Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chapter 2: Manufacturing Identities: The Social Construction of Race, Class, Gender, and Sexuality
Chapter 2
Manufacturing Identities: The Social
Construction of Race, Class, Gender, and
Sexuality
Perspectives On Identity
o Essentialism
o Constructionism
Definitions of Differences and Identities
o Racial/Ethnic Identities
The Social Construction of Race and Ethnicity
Multiracial Identities
o Class Identities
How do Americans Determine Class Standing?
Who is Poor?
o Gender Identities
Doing Gender
The Sexual Dichotomy
Intersexuality and Anatomical Ambiguity
o Sexual Orientations
The Complexities of Sexual Identity
Heteronormativity
“The Closet”
o Identities on the Borderlands
Conclusion
Investigating Identities and Inequalities—A sociological treasure hunt: The artifacts of
identity
Chapter Summary
Chapter 2 begins with a discussion on the active processes of making identities through
two narratives. The first example is about the transgendering process from man to woman
(so far as that was possible through internal and external medical treatments). The second
example is about the process of going from black to white to black again. The chapter
addresses the shifting boundaries between identity categories as well as their
intersections. The chapter defines identity and discusses where or in what criteria is
identity located. The chapter defines essentialism and constructionism, and raises the
question of which, if any, social identifiers exist as natural objective entities, and which
emerge from particular cultural and historical contexts and active human processes. Race,
ethnicity, class, sex, gender, and sexuality are all defined and reflected upon regarding
the poles of essentialism versus constructionism. The chapter concludes with an
examination of gay black men on the down low and the consequences they face.
Key Terms
Note: consists of both terms highlighted/defined by the author, and terms suggested for
instructor emphasis.
Identities: These are definitional categories used to specify to oneself and to others who
one is; social locations that determine one’s position in the world relative to other people.
Multiple identities: We all possess many identities be they based on race, ethnicity,
religion, gender, class, sexuality, oc-cupation, education, family, age, geography, or some
other aspect of our background. At any given moment, some of these identities can
overshadow the others.
Race: To most people, race is a category of individuals who share common inborn
biological traits, such as skin color; color and texture of hair; and shape of eyes, nose, or
head. It is widely assumed that people who are placed in the same racial category share
behavioral, psychological, and personality traits that are linked to their physical
similarities.
Ethnicity: Sociologists typically use the term ethnicity to refers to the nonbiological
traits—such as shared ancestry, culture, history, language, patterns of behavior, and
Honorary white: The government created a category of “honorary white” for rich,
powerful Asians (Hu-DeHart, 1996). Less affluent Asians—such as immigrant laborers
from China—weren’t afforded this privilege and remained “colored.”.
Social class: It is a group of people who share a similar economic position in society
based on their wealth and income.
Social mobility: It is the movement of people or groups from one class level or another.
Upper class: This group is the highest-earning 5% of the U.S. population. It is usually
thought to include owners of vast amounts of property and other forms of wealth, major
shareholders and owners of large corporations, top financiers, rich celebrities and
politicians, and members of prestigious families.
Middle class: This group roughly comprises of 45% of the population. This group is
likely to include college-educated managers, supervisors, executives, small-business
owners, and professionals (for example, lawyers, doctors, teachers, and engineers).
Working class: This group comprises of about 35% of the population. They typically
includes industrial and factory workers, office workers, clerks, and farm and manual
laborers. Most working-class people don’t own their own homes and don’t attend college.
Lower class or underclass: This group is also referred to as the “poor,” (about 15% of
the population) and consist of people who work for minimum wages or are chronically
unemployed. These are the people who do society’s dirty work, often for very low wages.
Moral boundaries: In terms of social class, this consist of assessments of such qualities
as honesty, integrity, work ethic, and consideration for others.
Cultural boundaries: These are identified on the basis of education, taste, and manners.
Class distinctions often go beyond upper-class snobbery and distaste for the lifestyles of
“lower” classes.
