position amongst the leading cement producers of the
world with a turnover of US$ 9.4 billions (2003) and a market capitalisation of US$ 12
billion. It is one of the world’s biggest suppliers of cement, aggregates (gravel and
sand), concrete and construction related services. The group has had a very humble beginning in 1912 in a
remote Swiss village and has ever since covered many milestones to reach the coveted position of being
number two in the world cement industry. The company today has very strong market presence in more than
70 countries the world over through minority or majority stakes.
Value creation is Holcim’s goal. Three distinct strategic thrusts support this goal:
• product focus
• geographic diversification, and
• local management with global standards
All of this rests upon a most important base: the people who work for Holcim. Holcim’s strategy is
characterised by sustainability—in the sense of long-term profitability in harmony with environmental and
social progress.
Holcim’s core competencies are innovative production and marketing of value-adding products and
services. With a market presence in every continent, Holcim is a global company. As part of its growth
BIT BOOK WALA
strategy, the Group has continuously strengthened its position in emerging markets. Around three quarters of
operational capacity is based in emerging markets, accounting for 45.7 percent of the Group’s net sales.
However, Holcim aims to keep a balanced portfolio between developed industrial and emerging high growth
markets.
It was but natural that the emerging economies of India would attract the attention of this global player and
the international giant entered into strategic alliance with Gujarat Ambuja Cement Limited to acquire ACC
Limited, and added the 71st country to its list. We will, through this case, try to understand the implication of
this high profile international foreign direct investment into one of the leading Indian cement companies.
www.bitbookwala.in
International Market Entry of a Foreign MNC in India: The Case of Holcim 351
• Partner with suppliers to deliver value for cost procurement for the group and customers
• Be recognised as an employer of first choice
• Empower our employees and integrate them fully into our global network
• Selectively grow our world wide presence of companies
• Demonstrate our commitment to sustainable development
• Be valued as a trusted partner in our community
• Be the most recommended stock in our industry
HOLCIMS HISTORY
• Founded 1912: Holcim was established as a company in Switzerland.
• 1920: The company tasted international expansion by investing in cement business in other European
countries as also in Egypt, Lebanon and South Africa.
• 1945: Holcim’s network spread into North and Latin America and continued spreading in fifties and
sixties too.
• 1970: The company ventured into emerging markets of Asia Pacific region.
• 1980: This year saw Holcim getting into Eastern Europe.
• 1990: The company increased its focus on core business in cement, concrete, and aggregates. Lead-
ership position attained through, employees’ empowerment, best management policies.
• 2000: Holcim emerged the numero uno in Asian countries too. The name too changed from
Holderbank Financiere Glaris Ltd. to Holcim Ltd.
BIT BOOK WALA
The Deal: Holcim-Gujarat Ambuja Strategic Alliance
True to its trend of growing through acquisitions and participation in the global network of cement
manufacturers, Holcim has been keen to enter into the Indian cement market. The opportunity presented itself
when the board of directors and executive committee of Holcim agreed to get an entry into Indian market
through an alliance with the one of the major cement manufacturers of India, Gujarat Ambuja Cement
Limited. As per this alliance the two signatories to the joint venture will create value addition projects in India
and become common partners to gain long term benefits from the emerging and growing cement and other
aggregates’ market in India. The following are the major features of this alliance:
1. Technical collaboration between a major global group of the status of Holcim and Gujarat Ambuja
Cements Limited in order to encash the local expertise, strong brand presence and sizeable market
share of Gujarat Ambuja Cements Limited
2. Strengthening of the alliance by sharing experience in all areas of cement manufacturing, marketing
and through exchange of managerial and technical talents
3. Strengthening the cement and clinker trading activities in South Asia and the Middle East
4. Using India as an additional base for the IT operations of Holcim and its research and development
projects. India can also be used as a procurement / sourcing hub by Holcim to generate additional
synergies and value for the group.
The Investment Methodology: Holcim enters into an agreement with AIG / GIC, both private
investors to acquire 40% stake of Ambuja Cement India Limited and simultaneously signs a share
www.bitbookwala.in
352 International MarketingText and Cases
subscription agreement with Ambuja Cement Limited that allows Holcim to raise its participation to 67
percent in Ambuja Cements.
