Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chapter 07 - Consolidated Financial Statements—Ownership Patterns and Income Taxes – Hoyle, Schaefer,
Doupnik, 14e
CHAPTER 7
CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS—OWNERSHIP
PATTERNS AND INCOME TAXES
Chapter Outline
I. Indirect subsidiary control
A. Control of subsidiary companies within a business combination is often of an indirect
nature; one subsidiary possesses the stock of another rather than the parent having direct
ownership.
1. These ownership patterns may be developed specifically to enhance control or for
organizational purposes.
2. Such ownership patterns may also result from the parent company's acquisition of a
company that already possesses subsidiaries.
B. One of the most common corporate structures is the father-son-grandson configuration
where each subsidiary in turn owns one or more subsidiaries.
C. The consolidation process is altered somewhat when indirect control is present.
1. The worksheet entries are effectively doubled by each corporate ownership layer but
the concepts underlying the consolidation process are not changed.
2. Calculation of the accrual-based income of a subsidiary recognizing the consolidated
relationships is an important step in an indirect ownership structure.
a. The determination of accrual-based income figures is needed for equity income
accruals as well as for the computation of noncontrolling interest balances.
b. Any company within the business combination that is in both a parent and a
subsidiary position must recognize the equity income accruing from its subsidiary
before computing its own income.
7-1
Copyright © 2021 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill
Education.
VI. Temporary tax differences can stem from the creation of a business combination
A. The tax basis of a subsidiary's assets and liabilities may differ from their consolidated values
(which is based on the fair value on the date the combination is created).
B. If additional taxes will result in future years (for example, if the tax basis of an asset is lower
than its consolidated value so that future depreciation expense for tax purposes will be less),
a deferred tax liability is created by a combination.
C. The deferred tax liability is then written off (creating a reduction in tax expense) in future
years so that the net expense recognized (a lower number) matches the combination's book
income (a lower number due to the extra depreciation of the consolidated value).
Answers to Questions
2. In a business combination having an indirect ownership pattern, at least one company is in both
a parent and a subsidiary position. To calculate the accrual-based income earned by that
company, a proper recognition of the equity income accruing from its own subsidiary must
initially be made. Structuring the income calculation in this manner is necessary to ensure that
all earnings are properly included by each company.
4. When an indirect ownership is present, the quantity of consolidation entries will increase,
perhaps significantly. An additional set of entries is included on the worksheet for each separate
investment. Furthermore, the determination of accrual-based net income figures for each
subsidiary must be computed in a precise manner. For any company in both a parent and a
subsidiary position, equity income accruals are recognized prior to the calculation of that
company's accrual-based net income. The accrual-based net income total is significant because
it serves as the basis for noncontrolling interest calculations as well as the equity accruals to be
recognized by that company's parent.
5. In a connecting affiliation, two (or more) companies within a business combination own shares
in a third member. A mutual ownership, in contrast, exists whenever a subsidiary possesses an
equity interest in its own parent.
6. In accounting for a mutual ownership, U.S. GAAP requires the treasury stock approach. The
treasury stock approach presumes that the cost of the parent shares should be reclassified as
treasury stock within the consolidation process. The subsidiary is viewed, under this method,
as an agent of the parent. Thus, the shares are accounted for as if the parent had actually made
the acquisition.
7. According to present tax laws, an affiliated group can be comprised of all domestic corporations
in which a parent holds 80 percent ownership. More specifically, the parent must own (directly
or indirectly) 80 percent of the voting stock of the corporation as well as at least 80 percent of
each class of nonvoting stock.
8. Several basic advantages are available to combinations that file a consolidated tax return. First,
intra-entity profits are not taxed until the goods are sold to outside customers or consumed
within the consolidated group. For companies with large amounts of intra-entity transactions,
7-3
Copyright © 2021 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill
Education.
Chapter 07 - Consolidated Financial Statements—Ownership Patterns and Income Taxes – Hoyle, Schaefer,
Doupnik, 14e
the deferral of intra-entity gains causes a delay in the making of significant tax payments.
Second, losses incurred by one company can be used to reduce or offset taxable income earned
by other members of the affiliated group. In addition, intra-entity dividends are not taxable but
that exclusion applies to the members of an affiliated group regardless of whether a
consolidated or separate tax return is filed.
Members of a business combination may be forced to file separate tax returns. Foreign
corporations, for example, must always file separately. Domestic companies that do not meet
the 80 percent ownership rule are also required to file in this manner. Furthermore, companies
that are in an affiliated group may still elect to file separately. If all companies within the
combination are profitable and few intra-entity transactions are carried out, little advantage may
accrue from preparing a consolidated return. With a separate filing, a subsidiary has more
flexibility as to accounting methods as well as its choice of a fiscal year-end.
