You are on page 1of 8

Social Science & Medicine 50 (2000) 169±176

www.elsevier.com/locate/socscimed

The role of the World Bank in international health:


renewed commitment and partnership
Joy A. de Beyer a, Alexander S. Preker a,*, Richard G.A. Feachem b
a
World Bank, 1818 H. Street, N.W., Washington DC, 20433, USA
b
Institute for Global Health, University of California, 74 New Montgomery Street, San Francisco, CA 94105, USA

Abstract

During the course of the past ten years, the World Bank has become the single largest external ®nancier of health
activities in low and middle income countries and an important voice in national and international debates on
health policy. This article highlights the Bank's new strategic direction in the health sector aimed at: improving
health, nutrition, and population outcomes of the poor; enhancing the performance of health care systems; and
securing sustainable health care ®nancing.
Millions of preventable deaths and treatable illnesses, together with health systems that are inecient, inequitable
and ine€ective, have motivated expanded Bank support for the health sector in many of its client countries. The
new policy directions and system-wide reforms observed in these countries are the result of both demand and supply
factors. It is part of a general shift in the Bank's approach to development assistance, which sees systemic reform as
a way to improve the impact and sustainability of investments in health. On the demand side, the Bank is trying to
adapt to ongoing political, technological, economic, demographic, epidemiological and social pressures. On the
supply side, the Bank's growing international experience and substantial ®nancial resources are used to complement
the development assistance provided by other organizations and the global e€ort to improve health and health
systems in low and middle income countries. # 1999 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.

Keywords: World Bank; Health policy; Health system reform; International health; Human development

During the past ten years, the World Bank has world-wide consultation. The 1997 ``Health, Nutrition,
become the single largest external ®nancier of health and Population (HNP) Sector Strategy'' de®nes the
activities in low-to middle-income countries and an im- Bank's enhanced commitment and policies in the
portant voice in national and international debates on health sector during the period leading into the 21st
health policy (Note 1). The Bank's major health sector Century. As described in this document, the objectives
report Ð ``World Development Report 1993: Investing of the Bank's involvement in the HNP sector are to
in Health'' Ð was based on extensive analysis and assist client countries to:
. improve the health, nutrition, and population outcomes
of the poor, and to protect the population from the
* Corresponding author Tel.: +1-202-473-3665; Fax: +1-
202-522-3234. impoverishing e€ects of illness, malnutrition, and
E-mail addresses: jdebeyer@worldbank.org (J.A. de high fertility;
Beyer), apreker@worldbank.org (A.S. Preker), rfeachem@- . enhance the performance of health care systems by
psg.ucsf.edu (R.G.A. Feachem) promoting equitable access to preventive and cura-

0277-9536/99/$ - see front matter # 1999 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
PII: S 0 2 7 7 - 9 5 3 6 ( 9 9 ) 0 0 2 5 8 - 0
170 J.A. de Beyer et al. / Social Science & Medicine 50 (2000) 169±176

