Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2) What are the key responsibilities and functions of the Prime Minister's
Office in India, and how has its role evolved over the years in the context of
governance and decision-making at the national level?
Approach:
First step is to This is the direct question about prime minister's
understand the demand office and its role
of the question
4
more centralization of power
6
3) Analyze the role and functions of the Central Secretariat in the Indian
Government? Evaluate the challenges and criticisms faced by the Central
Secretariat in recent times, and suggest recommendations to improve its
efficiency and effectiveness.
Approach:
First step is to The directive word is Analyse is digging deeper than
understand the demand examine but into every aspect of the question. It is
of the question very necessary to dismantle the questions into parts
and explain.
Conclusion: Measures:-
reducing political interference
empowering the bureaucracy
Answer:
The Central Secretariat is the administrative backbone of the Indian Government,
and plays a key role in the decision-making process at the national level. Some of the
key roles and functions of the Central Secretariat include:
Policy formulation: The Central Secretariat is responsible for the formulation of
government policies and programs.
Coordination of government activities: The Central Secretariat coordinates
the activities of various government departments and agencies to ensure that
policies are implemented effectively.
Preparation of Cabinet notes and Memorandums: The Central Secretariat
prepares Cabinet notes and Memorandums for the Union Cabinet, which are
used to inform and guide the Cabinet's decision-making process.
Maintenance of records: The Central Secretariat maintains records of the
decisions taken by the Cabinet and other important government documents.
7
Inter-ministerial coordination: The Central Secretariat coordinates the work
of different Ministries, ensuring that their activities are aligned with overall
government policies and objectives.
Representation of the government: The Central Secretariat represents the
government in various national and international forums.
Public communication: The Central Secretariat is responsible for
communicating the policies and actions of the government to the public.
Allocation of work to the bureaucrats: The Central Secretariat plays a crucial
role in the allocation of work to bureaucrats in various Ministries.
Appointment of senior bureaucrats: The Central Secretariat is responsible for
the appointment of senior bureaucrats in the government.
Monitoring the performance of Government: The Central Secretariat is
responsible for monitoring the performance of government departments and
agencies.
The Central Secretariat, the administrative backbone of the Indian Government, has
faced several challenges and criticisms in recent times:
Bureaucratic delays and inefficiency: The Central Secretariat has been
criticized for bureaucratic delays and inefficiency in decision-making, which can
hinder the implementation of government policies and programs.
Lack of transparency and accountability: There have been concerns about a
lack of transparency and accountability in the functioning of the Central
Secretariat, which can lead to a lack of public trust in government.
Political interference: The Central Secretariat has been criticized for being
influenced by political considerations, rather than focusing on the merits of a
policy or program.
Overlap of functions: There have been concerns about the overlap of functions
between the Central Secretariat and other government bodies, leading to
confusion and inefficiency.
Difficulty in implementation of policies: The Central Secretariat has faced
challenges in the implementation of policies, due to resistance from various
Ministries, lack of resources and lack of coordination with the states.
Lack of expertise and human resource: The Central Secretariat has been
criticized for the lack of expertise and human resource to handle complex issues
and challenges.
Digitalization and modernizing the system: The Central Secretariat has been
criticized for being slow in adopting digitalization and modernizing the system,
which can lead to inefficiency and lack of transparency.
Lack of participation from the civil society: The Central Secretariat has been
8
criticized for not involving the civil society in the policy making process, which
can lead to a lack of public support for government policies.
To improve the efficiency and effectiveness of the Central Secretariat in the Indian
Government, the following recommendations can be considered:
Streamlining bureaucratic processes: The Central Secretariat should work to
streamline bureaucratic processes and reduce delays in decision-making, to
improve the speed and efficiency of government policy implementation.
Greater transparency and accountability: The Central Secretariat should work
to increase transparency and accountability in its decision-making processes, to
build public trust in government.
Reducing political interference: The Central Secretariat should work to reduce
political interference in its decision-making processes, to ensure that policies
and programs are based on merit and not political considerations.
Greater coordination with other government bodies: The Central Secretariat
should work to improve coordination with other government bodies to reduce
overlap of functions and improve overall efficiency.