9. The allocation of income tax expense among the component companies of a business
combination has a direct bearing on adjusted income totals and, therefore, noncontrolling
interest calculations. Obviously, the more expense that is assigned to a particular company the
less income is attributed to that concern. Income tax expense can be allocated based on the
income totals that would have been reported by various companies if separate tax returns had
been filed or on the portion of taxable income derived from each company.
10. In filing a separate tax return (assuming that the two companies do not qualify as members of
an affiliated group), the parent must include as income the dividends received from the
subsidiary. For financial reporting purposes, however, income is accrued based on the
ownership percentage of the adjusted income of the subsidiary. Because income is frequently
recognized by the parent prior to when it receives a dividend (when it is subject to taxation),
deferred income taxes must be recognized.
Either the parent or the subsidiary might also have to record deferred income taxes in
connection with any intra-entity gain on assets that remain within the consolidated entity. On a
separate tax return, such gains are reported at the time of transfer while for financial reporting
purposes they are appropriately deferred until the goods are sold to outside customers or
consumed within the consolidated group. Once again, a temporary difference is created which
necessitates the recognition of deferred income taxes.
11. If the consolidated value of a subsidiary’s assets exceeds their tax basis, depreciation expense
in the future will be less on the tax return than is shown for external reporting purposes. The
reduced expense creates higher taxable income and, thus, increases taxes. Therefore, the
difference in values dictates an anticipated increase in future tax payments. This deferred
liability is recognized at the time the combination is created. Subsequently, when actual tax
payments do arise, the deferred liability is written off rather than recognizing expense based
solely on the current liability. In this manner, the expense is shown at a lower figure, one that is
matched with reported income (which is also a lower balance because of the extra depreciation).
Recognition of this deferred liability at date of acquisition also reduces the net amount attributed
to the subsidiary's assets and liabilities in the initial allocation process. Therefore, the residual
asset (goodwill) is increased by the amount of any liability that must be recognized.
12. A net operating loss carryforward allows the company to reduce future taxable income subject
to 80 percent of any future year’s taxable income. Thus, a benefit may possibly be derived from
the carryforward but that benefit is based on Wilson’s (the subsidiary) ability to generate future
7-4
Copyright © 2021 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill
Education.
Chapter 07 - Consolidated Financial Statements—Ownership Patterns and Income Taxes – Hoyle, Schaefer,
Doupnik, 14e
taxable income for offset against the carryforward. To reflect the potential tax reduction, a
deferred income tax asset is recorded for the total amount of anticipated benefit. However,
because of the uncertainty, unless the receipt of this benefit is more likely than not to be
received, a valuation allowance must also be recorded as a contra account to the asset. The
valuation allowance may be for the entire amount or just for a portion of the asset.
13. At the date of acquisition, the valuation allowance was $150,000. As a contra asset account,
recognition of this amount reduced the net assets attributed to the subsidiary and, hence,
increased the recording of goodwill (assuming that the price did not indicate a bargain
purchase). If the valuation allowance is subsequently reduced to $110,000, the net assets have
increased by $40,000. This change is reflected by a decrease in income tax expense.
7-5
Copyright © 2021 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill
Education.
Chapter 07 - Consolidated Financial Statements—Ownership Patterns and Income Taxes – Hoyle, Schaefer,
Doupnik, 14e
Answers to Problems
1. D
2. B
3. A
4. C
5. C
6. C
7-6
Copyright © 2021 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill
Education.
Chapter 07 - Consolidated Financial Statements—Ownership Patterns and Income Taxes – Hoyle, Schaefer,
Doupnik, 14e
12. A Recognition of this gross profit is not required on a consolidated tax return.
13. B Because fair value of the subsidiary's assets exceeds the tax basis by
$40,000, a deferred tax liability of $8,400 (21%) must be recorded. Goodwill is
then computed as follows:
7-7
Copyright © 2021 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill
Education.
Chapter 07 - Consolidated Financial Statements—Ownership Patterns and Income Taxes – Hoyle, Schaefer,
Doupnik, 14e
14. (continued)
14. (continued)
15. (15 minutes) (Income and noncontrolling interest with mutual ownership.)
7-9
Copyright © 2021 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill
Education.
Chapter 07 - Consolidated Financial Statements—Ownership Patterns and Income Taxes – Hoyle, Schaefer,
Doupnik, 14e
Reconciliation:
Boulder’s operating income $245,000
Boulder’s share of Rock’s operating income (90% × $85,000) 76,500
Boulder’s share of Stone’s operating income (90% × 75% × $150,000) 101,250
Boulder’s share of Rock’s excess amortization (90% × $22,000) (19,800)
Boulder’s share of Stone’s excess amortization (90% × 75% × $8,000) (5,400)
Controlling interest in consolidated net income $397,550
Net income attributable to noncontrolling interest 52,450
Consolidated net income $450,000
7-10
Copyright © 2021 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill
Education.
