Professional Documents
Culture Documents
process of decoding symbols o physically moving your eyes rapidly along the page
to derive meaning from a text. and tracing your finger along the lines of the text to
speed up your reading.
It is always an interaction
between the text and the reader. Scanning
We read to gain and share information and ideas, whether
o the reading is looking for specific information.
for academic, personal or reading professional purposes.
o involves physically moving your eyes quickly along
EFFECTIVE READING STRATEGIES the lines of text.
- means looking at the readily visible parts of the text, like 3. Context Clues
titles and subtitles, and also visual and graphs, pictures,
and charts. - are words, phrases and sentences that surround an
unfamiliar word that can help your recognize the
- helps familiarize you with the contents of the selection meaning of the unknown word because the text gives
and focus on the important information in the text. you information about it.
a. Identify your purpose for reading.
Common Types of Context Clues:
b. Examines the titles and subtitles of the text.
a. Synonyms – used when the text has words or
c. Browse the introduction and the conclusion of
phrases that are similar in meaning to the unknown
the text.
word. Synonym clues may be signaled by words:
d. Look at the visual elements of the text. “like” or “as”.
1 2
English for Academic and Professional Purposes English for Academic and Professional Purposes
3 4
English for Academic and Professional Purposes English for Academic and Professional Purposes
CRITICAL READING STRATEGIES o You can write questions any time, but in difficult
academic readings, you will understand the material
1. Previewing better and remember it longer if you write a question for
Learning about a text before really reading it. every paragraph or brief section.
7
o enables readers to get a sense of what the text is about o Each question should focus on a main idea, not on
and how it is organized before reading it closely. illustrations or details, and each should be expressed in
your own words, not just copied from parts of the
o includes seeing what you can learn from the headnotes
paragraph.
or other introductory material, skimming to get an
overview of the content and organization, and 4. Reflecting on challenges to your beliefs and values.
identifying the rhetorical situation. Examining your personal responses.
2. Contextualizing o As you read a text for the first time, mark an X in the
Placing a text in its historical, biographical, and margin at each point where you feel a personal challenge
cultural contexts. to your attitudes, beliefs, or status.
o When you read a text, you read it through the lens of o Make a brief note in the margin about what you feel or
your own experience. about what in the text created the challenge.
3. Questioning to understand and remember o helpful strategies for understanding the content and
Asking questions about the content. structure of a reading selection.
o Outlining the main ideas helps you to discover this Answer the following questions:
structure. When you make an outline, don't use the
1. What are the benefits of becoming a critical reader?
text's exact words.
________________________________________________
o Summarizing begins with outlining, but instead of ________________________________________________
merely listing the main ideas, a summary recomposes
them to form a new text. 2. Why is it important to have a preview before totally
reading the text?
6. Comparing and contrasting related readings ________________________________________________
Exploring likenesses and differences between texts to ________________________________________________
understand them better.
3. In summarizing a text, what are the things to be
o Many of the authors we read are concerned with the
considered?
same issues or questions, but approach how to discuss
________________________________________________
them in different ways.
________________________________________________
o Fitting a text into an ongoing dialectic helps increase
understanding of why an author approached a particular 4. What do you mean by CONTEXTUALIZING?
issue or question in the way he or she did ________________________________________________
________________________________________________
English for Academic and Professional Purposes English for Academic and Professional Purposes
5. Which strategy do you think is the best for a better 2. Chronological - information in the passage is
understanding of a text? Why? organized in order of time.
________________________________________________
Example:
________________________________________________
Jack and Jill ran up the hill to fetch a pail of water. Jack fell
ACADEMIC TEXT STRUCTURE down and broke his crown and Jill came tumbling after.
Text structure refers to 3. Compare and Contrast - two or more things are
how the information described. Their similarities and differences are
within a written text is discussed. 11
organized.
Example:
This strategy helps
students understand that a Linux and Windows are both operating systems. Computers
text might present a main use them to run programs. Linux is totally free and open
idea and details; a cause source, so users can improve or otherwise modify the source
and then its effects; and/or different views of a topic. code. Windows is proprietary, so it costs money to use and
users are prohibited from altering the source code.
DIFFERENT TEXT STRUCTURES
4. Order of Importance - information is expressed as a
1. Cause and Effect - The results of something are hierarchy or in priority.
explained.
Example:
Example:
Here are the three worst things that you can do on a date.
The dodo bird used to roam in large flocks across America. First, you could tell jokes that aren’t funny and laugh really
Interestingly, the dodo wasn’t startled by gun shot. Because hard to yourself. This will make you look bad. Worse
of this, frontiersmen would kill entire flocks in one sitting. though, you could offend your date. One bad “joke” may
Unable to sustain these attacks, the dodo was hunted to cause your date to lash out at you, hence ruining the
extinction. engagement. But the worst thing that you can do is to
appear slovenly. By not showering and properly grooming,
English for Academic and Professional Purposes English for Academic and Professional Purposes
you may repulse your date, and this is the worst thing that When you walk into my bedroom there is a window facing
you can do. you. To the right of that is a dresser and television and on
the other side of the window is my bed.