As per the understanding of the strategic alliance between Gujarat Ambuja Cements Limited and Holcim,
Ambuja Cement India Limited announces the public purchase offer for acquiring a majority share holding in
the Associated Cement Company Limited (ACC). Through ACIL, Holcim makes an offer of Rs. 370 per
share to the existing shareholders of ACC, with the plans to raise share holding to 50.01 percent. (ACIL,
already owns stakes of 13.8% in ACC.) ACIL also holds 94% shares of Ambuja Cement Limited, a company
that has shown the maximum profits in Indian cement industry in recent years.
Through this arrangement Holcim will be investing a total of US $ 850 millions, financed through internal
accruals, and already established credit sources.
Jammu &
Kashmir
BIT BOOK WALA
Punjab
Himachal Pradesh Arunachal Pradesh
Meghalaya
Chandigarh Uttarachal Assam
Haryana Sikkim
Delhi Bihar
Uttar
Rajasthan Nagaland
Pradesh
Manipur
Gujarat Madhya Pradesh Tripura
Mijoram
West Bengal
Maharashtra Jharkhand
Orissa
Andhra Pradesh
Goa
Chhattisgarh
Karnataka
Nadu
Padicherry
Andaman & Niocobar
Kerala
l
Tami
www.bitbookwala.in
International Market Entry of a Foreign MNC in India: The Case of Holcim 353
growth ever since the economy opened itself to international participation and the CAGR of 7 to 8 percent in
this sector is likely to continue for some more years to come.
Besides, the Indian cement industry offers a major cost advantage as compared to the industry in other
parts of the world. Over the years it has introduced major technological upgradation. The consolidation of
Indian cement industry into the controls of a limited number of players has further added to the strengthening
of the volumes profitability in the business. Today Indian cement industry is better placed in terms of
profitability as compared to the other cement manufacturers of the world.
Given below is the comparative statement of the operating profitability of some of the top cement
manufacturers of the world.
www.bitbookwala.in
354 International MarketingText and Cases
the existing CAGR of 8 percent per annum. The development and modernisation of four international air-
ports, sea ports, rail roads, power plants all will boost the demand for cement.
Developing Housing Sector The Indian housing sector has witnessed unprecedented boom in its
growth rate due to burgeoning population, attractive interest rates and customer friendly schemes offered by
the banking sector. The tax sops and incentives offered by Government policy further attract new investments
in housing sector. The Housing Finance Ministry estimates show a growth of 50% per annum for the next
three years in the housing sector with latent demand of 33 million houses in this period. This unprecedented
boom will generate demand for cement all across the country.
Liberal Fiscal Policies Sales tax incentives, exemptions, tax free periods are offered by the state
governments to attract location of plants in their respective states. The government import / export policy too
offers incentives in the shape of duty draw backs on imports of coal, furnace oil etc., to encourage imports and
exports of cement. The laws related to urban land ceiling are also being relaxed in many states to make land
available for housing projects.
www.bitbookwala.in
International Market Entry of a Foreign MNC in India: The Case of Holcim 355
ACC’s marketing, sales and distribution processes are of best industry standards. It has been the major
supplier to some of India’s most admired projects; ACC is essentially a people’s brand of cement with more
than 80 percent of sales made through an extensive dealer network that covers every state in India. Its
customer base represents the masses of India - individual homebuilders in small towns, rural and semi-urban
India. ACC cement enjoys an image of assuring consistency and of high quality backed by in-house research
and expertise.
Complementing this is a unique customer services cell comprising qualified civil engineers, who assist and
advice customers with prior and post sales service. This service begins with selection of type and grade of
cement (where applicable) to troubleshooting and on-site assistance.
ACC manufactures the various kinds of portland cement for general construction and special applications.
In addition to this, ACC offers two value added products namely, Bulk Cement and Ready Mix Concrete.5
REFERENCES
1. The Times of India, Mumbai.
2. The Economic Times, Mumbai
3. Business Standard, Ahmedabad.
4. Cement Manufacturers’ Associations’ Reports.
1. http://www.holcim.com
2. http://www.cmaindia.org/industry.html
3. http://www.gujaratambuja.com/index1.html#.
