You are on page 1of 5

BJUI BJU INTERNATIONAL

Redefining abnormal follicle-stimulating


hormone in the male infertility population
Jennifer Gordetsky, Edwin van Wijngaarden* and Jeanne O’Brien†
Department of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine, *Department of Community and Preventive Medicine, Division
of Epidemiology, and †Department of Urology, University of Rochester Medical Center, Rochester, NY, USA
Accepted for publication 17 August 2011

Study Type – Diagnostic (validating What’s known on the subject? and What does the study add?
cohort) FSH is a hormone released by the anterior pituitary gland via stimulation from
Level of Evidence 2a gonadotrophin-releasing hormone and potentially other factors. FSH reflects the status
of spermatogenesis (i.e. the ability to produce sperm) as a result of the feedback
OBJECTIVE between the testis and hypothalamus/pituitary glands. An elevated FSH level is
indicative of abnormal spermatogenesis and may indicate primary testicular failure.
• To examine the correlation between The range for ‘normal’ FSH varies somewhat between institutions but has been defined
follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH) and by the Strong Memorial Hospital (Rochester, NY, USA) clinical laboratory as 1.4–
testosterone/FSH levels with semen analysis 18.1 IU/L based on the ADVIA Centaur (Siemens Medical Solutions, Tarrytown, NY, USA)
parameters to evaluate whether the range FSH assay.
for judging normal FSH levels should be The findings obtained in the present study could be helpful for predicting male factor
reconsidered. infertility in patients with a borderline high FSH level (≈4.5 IU/L) and a low
testosterone level compared to someone with a borderline high FSH level and a normal
PATIENTS AND METHODS testosterone level. Although the ‘normal’ range for FSH is qualified as a value in the
range 1.4–18.1 IU/L, the present study shows that an FSH level >4.5 IU/L was
• The present study included 610 male associated with abnormal semen analysis in terms of morphology and sperm
infertility patients from a single urology concentration in the present patient population. Therefore, these findings suggest that
infertility clinic between 2004 and 2008. FSH values lower than those currently considered normal may be associated with
• Patients (n = 153) were excluded for abnormal semen analysis, and that the ‘normal’ range for FSH used in clinical settings
obstructive azoospermia, may need to be reconsidered.
hypogonadotrophic hypogonadism, steroid
use or failure to complete testing.
• Abnormal semen analysis values were of a dose response, with abnormal sperm CONCLUSION
based on the WHO 1999 criteria. concentration and morphology but not
• We performed t-tests, ANOVA, chi-squared with semen volume. • A significantly increased risk of abnormal
tests and logistic regression to statistically • In men with FSH levels >7.5 IU/L, semen analyses among men with FSH levels
examine the association between the FSH the risk of abnormal semen quality >4.5 IU/L and decreasing testosterone/FSH
(or testosterone/FSH ratio) level and semen was five- to thirteen-fold higher than ratios suggests that redefining normal FSH
parameters. that of men with FSH levels <2.8 IU/L in infertile men would be valuable.
depending on the specific semen
RESULTS parameter. KEYWORDS
• Similarly, semen parameters were had a
• The FSH level showed statistically greater probability of being abnormal with follicle-stimulating hormone, human, male
significant associations, as well as evidence decreasing testosterone/FSH ratios. infertility

INTRODUCTION the status of spermatogenesis as a result of evaluation for infertility [2]. The minimum
the feedback between the testis and initial hormonal evaluation should consist of
Follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH) is a hypothalamus/pituitary glands [1]. Despite measurements of serum FSH and serum
hormone released by the anterior pituitary the diurnal variations of FSH, single serum testosterone levels. A higher FSH level is
gland via stimulation from gonadotrophin- measurements are fairly representative of indicative of abnormal spermatogenesis and
releasing hormone and potentially other the estimated FSH in an individual. The may indicate primary testicular failure [2].
factors. It is released in a pulsatile fashion recently revised AUA Best Practice The range for ‘normal’ FSH varies somewhat
and is regulated in part by glycoproteins, Statement recommends that an endocrine between institutions, although it has been
including activin and inhibin. FSH reflects evaluation be performed as a part of a full defined by our institution’s clinical