Empowering the bureaucracy: The Central Secretariat should work to
empower the bureaucracy with the necessary resources and support to
effectively implement government policies and programs.
Involvement of Civil society: The Central Secretariat should work to involve
the civil society in the policy making process, to ensure that the policies made
are inclusive and have the support of the public.
Adoption of digitalization and modernizing the system: The Central
Secretariat should work to adopt digitalization and modernizing the system to
increase transparency, accountability and efficiency in the decision-making
process.
Human Resource Development: The Central Secretariat should work to
improve the human resource development, by providing regular training and
capacity building programs to the bureaucrats, to handle complex issues and
challenges.
Better coordination with the States: The Central Secretariat should work to
improve coordination with the States, to ensure that the policies are
implemented effectively, by taking into account the ground realities and the
needs of the states.
Evaluation and monitoring mechanism: The Central Secretariat should
establish an effective evaluation and monitoring mechanism to evaluate the
performance of various departments, to ensure that the policies are being
implemented as intended.
Conclusion:-
9
Overall, these recommendations aim to improve the efficiency and effectiveness of
the Central Secretariat by streamlining bureaucratic processes, increasing transparency
and accountability, reducing political interference, empowering the bureaucracy,
involving the civil society, adopting digitalization, improving human resource
development, better coordination with the states and by establishing an effective
evaluation and monitoring m
Source:-
https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/over-1600-posts-in-central-secretari
at-service-vacant-as-officers-not-promoted/article66144351.ece
https://cabsec.gov.in/
4) Explain the powers and functions of urban local bodies in India and how do
they impact the development and management of cities?
Approach:
First step is to The directive word esplain Clarify a topic by giving a
understand the demand detailed account as to how and why it occurs, or what
of the question is meant by the use of this term in a particular
context. Your writing should have clarity so that
complex procedures or sequences of events can be
understood; defining key terms where appropriate
and be substantiated with relevant research.
11
The discretionary functions are those that a municipal body may take up if funds
permit. These are given less priority. Some of the discretionary functions are
construction and maintenance of rescue homes and orphanages, housing for low
income groups, organising public receptions, provision of treatment facilities,
etc.
Urban governance plays a crucial role in the development and management of
cities in India. The powers and functions of urban local bodies (ULBs) as outlined
in the 74th Constitutional Amendment Act of 1992, provide a framework for the
planning and implementation of policies and projects that promote the economic
and social development of urban areas.
Effective urban governance can lead to the provision of basic services such as
water supply, sanitation, and solid waste management, which improve the
quality of life for residents. It can also facilitate the development of
infrastructure such as roads, transportation, and housing, which can attract
investment and promote economic growth. ULBs also play a key role in land-use
planning and regulation, which can help prevent haphazard development and
preserve the city's natural and built heritage.
However, the success of urban governance in promoting the development and
management of cities also depends on the effective participation and cooperation
of various stakeholders, including the state government, private sector, and civil
society. Urban governance also faces several challenges, such as lack of financial
resources, inadequate capacity, and limited participation of citizens in
decision-making.
Moreover, the role of urban governance is important in addressing the emerging
challenges of the cities, such as the increasing population, the strain on the
infrastructure, the need for sustainable development, and the need for inclusive
development. The ability of ULBs to address these challenges will have a direct
impact on the livability and resilience of the cities.
Conclusion:-
Overall, urban governance plays a critical role in shaping the development and
management of cities in India, and its success depends on the effective coordination and
cooperation of various stakeholders, as well as the ability to address the challenges and
emerging issues in the cities.
source:-
https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/social-sciences/urban-governance
12
5) Examine the role and significance of co-operatives in the economic
development of India. Discuss the measures taken by the government to
promote their growth and sustainability.
Approach:
First step is to The directive word Examine:- Examine
understand the demand Look in close detail and establish the key facts and
of the question important issues surrounding a topic. You should try
and offer reasons as to why the facts and issues you
have identified are the most important, as well as
explain the different ways they could be construed.
source:-
https://www.ica.coop/en/cooperatives/what-is-a-cooperative
https://www.gov.mb.ca/jec/busdev/coop/types.html
https://www.business.tas.gov.au/manage_a_business/tax/choosing_a_business_st
ructure/co-operative_-_advantages_and_disadvantages
15
Introduction: define service delivery systems.