Chapter 07 - Consolidated Financial Statements—Ownership Patterns and Income Taxes – Hoyle, Schaefer,
Doupnik, 14e
17. (30 Minutes) (Consolidated net income figures for a connecting affiliation)
NONCONTROLLING INTERESTS:
CLEVELAND:
Operating income (sales minus cost of goods sold and
expenses) ........................................................................ $60,000
Defer intra-entity gross profit (above) ................................ (3,000)
Accrual-based net income—Cleveland ........................ $57,000
Outside ownership ............................................................... 20%
Noncontrolling interest in Cleveland's net income ..... $11,400
WISCONSIN:
Operating income (sales minus cost of goods sold and
expenses) ...................................................................... $110,000
Defer intra-entity gross profit (above) .............................. (12,000)
Investment income (60% of Cleveland's accrual-based
income of $57,000) ....................................................... 34,200
Accrual-based net income—Wisconsin ..................... $132,200
Outside ownership ............................................................. 10%
Noncontrolling interest in Wisconsin's net income .. $ 13,220
CONSOLIDATION TOTALS
▪ Sales = $1,590,000 (add the three book values and eliminate intra-entity
transfers of $40,000 and $100,000)
▪ Cost of goods sold = $1,015,000 (add the three book values, eliminate intra-
entity transfers of $40,000 and $100,000, and defer [add] intra-entity gains of
$3,000 and $12,000)
▪ Expenses = $200,000 (add the three book values)
▪ Dividend income = -0- (eliminated for consolidation purposes)
▪ Consolidated net income = $375,000 (consolidated revenues less
consolidated cost of goods sold and expenses)
▪ Net income attributable to noncontrolling interest = $24,620 (above)
▪ Net income attributable to Baxter Company = $350,380 (consolidated net
income less noncontrolling interest share)
7-11
Copyright © 2021 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill
Education.
Chapter 07 - Consolidated Financial Statements—Ownership Patterns and Income Taxes – Hoyle, Schaefer,
Doupnik, 14e
19. (25 Minutes) (Tax expense with separate tax returns for a combination.)
a. CONSOLIDATED TOTALS
▪ Sales = $790,000 (add the two book values and eliminate the $110,000 intra-
entity transfer)
▪ Cost of goods sold = $340,000 (add the book values, eliminate intra-entity
transfers of $110,000, recognize [subtract] $30,000 deferred gross profit from
2021, and defer [add] $40,000 intra-entity gross profit into 2022)
▪ Operating expenses = $234,000 (add the two book values)
▪ Dividend income = -0- (eliminated for consolidation purposes)
▪ Consolidated net income = $216,000 (Revenues less expenses)
▪ Net income attributable to noncontrolling interest = $18,000 (20 percent of
reported Income of $100,000 plus $30,000 gross profit deferred from 2021
less $40,000 gross profit deferred into 2022)
▪ Net income attributable to Abajo Company = $198,000
7-12
Copyright © 2021 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill
Education.
Chapter 07 - Consolidated Financial Statements—Ownership Patterns and Income Taxes – Hoyle, Schaefer,
Doupnik, 14e
19. (continued)
ABAJO:
Reported income ............................................................ $100,000
Tax rate .......................................................................... 21%
Currently payable to government ........................... $ 21,000
Income tax liability ($26,460 + $21,000) = $47,460 less deferred tax asset ($2,100)
= income tax expense $45,360.
Otherwise stated as: Arriba has a tax expense of $26,460 and Abajo has a tax
expense of $18,900 ($21,000 payable - $2,100 deferred tax asset). Income tax
expense on the consolidated income statement is $45,360.
20. (45 Minutes) (Computation of income tax expense and the related payable
balances)
7-13
Copyright © 2021 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill
Education.
Chapter 07 - Consolidated Financial Statements—Ownership Patterns and Income Taxes – Hoyle, Schaefer,
Doupnik, 14e
20. (continued)
e. $109,116 (see part d. above) Martin owes $105,000 on its operating income
($500,000 × 21%) because the intra-entity gross profit in ending inventory cannot
be deferred. Martin also owes $4,116 from the dividends received ($56,000 × 35% ×
21%). The difference between Martin’s $109,116 payment and the $95,855 tax
expense in (d.) is created by the premature payment of the tax (a deferred tax
asset) on the intra-entity inventory gross profit ($90,000) less the deferred tax
liability on the parent's net equity accrual ($76,720) in excess of dividends received
($49,868).
7-14
Copyright © 2021 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill
Education.