© 2 0 11 T H E A U T H O R S
568 BJU INTERNATIONAL © 2 0 11 B J U I N T E R N A T I O N A L | 11 0 , 5 6 8 – 5 7 2 | doi:10.1111/j.1464-410X.2011.10783.x
REDEFINING ABNORMAL FSH

laboratory as 1.4–18.1 IU/L based on the included caffeine, tobacco, drug and steroid STATISTICAL ANALYSIS
ADVIA Centaur (Siemens Medical Solutions, use.
Tarrytown, NY, USA) FSH assay [3]. This large Initially, a descriptive univariate analysis was
range is not clinically useful because almost performed to describe the present study
all patients would be considered to have SEMEN ANALYSIS population of 457 participants in terms
normal levels. of age, semen parameters, FSH and
Semen samples were collected by testosterone. Indices of central tendency
Given this paradigm, the usefulness of masturbation into sterile plastic specimen included means and medians for continuous
elevated FSH levels as a marker of testicular cups and a routine semen analysis was measures, and proportions for nominal and
function is questionable given the assay’s completed within 1 h of submission, which ordinal variables. In addition, the standard
wide range for ‘normal’ FSH. The use of included volume, sperm concentration, deviation for continuous variables is
hormone levels as a potential predictor of motility, progressive velocity and sperm reported as a measure of variability in the
semen quality has been previously morphology. Semen samples were analyzed data.
evaluated. Specifically, previous studies in using computer-aided semen analysis
the infertility literature have investigated (HTM-IVOS, Hamilton-Thorn Research, Subsequently, bivariate analyses were
the correlation between semen quality and Beverly, MA, USA) with sperm concentration conducted with chi-squared statistics to
FSH [4–8]. Invariably, a significant negative and motility factors defined by the compare the proportion of patients with
correlation has been described between FSH Hamilton-Thorn Company and reference abnormal semen quality among patients at
and sperm concentration and morphology ranges defined by the WHO. different levels of FSH and testosterone/FSH
[4–8]. Some of these studies have suggested ratio. Subsequent logistic regression,
that an FSH level >10 IU/L could serve as a Morphology was analyzed using two slides adjusting for age, computed odds ratios
predictor of abnormal sperm concentration made from the each fresh semen sample, and 95% CI for the association between
[4,5]. which was allowed to air dry before staining categorical hormone levels (i.e. FSH level
with a Diff- Quick staining kit (Dad Behring <2.8, 2.8 to <4.5, 4.5 to <7.5 and 7.5+ IU/L;
The present study further investigated the AG, Dudingen, Switzerland). A minimum of testosterone/FSH ratio <46.2, 46.2 to <86.3,
‘normal’ range of FSH and its use as a 200 sperm cells were counted from the two 86.3 to <129.6, 129.6+) and dichotomous
marker with a clinically useful range to slides for each specimen and WHO 4th semen parameters. Hormone level categories
predict male fertility potential. Accordingly, edition was used to define normal and were based on quartiles of the distribution
we attempted to define a more clinically abnormal morphology. in the overall population. Semen parameters
useful range for FSH as a predictor of male were dichotomized according to established
infertility. thresholds (reference) with abnormal values
REPRODUCTIVE HORMONE ANALYSIS being defined as <50% for motility, <20
millions/mL for sperm concentration, <2 mL
PATIENTS AND METHODS A non-fasting blood sample was drawn on for volume and <20% for morphology.
patients within 30 days of a collected semen
STUDY POPULATION sample, with abstinence of 2–3 days before Finally, using logistic regression with
the semen sample. Testosterone was continuous hormone level variables,
A retrospective chart review of 610 men was measured using the ADVIA Centaur receiver-operating characteristic (ROC)
completed. These individuals visited a single Testosterone assay (ADVIA Centaur and curves were created to derive optimal
urologist’s practice during 2004–2008. Men ADVIA Centaur XP Systems; Siemens Medical thresholds for hormone levels that best
included in the present study were initially Solutions), which has inter-assay and predicted abnormal semen quality. An ROC
evaluated in an infertility clinic; however, intra-assay coefficients of variation of less curve plots the discriminatory ability of the
male infertility had not necessarily been than 7% and less than 8%, respectively, test (or range of threshold values) to
defined as the causative factor for the with a sensitivity of 10 nmol/L [9]. The correctly diagnose disease (or event) against
couple’s inability to conceive. Therefore, this testosterone assay was standardized using the probability of a false positive result. The
population included men with normal and international standards manufactured curve is represented by a line graph where
subfertility, as well as infertility. Exclusionary analytically, traceable to gas the best possible threshold is in the upper
criteria included incomplete evaluation chromatography–mass spectroscopy. The left corner of the graph when sensitivity is
(including failure to complete a semen serum FSH concentrations were determined on the y-axis and 1 – specificity is on the
analysis) or concurrent use of exogenous by the ADVIA Centaur FSH assay (ADVIA x-axis. Accordingly, FSH and testosterone/
hormones at the time of evaluation. Patients Centaur and ADVIA Centaur XP Systems) [3]. FSH thresholds were selected that
determined to have obstructive azoospermia The inter-assay and intra-assay coefficients maximized the sensitivity and specificity to
or hypogonadotrophic hypogonadism were of variation of FSH were less than 3% and accurate classify ‘events’ (i.e. abnormal
also excluded. In total 457 patients were less than 4%, respectively, with a sensitivity semen quality).
considered eligible and all were included in of 0.3 IU/L [3]. The FSH assay was standardized
the evaluation. Semen and blood samples based on the WHO 2nd International Tobacco use did not impact any of our
were collected. All subjects had complete Standard for human FSH (IS 94/632). The sperm quality measures; therefore, this
histories and physical examinations and testosterone/FSH ratio was calculated by variable was not controlled for in the
lifestyle and habits were reviewed. History dividing testosterone (nmol/L) by FSH (IU/L). logistic regression analysis.