5. Problem and Solution - a problem is described and a
response or solution is proposed or explained.
Example:
Thousands of people die each year in car accidents LANGUAGES OF ACADEMIC TEXTS FROM
involving drugs or alcohol. Lives could be saved if our VARIOUS DISCIPLINES
town adopts a free public taxi service. By providing such a
13
service, we could prevent intoxicated drivers from
endangering themselves or others.
Example:
Academic vocabulary is used in all academic You may need to ask the following questions to help you
disciplines to teach about the content of the discipline, e.g., find out a thesis statement:
a water table is different from a periodic elements table.
Before taking chemistry, for example, some students know o What main idea does most of my pre-writing support?
the technical words used in chemistry, while others do not. o What are the relationships that exit among my ideas?
Pre-teaching of vocabulary and subject-specific terminology
helps to address that need. Teaching academic language can o Which aspect of the topic seems to be given the most
be challenging because struggling readers and English detail?
learners do not always know the vocabulary used to learn o Where does my stand seem to be the most consistent?
specific academic terms or key concepts.
o What is the focus of the most interesting and significant
THESIS STATEMENT OF ACADEMIC TEXTS points of my pre-writing?
o What ideas should I do more research on?
What is Thesis Statement? Tips for Writing Your Thesis Statement
o is the central idea of an essay, around which all other 1. Determine what kind of paper you are writing:
ideas revolve. 15
o usually appears at the beginning of the introductory a. Analytical Paper - breaks down an issue or an idea
paragraph of a paper, and it offers a concise summary of into its component parts, evaluates the issue or idea,
the main point or claim of the essay, research paper, etc. and presents this breakdown and evaluation to the
audience.
o is usually one sentence that appears at the beginning
though it may occur as more than once. b. Expository Paper - explains something to the
o is developed, supported, and explained in the course of audience.
the paper by means of examples and evidence.
c. Argumentative Paper - makes a claim about a topic
o helps organize and develop the system of proper writing, and justifies this claim with specific evidence. The
and also serve as a signal to readers about the topic of a claim could be an opinion, a policy proposal, an
paper. evaluation, a cause-and-effect statement, or an
interpretation. The goal of the argumentative paper is to
Formulating a Thesis Statement convince the audience that the claim is true based on
the evidence provided.
English for Academic and Professional Purposes English for Academic and Professional Purposes
If you are writing a text that does not fall under these three by requiring students to participate in regular technology
categories (e.g., a narrative), a thesis statement somewhere detoxes.
in the first paragraph could still be helpful to your reader.
Thesis Statement 3:
2. Your thesis statement should be specific. School Officials’ Should Fight Cyber Bullying
It should cover only what you will discuss in your
Bullying has extended far beyond school and into
paper and should be supported with specific evidence.
cyberspace. Even though these acts of aggression take place
outside of school boundaries, school officials should have
3. Your topic may change as you write, so you may need
the authority to discipline students who engage in
to revise your thesis statement to reflect exactly what
cyberbullying without fear of reprisal. Doing so will help
you have discussed in the paper.
improve the online behavior of students and decrease
incidences of cyberbully-related suicide attempts.
Thesis Statement Examples Date: ________________ Score:
Marijuana has numerous medical applications, such as treating The first sentence or two of your summary should
symptoms of epilepsy, cancer, and glaucoma. Legalizing the use contain the author’s thesis, or central concept, stated in
of marijuana in the U.S. will greatly benefit the medical sector by your own words.
giving physicians access to this lifesaving drug.
Unlike student essays, the main idea in a primary
3. Thesis Statement: _____________________________ document or an academic article may not be stated in
________________________________________________ one location at the beginning. Instead, it may be
China’s one-child policy was intended to help control population
gradually developed throughout the piece or it may
growth. Instead, it has led to unintended and negative become fully apparent only at the end.
consequences, such as a diminishing labor force, an aging
population, the neglect of basic human rights, and an unbalanced When summarizing a longer article, try to see how the
gender population. To improve China’s situation, the policy various stages in the explanation or argument are built
should be reversed. up in groups of related paragraphs.
TECHNIQUES IN SUMMARIZING Divide the article into sections if it isn’t done in the
ACADEMIC TEXTS published form. Then, write a sentence or two to cover
the key ideas in each section.
Summarizing a text, or distilling its essential
Omit ideas that are not really
19 central to the text. Don’t
concepts into a paragraph or two, is a useful study tool as
feel that you must reproduce the author’s exact
well as good writing practice.
progression of thought. (On the other hand, be careful
not to misrepresent ideas by omitting important aspects
A summary has two aims:
of the author’s discussion).
1. to reproduce the overarching ideas in a text,
In general, omit minor details and specific examples.
identifying the general concepts that run through the
(In some texts, an extended example may be a key part
entire piece.
of the argument, so you would want to mention it).
2. to express these overarching ideas using precise,
specific language.
