Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Introduction
Ben Hogan, in his book [1], stated that "golf begins with
a good grip". This admonition has been echoed by
virtually all golf instructors, who uniformly emphasise
the importance of a good grip as being the fundamental
keystone of a good golf swing. Why do all golf instructors
place major emphasis on a good grip?
In the modern, total body golf swing, where the rotating
torso is the major power generator of the golf swing, the
arms and hands are flung around, and in front, of the
rotating body during the downswing. The major function
of the hands is to hold firmly onto the golf club - the hands
should be thought of as simply being "clamps" that firmly
hold onto the club while the club is swung through the
impact zone. The hands should not actively manipulate
the golf club during the impact zone. David Leadbetter
states "that one should think of the hands as conductors
through which the speed and power created by the turning
motion of your body is transferred to the clubhead" [2].
In this photo of Aaron Baddeley near-impact, note that
the clubface is approaching the ball so that it will become
square to the ball-target line at the time of impact.
Aaron Baddeley - from reference number [3]
The primary function of the hands is to hold onto the
clubshaft in such a manner that the clubface will be
allowed to become square to the ball-target line at the
time of impact, and this feat is best accomplished if the
hands are in the neutral position (palms facing each other
across the clubshaft, while being square to the target).
Consider the fact that the clubhead may be travelling at
>100 mph at the time of impact. At such a high velocity,
the golfer cannot possibly make small hand adjustments
during the late downswing to correct for small
imperfections in the alignment of the clubface as the
clubhead nears impact, and the golfer has to rely on a
good grip that will always allow the clubface to become
square to the ball-target line at impact. One of the
fundamental feastures of a good grip is a neutral hand
position, whereby the hands are placed alongside the
clubshaft in such a manner, that they will automatically,
and passively, reach the impact position in a consistent
manner - such that the back of the left hand, palm of the
right hand, and clubface always faces the target at the
time of ball impact.
To get to that ideal grip position, one should start off with
the left hand.
Golf instructors recommend different approaches to
gripping the club with the left hand. Some golf instructors
recommend holding the golf club directly in front of the
chest at a 45 degree angle to the ground (with the right
hand holding the clubshaft) and then gripping the club's
grip with the left hand. Other golf instructors recommend
placing the clubhead on the ground, and tilting the
clubshaft 45 degrees to the ground, and then gripping the
club.
Adopting a left hand grip - from reference number [5]
Note that the top of the grip lies below the hypothenar
muscle bulge and that it lies in the lower palm between
the hypothenar eminence and the base of the 5th finger.
Note that the grip lies diagonally across the lower palm
so that it crosses the proximal phalanx of the index finger.
When the fingers are closed, three fingers of the left hand
(3rd, 4th, 5th fingers) are primarily responsible for
gripping the club grip firmly in the left hand. The index
finger lies more loosely across the grip. Most importantly,
one should never let the grip ride high in the palm, so that
it is directly over, or inside (above) the hypothenar
eminence (along the lifeline palmar crease). One should
remember that the left hand golf grip is primarily a three-
finger grip, and not a palm grip. The left 3rd, 4th and 5th
fingers are primarily responsible for gripping the club,
and the grip pressure should be firm - it should not be
possible to pull the grip end of the club out of the left hand
if another person pulls on the clubhead end of the club,
and it should not be possible for that person to twist the
club in one's left hand if he attempts to twist the clubhead
end of the club. A golfer must maintain a firm left hand
grip throughout the swing action so that there is no chance
that the grip end of the club will twist within the left
hand's grip at any time point during the swing. Some golf
instructors state that one should grip the club lightly - as
if one was holding a live bird in one's left hand. I strongly
disagree with that advice - the left hand grip (using the
left 3rd, 4th and 5th fingers) should always be firm.
In this famous B&W photo from the 1950s, Ben Hogan
demonstrates the position of the grip in the left hand.
Note that the left thumb does not extend down the center
of the grip - it is slightly aft of the grip. Note that the left
thumb is relatively tightly opposed to the side of the index
finger knuckle, and that the "V" line (formed between the
left thumb and left index finger knuckle) points to the
right. Note that one can see 2-3 knuckles of the left hand
(left 2nd finger knuckle, and left 3rd finger knuckle).
