Professional Documents
Culture Documents
https://doi.org/10.1093/pnasnexus/pgad170
Advance access publication 20 June 2023
Research Report
Abstract
The expanding field of precision gene editing using CRISPR/Cas9 has demonstrated its potential as a transformative technology in the
treatment of various diseases. However, whether this genome-editing tool could be used to modify neural circuits in the central
nervous system (CNS), which are implicated in complex behavioral traits, remains uncertain. In this study, we demonstrate the
feasibility of noninvasive, intranasal delivery of adeno-associated virus serotype 9 (AAV9) vectors containing CRISPR/Cas9 cargo
within the CNS resulting in modification of the HTR2A receptor gene. In vitro, exposure to primary mouse cortical neurons to AAV9
vectors targeting the HT2RA gene led to a concentration-dependent decrease in spontaneous electrical activity following
multielectrode array (MEA) analysis. In vivo, at 5 weeks postintranasal delivery in mice, analysis of brain samples revealed single base
pair deletions and nonsense mutations, leading to an 8.46-fold reduction in mRNA expression and a corresponding 68% decrease in
the 5HT-2A receptor staining. Our findings also demonstrate a significant decrease in anxiety-like behavior in treated mice. This study
constitutes the first successful demonstration of a noninvasive CRISPR/Cas9 delivery platform, capable of bypassing the blood–brain
barrier and enabling modulation of neuronal 5HT-2A receptor pathways. The results of this study targeting the HTR2A gene provide a
foundation for the development of innovative therapeutic strategies for a broad range of neurological disorders, including anxiety,
depression, attentional deficits, and cognitive dysfunction.
Significance Statement
Current therapies for anxiety and depression rely heavily on selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors that may impact numerous sero
tonergic receptor pathways, are fraught with side effects, and require daily dosing. Herein, we employed precision gene targeting to
selectively knockdown the 5HT-2A receptor, one of the 15 serotonin receptor subtypes known to play a key role in anxiety and depres
sion. To accomplish this goal, we used a noninvasive, intranasal delivery platform consisting of two adeno-associated virus (AAV) vec
tors containing plasmids for CRISPR/Cas9 and guide RNA, respectively, to knockdown the 5HT-2A receptors in anatomical and
functional connectomes implicated in both anxiety and depression. Our results indicated administered AAV–CRISPR–Cas9 significant
ly reduced anxiety, thus demonstrating that complex behavioral traits can be directly modified long-term through genetic editing.
Introduction
any specific DNA sequence in the genome. Once double-strand
CRISPR is a powerful tool that has the potential to revolutionize
breaks are generated, the DNA is repaired by either nonhomolo
genomic engineering by potentially treating various diseases (1).
gous end joining (NHEJ) or homologous-directed repair (HDR)
The CRISPR/Cas9 system consists of two parts: the Cas9 protein pathways that induce insertions or deletions (indels) at the target
which is the nuclease capable of inducing double-strand DNA site (2). Dozens of human clinical trials are currently underway
breaks and the guide RNA (gRNA) which is designed to target using the CRISPR/Cas system, including those for sickle cell
Competing Interest: J.L.M. and D.R. are cofounders of Cognigenics and members of its scientific advisory board and hold equity in the
company. T.T.R. is a part-time consultant serving as Director of Preclinical Research at Cognigenics and, in addition to receiving a sal
ary, owns shares of the company’s common stock and options for common shares. J.H.F. is a part-time consultant serving as Chief
Science Officer at Cognigenics, Inc., and is a member of its scientific advisory board. In addition to receiving a salary, he owns shares
of the company’s common stock. He is the inventor of a patent application entitled “Systems and Methods for an Intranasal Drug
Delivery System.” All other authors declare no competing interests.