© 2 0 11 T H E A U T H O R S
BJU INTERNATIONAL © 2 0 11 B J U I N T E R N A T I O N A L 569
GORDETSKY ET AL.

All tests of significance were two-sided.


Characteristic Value TABLE 1
Analyses were conducting using SAS, version
Tobacco use, n (%) 69 (15) Descriptive characteristics
9.1 (SAS Institute, Cary, NC, USA).
Age, mean (SD) 35 (6) of male infertility patients
Motility (%), mean (SD) 33 (20.5)
Morphology (%), mean (SD) 14 (10.8)
RESULTS
Volume (mL), mean (SD) 3 (2.4)
Sperm concentration (millions/mL), mean (SD) 41 (52.3)
Of the 610 patients reviewed in the present
FSH (IU/L), mean (SD) 6.6 (6.7)
study, 153 were excluded for incomplete
testing or taking hormone medications. Of Testosterone/FSH, mean (SD) 105 (93.6)
the remaining patients, 457 men provided Normal volume, n (%) 412 (77)
both semen samples and serum for FSH Abnormal volume, n (%) 126 (23)
level measurements. There were 447 men Normal motility, n (%) 120 (22)
who provided semen samples and serum for Abnormal motility, n (%) 418 (78)
both FSH and testosterone level Normal morphology, n (%) 436 (81)
measurements. Abnormal morphology, n (%) 102 (19)
Azoospermia, n (%) 63 (12)
Table 1 shows descriptive data for age, Oligospermia, n (%) 192 (36) FSH, follicle-stimulating
tobacco use, semen parameters and Normal sperm concentration, n (%) 283 (53) hormone.
hormone levels. Analysis of the total men in
our database showed a mean (SD) age of 35
(6) years. There were 69 (15%) patients who
reported tobacco use. The mean (SD) FSH
TABLE 2 Association between follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH) and abnormal morphology
and log FSH were 6.6 (6.7) IU/L and 1.55
(0.78) IU/L, respectively. The mean (SD)
FSH Normal morphology, Abnormal morphology, Odds ratio
volume, motility, morphology and sperm
(IU/L) n (%) n (%) (95% CI)
concentration were 3 (2.4) mL, 33% (20%),
<2.8 95 (26) 15 (16) 1.0 (reference)
14% (11%), and 41 millions/mL (SD 52),
2.8–4.5 111 (30) 8 (9) 0.46 (0.19–1.14)
respectively. The mean (SD) testosterone/FSH
4.5–7.5 97 (27) 19 (21) 1.26 (0.61–2.64)
and log testosterone/FSH were 105 (94) and
>7.5 63 (17) 49 (54) 5.02 (2.59–9.74)
4.32 (0.88), respectively. In total, 23% of
Total 366 91
patients had abnormal semen volume; 78%
of patients had abnormal motility; 12% of
patients were azoospermic; 36% of patients
were oligospermic; and 19% of patients had
abnormal morphology. TABLE 3 Association between follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH), azoospermia and oligospermia

