Professional Documents
Culture Documents
WHO Pharmaceuticals
NEWSLETTER No. 1
Pharmacovigilance,
MHP/RPQ,
World Health Organization,
1211 Geneva 27, Switzerland,
E-mail address: Contents
pvsupport@who.int
This Newsletter is also available at: Regulatory Matters
https://www.who.int/teams/regula
tion-prequalification Safety of Medicines
Features
WHO Pharmaceuticals Newsletter No. 1, 2023
Some rights reserved. This work is available under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 IGO
licence (CC BY-NC-SA 3.0 IGO; https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/igo).
Under the terms of this licence, you may copy, redistribute and adapt the work for non-commercial purposes, provided the
work is appropriately cited, as indicated below. In any use of this work, there should be no suggestion that WHO endorses any
specific organization, products or services. The use of the WHO logo is not permitted. If you adapt the work, then you must
license your work under the same or equivalent Creative Commons licence. If you create a translation of this work, you should
add the following disclaimer along with the suggested citation: “This translation was not created by the World Health
Organization (WHO). WHO is not responsible for the content or accuracy of this translation. The original English edition shall
be the binding and authentic edition”.
Any mediation relating to disputes arising under the licence shall be conducted in accordance with the mediation rules of the
World Intellectual Property Organization (http://www.wipo.int/amc/en/mediation/rules/).
Suggested citation. WHO Pharmaceuticals Newsletter No. 1, 2023. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2023. Licence:
CC BY-NC-SA 3.0 IGO.
Sales, rights and licensing. To purchase WHO publications, see https://www.who.int/publications/book-orders. To submit
requests for commercial use and queries on rights and licensing, see https://www.who.int/copyright.
Third-party materials. If you wish to reuse material from this work that is attributed to a third party, such as tables, figures or
images, it is your responsibility to determine whether permission is needed for that reuse and to obtain permission from the
copyright holder. The risk of claims resulting from infringement of any third-party-owned component in the work rests solely
with the user.
General disclaimers. The designations employed and the presentation of the material in this publication do not imply the
expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of WHO concerning the legal status of any country, territory, city or area or
of its authorities, or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries. Dotted and dashed lines on maps represent
approximate border lines for which there may not yet be full agreement.
The mention of specific companies or of certain manufacturers’ products does not imply that they are endorsed or
recommended by WHO in preference to others of a similar nature that are not mentioned. Errors and omissions excepted, the
names of proprietary products are distinguished by initial capital letters.
All reasonable precautions have been taken by WHO to verify the information contained in this publication. However, the
published material is being distributed without warranty of any kind, either expressed or implied. The responsibility for the
interpretation and use of the material lies with the reader. In no event shall WHO be liable for damages arising from its use.
Table of Contents
Regulatory Matters
Amlodipine, nifedipine .................................................................................................................. 4
Amoxicillin .................................................................................................................................... 4
Atezolizumab ................................................................................................................................ 5
Bupropion ..................................................................................................................................... 5
Cabergoline .................................................................................................................................. 5
Cephalosporins ............................................................................................................................ 6
Clobetasol .................................................................................................................................... 6
Codeine with ibuprofen ................................................................................................................. 6
COVID-19 vaccine Astrazeneca (ChAdOx1-S) ............................................................................. 6
COVID-19 vaccines Moderna (Elasomeran) and/or Pfizer (Tozinameran) .................................... 7
Dupilumab .................................................................................................................................... 8
Durvalumab .................................................................................................................................. 8
Gabapentin ................................................................................................................................... 8
Haloperidol ................................................................................................................................... 9
Hydrochlorothiazide ...................................................................................................................... 9
Imatinib ......................................................................................................................................... 9
Itraconazole ................................................................................................................................ 10
Janus kinase (JAK) inhibitors ..................................................................................................... 10
Loxoprofen ................................................................................................................................. 11
Methotrexate .............................................................................................................................. 11
Nivolumab, ipilimumab and/or pembrolizumab ........................................................................... 11
Olanzapine ................................................................................................................................. 12
Pholcodine.................................................................................................................................. 12
Remdesivir ................................................................................................................................. 12
Roxadustat ................................................................................................................................. 13
Systemic corticosteroids ............................................................................................................. 13
Terlipressin ................................................................................................................................. 13
Tigecycline ................................................................................................................................. 14
Ustekinumab .............................................................................................................................. 14
Vitamin B6 (pyridoxine) .............................................................................................................. 14
Safety of Medicines
Denosumab ................................................................................................................................ 15
Gadoteric acid ............................................................................................................................ 15
Ibrutinib ...................................................................................................................................... 15
Methylphenidate long-acting formulations .................................................................................. 16
Minoxidil ..................................................................................................................................... 16
Newer antidiabetic medicines used with insulin and/or sulfonylureas ......................................... 16
Tranexamic acid injection ........................................................................................................... 16
Valproate .................................................................................................................................... 17
Features
Summary and recommendations from the virtual meeting of the members of the WHO
Programme for International Drug Monitoring (PIDM) and other partners ................................... 19
All the previous issues of the WHO Pharmaceuticals Newsletter can be accessed from our website.
