we ;I

rrr I

y
I
I lP J { . 1 0
-10-12
 r7

Ref. no . 171 /20 05

1
,•6 • •
.,t·tttnirnt of Shri Parv~en l(uin·\r D .
• ., • . • . ngg a 1 s/o Lat e Shr ·
. , f' ,,n1 .Jalandhar ( Re ran for c
cro ss ex•ll . .• Bh ·h· . ,
_ . • (, ,
1nmatton) on SA.
, 0
l us d,l h.u mar t ; •j f))!;,

\ \ _\ . \ x
. Cro ss Exa 1ni nat ion by Shr i Sud hir s-,ti · .
\; 1 l ,-
. 1 • n.' not bro ugh t the ori gin al oi' Ex.P-3
1 1.1 • • • • , ...,..._
. Nei the r l had b h h
. c of mv exa 1n1 nat 1on 1n chi ef. I can pro .,.._ c rou g tt esameon ➔ - 12-12 .itth t
run ~ . duc e the s·:tme lt • . . ..
is falls and fab nca ted doc un1 ent s. I rec ' · 1s wro ng to sugg est th at I.\. P-3
eiv ed the cha rge sheet dated I l-9 -200~ L, . :il
onu
with this ann cxu rc A & B. ~~~ ~~~-- is
the pho to copy of the tele gram . Ex . \1X3 tht
km:~
n:ccived fro m enq uir y off ice r. E_~_ : MX . 4 is the copy of the tele gram I haYe se nt. Ex .
is the copy of the tel egr am wh ich ·~-· ···-•--~-~ \ l.\.5
I hav e sen t to K. Shiv l(um ar. I hav e not n·ni
Y 1.:d \d tt- r
dat ed 2-t- 9-2 003 . (A djo urn me nt is req ues
ted by AR of the wor kma n fur th~r LT IJ :- ~ l · \-
e\a min atio n def err ed.

J.s. Kt..fs<1di\
Presi ~ ~ Ofli:: er,
. s --.
District & es::i i0 l''·(, Ju ,l 2"' I

Ind ust rial Tribu n~\ .

Ja\andhar s-1- 13
 Ref. No. 1 71/2005

of Sh. Parveen Kun1ar Duggal ( Re-call fo fi

F~d_ suitement
1 r urther cross exam. .
· / ~~ / ,· ' Ination afternc
• [1/! f ·.

,xx
xxxx,,
sss:<,' ' · . incon-ect that Ex. Mx. l___!_ was sent by
It IS . d . . me to the managem t . .
. Ex Mx.12 (ObJecte to) 1s the leave appl" t· en as 1t IS i.e. ~
orrectJOn. . -----· . ica rnn send by me t th
c 1"' is a telegram received by me. I don't remember th t I h . o e management.]
-x
I a ave received e · f
tvfx. -'
"' 11.2003 mark Mx.4 along with enclosure E M 14 . nquiry o ficer let
date 1-'· · · x. x. (Objected to) is AD d .
·s my name and address but same is not signed b...__ I d- , car whi
bem . Y me. on t know that the
I signed by anyone form my family. E~. M:X-J 5 is letter dated Nil send by me to th same may
· ffi Id , · e manageme
with copy to enquiry O icer. on t remember that I have received · f:c:
. enqmry o 11cer letter dat(
26.12.2003 mark ~:-~ along with enclosure. Ex. Mx.16 (Obiected to) · AD d .
- - ~ --
0
J• •·--- , ~ IS· car which bea
~ · -