In total, 80% of azoospermic patients and FSH Normal, Azoospermia, Oligospermia,


66% of oligospermic patients had an FSH (IU/L) n (%) n (%) n (%) Total
level >4.5 IU/L (P < 0.001) and 75% of <2.8 81 (35) 6 (11) 23 (13) 110
patients with an abnormal morphology had 2.8–4.5 77 (34) 5 (9) 37 (21) 119
an FSH level >4.5 IU/L (P < 0.001). 4.5–7.5 51 (22) 10 (19) 55 (32) 116
>7.5 20 (9) 33 (61) 59 (34) 112
Results for logistic regression are shown in Total 229 54 174 457
Tables 2–4. When comparing FSH in terms
of abnormal sperm concentration vs normal
sperm concentration, 40% of patients with
an abnormal sperm concentration had an
FSH level >7.5 IU/L compared to only 9% of TABLE 4 Association between follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH) and abnormal sperm concentration
patients with a normal sperm concentration.
If FSH was >7.5 IU/L, the risk of abnormal Normal sperm Abnormal sperm
sperm concentration was 13-fold higher FSH concentration, concentration, Odds ratio (95%
(95% CI, 6.9–25.3), and the risk of abnormal (IU/L) n (%) n (%) CI)
morphology was fivefold higher (95% CI, <2.8 81 (35) 29 (13) 1.0 (reference)
2.6–9.7) compared to a male with an FSH 2.8–4.5 77 (34) 42 (18) 1.55 (0.88–2.74)
level <2.8 IU/L. FSH levels did not correlate 4.5–7.5 51 (22) 65 (29) 3.66 (2.08–6.44)
with semen volume. When looking at the >7.5 20 (9) 92 (40) 13.23 (6.93–25.27)
testosterone/FSH ratio, a similar dose Total 229 228
response trend was found: the lower the

© 2 0 11 T H E A U T H O R S
570 BJU INTERNATIONAL © 2 0 11 B J U I N T E R N A T I O N A L
REDEFINING ABNORMAL FSH

FIG. 1. Receiver-operating characteristic curve: DISCUSSION on the reproductive health of men in


morphology and follicle-stimulating hormone the general population but indicated
(FSH). Assessment of semen parameters and an FSH level >10 IU/L to be predictive
reproductive hormone levels remains a of male factor infertility and thereby
Analysis III − logistic regression morphology, FSH routine and integral component of ‘abnormal’ [5].
Sensitivity evaluating a patient for infertility. Together,
1.0 they are useful for evaluating testicular Meeker et al. [6] evaluated the relationship
0.9
0.8 function and the hypothalmic–pituitary– between serum hormone levels and semen
0.7 gonadal axis. Testosterone and follicle quality among 388 men from an infertility
0.6 stimulating hormone are necessary for clinic. They reported FSH to be inversely
0.5
0.4 signaling Sertoli cells to produce factors associated with sperm concentration,
0.3 required for maturation of germ cells into morphology and motility. Compared to men
0.2 spermatozoa [10]. FSH reflects the status of in the lowest FSH tertile, men in the highest
0.1
0.0 spermatogenesis as a result of the feedback tertile had an almost fivefold greater
between the testis and hypothalamus/ probability of having oligospermia (odds
0.0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1.0