tive health, nutrition, and population services that . the health sector serves people throughout their life-
are a€ordable, e€ective, well managed, of good cycle;
quality, and responsive to client needs; and . most interventions require behavioral changes and
. secure sustainable health care ®nancing by mobilizing time;
adequate levels of resources, establishing broad- . implementation arrangements are often di€use;
based risk pooling mechanisms, and maintaining . reforms are often intensely political;
e€ective control over public and private expenditure. . frequently there is institutional resistance to change;
. uncertainty and the high cost of illness require risk
These new policy directions will be described in greater
pooling;
detail in this article.
. the private sector is prominent but market failure is
signi®cant;
. governments have an important role but have weak
Rationale for Bank involvement in international health institutional capacity; and
. monitoring and evaluating performance is dicult.
Investing in people is at the center of the Bank's
development strategy for the 1990s, re¯ecting the fact An available supply of contraceptives, vaccines, or
that no country can achieve sustainable economic micro-nutrient supplements does not automatically eli-
growth and poverty reduction without a healthy and cit people's demand for them. Many health interven-
educated population. E€ective programs for infectious tions require behavioral changes, time and complex
disease control, nutrition and reproductive health can partnerships between the public and private sector to
enhance workforce productivity, reduce disease-related work. The social choices that societies face in allocat-
poverty and improve children's learning in school. ing resources eciently and e€ectively across the life-
Good health and reproductive choice have a strong cycle and encouraging individuals or population
impact on individual welfare and a nation's socio-econ- groups to change their behavior, make HNP sector
omic development (Note 2). Despite clear gains in reforms intensely political and can generate strong re-
health for developing nations during the past 30 years, sistance from vested stakeholders whose interests are
there are still millions of deaths and illnesses that threatened by proposed changes. The diculty of
could be prevented or treated easily and inexpensively. reaching consensus is more general; the complexity of
In some countries, per capita spending on health is so the issues gives rise to debate among professionals in
low that it does not provide sucient resources for the Bank and other international organizations, for
even basic health care for the population. In other example: about the most appropriate balance and roles
countries, a more tractable and pervasive problem is of the public and private sectors, the cost-e€ectiveness
poor allocation that squanders scarce resources on of di€erent types of interventions and the extent to
interventions that give only meager health improve- which these calculations should guide resource and
ments. program decisions, the rationale and realities of fees
In addition to the links among health outcomes, for health care and the trade-o€s between some growth
economic growth and poverty alleviation, the economic promoting policies and poverty alleviation objectives.
and ®scal importance of the health sector is another
compelling reason for World Bank involvement. In
many countries, a very large share of national product Need for international collaboration and partnerships
and public resources is spent on health care, and
should be well spent. If health expenditures grow too To change the deeply ingrained systemic problems in
rapidly relative to the rest of the economy, the negative the health sector, most countries say they need: (a)
®scal consequences can hurt economic growth and ®nancial resources that outstrip their local capacity;
crowd out other social expenditure (such as education (b) a broad global perspective and intersectoral exper-
and social protection) which have a signi®cant impact tise; (c) long-term commitment since even small
on poverty reduction and health. changes in outcome may take as long as 10 to 15 years
to realize, extending well beyond the average length of
a Minister's term in oce; and (d) an understanding of
Unique features of the social sectors local circumstances (economic, political, social and in-
stitutional).
The Bank is continually making internal changes to WHO, UNICEF, the Bank and other international
develop the skills and procedures needed to respond organizations have each contributed in their own mod-
appropriately and in a ¯exible way to some of the est way to improving health across the world during
special characteristics that make international health a the past few decades. Yet the 21st Century harbors
dicult area in which to work e€ectively: many new challenges. Demographic shifts with contin-
J.A. de Beyer et al. / Social Science & Medicine 50 (2000) 169±176 171

ued population growth, aging populations, urbaniz- Some countries will become better o€, no longer
ation, economic disparity and a growing number of needing the intensive assistance they previously
poor will put new demands on health care systems. received from the international donor community.
Looming behind these predictable trends are a number Others will slip back and require more attention.
of unknown threats such as new diseases and epi- Finding the right balance in the mix of inputs among
demics, and political turmoil. basic, post basic and systemic interventions in this

Fig. 1. Cumulative growth in HNP lending and projects (1996 prices).


172 J.A. de Beyer et al. / Social Science & Medicine 50 (2000) 169±176

dynamic context will be one of the great challenges for From a modest start 30 years ago, the Bank's role in
the next decade. international health has expanded rapidly. At the end
Fortunately, recent progress in the natural and of FY99 there were 199 active Bank supported HNP
social sciences holds the hope that some of these po- projects in 84 countries with total commitments of
tentially negative trends may be o€set by new and US$9.5 billion (1996 prices), and 130 completed pro-
more e€ective approaches to health care, an enhanced jects (see Fig. 1 and Note 3). By comparison, total
partnership between the public and private sectors in overseas development assistance to the HNP sector for
providing health services, and a worldwide spread of the period from 1985 through 1993 was about US$2
new information and technology which should even- billion annually in 1996 prices (excluding Bank loans
tually bene®t the poor. which averaged US$0.75 billion per year in 1996 prices
The Bank's comparative advantage is its ability to over this period).
mobilize large ®nancial resources, work across many Typically, well over half of Bank health funding is
sectors, and provide a macro-level country focus. Yet ``soft'' money with an e€ective grant component of
none of the international organizations can address the 80%. All projects include substantial funds from the
complex health, nutrition, and reproductive challenges borrowing government, and many also include funds
which face the world during the 21st Century alone. from other multilateral and bilateral donors who ``buy
The Bank is, therefore, seeking to strengthen its collab- into'' projects and often team up with Bank sta€ to
oration and partnerships with many other agencies, work with client governments to de®ne and develop
including NGOs, and the private sector. Within the project activities and ®nancing needs.
Bank, the aim is continual strengthening of technical
expertise and signi®cant re-tooling of both skill-mix
and working culture. Greater selectivity and comple- Recent directions in lending and credits
mentarity is also required so that scarce technical and
®nancial resources reach those who need them the The content and focus of health loans has changed
most. signi®cantly in recent years and continues to change.
Earlier projects typically expanded and upgraded state
health services, and Bank funds were spent on govern-
ment rural health centers and hospitals, medical equip-
Current track record of the Bank in international health ment and supplies including contraceptives and
pharmaceuticals, training (and sometimes salaries) for
The Bank is currently involved in international sta€, and ambulances and other vehicles (inter alia).
health in four di€erent areas: Some project funds still go to such things because
. Lending and credits expansion and strengthening of the government health
. Development grants system is still a priority in much of Africa and Asia. In
. Policy advice addition, three other important needs are also being
. Research addressed worldwide (see Fig. 2).

