Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Preface
The fate of our global food The future of food is being propelled by seismic Agriculture is transitioning to a system that is From our purview as investors across the food,
tailwinds: massive demographic change less extractive and more regenerative. Supply oceans, and energy sectors, we also see
system requires a shift to spurring new consumer demand, significant chains must become more resilient to support numerous intersection points where
working with nature instead advancements in the biology, chemistry and food security. Food is heading towards what innovations in one industry can create
physics of food production to create new consumers want - nutritious, more affordable cross-sector opportunities. By highlighting these
of against it, leveraging the
choices, and sustainability-minded investors are products with better flavor. instances, we hope to show the
power of science, technology, fueling a desire across capital markets to fund interconnectedness of these sectors and
The approaching bear market will impact the
high-growth, disruptive companies. advocate for a more holistic approach to
and entrepreneurship to trajectory of these changes applying cost,
systems transformation.
move forward. At the same time, due to changing externalities, margin and financing pressures to companies
including the pandemic, war in Ukraine and across the food system. At the same time, the This report explores ten trends driving the
devastating climate-related events, the risks uncertain macro environment may fuel growth evolution to a climate-smart, healthy food
inherent in our food system are increasing and for companies offering more sustainable system, including updates to several trends
getting more entangled. If left unchecked, these solutions that are also cheaper, faster, better included in our 2022 analysis as well as new
risks will intensify due to the alarming impact and more resilient than their traditional emerging themes.
on our most important resources. analogs. While the world’s economies may see
a slow down in 2023, those companies that can
In response, stakeholders across the food
execute well and maintain funding levels
system are working toward new solutions.
needed to ride out the downturn may emerge
stronger and well positioned to bring significant
positive change to the food system.
© 2023 Builders Vision 2
S2G Ventures
01 04 07
Robotics Optimization Sustainable Packaging
08
02 05
09
03 06
10
Convergence of
Food and Healthcare
01 | Robotics
Robotics will be
deployed on farms
at commercial scale.
While the United States has been facing acute labor shortages
across many industries, the agricultural sector has been one of
the hardest hit. Agriculture has experienced strained labor
markets for over a decade caused by an aging workforce,
restrictive immigration policies, and decreasing interest in farm
work due to the harsh nature of the job. This last point is
increasingly exacerbated by climate change as field conditions
regularly reach above 110 ºF during harvest season.
6
© 2023 Builders Vision nick barounis - stock.adobe.com 6
S2G Ventures
Technology
Agricultural robots have become substantially The increase in data capture and improvements Image courtesy of Burro
more capable over the last couple of years by in processing have drastically advanced AI and
combining the latest advancements in machine learning models, driving better
computer vision, navigation, artificial robotics and improving data collection.
intelligence, robotics, and chemistry, as well as Solutions that can best capitalize on this wealth
soil and plant sciences, to support the future of of data will have a competitive advantage.
crop production. Cameras, sensors, and
computer processing capabilities have become Robots are also being used in diverse settings,
more advanced, drastically enhancing robots’ providing them with more robust experiences
ability to perceive the world around them. from which to derive data. For example, S2G
Robots are now collecting and processing portfolio company Burro has expanded its
terabytes of data per day. In addition, collaborative robots into new use cases, moving
hardware has gotten cheaper, although the from its core mobility applications of carrying,
post-pandemic supply chain remains a following and towing to include scouting and
challenge. There have also been improvements patrol/security surveillance. The autonomy
in software development and AI models. curve has seemingly reached a tipping point
on automated seeing and perceiving
functionality being adopted at scale.
7
© 2023 Builders Vision Images courtesy of Burro 7
S2G Ventures
The Opportunity
The case for weeding robots has been made with growers There will also be increased production and adoption of smaller, “While we are currently automating less than
buying up million-dollar weeding implements to the point some cheaper machines with minimal soil impact that can continuously
start-ups can’t produce them fast enough. Large operations are run up and down the field collecting data.
10 percent of fresh produce labor, that
purchasing more than one, which suggests that the economics number will grow substantially over the next
are attractive. But even though overall automation is making As the venture capital environment constricts in the coming year,
ten years. Weeding robots will continue to be
strides, soft automation or dexterity is still challenging in many companies with major commercial sales demonstrating real ROI will
use cases. For example, harvesting whole foods has proven to have a competitive advantage. Large agricultural machinery purchased and produced faster, opening up
be the most complex task to automate, even though it is a companies struggling to innovate internally will continue to shift
exit opportunities and capital and enabling
significant opportunity, sometimes making up half of the cost money from research and development to mergers and acquisitions,
of a farming operation. boding well for startups and investors. thinning, planting, and harvesting. Once the
automation advances, companies can devote
While single-purpose robots currently dominate the market, “Agriculture autonomy is no longer a science project,” according to
these solutions will evolve into platforms where software Arthur Chow, Vice President at S2G Ventures. “Several companies are
more resources to the AI layer and explore
enables additional capabilities, whether in soil health booking revenues in excess of seven figures and developing into how they can derive value from all that data.”
measurement, scouting, or disease and pest detection. viable businesses with real commercial use cases.”