4. http://www.business-standard.com/common/storypage
5. http://www.acclimited.com/newsite/products.asp
REVIEW QUESTIONS
5. http://www.acclimited.com/newsite/products.asp
www.bitbookwala.in
BIT BOOK WALA
www.bitbookwala.in
Case Study 2
Logistics Solutions in
Information Technology
Business–Approach to
International Distribution &
Supply Chain Management
www.bitbookwala.in
358 International MarketingText and Cases
Profit after Taxation PAT from India operations have grown from Rs. 149.16 million in 2003-2004
to Rs. 291.20 million in 2005-2006 with a CAGR of 39.72 percent.
www.bitbookwala.in
Logistics Solutions in Information Technology Business 359
expectations. This industry is witnessing growth fuelled by investment in the IT and ITES sector, increasing
the need for automation and information technology in all industries, an increase in communication and
computing infrastructure spending and greater internet usage. In this scenario companies providing IT
distribution services have tremendous scope to grow as IT distributors play a key role in providing supply
chain services to enable the movement of technology products, solutions, and after sales service from the
vendors of the product to the end users of these products; the products include PCs, servers, notebooks,
printers, and PC components, networking products, software products and license, storage products, power
solutions, and mobile devices.
The solutions are based on the integration of multiple products and technologies from several
manufacturers with services in the form of installations and configuration or customisation to cater to the
unique needs of the customers. The after sales services include installation, warranty support, post warranty
support, maintenance contract, reverse logistics activities etc. apart from distributors, other entities like
resellers, solutions providers, system assemblers, system integrators, and retailers form part of the IT
industry’s distribution channels.
www.bitbookwala.in
360 International MarketingText and Cases
vendor, assuring the buyers genuine quality. The company is able to make the parts available in the shortest
possible lead time due to its large network of offices and warehouses. The company uses customised
forecasting techniques as the failure patterns are unpredictable.
Redington’s second area of focus is the upgrades and service sales. In the business of upgradation the
requirements of parts can be safely predicted. That simplifies the management of inventories. The company
sells packaged services, specialty tailored to suit the customers after sales service requirements.
Redington’s revenue models are both event based and annuity based. The event based model is as per the
repair based model where the service provider is compensated by the vendor for every customer request for
service during the warranty period. In the same way any repair out of warranty is also event based. Redington
earned 32.66 percent of its total revenue in the year 2006, from event based model.
The annuity based model of after sales service contributed 17.54 percent of its total revenues in the year
2006. This included service provided to the outsourcing requirements of vendors serviced by the company.
Annual maintenance contract is another form of annuity service model where the customer enters into the
maintenance contract with the company for extended period after the warranty period provided by the original
vendor has expired. Redington earned 16.55 percent of its revenues for the year 2006 from annual
maintenance contracts.
WEBSITES VISITED
1. http://www.redingtonindia.com/history.asp
2. http://www.dqindia.com/content/
3. http://www.blonnet.com/i
4. http://www.channeltimes.com
5. http://www.dqchannels.com
www.bitbookwala.in
Logistics Solutions in Information Technology Business 361
REVIEW QUESTIONS
1. Carry out a survey on the internet to identify at least five major IT distributors in India
who play a key role in providing supply chain services to enable the movement of tech-
nology products, solutions, and after sales service from the international vendors of the
product to the end users of these products.
2. What are the forward and reverse parts logistics? How has Redington been able to
implement the system successfully?
3. From the above article identify three core services models that Redington provides to
customers.
www.bitbookwala.in
BIT BOOK WALA
www.bitbookwala.in
Case Study 3
www.bitbookwala.in
364 International MarketingText and Cases
HISTORY OF COMPANY
WIPRO, the short form has been derived from The Western India Vegetable Products Company which
was founded in early 1950s basically to manufacture and market vegetable cooking oil. The transition of The
Western India Vegetable Products Company to Wipro is an interesting journey and through this case study we
will have a brief look into the Wipro fact file to understand how it moved from a regional company to an
international giant in a short span of 35 to 40 years. The reigns of the company had been inherited by Mr. Aziz
Premji from his father in 1966. The company continued making inroads into the vegetable oil business for
almost a decade in his guidance and leadership. However a decision to venture into computers hardware in
1981 and into software in the year 1984 changed the entire direction of the business Wipro had to handle in
future. This, infact, was the time when international computer giant IBM had been asked to move out of India.
www.bitbookwala.in
Internationalisation of Wipro Technologies 365
2. IT Services
Wipro’s complete range of IT Services addresses the needs of both technology and business requirements to
help organisations leverage leading-edge technologies for business improvement. Wipro takes charge of the
www.bitbookwala.in
366 International MarketingText and Cases
IT needs of the entire enterprise. The range of its services extends from Enterprise Application Development
and Maintenance, Architecture Consulting, Business Process Management, Content Management, etc. These
services stretch across sectors like finance and banking, insurance, to health, utilities, government and
hospitality.
www.bitbookwala.in
Internationalisation of Wipro Technologies 367
Europe
Asia pacific
Middle East
also has a strong presence in Melbourne, in Shanghai, in Tokyo, and in Taiwan. Its location in Dubai provides
it with a strategic benefit of growing substantially as and when the trade barriers in Middle East fall.
