Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Part 2. The influence of pretreatment and cooking conditions on the pulp properties,
bleachability in a TCF-sequence and strength properties
Keywords: Modified kraft pulping, Pretreatment, Delignifica- cation rate in the bulk phase of the kraft pulping (LeMòn,
tion, Bleachability, Strength properties Teder 1973; Holm, Warnquist 1994; Lindgren, Lindström
1996). A high ionic strength in the cooking liquor increa-
SUMMARY: This paper describes the influence of the conditions ses the rate of alkaline hydrolysis of carbohydrates and
in the pretreatment (hydroxide ion concentration and temperatu- thus reduces the pulp viscosity (Lindgren 1997;
re) and in the cooking stage (hydroxide ion concentration and
hydrosulfide ion concentration) and possible interaction effects Andersson, Olm 1998). In the above mentioned kinetics
on the delignification and carbohydrate degradation in softwood equations, however, no consideration has been given to
kraft pulping with sulfide pretreatment. In addition the bleachabi- changes in the ionic strength of the cooking liquor.
lity in an OZQP*-sequence and the strength properties of the
unbleached pulp with different hydroxide ion concentrations in The selectivity of kraft pulping is also influenced by the
the pretreatment and cooking stages have been evaluated. The presence of dissolved wood substances in the cooking
cooking experiments were conducted at liquor-to-wood ratio 4:1. liquor (Sjöblom et al. 1983, 1988; Sjöblom 1996; Anders-
The delignification during kraft pulping with sulfide pretreat-
ment within the investigated experimental domain is affected son, Olm 1998). Sjöblom (1988) found that reducing the
mainly by the hydroxide ion concentrations in the pretreatment concentration of dissolved lignin and the ionic strength in
and in the cooking stage and by an interaction effect between the cooking liquor during the final part of kraft pulping
these factors. The cooking time required to reach a certain kappa
number can be considerably reduced by increasing the hydroxide improved the pulping selectivity, defined as viscosity at a
ion concentration in the pretreatment with a low hydroxide ion given kappa number. The improved selectivity was attribu-
concentration in the cooking stage. The hydrosulfide ion concen- ted to the higher delignification rate with a lower amount
tration in the cooking stage had a minor effect on the delignifica-
tion within the investigated experimental domain. The results of dissolved wood substances in the cooking liquor
indicate that in industrial displacement kraft pulping it would be (Sjöblom 1996). Recently it has been reported that the
advantageous to increase the hydroxide ion concentration in the organic substances (analysed as UV-lignin) in black liquor
hot black liquor displacement and to decrease the hydroxide ion
concentration in the white liquor in order to produce a pulp with mainly have a negative influence on the brightness of
high yield, good bleachability and high unbleached pulp strength. unbleached pulp (Andersson, Olm 1998). A slower delig-
The results of the experiments reported in this paper indicate nification when black liquor was added to the cooking
the importance of terminating the cook in the bulk delignification
phase. A long cooking time at a relatively low hydroxide ion con- liquor was found to be an effect of higher ionic strength.
centration (residual alkali 0.15 mol/L), as when the cook is termi- Earlier kinetic studies (Edwards et al. 1974) have indi-
nated in the residual phase, leads not only to poorer brightness of cated a two-factor interaction effect between hydroxide ion
unbleached pulp and bleachability but also to a loss of strength
properties. The fact that the displacement kraft cooks are finished and hydrosulfide ion concentrations on the delignification
in the bulk delignification phase may be the major advantage and rate in the bulk delignification phase of the kraft pulping.
may explain the high strength potential and good bleachability of Recently interaction effects between hydroxide ion, hydro-
the pulps obtained in industrial displacement kraft pulping.
sulfide ion and sodium ion concentration on the amount of
ADDRESS OF THE AUTHORS: STFI, Box 5604, SE-114 86 residual lignin have been reported (Gustavsson et al.