Australia. The Therapeutic 1. Risk of heavy menstrual Patients and carers, EMA, 28
Goods Administration (TGA) bleeding October 2022 (link to the source
has announced that the within www.ema.europa.eu)
existing warning on very rare Europe. The PRAC has
demyelinating disorders in the recommended that heavy
2. Risk of myocarditis and
product information for menstrual bleeding should be
added to the product
pericarditis
COVID-19 vaccine Astrazeneca
(ChAdOx1-S, Vaxzevria®) has information as an adverse
Australia. The TGA has
been updated to include the reaction of unknown frequency announced that the product
potential risk of acute for COVID-19 vaccines information for COVID-19
disseminated encephalomyelitis Moderna (elasomeran, vaccines Moderna and Pfizer
(ADEM). Spikevax®), Pfizer and the bivalent vaccines have
(tozinameran, Comirnaty®) been updated to expand on an
The updated warning states
and the bivalent vaccines. existing warning on myocarditis
that:
Heavy menstrual bleeding may and pericarditis to include the
• very rare events of be defined as bleeding following points:
demyelinating disorders, characterized by an increased
• Rare cases can also occur in
including acute disseminated volume and/or duration which
females.
encephalomyelitis, have been interferes with the person’s • Cases of myocarditis and
reported following physical, social, emotional and pericarditis following
vaccination; quality of life. vaccination have rarely been
• a causal relationship between associated with severe
Cases of heavy menstrual
the vaccine and event has outcomes including death.
bleeding have been reported
not been established; • The signs and symptoms of
after the first, second and
• health-care professionals myocarditis and pericarditis
booster doses of these
should be alert of signs and following vaccination include
vaccines. The PRAC reviewed
symptoms of demyelinating atypical presentations and
available data, including cases non-specific symptoms of
disorders to ensure correct
reported during clinical trials, fatigue, nausea and
diagnosis, in order to initiate
cases spontaneously reported vomiting, abdominal pain,
adequate supportive care and
in Eudravigilance and findings dizziness or syncope,
treatment, and to rule out
from the medical literature. oedema and cough.
other causes.
Most cases appeared to be Reference:
Cutaneous vasculitis has also
non-serious and temporary in COVID-19 vaccine safety
been added to the product
nature. The PRAC concluded report, TGA, 20 October 2022
information as a rare skin
that there is at least a (link to the source within
disorder that has been reported
reasonable possibility that the www.tga.gov.au)
after vaccination.
occurrence of heavy menstrual
Reference: bleeding is causally associated
COVID-19 vaccine safety with these vaccines. 3. Potential risk of non-
report, TGA, 23 September sexually acquired genital
There is no evidence to suggest
2022 (link to the source within ulceration and dizziness
the menstrual disorders
www.tga.gov.au)
experienced by some people Australia. The TGA has
have any impact on announced that the product
reproduction and fertility. information for COVID-19
COVID-19 vaccines Available data provides vaccine Pfizer and the bivalent
Moderna reassurance about the use of vaccines1 have been updated
mRNA COVID-19 vaccines to include the potential risk of
(Elasomeran) and/or non-sexually acquired genital
before and during pregnancy.
Pfizer (Tozinameran) ulceration and dizziness.
Reference:
1
COVID-19 vaccine Moderna is not
included in the scope of this measure.
The condition is characterized indicated for the treatment of Based on the available
by painful ulcers that tend to atopic dermatitis in adults and evidence it is considered that a
resolve spontaneously within a children. causal relationship between
few weeks without scarring. In myelitis transverse and
rare cases they may cause pain The MHRA has received 479 UK
durvalumab is a reasonable
or urinary retention that reports (7 September 2022)
possibility.
require hospitalization. These which include suspected ocular
ulcers predominantly affect adverse effects with Reference:
adolescent females and are dupilumab. One hundred and PRAC recommendations on
generally a diagnosis of eleven of these reports were signals, EMA, 21 November
exclusion when infectious and considered serious. Nine 2022 (link to the source within
non-infectious causes of ulcers reports (representing five www.ema.europa.eu)
have been ruled out. cases) of ulcerative keratitis
were received, of which two
Dizziness has been added to
cases reported corneal
Gabapentin
the product information as a
potential adverse event that perforation.