Fig. 2. Scope of intervention.


J.A. de Beyer et al. / Social Science & Medicine 50 (2000) 169±176 173

In many middle-income countries, where basic ser- of ownership of health facilities in Croatia and
vices are already in place, the main challenge is to Hungary from the central government to local commu-
®nance, deliver and regulate services at higher levels of nities. In Zambia, the Bank helped the Ministry of
care in a balanced and a€ordable manner. Second, Health develop a strategic plan for sweeping health
health systems in a number of countries (such as sector reform to decentralize management, increase
Bosnia, Croatia, and Mozambique) need support in autonomy of health facilities, and strengthen ®rst-level
the face or aftermath of devastating political or econ- service delivery. The program joins six other donors in
omic turmoil. Finally, Bank-funded projects increas- providing ®nancial support for the reform.
ingly contribute to broad systemic reforms aimed at Similar initiatives are underway in Mozambique,
making investments in health systems and programs Ethiopia, Tanzania, Sierra Leone, and Ghana. Bank
more sustainable and e€ective, while improving quality sta€ are engaged in Argentinean e€orts to reform
and access for the poor. The following provides some health insurance, and have worked with researchers
examples of the sort of health projects for which gov- and policy-makers to evaluate past Brazilian reforms
ernments are now borrowing from the World Bank. and facilitate broad national discussion and consensus-
Numerous projects are helping to ®ll serious gaps in building on an agenda for renewed reform e€orts
health care. The Indian Urban Slums Family Welfare including improved ®nancing arrangements to tackle
Project pays private organizations and medical prac- the immense challenges that still face the health sector
titioners to provide services in slums and to train in this country (World Bank, 1994).
21,000 urban health workers and local leaders. In
Malawi and Zimbabwe, in addition to support for nu-
merous other activities, health centers are being built Policy role
in unserved rural areas and community-based health
and population services are being expanded and sup- Policy advice has long been one of the ways that the
ported. In Russia, basic medical equipment lacking World Bank serves its clientele, usually through so-
from ®rst and second level facilities is being ®nanced. called ``sector work'' Ð analytic studies of sectors or
Investment in basic health services has remained the speci®c issues, which invariably include policy and pro-
major focus of the Bank's lending to the health sector gram reform recommendations. These studies tra-
(over 75% of total lending). ditionally preceded loan preparation, and are an
Many examples could be cited where the focus is on important mechanism for Bank sta€ to study the
``post-basic'' interventions and improvements in investment needs within the sector. They also stimulate
resource allocation. The Bank is helping the analysis, debate and consensus-building needed to
Uruguayan e€ort to improve eciency and quality of guide investment decisions. Formerly, sector work and
health care services (especially for the poor and unin- loan development fed o€ each other, but were usually
sured) through institutional strengthening in the separate activities. Recently, policy analysis, advice
Ministry of Health and a pilot e€ort to strengthen the and sectoral reform are increasingly becoming an inte-
management of four public hospitals. Hungary has gral part of the loan process. This greater emphasis on
used Bank funds to establish a School of Public health sector policy and system-wide reform is the
Health and a (tertiary level) Health Services result of both supply and demand factors.
Management Training Centre, to equip 15% of hospi-
tals with management information systems, to set up a Supply side factors
cancer registry, health education in schools and to cre-
ate an information base and network focused on There are two ``supply side'' factors leading to
tobacco policy. These activities are part of a project greater policy engagement by the Bank. The ®rst is a
that aims to improve health by reallocating resources general shift in the institution's approach to develop-
to cost-e€ective strategic public health activities and ment and aid.
selected clinical services. Many countries in Latin Disappointing results, and the apparent unsustain-
America, the Caribbean, Asia and Africa are studying ability of investments in many sectors, have led to an
health priorities in order to identify cost-e€ective emphasis on macro-economic and sectoral adjustment
packages of essential public health and clinical services to improve the environment within which investments
for the poor and to provide data upon which to base are made, and the bene®ts that ¯ow from them (Note
future ®nancing strategies (Bobadilla, 1997). 4). In health (as in other sectors) structural reforms are
The Bank is also contributing intellectually and often as necessary to better health outcomes as ad-
®nancially to attempts to transform the health sectors ditional investments in infrastructure, training, drugs
in many of the formerly socialist countries, and else- and other inputs. Comparisons across 69 countries of
where across the globe (Preker and Feachem, 1995). life expectancy relative to per capita spending on
These include health reform in Russia and the transfer health care suggest that countries di€er signi®cantly in
174 J.A. de Beyer et al. / Social Science & Medicine 50 (2000) 169±176