CASTRUCCIO CASTRACANI
Castruccio was the scion of a Ghibelline stock, and was devoted to the
Ghibelline cause; for four years successively he was freely elected to
command the Lucchese with almost sovereign power. He knew men and
how to govern them; knew what enmities to despise or punish, and what
friendships to win and retain. As a daring soldier and skilful general he
was beloved by the troops, for he was not blind to merit and knew how
to reward it, but cared little about the morality of his followers if they
only did their duty and quietly submitted to the rigid discipline that he
established and enforced. No man was more beloved by the people or
more generally popular with every class of citizen; they admired his
talents and were proud of his fame. In 1320 he felt so confident of his
position in the public mind that he ventured to expel the Avocati, who
with about 180 great Guelfic families now bid adieu to their country, and
then boldly demanded the supreme authority; out of 210 senators there
was but one voice against him, and the people unanimously confirmed
this election. He was therefore a legitimate ruler. His economical
management of the public revenue was exemplary and productive; he
had amassed great treasure, and his system of military honours and
rewards heightened and improved the warlike spirit of the people until it
had acquired a more professional character. All the neighbouring
predaceous chiefs were allured to his standard by the hope of future
conquests, and rough and unscrupulous as they were he made them all
bend to his discipline.
Thus prepared on every hand to begin that career of ambition to which
he felt himself more than equal, Matteo Visconti’s proposal was warmly
received, and Philip of Valois’ expedition with the ready assistance of the
Guelfic league were together considered an infringement of the general
peace, or at least a sufficient excuse for retaliation on the part of the
Ghibellines. Uguccione Faggiuola was dead, a circumstance that
heightened the anxiety of both Castruccio and the Florentines,
particularly the latter, whose dread of this veteran chief, blinding them as
it did to the dangerous ambition of his successor, had never ceased since
the disaster of Montecatini.
Such was the state of affairs in April, 1320,
[1320-1321 . .] when Castruccio Castracani with some Pisan
auxiliaries suddenly occupying Cappiano,
Montefalcone, and the bridges of the Gusciano, broke into the Florentine
territory carrying death and devastation as far as Cerreto Guidi, Vinci,
and Empoli; then, getting possession of Santa Maria a Monte by
treachery, returned in triumph to Lucca. Afterwards, invading Lunigiana
and Garfagnana, he dispossessed Spinetto Malespina of several places
necessary for his own military operations and then marched with all his
force to aid the siege of Genoa. This city still maintained a fierce and
bloody struggle with its own exiles and the Lombard Ghibellines; war
raged not only round the walls but throughout the whole Riviera, or coast
district; it extended to Sicily and Naples and involved even more distant
countries in its action, so that the siege of Troy itself, as Villanid asserts,
was hardly equal to it for heroic deeds, marvellous exploits, and hard-
fought battles by land and water, without any cessation either in summer
or winter.
The Florentines determined to prevent a junction that would probably
have settled the fate of Genoa, therefore made a powerful diversion in
the Lucchese states which compelled Castruccio to return ere he had
joined the besiegers; avoiding an action they retreated to the frontier at
Fucecchio while the enemy halted in front of Cappiano, both armies
remaining nearly inactive until the advancing season drove them into
winter quarters. To make amends for this inglorious campaign, more
vigorous measures were pursued and an alliance was concluded with the
marquis Spinetto Malespina, who, although a Ghibelline, had been too
much injured by Castruccio on account of his friendship for Uguccione
not to seize the first opportunity of revenge. Florentine troops were
despatched to his aid, yet Castruccio was not apprehensive of anything in
that quarter, but prepared with the help of a powerful body of Lombard
Ghibellines for a more serious struggle on the side of Florence and soon
marched to raise the siege of Monte Vettolini at the head of sixteen
hundred men-at-arms. The Florentines, having only half that number,
immediately retired and allowed him to devastate their territory with
impunity for the last twenty days of June, after which he retired to
chastise the Malespini in Lunigiana.