Chapter 07 - Consolidated Financial Statements—Ownership Patterns and Income Taxes – Hoyle, Schaefer,
Doupnik, 14e
21. (20 Minutes) (Comparison of income tax expense and payable on separate and
consolidated tax returns.)
a. Consolidated Return—2021
Because no temporary differences exist in this problem, the income tax expense
would also be $77,700. The intra-entity gross profit is not taxed until the goods
are sold to an outside customer or consumed within the consolidated group.
Dividend income is not important because the group files a consolidated return.
b. Separate Returns—2021
On its separate tax return, Abbey will report taxable income of $300,000—the
intra-entity inventory gross profits cannot be deferred. The dividends would not
be taxable because Benjamin still meets the criteria to be a member of an
affiliated group. A consolidated return is not a requirement for these dividends
to be excluded. Thus, income taxes payable by Abbey would be $63,000
($300,000 × 21%).
To determine the income tax expense for Abbey, the two temporary differences
must be taken into account:
The $6,300 difference between the expense and the payable is the tax effect on
the net intra-entity gross profit ($30,000 × 21%).
7-15
Copyright © 2021 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill
Education.
Chapter 07 - Consolidated Financial Statements—Ownership Patterns and Income Taxes – Hoyle, Schaefer,
Doupnik, 14e
22. (45 Minutes) (Comparison of income tax expense and payable on separate and
consolidated tax returns. Includes question on mutual ownership and the
conventional approach.)
7-16
Copyright © 2021 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill
Education.
Chapter 07 - Consolidated Financial Statements—Ownership Patterns and Income Taxes – Hoyle, Schaefer,
Doupnik, 14e
22. (continued)
b. Boxwood will pay $21,000 ($100,000 × 21%) because separate returns are filed.
Lake, however, will pay its taxes based on dividends received rather than on the
equity accrual. A deferred income tax liability would be established for the
difference. Lake's payment for the current year is computed as follows:
The $385 difference ($84,441 – $84,056) between the expenses in a. and the
payable in b. is created by the following two effects:
Deferred income tax liability on equity income accrual not yet taxed
($67,940 – $10,000) x 60% = $34,764 × 35% × 21%) ................... $2,555
Deferred income tax asset on net intra-entity gross profit
($32,000 – $18,000 = $14,000 × 21%) ........................................... 2,940
Net decrease in expense ................................................................... $ 385
7-17
Copyright © 2021 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill
Education.
Chapter 07 - Consolidated Financial Statements—Ownership Patterns and Income Taxes – Hoyle, Schaefer,
Doupnik, 14e
23. (30 Minutes) (Computation of income tax expense and income tax payable on
consolidated and separate tax returns.)
The affiliated group would be taxed on its operating income of $450,000 (the
$50,000 intra-entity gain is deferred). Intra-entity income and dividends are not
relevant because a consolidated return is filed.
b. Total taxes to be paid are $105,000. Robertson would have to pay $42,000 or
21% of its $200,000 operating income. Garrison would pay $63,000 or 21% of its
$300,000 operating income. The intra-entity gain is not deferred because
separate returns are filed. Intra-entity dividends are not taxable because the
parties still qualify as an affiliated group even though separate returns are filed.
c. Robertson must report an income tax expense of $42,000 or 21% of its $200,000
operating income.
Garrison records its expense based on the revenue recognized during the
period. Thus, the expense is computed on an operating income of $250,000 (the
net intra-entity gain is not recognized in this period) along with equity income
from Robertson of $110,600 (70% of that company's $158,000 after-tax income).
Garrison will record an income tax expense of $52,500 in connection with the
operating income ($250,000 × 21%) and $8,129 resulting from its equity income
($110,600 × 35% × 21%). Total expense to be reported amounts to $102,629 for
Garrison and Robertson ($42,000 + $52,500 + $8,129).
d. Garrison will pay $63,000 in connection with its operating income ($300,000 ×
21%) and $2,205 because of the dividends received from Robertson. Garrison
will receive $30,000 in dividends based on its 60% ownership. Of this total, only
$10,500 (35%) is taxable. Thus, at a 21% rate, the tax on the dividends would
amount to $2,205 ($10,500 × 21%). The total income taxes payable by Garrison is
$65,205 ($63,000 + $2,205).
7-18
Copyright © 2021 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill
Education.
Chapter 07 - Consolidated Financial Statements—Ownership Patterns and Income Taxes – Hoyle, Schaefer,
Doupnik, 14e
24. (10 Minutes) (Impact on goodwill of assets with a different tax vs. book value.)
7-19
Copyright © 2021 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill
Education.
Chapter 07 - Consolidated Financial Statements—Ownership Patterns and Income Taxes – Hoyle, Schaefer,
Doupnik, 14e
Entry *C
Retained Earnings, 1/1/21 (House) ............................... 11,200
Investment in Wilson .......................................... 11,200
(To convert investment account from partial equity method to equity method.