the e€ectiveness of their health care systems nization and TB chemotherapy may cost as little as
(Musgrove, 1996 and Note 5). US$10.0 per DALY, whereas some terminal or inten-
There is no single prescription for a successful health sive care interventions that prolong life for at best a
care system. Several things clearly matter though: few days costs US$1.0 million or more per DALY
measures that correct for market failure and that (Note 7).
ensure that interventions with large externalities are Computing the cost per DALY of interventions pro-
available to the population; adequate spending on cru- vides an objective measure of why it makes more sense
cial public health interventions such as immunizations to spend scarce health resources on Vitamin A sup-
and prenatal care; the overall allocation of health plementation in northern Ghana rather than heart
spending, especially making sure that high-cost inter- bypass surgery; treat sexually transmitted diseases in
ventions bene®ting relatively small numbers of people rural China rather than pay for high-tech cancer
do not divert resources from activities that bene®t therapy; or promote diet, lifestyle and tobacco-use
large numbers of people; and access to health care changes in Eastern Europe rather than install more
which is largely determined by the nature, distribution, CAT scanners in the hospitals. Health policy makers
cost and quality of public and private services. Where who care about cost-e€ectiveness and public health
health services are of poor quality, the private sector impact must also consider the numbers of people who
crowded out or poorly regulated, or the state sector will bene®t from proposed interventions. It may not
inecient (perhaps su€ering from over-centralized de- make sense to train and equip government health prac-
cision making, poor incentives, misallocation of titioners to deliver services which, although highly
resources, and inadequate or inappropriate training of cost-e€ective, address only relatively rare conditions.
health managers), broad systemic reforms have the po- The cumulative impact on a society is therefore an im-
tential to do more to improve health and the function- portant element in the ®nal resource allocation de-
ing of health care systems than additional ill-chosen cision-making process.
investments in infrastructure or consumables. Reallocating public funds to interventions with wide
The other ``supply side'' factor is the Bank's cumu- bene®ts and low costs per DALY enhances equity as
lative experience of engaging in policy debate in over well as eciency because these interventions are often
80 countries, its research and analysis, and its good of particular bene®t to poor people, women and chil-
working partnerships with the World Health dren. Although the optimal mix of interventions will
Organization, UNICEF and other institutions. vary depending on country circumstances, in many
Improved knowledge and partnerships with other or- developing countries they are likely to include: immu-
ganizations, combined with the Bank's ®nancial nization; school-based services such as deworming and
resources and leverage, have supported policy formu- distribution of micronutrient supplements; information
lation and health sector reforms in many countries. and selected services for family planning and nutrition;
Two policy domains where the Bank has been es- programs to reduce tobacco and alcohol consumption;
pecially active are: the allocation of resources accord- regulation, information and limited public investments
ing to cost-e€ectiveness principles; and rede®ning the to improve household environments (clean water, sani-
appropriate role of the state and private sector in tation, drainage, indoor air pollution); AIDS preven-
health care (Note 6). tion, and a basic set of clinical services at least
including pregnancy-related care, TB therapy, STD
Allocation of resources according to cost-e€ectiveness detection and treatment, care for the common serious
principles illnesses of childhood, and some treatment for minor
infection and trauma (World Bank, 1993; Bobadilla,
The analysis reported in ``Disease Control Priorities 1997).
in Developing Countries'' (Jamison et al., 1993) and
``Investing in Health'' (World Bank, 1993) on the rela-
tive cost-e€ectiveness of various health care interven- Rede®ning the appropriate role of the state and non-
tions has already helped many policy-makers in governmental sector
developing countries focus scarce health care resources
on achieving better health outcomes. In this analysis, a The Bank is also focusing on assisting countries to
range of preventive and curative interventions are com- rede®ne the role of the State and the non-governmen-
pared on the basis of their costs and impact on disabil- tal sector in health care (World Bank, 1995). The
ity adjusted life years (DALYs). The cost of preventing Bank's new Sector Strategy for Health, Nutrition, and
the loss of a disability adjusted life year can vary Population (World Bank, 1997) argues for greater gov-
hugely, depending on the cost and ecacy of the inter- ernment action in o€setting the negative e€ects of mar-
vention, the age group that the illness a€ects, and the ket failure and facilitating partnerships with non-
severity of the a‚iction. For example, measles immu- governmental health care providers within a regulatory
J.A. de Beyer et al. / Social Science & Medicine 50 (2000) 169±176 175

