The document describes several barriers to effective supply chain management in healthcare systems, including competing priorities for overworked health center staff, difficulty accessing remote communities, lack of community engagement, and unfavorable pricing in the private sector. It then lists corresponding promising practices to help address each barrier, such as performance-based financing, community-based distribution, increasing community participation, and subsidizing underutilized commodities.
The document describes several barriers to effective supply chain management in healthcare systems, including competing priorities for overworked health center staff, difficulty accessing remote communities, lack of community engagement, and unfavorable pricing in the private sector. It then lists corresponding promising practices to help address each barrier, such as performance-based financing, community-based distribution, increasing community participation, and subsidizing underutilized commodities.
The document describes several barriers to effective supply chain management in healthcare systems, including competing priorities for overworked health center staff, difficulty accessing remote communities, lack of community engagement, and unfavorable pricing in the private sector. It then lists corresponding promising practices to help address each barrier, such as performance-based financing, community-based distribution, increasing community participation, and subsidizing underutilized commodities.
health center staff Health workers in low- and middle-income countries are often overworked and under-resourced. Health workers are often responsible for multiple jobs, including clinical care, reporting, ordering and managing commodities, and cleaning and maintenance of equipment and the facility. Performance- based financing at the SDP Difficulty accessing hard-toreach communities For individuals living in remote and rural areas, the time, money, and effort it takes to reach the nearest health facility may be prohibitive and limit access to care. Community-based distribution Subsidizing underutilized commodities Lack of community engagement Inadequate information provided to the community on service delivery and product availability issues, leading to low or nonexistent community engagement and limited accountability. Increase community participation in service delivery accountability Unfavorable pricing for the private sector Private sector entities face challenges when trying to supply products at a price that is affordable for the consumer while still profitable for the entity. This is sometimes exacerbated in an environment where the public sector secures donated commodities and provides products at no cost. Barriers Description Promising Practice(s) that Address the Barriers: Delayed, inaccurate, and incomplete data Data that are not accessible for decision making within a reasonable timeframe after collection will not reflect current levels of need or supply. Inaccurate data may lead to under- or overestimating commodity needs. Incomplete data means that guesswork must be used to determine the current level of need or supply. Focused data collection Use information and communications technology (ICT) tools for data collection and management System design to improve data quality and use Insufficient use of data for decision making Data are often collected, but are rarely used to the fullest extent possible in decision making. Exacerbating the problem is the over-collection of unnecessary data. Not only does this use up valuable personnel time, it makes it difficult to see and understand the data that are actually important for decision making. Streamlining data collection activities to focus only on data that will be used helps address this barrier. Focused data collection Create and use a logistics information portal Use information and communications technology (ICT) tools for data collection and management Insufficient human resource capacity for appropriate data collection and use Human resource limitations at all levels of the system significantly impact data management. Inadequate training, incentives, and feedback result in poor data collection quality and inadequate use throughout the supply chain. System design to improve data quality Incentivize data completeness and accuracy Lack of easily accessible and shareable information In many locations, there is a wealth of data collected. Too often, data are inaccessible because: they are paper-based; decision makers are located far away; the data are locked up in a secure setting; or the data are located on a computer to which few people have access. Use ICT tools for data collection and management Create and use a logistics information port
Initial and recurring costs: Adoption of ICT
tools involves upfront costs to purchase and install equipment, procure software licenses, as needed, migrate data from the current system, and provide user training. Ongoing operational costs should also be taken into account, including maintenance and repair of equipment, support for applications, user help desk, anti-malware software for computers, recurring charges for communications services (both wired and cellular), and refresher training. The effort and cost needed to define and apply an organizational policy regarding misuse or loss of equipment should also be considered.
Barriers Description Promising Practice(s)
that Address the Barriers Lack of training and capacity in SCM Health personnel often have inadequate training (or sometimes no training) to prepare them for the logistics tasks they are expected to perform. Dedicated logistics personnel Increased SCM capacity for health personnel at the service delivery point Outdated or nonexistent standard operating procedures In many places, standard operating procedures for SCM are outdated or non- existent. This problem occurs at all level of the health system. Furthermore, job descriptions of health personnel often do not include logistics tasks. Create and use systematic HR plans and policies to support SCM Performance management and supportive supervision for supply chain activities Lack of a systematic approach to HR for SCM HRH and supply chain planning often lie in separate silos, lacking a coordinated, systematic approach to HR for SCM. Create and use systematic HR plans and policies to support SCM Lack of performance support and motivation for logistics tasks Overburdened and under- resourced staff are often unsupported and unmotivated to perform logistics tasks. Supervision methods that exist are often performed sporadically and/or focus on clinical duties only, ignoring SCM. Performance management and supportive supervision for supply chain activities High staff turnover and mobility High staff turnover and mobility of health personnel cause barriers to keeping staff trained and experienced in required logistics tasks. Dedicated logistics personnel Increased SCM capacity for health personnel at the service delivery point High workload among health personnel Many countries have human resources shortages among health workers increasing the number of patients each provider sees and their workload. Dedicated logistics personnel
International Code of Practice for Planning, Commissioning and Providing Technology Enabled Care Services: A Quality Framework for Procurement and Provision of Services