16
diversion of subsidies away from the intended beneficiaries and makes it difficult
for marginalized communities to access services.
Lack of political will: The lack of political will, particularly at the local level, to
implement policies and programs to provide access to services for marginalized
communities can impede the effectiveness of these systems.
Lack of community participation: The lack of community participation in the
design and implementation of programs and policies can lead to a lack of
ownership and sustainability of the systems.
Inadequate coverage and reach: The coverage and reach of these systems are
often inadequate, particularly for marginalized communities in remote and rural
areas, making it difficult for them to access services.
The government of India has taken several measures to address the challenges faced by
the systems for delivery of services in providing access to services for marginalized
communities. Some of the main measures are:
Policies and programs: The government has launched several schemes and
programs to improve the infrastructure and capacity of the systems for delivery
of services, such as the National Health Mission and the Sarva Shiksha Abhiyan.
These schemes aim to improve the accessibility and quality of services for
marginalized communities.
Financial assistance: The government provides financial assistance to systems
for delivery of services through institutions such as the National Cooperative
Development Corporation (NCDC) and the National Cooperative Union of India
(NCUI). These institutions provide financial assistance for development
activities, capacity building, and other forms of support.
Legal framework: The government has enacted laws and regulations to promote
the growth and sustainability of systems for delivery of services. For example,
the Multi-State Cooperative Societies Act, 2002, provides a legal framework for
the registration and regulation of multi-state systems for delivery of services,
and the Cooperative Societies Act, 1912 governs the registration and regulation
of systems for delivery of services at the state level.
Community participation: The government promotes community participation in
the design and implementation of programs and policies by involving
community-based organizations and civil society groups. This helps to ensure
that the needs and priorities of marginalized communities are taken into
account.
Anti-corruption measures: The government has implemented anti-corruption
measures such as the Public Services Guarantee Act, 2011 which aims to ensure
that citizens have access to services within a specified time frame and also have
the right to file complaints when services are not provided within the specified
time frame.
17
Increasing coverage and reach: The government is implementing measures to
increase the coverage and reach of services, particularly in remote and rural
areas. For example, the Pradhan Mantri Jan Dhan Yojana (PMJDY) aims to
increase financial inclusion for marginalized communities by providing them
with access to banking services.
Conclusion:-
the government has taken several measures to address the challenges faced by the
systems for delivery of services in providing access to services for marginalized
communities. These measures include launching schemes and programs, providing
financial assistance, enacting laws and regulations, promoting community participation,
implementing anti-corruption measures, and increasing coverage and reach of services.
However, the implementation of these measures has been found to be weak and the
systemic issues continue to impede the effectiveness of these systems in providing
access to services for marginalized communities.
source:-
https://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/Thiruvananthapuram/improve-service-
delivery-govt-told/article31064423.ece
https://www.lawinsider.com/dictionary/service-delivery-system
https://www.sigmaweb.org/ourexpertise/service-delivery.htm
7) What are the major issues facing the Indian healthcare system and what
steps can be taken to address them, with a focus on increasing access to
healthcare for marginalized communities?
Approach:
First step is to It is the direct question about Health care sector in
understand the demand India.
of the question
BODY: Challenges
poor Accessibility to health care
poor infrastructure
low affordability
low quality of care
18
Measures:-
Increasing investment
expanding health insurance
community participation
19
To address these challenges, steps that can be taken include:
Increasing investment in healthcare infrastructure and equipment, particularly
in marginalized communities.
Providing incentives and training programs to attract and retain healthcare
professionals, particularly in marginalized communities.
Expanding health insurance coverage, particularly for marginalized
communities, to make healthcare more affordable.
Improving the quality of care provided by healthcare facilities, through measures
such as regular monitoring and accreditation.
Increasing community participation in healthcare planning and delivery, to
ensure that services are tailored to the specific needs of marginalized
communities.
Addressing the social determinants of health, such as poverty and malnutrition,
which can contribute to poor health outcomes for marginalized communities.