Walt Duflock
Vice President of Innovation at Western Growers
“
Autonomy in agriculture is no longer a science
project. Several companies are booking revenues
in excess of seven figures and developing into
viable businesses with real commercial use cases.
“
Arthur
Chow
Vice President
S2G Ventures
02 | Digitization
Digital technologies
will enable profitable,
climate-smart farming
on land and at sea.
Last year we said that the rise of ESG would The need to consider the environmental impact
help digitize the farm. Now, questions around of our food system is also true with respect to
the integrity of ESG claims will do even more to seafood. As global protein consumption
bring digitization to agriculture. Although it is continues to increase, seafood is anticipated to
generally expected the SEC will ultimately make lead the pack as the fastest-growing consumed
changes to its proposed scope 3 emissions protein. By 2050, global aquaculture production
disclosure requirements, the conversation is expected to at least double, with
around emissions across the value chain has well-managed fisheries expected to flatline or
already spurred corporations to work more decline over the same period. There is also a
closely with producers and other supply chain widespread understanding that aquaculture
actors to implement sustainability initiatives. will have to become more productive while
Accounting for environmental outcomes is no reducing the associated environmental
longer an option but rather an imperative for externalities to contribute meaningfully to
all companies to remain financially viable in the our future global food supply.
face of today’s climate risks.
Ground truth measurement tools, including sensors, satellites, and GPS IoT solutions, cameras, and hydroacoustics enable smart feeding, health
systems, paired with modeling, prediction, and estimation applications, monitoring, and biomass estimation for aquaculture operations.
offer farmers increasingly better visibility into what is happening in their Companies are developing algorithms that can inform farmers when to
fields and provide opportunities for better management. Field data start and stop feeding and recognize symptoms of disease based on
Technology aggregation tools enable tracking and monitoring, which will be vital to
validating sustainability claims over time. These tools are also getting
real-time analysis, helping to optimize inputs and outcomes. For
small-scale farmers, companies are developing platforms that use
cheaper, and connectivity is more accessible, increasing the adoption of production performance data to provide additional services such as
digital agriculture. For example, the cost of visual sensors decreased by access to inputs, markets, finance, and insurance.
100x over the last ten years, while their resolution has increased by 100x.
Platforms that can break down silos and incorporate data from numerous
sensors or inputs to derive insights will drive adoption.
The Opportunity
Both agriculture and aquaculture industries are Consumer demand for transparency and According to AgFunder’s 2022 Agrifoodtech “One of the most significant
moving from data-poor to data-rich, creating products that minimize environmental harm is Investment Report, investment in farm
actionable insights for producers. encouraging CPGs to invest in digitization management software, sensing and IoT grew 51
barriers for farmers is figuring out
across their supply chains. In some cases, percent yearly from 2020 to 2021. how to use new technology.
For example, by 2030, the average farm will corporates are providing producers with
Companies that are hands-on in
generate over 1.5 million data points per day. funding for sustainability programs and We are currently crossing the chasm beyond
The rapid rise of digital solutions is resolving technology adoption. early adopters to farmers who are more figuring out what a farm needs
production issues and increasing productivity risk-averse but are motivated by proof of
and tailor-making solutions for
and profitability while reducing environmental Financing for startups developing digital improved ROI. Digital technologies that can
externalities. Companies are racing to capitalize agriculture and aquaculture solutions is also enhance access to markets and generate better them while training the company
on this influx of data and develop products that growing. According to Aqua-Spark’s 2022 production results and profitability will be the to use them are standing out
can support better financial and environmental report, The Transformative Power of Digital ultimate drivers of widespread adoption.
outcomes for farmers. For example, John Deere Aquatech, the aquatech boom has gone from According to Cristina Rohr, Managing Director
above the competition.”
now has precision ag hardware installed on an almost zero to over 100 active digital aquatech at S2G Ventures, “Measurement and analytical
estimated half a billion acres globally, enabling solutions in the past decade, with at least 100 tools are becoming more integrated and better
Vonnie Estes
farmers to view a digital twin of their farm, run investors supporting these companies. equipped to quantify the cross-value chain Vice President of Innovation at the
experiments, understand the impact of new According to the report, “Digital aquatech will benefits of climate-smart agriculture. As digital International Fresh Produce Association
technologies and share their data with enable more efficiency, transparency, and technologies scale to more farms, they will
agronomic advisors. sustainability in the industry while increasing a provide new insights and opportunities to
farmer’s profitability and laying the framework optimize environmental and economic
for a resilient aquaculture industry.” outcomes for all stakeholders from farmers to
CPG companies.”