Stockholm, Sweden 1997). It was found that the influence of hydrosulfide ion
concentration on the amount of residual lignin was more
In modified kraft pulping, the concentration profiles of pronounced at low than at high hydroxide ion concentra-
the active pulping chemicals and the temperature are chan- tion in the cooking liquor, indicating an interaction effect.
ged in order to improve the pulping selectivity, viscosity at The results also showed that the negative effect of sodium
a given kappa number, and to allow extended delignifica- ion concentration on the amount of residual lignin decrea-
tion without any loss in pulp quality (Hartler 1978, sed with increasing hydroxide ion and increasing hydro-
Nordén, Teder 1979; Johansson et al. 1984). The changes sulfide ion concentrations in the cooking liquor. Modern
in concentration profiles have been proposed from the dif- kraft pulping processes are complicated with several addi-
ferential equations describing the rate of delignification tions and withdrawals of white and black liquors. The pos-
(LeMón, Teder 1973, Olm, Tistad 1979; Axegård, Wikén sible interaction effects may have a great influence on pul-
1983) in different delignification phases and carbohydrate ping results.
degradation by alkaline hydrolysis during a kraft cook This paper deals with displacement kraft pulping of the
(Kubes et al. 1983). The rate equations of delignification SuperBatch and RDH (Rapid Displacement Heating) types
are based upon kinetic studies with a constant cooking simulated in the laboratory as kraft pulping with sulfide
liquor composition with a high liquor-to-wood ratio. A pretreatment. The influences of the conditions in the pre-
variation in the hydroxide ion and hydrosulfide ion con- treatment (hydroxide ion concentration and temperature)
centrations also influences the ionic strength of the coo- and in the cooking stage (hydroxide ion concentration and
king liquor. The ionic strength is usually defined as a sum hydrosulfide ion concentration) on the delignification and
of [Na+] and [K+] in the cooking liquor. A high ionic carbohydrate degradation were investigated. The cooking
strength has a substantial negative effect on the delignifi- experiments were conducted at a liquor-to-wood ratio of
4:1 and with a constant sodium ion profile. Since the pre- Experimental Design 1
treatments were conducted with inorganic aqueous sulfide A statistical experimental design, 24-1, was used to evalua-
solution, a small amount of sodium carbonate was added te the influence of hydroxide ion concentration and tempe-
to the pretreatment liquor to simulate the buffer capacity of rature in the pretreatment and of hydroxide ion and hydro-
black liquor. The objective was to clarify the possible sulfide ion concentrations in the cooking stage on the
interaction effects of the process parameters studied on the delignification and carbohydrate degradation. The sodium
delignification and carbohydrate degradation. A statistical ion concentration was controlled by the addition of analy-
experimental design was employd to reach this goal. tical grade Na-acetate. The conditions in the pretreatment
Another aim was to study the effect of the hydroxide ion and cooking stage are given in Table 1.
concentrations in the pretreatment and in the cooking stage
on the bleachability of the produced pulps in an OZQP*- Experimental Design 2
sequence and on the strength properties of the unbleached A statistical experimental design, 24-2, was used to evalua-
pulp. An attempt has been made to propose profiles of te the pulping selectivity, bleachability and strength pro-
active cooking chemicals and temperature in order further perties for various hydroxide ion concentrations in the pre-
to improve of the selectivity of the modern softwood kraft treatment and cooking stages. The sodium ion concentra-
pulping and to produce softwood pulps with good bleacha- tion was controlled by the addition of analytical grade
bility and high strength properties. NaCl. The cooking time was varied to obtain a kappa
number of 20. The conditions in the pretreatment and coo-
king stage are given in Table 2.
Experimental
Wood TCF-bleaching
Industrial fresh pinewood chips (Pinus silvestris) were The pulps were bleached in an OZQP*-sequence, where
used. The chips were screened on a disk screen and the P* means a P-stage with MgSO4-addition. Oxygen blea-
2–6 mm fraction was used in cooking experiments. Bark ching was carried out in steel autoclaves. Ozone treatment
and knots were removed by hand sorting. The lignin con- was performed in a rotating glass reactor. Peroxide blea-
tent on wood was 27.8%. ching and complexing agent stages were carried out in sea-
led polyethylene bags in thermostated water baths.