my name and address but same is not signed by me or anybody from my famjly. I don
remember that I have re_ceived enquiry officer letter dated 6.1.2004 mark Mx.6 along wi 1
enclosure. Ex. ~~- -1_? (Objected to) is AD card which bears my name and addre;s b~t same is nc
signed by ..--m e or anybody from my family. I received Ex.Mx.18 (Objected to) letter date
6.1.2004 from the management. I don't rememberthatT have received enquiry officer lettc
dated 28.1.2004 mark Iy.fx. 7 along with enclosure. E~.:Mx.J.~is the letter dated 16-1-2004 sent b
me to the n1anagement. I don't remember that I have received enquiry officer letter date
6.2.2004 mark MX-8. Ex. Mx. 20 is the letter fax by me through my computer. Ex. Mx.
21 (Objected to f "pl~~to copy of letter dated 21-6-2004 sent by management to me alongwit
eiiq~y report dated 10.6.2004. Ex. Mx-22 is the fax copy of my comments dated_ 14.7.2004 o
enquiry report. Ex. Mx-23 is photo c~py ofdismissal letter dated 21 July 2004 r~ceived by ~1e.
. . ~-·--··"-~--:-~ est that in the charge sheet I was given oppo1iumty to submit m
It IS Incorrect to sugg · . . •ti th haroe sheet date
t tl1 t I received Annexme wi 1 e c t:,
explanation. It is incorrect to sugges a
11.9.2003. ( Further cross exan1ination deferred)

J.S.
Presidi ~ fficer,
(Distri & Sessions Judge)
Ind •trial Tribunal,
Jalandhar/4-4-13
 ,·.x·xx xxx
£\ PX! certified copy of Ex. P3 was applied by mv advo
.. fi t I
ca e. cannot say that Ex p . . fi
I copy and not Ex. P3 has iled by me earlier. It is Jincorrect
. f k
dated 24-9-2003 o . n1ar - MX .
from K. Shiv Kumar ~1 had
t
o sugg
tt 1
est that I had
. x is a res
recei ved Jett
I had sent registered letter dated 11-10-2003 Ex. Mx. . sen e egram Ex MX6 (Ob" d e
7 ( Obie t d t ) h · ' _~ecte to
• • J c e O , 1 ave not receiv
dated 16.10. 2003 mark-Mx-1. It 1s mco rrect to suggest that I had ed Jette
. . . · d
from enqmry Officer along with its enclosure. I had sent receive 1etter mark-Mx l
letter Ex.Mx.8 to enquiry Officer
(Objected to). I have not received letter dated 13-11-20
03 mark Mx. 2 from enquiry Officer. It i~
incoITect to suggest that I had received letter mark -Mx2
from enquiry Officer along with it~
enclosure. Ex. Mx .9 (Ob jecte d to) which is the A.D. card
of mark Mx.2 which does not bear m\
signatures. It is inco rrec t to sugge:,t that Ex. Mx. 9 bear my
signatures . I had sent letter dated 18-
11-2003 to enquiry offic er Ex. Mx.1 0(Objected to) volu
nteer the word " back!' hand wTitten in
Para- 2 of this letter was not written by me. It is incoITect
to suggest that I had written the said
word. I had not rece ived the letter dated 26-11 -2003 from
the enquiry officer mark ivh.3 . I do
not remember that my lette r Ex. MX.10 to the enquiry offic
er was in reply to which lett~r of him.
It is correct that my lette r Ex. Mx.10 is in reply to enquiry offic
er letter mar~ Mx. 2. It_ 1~ co:rect_
that I had rece ived enqu iry offic er letter mar k Mx. 2' I teer I had received enqmn officer
vo un . ·
. 1 ,-,
letter mark Mx. 2 with out docu men ts and its enc o.,ure. E Mx-1 l(Objected to) is t1e 1 rep 1y to
x. · . . 0 5 of this
the charge shee t date d 11.9.2003 sent by me to the man aaem
0
ent, volun tee1 al pace
. .d h t done b)r me. ( further cross
documents at line no.4 , and para-8, as erase d by wiute flm as no l

examination defe rred )

Presid n fleer,
(Distric Sessions Judge)
Indus ial Tribunal,
Jal dhar/4-4-13
 Ref. No.171/05

ww1
Statement of Praveen Kumar Duggal , workman, recalled for further cro ss
.nation, on SA.
exa ml