Avoid writing opinions or personal responses in your
summaries (save these for active reading responses or
Include the title and identify the author in your first tutorial discussions).
sentence.
English for Academic and Professional Purposes English for Academic and Professional Purposes
2. Set the original aside, and write your paraphrase on a In research papers students often quote excessively, failing
note card. to keep quoted material down to a desirable level. Since the
problem usually originates during note taking, it is essential
3. Jot down a few words below your paraphrase to remind to minimize the material recorded verbatim (Lester 46-47).
you later how you envision using this material. At the
top of the note card, write a key word or phrase to A plagiarized version:
indicate the subject of your paraphrase.
4. Check your rendition with the original to make sure that Students often use too many direct quotations when they
your version accurately expresses all the essential take notes, resulting in too many of them in the final
information in a new form. research paper. In fact, probably only about 10% of the final
copy should consist of directly quoted material. So it is
5. Use quotation marks to identify any unique term or important to limit the amount of source material copied
phraseology you have borrowed exactly from the source. while taking notes.
6. Record the source (including the page) on your note card
so that you can credit it easily if you decide to Date: ________________ Score:
incorporate the material into your paper. ACTIVITY # 3
Examples to Compare PARAPHRASING TEXTS 23
Purpose: To inform
OUTLINE Audience: High School Students Aged25 12-17 Years Old
Tone: Light and Educational
Point of View: Third Person Point of View
Thesis Statement: In the old times, the Spanish bore such a great influence
over Philippine languages and Philippine life.
1. These concepts include: God, Holy Trinity, Holy Ghost, Virgin 1) Open eyes
Mary, the Pope, grace, sin, cross, hell, Holy Church, Sunday, 2) Encourage activism
and the names of the Sacraments. III. Douglass as Author/Publisher
2. These words can be found in the first book to be published in A. Narrative’s success and effect
Tagalog, named the Doctrina Christiana. This book was
1) Springboard for paper
published in 1593.
B. This was the beginning of the marriage of Spanish and the Philippine B. Goals/hopes for paper
languages that came under the Spanish Christian influence. C. Garrison set-back and significance
C. This allowed the “common people” to start learning Spanish not only D. Significance of Paper
in religion but also at home and in everyday life. IV. Douglass as Politician
III. The Spanish, and a minority of Filipinos, also used the Spanish language A. Key trait for success
in the domains of higher education, government, and law. B. Goal of political activism
A. Very few Filipinos learned Spanish well. C. Efforts for Republican party
1. The University of Santo Tomas only conferred 2, 169 degrees 1) Significance of efforts
from 1634 to 1865.
D. Black soldier enlistment crusade
2. Toward the end of the Spanish regime, only 2.46% of an adult
population of 4.65 million spoke Spanish.
E. Joining of Republican party
B. The few Filipinos who did learn Spanish (referred to as illutrados) 1) Significance of efforts
were the same people who exerted an enduring influence in the V. Conclusion
domains of Philippine education, government and law. A. Summarize arguments and efforts
C. Spanish was an official language of the Philippines until 1986.
Sample Writing Outline CRITICAL READING as REASONING
(This statement is fact because it can be directly verified 2. Convention – is a way in which something is done,
by experience or reliable research reports.) similar to traditions and norms. It depends on historical
precedent, laws, rules, usage, and customs. It may sound
Sources of Factual Information: factual due to their being derived from customs.
a. Magazine – a collection of articles and images about
diverse topics of popular interest and current events. Example: The sampaguita belongs to the genus
Jasminum of the family Oleaceae.
b. Journal – a collection of articles usually written by
scholars in an academic or professional field. (This statement is convention because it is based on
classification system made up by scientists and is
c. Database – contains citations of articles in acceptable to the scientific community.)
magazines, journals, and newspapers.
3. Opinion – based on facts, but are difficult objectively
d. Newspaper – is a collection of articles about current verify because of producing satisfactory proofs of
events usually published daily. soundness.
e. Library Catalog – an organized and searchable
collection of records of every item in a library and Example: The popularity of sampaguita flowers is most
can be found on the library home page. evident in places of worship.
f. Books – cover virtually any topic, fact or fiction. For (This statement is an opinion because it is based on an
29
research purposes, you will probably be looking for observation that needs to be proven by studies or
books that synthesize all the information on one repeated observation.)
topic to support a particular argument or thesis.
Forming Opinions Based On Facts
g. Encyclopedias – collections of short, factual entries
often written by different contributors who are An opinion is a judgment based on facts, an honest
knowledgeable about the topic. attempt to draw a reasonable conclusion from factual
evidence.
h. Web – allows you to access most types of
information on the Internet through a browser. Example:
English for Academic and Professional Purposes English for Academic and Professional Purposes
o We know that millions of people go without proper _____ 3. In 2012, there were 1.4 billion users of social
medical care, and so you form the opinion that the media worldwide.
country should institute national health insurance even _____ 4. Teachers should use social media in their lessons
to get more students interested.
though it would cost billions of dollars.