1. Risk of drug dependence
can occur after vaccination.
It is not currently possible to and withdrawal symptoms
Dizziness was not observed in
clinical trials but has been predict who may experience
Ireland. The HPRA has
reported through real-world the rarer and most serious
announced that the product
use of the vaccine after ocular adverse reactions, such
information for gabapentin will
approval. It is not currently as ulcerative keratitis. It is
be updated to indicate that
known how frequently this therefore important, with all
drug dependence at
reaction occurs. ocular reactions, for patients to
therapeutic doses and
receive prompt care, with
Reference: withdrawal symptoms following
treatment provided as
COVID-19 vaccine safety discontinuation can occur.
appropriate to prevent or
report, TGA, 20 October & 22
minimize damage to the eye. Gabapentin is indicated for the
December 2022 (link1 and link2
Health-care professionals treatment of neuropathic pain
to the source within
should promptly review new in adults, and as monotherapy
www.tga.gov.au)
onset or worsening ocular or as adjunctive therapy for
symptoms, referring patients specific forms of epilepsy.
for ophthalmological
Dupilumab examinations as appropriate.
The update has been made
following a review of available
Risk of ocular adverse Reference: data by the PRAC of the EMA.
reactions Drug Safety Update, MHRA, 29 Health-care professionals
November 2022 (link to the should carefully evaluate an
United Kingdom. The source within www.gov.uk/mhra) individual patient’s risk of
Medicines and Healthcare
misuse, abuse and dependence
Products Regulatory Agency
(MHRA) has announced that
Durvalumab before prescribing gabapentin.
Patients treated with
the product information for
Risk of myelitis transverse gabapentin should be
dupilumab (Dupixent®) is to
monitored for these symptoms.
be updated to include the risk Europe. The PRAC has If gabapentin use is to be
of dry eyes and also to recommended updating the discontinued, it is
emphasize the need for prompt product information for recommended this should be
done gradually over a December 2022 (link to the a causal relationship between
minimum of one week source within www.hpra.ie) the drug and ARDS was
independent of the indication. (See also WHO Pharmaceuticals reasonably possible.
Newsletter No.2, 2021: Gabapentin,
Considering the severity of
In addition, neonatal pregabalin and Risk of dizziness,
ARDS and following the product
withdrawal syndrome has been somnolence, abuse and dependence in
New Zealand) information revision in the EU,
reported in newborns exposed
the MHLW and PMDA concluded
in utero to gabapentin. Co-
that ARDS should be added as
exposure to gabapentin and
opioids during pregnancy may Haloperidol a clinically significant adverse
reaction.
increase the risk of neonatal
withdrawal syndrome. Risk of cogwheel rigidity Reference:
Newborns should be monitored Revision of Precautions,
India. The CDSCO has
carefully. MHLW/PMDA, 16 November
approved the recommendation
2022 (link to the source within
from the NCC-PvPI, IPC to
www.pmda.go.jp/english/)
revise the PIL for haloperidol to
2. Risk of Toxic Epidermal
include cogwheel rigidity as an
Necrolysis (TEN)
adverse drug reaction.
The HPRA has announced that Imatinib
the product information for Haloperidol is indicated for the
gabapentin will be updated to treatment of chronic Risk of thrombotic
include the risk of Toxic schizophrenia. microangiopathy
Epidermal Necrolysis (TEN) The NCC-PvPI, IPC reviewed 11 Japan. The MHLW and PMDA
under the heading of severe ICSRs of haloperidol associated have announced that the
cutaneous adverse reactions cogwheel rigidity and a causal product information for
(SCARs), where Steven- relationship between them was imatinib should be revised to
Johnson-Syndrome (SJS) and found. include the risk of thrombotic
Drug Rash with Eosinophilia
Reference: microangiopathy.
and Systemic Symptoms
(DRESS) are already listed as Based on the communication Imatinib is indicated for the
known adverse reactions. from IPC, India, October 2022 treatment of chronic myeloid
(link to the source within ipc.gov.in)
leukaemia and other cancers.