“
Measurement and analytical tools are becoming
more integrated and better equipped to quantify
the cross-value chain benefits of climate-smart
agriculture. As digital technologies scale to more
farms, they will provide new insights and
opportunities to optimize environmental and
economic outcomes for all stakeholders.
Cristina
“ Rohr
Managing Director
S2G Ventures
03 | Alternative Inputs
Technology
Our fertilizer series examined technologies Chemical stimulants present another Green ammonia, which uses renewable energy Environmentally friendly pesticide alternatives
enabling farmers to use less synthetic fertilizer opportunity to take advantage of the nutrients to split water and extract hydrogen, could also are also making strides. For example,
while maintaining yields. Biostimulants or that exist in the soil but are not accessible. For serve as a more sustainable alternative to RNA-based biopesticides present a promising
biofertilizers are living microbes that improve example, Sound Agriculture’s SOURCE is a traditional fertilizer production, which utilizes alternative to chemical products in crop
plant nutrient access by either mobilizing or low-use rate foliar spray that activates N-fixing natural gas. Today, the production of green protection due to their accuracy and specificity.
increasing nutrient availability in soils. There and P-solubilizing bacteria, making these ammonia is uneconomic without subsidies such While earlier approaches to RNA production
are a number of studies showing the nutrients available to plants. The product boosts as those provided for in the Inflation Reduction synthesized RNA using fermentation in vats of
effectiveness of microbial fertilizers. Still, the yield while reducing the need for synthetic Act (IRA), but as the costs for wind and solar living microbes, Greenlight Biosciences has
expectation that these products have varying fertilizer by up to 50 pounds per acre. continue to drop and production technologies developed a cell-free bioprocessing system
efficacy across different environmental improve, it could become as cheap or cheaper. enabling the production of quality RNA
conditions has been a barrier to adoption, and products at a fraction of the cost. Other
regulatory hurdles still exist. technologies, such as Terrasym from NewLeaf
Symbiotics, use microbial inoculants to make
crops more resistant to various pests.
© 2023 Builders Vision Image courtesy of NewLeaf Symbiotics | Image courtesy of Sound Agriculture 17
S2G Ventures
The Opportunity
Alternative crop protections are seeing a boost in interest and Regulation is also pushing farmers, particularly in Europe, to seek “While the perception of biologicals is still
adoption. A McKinsey survey found that 38 percent of growers alternatives. Ag input companies which also serve in advisory roles
say they would try new crop protection products over the next to farmers, will be a crucial channel for introducing farmers to
new and changing, growers are starting to
two years. Soaring prices sparked interest in fertilizer new products. view them as a more sustainable future for
alternatives, and large synthetic fertilizer companies such as
crop protection.”
OCP and Mosaic are partnering with or acquiring biological “The need is as critical as ever to fill the vacuum for environmentally
companies to meet growing market demand. Bayer partnered friendly, effective inputs,” says Matthew Walker, Managing Director at
with Ginkgo Bioworks to identify the next generation of S2G Ventures. “We believe the time is now for alternative input Mark Brooks
biologicals to meet various needs, from crop protection to solutions to achieve large-scale adoption and impact.” Director at FMC Ventures
nitrogen fixation and carbon sequestration. The McKinsey
survey also found that 30 percent of large farms plan to use
“green” products such as biofertilizers due to lower costs per
acre. In Brazil, 60 percent of farmers have already adopted
biocontrols and biostimulants.
“
The need is as critical as ever to
fill the vacuum for environmentally
friendly, effective inputs. We believe the time
is now for alternative input solutions to
achieve large-scale adoption and impact.
“
Matthew
Walker
Managing Director
S2G Ventures
04 | Optimization
Supply chain
optimization technologies
can reduce costs,
emissions, and risk.
The globalization of food supply chains has added significant The cost of inefficiently producing, transporting, processing, and
complexity and created information asymmetry between producers and distributing food also results in excessive energy use and food waste.
consumers, making them more rigid in the face of disruption. Operational According to a recent study, transport accounts for about 19 percent of
factors such as production disruptions and external factors such as total food-system emissions. The International Maritime Organization
weather conditions, transportation issues, input shortages, and pricing aims to reduce vessels' carbon emissions per transport work by at least
volatility have led to substantial food supply chain inefficiencies. This 40 percent and is targeting a 70 percent reduction by 2050. Forty percent
vulnerability was starkly apparent when the supply chain disruptions of food waste occurs before products reach retailers and consumers,
during Covid-19 left grocery store shelves empty while farmers could not stemming from improper storage transportation and inaccurate order
find markets for crops and livestock. As the pandemic started to wane sizes. Companies across the food supply chain need better insight into
and Americans went on a purchasing spree, US ports could not handle the markets, risks, transportation inefficiencies, and demand drivers to
traffic. At the ports of Los Angeles and Long Beach, the entry point for minimize emissions and food waste and maximize profits.
about 40 percent of goods imported into the US, congestion reached a
record 73 anchored container ships in the fall of 2021. A recent survey
from the Food Industry Association, conducted in the second quarter of
2022, found that 70 percent of retailers said supply chain disruptions
negatively impacted their business, up from 42 percent the year before.