_____ 5. Another name for social media is “Web 2.0”
because both terms emphasize the social aspects of the
4. Preference – based on personal choice; therefore, they Internet as avenues for communication, collaboration, and
are subjective and cannot be objectively proven or creative expression.
logically attacked. _____ 6. Many teenagers’ present obsession with taking
selfies shows they are the most narcissistic generation.
Example: Sampaguitas are the most beautiful and the _____ 7. Social networks are the most distracting websites
most fragrant of all flowers. on the Internet.
_____8. In the first quarter of 2014, nearly 300 million
(This statement is preference because it says a lot about smartphone units were sold all over the world.
the type of flowers that the writer likes, instead of _____ 9. Parents ought to enforce stricter guidelines in
objectively comparing the qualities of sampaguitas to social media to safeguard their children’s privacy.
that of other flowers.) _____ 10. Children are learning how to operate mobile
devices at increasingly younger ages; many of them have an
idea on how to use a touchscreen tablet before they are two.
Date: ________________ Score: WRITING THE REACTION PAPER
QUIZ # 3 A reaction or response paper requires the writer to
analyze a text, then develop commentary related to it. It is a
IDENTIFYING ASSERTIONS
popular academic assignment 31 because it requires thoughtful
Identify the type of the following assertions. Write C if reading, research, and writing.
convention, F if fact, O if opinion or P if preference.
How to Write a Reaction Paper?
_____ 1. Social media is defined as the internet and mobile-
based tools and devices that facilitate the integration of A. Prewriting and Actively Reading
technology, telecommunications, and social interaction.
_____ 2. Facebook is a cooler social media platform than 1. Understand the purpose of a reaction paper.
Twitter.
English for Academic and Professional Purposes English for Academic and Professional Purposes
i. Evaluate the text's strengths and weaknesses, Annotating in the margins of the text allows you to
along with if and how well the text accomplishes its easily locate quotations, plot lines, character
objective. development, or reactions to the text. If you fail to
j. Have a close reading of the text that goes beyond annotate thoroughly, it will be more difficult to create a
the surface meaning. cohesive reaction paper.
Figure out exactly what your teacher or professor is Start questioning the text. This is where your evaluation
looking for. Some teachers want you to react by of the material and your reaction begins.
analyzing or evaluating the reading. Other teachers want
a personal response. B. Drafting Your Essay
3. Read the text you are assigned right after it is 1. Free write
assigned.
Put into words what you think the author is trying to do
and whether you agree or disagree.
Give yourself time to do the readings, but more
importantly, to digest what you've read so you can put
2. Decide on your angle.
the ideas together.
Decide what your angle is. Keep asking yourself the
same questions as you craft a coherent reaction.
4. Write down your initial reactions.
Think about why the author has written the article or
story as they have. Why did he structure things in this
Jot down your initial reactions to the text. Do the same
particular way? How does this relate to the outside
thing on any subsequent readings. world?
33
Try completing some of the following sentences after
3. Determine your thesis.
you read: I think that..., I see that..., I feel that..., It
Start to state why what you said is interesting and
seems that..., or In my opinion...
important. This is the core of your reaction paper.
5. Annotate the text as you read. Take all your points, opinions, and observations, and
combine them into one claim that you will prove.
English for Academic and Professional Purposes English for Academic and Professional Purposes
Your thesis will be one statement that explains what you 1. Write your introduction.
will analyze, criticize, or try to prove about the text. It
will force your reaction paper to remain focused. Make sure your introductory paragraph states the name
of the text, the author, and the focus of your paper.
4. Organize your paper. You may also want to include the year of publication
and the publication it was taken from if relevant.
It needs an introduction, body paragraphs, and a It is also good to include the topic of the text and the
conclusion. author's purpose.
Each body paragraph should directly support your thesis.
2. Reread your reaction paragraphs to ensure you make
Organize your reactions together into a few common a stance.
topics so you can write them into paragraphs.
Although most reaction papers don't ask specifically for
5. Gather quotations your personal opinion, you should be critiquing,
analyzing, and evaluating the text, rather than just
Find quotations that will support your points. sticking to the facts.
Look at your annotations for quotations that support 3. Explain the greater implications of the text for the
your thesis. class, author, audience, or yourself.
Decide how to structure your paragraph. You can start 4. Edit for clarity and length.
with what the author says and follow that with your
reaction. Or you can start with the author and then Since reaction papers are usually short, you don't want
follow with how your reaction contrasts. them to be long. They can range from 500 words to 5
pages.
Make sure to read your assignment carefully to make getting through the day and handing the child back to the parents. For Emily, it
is the time she spends with the baby that she discovers her maternal, nurturing
sure you follow directions.
instinct has been awakened and feels her biological clock has begun to tick. It is
this new revelation that has her contemplating the idea of marriage and starting a
5. Proof and spell check your document. family—with her boyfriend, Andrew. On the other hand, the vibe from Andrew
is he sees the child as nothing more than a distraction to his everyday routine, the
Proof by reading for grammar errors. Look for run ons, reason that is keeping him away from his computer and his writing. Andrew is a
fragments, verb tense issues, and punctuation errors. man self-absorbed in his work. He is happy with the status quo, but Emily is
now longing for something more. It is their different reactions to the experiences
Check for spelling
of the day that causes them to question their life together and the possibility that
neither one of them might be “marriage material.” This short film does a fairly
6. Ask yourself if you responded to the assignment good job of showing how social devaluation, dominant cultural values and even
adequately. self-concept play a role in our daily interactions, as well as the choices we make.