SJS, TEN and DRESS, which
can be life-threatening or fatal, The MHLW and PMDA reviewed
have been reported with international and national
Hydrochlorothiazide
gabapentin treatment. reports of thrombotic
Risk of acute respiratory microangiopathy, and a causal
Health-care professionals
distress syndrome (ARDS) relationship between the drug
should advise patients of the
and event was reasonably
signs and symptoms and
Japan. The MHLW and PMDA possible. The MHLW and PMDA
closely monitor for skin
have announced that the concluded that thrombotic
reactions when starting
product information for microangiopathy should be
treatment with gabapentin. If
hydrochlorothiazide should be added as a clinically significant
signs and symptoms
revised to include the risk of adverse reaction.
suggestive of these reactions
acute respiratory distress
appear, gabapentin should be Health-care professionals are
syndrome (ARDS).
withdrawn immediately. If a advised to suspend treatment
patient has developed a serious Hydrochlorothiazide is with imatinib when anemia
reaction such as SJS, TEN or indicated for the treatment of with fragmented red blood
DRESS, treatment with hypertension and oedema. cells, thrombocytopenia, or
gabapentin must not be renal dysfunction are observed.
The MHLW and PMDA reviewed
restarted in this patient at any
cases of ARDS reported Reference:
time.
domestically and Revision of Precautions,
Reference: internationally. In MHLW/PMDA, 16 November
Drug Safety Newsletter, HPRA, internationally reported cases, 2022 (link to the source within
www.pmda.go.jp/english/)
WHO Pharmaceuticals Newsletter No. 1, 2023 • 9
Regulatory Matters
Health-care professionals are November 2022 (link to the the results of the ALPHO
advised to periodically examine source within (Allergy to Neuromuscular
presence of ocular abnormality nedrug.mfds.go.kr/index) Blocking Agents and Pholcodine
and to instruct patients to Exposure) study and one post-
immediately seek medical marketing safety data. The
attention if any ocular Olanzapine available data showed that the
abnormalities are observed. use of pholcodine in the 12
Risk of hyponatraemia months before general
Reference:
anaesthesia with
Revision of Precautions, India. The CDSCO has neuromuscular blocking agents
MHLW/PMDA, 12 October 2022 approved the recommendation (NMBAs) is a risk factor for
(link to the source within
from the NCC-PvPI, IPC to developing an anaphylactic
www.pmda.go.jp/english/)
revise the PIL for olanzapine to reaction to NMBAs. As it was
include hyponatraemia as an not possible to identify
adverse drug reaction. effective measures to minimize
2. Risk of rhabdomyolysis
Olanzapine is indicated for the this risk, nor to identify a
Republic of Korea. The MFDS treatment of schizophrenia in patient population for whom
has updated the product adult patients, rapid control of the benefits of pholcodine
information for agitation and disturbed outweigh its risks, pholcodine
pembrolizumab2 to include behaviour in patients. is being withdrawn from the EU
rhabdomyolysis as an adverse market.
reaction. The NCC-PvPI, IPC reviewed 20
ICSRs of olanzapine associated Health-care professionals
Reports of serious adverse hyponatraemia and a causal should consider appropriate
event (SAE) reports were relationship between them was treatment alternatives and
evaluated, and the KIDS found. advise patients to stop taking
reviewed two cases of pholcodine. Health-care
rhabdomyolysis in patients Reference: professionals should also check
treated with pembrolizumab- Based on the communication whether patients scheduled to
containing chemotherapy for from IPC, India, October 2022 undergo general anaesthesia
non-small cell lung cancer, of (link to the source within ipc.gov.in) with NMBAs have used
which one was fatal. A causal pholcodine in the previous 12
relationship could not be months and remain aware of
excluded in any of these cases. Pholcodine the risk of anaphylactic
Based on the result of this SAE reactions in these patients.
Withdrawal of pholcodine
review and information from
medicines from EU market Reference:
the regulatory authority in the
Patients and carers, EMA, 2
US, EU, Japan and UK, the
Europe. The PRAC has December 2022 (link to the
MFDS concluded that the
recommended the revocation source within www.ema.europa.eu)
product information should be
of the marketing authorizations (See also WHO Pharmaceuticals
updated to include the risk of Newsletter No.4, 2022: Pholcodine and
for pholcodine in the European Potential risk of developing anaphylactic
rhabdomyolysis.