1 - Specificity
pituitary glands [1]. Reproductive hormone ratio, 4.6; 95% CI, 1.9–11.2) and a twofold
levels, being easily obtainable, are often the greater probability of having an abnormal
starting point in the evaluation process and morphology (odds ratio, 2.3; 95% CI,
are ordered by primary care physicians 1.2–4.4). An FSH level >10 IU/L was
FIG. 2. Receiver-operating characteristic curve: before referral to specialists for infertility. predictive of oligospermia with a sensitivity
sperm concentration and follicle-stimulating For these results to be interpreted of 0.55 [6].
hormone (FSH). appropriately, the range that is defined as
‘normal’ needs to be considered. In our Morrow et al. [7] performed a retrospective
Analysis III − logistic regression spermconc1, FSH hospital’s laboratory, the normal reference chart review on 1745 male infertility
Sensitivity range of FSH is defined by the ADVIA patients from a single clinic. They reported
1.0 Centaur assay as 1.4–18.1 for males [3]. This on semen characteristics and hormone levels
0.9 range was based on a central 95% interval on 1479 men with different ranges of FSH.
0.8
0.7 of a sampling of 117 ‘apparently healthy’ Their results showed a mean sperm
0.6 men aged 13–70 years [3]. This reference concentration of 22 millions/mL for an FSH
0.5
0.4 range was based on a small selection of level in the range 6–9 IU/L, and a mean
0.3 men, with a large age range, without any sperm concentration of less than 1 millions/
0.2
0.1 information regarding patient fertility. Upon mL for an FSH level >9 IU/L. It was
0.0 contacting three other hospitals in the city concluded that there was an inverse
0.0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1.0

of Rochester (NY, USA), similar laboratory relationship between increasing FSH


1 - Specificity reference ranges were discovered for FSH and decreasing sperm concentration.
assays. On a subgroup analysis of 342 patients
who had undergone testicular biopsy,
Previous studies have looked at the normal biopsy (n = 33) and mild
testosterone/FSH ratio, the greater the risk relationship between semen parameters and hypospermatogenesis (n = 58) was
of abnormal semen parameters. Most hormonal levels. Jensen et al. [4] looked associated with a mean FSH level of 3.1 and
patients with an abnormal morphology at the correlation between sperm 3.5 IU/L, respectively [7].
(65%) and sperm concentration (64%) had a concentration and FSH in a study of 349
testosterone/FSH <86; 79% of azoospermic Danish men. Men with unknown fertility, Schoor et al. [11] performed a retrospective
patients had a testosterone/FSH ratio <86. between the ages of 20–35 years, were analysis of 153 azoospermic men, 54 of
For a testosterone/FSH ratio <46, there was enrolled at two separate centres. Their study whom had non-obstructive azoospermia. It
a fivefold increased risk for abnormal found a median FSH level of 3.42 and was found that, in men with obstructive
morphology and a sevenfold increased risk 3.21 IU/L, respectively. They reported a azoospermia, 96% had an FSH level
for abnormal sperm concentration compared predictive power of 85.7% for predicting ≤7.6 IU/L. However, 89% of men with
to the highest quartile (>129). oligospermia (<20 millions/mL) with an non-obstructive azoospermia had an FSH
FSH level >10 IU/L [4]. Uhler et al. [5] level >7.6 IU/L. It was concluded that men
ROC curves (Figs 1,2) show FSH to have a similarly examined the relationship with an FSH level of ≥7.6 IU/L may be
‘fair’ discriminatory ability for morphology between semen analysis measures and considered to have non-obstructive
(71.7%) and concentration (75.2%). fertility in 145 male partners of presumed azoospermia. However, their study included
Calculating the FSH threshold for predicting normal couples. Although the men in a relatively small number of non-obstructive
abnormal semen parameters by maximizing their study had unproven fertility, 82% azoospermic patients and did not address
a combination of sensitivity and specificity of the couples achieved pregnancy within patients with oligospermia [11].
showed an FSH level of 4.3 IU/L for sperm 12 months. In their study, 17 out of the
concentration and an FSH level of 4.9 IU/L 22 men with oligospermia had an FSH Consistent with previous studies, the present
for morphology. level >10 IU/L. Their studies were focused study found a correlation between

© 2 0 11 T H E A U T H O R S
BJU INTERNATIONAL © 2 0 11 B J U I N T E R N A T I O N A L 5 71
GORDETSKY ET AL.