Received: March 4, 2023. Accepted: May 15, 2023
© The Author(s) 2023. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of National Academy of Sciences. This is an Open Access article
distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits
unrestricted reuse, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
2 | PNAS Nexus, 2023, Vol. 2, No. 6
anemia and several forms of cancer (3). Despite the medical prom have been modified after a gRNA/Cas9-mediated cut to DNA
ise of CRISPR, the use of this system in treating central nervous strands (15). Briefly, following preparation of genomic DNA, amp
system (CNS) disorders is challenged by the noninvasive delivery lification of the target site by PCR was carried out using designed
across the blood–brain barrier (BBB). It has been estimated that primers on either side of the target sequence: Htr2A LF1:
more than 98% of small-molecule drugs and nearly 100% of large- TGACTCGCTAGTCTCTCCACAC and HTr2A LR1:
molecule drugs, such as the CRISPR/Cas9 system, are precluded GCTTCCCATGGAGGGTGG. Following amplification, T7E1 digests
from drug delivery to the brain as a result of the BBB (4). Efforts were performed to detect potential mismatches at the target
to overcome this hurdle include the use of adeno-associated viral site. In silico design and in vitro validation of gRNA as well as
(AAV) vectors, such as AAV9, due to their ability to deliver stable, spCas9 cutting efficiency was performed by Mirimus Inc.
long-lasting transgene expression in nondividing cells (5). (Brooklyn, NY).
However, even this platform has been met with limited success
in penetrating the BBB (6). Validation of gRNA in mouse embryonic stem
In the present study, we investigated whether intranasal deliv cells and generation of F0 founder knockout mice
cortical neurons was based on the multiplicity of infection (MOI), libitum. Mice were given at least 1-week acclimatation to the ani
which refers to the number of viral particles per cell. Three differ mal facility before starting any experimental procedures.
ent MOI concentrations were used: 2 × 105 (which is equivalent to
a total number of viral particles of 1 × 1011), 2 × 104, and 2 × 103
(Table 1). Control neurons received vehicle (40 µL of saline) Test formulation and intranasal administration
equivalent to the volume of fluid given at each MOI. Treatment The AAV-treated group consisted of an equal mixture of AAV9–
was done in triplicate. Treatment occurred on day 6 for 24 h at gRNA–U6–GFP and AAV9–Mecp2–spCas9 suspended in 0.9%
37°C at which time the media was replaced with fresh, complete NaCl (saline). The concentration of AAV9 stock mixture was
media. MEA analysis was then performed on day 14. Primary ∼5.0 × 1012 GC/mL for mice tested in the light–dark and marble
mouse cortical neuron cultures and MEA analysis were performed burying test, respectively. For each behavioral test, a new, inde
by Creative Biolabs (Shirley, NY). pendent batch of AAV9 vectors was synthesized and prepared ac
cordingly. The AAV cocktail was administered twice on day 1
Animals for light–dark and marble burying tests (morning and afternoon) 5 weeks before the behavioral tests. For
All animal care and experimental procedures were performed in intranasal delivery of AVV, mice were hand-restrained with the
accordance with institutional guidelines and were conducted in nose positioned to facilitate the dosing. A meniscus of AAV solu
compliance with French Animal Health Regulation, at Neurofit tion droplet (10 µL per nostril) was then formed at the tip of the
SAS (Illkirch, France). Male CD-1 mice, 4–5 weeks old, were ob micropipette and presented for inhalation in each of the nares
tained from Janvier (Le Genest St Isle, France), and group-housed of the mouse. Each mouse received a total of 40 µL of AAVs
five or six per cage in a temperature-controlled room (21–22°C) equivalent to ∼2 × 1011 viral particles (vehicle-treated animals re
with a light–dark cycle (12 h/12 h; lights on: 5:30 PM–5:30 AM; ceived 40 µL of saline for each treatment following the same
lights off: 5:30 AM–5:30 PM) with food and water available ad protocol).