Union. reactions to NMBA in Europe)
Health-care professionals
Pholcodine is used in adults
should monitor for any signs of
and children to treat non-
rhabdomyolysis during use of Remdesivir
productive (dry) cough and, in
this drug.
combination with other active Risk of sinus bradycardia
Reference: substances, for the treatment
Based on the communication of symptoms of cold and flu. India. The CDSCO has
from KIDS and Drug Safety approved the recommendation
The PRAC evaluated all
Update, MFDS/KIDS, 8 from the NCC-PvPI, IPC to
available evidence including
2
Nivolumab and ipilimumab are not
included in the scope of this measure.
WHO Pharmaceuticals Newsletter No. 1, 2023 • 12
Regulatory Matters
revise the PIL for remdesivir to advised to conduct periodic within www.medsafe.govt.nz/)
include sinus bradycardia as an thyroid function tests
adverse drug reaction. (measurement of thyroid-
receive treatment to manage the treatment of severe plaque dose of vitamin B6 in products
their condition before starting psoriasis, psoriatic arthritis, has also been reduced from
terlipressin. During and after Crohn’s disease and ulcerative 200 mg to 100 mg for adults,
treatment, patients should be colitis. The product information with lower daily dose limits in
monitored for signs and already advises that it is place for children depending on
symptoms of respiratory failure preferable to avoid use of their age.
and infection. ustekinumab during pregnancy. Vitamin B6 is present in many
Reference: The PRAC has reviewed the multivitamin and mineral
Patients and carers, EMA, 11 available evidence including supplements. Peripheral
November 2022 (link to the observational studies from the neuropathy is a known adverse
source within www.ema.europa.eu) EU, United States and Canada, reaction of vitamin B6, where
as well as a review by the delayed diagnosis and
marketing authorisation holder. continued exposure can lead to
Tigecycline Ustekinumab can cross the its progression.
placenta and it has been Up to 5 August 2022, the TGA
Risk of coagulopathy detected in the serum of had received 32 adverse event
infants who were exposed to reports with sufficient
India. The CDSCO has
ustekinumab in utero. The risk information to establish a
approved the recommendation
of infection may be increased possible causal association
from the NCC-PvPI, IPC to
after birth in infants who were between peripheral neuropathy
revise the PIL for tigecycline to
exposed to ustekinumab in and products containing
include coagulopathy as an
utero. Therefore, the PRAC vitamin B6. The TGA found that
adverse drug reaction.
recommends that, in infants peripheral neuropathy can
Tigecycline is indicated for the who were exposed to occur at doses less than
treatment of skin and ustekinumab in utero, the 50 mg, and when people are
abdominal infections. administration of live vaccines taking multiple products
is not recommended for six containing vitamin B6. The risk
The NCC-PvPI, IPC reviewed
months following birth or until appears to vary between
three ICSRs of tigecycline
the infant’s serum levels of individuals, with no minimum
associated coagulopathy and a
ustekinumab are undetectable. dose, duration of use or
causal relationship between
them was found. Reference: specific patient risk factors
Patients and carers, EMA, 28 identified.
Reference:
October 2022 (link to the source Health-care professionals
Based on the communication
within www.ema.europa.eu) should consider vitamin B6
from IPC, India, October 2022
(link to the source within ipc.gov.in) toxicity in patients presenting
with symptoms of peripheral
Vitamin B6
neuropathy. A review of the
(pyridoxine) patient’s vitamin B6 intake is
Ustekinumab
recommended paying close
Risk of peripheral attention to potential sources
Risk of infection from live
neuropathy such as multivitamins,
vaccines in infants exposed
magnesium and zinc products,
in utero Australia. The TGA has particularly when taken in
strengthened labelling combination.
Europe. The PRAC has
requirements for products
recommended adding a Reference:
containing daily doses of 10mg
warning to the product Medicines Safety Update, TGA,
of vitamin B6 (pyridoxine) to
information for ustekinumab 1 November 2022 (link to the
include a warning about
(Stelara®) on the use of live source within www.tga.gov.au)
peripheral neuropathy.
vaccines in infants whose
mothers received ustekinumab Previously, products containing
during their pregnancy. daily doses over 50mg were
required to carry the warning.
Ustekinumab is indicated for The maximum permitted daily
WHO Pharmaceuticals Newsletter No. 1, 2023 • 14
Safety of Medicines
risk of administration errors in serious undesirable adverse other conditions of PPP are
that can potentially occur with effects. met. PPP was introduced in
tranexamic acid (TXA) 2018 to ensure all women and
Recently, obstetricians from
injection. There have been girls are fully informed of the
several countries have reported
reports of TXA being mistaken risks and the need to avoid
inadvertent intrathecal TXA
for obstetric spinal anaesthesia exposure to valproate
administration and related
used for caesarean deliveries medicines in pregnancy
serious neurological injuries.
resulting in inadvertent through annual review and
intrathecal administration. TXA is a lifesaving medicine; signing a risk
however, this potential clinical acknowledgement form.