Focusing on preventative care, including vaccination and health education, to
help reduce the burden of non-communicable diseases among marginalized
communities.
Providing mental health services and creating awareness about mental health
among marginalized communities.
Providing COVID-19 vaccines to marginalized communities, along with providing
information and access to testing and treatment facilities.
Conclusion:-
He healthcare sector in India is facing significant challenges in terms of access,
quality, and affordability, and there is a need for increased investment as recommended
by National Health policy,2017.
source:-
https://www.thehindu.com/opinion/op-ed/strengthening-healthcare/article372
00628.ece
https://www.thehindu.com/opinion/lead/india-needs-a-renewed-health-care-sy
stem/article62105791.ece
20
8) Examine the status of women empowerment in India and suggest measures
to address the existing challenges in achieving gender equality in the
country, with a focus on the role of government policies and societal
attitudes.
Approach:
First step is to The key words Examine is to Look in close detail and
understand the demand establish the key facts and important issues
of the question surrounding a topic. You should try and offer reasons
as to why the facts and issues you have identified are
the most important, as well as explain the different
ways they could be construed.
BODY: Challenges
challenges in acheiving gender equality:-
lack of political representation
health disparities
economic Inequality
Measures:-
economic empowerment via financial
ninclusion
education and awareness
21
compared to men.
Societal attitudes also play a role in shaping the status of women in India. Despite
the progress made in some areas, discrimination and gender-based violence
against women remain prevalent issues. Additionally, traditional patriarchal
norms and stereotypes continue to limit the opportunities and choices available
to women.
The existing challenges in achieving gender equality in India are multifaceted and
include:
Societal attitudes and stereotypes: Traditional patriarchal norms and
stereotypes continue to limit the opportunities and choices available to women,
and discrimination and gender-based violence against women remain prevalent
issues.
Lack of political representation: Women are underrepresented in politics, with
less than 10% of members of parliament being women, which limits their ability
to shape policies and laws that affect them.
Health disparities: Women in India face significant health disparities, such as a
higher maternal mortality rate and a lower life expectancy compared to men.
This is due to a lack of access to quality healthcare, and inadequate nutrition and
sanitation facilities.
Economic inequality: Women in India are paid less than men for the same work
and have less access to financial resources and credit, which limits their ability to
participate fully in the economy.
Education: Despite an increase in female literacy rate, there is a significant
gender gap in terms of education and enrollment in schools, especially in rural
areas.
Lack of legal protection: India has laws to protect women from discrimination
and violence, but enforcement is weak, and the judicial process is slow and often
insensitive to the needs of victims.
Reproductive rights: Women in India still lack control over their own bodies and
face cultural and legal barriers to accessing safe and legal abortion and
contraception.
Climate change: Climate change disproportionately affects women, who are often
responsible for providing food, water, and fuel for their families and
communities.
COVID-19 pandemics: COVID-19 pandemics have further exacerbated the
existing inequalities and discrimination towards women in terms of access to
healthcare, education, and employment.
To address the existing challenges in achieving gender equality in India, several
measures can be taken, with a focus on the role of government policies and
22
societal attitudes:
Education and awareness: Government policies and programs should focus on
educating and raising awareness about gender equality among all members of
society, including men and boys, to change societal attitudes and stereotypes that
perpetuate gender inequality.
Political representation: The government should implement measures such as
quotas for women in political positions to ensure that women have a voice in
shaping policies and laws that affect them.
Health: The government should invest in healthcare infrastructure and
programs to address health disparities, including maternal health and nutrition
programs for women and girls.
Economic empowerment: The government should implement policies and
programs to promote economic empowerment for women, such as providing
access to financial resources and credit, and ensuring equal pay for equal work.
Education: The government should invest in education and support programs
for girls, and provide incentives for families to send their girls to schools.
Legal protection: The government should ensure that laws to protect women
from discrimination and violence are effectively enforced and that the judicial
process is sensitive to the needs of women.
Reproductive rights: The government should ensure that women have access to
safe and legal abortion and contraception, and provide education and awareness
on these issues.
Climate change: The government should consider the specific needs of women
in its climate change policies and programs, and ensure that women are included
in decision-making processes.