Marriage Material allowed the viewer to look at the complexities of a To be printed in a short bond paper
relationship through the lives of two young people. We could see how things as
dominant cultural values, social devaluation and a person’s own self-concept can Font Style: Times New Roman
lead to a breakdown in how we communicate. To me, I felt the film was like a
three-part play with each act allowing us to look a little deeper into their Font Size: 12
relationship. Each act connecting to the other to show how one little event can
snowball into a much larger event. In the case of Andrew and Emily, it was
something as little as a seven-month old baby that caused Emily to stop
suppressing her desire to have a baby. For Andrew, the caring of the baby only
proved to be a distraction in his writing. From watching the interaction and
dialog between the two of them throughout the film, it became apparent they did
not place the same emphasis on society’s institution of marriage. In the last few
scenes of the film, we see both of them outside doing yard work. They are still
together, but somehow there is a great divide between them. Something has
changed for both of them. There is a sense of defeat in Emily, a kind of sadness.
She knows that Andrew is not “marriage material,” so where does she fit into his
life. Andrew must also re-evaluate his feelings for Emily. Can he change his
values to fit hers, does he even want to? Initially, I thought based on the
description of the film, “a couple agrees to watch a friends’ baby,” that it might
have some light-hearted moments…two inexperienced twenty-something’s
trying to care for a baby. Instead it was the complete opposite. It was a great film
to watch from a sociological standpoint. It was just sad to watch the breakdown
and deterioration of a relationship.
make your own conclusions about the meanings of those Move into a summary of the book's themes and main
papers. points.
Keep the summary short, to the point, and informative.
How to Write A Review Paper?
4. Evaluate and critique the book.
A. Preparing to Write Your Review Shift into your critical analysis. This the heart of your
review, so be as direct and clear as you can.
1. Read the book and take notes. Address how well the book has achieved its goal, how to
book compares to other books on the subject, specific
2. Think about the book's genre and/or field of study. points that were not convincing or lacked development,
and what personal experiences.
3. Determine the major themes of the book.
5. Wrap up the review.
4. Consider the author's writing style. Examine the strengths and weaknesses of the book, and
discuss whether or not you would recommend the book
5. Make note of the book's format, if relevant. to others.
7. Think about how unique the book is. 1. Reread and revise your review.
2. Get feedback.
8. Assess how successful the book is. 3. Always submit your best work.
B. Creating a First Draft of the Review
Sample Review Paper
1. Begin with a heading.
2. Write an introduction. THE SCARLET LETTER
Ensure your introduction contains relevant details like A Book 41
Review
the author's background, and if applicable, their
previous work in the genre. The Scarlet Letter, a romantic work of fiction in a historical
setting is considered Nathaniel Hawthorne's magnum opus. Set in
3. Write a summary of the book. 17th-century Puritan Boston during the years 1642 to 1649, it tells
the story of Hester Prynne, who conceives a daughter through an
adulterous affair and struggles to create a new life of repentance and
English for Academic and Professional Purposes English for Academic and Professional Purposes
dignity. Throughout the book, Hawthorne explores themes of impressions. Follow the suggestions below to learn to write
legalism, sin, and guilt.... The book's immediate and lasting success a thorough and impressive article critique.
are due to the way it addresses spiritual and moral issues from a
uniquely American standpoint. In 1850, adultery was an extremely
risque subject, but because Hawthorne had the support of the New
A. Becoming an Active Reader
England literary establishment, it passed easily into the realm of
appropriate reading. It has been said that this work represents the 1. Read through the article once to get the main idea.
height of Hawthorne's literary genius; dense with terse descriptions. 2. Form a vague opinion.
It remains relevant for its philosophical and psychological depth, and 3. Make a preliminary list of possible places to search
continues to be read as a classic tale on a universal theme. for evidence.
The style of Hawthorne is purity itself. His tone is singularly B. Gathering Evidence
effective—wild, plaintive, thoughtful, and in full accordance with his
themes... We look upon him as one of the few men of indisputable
genius to whom our country has as yet given birth. 1. Question whether the writer's overall message is
logical.
It is beautiful, admirable, extraordinary; it has in the highest 2. Examine the author's introduction and conclusion to
degree that merit which I have spoken of as the mark of Hawthorne's make sure they match up as supporting elements.
best things--an indefinable purity and lightness of conception...One 3. Search the article for any bias demonstrated on behalf
can often return to it; it supports familiarity and has the inexhaustible of the author.
charm and mystery of great works of art 4. Consider the author's interpretation of other scholarly
texts.