4 | PNAS Nexus, 2023, Vol. 2, No. 6
Table 1. Experimental setup for treating primary mouse cortical acclimate. Mice were placed in the center of the EPM facing the
neurons with CRISPR/Cas9 cargo, in vitro. closed arm for a 5-min run. All animals were tested once. The
number of entries in the closed and open arms was automatically
Group AAV9 mixture (µL) Saline (µL) MOI
recorded by a computer, and the EPM was thoroughly cleaned
A 40 — 2 × 105 after each mouse. Testing was conducted at week 5 of intranasal
B 4 36 2 × 104
dosing as described above, with each mouse (n = 15) receiving a to
C 0.4 39.6 2 × 103
D — 40 0 tal of 40 µL of AAVs equivalent to ∼2 × 1011 viral particles.
Vehicle-treated animals (n = 15) received 40 µL of saline for each
treatment following the same protocol. Treatment and EPM be
havioral analyses were performed by PsychoGenics (Paramus,
Light–dark behavioral test NJ). The behavioral tests were conducted according to established
In this task, mice were given a choice between exploring a brightly protocols approved by the PsychoGenic’s IACUC committee and
lit chamber or a dark chamber; anxious mice will spend more time their standard operation procedures (SOP).
The elevated plus maze (EPM) has two opposite open arms and
two closed arms. Mice will sometimes explore and spend time in Quantitative real-time qPCR
the open arms, but anxious mice tend to first enter and spend Total RNA was extracted from frozen brains using a standard ex
most of the test time in the closed arms. The maze (Hamilton traction protocol with TRIzol, dissolved in diethylpyrocarbonate-
Kinder) consists of two closed arms (14.5 h × 5 w × 35 cm length) treated deionized water, and quantified. Following reverse tran
and two open arms (6 w × 35 l cm) forming a cross, with a square scription, qPCR was carried out using the following primers:
center platform (6 × 6 cm). All visible surfaces are made of black Primer-F: 5′-AGAGGAGCCACACAGGTCTC-3′ and Primer-R:
acrylic. Each arm of the maze is placed on a support column 5′-ACGACAGTTGTCAATAAAGCAG-3′. The relative expression
56 cm above the floor. Antistatic black vinyl curtains (7′ tall) sur was determined by calculating the 2−ΔCt value. The 2−ΔΔCt value
round the EPM to make a 5′×5″ enclosure. Animals are brought was calculated and normalized to calculate a fold difference be
into the experimental room at least 1 h before the test to tween the two vehicle controls and AAV9-treated groups. The
6 | PNAS Nexus, 2023, Vol. 2, No. 6
RNA extraction and qPCR were performed by Creative Biogene would insert two stop codons in the first coding exon (Fig. 1A).
(Shirley, NY, USA). This system requires HDR, a process that mainly occurs in the S
and G2 phases of the cell cycle and is thought to rarely take place
Targeted region sequencing in mature neurons (20). However, a recent study has demon
To identify potential CRISPR/Cas9 mutations in primary mouse strated virus-mediated HDR gene editing by CRISPR/Cas9 in post
cortical neurons and treated mouse brain samples, NGS was per mitotic neurons (21). In this study, the authors used a dual AAV9
formed of PCR targeted amplicons as previously described (18). system to demonstrate HDR-mediated genome editing with
Briefly, following genomic DNA isolation, PCR was used with CRISPR/Cas9 in postmitotic neurons in the adult mouse brain
site-specific primers to amplify the target region. Primers used (21). Therefore, we used a similar approach to test this as a pos
were the following [length: 149 bp; sgRNA: 57–79 bp (italicized); sible gene editing pathway.