Discontent ran high in Florence and the retiring seigniory were much
censured for their feeble conduct; the Agubbio faction was still powerful,
and probably the inconvenience of a fluctuating administration was
beginning to be felt, as the foreign affairs with a more complex character
embraced a wider circle; to remedy this, twelve counsellors, two for each
sesto under the denomination of “Buonuomini” were added to the new
seigniory, but to continue six months in office instead of two, and
without whose sanction nothing important could be undertaken. To check
also the increasing intimacy, and consequent favouritism between
citizens and foreign officers of state, which led to great abuse, it was
decreed that no stranger who brought a kinsman in his suite could have a
place in the commonwealth, and that until ten years from his resignation
of office he could not be re-elected. Some taxes were then reduced, the
gold and silver currency reformed, and preparations made for a fresh
campaign. Azzo of Brescia was appointed captain-general; one hundred
and sixteen knights and one hundred and sixty mounted crossbowmen
were enlisted and under the command of Jacopo da Fontana soon
checked Castruccio’s incursions so as to protect the line of the Gusciana.
But Philip of Valois’ expedition had in the meanwhile failed, and in
Lombardy the Tuscans were defeated at Bardo in the Val-di-Taro, their
captain the marquis of Cavalcabò was killed, Cremona recaptured, and
Visconti everywhere victorious.
In Florence one of the first public measures in
[1321-1323 . .] 1321 was to complete the whole circuit of public
walls and strengthen it by flanking towers fifty-
five feet high at regular intervals of more than one hundred and eighty
feet apart; a work that was doubtless accelerated by their apprehension of
Castruccio, which had now taken a more alarming character from some
recent proceedings at Pistoia.
This ever-vexed city, harassed by external war and inward troubles,
finally elected the abbate da Pacciana de’ Tedici, a tool of Castruccio, as
their ruler; he was a weak intriguing man who, catching at a popular
opinion, was suddenly floated into power by the stormy multitude
without ballast enough to steady him. Castruccio made good use of him,
and a truce was suddenly concluded with that leader against all the
influence of Florence, by which, according to Villanid (though unnoticed
by the anonymous author of the Istorie Pistolese),f an annual tribute of
three thousand florins was to be paid by Pistoia. The dread of Castruccio
was rapidly and generally spreading.
FLORENCE MENACED
S M ,F
She might have bought it for the same price or even less than
Castruccio, because Filippo felt himself too insecure not to make both
friends and money by the sacrifice of his country; but failing, either from
want of skill or perhaps dishonesty in her agents, she repeated her
attempts to surprise the place, thus forcing him into the arms of
Castruccio, and he poisoned his own wife to complete the union.
Rumours of this event reached Florence while the magistrates were
engaged in public festivities on the occasion of two foreign officers of
state being dubbed knights by the republic, and the banquet was going on
in the church of San Piero Scheraggio when the news was confirmed. In
a moment the whole assembly fell into confusion, the tables were
overturned, and every man was immediately armed and in his saddle;
believing that a part of the town might still hold out, a rapid march was
made as far as Prato, where hearing the whole truth they returned
dejected and mortified to Florence. The following day brought some
consolation in the arrival of Raymond of Cardona, who had been sent in
the preceding November from Milan on a mission to Rome; he had
promised to return, but was absolved by the pope and sent instantly to
Florence as commander-in-chief of the republican forces. His presence
gave new spirit to the people, which was increased by the capture of
Artimino on the 22nd of May.
One of the finest armies ever assembled by the republic soon took the
field at the enormous expense of 3000 florins a day; the city bells tolled
as a declaration of war; the public standard waved over San Piero a
Monticelli; the soldati or mercenary troops first moved to Prato, and the
cavallate with all the mass of civic infantry joined them on the following
morning. One of the city bells which had been captured at Montale broke
while in the act of sounding; three weeks before there had been a violent
earthquake in Florence, and the following evening a broad stream of
fiery vapour flared over the city. All these circumstances were dwelt
upon with anxious and gloomy foreboding by numbers of citizens over
whose mind the talents and success of Castruccio had gained a
superstitious ascendency. The cavalry consisted of 500 gentlemen of the
highest rank in Florence under the name cavallate or men-at-arms on
horseback, all magnificently equipped and a hundred of them mounted
on destrieri, the largest and finest war-horses of the time and which few
could afford to purchase; none cost less than 150 golden florins [nearly
£200 or $1000], yet there were 300 of these, natives and strangers, in the
Florentine army. Besides the cavallate there were 1500 foreign cavalry in
the pay of Florence, of whom 800 were French and German gentlemen
of the highest rank and distinction; the general-in-chief, Raymond of
Cardona, a Spanish condottiere, and his lieutenant, Borneo of Burgundy,
were followed by a troop of 230 Catalan and Burgundian cavalry, and
lastly there were 450 Gascons, French, Flemings, Italians, and men of
Provence picked with great care from the veteran companies of
Masnadieri, and all experienced soldiers. Fifteen thousand well-
appointed infantry, between citizens and rural troops, completed the
personal force of this fine army, and 800 canvas pavilions and other great
tents, with 6000 ronzini and baggage horses attended its movements.
