Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Zohoori FV, Duckworth RM (eds): The Impact of Nutrition and Diet on Oral Health.
Monogr Oral Sci. Basel, Karger, 2020, vol 28, pp 91–98 (DOI: 10.1159/000455376)
92 Saads Carvalho · Lussi
UCSF Library & CKM
Downloaded by:
venting tooth erosion; lastly, Corica and Caprio- In addition, the different results in these re-
glio [16] included 3 studies in their review on the views could be related to other patient-related
prevalence of tooth wear in the primary dentition, conditions. Gastro-oesophageal reflux is seldom
and they could not explain the role of diet on the considered in such studies, and it is an impor-
basis of their data. tant factor in the majority of patients with den-
Two systematic reviews, by Li et al. [17] and by tal erosion [20]. Some patients have no appar-
Salas et al. [18], specifically reported the associa- ent symptoms for reflux, or they may not even
tion of diet and erosion. Both studies identified be aware that they suffer from this condition.
carbonated/soft drinks as the main dietary factor These patients, therefore, present silent reflux,
associated with ETW. In the meta-analysis by Li and this condition is only detected by a special-
et al. [17], the authors showed a twofold increase ist. Further studies on the association between
in the risk of ETW (OR 2.41, 95% CI 2.03–2.85) ETW and diet should also consider other pa-
associated with the consumption of soft drinks. tient-related (confounding) variables. More-
Likewise, a similar association was shown in the over, further studies on sports/energy drinks
meta-analysis and meta-regression by Salas et al. are still encouraged, especially considering the
[18] (OR 1.61, 95% CI 1.29–2.01). increased popularity of these drinks among
Interestingly, although juice, sports drinks, children and adolescents. An urgent additional
milk or yoghurt were not associated with dental reason for such research is that high consump-
erosion, Li et al. [17] observed that chewing vita- tion of such drinks by young people could result
min C tablets increased the risk of ETW (OR 1.16, in more serious health issues, such as calcium
95% CI 1.10–1.22). In the study by Salas et al. [18], deficiency, which could jeopardise the accrual
the authors were able to demonstrate that fre- of maximal peak bone mass at a critical time of
quent consumption of natural fruit juices (OR life [21].
1.20, 95% CI 1.02–1.42) and acidic snacks or
sweets (OR 2.24, 95% CI 1.16–4.34) are also sig-
nificantly associated with a greater risk of tooth Chemical Parameters Associated with ETW
erosion, whereas the higher consumption of dairy
products, like milk (OR 0.96, 95% CI 0.92–0.99) Human dental enamel is made up mostly of cal-
and yoghurt (OR 0.77, 95% CI 0.64–0.91) can be cium (Ca2+), phosphate (PO43–), hydroxide
considered as a protecting factor. (OH– ), fluoride (F–), carbonate (CO32–) and so-
It is important to bear in mind that these as- dium (Na+) ions [22]. It is represented by the sim-
sociations are related to how frequent the prod- plified chemical formula: Ca10–xNax(PO4)6–y
ucts are consumed. This is particularly impor- (CO3)z(OH)2–uFu, which is slightly different from
tant when considering the data related to vita- pure hydroxyapatite (HAP): Ca10(PO4)6(OH)2
min C chewable tablets and natural fruit juices, [22–24]. In the oral cavity, enamel is in a constant
where their frequent consumption increases the equilibrium with its surrounding fluids. So, the
odds of developing erosion by only 16 and 20%, de- and re-mineralisation processes on the enam-
respectively. Higher odds are observed for the el surface are mediated by the continuous ionic
intake of acidic snacks/sweets and carbonated/ exchange between the enamel and the oral envi-
soft drinks. Although these studies do not spec- ronment.
ify the frequency, other studies have observed Under normal (healthy) circumstances, the
that, in general, ETW is associated with four or outer surfaces of the enamel are surrounded by
more servings of acidic products per day [11, saliva, which is rich in Ca2+, PO43–, and OH–. So
19]. the enamel crystals remain in equilibrium with
132.174.255.215 - 11/8/2019 1:53:23 PM
94 Saads Carvalho · Lussi
UCSF Library & CKM
Downloaded by:
with its low pH of 4.2 it has no erosive impact on to HAP and FAP will tend to precipitate salts on
enamel [34]. Since these mineral ions are key the dental enamel [22]. Lussi et al. [27], Lussi and
protecting factors, experiments have been done Hellwig [34], as well as Lussi and Carvalho [26]
supplementing orange juice with calcium and analyzed the effects of several beverages and
phosphate. Orange juice supplemented with cal- foods on deciduous and permanent enamel.
cium (42.9 mmol/L) and phosphate (31.2 These authors further investigated different
mmol/L) caused no enamel erosion despite its chemical parameters of the substances and used
low pH of 4.0, whereas the non-supplemented a multiple linear regression analysis to determine
orange juice caused deep erosive lesions [31]. which factors played significant roles in enamel
Hemingway et al. [35] suggested that Ca2+ is re- dissolution. A list of erosive potentials of several
leased before phosphate ions from dissolving beverages and foods can be found in these re-
enamel, and Ca2+ will play a more important role ports [26, 27, 34].