PAM: 77–79 bp (in bold)]: If HDR-mediated insertion of the SS ODN sequence does not oc
cur, it is still possible to produce potential genomic changes in
postmitotic neurons by random indels induced by Cas9 cleavage
Htr2a-TRS-F1: 5′-CATGGAAATTCTCTGTGAAGAC-3′
MeCP2 (AAV9–Mecp2–spCas9–sPA). This promoter was chosen mixture of AAV9(1) and (2) vectors (final concentration of mix
due to its small size (229 bp), thus allowing for packaging in the ture was ∼2.0 × 1011 viral particles) resulted in widespread ex
AAV9(1) vector. The second vector contained the gRNA sequence pression of GFP/gRNA throughout the CNS including the
together with the knockin SS ODN under the U6 promoter (AAV9– olfactory bulb, cortex, and subcortical areas including the inter
GFP–U6–mHtr2a–gRNA–ssODN). This AAV9 vector also contained peduncular nucleus (IPN) (Fig. 3), a major connectome for
the GFP reporter gene to provide a visual proxy of gRNA expres stress-mediated pathways (31). In all in vivo experiments, mice
sion. Typical viral titers were on the order of 2.0×1013 GC/mL. were treated intranasally on day 1, and immunofluorescent de
tection of GFP/gRNA was undertaken 5 weeks later. This concen
AAV exposure of primary mouse cortical neurons tration of AAV9 vectors and the time point chosen were based
with Cas9 DNA and a HTR2A-targeting gRNA on a previous study examining neonatal intracerebroventricular
leads a decrease in spontaneous electrical activity injection of AAV9 (32).
5HT-2A receptor protein expression. gRNA expression was visual Intranasal AAV delivery of copackaged Cas9 DNA
ized by GFP fluorescence while 5HT-2A receptor labeling was and a HTR2A-targeting gRNA decreases anxiety
accomplished utilizing an antibody previously demonstrated Decades of research has supported the role of serotonin in
to be highly specific for the mouse 5HT-2A receptor (34). stress-associated neurocircuitry and therapeutics such as the se
Colocalization of gRNA/GFP together with 5HT-2A receptor fluor lective 5-HT uptake inhibitors (SSIRs) that down-regulate or other
escence was evident throughout the CNS including layers I–III of compounds that block serotonin receptors, as used in the treat
the cortex (Fig. 4D–F), the Purkinje cell layer of the cerebellum ment of anxiety disorders (36–41). The serotonin receptor most
(Fig. 4J–L), and subcortical areas including within pontine gray nu likely mediating anxiety is the 5HT-2A receptor, which is upregu
clei (Fig. 4P–R). While strong 5HT-2A receptor labeling was evident lated by various stressors (42). Conversely, anxiety is reduced in
in vehicle controls in these regions, in AAV-treated mice, staining 5HT-2A receptor knockout mice (9, 10). We propose that the fore
appeared to be less robust (Fig. 4). As expected, there was little brain circuits underlying the potential anxiolytic effects of
evidence of GFP (gRNA) staining in vehicle control mice. In 5HT-2A receptor knockdown involve key nodal points in overlap
ping functions related to the generation and entrainment of circa
AAV-treated mice, GFP (gRNA) labeling was strongest in the cell
dian rhythms, the limbic cortices implicated in the etiology of
bodies of neurons, and when colocalized with 5HT-2A in
anxiety, and the monoamine and thalamic nuclei interconnected
AAV-treated mice, staining of 5HT-2A appeared weaker in the
with these limbic and circadian systems (43, 44). These ventral
cell bodies with some labeling still apparent within apical den
primarily limbic structures extend from the anterior hypothal
drites. ImageJ quantification indicated a significant 68% decrease
amus to the midbrain and pons and include connections with
in 5HT-2A receptor fluorescence of AAV-treated mice as com the limbic cortices such as the orbital insular and hippocampal–
pared with vehicle controls (Fig. 4S), P = 0.0026. These results amygdala cortices with rich connections to the epithalamic
can be interpreted to suggest that treatment of the copackaged structures such as the medial and lateral habenula as well as
spCas9 DNA and a Htr2A-targeting gRNA led to a decrease in the substantia nigra and ventral tegmental area, the raphe nuclei,
5HT-2A receptor staining. Importantly, knockdown of the and nearby locus coeruleus region (45). The locus coeruleus path
5HT-2A occurred in brain regions linked to anxiety-mediated way includes areas implicated in stress including the habenula
pathways including the IPN (31) and pontine gray nuclei (35). and the IPN (44).Therefore, we tested whether codelivery of Cas9
Rohn et al. | 9
DNA and a Htr2a-targeting gRNA could decrease anxiety in mice 5-week trial (P = 0.569) (Fig. 5C), suggesting there were no major
using two well-characterized behavioral tests: marble burying off-target edits in critical genes.