Wipro has won a global service contract with GM which is designed to integrate the company’s
Middleware Systems and Information Systems and Services Software Tools around the world. The five-year
March 2004 Focus on innovation “Innovation Is Wipro, Wipro Is Innovation”. The company crossed
one billion mark in annualised revenues. Revenues of foreign exchange Rs. 38,357 millions, a jump of 33%
over last year.
March 2005 Company highlights the social responsibility of a corporate. “Practicing Values to Create
Values” is the theme of the year; revenues for the year Rs. 73,267 millions, a growth of 39 percent and gives
a profit after tax of Rs. 14,948 millions, a steep jump of 63 percent over last year. Impressive foreign
exchange earnings additional growth of 40% over last year added Rs. 53,736 millions to the company’s
earnings.
www.bitbookwala.in
368 International MarketingText and Cases
REFERENCES
1. Wipro Annual Reports for 2003, 2004, and 2005.
2. Business India Magazine.
3. Business Standard, Ahmedabad.
WEBSITES VISITED
1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wipro
2. http://www.wipro.com/webpages/itservi
3. http://qualityconsulting.wipro.com/continuousimprovement.php
4. http://www.ciol.com/content/news/
5. http://www.indiadaily.com/editoria
6. http://cities.expressindia.com/fullstory
www.bitbookwala.in
Objective Type Questions
Section I: True/False
State if the following sentences are true or false.
1. The major objectives of WTO agreement on agriculture is to make policies more market oriented (T/F).
2. The agreement on TRIMs applies only to measures that affect trade in goods (T/F).
3. Foreign Institutional Investors (FIIs) are allowed to invest in non-listed companies (T/F).
4. Quantitative Restrictions (QRs) refer to limits set to curb imports (or exports) (T/F).
5. High Uncertainty Avoidance ranking indicates that the country has high tolerance for uncertainty and
ambiguity (T/F).
6. Women may not wait for a man to offer his hand first in a Muslim country, if a Western handshake is
going to be used (T/F).
7. According to Porter, a nation does not attain a competitive advantage just because its firms are
competitive (T/F).
BIT BOOK WALA
8. Countries with a short-run outlook and strategy will tend to be less competitive in industries where
investment is short term (T/F).
9. An international acquisition makes the acquired local firm a subsidiary business within its global
portfolio (T/F).
10. In the right circumstances, the presence of foreign firms reduces market concentration and promotes a
more competitive market structure (T/F).
11. The term “core competencies” refers to the processes within the firm that competitors cannot easily
match or imitate (T/F).
12. McDonald’s is a good example of a firm that has grown by using licensing strategy (T/F).
13. A joint venture (JV) is a strategic alliance between two or more parties to undertake economic activity
together (T/F).
14. A subsidiary may itself have subsidiaries, and these, in turn, may have subsidiaries of its own (T/F).
15. Formation of export consortia type of cooperative marketing groups disables the individual firms to
take advantage of joint marketing efforts, joint marketing research and joint shipments (T/F).
16. In the cost and freight (C&F) type of pricing system, any insurance of the goods up to the point of
unloading or discharge is the responsibility of the exporter/seller (T/F).
17. Proforma invoice is a proforma of the invoice prepared by an exporter and sent to the importer for
necessary acceptance (T/F).
18. The consular invoice is an important document, which needs to be submitted for certification to the
embassy of concerned country, and is applicable to all the countries (T/F).