Intra-entity gross profit shown in Entry *G is not properly reflected by parent
under partial equity method [12,000 × 70% = $8,400 income decrease] nor would
be the $2,800 in amortization expense for 2019–2020. Thus, a reduction of
$11,200 is required. Because Cuddy is a current year acquisition, no prior
conversion to equity method is required for the investment.)
Entry S1
Common Stock (Cuddy) ................................................ 150,000
Retained Earnings, 1/1/21 (Cuddy) ............................... 150,000
Investment in Cuddy (80%) ....................................... 240,000
Noncontrolling Interest in Cuddy Common Stock (20%) 60,000
(To eliminate Cuddy's stockholders' equity against the corresponding
investment balance and to recognize noncontrolling interest in common stock.)
7-20
Copyright © 2021 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill
Education.
Chapter 07 - Consolidated Financial Statements—Ownership Patterns and Income Taxes – Hoyle, Schaefer,
Doupnik, 14e
25. (continued)
Entry S2
Common Stock (Wilson) ............................................... 310,000
Retained Earnings, 1/1/21 (Wilson)
(adjusted by Entry *G) .............................................. 578,000
Investment in Wilson (70%) ................................ 621,600
Noncontrolling Interest in Wilson (30%) ........... 266,400
(To eliminate Wilson's stockholders' equity against corresponding investment
balance and to recognize noncontrolling interest.)
Entry A
Buildings ......................................................................... 54,000
Franchise Contracts ...................................................... 32,000
Goodwill ........................................................................... 140,000
Equipment ................................................................. 10,000
Investment in Wilson ................................................ 151,200
Noncontrolling Interest in Wilson ............................ 64,800
(To allocate excess payment made in connection with purchase of Wilson
shown above. Amortization for 2019 and 2020 has been taken into account in
determining the January 1, 2021 value for each account.)
Entry I1
Income of Cuddy ...................................................... 56,000
Investment in Cuddy ........................................... 56,000
(To eliminate intra-entity income accrued by both House and Wilson during
the year.)
Entry I2
Income of Wilson ...................................................... 91,000
Investment in Wilson .......................................... 91,000
(To eliminate intra-entity income accrued by House during the year.)
Entry D1
Investment in Cuddy ............................................... 40,000
Dividends declared (80%) (Cuddy) .................... 40,000
(To eliminate effects of intra-entity dividend payments.)
Entry D2
Investment in Wilson ............................................... 67,200
Dividends declared (70%) (Wilson) .................... 67,200
(To eliminate effects of intra-entity dividend payments.)
7-21
Copyright © 2021 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill
Education.
Chapter 07 - Consolidated Financial Statements—Ownership Patterns and Income Taxes – Hoyle, Schaefer,
Doupnik, 14e
25. (continued)
Entry E
Operating Expenses ................................................. 2,000
Equipment ............................................................... 5,000
Franchise Contracts ........................................... 4,000
Buildings ............................................................... 3,000
(To record 2021 amortization of excess payment made in connection with
acquisition of Wilson Company.)
Entry TI
Sales and Other Revenues ...................................... 200,000
Cost of Goods Sold .............................................. 200,000
(To eliminate intra-entity inventory sales for the current year.)
Entry G
Cost of Goods Sold ................................................... 18,000
Inventory ............................................................... 18,000
(To defer intra-entity gross profit in ending inventory.)
7-22
Copyright © 2021 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill
Education.
Chapter 07 - Consolidated Financial Statements—Ownership Patterns and Income Taxes – Hoyle, Schaefer, Doupnik, 14e
25. (continued)
HOUSE CORPORATION AND CONSOLIDATED SUBSIDIARIES
Consolidation Worksheet
December 31, 2021
Cost of goods sold 551,000 300,000 140,000 (G) 18,000 (*G) 12,000 797,000
(TI) 200,000
Operating expenses 219,000 270,000 90,000 (E) 2,000 581,000
Income of Wilson Company (91,000) (I2) 91,000 -0-
Income of Cuddy Company (28,000) (28,000) (I1) 56,000 -0-
Net income (249,000) (158,000) (70,000)
Consolidated net income (322,000)
Net income attributable to
noncontrolling interest (Wilson) (45,000) 45,000
Net income attributable to
noncontrolling interest (Cuddy) (14,000) 14,000
Net income attributable to House Corporation (263,000)
Retained earnings, 1/1/21:
—House Corporation (820,000) (*C) 11,200 (808,800)
—Wilson Company (590,000) (*G) 12,000 -0-
(S2)578,000
—Cuddy Company (150,000) (S1)150,000 -0-
Net Income (249,000) (158,000) (70,000) (263,000)
Dividends declared
—House Corporation 100,000 100,000
—Wilson Company 96,000 (D2) 67,200 28,800 -0-
—Cuddy Company 50,000 (D1) 40,000 10,000 -0-
Retained earnings, 12/31/21 (969,000) (652,000) (170,000) (971,800)
7-23
Copyright © 2021 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill Education.