Technology
Companies across the supply chain have more various outcomes, and digital twins of
data than ever, and predictive data science and transportation vessels can predict speed, RPM,
optimization techniques have improved and and fuel consumption for any scenario.
become more prevalent. Software that uses
cognitive computing to optimize critical Technologies embedded in objects, such as
processes such as load planning, inbound and RFID (Radio Frequency IDentification) Image courtesy of Corvus Robotics
outbound logistics, demand planning, and price technology, can give companies a more
optimization can help companies define supply granular view of their supply chains, allowing
chain problems and match them to solutions. for more accurate inventory data and food
Software, as well as the implementation of IoT, tracking at various levels of aggregation. IoT in
can improve operational efficiencies at ports. food chains is growing, and combined with
other technologies, it can help companies
Optimization engines consider hundreds of visualize food supply chain processes and map
options for transportation systems, such as supply routes.
shipping and trucking, before providing the
most efficient route optimized for fuel and time Better warehouse inventory management is
cost, weather, safety, emissions, and other also an essential component of supply chain
constraints. Digital twins also run simulations optimization. For example, Corvus Robotics
and help companies understand where they utilizes drone technology, enabling inventory
can optimize. visibility across the warehouse workflow
through efficient inventory scanning, so
For example, supply chain digital twins can help
companies know what and where everything is.
companies calibrate models to prioritize
© 2023 Builders Vision Image courtesy of Corvus Robotics | Image courtesy of Sofar Ocean 23
S2G Ventures
The Opportunity
Better-optimized supply chains could result in numerous social, Lastly, optimization technologies can improve food safety and supply According to Kate Danaher, Managing Director of S2G Ventures,
economic, and environmental benefits. Increased efficiencies chain transparency. Supply chain visibility can reduce food safety “Increased data collection across the supply chain, paired with
and improved logistics will lead to substantial cost and energy risks by ensuring proper food handling and storage and enabling advances in AI and ML, are enabling optimization solutions that will
savings and reduced food waste and risk across the supply companies to carry out more targeted recalls. In addition, if data is substantially lessen the environmental externalities of transportation
chain through shorter and more energy-efficient transportation standardized and data sharing is encouraged, all stakeholders, while creating efficiencies and cost savings.”
routes. Supply chain insights and optimization are also critical including consumers, can trace a food product along its entire supply
for inventory management today and supply planning for the chain from farmer to grocery store shelf, which could verify the
near and distant future. Understanding demand drivers product’s environmental credentials and associated emissions across
enables companies to decide how much variability they want to the supply chain.
cover and the impacts their decisions have on the consumer.
Companies that can continuously optimize their supply chains
will prove more agile in a time of increasing market, weather,
and geopolitical volatility.
“
Increased data collection across the supply chain,
paired with advances in AI and ML, are enabling
optimization solutions that will substantially
lessen the environmental externalities of
transportation while creating efficiencies
and cost savings.
“ Kate
Danaher
Managing Director
S2G Ventures
05 | Decentralization
Controlled production
will improve food security
and system resilience
Technology
Local agriculture production models and in location and species, and reduce transport
markets that connect farmers to consumers distances by situating farms near markets.
can support profitability for farmers, better
system resilience, and provide consumers with While these systems are currently cost-sensitive
higher quality and traceable products. But to and energy-intensive, great strides have been
fully realize efficient local food production made in the last few years to improve energy
systems, we need to reimagine production efficiency and develop more sustainable,
methods and resource use. tailored, and cost-effective inputs to improve
scaling opportunities.
Several types of growing systems are enabling
agricultural production in previously unsuitable Distributed renewable energy sources will be a
areas. Cellular agriculture, controlled crucial part of providing more reliable,
environment agriculture, and land-based sustainable power across the food supply
aquaculture systems all separate production chain. Renewable energy will be instrumental
from the natural environment making the for rural energy access, improve the
output much less susceptible to environmental sustainability of energy-intensive supply chain
conditions. These systems leverage technologies and make food supply chains less
technologies and opportunities such as vulnerable to global energy dynamics. In
automation, resource recycling, data science particular, access to renewables such as solar
and careful input selection and design to could be transformational in rural areas in
optimize the use of various resources such as developing countries, enabling everything from
water, land, energy, and labor, deliver high cold food storage to irrigation where access to
yield and consistent output, provide flexibility traditional power sources is limited.