T P P ,F
With the exception of 200 Sienese cavalry no allies had yet joined, but
hostilities commenced on the 17th of June by devastating the Pistoian
territory up to the gates of the capital, capturing many small places,
insulting Castruccio, who was in that city, by running for the Palio under
its walls, and sending him repeated challenges to battle. Castruccio dryly
answered that it was not the right time, and the Florentines marched
directly to besiege Tizzano, a strong town about seven miles from Pistoia
on the road to Florence; there every preparation was apparently made for
a regular siege, while Cardona on the 9th of July sent his lieutenant
Borneo with 500 picked men towards Fucecchio; and to engage
Castruccio’s attention a strong detachment was at the same time directed
to alarm Pistoia and the surrounding country. Borneo was joined at
Fucecchio by 150 Lucchese exiles and a numerous infantry, besides
some reinforcements from the garrisons in Val d’Arno. Carrying with
him a pontoon bridge, apparently the first noticed by the early historians
of these campaigns, he threw it silently over the Gusciana at Rosaiuolo
during the night, and the whole division crossed that river without being
perceived by the garrisons at the bridge of Cappiano or Montefalcone,
scarcely a mile above and below the point of passage.
RAYMOND TEMPORISES
A BRILLIANT SKIRMISH
Castruccio did not fail to profit by this delay, although his army also
had decreased from want of funds and sickness, and therefore could not
long maintain its position without reinforcements, but he discovered in
that of the enemy the seeds of certain victory. By reason, money, and
promises he had already prevailed on Galeazzo Visconti to send his son
with eight hundred horse into Tuscany; and with two hundred more from
Passerino, lord of Mantua and Modena, he hoped soon to recover his
ascendency; in the meanwhile his situation was very precarious, for
Cardona by a vigorous effort might have cut his line of communication;
the latter, now sensible of his errors and probably urged by the general
discontent, had actually detached a hundred men-at-arms and a body of
pioneers to clear a passage over the mountain. Castruccio’s outposts soon
checked their progress and were followed by a stronger body then
descending the hill in order of battle; skirmishing began, and voluntary
reinforcements pushed out unordered from the Florentine camp below. It
was entirely an encounter of cavalry; the green slopes of the hills were
covered with armed and plumed knights, the whole scene resembled a
tournament rather than a real battle and the effect is described as
beautiful. Each party was broken four different times and each reuniting
in compact order returned unconquered to the charge; many lances were
shivered, many gentlemen unhorsed, and arms and wounded and
expiring men lay scattered on the mountain side. The Florentines with
only half its numbers for three hours sustained and repulsed the charges
of Castruccio’s chivalry, and might have finally prevailed if they had
been well supported; but Cardona in complete order of battle looked on
inactively, his troops cooped up in a narrow angle of the plain below
whence they could not move without incurring danger. This did not
escape Castruccio who therefore pushed boldly on with augmenting
numbers and, though unhorsed by a German knight, wounded, and some
of his bravest followers slain, by night-fall had succeeded in driving the
enemy back to their entrenchments in face of a much superior army.
Forty men-at-arms were either killed or taken on the side of Florence,
and many wounded, but all in front; for the Florentines did not turn, but
battled proudly and retreated sullenly, more angry with their own
commander than with the enemy; they made no prisoners but must have
smote well in the conflict, for no less than a hundred of their opponents’
horses had galloped to the plain with empty saddles from the field of
battle.
The trumpets of either host answered each other in defiance until after
dark, and neither choosing to own a defeat both remained under arms
long after night set in; but the Florentines lost their spirit from that day’s
fight and no longer trusted either in the faith or talents of their general.