Chapter 07 - Consolidated Financial Statements—Ownership Patterns and Income Taxes – Hoyle, Schaefer, Doupnik, 14e
25. (continued)
7-24
Copyright © 2021 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill Education.
Chapter 07 - Consolidated Financial Statements—Ownership Patterns and Income Taxes – Hoyle, Schaefer,
Doupnik, 14e
26. (20 Minutes) (Consolidation entries for a mutual holding business combination)
CONSOLIDATION ENTRIES
Entry *C
Investment in Lowly ................................................. 117,000
Retained Earnings, 1/1/21 (Mighty) .................... 117,000
(To accrue income to parent during the previous years as measured by
increase in book value [$200,000 × 60%] and amortization expense of $3,000
[$5,000 × 60%] for the previous year.)
Entry S1
Common Stock (Lowly) ............................................ 300,000
Retained Earnings, 1/1/21 (Lowly) ........................... 500,000
Investment in Lowly (60%) ................................. 480,000
Noncontrolling Interest in Lowly 1/1/21 (40%) .. 320,000
(To eliminate subsidiary stockholders' equity accounts against investment
account and to recognize noncontrolling interest ownership.)
Entry S2
Treasury Stock .......................................................... 240,000
Investment in Mighty ........................................... 240,000
(To reclassify cost of parent shares as treasury stock.)
Entry A
Trademarks ............................................................... 95,000
Investment in Lowly ............................................ 57,000
Noncontrolling Interest in Lowly 1/1/21 (40%) .. 38,000
(To recognize unamortized portion of acquisition-date excess fair value.)
Entry E
Amortization Expense .............................................. 5,000
Trademarks .......................................................... 5,000
(To record trademarks amortization expense for 2021.)
7-25
Copyright © 2021 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill
Education.
Chapter 07 - Consolidated Financial Statements—Ownership Patterns and Income Taxes – Hoyle, Schaefer,
Doupnik, 14e
CONSOLIDATION ENTRIES
Entry *G
Retained Earnings, 1/1/21 (Stookey) ....................... 7,680
Cost of Goods Sold .............................................. 7,680
(To give effect to intra-entity gross profit deferral from 2020. Amount is
calculated based on normal 48% markup [found from Income Statement]
multiplied by $16,000 retained inventory [20% of $80,000])
Entry *C1
Investment in Stookey ............................................. 85,856
Retained Earnings, 1/1/21 (Yarrow) ................... 85,856
(To recognize equity income accruing from Yarrow's investment in Stookey
during 2020. Because the initial value method is applied and no dividends
declared, no income has been recognized in connection with the 2020
ownership of Stookey. Reported income of $120,000 [2020] less intra-entity
gross profit of $7,680 deferred above indicates income of $112,320. Based on
80% ownership, an $89,856 accrual is needed, which is reduced by the
$4,000 amortization (80% × $5,000) for that year.
7-26
Copyright © 2021 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill
Education.
Chapter 07 - Consolidated Financial Statements—Ownership Patterns and Income Taxes – Hoyle, Schaefer,
Doupnik, 14e
27. (continued)
Entry *C2
Investment in Yarrow ............................................... 217,670
Retained Earnings, 1/1/21 (Travers) .................. 217,670
(To recognize equity income accruing from Travers' investment in Yarrow
during 2020. Because the initial method is applied and no dividends
declared, income has not been recognized in connection with the 2020
ownership of Yarrow. Income of $245,856 is calculated based on reported
income of $160,000 [2020] plus the $85,856 accrual recognized in Entry *C1.
Ownership of 90% dictates a $221,270 accrual that is then reduced to
$217,670 by the $3,600 [90% × $4,000] amortization applicable to 2020.)
Entry S1
Common Stock (Stookey) ........................................ 200,000
Retained Earnings, 1/1/21 (Stookey, as adjusted
by Entry *G) ......................................................... 292,320
Investment in Stookey (80%) ........................ 393,856
Noncontrolling Interest in Stookey (20%) .... 98,464
(To eliminate stockholders' equity accounts of subsidiary [Stookey] against
corresponding balance in investment account and to recognize
noncontrolling interest ownership.)
Entry S2
Common Stock (Yarrow) .......................................... 300,000
Retained Earnings, 1/1/21 (Yarrow, as adjusted
by Entry *C1) ........................................................ 685,856
Investment in Yarrow (90%) .......................... 887,270
Noncontrolling Interest in Yarrow (10%) ...... 98,586
(To eliminate stockholders’ equity accounts of subsidiary Yarrow against
corresponding balance in investment account and to recognize
noncontrolling interest ownership.)