in the erosive potential of a substance than phos-
phate. In solution, orthophosphate can exist as 4
different species (H3PO4, H2PO4–, HPO42– and Physical Parameters Associated with ETW
PO43–). The only species of importance with re-
gard to erosive potential is PO43–, since it is the Besides chemical parameters, physical parame-
relevant species of enamel mineral (see formula ters will also modulate the demineralisation pro-
at the beginning of the chapter) [27, 35]. The cesses. In dentine, continued acid attacks cause a
concentrations of the different species are strong- surface demineralisation of the dentine, exposing
ly influenced by pH. In erosive substances with the dense, fibrous, organic collagen network (or-
low pH, only a minute fraction of the phosphate ganic matrix). During dental erosion, this organic
species are in the form of PO43–, so phosphate matrix is retained, and it serves as a physical dif-
plays a minor role in the erosive potential of bev- fusion barrier, constraining the dissolved mineral
erages and foods. Lastly, the literature is still con- ions largely within the liquid phase surrounding
tradictory in relation to how F– concentrations in the collagen fibres, leading to a higher concentra-
the beverages and foods affect their erosive po- tion of these ions near the surface of the dentine
tential [26, 27, 31, 36], although caution should than if diffusion were unhindered. This higher
be taken that excess intake of fluoride is directly ionic concentration increases the degree of satu-
linked to cases of fluorosis. ration immediately surrounding the dentine sur-
All the above mentioned chemical parameters face, markedly decreasing further mineral loss
act in unison in the erosive potential of substanc- [38].
es, and the interplay between these parameters In enamel, there is no corresponding layer of
will modulate the amount of demineralisation of insoluble matrix, but a diffusion process can still
the enamel. Together, these parameters can be occur when an erosive substance is left on the
used to calculate the degree of saturation of a giv- tooth surface with no movement. In this case, the
en substance with respect to HAP and fluorapa- outflow of PO43– and OH– from the enamel dur-
tite (FAP) [37]. The degree of saturation repre- ing the demineralisation process will slowly neu-
sents the driving force for whether a substance is tralise the H+ in the immediate vicinity of the
more or less likely to demineralise the enamel or enamel surface. This too leads to a local rise in the
cause precipitation of the mineral. When a sub- concentration of mineral ions in the semi-static
stance is undersaturated with respect to HAP and liquid layer immediately adjacent to the enamel
FAP, it will cause the enamel to demineralise, surface [38]. This semi-static layer is called the
whereas substances supersaturated with respect “Nernst layer.” The higher concentration of these
132.174.255.215 - 11/8/2019 1:53:23 PM
† Values
calculated from Lussi and Carvalho [26].
‡ Values
calculated from Carvalho et al. [40].
* Mann-Whitney tests were used to verify significant differences between the 2 types of movements for each substance
and erosion time.
ions in the Nernst layer will also increase its de- observed in 2 studies from our group [26, 40],
gree of saturation in the immediate vicinity of the where we investigated erosion in deciduous teeth
enamel, eventually becoming saturated with re- using different agitation speeds. Both experi-
spect to the tooth mineral, and, in turn, reducing ments were conducted by immersing the decidu-
the demineralisation. ous teeth in acidic beverages for either 2 or 4 min,
These parameters (collagen layer and Nernst at the same temperature 30 ° C, but using 2 differ-
layer) are influenced by in vivo circumstances. ent kinds of agitation: in one study [26], we used
The collagen layer may be influenced by matrix gentle agitation (similar to patients who drink
metalloproteinases from dentine and saliva, and without swishing the drinks in their mouth), and
the Nernst layer is influenced by normal eating in the other study [40] we used vigorous agitation
and drinking movements. The latter causes a con- (similar to patients who swish drinks in their
tinuous flow of the acidic beverages over the mouths). The results are presented in Table 1.