COVID-19 pandemics: The government should take measures to ensure that
women have access to COVID-19 vaccines and other healthcare services, and
provide support for women who have lost their jobs or income during the
pandemic.
Gender budgeting: The government should ensure that budget allocation and
its usage reflect the needs and concerns of women and girls.
Conclusion:-
It is important to note that these measures are interrelated and should be
implemented in a holistic and integrated manner to achieve sustainable progress
towards gender equality in the country. Additionally, it is crucial for the government to
actively involve women and civil society organizations in the design and
implementation of these measures.
source:-
23
https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/independence-day-women-status-an
d-freedom/article65771135.ece
https://www.thehindu.com/opinion/open-page/gender-equality-and-female-em
powerment-as-a-norm/article24956584.ece
9) What steps can be taken to address the major challenges facing the Indian
education system and improve access to quality education for all, with a
focus on reducing disparities and promoting inclusivity?
Approach:
First step is to It is the direct question about Education sector in
understand the demand India.
of the question
BODY: Challenges
Challenges in Indian education system:-
shortage of trained andd qualified teachers
acheivement based education
over reliance on rote learning
Measures require:-
Increasing governmnet spending on
education
Holisitc approach
Value based education
10) What are the challenges and potential solutions in implementing successful
public-private partnerships in India, specifically with regard to
infrastructure development?
Approach:
First step is to It is the direct question about challenges and potential
understand the demand of Public-private partnership
of the question
BODY: Challenges:-
lack of transparencY
inadequate capacity
socio-economic & environmental concerns
Solutions:-
innovative financing options
risk-sharing mechanism
improved project solution
Conclusion: Significance of PPP
Answer:
A public-private partnership (PPP) is a cooperative arrangement between the
public sector and the private sector to jointly undertake a project or activity that would
typically be the responsibility of the public sector alone. The goal of a PPP is to combine
the strengths of both sectors to achieve a mutually beneficial outcome, such as the
delivery of a public service or the construction of infrastructure.
26
The implementation of Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs) in India has been met
with a range of challenges, including:
Lack of transparency and regulatory oversight: This can lead to corruption
and lack of accountability, which can result in delays or even project
abandonment.
Difficulty in project structuring and financing: PPPs often require a complex
web of financing arrangements, which can make them difficult to implement.
Inadequate capacity in the public sector: The public sector often lacks the
skills and knowledge needed to effectively manage PPP projects, which can lead
to poor project outcomes.
Political risks and uncertainties: Political instability and changes in
government policies can disrupt or even cancel PPP projects, leading to huge
losses for private partners.
Risks of cost overruns and revenue shortfalls: These can erode the financial
viability of PPP projects and lead to disputes between public and private
partners.
Socio-economic and environmental concerns: PPP projects can often have
negative socio-economic and environmental impacts, such as displacement of
communities, and inadequate consideration of these impacts can lead to project
failure.
Complex legal and contractual frameworks: PPP contracts can be complex
and difficult to navigate, making it challenging to ensure that the interests of all
parties are protected.
Limited public sector resources: PPP projects often require significant
resources, such as land and financing, which the public sector may not have
readily available.
Limited private sector participation: PPP projects may not always be
attractive to private sector investors due to high risks, lack of regulatory
certainty, and lack of trust in government's ability to honor its commitment.
Limited understanding of PPPs: There is a limited understanding of PPPs in
India among stakeholders, which can lead to confusion and lack of confidence in
the model.
Potential solutions to the challenges of implementing successful public-private
partnerships (PPPs) in India include:
Strengthening regulatory and oversight frameworks: This can increase
transparency and accountability, helping to reduce corruption and ensure
projects are implemented on time and on budget.
Innovative financing options: These can help to reduce the financial risks of
PPP projects and make them more attractive to private investors.
27
Building capacity in the public sector: This can help to ensure that public
sector officials have the skills and knowledge needed to effectively manage PPP
projects.
Mitigating political risks: This can be done through building political consensus
and ensuring stability in government policies.
Risk-sharing mechanisms: This can help to ensure that the risks and benefits of
PPP projects are shared more equitably between public and private partners.
Improved project selection and structuring: This can be done by ensuring
that PPP projects are aligned with the public sector's objectives, and that the
risk-reward balance is appropriate for the private sector investors
Addressing socio-economic and environmental concerns: PPP projects can
often have negative socio-economic and environmental impacts, such as
displacement of communities, and adequate consideration of these impacts can
lead to project success
Simplifying legal and contractual frameworks: PPP contracts can be complex
and difficult to navigate, making it challenging to ensure that the interests of all
parties are protected, simplifying the legal and contractual frameworks can help
to reduce the complexity and increase the transparency of PPP projects
Encouraging private sector participation: The government can create an
environment that is conducive to private sector participation by providing the
necessary resources and regulatory certainty, which can increase private sector's
interest in PPPs.
Improving public-private communication and collaboration: Effective
communication and collaboration between the public and private sectors is
essential for the success of PPP projects. The government can facilitate this by
creating platforms for dialogue, consultation and collaboration between the two
sectors.
Conclusion:-
The Government of India has also introduced several policy measures to address
these challenges and promote PPPs, such as the National PPP Policy and the PPP
Appraisal Framework. These policies aim to create a more conducive environment for
PPPs, and to ensure that they are implemented in a transparent, accountable and
efficient manner.
Source:-
https://www.investopedia.com/terms/p/public-private-partnerships.asp
https://pib.gov.in/PressReleaseIframePage.aspx?PRID=1839350
https://www.pppinindia.gov.in/
28
11) What are the key principles and strategies for effective implementation of
Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) in India? Mention In what ways
corporate social responsibility promotes sustainable devlopment and
responsible corporate citizenship?
Approach:
First step is to This question is on the topic Corporate social
understand the demand responsibility. it demands to wtire the key principles of
of the question CSR and how it is contributing to the sustainable
devlopment.
30
adopt sustainable practices and promote responsible corporate citizenship.
Promoting transparency and accountability: CSR activities that include
transparent and accountable reporting on company performance can promote
responsible corporate citizenship by holding companies accountable for their
actions.
Creating shared value: CSR activities that create shared value for society and
the company can promote sustainable development and responsible corporate
citizenship by addressing social and environmental issues while also creating
economic opportunities.
Support for sustainable production and consumption: CSR initiatives that
support sustainable production and consumption can contribute to sustainable
development and responsible corporate citizenship by promoting
environmentally friendly products and services.
Conclusion:-
CSR activities that build trust and reputation among stakeholders can promote
sustainable development and responsible corporate citizenship by enhancing the
company's reputation and building relationships with stakeholders.
source:-
https://www.thehindu.com/opinion/op-ed/the-evolving-role-of-csr-in-funding-n
gos/article65861246.ece
12) What are the key principles and strategies for the formation and functioning
of Self-Help Groups (SHGs) in India, and how do they contribute to the
socio-economic development of marginalized communities and the
empowerment of women?
Approach:
First step is to The question is on the topic Self Help Groups. It
understand the demand demands to wrtie about the principles and contribution
of the question of self help groups
31
Contribution
economic empowerment
social capital
13) What are the key functions and powers of the Central Bureau of
Investigation (CBI) in India? Suggest some measures to improve the
functioning of CBI?
Approach:
First step is to It is the direct question about functions and power of
understand the demand the CBI
of the question
33
crime
providing assistance to state police
Challenges in functioning:-
political interference
lack of autonomy
limited resources
limited jurisdiction
Measures:-
ensuring autonomy and independence
amending laws and regulations
Conclusion: Significance of CBI as counter part of Interpol
Answer:
The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) is the premier investigative agency of
the Government of India. It was established in 1963 and operates under the jurisdiction
of the Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions. The CBI's mandate is to
investigate serious and complex cases of crime and corruption, including economic
offenses, organized crime, and terrorism.
The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) is the premier investigative agency of the
Government of India. Its key functions include:
Investigation of corruption cases involving public servants and other
individuals: The CBI has the mandate to investigate cases of corruption, bribery,
and other criminal offenses involving public servants and other individuals.
Investigation of serious and organized crime: The CBI investigates serious
and organized crime, such as economic offenses, organized crime, and terrorism.