Entry A1
Copyright.................................................................... 45,000
Investment in Stookey ........................................ 36,000
Noncontrolling Interest in Stookey (20%) ......... 9,000
7-27
Copyright © 2021 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill
Education.
Chapter 07 - Consolidated Financial Statements—Ownership Patterns and Income Taxes – Hoyle, Schaefer,
Doupnik, 14e
27. (continued)
Entry A2
Customer List ............................................................ 56,000
Investment in Yarrow . ......................................... 50,400
Noncontrolling Interest in Yarrow ...................... 5,600
(To recognize January 1, 2021 unamortized portion of acquisition price
assigned to customer list.)
Entry E
Operating Expenses ................................................. 9,000
Copyright .............................................................. 5,000
Customer List ....................................................... 4,000
(To recognize amortization expense for 2021—$5,000 in connection with
Yarrow's investment and $4,000 in connection with Travers’ investment.)
Entry Tl
Sales .......................................................................... 100,000
Cost of Goods Sold .............................................. 100,000
(To eliminate intra-entity inventory transfers made during 2021.)
Entry G
Cost of Goods Sold ................................................... 9,600
Inventory (current assets) .................................. 9,600
(To defer intra-entity gross profit on ending inventory—$20,000 × 48%
markup.)
7-28
Copyright © 2021 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill
Education.
Chapter 07 - Consolidated Financial Statements—Ownership Patterns and Income Taxes – Hoyle, Schaefer, Doupnik, 14e
7-29
Copyright © 2021 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill Education.
Chapter 07 - Consolidated Financial Statements—Ownership Patterns and Income Taxes – Hoyle, Schaefer,
Doupnik, 14e
27. (continued)
d. (1) Because Yarrow owns 80% of Stookey's stock, intra-entity dividends are
nontaxable. Thus, no temporary difference is created by Stookey's failure to
pay a dividend.
(2) Stookey's intra-entity gross profits in ending inventory are recognized in one
time period for financial reporting purposes and in a different time period for
tax purposes. This temporary increases taxable income by $1,920 over
reported income:
Because a single 21% tax rate is used, income tax expense can also be
computed by multiplying consolidated net income (prior to noncontrolling
interest reduction) of $609,080 (part a.) by the 21% tax rate to obtain $127,907.
7-30
Copyright © 2021 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill
Education.
Chapter 07 - Consolidated Financial Statements—Ownership Patterns and Income Taxes – Hoyle, Schaefer,
Doupnik, 14e
28. (40 Minutes) (Series of questions about a business combination and its income
tax reporting)
a. Equity method. "Income of Syber" is 80% of Syber's reported total, adjusted for
excess acquisition-date fair value amortization and intra-entity profit
adjustments. Also, Parson’s recognition of “Income of Syber” equals its share
of consolidated net income and Parson’s retained earnings equal consolidated
retained earnings.
f. $20,000. For both receivables and liabilities, the consolidated total is $20,000
less than the sum of the two companies.
7-31
Copyright © 2021 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill
Education.
Chapter 07 - Consolidated Financial Statements—Ownership Patterns and Income Taxes – Hoyle, Schaefer,
Doupnik, 14e
28. (continued)
7-32
Copyright © 2021 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill
Education.
Chapter 07 - Consolidated Financial Statements—Ownership Patterns and Income Taxes – Hoyle, Schaefer,
Doupnik, 14e
28. k. (continued)
29. (45 Minutes) Develop worksheet entries that were used to consolidate the
financial statements of a father-son-grandson combination.
Entry *G
Retained Earnings, 1/1/21 (Delta) ............................ 15,000
Cost of Goods Sold .............................................. 15,000
(To recognize intra-entity gross profit in inventory in 2020 [amount
provided].)
Entry *C1
Retained Earnings, 1/1/21 (Delta) ............................ 7,000
Investment in Omega Company ......................... 7,000
(To recognize amortization expense from Delta’s acquisition for 2020.)
7-33
Copyright © 2021 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill
Education.
Chapter 07 - Consolidated Financial Statements—Ownership Patterns and Income Taxes – Hoyle, Schaefer,
Doupnik, 14e
29. (continued)
Entry *C2
Retained Earnings, 1/1/21 (Alpha) ........................... 27,600
Investment in Delta Company ............................ 27,600
To recognize accrual adjustments for excess amortization
and inventory deferral as follows:
Excess amortization from Delta acquisition
(80% × $6,250 × 2 years)........................................ $10,000
Deltas’ share of excess amortization from Omega acquisition
(80% × [70% × $10,000] × 1 year) .......................... 5,600
Inventory profit deferral at 1/1/21 (80% × $15,000) . 12,000
*C2 adjustment .......................................................... $27,600
Entry S1
Common Stock (Omega) .......................................... 100,000
Retained Earnings, 1/1/21 (Omega) ......................... 100,000
Investment in Omega (70%) ................................ 140,000
Noncontrolling Interest in Omega (30%) ........... 60,000
(To eliminate stockholders' equity accounts of Omega against parent's
Investment account and to recognize outside ownership.)