framework that prevents abuses and deterioration in Africa and Zambia Ð political changes have catalyzed
quality or safety. restructuring of health (and other) systems. Argentina,
Four recent Bank documents carry this analysis Brazil, Colombia and Ecuador are attempting to
further (Preker and Feachem, 1995; Musgrove, 1996; restructure and reform health systems that were clearly
Van der Gaag, 1995; Schieber, 1997). Preker and failing to improve health or satisfy demand in the face
Feachem describe the political economy of the tran- of rising expectations, ®scal pressure and ¯awed health
sition which has swept across the health sector in insurance systems. China, with assistance from the
Central and Eastern Europe since the collapse of com- World Bank, is considering options for health ®nance
munism. They provide sobering examples of the nega- reform that would make basic health services more
tive impact of excesses in both state and private sector accessible to the rural poor and other disadvantaged
activities in the health sector, arguing for a mixed and populations (World Bank, 1996). It has been observed
balanced approach. Musgrove sets out the economic in many countries that a successful shift to greater re-
and poverty-related reasons for state intervention in liance on the private sector for health care also
health care and discusses the extent to which the state requires a shift and strengthening in the role of the
might inform, regulate, mandate, ®nance, and deliver state in policy making, regulation and quality control.
health services. He concludes that there are compelling Although the problems that health sector reforms
reasons for a signi®cant state role in health, but that are attacking are not new, pressure to address them
many governments ®nance and deliver too much, but has come to a head in many countries. Fiscal pressures
inform and regulate too little. Van der Gaag describes have squeezed health budgets while several factors con-
10 examples of partnerships between the state and pri- spire to raise the demand for health spending. Rising
vate sector in health care provision in developing incomes lead to higher demand for health care. Many
countries that are being supported by the Bank. He middle-income countries that have secured access to
also gives a brief historical overview of their relative basic health services now face more dicult choices in
roles in health (and education), notes that equity, qual- providing ``mid-level'' services, which tend to be much
ity and eciency are not always better or worse when costlier and which draw resources away from basic
the government or private sector dominates, and gives care. New medical technology and rising expectations
4 principles to help attain an optimal mix. Schieber exert powerful upward pressures on spending.
reviews the various dimensions of mobilizing adequate Dissatisfaction with the quality (and sometimes quan-
®nancial resources for the health sector. tity) of services is widespread and seems increasingly
These analyses and descriptions aim to help policy- to be voiced. Aging populations and the attendant epi-
makers and advisors in their deliberations and de- demiological transition also raise health care costs. In
cisions in an area where there is little published practi- much of Africa especially, persistent high fertility and
cal advice. population growth require expanded health spending
simply to maintain service levels.
Demand side factors Finally, not all health care reforms are based on
sound technical analysis. Many of the health care
Worldwide, there is a global pandemic of health sec- reforms in Central and Eastern Europe and elsewhere
tor reform occurring today. Countries are trying to in the world are hotly debated, and some are unlikely
restructure and reform their health systems, some in to improve outcomes or even the quality of health ser-
the context of broader changes such as those occurring vices.
in transition economies, economic crises or post-con-
¯ict situations. Reform initiatives are a response to a
variety of political, technological, economic, demo-
Preparing for the challenges of the 21st century
graphic, epidemiological and social pressures, the im-
portance (or presence) of which varies across
Several recent initiatives underscore the importance
countries. Sometimes the Bank's advocacy, in close
and urgency that the Bank has attached to ®nding new
collaboration with other international institutions, acts
and more e€ective ways to assist developing countries.
as an additional impetus to these reforms.
These fall into ®ve categories:
In the formerly socialist countries, the hope is that
market forces, greater diversity in supply, decentraliza- . developing a new strategic focus on clearly de®ned
tion and more individual choice will improve eciency, priorities in the health sector which builds on the
responsiveness to health care needs and patient satis- comparative strength of the Bank as a multi-sectoral
faction (Preker and Feachem, 1995). Health ®nancing and global agency;
is becoming more diversi®ed, requiring new regulatory . working more closely with clients in analyzing pro-
and cost containment measures. In a number of blems, de®ning solutions and implementing change;
African countries Ð notably Mozambique, South . increasing selectivity in de®ning the Bank's product
176 J.A. de Beyer et al. / Social Science & Medicine 50 (2000) 169±176