teeth, leading to a constant renewal of the Nernst We clearly observe that vigorous agitation causes
layer, which never reaches saturation with respect significantly more erosion than gentle agitation
to the dissolving enamel [39]. either after 2 or 4 min erosion, yet no significant
Lussi and Carvalho [30] suggested that the differences are observed when candy spray is
process of renewing the Nernst layer is particu- used for 4 min. Substances like candy spray are so
larly important when a substance is only slightly aggressive that a normal intake (gentle agitation)
undersaturated with respect to tooth mineral. for a slightly longer period of time (4 min) will
During greater agitation, like when patients already cause maximum harm to the teeth. From
swish drinks in the mouth, the continuous out- these results (Table 1), we can conclude that the
flow of Ca2+, PO43–, and OH– from the enamel kind of intake plays a significant role in initial
will lead to a more rapid erosive process. This was enamel erosion, leading to distinct differences in
132.174.255.215 - 11/8/2019 1:53:23 PM
96 Saads Carvalho · Lussi
UCSF Library & CKM
Downloaded by:
enamel surface hardness loss, but this difference Conclusion
diminishes when a non-erosive substance (like
mineral water) is used, or when a strong erosive Since diet plays a significant role in ETW, dietary
substance (like candy spray) is used for longer habits should be thoroughly and routinely inves-
erosion times. tigated in the clinical setting. Lussi and Hellwig
This effect has also been observed in patients, [34] advise that patients should record their com-
who adopt specific behaviours that increase the plete dietary intake over a course of 4 consecutive
contact time between the tooth and the acidic days, taking notes specifically on the time of day,
substance (like swishing). In a case-control study, the duration of ingestion, and the quantity of all
O’Sullivan and Curzon [11] compared a group of ingested beverages and foods. Additionally, both
patients who presented with ETW to a group of weekdays and weekends should be included in
patients who had active caries lesions, and anoth- the diet record sheet, for behaviours can differ
er (control) group who had neither ETW nor car- considerably depending on the day of the week.
ies. The authors observed that 43% of the patients Dentists should use these food diaries to assess
with ETW had some kind of drinking habit, such the erosive potential of all beverages and foods, as
as holding the drinks in the mouth, sucking or well as the frequency of ingestion, thus estimating
swishing; whereas, only 15% of the caries-active the patient’s daily acidic intake [34]. With this in-
patients and 3% of the control group exhibited formation, preventive measures and dietary in-
such habits. So during the clinical assessment of terventions individually tailored to each patient
patients with ETW, it is important to assess their can then be elaborated in an attempt to slow the
behaviours and drinking habits. progression of ETW.
References
1 Shellis RP, Ganss C, Ren Y, Zero DT, 6 Zucconi S, Volpato C, Adinolfi F, et al: 12 Nahás Pires Corrêa MS, Nahás Pires
Lussi A: Methodology and models in Gathering Consumption Data on Spe- Corrêa F, Nahás Pires Corrêa JP, Mu-
erosion research: discussion and conclu- cific Consumer Groups of Energy rakami C, Mendes FM: Prevalence and
sions. Caries Res 2011;45(suppl 1):69– Drinks. http://www.efsa.europa.eu/pub- associated factors of dental erosion in
77. lications 2013:EN-394:190 pp. children and adolescents of a private
2 Carvalho TS, Colon P, Ganss C, et al: 7 Jarvinen VK, Rytomaa, II, Heinonen OP: dental practice. Int J Paediatr Dent 2011;
Consensus report of the European Fed- Risk factors in dental erosion. J Dent Res 21:451–458.
eration of Conservative Dentistry: ero- 1991;70:942–947. 13 Van’t Spijker A, Rodriguez JM, Kreulen
sive tooth wear – diagnosis and man- 8 Lussi A, Jaeggi T, Zero D: The role of CM, Bronkhorst EM, Bartlett DW,
agement. Clin Oral Investig 2015;19: diet in the aetiology of dental erosion. Creugers NH: Prevalence of tooth wear
1557–1561. Caries Res 2004;38(suppl 1):34–44. in adults. Int J Prosthodont 2009;22:
3 Siqueira WL, Custodio W, McDonald 9 Dugmore CR, Rock WP: A multifactorial 35–42.
EE: New insights into the composition analysis of factors associated with dental 14 Kreulen CM, Van’t Spijker A, Rodriguez
and functions of the acquired enamel erosion. Br Dent J 2004;196:283–286. JM, Bronkhorst EM, Creugers NH,
pellicle. J Dent Res 2012;91:1110–1118. 10 Lien N, Lytle LA, Klepp KI: Stability in Bartlett DW: Systematic review of the
4 Zimmerman JN, Custodio W, Hatibovic- consumption of fruit, vegetables, and prevalence of tooth wear in children and
Kofman S, Lee YH, Xiao Y, Siqueira WL: sugary foods in a cohort from age 14 to adolescents. Caries Res. 2010;44:151–
Proteome and peptidome of human ac- age 21. Prev Med 2001;33:217–226. 159.
quired enamel pellicle on deciduous 11 O’Sullivan EA, Curzon ME: A compari- 15 Harris R, Gamboa A, Dailey Y, Ashcroft
teeth. Int J Mol Sci 2013;14:920–934. son of acidic dietary factors in children A: One-to-one dietary interventions
5 Cavadini C, Siega-Riz AM, Popkin BM: with and without dental erosion. ASDC J undertaken in a dental setting to change
US adolescent food intake trends from Dent Child 2000;67:186–192. dietary behaviour. Cochrane Database
1965 to 1996. West J Med 2000;173: Syst Rev 2012;3:CD006540.
378–383.
132.174.255.215 - 11/8/2019 1:53:23 PM
98 Saads Carvalho · Lussi
UCSF Library & CKM
Downloaded by: