Example of a Rubric

Group Video Project Evaluation Tools

EXCELLENT VERY GOOD GOOD POOR SCOR REMARK
CRITERIA
4 3 2 1 E S

The content
The content
The content includes a
includes a
includes an highly The content
somewhat
outstanding satisfactory lacks a
clear
clarity of clarity central
statement of
Content/ statement of statement of theme, clear
theme;
Organization theme; theme; point of view
Messages are
Messages are Messages are and logical
somewhat
presented in presented in sequence of
presented in
a highly a satisfactory information.
a logical
logical order. logical
manner.
manner.
Project has
problems in
Project is
staying
deeply
Project is focused on Project’s
focused and
focused and topic; it focus and
very
informative; provides information
informative;
it promotes some are in
it highly
the use of information; question; the
Focus/Level of promotes the
computer the use of use of
information use of
technology in computer computer
computer
creating a technology is technology is
technology in
video to somewhat ineffective in
creating a
deliver effective in delivering
video to
information. creating a information.
deliver
video to
information.
deliver
information.
There re The entire
There are
minimal video is of
All shots are several poor
shots that poor quality;
of high shots; Shots
are of low The shots
quality; Shots and scenes
Quality of Shots quality. Shots and scenes
and scenes have many
and scenes are full of
flow unnatural
flow good unnatural
seamlessly. breaks and/
pacing and breaks and/
or early cuts.
timing. or early cuts.
Clarity of Audio The audio is The audio is The audio is The audio is
very clear clear and has inconsistent cut-off and
and has an a highly in clarity at has an
outstanding satisfactory times and unsatisfactor
level of level of has a y level of
 satisfactory
effectiveness effectiveness level of effectiveness
in in effectiveness in
communicati communicati in communicati
ng the main ng the main communicati ng the main
idea. idea. ng the main idea.
idea.
The running
The running The running
time falls The running
time falls time falls a
within the 1 time falls
within the little longer
– 2 minutes short of the
assigned 1 – than 1 – 2
and the required 1- 2
Running Time and 2 minutes. minutes; the
video is minutes; the
Video The video is video has
somewhat video fails to
Effectiveness effective in lapses in
effective in communicat
communicati communicati
communicati e the
ng the ng the
ng the message to
message to message to
message to the audience.
the audience. the audience.
the audience.