line of interventions in the health sector to respond included in the analysis reported, but the results are
most appropriately to current demand and future robust.
needs; 6. In these areas and others, the Bank works closely
. adapting the Bank's management culture, knowledge with and depends on researchers, practitioners and
base, sta€ development policies, business processes other professionals and policy-makers across the
and portfolio performance to the needs of the health world.
sector; and 7. There are of course several other methods for asses-
. providing support to other organizations and leader- sing the burden of disease and cost-e€ectiveness of
ship in spearheading major international initiatives interventions.
in the health sector with the potential for making a
signi®cant global impact on health outcomes.
It is hoped that these e€orts will allow the Bank to
become more e€ective in assisting developing countries
to break the vicious cycle of poor health, low pro- References
ductivity and poverty.
Bobadilla, J.L., 1997. Searching for Essential Health Services
in Low and Middle Income Countries: A Review of
Recent Studies on Health Priorities. World Bank,
Notes
Washington World Bank Technical Paper.
1. Throughout this article, health includes health, Jamison, D., Mosley, W.H., Measham, A., Bobadilla, J.,
population and nutrition. Many other Bank-sup- 1993. Disease Control Priorities in Developing Countries.
ported activities (for example poverty reduction, Oxford University Press, New York.
housing, water and sanitation, and education of Musgrove, P., 1996. Public and Private Roles in Health:
girls) also a€ect health. Theory and Financing Patterns. World Bank, Washington
World Bank Technical Paper.
2. Good health and longer life expectancy encourage
Preker, A., Feachem, R., 1995. Market Mechanisms and the
investment in education and other human capital. Health Sector in Central and Eastern Europe. World
Together these raise productivity and income. Bank, Washington World Bank Technical Paper Number
Information on and access to contraception, along 293.
with low child mortality and more education (es- Psacharopoulos, G. 1995. Building Human Capital for Better
pecially for women), are important factors for smal- Lives. Directions in Development, World Bank,
ler family size. This a€ords greater human capital Washington.
investments in the next generation (Psacharopoulos, Schieber, G., 1997. Innovations in Health Care Financing.
1995). World Bank, Washington.
3. The average annual value of new loans for health Van der Gaag, J., 1995. Private and Public Initiatives,
Working Together for Health and Education. In:
over the three years 1993±1995 was $1.3 billion, 6%
Directions in Development. World Bank, Washington.
of total Bank lending. This increase to $1.6 billion Van der Gaag, J., Barham, T., 1998. Health and health
and 6.5% during 1996±1999. This trend is expected expenditures in adjusting and non-adjusting countries.
to continue. Social Science and Medicine 46 (8), 995±1009.
4. Concern has often been expressed that macroeco- World, Bank 1993 World Development Report 1993:
nomic structural adjustment reduces spending on Investing in Health. World Bank, New York.
health care and damages health. The Bank is cur- World, Bank, 1994. The Organization, Delivery and
rently reviewing the evidence (Van der Gaag and Financing of Health Care in Brazil: an Agenda for the
Barham, 1998). Today many Bank-supported 1990s. The World Bank, Washington.
adjustment programs require governments to protect World, Bank, 1995. Investing in People. The World Bank in
Action. In: Directions in Development. World Bank,
the budget share or level of spending on health, or
Washington.
to increase the allocation to basic health services World, Bank, 1996. China: Issues and Options in Health
that bene®t the poor particularly. Financing, (Report No 15278-CHA). World Bank,
5. The analysis controls for per capita income, which Washington.
is the most signi®cant predictor of life expectancy. World, Bank, 1997. Health, Nutrition, and Population (HNP)
Health outcomes have numerous determinants not Sector Strategy. World Bank, Washington.

You might also like