Entry S2
Common Stock (Delta) ............................................. 120,000
Retained Earnings, 1/1/21 (Delta, as adjusted) ...... 378,000
Investment in Delta (80%) ................................... 398,400
Noncontrolling Interest in Delta (20%) .............. 99,600
(To eliminate stockholders' equity accounts of Delta [as adjusted as Entry *G
and Entry *C1] against corresponding balance in Investment account and to
recognize outside ownership.)
Entry A
Copyrights ................................................................. 222,500
Investment in Delta ............................................. 90,000
Investment in Omega .......................................... 77,000
Noncontrolling Interest in Delta .......................... 22,500
Noncontrolling Interest in Omega ...................... 33,000
(To recognize January 1, 2021 unamortized copyrights, 2 years amortization
recorded on first investment but only one year for second.)
Entry I1
Income of Subsidiary ............................................... 144,000
Investment in Delta ............................................. 144,000
(To eliminate intra-entity income accrual found on Alpha's records.)
7-34
Copyright © 2021 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill
Education.
Chapter 07 - Consolidated Financial Statements—Ownership Patterns and Income Taxes – Hoyle, Schaefer,
Doupnik, 14e
29. (continued)
Entry I2
Income of Subsidiary ............................................... 49,000
Investment in Omega .......................................... 49,000
(To eliminate intra-entity income accrual found on Delta's records.)
Entry D1
Investment in Delta ................................................... 32,000
Dividends Declared (Delta) ................................. 32,000
(To eliminate intra-entity dividends.)
Entry D2
Investment in Omega ............................................... 35,000
Dividends Declared (Omega) ............................. 35,000
(To eliminate intra-entity dividends.)
Entry E
Operating Expenses ................................................. 16,250
Copyrights ........................................................... 16,250
(Current year amortization, $6,250 on first acquisition and $10,000 on
second.)
Entry Tl
Sales .......................................................................... 200,000
Cost of Goods Sold .............................................. 200,000
(To eliminate intra-entity inventory transfer.)
Entry G
Cost of Goods Sold ................................................... 22,000
Inventory ............................................................... 22,000
(To defer ending intra-entity gross profit on intra-entity transfers.)
7-35
Copyright © 2021 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill
Education.
Chapter 07 - Consolidated Financial Statements—Ownership Patterns and Income Taxes – Hoyle, Schaefer,
Doupnik, 14e
29. (continued)
7-36
Copyright © 2021 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill
Education.
Chapter 07 - Consolidated Financial Statements—Ownership Patterns and Income Taxes – Hoyle, Schaefer,
Doupnik, 14e
Ownership percentages
Highpoint-->Middlebury 95%
Middlebury-->Lowton 80%
Comparison
Consolidated net income (operating incomes less
amortizations) $970,000
Net income attributable to noncontrolling interests
(20% × $225,000 plus 5% × $500,000) 70,000
Net income attributable to Highpoint Company $900,000
7-37
Copyright © 2021 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill
Education.
Solution Manual for Advanced Accounting, 14th Edition, Joe Ben Hoyle Thomas Schaefer Timothy
Chapter 07 - Consolidated Financial Statements—Ownership Patterns and Income Taxes – Hoyle, Schaefer,
Doupnik, 14e
In October 2016, the FASB issued ASU 2016-16, which requires the Company to recognize the
income tax consequences of an intra-entity transfer of an asset other than inventory when the
transfer occurs. ASU 2016-16 was effective for the Company beginning January 1, 2018 and was
adopted using a modified retrospective basis. We recorded a $2.9 billion cumulative effect
adjustment to increase the opening balance of reinvested earnings with the majority of the offset
being recorded as a deferred tax asset. This amount is primarily related to trademarks and other
intangible assets and was recorded in the line item deferred income tax assets in our
consolidated balance sheet.
As of December 31, 2018 , we had net deferred tax assets of $2.0 billion and as of December 31,
2017, we had net deferred tax liabilities of $539 million located in countries outside the United
States.
As of December 31, 2018 , we had $ 2,906 million of loss carryforwards available to reduce future
taxable income. Loss carryforwards of $ 372 million must be utilized within the next five years,
and the remainder can be utilized over a period greater than five years.
7-38
Copyright © 2021 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw-Hill
Education.