Castruccio, being anxious to keep the Spaniard in his difficult position,
directed the governors of several towns in the Val di Nievole to entangle
him in a fictitious intrigue with the expectation of their surrender, and
Cardona, thus duped, notwithstanding every warning, chose to continue
in this state of vain inactivity.
On hearing of Azzo Visconti’s arrival at Lucca with eight hundred
men-at-arms he took fright and hastily retreated to Altopascio, whilst
Castruccio, apprehensive of his escape, hurried back to the capital to
accelerate the march of the Lombards. Visconti was so unwilling to
proceed without repose or money that it required all the influence of
Castruccio’s wife, seconded by the blandishments of the most beautiful
women in Lucca and the payment of 6000 florins, to gain his promise of
marching on the following morning; Castruccio then departed, leaving to
the women the care of keeping the young Milanese chieftain to his
engagement. On the morning of the 23rd of November the allied army
paraded ostentatiously in front of Castruccio’s position, with flying
colours and sound of many trumpets, daring him as it were to battle, and
the latter fearful of losing such a moment sent out some troops to amuse
them with a prospect of victory while he kept his main body in hand
awaiting the junction of Visconti. This was completed at nine in the
morning, when Castruccio was seen once more descending from the hills
with three-and-twenty hundred men-at-arms in majestic movement
towards the plain, while the greater part of his infantry remained in the
mountain and took no part in the events of this day. An advanced
squadron of 150 French and Italian gentlemen began the fight by a bold
charge directly through Visconti’s line; but the second line or main body
of Feditori, consisting of seven hundred horsemen under Borneo of
Burgundy who had been corrupted by Azzo or Castruccio, turned when it
was time to charge and fled from the encounter. The whole army, whose
confidence was already shaken, were confounded and some others began
to fly; but had Raymond promptly moved forward to the support of his
first line which had charged so effectively, the battle might still have
been maintained on equal terms; instead of which he remained
motionless and added to the general consternation.
Presently the main body of cavalry, scarcely tarrying to exchange a
single lance-thrust, hurried off in universal confusion, leaving everything
to the infantry who still maintained their ground with undaunted courage;
but neither their arms nor discipline was calculated to stand alone against
such masses of man and steel as came successively upon them, and after
an obstinate resistance they also were discomfited. The battle lasted but a
short time, few were killed in the fight but many in the pursuit, for
Castruccio instantly sent on a detachment to
Cappiano, took possession of the bridge
which had already been abandoned, and cut
off all direct means of escape. The slaughter
was therefore considerable but uncertain; the
prisoners, amongst whom were Raymond of
Cardona and his son, were numerous; the
carroccio, the martinella, with all the public
standards, banners, and baggage of the army,
were taken; Cappiano and Montefalcone soon
capitulated, and Altopascio not many days
after. Thus did the tide of fortune turn and
bear forward Castruccio to prouder hopes and
higher dignities. On the 27th of September
his whole army assembled at Pistoia and was
reinforced by that garrison, while Castruccio
in all the confidence of victory dismantled
the bridge and forts of Cappiano and
Montefalcone, and secure in the possession
I S
F C
of Pistoia left the rest of his frontier open to
the Florentines, whose territory he ravaged
for nearly seven weeks without interruption.
Policy and necessity dictated this course, for his funds were exhausted,
Azzo Visconti was still unsatisfied, and the army in arrears of pay; so
that nothing but the plunder of Florentine citizens could supply his
present necessities. Carmignano was his first conquest; he then marched
to Lecore, to Signa, Campi, Brozzi, and Guaracchi; all were captured or
fell a prey to flames and plunder; Peretola, within two miles of Florence,
became for a while his headquarters, while from the Arno to the
mountains he ravaged all the plain, a plain covered, then as now, but
more richly, with magnificent villas and beautiful gardens, the delight of
the citizens and the admiration of the world. All was destroyed. The
wealth was plundered, the monuments of then reviving art were carried
away and reserved for the conqueror’s triumph. Games were celebrated
and races run on the very spot time out of mind reserved by the
Florentines for their public spectacles. A course of horsemen began the
sports; that of footmen followed; and afterwards, to make the insult still
more disgusting, a bevy of common prostitutes ran together in mockery,
deriding the impotence of the Florentines, not one of whom had the
courage to come forth and check these insulting spectacles. Yet the city