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

It is c52.rrect that after,,£ond~_~tin~ the enquiry into the charge sheet dated 9.9.02, 1
was offered letter of suspension dat~d 25 .7.03 by w~y of ·punis·h-men t on th ; ba~;; of
• • '•1<1 -
' - - - -- - • - --- , _,,.. •'

gnthe
outcome ?.f the_inq~iry. !he same is Ex.MX 25. Volunteered I was forced tosT
-----------~- - "==~:::::$":S.:=-~
_ _ __ _ _ ,...n,r~.,...,._. It is correct that I challenged the
abvoesaid punishment letter which is Ex.MX25.
_ _ ...______ -~..........: . - . ; - - f ~ - - -

letter of suspension Ex.MX 25 before Labour Authorities, Jalandhar . It is correct th at

the above ciTsp~ite raised by rne was referred to Industrial Tribunal Chandiga rh ~I " I

- . - -· - . - ~

clo-nof remember that it was numbered as Reference No.82 /2004 before the
Tribunal . An award was passed by Industrial Tribunal, Chandigarh in the above
reference. I don't re member the date of award. I can not say it was 21.12.06 ...The
•
award was answered against the workman but the same was on technical grounds. I
am not 'ln possession 'of't·h-~-~;py~f ~~id-~·~;~d- ~ight ~~~ It i~ ncorrect that I am
deposing falsely .

RO&AC

Pri siding Officer,

---
ndustrial Tribunal,
Jaland

Dated : 17.5.13.
 ,.

,
l ; -

~ ri, -- - .
l - -;- ;; ;f· ,-;-;:~-,: -
;___J
. ·:, ,,_. ··-
'
--:-· .
 ,

r· ~

r , d

c _. c.., ;'°r ? v
/
f. c• ,....
I I
,..
Cl

) )
,
-.

r r " / .' r•

,,

I I/
. •I

\
.
) f .J J
\,
, /
\ ' )

I
I
I
 I 1 . •
• . r

~}l t,~
j '

Ji1?-~J

:·;.;1 1~ ?H t"' , l( ') )

"-
,

Bi fur M,.,V '

i; c 'i-G ·. - - .
4 0 9 / 0 3 fi-f3't 2 1 - s - 3
~-
..... ) r Y l) lc f
?iaa

~ ~- ? t ~ tT 'c l
roa d3 "431f~u y8Qc< I
IT..T H- Ola Hot Yr1
1

) ).
X )( ] r id m

uf3»fr ~ ) ) 8 egR3 ~
I ~
~:J ~
u.uWo fi )~ . ·
 --- / .' I i \ -,
r I/ 7/1,,
/ --'-~

ic
~ n
L
~ 171/ 200 5

' :::,. +::-r-r-

t H 3 ~ i:l
1 ' -R~
Y } f l ~ 1r1::51 2 9-3- 2017 -fuB tfB 7)T cx13 m, "t f t Fcx c. fu;: :~"
12 »B 1S Ho I H I c: cJ
~ 7-,!+ ~~ ~ -. -
t~c.;.; ~ ~c-..:- -:.
, '
'
.., . fjdG a ""' ~ .p_,_.,_ '--, A--.-;..
o' .r.:: +!--,. " "
I 1-1~G
~ "t 6(d H ,~ti t=rt; 'go'
.g_...._.,. 1
11:u aR7) r101 10( 1--@ I q(")'G
~R 1J-1<c

fa H" ~ ~ ~ He Hr-a- a~ Yr{T ~ Y}-\TQ o( d~ I el ~ fuR ~ tR3 '~ Mai1 ;~ C ' ::-~ C-, :-
rr 1 ~ 3 ~ -P-.. ~ :3-=r· (~~
Lllc.J( ")' -dt ~ ¢5 1 el M 3) YX1irM t't arm ~ tr lrF. o:,-:~- t ; '-
i d i rni
~A
1<:::cJ dlM--r
cff05 -.-r-.-r 1...J 10( FT'-l v\ no1

Sc51" ~ I f2u arc:5 dlM 3 ~ fu t( ~ ~J t fu3t fr I

It
-~
~ ~ »G t:!§H3 ~I ~tTT3 ~
lf(P?)off r,R:;"fl J '
ru ~RZc]T},{0) fc;ru ~ _.., ,') ,
;:r~ra"/ 30. o~..1'.I