When viewed from the side, you should note that the last
three fingers (3rd, 4th and 5th fingers) of the left hand are
primarily responsible for firmly gripping the club. The
tips of the 3rd, 4th and 5th fingers should just touch the
side of the base of the thumb (inner side of the thenar
eminence) thus effectively trapping the club between the
fingers and the lower palm. If the tips of the fingers do
not reach the thenar eminence, then the grip's width is too
large for the golfer's hand size. If the tips of the fingers
slide under the inner edge of the thenar eminence, then
the grip's width is too small for the golfer's hand size.
After the left hand has been correctly placed on the grip,
the golfer should then hold the club at 45 degrees in front
of the body, and allow the right hand to approach the grip
from the right side.
Els grip - from reference number [6]
Note that Ernie Els prefers to have his his left thumb
slightly to the right of center - which I now believe is the
optimum position for the left thumb (rather than down
the center of the grip). The left thumb should be slightly
aft of the grip end of the shaft. He then places his right
palm against the grip so that the palms face each other.
He then wraps the right palm over the left thumb so that
the lifeline palmar crease ("cup" of the right palm) rests
over the right side of the left thumb and slightly over the
top of the left thumb. This will cause part of the right
thenar eminence to lie on top of the left thumb. Placing
the right hand firmly over the left hand in this manner
helps to interlink the hands, so that they can better
function as a close-knit unit. Also, note that the right 3rd
and 4th fingers are used to firmly grasp the club's grip,
and that the grip is in the fingers and not the palm of the
right hand. The club's grip lies in a finger-channel that is
created as the 3rd and 4th fingers curl under the shaft. The
5th right finger lies on the top of the left hand's fingers,
in the groove between the left second finger and left third
finger (see Vardon grip photo).
I think that this neutral left hand grip is an ideal grip for a
full golf swing. The low palmar position of the grip
doesn't restrict wrist motions, but it also doesn't allow for
excessive wrist mobility that occurs if the power
accumulator number 3 angle becomes too large (as occurs
with a finger grip). Note the short thumb position - the
end of the left thumb doesn't extend more than one
finger's width beyond the left 2nd finger. That's also
optimum. Finally, this type of grip pattern can ensure that
the grip is held firmly within the left hand - when the left
3rd, 4th and 5th fingers grip the club's grip firmly against
the soft tissue of the lower palm - and that action prevents
the grip from slipping in one's left hand.
Finger grip pattern
Here is a photo-demonstration of how to adopt a finger
grip.
Question number 3:
What is the difference between a long thumb grip and a
short thumb grip?
Answer:
A short thumb grip exists when the distance between the
tip of the left thumb and the left index finger's metacarpo-
phalangeal joint is less than 1 finger's width, and a long
thumb grip exists when that distance is >2-3 fingers
width.
Here is an example of a long thumb grip situation.
Long thumb grip is produced when adopting a left hand
finger grip pattern - capture image from reference number
[7]
Question number 4:
How firmly should a golfer grip the club with his left
hand?
Answer:
In my first version of this chapter, I advised golfers to
adopt a non-firm left hand grip (eg. 4-5 on a scale of 1-
to-10). Some golf instructors advise a golfer to adopt an
an even looser left hand grip - using the analogy of
holding a live bird in one's hand and making sure that the
left hand grip is never firm enough to harm the live bird.
Another similar analogy used by golf instructors is the
mental idea of gripping an open tube of toothpaste, and
not gripping the tube so tightly that it will cause
toothpaste to ooze out of the tube. The primary reason for
advocating a loose left hand grip was to discourage a
golfer from acquiring a tense left wrist that doesn't cock-
and-uncock easily during the swing. I now believe that it
is a major mistake to have a loose left hand grip. I
presently believe that the grip should be firm enough, so
that it becomes i) impossible for a golfer friend to pull the
club out of your hand and ii) impossible for him to cause
the grip to twist in your left hand when he attempts to
twist the clubhead to-and-fro with his dominant hand.