Providing assistance to state police and other agencies: The CBI provides
assistance to state police and other agencies in the investigation of serious and
complex cases, as well as in the training of police personnel.
Coordination and sharing of information: The CBI coordinates and shares
information with other law enforcement agencies, both within India and
internationally, in order to combat crime and maintain law and order.
Prosecution of cases: The CBI has the power to prosecute cases in courts and to
represent the government in legal matters.
Collection and analysis of crime data: The CBI collects and analyzes crime data
to identify trends and patterns, and to develop strategies for preventing and
combating crime.
Protection of human rights: The CBI also has a mandate to investigate human
rights violations, and to ensure that the human rights of citizens are protected.
Acting as a nodal agency: The CBI acts as a nodal agency for Interpol in India
34
and coordinates with the Interpol in matters of mutual assistance and
cooperation.
Acting as a nodal agency for extradition: CBI acts as nodal agency for
extradition of criminals and provides assistance to the Ministry of External
Affairs for the same
Acting as a nodal agency for mutual legal assistance: CBI acts as nodal agency
for providing mutual legal assistance to foreign countries in criminal matters and
coordination with foreign law enforcement agencies.
The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) faces several challenges in its
functioning in India, including:
Political interference: The CBI has been criticized for being susceptible to
political influence and pressure, which can compromise its independence and
integrity.
Lack of autonomy: The CBI operates under the administrative control of the
Government of India, which can limit its autonomy and ability to function
independently.
Limited resources: The CBI often lacks the resources, such as funding and
personnel, to effectively investigate and prosecute complex cases.
Limited jurisdiction: The CBI's jurisdiction is limited to certain cases and
certain areas of the country, which can limit its ability to effectively combat
crime and corruption.
Limited statutory powers: The CBI's powers are limited by the laws under
which it operates, which can impede its ability to effectively investigate and
prosecute cases.
Limited technical and forensic capabilities: CBI lacks the necessary technical
and forensic capabilities to keep up with the modern trends of crime and thus,
it's investigation can be hindered.
Limited legal powers: CBI's legal powers are limited and it's functioning can be
hindered by the legal formalities and procedures.
Limited international cooperation: CBI's international cooperation is limited
and it's functioning can be hindered by the lack of mutual legal assistance and
extradition treaties with other countries.
Lack of transparency and accountability: CBI's functioning is opaque and
there is a lack of transparency and accountability in its investigations and
decision making.
Conflicting roles: CBI has to balance its role as a law enforcement agency and as
an agency to investigate corruption among public servants, which can lead to
conflicts in its functioning.
35
Measures that can be taken to improve the functioning of the Central Bureau of
Investigation (CBI) in India include:
Ensuring autonomy and independence: The CBI should be insulated from
political pressure and interference, and be given the autonomy and
independence it needs to function effectively.
Providing adequate resources: The CBI should be provided with adequate
resources, such as funding and personnel, to enable it to effectively investigate
and prosecute complex cases.
Amending laws and regulations: The laws and regulations governing the CBI
should be reviewed and amended as necessary to give it the powers and
jurisdiction it needs to effectively combat crime and corruption.
Enhancing technical and forensic capabilities: The CBI should be provided
with the necessary technical and forensic capabilities to keep up with the
modern trends of crime and improve its investigations.
Improving legal powers: The CBI's legal powers should be enhanced by
providing more flexible and effective legal procedures and frameworks that can
support its functioning.
Improving international cooperation: The CBI should be provided with better
international cooperation and mutual legal assistance frameworks to improve its
functioning.
Enhancing transparency and accountability: The CBI's functioning should be
made more transparent and accountable, by providing regular public reports on
its investigations and by making its decision-making processes more open and
accessible.
Establishing a separate body to investigate corruption among public
servants: The CBI's role as a law enforcement agency and as an agency to
investigate corruption among public servants should be separated, to avoid
conflicts and improve its functioning.
Conclusion:-
The CBI's mandate and objectives should be clearly defined and communicated to
the public and other stakeholders, to ensure effective functioning of CBI.
