Republic of the Philippines

Department of Agriculture
ADJUDICATION COMMITTEE
Fisheries Building Complex, BPI Compound,Visayas Ave., Quezon City

24th REGULAR MEETING OF THE ADJUDICATION COMMITTEE

Venue: Orchard Hotel, Baguio City
July 19-22, 2022

PROGRAM OF ACTIVITIES

DATE TIME ACTIVITY RESOURCE PERSON

July 19
Arrival of the Participants
July 20- 8:30AM-
Registration Secretariat
21 9:00AM
9:01AM- Preliminaries
AVP
9:05AM Prayer
National Anthem
BFAR Hymn
9:06AM- Secretariat
Roll Call
9:10AM
Committee
Declaration of Quorum
Presentation of the Proposed
Agenda
PROPOSED AGENDA

1. Review of the Minutes of the 23rd Regular Meeting of the Adjudication Committee
2. Matters Arising from the Previous Meeting
a. Report on the status of Administrative Case No. ADM-RO5-2021-054, entitled PNP
Bulan, Sorsogon versus Jaime Gipa of FBca Crissualyn.
3. Deliberation of Cases
No. Case Docket Case Title Handling Hearing Remarks
Officer
1 OTS-CO-2022- BFAR CO represented by Rommel Atty. Remle Anne M. 3rd offense
0027 Adolf I. Diciano v. Wilfredo C. Almario Estacio
(Owner) of "FBca Wilissa"
2 OTS-R06-2022- Capiz Maritime Police Station Atty. Paul Andre R. 3rd offense
0087 represented by PLT John D Delgado v. Margarico
Noriel F. Araiz (Boat Owner), Rogelio
B. Lacrete (Boat Captain) of "FB
Krezielle"
3 OTS-R06-2022- Capiz Maritime Police Station Atty. Paul Andre R. 3rd offense
0112 represented by PLT John D. Delgado Margarico
v. Leo M. Bonapus (Boat Owner)
represented by Jubilee V. Bonapus,
Crosene R. Roco (boat captain), and
Chirex S. Dequina (boat mechanic) of
"Fbca Sunshine"
4 ADM-R07- BFAR VII v. Ricardo Pestaño et al. Atty. Mary Rose C. Motion for
2019-002 Lituañas Reconsideration
5 ADM-CARAGA- BFAR 13 represented by FIRO1 John Atty. Joana S. Motion for
2020-0008 Rey Elifane and FIRO1 Jovery G. Gordonas & Atty. Reconsideration
Clapano v. Jonathan Julius Roy Tizon Annaliza A. Vitug
6 ADM-R08- PNP MG Calbayog City represented Atty. Kim Marie R. Motion for
2020-004 by PSSg. German R. Monsanto and Pat Babiano & Atty. Reconsideration
Virgilio A. Galvez v. Lyn P. Atega (boat Annaliza A. Vitug
owner) and Marvin B. Rivero (boat
captain) of an Unmarked Fishing
Vessel

7 ADM-R08- PNP MG Calbayog City represented

2020-005 by PSSg. German R. Monsanto and Pat
 Virgilio A. Galvez v. Omar G. Argenio
and Roselle P. Elcarte
8 ADM-R08- PNP MG Calbayog City represented
2020-006 by PSSg. German R. Monsanto and Pat
Virgilio A. Galvez v. Ariel R. Atega
(boat owner) and Jimmy Boy
Alejandre (boat captain) of an
Unmarked Fishing Vessel
9 ADJ-RO7-2018- Unecias Gentapa vs. Marcelo Deligero Atty. Madeleine Motion for
011 Andrea T. Pia Reconsideration
10 ADM-RO5- BFAR 05 represented by Jorge T. Atty. Madeleine Motion for
2021-016 Camacho, PFO Catanduanes vs. Andrea T. Pia Reconsideration
Teddy Delos Santos
11 ADM-CO-2022- BFARCO represented by Rommel Atty. Madeleine
001 Adolf I. Diciano vs. Arnulfo G. Singca, Andrea T. Pia
Mica by the Sea
12 ADM-RO5- BFAR RO5 represented by Team Atty. Hilario U. de
2022-001 ADM- Leader RFO-1 Roel L. Marbella vs. los Santos
RO5-2022-002 Diego B. Barranda "FBca Sta
Teresita 1"
13 BFAR RO5 represented by Team
Leader, FRO -1 Marcelino B.
Britanico,JR. vs. Diego B. Barranda
"FBca Teresita 4"
14 ADM-RO5- BFAR RO5 represented by Efraim T. Atty. Monaliza B. De
2021-078 Mendoza vs. Rowena R. Roxas, los Santos
Manuel A. Borromeo and Armando E.
Gonzales "FBca Sam"
15 ADJ-RO7-2018- Dandie Miranda, as one of the Heirs Atty. Paul Andre R. FLA
010 of Delfin Miranda vs. DPWH Regional Margarico
Office No. VII and Local Government
Unit of Cordova, Cebu
16 ADM-R11- Virginia V. Caballero v. Edna G. Atty. Rachel Mernil Letter of Hon.
2018-002 Ampog, Oscar Garcia Jr., Maura Vda O. Maratas-Bacera Dayaday
De Figueroa, Alexander Figueroa, requesting for
Leonila Dayaday and Patrocino installment
Doriman payment of
penalty (FOR
DISCUSSION
ONLY)
17 ADM-RO11- BFAR R011 vs. Normand Joseph D. Atty. Rachel Mernil
2019-013 Pahl O. Maratas-Bacera
18 ADM-RO11- BFAR 11 represented by Mervin Atty. Rachel Mernil
2019-006 Cabrera vs. Eldon J. Maynambong, O. Maratas-Bacera
Calixtro P. Manib, Manolo M. Tipudan,
Edcel B. Benaning, Belly B. Cinco
19 ADM-RO11- BFAR 11 represented by Marvie Atty. Rachel Mernil
2019-022 Padasay Vs. Virginio Bandayanon and O. Maratas-Bacera
Joseph Bandayanon
20 ADM-RO11- BFAR R011 represented by Mervin Atty. Rachel Mernil
2019-012 Cabrera Vs. Marlon M. Lancian O. Maratas-Bacera
21 ADM- RO4B-SP- BFAR 4B represented by Mario C. Atty. Annaliza A. Poaching
2018-026 ADM- Basaya vs. Vo Quoc Phong aka Vitug
RO4B-SP-2018- Phyong Vo Gouc, pham Van Dung aka
027 Pham Ken Dung, Doan Van Van, Pham
Van Tien, Pham Ngoc Vang aka
Truong Van An, Doan Hong Tham,
Doan Hong Tham, Doan Van An and
Ho Van Nghia aka Ho Hu Ghia
22 ADM- RO4B-SP- BFAR 4B represented by Mario C. Atty. Annaliza A. Poaching
2018-032 Basaya vs. Nguyen Minh Tuan, Ho Vitug
Huyn Them, Cao Ba Tan, Cao Tien,
Huynh Cu
23 ADM- RO4B-SP- BFAR 4B represented by Mario C. Atty. Annaliza A. Poaching
2018-033 Basaya vs. Nguyen the Toan Nguyen Vitug
The Hiep Nuyen Dung and Phan say
July 22 DEPARTURE