In TXA administered
risk should be considered and
intrathecally, potent neurotoxin In 2022, the Commission on
addressed by all operating
and neurological sequelae are Human Medicines (CHM)
theatre staff. Reviewing of
manifested, with refractory considered a review of safety
existing operating theatre drug
seizures and 50% mortality. data relating to valproate. This
handling practices are required
The profound toxicity of TXA review included prescribing
in order to decrease this risk,
administered intrathecally was data showing continued use of
such as storage of TXA away
described in 1980. A 2019 valproate in female patients
from the anaesthetic drug
review identified 21 reported and also some use during
trolley, preferably outside the
cases of inadvertent intrathecal pregnancy, as well as evolving
theatre.
injection of TXA since 1988, of information about potential
which 20 were life-threatening Reference: Medical product
risks in male patients. The CHM
and 10 fatal. Sixteen were alert, WHO, 16 March 2022 (link
has recommended a number of
reported between 2009 and to the source within www.who.int)
regulatory actions to further
2018. strengthen safety measures for
WHO recommends early use of valproate, which will be
intravenous TXA within 3 hours Valproate introduced over the coming
of birth in addition to standard months and include:
care for women with clinically
Risks in pregnancy and
potential risks in male • No patients (male or female)
diagnosed postpartum
patients under the age of 55 years
haemorrhage (PPH) following
should be initiated on
vaginal births or caesarean
United Kingdom. The MHRA valproate unless two
section. TXA should be
has reminded health-care specialists independently
administered at a fixed dose of
professionals of the risks in consider and document that
1g in 10 ml (100 mg/ml) IV at
pregnancy and the current there is no other effective or
1 ml per minute, with a second
Pregnancy Prevention tolerated treatment.
dose of 1g IV if bleeding
Programme (PPP) requirements • For patients under 55 years
continues after 30 minutes.
and provided information about currently receiving valproate,
TXA is frequently stored in the potential risks of valproate two specialists should
close proximity with other in other patients including male independently consider and
medicines, including injectable patients. New safety measures document that there is no
local anesthetics indicated for for valproate-containing other effective or tolerated
spinal analgesia (e.g., for medicines are to be put in treatment or the risks do not
caesarean section). The place in the coming months. apply.
presentation of some of the • Further warnings in the
local anesthetics is similar to Valproate is indicated for the product information,
the TXA presentation treatment of epilepsy and improved educational
(transparent ampoule bipolar disorder. As valproate materials, and better
containing transparent has a high teratogenic monitoring of health-care
solution), which can potential, it is contraindicated professionals’ compliance
erroneously be administered in female children and women with the new measures.
instead of the intended of childbearing potential unless
intrathecal anesthetic resulting other treatments are
Reference:
ineffective or not tolerated and
Drug Safety Update, MHRA, 29
WHO Pharmaceuticals Newsletter No. 1, 2023 • 17
Safety of Medicines
We also welcome short reports on any recent events or achievements in pharmacovigilance in your
country.
All submissions will be reviewed for relevance and subject to the WHO internal selection, editorial
review, and clearance process.
20 October 2022
The WHO Programme for International Drug Monitoring (PIDM) provides a global platform for WHO Member
States, territories and areas to exchange safety and regulatory information on medicines and vaccines 3.
Coronavirus disease (COVID-19) has had a significant impact on pharmacovigilance worldwide, with new
vaccines and medicines for the prevention and treatment of COVID-19 being implemented on an
unprecedented scale, with the associated increase in case safety reports.
WHO convened a virtual meeting to provide an opportunity for PIDM members and other partners to share
their pharmacovigilance experiences from the COVID-19 pandemic, discuss the challenges and how these
were addressed and to consolidate the collective learnings and gains for establishing pandemic-ready, resilient
and functional pharmacovigilance systems and practices.
The objective of this session was to summarize what pharmacovigilance infrastructures have been established
by the WHO Pharmacovigilance (PVG) Team at HQ and the WHO Regional Offices during the COVID-19
pandemic, what will be preserved in the post-pandemic period and if pharmacovigilance systems are ready for
the next pandemic.
vaccines/subcommittee
Features
Pandemic preparedness
The PVG team are cautiously optimistic that the infrastructures and process developed to respond to the
COVID-19 pandemic will help prepare for the next pandemic. However, other challenges are likely and some
serious gaps remain, e.g., AESI background rates, exposure data and data for specific subpopulations.