© 2023 Builders Vision Image courtesy of Future Meat | Image courtesy of Soli Organic 28
S2G Ventures
The Opportunity
Short, decentralized food supply chains have the potential to As a result, regional, resilient supply chains are now a major priority “Stabilization in the face of geopolitical issues, extreme weather
meet consumer demand while offering producers better prices for governments. The USDA recently announced over $2 billion in events, and pest and disease outbreaks is becoming increasingly
and building more redundancy and resilience into the supply funding to support increased choices for farmers and consumers essential for resilient food systems,” says Sanjeev Krishnan, Chief
chain. CEA, land-based aquaculture, and cellular agriculture and the transition to a more decentralized food system. New York Investment Officer and Senior Managing Director of S2G
production systems can operate in areas such as arid deserts City is investing $140 million to strengthen the Hunts Point Terminal Ventures, “Decentralized systems that create redundancies and
where conventional agriculture practices are not feasible or Market, including building a dedicated warehouse for local produce enable production in areas previously inhospitable to food
regions where land suitable for crop and animal production and increasing the number of local and regional farmers selling to production will increase supply chain resilience and food security
is minimal, thereby improving food security. the market. Up to $400 million in funding is available now from the across the globe.”
USDA to support local food purchased for school meals, food banks,
There are numerous environmental benefits to decentralized and other nutritional assistance programs.
food systems. Hydroponic and vertical farming methods can
reduce agricultural water and agrochemical use. Cellular
agriculture can curtail land use and emissions from raising
livestock, and land-based aquaculture systems take pressure
off wild fisheries. Minimizing the distance between production
and consumption can also reduce food miles and emissions
associated with food transportation and result in fresher,
more nutrient-dense food that lasts longer.
“
Decentralized systems that create
redundancies and enable production in areas
previously inhospitable to food production
will increase supply chain resilience and
food security across the globe.
“ Sanjeev
Krishnan
Chief Investment
Officer and Senior
Managing Director
S2G Ventures
Adoption of
food waste solutions
will be recognized as both
a good business practice
and an essential tool
for feeding the world.
Feeding a population of 10 billion by 2050 For these reasons, the US Government, the UN,
while arable land and agricultural productivity and the EU have set goals to cut the amount of
continue to decline, cannot be done by food that goes to landfills and other Karen - stock.adobe.com
mustbeyou - stock.adobe.com
expanding acreage. Today about a third of food destinations in half. Rising food prices and
is wasted at some point in the supply chain, increasing food shortages over the last few
enough food to feed more than a billion years have generated more motivation for food
people. Food that is never eaten still takes waste reduction efforts and made the payback
resources to grow, harvest, transport, and even more attractive. According to ReFed,
cook. According to ReFed data, uneaten food households are the most significant contributor
uses 14 percent of all freshwater, 18 percent of to food waste (37 percent) followed by
all cropland, and 24 percent of landfill inputs. consumer-facing businesses (28 percent),
Food waste is also the number one material making them both primary target areas for
entering landfills where it produces methane food waste technology and innovation.
gas, which has more than 80 times the warming
power of carbon dioxide. Over its lifecycle, food
waste accounts for 8 to 10 percent of global
greenhouse gas emissions, at least double that
of the aviation industry.
32
© 2023 Builders Vision Deyan - stock.adobe.com 32
S2G Ventures
Technology
Upcycling has become an increasingly popular For food that still ends up as excess, markdown
way for companies to redirect ingredients that and sharing apps, such as Flashfood, connect
are otherwise headed to the trash. Rejected retailers to companies or consumers who will
food, imperfect produce, and food purchase it at a discount. These apps enable
manufacturing byproducts such as spent grain, the rescue of food that would otherwise go to
cashew apples, or discarded dates are being waste while helping shoppers save on their
turned into various value-added products for grocery bills.
human consumption.
33
© 2023 Builders Vision Image courtesy of Atomo Coffee | Image courtesy of Flashfood 33
S2G Ventures
34
© 2023 Builders Vision Image courtesy of Mill 34
S2G Ventures
The Opportunity
According to calculations by ReFed, cutting our food waste by For example, California just passed what might be the most “There is an ever-increasing interest in food waste solutions
50 percent by 2050 will require a $14 billion investment ambitious food waste law in the US, requiring supermarkets to give among public markets and later-stage businesses, especially with
annually. But there is also a substantial economic opportunity, away food that is unsold but fine to eat. Additionally, every city and the recognition that mitigating food waste is an important climate
with BCG estimating that closing the gap between food loss county must reduce the organic waste that goes into landfills by 75 solution,” says Chuck Templeton, Senior Managing Director at
and waste could be worth $700 billion. percent by 2025. The Infrastructure and Investment Jobs Act, signed S2G Ventures, “Even before increasing yields and using new land,
into law in November 2021, includes $350 million in investments over if we focused on eliminating food waste, we'd be able to keep up
Over 250 companies have signed onto initiatives to cut food 5 years to transform municipal solid waste and recycling, including with growing food demand for the foreseeable future.”
waste in half. General Mills and Compass Group have cut their food waste and reduction.
food waste by 24 and 33 percent respectively since 2020.