19. Globalisation is a reversal phenomenon (T/F).
www.bitbookwala.in
370 International MarketingText and Cases
www.bitbookwala.in
Objective Type Questions 371
6. India has been instrumental in setting up SAARC, whose major achievement in 1995 was the conclu-
sion of the negotiations on trade preferences within the framework of the SAPTA. SAPTA is an
abbreviation for
(a) South Asian Preferential Trading Agreement
(b) South Asian Preferential Trading Arrangement
(c) SAARC Preferential Trading Arrangement
(d) SAARC Preferential Trading Agreement
(e) None of the above
7. Dr Geert Hofstede conducted perhaps the most comprehensive study of how values in the work place
are influenced by culture. The study initially was done to develop a model, which comprised of four
primary dimensions. Later he added a fifth dimension i.e. long term orientation (LTO). LTO explains us
the extent to which a society exhibits a pragmatic future oriented perspective rather than a conven-
tional historic or short-term point of view. Countries scoring high on this dimension are
(a) Western Countries (b) North European Countries
(c) America (d) Asian Countries
(e) None of the above
8. Non-verbal communication can be called the Silent language. It has following dimensions:
(a) space (b) friendship
(c) time (d) business agreements
(e) all above
BIT BOOK WALA
9. Handshake is an important mode of greetings. The style of handshaking however, differs from country
to country. A firm handshake has been traditionally used as mutual exchange of greetings, in the
following country/countries:
(a) US and Europe (b) Japan
(c) None of the above
10. The doctrine of one of the theories of 16th and 17th centuries of international trade advocates that
countries should simultaneously encourage exports and discourage imports. Which theory are we
talking about?
(a) Theory of Absolute Advantage (b) Theory of Comparative Advantage
(c) Heckscher-Ohlin Theory (d) Theory of Mercantilism
(e) None of the above
11. Porters Diamond Model for the Competitive Advantage of Nations, talks about four attributes. Identify
as to which of the following attributes does not form part of the Porter’s Model.
(a) factor conditions (b) supply conditions
(c) demand conditions (d) firm strategy, structure and rivalry
(e) related and supporting industries
12. FDI occurs when a company invests in real state in a foreign country to produce or to market a product.
According to US department of Commerce, foreign investment is considered as FDI whenever an
organisation takes an interest of
(a) 5% or more in a foreign company (b) 10% or more in a foreign company
(c) 15% or more in a foreign company (d) 20% or more in a foreign company
(e) Any percentage
www.bitbookwala.in
372 International MarketingText and Cases
13. The factor that determines whether a company has to invest abroad in the form of FDI is
(a) Cost of transportation (b) Strategic rivalry
(c) Product Life Cycle (d) Location
(e) All above
14. The product Life Cycle Theory was developed by
(a) John Dunning (b) Raymond Vernon
(c) F.T. Knicker Bocker (d) Michael Porter
(e) None of the above
15. The FDI investments in developing countries are governed by various factors, which can very well be
called determinants of FDI. These determinants are related to
(a) laws and regulations of the country
(b) general business environment and administrative procedures
(c) resource cost structure
(d) cultural ties between two-party countries
(e) all above
16. FDI helps the host country in
(a) building or expanding procurement network
(b) building or expanding marketing network
(c) increasing foreign exchange earnings
(d) reducing the risk sharing in comparison to foreign debt
(e) all above BIT BOOK WALA
17. Transnational Strategy for competing in the international market, has a distinct disadvantage that
(a) It does not exploit experience curve location economies effects
(b) It is not customised to local responsiveness
(c) It does not reap the benefits of global learning
(d) It is difficult to implement due to organisational problems
(e) None of the above
18. The firms that pursue transnational strategy for entry maintain the following in respect of flow of
offerings pertaining to skills and product
(a) flow of competencies from home to foreign subsidiaries
(b) flow of competencies from foreign subsidiary to home country
(c) flow of competencies from foreign subsidiary to foreign subsidiary
(d) all above
(e) non of the above
19. Strategic Planning for relating to the future is conducted at the highest levels of management and deals
with the following
(a) product (b) capital
(c) research (d) long and short term goals.
(e) all above
20. The major problems in going global for business are:
(a) non-exploitation of economies of scale in production due to labor and transportation of raw
materials and finished goods
www.bitbookwala.in
Objective Type Questions 373
(b) unifying of product development, purchasing and supply activities across countries will result in
varied quality due to cultural differences
(c) problems of coordination and integrating marketing activities and transfer of experience and
know-how due to variations in the local rules and policies
(d) diversity of markets due to variations in the tastes and preferences
(e) none of the above
21. The major difference between licensing and franchising is that
(a) licensing is explicitly applicable to manufacturing firms and franchising to service sector firms
(b) licensing involves large capital outlays while franchising does not involve capital at all
(c) licensing relates to rights pertaining to trade mark, patent, use of technological designs, etc. while
franchising provides no rights at all
(d) licensing gives total freedom of management to licensee, while franchiser retains the control over