Pandemic preparedness
It is unlikely that the African region will be fully prepared for the next pandemic but notable progress has been
made.
Pandemic preparedness
Much has been achieved and learnt, but much remains to be done to build and maintain trust and to build
resilient systems to be prepared for the next pandemic. Some of the key areas for response include
continuous process improvement, coordination and collaboration, improved networking and reliance and
access to data. Country-specific contexts need to be understood to provide tailored solutions. Transparency
and communication must continue to be improved.
• workshops and sharing of WHO guidelines, tools and regulatory updates to provide regional guidance;
• expert advice provided on vaccine safety signals after implementation of COVID-19 vaccination
programme and vaccine safety expert employed in the region.
Pandemic preparedness
The region is not completely ready for future pandemics. This will depend on using lessons learnt from the
COVID-19 pandemic for strengthening and sustaining AEFI surveillance systems continuously. Direct consumer
reporting should be developed and feedback mechanisms strengthened. Closer collaboration with medical
associations would improve preparedness. Mechanisms for timely sharing of data on serious AEFIs between
vaccine manufacturers, NRAs and EPIs need to be reinforced. Communication and social sciences experts
should be systematically included in AEFI committees. AESI surveillance and specific active surveillance
studies need to be extended to include more countries.
Pandemic preparedness
Readiness for future pandemics will require further development of capacity to integrate real-world data and
evidence into policy guidance on post-marketing safety surveillance for investigational products being used in
emergency situations. Open access training on reporting, investigation and causality assessment of AEFIs
should be made available to all healthcare workers. The training should aim to enhance the quality and
capacity for timely investigation, causality assessment and risk communications about serious AEs at all levels.
In addition, a legal framework and mechanisms for assessment of causality and vaccine injury claims are
needed.
The meeting then split into three break-out rooms with speakers from two regions in each who presented
experiences in their country during the COVID-19 pandemic, based on the following questions:
• How did the COVID-19 pandemic impact your programme?
• Did your programme develop any new pandemic?
• How did your programme improve pharmacovigilance systems, methods of working, tools or processes
during the COVID-19?
• What lessons have been learnt for the next pandemic?
• How do we leverage what we have learnt and maintain momentum?
Summary of recommendations
• decentralization of national pharmacovigilance functions is recommended in pandemic situations;
• capacity to anticipate and forecast and resolve potential or emerging issues to be improved;
• important to be flexible and modify strategy and adapt plans, as needed;
• develop national and international emergency plans for future pandemics, based on the lessons learnt
from the COVID-19 pandemic;
• reassess existing systems to identify key areas of fragility and implement mitigation strategies to
improve preparedness for a future pandemic;
• CEM study protocols need to be adapted to each country setting;
• national pharmacovigilance system steering committees should be established;
• web-based data collection and online reporting systems and dashboards are important and practical
for CEM studies;
• continuous quality control should be implemented during CEM studies using online, live and interactive
dashboards.
Summary of recommendations
• continue to encourage and facilitate local and inter-country collaboration;
• prioritize training of pharmacovigilance staff, healthcare workers and the general public;
• implement clear guidelines to guarantee good quality pharmacovigilance activities;
• continue to advocate funding for pharmacovigilance activities to maintain safety surveillance
improvements;
• ensure availability of tools, especially integrated electronic systems for data capture and sharing.
3. How to leverage what has been learnt and maintain the momentum
In this session four panellists presented and discussed the regional mechanisms for networking and
collaboration between countries which responded to the pandemic.
(1) EU-M4all
EU Medicines for all or EU-M4all (previously Article 58) is a procedure whereby the EMA and WHO provide a
scientific opinion for high priority human medicines and vaccines that are intended for use outside the
European Union9. The procedure is led by EMA’s Committee for Medicinal Products for Human Use (CHMP) with
involvement of the Pharmacovigilance Risk Assessment Committee (PRAC) who are responsible for the risk
management plan (RMP), periodic safety updates reports (PSURs) and non-interventional post-authorization
safety studies (PASS). The procedure used is the same as that for drugs and vaccines intended for use in the
EU and is based on reliance and trust. Between 2004 and 2021, EMA issued 12 positive opinions under the
EUM4all procedure, which resulted in 142 authorizations in 91 countries.