Albertsons has committed to reducing food waste by 50 The investment community is also shoring up funds for food waste
percent in its Pacific Coast divisions by 2030 and Walmart set a solutions. In 2022, $1.75 billion was invested in solutions, up from
goal to eliminate food waste in the US, Canada, Japan, and the $101 million in 2012, with funding split pretty evenly between
UK by 2025. prevention and recycling technologies. Food waste solutions are
particularly satisfying because every dollar is a sustainable dollar.
There is also mounting government pressure and support for Food waste is a straightforward issue for people to understand
preventing food waste, with 99 bills introduced at the state and an easy story to tell, and efforts to mitigate it are measurable
level, of which 24 passed. and concrete.
“
Even before increasing yields and using new land,
if we focused on eliminating food waste, we'd be
able to keep up with growing food demand for
the foreseeable future.
“
Chuck
Templeton
Senior Managing
Director
S2G Ventures
07 | Sustainable Packaging
Innovative packaging
and closed loop recycling
will begin to address
our plastics problem.
For the past five decades, plastic packaging has been prolific
in the food industry because of its advantageous characteristics:
It is economical, functional, lightweight, and very versatile. But most
plastics are derived from petroleum and are non-degradable. Nearly
26 percent of global plastic production is used for packaging, of which
single-use plastics account for 50 percent. Only 5 percent of plastic waste
in the US was recycled in 2021–the rest ended up in landfills, oceans,
or the atmosphere as tiny toxic particles. According to UNEP, plastic
packaging generates negative externalities valued at 40 billion, which
is expected to increase substantially in a business-as-usual scenario.
Technology
Mechanical recycling technologies, particularly those already According to Closed Loop Partners, reuse/refill systems are nascent
tested in European markets, are also well-positioned for growth but fast-growing, and innovative reuse models, enabled by digital
in the US. Historically, plastics recyclers in the US were largely technology, can unlock significant benefits, like improving the user
focused on downcycling plastics for single-use applications, but experience, building brand loyalty and customer retention through
companies are now seeing the benefit of upcycling plastics for deposits and reward schemes, and cutting packaging and
circular applications. While many mechanically recycled plastics transportation costs. Companies can use these models to gather
are not yet approved for food-grade use, they can be substituted user insights through sensors, RFID tags, and GPS tracking.
for other consumer goods and in parts of the supply chain, such
as stretch wraps and protective packaging.
The Opportunity
Historically, commitments by companies and New policies are also applying pressure on the Oregon and Maine passed extended producer According to Chuck Templeton, Senior Managing
retailers to reduce the impacts of packaging CPG sector to improve packaging. In March, responsibility laws, requiring manufacturers to Director at S2G Ventures, “Given the fast-growing
have primarily focused on easy wins, such as more than 170 nations backed a historic UN help fund the collection and processing of their consumer awareness, escalating government
reducing weight and material usage. In the last resolution establishing a committee to develop packaging. California passed a groundbreaking regulations, increasing manufacturer
few years, companies have made more a plastics pollution treaty by the end of 2024. law requiring producers to create less plastic commitments, and clever suppliers and startups’
substantial commitments to adopt sustainable The UK introduced a plastic packaging tax, the and ensure all single-use plastics are recyclable innovation, sustainable packaging solutions will
packaging, which presents massive funding and EU introduced a ban on single-use plastic or compostable. achieve value and functionality parity, gaining
partnership opportunities for companies plates, cutlery, and straws, and the Chilean market share.”
working on these technologies. For example, Government passed a law that nearly Consumer demand for alternatives is also high.
Coca-Cola pledged to ensure that at least 25 eliminates all single-use plastics from the According to Shorr’s 2022 Sustainable
percent of its beverages are sold in refillable or food and beverage sector. Packaging Consumer Report, 86 percent of
returnable glass or plastic bottles by 2030 and consumers surveyed are more likely to
Nestle invested around $5 million in the Italian purchase a product from a brand or retailer if
venture capital fund Eureka! Fund to accelerate the packaging is sustainable.
the research of innovative packaging solutions
and improve recycling processes.
“
Given the fast-growing consumer awareness,
escalating government regulations, increasing
manufacturer commitments, and clever suppliers
and startups’ innovation, sustainable packaging
solutions will achieve value and functionality
parity, gaining market share.