operations of the franchisee
(e) none of the above
22. Which of the following is not a disadvantage in respect of turnkey projects be?
(a) no long-term interest in the foreign country
(b) may create a competitor
(c) selling process technology may be selling competitive advantage as well
(d) amount of risk in relation to FDI
(e) none of the above
23. BIT BOOK WALA
The following is the common reason for companies having foreign subsidiaries:
(a) risk management (b) as a result of acquisition
(c) regulation or licensing (d) taxation
(e) none of the above
24. The following is not a form of direct exporting:
(a) domestic based export department (b) domestic based export merchant
(c) overseas sales branch (d) traveling export sales representative
(e) foreign based distributors
25. The following is a form of joint venturing:
(a) licensing (b) international franchising
(c) contract manufacturing (d) joint ownership
(e) all above
26. The following is not true in respect of IEC number:
(a) IEC number is the first and a must for the exporters and importers
(b) It is a permanent number and has no expiry date
(c) It is valid for both export and import
(d) It is valid for all products
(e) IEC is of 10 digits and a letter suffix
27. Which of the following is not a correct definition?
(a) Issuing bank is one that issues the credit i.e. LC.
(b) Advising bank is the one which advises the credit to the beneficiary.
(c) Nominate bank is the bank nominated by the applicant to receive the payment.
www.bitbookwala.in
374 International MarketingText and Cases
(d) Confirming bank adds guarantee to the credit opened by another bank.
(e) Reimbursing bank authorises to honor the reimbursement claim in settlement of negotiation/
acceptance/payment lodged with it.
28. Globalisation in today’s scenario means
(a) removal of restrictions on foreign trade
(b) benefits to a country in terms of capital, technology and skilled labor
(c) Small industries can trade internationally
(d) All the above
29. The outcome of globalisation is
(a) price hike
(b) quality of product and services declines
(c) Customers enjoy competitive price
(d) Methodology of reaching the customer becomes difficult
30. India’s approach towards FDI is
(a) optimistic (b) liberal
(c) pessimistic (d) stringent
31. WTO stands for
(a) commanding prices of goods at its’ own choice
(b) lobbying commercial interests
(c) free trade and fair trade
www.bitbookwala.in
Objective Type Questions 375
www.bitbookwala.in
376 International MarketingText and Cases
(c) in which parties agree to create a new entity by contributing equity and share revenue, expenses
and control of the enterprise
(d) a company controlled by another
50. Letter of credit is
(a) arrangement of making payments against cash/cheque
(b) undertaking of customer
(c) undertaking of bank to make payment on behalf of an importer
(d) undertaking of third party for payment
51. ______ is document issued by shipping company which acknowledges receipts of goods mentioned
in the bill for shipment:
(a) bill of exchange (b) airway bill
(c) shipping bill (d) bill of lading
www.bitbookwala.in
Index
B D
Bill of Exchange 316, 317 Data Interchange 265
Bill of lading 316, 329, 331, 332 Direct Marketing 13, 16, 272, 275
Body Language 110 Distance Selling Directive 278
Bureau of Quality Standards 210
Business process outsourcing 11
BIT BOOK WALA Documents 313, 316, 329
Domestication 137, 143, 144
Dumping 30, 34, 234, 245, 247
C Duties and tariffs 239
Casteism 101, 102
Certificate of Origin 314 E
Civil Law 147, 157 E-Commerce 63, 265, 342, 343, 344, 347, 348
Code law 147, 157 English common law 147
Collective programming 100 Enterprise Resource Planning 265
Collectivism 108 Exchange Rates 240
Commercial Documents 313 Excise Clearance 326
Commercial Launching 207 Expatriate 5, 99, 124, 279, 285, 286, 290, 292, 293, 294,
Common Law 147, 157, 158 295, 296, 297, 298, 307
Communism 101, 129, 130 Expatriates 121, 290, 291, 295, 303
Conciliation 157 Export Houses 252
Consignment 325
Consumerism 101 F
Contract Law 148 Femininity 108
Corporations 128, 176, 252 Franchisees 255
Cost-based Pricing 224 Free trade zones 307
Counter trade 242, 247, 248
Countervailing duties 247 G
Country of origin 218 Generalised System of Preference 314
www.bitbookwala.in
378 Index
www.bitbookwala.in
Index 379
www.bitbookwala.in
BIT BOOK WALA
www.bitbookwala.in