Source:-
https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/chief-justice-of-india-flags-falling-cre
dibility-of-cbi/article65282123.ece
https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/can-cbi-be-liberated-from-delhi-spec
ial-police-establishment-act-asks-sc/article65867157.ece
36
14) What are the principles of neutrality of the civil services? What are the
challenges to maintaining the neutrality of the civil services in the present
political climate? Also suggest some measures to ensure the neutrality of the
civil services in India.
Approach:
First step is to It is the question on the topic neutrality of civil services.
understand the demand
of the question
37
political party or group and should not actively participate in political activities.
Professionalism: Civil servants should discharge their duties in a professional
and competent manner, without letting personal beliefs or interests influence
their decisions.
Confidentiality: Civil servants are expected to maintain confidentiality of official
information and not disclose it to unauthorized persons.
Service to the government: Civil servants should work for the government of
the day and implement the policies and decisions of the government, even if they
may not personally agree with them.
Responsiveness: Civil servants must be responsive to the needs and concerns of
the public, and must work to ensure that the government's policies and
programs are implemented effectively and efficiently.
Transparency: Civil servants must conduct their work in a transparent and
accountable manner, and must be willing to explain their decisions and actions
to the public and to oversight bodies.
There are several challenges to maintaining the neutrality of the civil services in
the present political climate, some of which include:
Political Pressure: Civil servants are often subject to pressure from politicians
to make decisions that are favorable to their party or ideology. This can
compromise their ability to remain neutral and impartial in their work.
Lack of autonomy: Civil servants often lack the autonomy to make decisions
independently, as they are often expected to follow the instructions of their
political superiors.
Interference in appointments: Political interference in the appointment
process can lead to the selection of individuals who are not competent or who
are beholden to a particular party or group, which can compromise the
neutrality of the civil services.
Lack of protection for whistleblowers: A lack of protection for whistleblowers
can deter civil servants from reporting instances of political interference or
misconduct, which can further undermine the neutrality of the civil services.
Political polarization: The increasing polarization of Indian politics can lead to
a situation where civil servants are expected to take sides and support one
political party or ideology over another, which can compromise their neutrality.
Lack of transparency in decision making: Civil servants may take decisions
which are not transparent or not in the public interest but in the interest of the
ruling party, which can compromise their neutrality.
Lack of accountability: Civil servants may not be held accountable for their
actions, which can lead to misconduct and a lack of transparency, which can
compromise their neutrality.
38
There are several measures that can be taken to ensure the neutrality of the civil
services in India:
Autonomy: Civil servants should be given autonomy to make decisions
independently, without fear of political retaliation.
Protection for whistleblowers: Civil servants should be given protection for
reporting instances of political interference or misconduct.
Transparent appointment process: The appointment process for civil servants
should be transparent and based on merit, to ensure that competent individuals
are selected for these positions.
Code of conduct: A code of conduct for civil servants should be established,
outlining the ethical and professional responsibilities of civil servants to ensure
their neutrality in the discharge of their duties.
Transparency in decision making: Civil servants should be transparent in their
decision-making process and be willing to explain their decisions and actions to
the public and to oversight bodies.
Professional training: Civil servants should be given professional training to
develop the skills and knowledge needed to discharge their duties in a neutral
and impartial manner.
Grievance redressal mechanism: A mechanism should be established to
address grievances and complaints of political interference or misconduct by
civil servants.
Performance appraisal: Civil servants should be evaluated based on their
performance, not on their loyalty to a particular political party or group.
Conclusion:
There should be a clear separation between politics and administration, to ensure
that civil servants are able to discharge their duties in a neutral and impartial
manner.
Source:-
https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/0019556119580101?journalCo
de=ipaa
39
15) Examine the challenges faced by marginalized and disadvantaged groups in
accessing information under the Right to Information Act, 2005 and suggest
ways to address them.
Approach:
First step is to The key word Examine is to Look in close detail and
understand the demand establish the key facts and important issues
of the question surrounding a topic. You should try and offer reasons
as to why the facts and issues you have identified are
the most important, as well as explain the different
ways they could be construed.
BODY: Challenges:-
literacy and language barriers
access to information centres
financial cosntraints
Measures:-
creating awareness
providing support
waving or reducing fees
42