(46) and light–dark box (47, 48). The light/dark box test is also a well-characterized method for
The marble burying test is used to record the number of mar evaluating the relative anxiety status of mice (47). The light/dark
bles buried by mice placed in a novel environment. The theoretic paradigm in mice is based on a conflict between the innate aver
al basis for marble burying as an anxiety-related behavior stems sion to brightly illuminated areas and the spontaneous explora
from findings that it is reduced by anxiolytics/SSRIs and from tory activity. If given a choice, mice prefer the dark box and
the well-documented innate response of mice to bury threating anxiolytic compounds have been found to increase the total dur
objects (49, 50). Results for 5-week AAV-treated mice indicated a ation of time spent in the lit area as well as the number of entries
14.8% decrease in the number of marbles buried compared with into the lit box area (48). AAV-treated mice led to a significant in
vehicle controls (N = 30, P = 0.0008) (Fig. 5A). Similar results were crease compared with vehicle controls in the time spent in the lit
obtained following a doubling of the dose at 7 weeks post treat box (35.7% increase, P = 0.024), the number of entries into the lit
ment (N = 15, P = 0.013) (Fig. 5B). Following treatment of mice box (27.5% increase, P = 0.024), and total locomotion within the
with copackaged Cas9 DNA and gRNA on day 1, there were no re lit box (27.8%, P = 0.049) (Fig. 5D–F). A regression analysis between
ported observational differences in behavior of mice and treated total 5HT-2A receptor protein fluorescence and time spent in the
mice did not differ significantly in weight at the end of the lit box indicated a moderate negative linear correlation (r = −0.55)
10 | PNAS Nexus, 2023, Vol. 2, No. 6
(Fig. 5G). For context, we compared these results with the acute ef copackaged Cas9 DNA and a Htr2a-targeting gRNA significantly
fects of diazepam (1 mg/kg p.o., 1 h). As shown in Fig. 5, AAV treat decreased anxiety and performed on par with the benzodiazepine,
ment led to comparative results to diazepam in the time spent in diazepam.
the lit box (35.7% versus 40%) (Fig. 5H), with diazepam outper We also tested the ability of the designed CRISPR/Cas9 cargo to
forming AAV-treated mice in the number of entries into the lit decrease anxiety utilizing the EPM test, a common test used to
box (27.5% versus 55%) (Fig. 5I). Thus, intranasal AAV delivery of evaluate anxiety in rodents (51). In this case, a different species
Rohn et al. | 11
of mice was tested (C57Bl/6J); otherwise, identical treating proto improved efficacy could be obtained by increasing the directional
cols were employed. At 5 weeks postdosing, mice exhibited a sig flow of cargo following intranasal delivery. Techniques that could
nificant 24% decrease in the number of entries into the closed arm be applied in this manner include pulsed ultrasound and trans
(Fig. 5J) (P = 0.017). In addition, the AAV-treated cohort resulted in cranial magnetic stimulation (57, 58). Delivery within the CNS
less distance traveled into closed arms (P = 0.032). There was no was accomplished using a noninvasive intranasal delivery plat
significant difference between the two groups in the number of form that can bypass the BBB, typically a major hurdle for large
entries into the open arm (P = 0.50) (Fig. 5K). A documented 17% cargo such as CRISPR/Cas9. Our delivery platform of CRISPR/
increase in the time spent in open arms was observed; however, Cas9 and proof-of-concept results indicate that certain traits
this did not reach statistical significance due to the large variance can be directly modified long-term, and that this has important
observed in the AAV-treated group (P = 0.257) (Fig. 5L). There implications for the next generation of psychotropic medications.
were no significant differences in weight between the two groups Specifically, precision targeting of the 5HT-2A receptor by CRISPR/
(P = 0.183). Cas9 gene editing may provide a new direction for patients who
Finally, to test whether the designed CRISPR/Cas9 cargode exhibit treatment-resistant anxiety or depression (13, 14).