Cooking Deionized water was used in all bleaching experiments.
The cooking experiments were carried out as two stage Bleaching conditions are given in Table 3.
cooks: a pretreatment and a cooking stage. Three hundred
grams of wood (o.d.) were charged in autoclaves and the Analyses
pretreatment liquor was added. The liquor-to-wood ratio The hydroxide ion concentration was determined accor-
was 4:1. The autoclaves were placed in a glycol bath for ding to SCAN-N 33:94 and the hydrosulfide ion concen-
10 minutes at 100°C and heated at a rate of 2°C/min to the tration according to SCAN-N 31:94. Wood/pulp properties
pretreatment temperature. The pretreatment time was 60 were determined as follows: wood dry content SCAN-CM
minutes at 130°C or 55 minutes at 150°C. After it had 39:88, pulp dry content SCAN-C 3:78, kappa number
been cooled, a part of the pretreatment liquor was removed SCAN-C 1:77, viscosity SCAN-CM 15:88 and ISO-
until a liquor-to-wood ratio of 2:1 was reached and repla- brightness SCAN-C 11:75. The lignin content in the wood
20
50
18
16
40
14
30 12
10
20 0,8
0,8 8
0,6 0,6
1,0 1,0
1,2 1,2
1,4 0,4
1,4
1,6
0,4
[OH¯ ]PRE, mol/L 1,6
[OH¯ ]PRE, mol/L
1,8 1,8
0,2 2,0 0,2
2,0
[OH¯ ]COOK, mol/L [OH¯ ]COOK, mol/L
Fig. 1. Kappa number at 70 minutes and 180 minutes for different hydroxide ion concentrations in the pretreatment and cooking stages.
43 800
42 700
600 0,8
41 0,8
0,6
0,6 1,0
1,0 1,2
1,2 1,4 0,4
1,4 0,4
[OH¯ ]PRE, mol/L 1,6 [OH¯ ]PRE, mol/L
1,6 1,8
1,8 2,0 0,2
2,0 0,2
cosity were affected by the hydroxide ion concentration in tration was studied. The kappa number of the studied pulps
the pretreatment and cooking stages. Results indicated a was 18–21. The main cooking conditions and the results
more pronounced loss of pulp yield at cooking times of are presented in Table 4.
180 minutes than at 70 minutes. Obviously, the carbohy- In spite of the fact that the hydroxide ion concentration
drates are more labile towards high hydroxide ion concen- in the beginning of the cooking stage was corrected for the
tration during the latter part of the cook. This effect has carry-over of alkali from the pretreatment to the cooking
also been noticed in previous studies by Aurell and Hartler stage, the residual alkali at the end of the cook varied
(1965) and by Sjöblom et al. (1983) and it has been explai- widely (compare cook LL with cook HL and cook LH
ned by the greater accessibility of the carbohydrates due to with cook HH in Table 4). The residual alkali was about
the higher degree of delignification. The decrease in pulp 0.2–0.3 mol/L higher at a high (0.5 mol/L) hydroxide ion
viscosity was of the same magnitude at cooking times of concentration than at a low (0.1 mol/L) hydroxide ion con-
70 and 180 minutes. In the studied experimental domain, centration in the pretreatment liquor. With a high hydroxi-
the carbohydrate yield and pulp viscosity were indepen- de ion concentration in the pretreatment liquor, the wood
dent of the pretreatment temperature. As expected, the substances are dissolved and neutralised to the greater
hydrosulfide ion concentration had no significant effect on extent during the pretreatment than at a low hydroxide ion
either the carbohydrate yield or the pulp viscosity. concentration. The consumption of alkali in the cooking
stage is reduced and this leads to a higher residual alkali in
II: Alkali profiling in kraft pulping with sulfide pretreatment the black liquor.