The sponsor (pharmaceutical company, non-governmental organization (NGO) or academics) initiates the
procedure. After a positive opinion, the sponsor is responsible for all pharmacovigilance activities required by
EMA and NRA. In addition to the usual 6-month PSUR, a monthly safety summary report was submitted for
COVID-19 vaccines.
(2) AU-3S
The AU Smart Safety Surveillance (AU-3S) is a 10-year programme, based on a continent-wide approach to
patient safety, to ensure that African regulators and patients have confidence in global health product safety
by10:
• improving safety across priority products’ lifecycles;
• enabling African ownership of African data (e.g., AfriVigilance database);
The COVID-19 pandemic happened while this programme was being set up. A COVID-19 vaccine safety
response group, initially involving four countries (Ghana, Nigeria, Ethiopia and South Africa) and other
partners was set up. The activities during the pandemic demonstrated that:
• African EPIs and NRAs can collaborate within and across countries;
• technology and work-sharing (reliance) can be used to address resource constraints and limited
expertise;
• African regulators can conduct signal detection and validation on their own safety data;
• African regulators can make evidence-based decisions on their own data to protect their populations.
The group was able to confirm the safety of COVID-19 vaccines in Africa with African safety data being very
similar to global data. High levels of sponsorship and engagement from NRAs and removing barriers to EPI
and NRA collaboration were among the key success factors. Commitment to solutions adapted to country-
specific settings development of digital tools for healthcare providers and the public, across products and
countries and provision of real-time technical support to countries were also important. AU-3S can be
considered as a model for safety responses in future pandemics in LMICs.
(3) SEARN
The South-East Asia Regulatory Network (SEARN), a voluntary association of 11 countries, was initiated in
April 2017 in Delhi to enhance information sharing, collaboration and integration of regulatory practices 11.
Their 2022-2023 workplan includes developing strategies to improve AEFI reporting rates, setting up regional
pharmacovigilance integration, reviewing NRAs’ COVID-19 experience to improve regional preparedness,
supporting capacity building for SEARN members and facilitating information sharing and reliance. One
challenge for SEARN is dealing with language diversity. Future plans include identifying regional solutions for
integration (signal detection), capacity building (signal assessment and PSURs) and reliance (core risk
management plans).
Session Summary
The promotion of efficient and clear mechanisms for networking and collaboration between countries with
different regulatory maturity levels can develop regional capacity. Many medicines and vaccines used during
the pandemic have emergency use authorizations and therefore potentially have increased risks requiring
reinforced surveillance by passive and active surveillance systems.
Pharmacovigilance activities have greatly increased during the COVID-19 pandemic. It will be important to
build on the pharmacovigilance and AEFI surveillance systems that have been implemented and the increased
collaboration and networking across all stakeholder levels at national, regional and global levels. Collaboration
Participants
Speakers:
Bartholomew Dicky Akanmori (WHO/AFRO), Oleg Benes (WHO/EURO), Pankaj Bhatnagar (WHO/SEARO), David Chakhunashvili
(National Center for Disease Control and Public Health, Georgia), Merhawi Debesai (Eritrean Pharmacovigilance Centre, Eritrea),
Magnus Ekelo (WHO-CC UMC), Mohammad Hassan Emamian (Shahroud University of Medical Sciences, Iran), Ayako Fukushima
(WHO/HQ PVG), Rogério Gaspar (WHO/HQ), Md. Akter Hossain (National Pharmacovigilance Centre, Bangladesh), Adrien Inoubli
(WHO/SEARO), Houda Langar (WHO/EMRO), Birgitta Lindner (WHO-CC UMC), Mark Ryann A Lirasan (Food and Drug Administration,
Philippines), Viola Macolic Sarinic (EMA), Hudu Mogtari (NEPAD), Shanthi Pal (WHO/HQ), Rogerio Paulo Pinto de Sa Gaspar
(WHO/HQ), Edgar Robin Rojas-Cortés (WHO/PAHO), Juan Roldan (Public Health Institute of Chile, Chile), Jinho Shin (WHO/WPRO),
Maia Uuskula (State Agency of Medicines, Estonia)
The meeting received more than 890 online registrations from approximately 140 countries covering all the WHO Regions and was
attended online by approximately 500 participants.
This virtual meeting was organized by the WHO Pharmacovigilance (PVG) team within the Regulation and Safety Unit of the Department
of Regulation and Prequalification at WHO HQ, in close collaboration with the WHO Regional Offices (ROs) and the WHO Collaborating
Centre (WHO-CC) for International Drug Monitoring, the Uppsala Monitoring Centre (UMC).