Chuck
“ Templeton
Senior Managing
Director
S2G Ventures
08 | Novel Ingredients
In last year’s report, we noted that many Consumers also want to know they are doing
plant-based products still struggle to offer the good by choosing plant-based options.
taste, smell, and feel consumers associate with Unfortunately, the portion of shoppers that
animal proteins. Today some products are believe plant-based products are better for the
receiving mounting criticism due to their long environment fell by 7 percent over the first
ingredient lists and questionable nutritional three quarters of 2022. Additionally, rising
content, and there has been a decline in inflation is making it harder for consumers to
plant-based meat sales. It is time for another justify the higher price points of many
evolution in alternative proteins. Consumers plant-based alternatives, especially when
want to see better dietary values, clean labels conventional meat prices have fallen from their
with fewer, more recognizable ingredients, and 2020 highs. Ingredients and products with
improvements in the multidimensional better nutritional qualities, clean labels, clear
experience, such as mouth feel, moisture environmental benefits, and price
retention, and coloring. According to research competitiveness will drive the next generation
from the International Food Information Council, of plant-based proteins.
almost two-thirds of consumers try to choose
foods made from clean ingredients, which most
people define as “not artificial or synthetic.”
Technology
The Opportunity
There is a hunger for rapid food innovation, Partnerships provide an excellent funding When plant-based meat and seafood According to Sanjeev Krishnan, Chief
and competitors are racing to find the next source and an avenue to commercialize novel substitutes first came to market, the focus was Investment Officer and Senior Managing
generation of plant-based proteins. As a result, products. Big CPGs are working with agile food almost exclusively on nailing the taste and Director, “Alternative proteins are still
food brands in the alternative protein space tech startups for support with R&D, especially texture. Now, companies must continue to in the iPod phase–not yet the iPhone phase.
must be flexible, fast-moving, and ones looking for black swan ingredients that optimize taste, texture and the sensory There are still tremendous progress
forward-thinking. AI platforms and precision could make up most of their revenue. ICL Food experience while improving nutrition, removing to be had in this sector through the
fermentation are vital to rapidly developing Specialties is teaming up with AI food tech undesirable additives and ingredients, and introduction of novel ingredients.”
clean-label, sustainable, and taste-competitive company Protera Biosciences to develop new reducing costs. Products that make a
plant-based products. protein ingredients with specific functionalities compelling “better for you and the planet”
for food manufacturers using precision argument will stand out in an increasingly
Discovery platforms have become incredibly fermentation. Mars is entering a multi-year crowded space.
powerful to the point where they are making collaboration with Pipa, an artificial intelligence
connections faster than we can figure out what food research company, to accelerate the
to do with them. And while precision discovery of novel plant-based ingredients.
fermentation is making great strides, there is
still the question of scale and the need for
expanded production facilities.
“
Alternative proteins are still
in the iPod phase–not yet the iPhone phase.
There are still tremendous progress
to be had in this sector through the
introduction of novel ingredients.
“
Sanjeev
Krishnan
Managing Director
S2G Ventures
09 | Cultivated Protein
Cultivated protein
will provide consumers
around the world with
safe, sustainable food.
Technology
Lab-grown products are biologically identical to Companies are also developing low-cost,
animal products without requiring the effective, and scalable media formulations
slaughtering of animals. Instead, the process since the media make up 55-95 percent of the
begins with cells extracted from animals. These cost of cell-based meat. There is also the issue
cells are grown in tanks and fed fats, sugars, of the complex three-dimensional
amino acids, and vitamins that enable the cells characteristics of meat products that a group of
to mature and multiply. Several factors cells alone can’t replicate. As a result, several
determine the viability of cultivated protein, companies are working on scaffolding
and some companies are tackling specific technologies, such as Matrix F.T., which makes
aspects while others are taking on multiple three-dimensional nanofiber, scaffolds, and
components. For example, cell line microcarriers that can organize cells in a way
development is critical for the cellular protein that imitates the composition of an animal. The
process and requires finding the type of cell muscle structure for seafood products is more
most suitable for consumption. clear-cut than other animal proteins, making it
more straightforward to grow a product that
better resembles the wild or farmed species.
The Opportunity
In one of the biggest food tech stories of the Another significant barrier to scaling is access to According to Larsen Mettler, Managing Director “Another big consideration for
year, UPSIDE Foods received a “no questions” capital for building production facilities. To date, at S2G, “The technology for protein cultivation
letter from the FDA indicating that regulators we have seen money flow to support the is ready for commercialization, and it continues
companies is scalability,
have found nothing unsafe about the development of the first wave of cultivated to improve. To bring a product to market, particularly due to the high costs
company’s cellular chicken product. The next protein products. Still, companies will have to companies need to focus on reducing the cost
of inputs. Many of the feedstocks
step is USDA approval, the final sign-off before demonstrate a consistent, quality product and of production, brand-building, labeling,
selling to consumers. This is expected to come scale production through a viable business consumer education, and improving supply used for cellular agriculture are
within the year, and renowned chef Dominique model to achieve a step up in valuations. chain and inputs to support a scalable
expensive and can be difficult to
Crenn has already announced she will serve the Startup founders can support industry growth industry.”
chicken at her restaurant Atelier Crenn in San and commercialization by building partnerships procure at scale for food
Francisco. The public material made available with different types of investors and production.”
alongside UPSIDE’s approval can help other industry groups.
companies expedite internal processes, and in
the long term, the federal review processes will These products will likely first be available in Grant Leslie
likely become more standardized. restaurants, enabling companies to go to Global Head of FGS Global’s food practice
“
To bring a product to market,
companies need to focus on reducing
the cost of production, brand-building,
labeling, consumer education, and improving
supply chain and inputs to support
a scalable industry.