On the basis of the results described in the first part, five
pulps were produced with different hydroxide ion concen- Cooking selectivity
trations in pretreatment and cooking liquor (see Experi- The pulping selectivity was determined as pulp viscosity
mental, Design 2) since these process variables had been and pulp yield at a given kappa number and is presented in
found to be of primary importance in a kraft cook with sul- Fig. 4 as a function of residual alkali at the end of the coo-
fide pretreatment. The ionic strength ([Na+]) was kept con- king stage. A linear relationship was obtained between
stant in the pretreatment and in the cooking stage in all the pulp viscosity and residual alkali in the black liquor in
cooks, so that only the influence of hydroxide ion concen- accordance with Kubes et al. (1983). The highest pulp vis-
Table 4. Cooking conditions and pulp properties. The pulp viscosity and pulp yield are corrected to the kappa number (K) 20. It
was assumed that the viscosity change per kappa number was 20 mL/g (according to experience at STFI) and yield change
0.15% on wood (Bergnor et al. 1988).
cosity at kappa number 20 was attained, as expected, at the When a comparison is made at approximately the same
lowest residual alkali, i.e. with a low hydroxide ion con- total hydroxide ion concentration (the sum of [OH¯] in
centration in the pretreatment (0.1 mol/L) and cooking pretreatment and cooking stage), the HL cook (total
stage (1.0 mol/L), LL cook. [OH¯]=1.5 mol/L) gives about 1 %-unit higher pulp yield
The hydroxide ion concentration profile in LL cook, at kappa number 20 than the MM cook (total [OH¯]=1.6
which gave the highest pulp viscosity, resulted in the same mol/L), with a medium hydroxide ion level in the pretreat-
pulp yield as the HL cook, with a high hydroxide ion con- ment and cooking stages. The loss of pulp yield was cau-
centration in pretreatment and low in cooking stage, Fig. 4 sed mainly by a decrease in the xylan yield, Table 5. At
and Table 4. With a low hydroxide ion concentration in the high hydroxide ion concentration, the xylan degradation is
pretreatment and cooking stages (0.1 and 1.0 mol/L more extensive and xylan sorption is retarded (Simonson
respectively) the cooking time needed to reach a kappa 1963). The results thus suggest that in order to improve the
number of 20 was almost doubled, 194 and 104 minutes, pulp yield in industrial displacement kraft pulping the
respectively. The prolonged cooking time between hydrox- hydroxide ion concentration in the displacements with
ide ions and carbohydrates presumably counteracts the black liquor may be increased and the white liquor charge
positive effect of a reduced hydroxide ion concentration in in the cooking stage reduced.
the cooking liquor. The same tendency can be observed in In the kraft process, the methylglucuronic acids groups
the experimental data of Gustavsson et al. (1999). When in xylan are partly converted into hexenuronic acid groups
the hydroxide ion concentration was levelled out at a low (HexA) (Buchert et al. 1996, 1997). HexA contribute to
level (0.55 mol/L) the cooking time was prolonged (four the kappa number (Gellerstedt, Li 1996) and affect the
times) and pulp viscosity improved by 80 mL/g compared consumption of bleaching chemicals (Vuorinen et al.
with the high level (1.5 mol/L). The pulp yield was unaf- 1996). Fig. 5 shows the xylan yield and HexA content in
fected by these changes in hydroxide ion concentration pulp for various hydroxide ion concentrations in the pre-
level. treatment and cooking stage. The results in Fig. 5 and
Table 5. Carbohydrate composition of the pulps calculated according to Jansson (1974) and hexenuronic acid (HexA) con-
tent in pulp.