If we have a national heroine of our version of the Protestant
will in America, then it must be Hester Prynne, Hawthorne's triumph.
5. Remember that a critique doesn't have to be entirely
positive or entirely negative.
HOW TO WRITE AN ART CRITIQUE? o The particular interest to the formalist critic are the
elements of form—style, structure, tone, imagery,
1. Describe what you see. This is the objective portion of etc.—that are found within the text or work.
the art critique. It involves a technical description- o A primary goal for formalist critics is to determine
nothing more. how such elements work together with the text’s
2. Analyze the artwork. Evolve the art criticism from a content to shape its effects upon readers.
technical description to an in-depth examination of how
the technical elements were utilized by the artist to 2. Biographical Criticism
create the overall impression conveyed by the artwork.
3. Interpret the artwork. This part of an art critique is o This is about an understanding of an author’s life.
more subjective than the others, as you are expected to o A biographical critic must be careful not to take the
use your analysis of the technical aspects of the piece of biographical facts of a writer’s life too far in
art to apply your own supposition to the artist's intended criticizing the works of that writer.
purpose for the artwork.
4. Evaluate the artwork. This is a summation of the art 3. Historical Criticism
criticism process leading up to this point. Use your
analysis and interpretation to draw conclusions and o This is done by investigating the social, cultural,
reach judgments about the artwork. and intellectual context that produced it.
5. Say how the art piece comes across to you: o A key goal for historical critics is to understand the
What do you think could be done better?
effect of a literary work upon its original readers.
Why didn't the artist do it that way?
How is this picture unique in its composition? 4. Gender Criticism
What have you gained through examining this
picture? o This approach “examines how sexual identity
influences the creation and reception of literary
TYPES OF CRITICAL APPROACHES works or art works.”
o Feminist criticism attempts to correct the
1. Formalist Criticism imbalance by analyzing and combating such
attitudes—by questioning, for example, why none
o All the elements necessary for understanding the of the characters in Shakespeare’s play Othello ever
work are contained within the work itself. challenge the right of a husband to murder a wife
45
accused of adultery.
English for Academic and Professional Purposes English for Academic and Professional Purposes
AN AFTERNOON AT 47
LA GRANDE JETTE
English for Academic and Professional Purposes English for Academic and Professional Purposes
CRITICAL APPROACHES
Complete the table
by writing the different critical approaches. Have a
RICHARD MCKINLEY short definition in each approach.
- a short summary that tells the reader what the project is, o Include information on incidence or prevalence and
why it is important, and how it will be carried out. severity of the problem in children.
o Describe what is not known about the problem that the
- serves as a prelude to a full paper. What is the full paper proposal intends to address.
all about? The full paper may be a thesis, a program, a o Include any preliminary data or additional background
project, or anything that will require a longer time to information indicating the rationale for the proposed
prepare. research.
- may also be used as an instructional tool that may have b. Objective(s) and Hypothesis(es)
developed as a result of extensive research, committee
o Describe the precise objective(s) of the proposed
input and/or as a result of the outcome of a current
research.
project.
o State the specific hypothesis(es) to be tested.
c. Design
Format of Concept Paper
o Describe the basic design of the study.
1. Page One: Administrative Information
o Indicate the primary outcomes and how they will be
measured.
a. Title of the Study
b. Principal Investigator d. Potential Impact
c. Length of Study (Maximum 3 years)
o Discuss where the research is leading and in what
d. Estimated Total Budget ways and in how many years the findings might
e. Supervising Institution potentially influence the prevention, diagnosis and/or
treatment of the particular medical problem in
f. Project Site(s) children.
50 51
English for Academic and Professional Purposes English for Academic and Professional Purposes
3. Page Three: Structured Lay Summary - It is important to support your argument with evidence
to ensure the validity of your claims, as well as to refute
a. The lay summary should be 250 words or less and is the counterclaims to show that you are well informed
intended as a brief, simplified summary for those who about both sides.
may not have scientific training.
- A good position paper will not only provide facts but
I should include three sections: also make proposals for resolutions.
Background
Objective(s) and Hypothesis(es) (one sentence per Steps in Writing a Position Writing
objective/hypothesis).
Potential Impact 1. Select a Topic
- a formal, usually detailed written statement, especially o Preliminary research is necessary to determine
regarding a single issue, that articulates a position, whether evidence is available to back up your stance.
viewpoint, or policy, as of a government, organization, o Search a few reputable sites, like educations sites and
or political candidate. government sites, to find professional studies and
statistics.
- Like a debate, a position paper presents one side of an
arguable opinion about an issue. 3. Challenge Your Own Topic
- The goal of a position paper is to convince the audience o You must know the opposite view as well your own
that your opinion is valid and defensible. stance when you take a position.
o You must know all the possible challenges that you
- Your job is to take one side of the argument and might face as you support your view.
persuade your audience that you have well-founded
knowledge of the topic being presented.