8 Celada P, Puig M, Amargos-Bosch M, Adell A, Artigas F. 2004. The 29 Scranton RA, Fletcher L, Sprague S, Jimenez DF, Digicaylioglu M.
therapeutic role of 5-HT1A and 5-HT2A receptors in depression. J 2011. The rostral migratory stream plays a key role in intranasal
Psychiatry Neurosci. 29(4):252–265. delivery of drugs into the CNS. PLoS One 6(4):e18711.
9 Jaggar M, Weisstaub N, Gingrich JA, Vaidya VA. 2017. 5-HT2A re 30 Tuszynski MH, et al. 2005. A phase 1 clinical trial of nerve growth
ceptor deficiency alters the metabolic and transcriptional, but factor gene therapy for Alzheimer disease. Nat Med. 11(5):
not the behavioral, consequences of chronic unpredictable 551–555.
stress. Neurobiol Stress. 7:89–102. 31 Sherafat Y, et al. 2020. The interpeduncular-ventral hippocam
10 Weisstaub NV, et al. 2006. Cortical 5-HT2A receptor signaling pus pathway mediates active stress coping and natural reward.
modulates anxiety-like behaviors in mice. Science 313(5786): eNeuro 7(6):ENEURO.0191-20.2020.
536–540. 32 Hana S, et al. 2021. Highly efficient neuronal gene knockout in
11 Liu B, Liu J, Wang M, Zhang Y, Li L. 2017. From serotonin to neuro vivo by CRISPR-Cas9 via neonatal intracerebroventricular injec
plasticity: evolvement of theories for major depressive disorder. tion of AAV in mice. Gene Ther. 28(10–11):646–658.
Front Cell Neurosci. 11:305. 33 Zhang N, Roberts HM, Van Eck J, Martin GB. 2020. Generation and
48 Rosso M, et al. 2022. Reliability of common mouse behavioural 53 Can A, et al. 2012. The tail suspension test. J Vis Exp. (59): e3769.
tests of anxiety: a systematic review and meta-analysis on the ef doi: 10.3791/3769.
fects of anxiolytics. Neurosci Biobehav Rev. 143:104928. 54 Cryan JF, Markou A, Lucki I. 2002. Assessing antidepressant ac
49 Taylor GT, Lerch S, Chourbaji S. 2017. Marble burying as compul tivity in rodents: recent developments and future needs. Trends
sive behaviors in male and female mice. Acta Neurobiol Exp Pharmacol Sci. 23(5):238–245.
(Wars). 77(3):254–260. 55 Organization WH. 2022. COVID-19 pandemic triggers 25% in
50 Li X, Morrow D, Witkin JM. 2006. Decreases in nestlet shredding crease in prevalence of anxiety and depression worldwide.
of mice by serotonin uptake inhibitors: comparison with marble 56 Bystritsky A. 2006. Treatment-resistant anxiety disorders. Mol
burying. Life Sci. 78(17):1933–1939. Psychiatry. 11(9):805–814.
51 Komada M, Takao K, Miyakawa T. 2008. Elevated plus maze for 57 Ye D, Chen H. 2022. Focused ultrasound-mediated intranasal
mice. J Vis Exp. (22): e1088, doi:10.3791/1088 brain drug delivery technique (FUSIN). Methods Mol Biol. 2394:
52 Cryan JF, Mombereau C, Vassout A. 2005. The tail suspension test 501–513.
as a model for assessing antidepressant activity: review of 58 Vejdani Afkham B, et al. 2022. Investigation of how stimulation