That requires a firm left hand grip.
I believe that the best method of adopting a firm left hand
grip (without needing to over-tense the finger flexor
muscles) is to use a low palmar left hand grip, and to use
the left 3rd, 4th and 5th fingers to grip the club (against
the lower palmar area). The grip should "feel" locked-in
between those 3 fingers and the lower palm. The left
index finger and left thumb play no role in achieving a
firm grip. If a golfer only uses the left 3rd, 4th and 5th
fingers to firmly grip the club, then it should not create
any untoward tension in the wrist flexor muscles and it
should not negatively affect the ease-of-motion
(looseness) of the left wrist's hinging and/or cocking
motions.
Question number 5:
Why don't you recommend the baseball grip, where all 10
fingers hold onto the grip?
Answer:
A golfer who uses a baseball grip is using all 10 fingers
of the left/right hand to hold onto the grip.
Baseball grip - capture image from reference number [7]
Note how the right hand is bonded to the left hand at PP#1
(where the nail penetrates the dorsum of the left thumb).
That's my idea of a good grip!
Question number 6:
Should the degree of left wrist cupping at the end-
backswing position be the same as it was at address - as
recommended by Jim Flick in this Golf Digest tip.
http://www.golfdigest.com/golf-instruction/2010-
01/jim_flick_wrist
Answer:
No.
The left wrist is bent at address when the clubshaft is held
centralised between the feet, with the clubshaft
perpendicular to the ball-target line. That causes the left
arm and clubshaft to not be in a straight line relationship,
which means that the LAFW is disrupted and not intact.
Question number 7:
In question number 1, you stated that a swinger, who uses
a HH action in his followthrough, should not use a strong
left hand grip (4 knuckle grip). Could you provide more
details as to why you do not recommend a strong left
hand grip for a swinger who uses a roll-over release
action through impact?
Answer:
The advantage of a strong left hand grip is that one has to
adopt a pronated left forearm at address to acquire a
strong left hand grip (4 knuckle grip). That means that
one does not roll the left forearm more during the
backswing action via the mechanism of a left forearm
pronatory motion. There is still a small amount of
clockwise rotation of the left hand in the backswing
action to get the left hand to its end-backswing position,
but that is due to internal rotation of the left humerus in
the left shoulder socket, while the left shoulder socket
moves back-and-inside as a result of the rotation of the
upper torso. If there is no left forearm pronation in the
backswing, then one doesn't have to reverse the process
in the late downswing by performing a left forearm
supination motion (which consititutes the biomechanics
underlying the release swivel action - release of PA#3).
Jamie Sadlowski is an example of a golfer who has a very
strong left hand grip, and he therefore doesn't use a
release swivel action in his late downswing.
Jamie Sadlowski's late downswing - capture images from
his swing video [10]
Note that the back of his left hand and back of his left
forearm is parallel to the ball-target line at the delivery
position (image 1) and at impact (image 4). That means
that he doesn't have to roll his left hand into impact via a
left forearm supination action in order to square the
clubface - note that the clubface is relatively square to the
clubhead arc throughout the late downswing. Note that
his left forearm is pronated at impact - to the same degree
that it was at address.
Now consider what happens in his followthrough.
Jamie Sadlowski's followthrough - capture images from
his swing video
Note that Jamie Sadlowski still maintains a pronated left
forearm throughout the early followthrough (images 1
and 2) and that allows him to keep his clubface relatively
square to the clubhead arc for >12" after impact. In other
words, Jamie Sadlowski is not employing a roll-over
release action and a HH action in his early followthrough.
Jamie Sadlowski is employing a drive-hold release
action through impact where he keeps his clubface
relatively square to the clubhead arc through impact, and
he therefore doesn't have to time-coordinate a roll-over
release action after impact.
Now consider another golfer, who also uses a strong left
hand grip, but who utilises a roll-over release action after
impact.
JK's swing video using a strong left hand grip -
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Dv2suorUZw
He uses a strong left hand grip (4 knuckle grip) but he
also utilises a roll-over release action through impact.