English for Academic and Professional Purposes English for Academic and Professional Purposes
o Your position paper must address the opposing view b. List possible objections to your position.
and chip away at it with counter evidence.
o You must find arguments for the other side of your Sample points:
position, present those arguments or points in a fair
manner, and then state why they are not sound. o Such labels would affect profits of major corporations.
o Many people would see this as overreaching
53
4. Continue to Collect Supporting Evidence government control. 54
o Whose job is it to determine which restaurants are bad?
o Once you’ve determined that your position is Who draws the line?
supportable and the opposite position is (in your o The program would be costly.
opinion) weaker than your own, you are ready to
branch out with your research. c. Support and acknowledgement of the opposing points.
o Try to collect a variety of sources, to include an
expert’s opinion (doctor, lawyer, or professor, for Sample points:
example) and personal experience (from a friend or
family member) that can add an emotional appeal to o It would be difficult and expensive for any entity to
your topic. determine which restaurants should adhere to the
policy.
5. Create an Outline o Nobody wants to see the government overstepping its
boundaries.
A position paper might be arranged in the following format: o Funding would fall onto the shoulders of taxpayers.
a. Introduce your topic with a little background d. Explain that your position is still the best one, despite
information. Build up to your thesis sentence, which the strength of counter arguments.
asserts your position.
Sample points:
Sample points:
o The cost would be countered by the improvement of
o For decades, the FDA has required that warning labels public health.
should be placed on certain products that pose a threat o Restaurants might improve the standards of food if
to public health. warning labels were put into place.
o Fast food restaurants are bad for our health. o One role of the government is to keep citizens safe.
o Fast food packages should contain warning labels.
English for Academic and Professional Purposes English for Academic and Professional Purposes
o The government already does this with drugs and 6. Let the bullets fly. Create a bulleted list of your
cigarettes. proposals along with your most important facts and
statistics so that you will not lose time looking for them
6. Summarize your argument and restate your position. during debate.
what new users expect from your services, and whether 3. Surveys can be created quickly and administered easily.
users are satisfied with what you provide.
4. Surveys can be used to collect information on a broad
range of things, including personal facts, attitudes, past
behaviors and opinions.
o The information you need isn't readily available 4. The social desirability bias can lead people to respond in
through other means. a way that makes them look better than they really are.
For example, a respondent might report that they engage
in more healthy behaviors than they do in real life.
ADVANTAGES OF USING SURVEY
TYPES OF SURVEYS
1. Surveys allow researchers to collect a large amount of
data in a relatively short period. A. According to Instrumentation
1. QUESTIONNAIRE - is a paper-and-pencil instrument
2. Surveys are less expensive than many other data that is administered to the respondents.
collection techniques. Advantage of Using Questionnaires:
English for Academic and Professional Purposes English for Academic and Professional Purposes
Ideal for asking closed-ended questions; effective for 3. Multiple choice: Allow the respondent to select one
market or consumer research answer from a few possible choices.
Disadvantages of Using Questionnaires: Example: “I smoke cigarettes … a) every time, b) most
times, c) sometimes, d) rarely, e) never."
Limit the researcher to understand the respondent’s
answers. 4. Likert scale: Each respondent is asked to rate items on a
Requires budget for reproduction of survey response scale. For instance, they could rate each item
questionnaires. on a 1-to-5 response.
FORMS OF QUESTIONNAIRES
AGREEMENT
Strongly disagree Completely disagree
Disagree Disagree Mostly disagree
Neither agree nor Neither agree nor Slightly disagree
disagree disagree Slightly agree
Agree Agree Mostly agree
Strongly agree Completely agree
OCCURRENCES
Very rarely Never
Not at all
Rarely Seldom
Little
Occasionally About half the time
Occasionally
Frequently Usually
Often all thetime
Very frequently Always
Never
Never
Not really Rarely
Seldom
Somewhat Sometimes
Sometimes
Quite a bit Often
Often
Always
QUALITY
Poor Very poor Extremely poor
Fair Not good Below average
Average All right Average
Good Good Above average
Excellent Excellent Excellent
OVERALL IMPRESSION
Very dissatisfied
Not at all satisfied
Somewhat dissatisfied
Slightly satisfied
Neither satisfied nor dissatisfied
Somewhat satisfied
Somewhat satisfied
Very much satisfied
Very satisfied
Didn’t get what I wanted Very uncomfortable Date: ________________ Score:
Got a little of what I wanted Uncomfortable
Got a lot of what I wanted Comfortable
Got everything I wanted Very comfortable
63 64
English for Academic and Professional Purposes English for Academic and Professional Purposes
1. Cross-Sectional Surveys
o Collecting information from the respondents at a single
period in time uses the cross-sectional type of survey.
o Cross-sectional surveys are used to identify the
relationship between two variables, as in a comparative
study.