Strength properties
The tear strength of the chemical pulps is affected both by
the pulp yield and by the pulp viscosity. Generally, the tear
strength increases as the pulp yield decreases, since the
number of load-bearing fibres in the paper sheet increases
(Bovin, Teder 1972). The loss of pulp viscosity increases
with decreasing kappa number due to the higher effective
Fig. 6. Brightness as a function of the consumption of bleaching alkali charge and longer reaction time required. For a
chemicals, defined as OXE per ton of pulp and per kappa number given wood material and a given pulping and bleaching
after the oxygen stage. process, there is a non-linear relationship between the tear
index (at a certain tensile index) and the pulp viscosity pretreatment and cooking stages on the tensile index deve-
(Rydholm 1965). There is no well-defined limit below lopment with increasing beating in PFI-mill was minor. As
which a large decrease in tear strength occurs. In addition expected, the HH pulp had a lower tensile index level than
the tear strength of kraft pulp also increases with increa- the other pulps, due to the lower hemicellulose and higher
sing fibre strength (Page, MacLeod 1992; Page 1994) and cellulose contents in pulp, Table 5. The LL pulp did not
increasing fibre length (Seth, Page 1988). have the best beatability in spite of the highest hemicellulo-
Fig. 7 gives the tear index/tensile index relationship of se content in the pulp and fibre swelling measured as Water
unbleached pulps produced in kraft cooks with pretreat- Retention Value, reported as WRV in Table 6.
ment at various hydroxide ion concentrations in the pretre- The results of this study indicate that terminating the
atment and cooking stages. The HH pulp with a high cook in the residual phase, LL cook, may have a negative
hydroxide ion concentration in the pretreatment and coo- influence not only on the bleachability but also on the
king stages (0.5 mol/L and 1.6 mol/L respectively) exhibi- strength properties of the pulp. In Paavilainen’s (1989)
ted the highest tear index values at tensile index values study (at kappa number 28), the pulp produced at 18%
below 100 Nm/g. The LL pulp with a low hydroxide ion effective alkali charge had a lower fibre strength (-15
concentration in the pretreatment and cooking stages (0.1 Nm/g) and tear strength (-1.5 mNm2/g) than pulps produ-
mol/L and 1.0 mol/L respectively) had a significantly ced at effective alkali charges of 21 and 24 % respectively
lower tear index level than all the other pulps. The lower on wood. The differences in tear index for pulps produced
pulp yield and higher fibre strength may explain the higher at the high effective alkali charges (21 and 24%) were
tear strength of HH than of LL pulp. The fibre strength small. The present study as well as Paavilainen’s work deal
was evaluated as rewetted zero-span tensile index, since with the strength properties of unbleached pulp. Recently
rewetting minimises the influence of fibre-fibre bonds the same tendency was found in a study of the strength pro-
(Mohlin, Alfredsson 1990). As shown in Table 6, the diffe- perties of ECF-bleached pulps (Poukka et al. 1999). An
rences in the zero-span tensile index of the studied pulps optimum in kappa number with respect to strength properti-
are small, except for the LL pulp. The LL pulp had a signi- es was obtained at kappa number of 30–40. The kappa
ficantly lower fibre strength, 158 Nm/g compared to a range studied was 20–60 and the cooking time at 167°C
value of 167 Nm/g (at 2000 rev. in PFI-mill) for the HH varied from 46 to 146 minutes. It is reasonable to assume
pulp. No significant effect of hydroxide ion concentration that the pulp with the lowest kappa number was finished in
on the fibre length was found in this study. In conventional the residual phase. These literature data support the obser-
kraft pulps, an improvement in tear index with increasing vation made in the present study that continuing the kraft
effective alkali charge has also been found (Paavilainen cook into the residual delignification phase has a detrimen-
1989). The differences in tear index caused by changes in tal effect on the strength properties of the pulp.
effective alkali charge were explained in terms of fibre
flexibility and fibre stiffness. It should be noted that HH Process considerations
pulp with the lowest viscosity (Table 4) had the highest In an industrial displacement kraft cook of the SuperBatch
tear index at a tensile index of 90 Nm/g. There seems to be or RDH type, the hydroxide ion concentration is low during
a tendency towards a higher tear index with decreasing displacement with black liquor and high in the cooking
pulp viscosity. Similar observation has been made for the stage (Perala, Hiljanen 1992; Lönnberg et al. 1993;
RDH type of pulps (Andrews 1989). Andersson, Olm 1998). The hydroxide ion concentration
The beatability expressed as tensile index as a function remains on a relatively high level throughout the cooking
of the number of revolutions in a PFI-mill is presented in stage due to the neutralisation of lignin and carbohydrate
Fig. 8. The influence of hydroxide ion concentrations in the degradation products during the displacement with black