“ Larsen
Mettler
Managing Director
S2G Ventures
55
© 2023 Builders Vision beats_ - stock.adobe.com 55
S2G Ventures
Technology
A slew of government programs are being Consumer healthcare has expanded through
trialed to improve healthy food access and wearable technologies, the internet of things,
health outcomes on a population level, from and new diagnostic tools that can enable users,
produce prescription programs to refrigerated physicians, and health and wellness companies
food lockers and electronic EBT cards that can to understand in real-time how food is
be used online. impacting an individual’s health. Companies are
utilizing continuous glucose monitors to
Ingredients pose new health benefits as the understand consumers' glucose response to
discovery of new compounds is accelerated specific foods and optimize their eating habits.
through the application of machine learning Wearables are enabling heart rate and blood
and artificial intelligence. The functionality is pressure monitoring, sleep pattern analysis,
increasingly matched with more specificity with step tracking, and workout reminders. These
health indications. This sector is further technologies also provide new methodologies
supported by cost reduction of key tools for data collection and analysis for food-based
including precision fermentation, DNA clinical trials.
sequencing, and data storage.
56
© 2023 Builders Vision Image courtesy of Faeth Therapeutics | Image courtesy of Brightseed 56
S2G Ventures
The Opportunity
There is certainly political will to progress the Studies published this year have shown that US consumer use of wearable technology has This is further underpinned by opportunities
field of food as medicine. The White House providing medically-tailored meals increases increased from 9 to 33 percent in just four within the state and federal government to
Conference on Hunger, Nutrition, and Health dietary adherence above 90 percent and allows years, and they have been shown to incentivize use the food we grow to heal and build a
was held for the first time in 50 years during patients to realize significantly better chronic behavior that reduces hospital visits due to healthier population. According to Dan Ripma,
which the Biden Administration unveiled a disease control, and that providing eligible poorly managed personal health. They also Vice President at S2G Ventures, “Food as
national strategy to end hunger, support child patients with medically-tailored meals could enable the creation of aggregated datasets that medicine initiatives will only continue to
nutrition and eliminate health disparities, and prevent over 1.5 million hospitalizations for a can be used for preventative treatment, accelerate as we connect compounds and foods
announced more than $8 billion in net cost savings of $13.6 billion. Despite this real-time diagnostics, disease monitoring, and to health outcomes and consumer demand
commitments to the food as medicine progress, it will take many years to create therapeutic adherence. Wearables are building grows for more holistic forms of healthcare.”
movement. At the recent Come to the Table: commercially viable and scalable solutions the digital connective tissue across real-time
USDA’s National Nutrition Security and within healthcare. actionable health insights, aggregated health “There are so many food as
Healthcare Summit, more than 200 healthcare, datasets, and individual and population-level
healthcare opportunities
federal, and community leaders came together Additionally, healthcare data sharing will be health decisions.
to advance the conference goal of ensuring all essential for new therapy discovery and premised on allowing data
Americans can access nutritious food. The health equity. At S2G, we believe the convergence of food and
matching, and better
Biden administration has also started allowing healthcare will continue to accelerate as
Medicaid benefits to be used for food and For individuals, technologies such as wearables companies develop new channels for food in streamlining and sharing
nutrition counseling in certain states. and at-home testing are providing physicians direct-to-consumer and healthcare sectors that of data has become a massive
with more data to support their patients and improve health outcomes for consumers and
Establishing clinical studies, standards of care, can facilitate a transition to more timely and patients. Discovery platforms will bolster this
opportunity in the sector.”
and medical cost savings support to provide accurate healthcare interventions. effort as new bioactive compounds are
medically-tailored meals and other meal discovered and paired with specific indications.
Geraldine Hency
benefits will be critical to establishing the food Director of Nutrition Policy at the
as medicine sector within healthcare. Food Research and Action Center (FRAC)
© 2023 Builders Vision 57
S2G Ventures
“
The convergence of food and healthcare will
continue to develop as food and food-derivatives
are more accurately linked with health outcomes.
Consumers are already searching for more
holistic and integrated solutions.
“
Dan
Ripma
Vice President
S2G Ventures
Connect with us
We want to work with you. Implementing more sustainable technologies
and business models we’re working toward healthier people and a
healthier planet driven by healthier ocean, food and energy systems.