Example:
Administering a Cross-sectional Survey about the
Relationship of Peer Pressure and Cigarette Smoking
among Teenagers as of May 2010
2. Longitudinal Surveys
o Collecting information from the respondents over a
2. INTERVIEWS period of time or from one point in time up to another.
65 66
English for Academic and Professional Purposes English for Academic and Professional Purposes
ACTIVITY # 8
67 68
English for Academic and Professional Purposes English for Academic and Professional Purposes
Present your research results in detail. Rating scale questions can be those that explicitly ask
Display your results in the form of tables, charts and participants to rate their level of agreement or satisfaction
graphs, and incorporate descriptive text to explain from 1 to 5, 1 to 7 or any bounded number range. You can
also take questions that have ordered categories and assign
what these visuals mean, and to emphasize important
numbers. For example, strongly disagree to strongly
points. agree becomes 1 to 5.
Summarize the key points. This concise collection of
findings is similar to the Executive Summary.
Remember that thoughts expressed here must be Strongly Strongly
Disagree Normal Agree
supported by data. Disagree Agree
You may also mention anything that may be related to 1 2 3 4 5
this survey research, such as previous studies or survey
results that may prove useful if included.
3. Single Select
If participants are asked to pick one choice out of a
How To Summarize And Display Survey Data? number of alternatives, then this is a single-select
response option. We summarize the proportion that
1. Binary Responses - a question has only two possible chose each category.
response options.
Examples: Male/Female, Yes/No, Agree/Disagree For example, if respondents were asked the primary
method by which they pay their online bill (laptop,
When summarizing just the sample of respondents, smartphone, tablet or desktop), we can summarize this
such as the percent of women who responded, you can single-select question below.
use the ubiquitous pie graph. 49%
38%
40
% Female
10% 3%
60 Female
% Laptop Smart Phone Tablet Desktop
69 70
English for Academic and Professional Purposes English for Academic and Professional Purposes
4. Net Promoter Questions - is a rating scale, but is Sample Report Survey Findings
usually presented as a difference between two paired
proportions--the proportion of promoters minus the
proportion of detractors. An example NPS score of
46% is shown below.
14%
26%
Destractor
Passive
60%
Promoter
NPS = 46%
71 72
English for Academic and Professional Purposes English for Academic and Professional Purposes
This report was commissioned to examine why the sales volume of ACTIVITY # 9
Choice Chocolate has dropped over the past two years since its peak in
1998 and to recommend ways of increasing the volume. CONDUCTING SURVEYS
The research draws attention to the fact that in 1998, the market share of Conduct a survey using the questionnaire that you have
Choice Chocolate was 37%. The shares of their key competitors such as
Venus and Bradbury were 22% and 18% respectively. The size of the designed to the appropriate respondents.
chocolate market then was $36 million. Over the next two years,
although Choice Chocolate retained its market share the volume of sales For open-ended questionnaire: Minimum of 15
in the whole market decreased to $29 million. Further investigations respondents
reveal that this market shrinkage coincided with an increase in health
awareness amongst consumers who regard the milk and sugar
For rating scale questionnaire: Minimum of 30
ingredients in chocolate as negative; moreover, since the second half of
1999, an increasing number of rival ‘health candies’ had appeared on the respondents
market. These claimed to offer the consumers a healthy alternative.
These factors appear to be the major causes of the decreased sales DOING SUMMARY REPORTS
volume of Choice Chocolate.
Slim Choice is the latest chocolate range put forward by the R & D Tabulate the result of the survey that you conducted.
Department of Choice Chocolate. The report evaluates this range and Have a Narrative Summary of the report.
concludes that it would be an ideal candidate to meet the challenge
presented by the market and could satisfy the new consumer demand
since it uses significantly reduced milk and sugar ingredients and is
endorsed by renowned health experts. According to 97% of the 2000
subjects tested recently, it also retains the same flavour as the original
range.
It is recommended:
73 74
English for Academic and Professional Purposes English for Academic and Professional Purposes
REFERENCES http://simplyeducate.me/2012/10/31/how-to-write-a-
concept-paper/
Books
Internet
http://writing.wisc.edu/Handbook/
http://ctb.ku.edu/en/tableofcontents/assessment/ presentations_abstracts_examples.html
assessingcommunity-needs-and-resources/conduct-
surveys/main
http://www.adlit.org/strategies/23336/
http://essaysandreactionspapers.blogspot.com/2013/03/
every-child-is-special-reaction-paper.html http://www.austincc.edu/tmthomas/sample%20outline
%201.htm
http://forpd.ucf.edu/strategies/strattextstructure.html
http://www.litlovers.com/reading-guides/13-fiction/8768-
scarlet-letter-hawthorne?start=2
http://home.olemiss.edu/~egjbp/spring97/litcrit.html
http://www.plagiarism.org/citing-sources/how-to-
http://idea.uoregon.edu/~ncite/documents/techrep/ paraphrase/
tech17.htmlhttp://www.writing.utoronto.ca/advice/
reading-and-researching/summarize
http://www.sfu.ca/cmns/130d1/
WritingaPositionPaper.htm
http://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/619/02/
http://www.slideshare.net/Wangkig/components-of-a-
review-paper#related-tab-content
English for Academic and Professional Purposes English for Academic and Professional Purposes