increasing FSH levels and abnormal semen >4.5 IU/L in the male should be considered Clegg ED. Relationship between sperm
parameters. Although many stusies have as an abnormal value when evaluating characteristics and hormonal parameters
investigated the relationship between semen patients with possible male infertility. in normal couples. Fertil Steril 2003; 79:
parameters and hormone levels, to our 135–542
knowledge, the present study is the first to 6 Meeker JD, Godfrey-Bailey L, Hauser
attempt to redefine the ‘normal’ reference ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS R. Relationships between serum
range of FSH. In the present study, an FSH hormone levels and semen quality
level >4.5 IU/L showed statistically The present study was presented at the among men from an infertility clinic.
significant associations with abnormal American Urological Association Annual J Androl 2007; 28: 397–406
sperm concentration and morphology Meeting, Chicago, 2009. No financial 7 Morrow AF, Baker HWG, Burger HG.
(P < 0.001). This places the ‘normal’ support was received. Different testosterone and LH
reference range of FSH lower than in relationships in infertile men. J Androl
previous studies. In addition, semen 1986; 7: 310–5
parameters had a greater probability of CONFLICT OF INTEREST 8 Sina D, Schuhmann R, Abraham R,
being abnormal with decreasing Taubert HD, Dericks-Tan JSE. Increased
testosterone/FSH ratios. This could be None declared. serum FSH levels correlated with low
helpful in patients with a borderline high and high sperm counts in male infertile
FSH level (≈4.5 IU/L) and a low testosterone patients. Andrologia 1975; 7: 31–7
level compared to someone with borderline REFERENCES 9 ADVIA Centaur Assay Manual:
a high FSH level and a normal testosterone Testosterone. Tarrytown: Siemens
level. 1 Nieschlag E, Simoni M, Gromoll J, Healthcare Diagnostics Inc., 2008
Weinbauer GF. Role of FSH in the 10 Walker WH, Cheng J. FSH and
The limitations of the present study include regulation of spermatogenesis: clinical testosterone signalling in Sertoli calls.
it comprising a retrospective review with no aspects. Clin Endocrinol 1999; 51: Reproduction 2005; 130: 15–28
fertile control group to compare FSH and 139–46 11 Schoor RA, Elhanbly S, Niederberger
semen analysis values. In addition, semen 2 Jarow J, Sigman M, Kolettis PN et al. CS, Ross LS. The role of testicular
analysis and blood draws were not obtained AUA – Clinical guidelines: the optimal biopsy in the modern management of
on the same day. In addition, the present evaluation of the infertile male: best male infertility. J Urol 2002; 167:
study did not control for potentially practice statement. AUA – Home. 197–200
important covariates other than age. American Urological Association
Despite being retrospective, the present Education and Research, Inc., 2010. World Health Organization. WHO
study reviews a large population of Available at: http://www.auanet.org/ laboratory manual for the examination
male infertility patients, all of whom content/guidelines-and-quality-care/ of human semen and sperm-oervical
were from a single urologist’s practice. clinical-guidelines.cfm. Accessed August mucus interaction, 4th edition.
All semen analyses were completed through 2010 Cambridge: Cambridge University Press;
the same andrology laboratory and all 3 ADVIA Centaur Assay Manual: FSH. 1999
blood samples were analyzed using the Tarrytown: Siemens Healthcare
same assay. Diagnostics Inc., 2008 Correspondence: Jennifer Gordetsky, 601
4 Jensen TK, Andersson A-M, Hjollund Elmwood Avenue, Box 626, Rochester, NY
Although the ‘normal’ range for FSH is NH et al. Inhibin B as a serum marker 14642-8656, USA.
qualified as a value in the range 1.4– of spermatogenesis: correlation to e-mail: jennifer_gordetsky@urmc.rochester.
18.1 IU/L, the present study has shown that differences in sperm concentration and edu
an FSH level >4.5 IU/L is predictive of an follicle-stimulating hormone levels. A
abnormal semen analysis in terms of study of 349 Danish men. J Clin Abbreviations: FSH, follicle-stimulating
morphology and sperm concentration. Endocrinol Metabol 1997; 82: 4059–63 hormone; ROC, receiver-operating
Therefore, we suggest that an FSH level 5 Uhler ML, Zinaman MJ, Brown CC, characteristic.

© 2 0 11 T H E A U T H O R S
572 BJU INTERNATIONAL © 2 0 11 B J U I N T E R N A T I O N A L

You might also like