Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2010 349
DOI 10.1007/s11595-010-2349-0
Abstract: To decrease the cement and SF content of RPC by using ultra-fine fly ash (UFFA)
and steel slag powder (SS), the effect of these mineral admixtures on compressive strength of RPC
were investigated. The experimental results indicate that the utilization of UFFA and SS in RPC is
feasible and has prominent mechanical performance. The microstructure analysis (SEM and
TG-DTG-DSC) demonstrated that the excellent mechanical properties of RPC containing SS and
UFFA were mainly attributed to the sequential hydration filling effect of the compound system.
Key words: ultra-fine fly ash; steel slag powder; reactive powder concrete; sequential hydra-
tion; microstructure; strength
Table 4 Mixing proportions of mixtures with UFFA and SS Thus, ternary blends of SF, UFFA and SS may be pre-
replacement (SF constant) +
ferred rather than only using binary blend of SF UFFA
No.
SF15
C
0.85
UFFA SS
— —
SF Sand Water* SP +
or SF SS in RPC mixtures.
Thirdly, the effect of SS/UFFA ratio on compressive
F05S05 0.75
F10S10 0.65
0.05
0.10
0.05
0.10
+
strength of RPC was investigated. The SS UFFA con-
0.15 1.1 0.18 0.035 tent of mixtures designed for this experimental program
F15S15 0.55 0.15 0.15
F20S20 0.45 0.20 0.20 was 20%, 30% and 40% respectively and the content
F25S25 0.35 0.25 0.25 +
ratio of SS-to-UFFA in each SS UFFA content mixture
=+ +
* Including water from SP, binder C SF UFFA SS + was 0.5, 0.67, 1, 1.5 and 2 respectively. Nine strength
As shown in Table 4, cement was replaced with SS × ×
specimens (40 mm 40 mm 160 mm prism) among
and UFFA in different proportions and SF content was ℃
which six prisms were cured in 20 water and three were
kept constant (15%) in these mixtures. It could be ob-
served from Fig.2 that total replacement level (SS FA) + ℃
cured in 90 water for each mixture are tested. The results
are shown in Fig.3.
was critical in terms of compressive strength. Compres- As Fig.3 shown, the compressive strength of these
sive strength decreased slightly up to the 30% total re-
+
placement level. Beyond this level, 20% SS 20% UFFA
mixtures (cured under the condition of T20 or T90) rose
along with the increase of the SS/UFA ratio up to a limit.
combination reduced the compressive strength evidently. Beyond the specific value, increasing the SS/UFFA ratio
This is attributed to, at a large extent, the filling effect of would decrease compressive strength slightly. In other
mineral admixtures in cement-based material. According words there is an optimum SS/UFFA ratio giving
to Aim and Goff model[9,10], there is a volume fraction (y*) maximum strength for each mixture. The reason for this
of mineral admixture which furnishes the mixture with a is that appropriate increase of the amount of the middle
maximum packing density. When the volume fraction of particles, namely SS particle, in quadruple cementitious
mineral admixture (SS or UFFA) is less than y*, the
packing density of mixture rises according to the increase
+ + +
materials (C SF SS UFFA) is conducive to the im-
provement of paste density. And when the paste reaches a
of SS or UFFA content and the addition of SS or UFFA higher density, a little more increase of the amount of SS,
reduces both pore sizes and porosity, and therefore the i e, a little decrease of the amount of UFFA, would result
hardened paste strength intensifies. However, once the in decline of the paste density[11]. Thus, the strength of
volume fraction of SS or UFFA attains y*, a little more RPC rises with the increase of the SS/UFFA ratio at the
increase of SS or UFFA would make the packing density beginning, and then drops. Therefore, there is an optimal
of admixture decline obviously and therefore the hard- SS/UFFA ratio when SS and UFFA substitute for ground
ened paste strength drops. Hence, when compound ul- fine quartz sand and partial cement for preparation of RPC
tra-fine admixture is utilized to replace partial cement for and the optimum ratio is about 1.5 in this study.
RPC preparation, there is a proper content fraction of Finally, mixing proportion of F12S18 presented in
ultra-fine admixture. On the other hand, the binary
+
(UFFA SS) replacement (Fig.2) caused similar or
Table 5 had been selected to prepare RPC. Furthermore,
the brass coated steel fibers (2% by volume) were intro-
slightly greater mechanical performance compared with duced into mixture F12S18 in order to improve the duc-
using only SS or UFFA (Fig.1), which demonstrated that
+
UFFA SS combinations had positive effect on com-
tility of RPC. The strength (compression and flexure) of
mixture F12S18 are also shown in Table 5. Compared
pressive strength compared to the UFFA or SS replace- with the reference mixture (SF15), whose cement content
ment alone. The reason is the so called compound filling is 85% or 850 kg/m3, the incorporation of SS and UFFA
effect of mineral admixtures. XIE Youjun et al[11] re- in RPC with the same steel fiber ratio has no significant
ported that utilization of mineral admixtures could ef- strength loss: the compressive and flexural strength of
fectively increase the packing density of cementitious those specimens achieves 188.3 MPa and 32.8 MPa re-
material and when two or three different sized mineral spectively.
admixtures were added in cement, the packing density The results mentioned above indicate that using
would be improved more obviously than that of cemen- UFFA and/or SS in RPC is feasible and the mechanical
titious material when only one was added. The compound performance is impressive. Furthermore, the amount of
filling effect of mineral admixtures (UFFA and SS) in- cement can be decreased markedly which also decreases
creases the packing density of blends and enhances the the heat of hydration, shrinkage and production costs
density of paste at low water/binder ratio, which may with the incorporation of SS and UFFA in RPC.
improve the compressive strength of hardened paste.
Journal of Wuhan University of Technology-Mater. Sci. Ed. Apr.2010 353
The thermogravimetric analysis results of those 3 filling effect of the compound system.
samples are given in Table 6. As given by Table 6, long
heat treatment durations lead to a higher bound-water/ References
total water percentage. At age of 1 d (ie, without heat
treatment durations), the bound-water percentage is [1] Richard P and Cheyrezy M. Composition of Reactive Pow-
35.6% while that reaches 59.8% when the duration is 3d. der Concretes[J]. Cem.Concr.Res., 1995, 25(7): 1501-1511
It is generally considered that, to a certain extent, the [2] Richard P and Cheyrezy M. Reactive Powder Concretes with
bound-water content reflects the relative amount of hy- High Ductility and 200-800 MPa Compressive Strength[J].
dration product (C-S-H gel) in paste. The increase of ACI SP., 1994, 144(24): 507-518
bound-water content demonstrates that more hydration [3] Kejin W, Zhi G. Evaluating Properties of Blended Cements
product forms in cement paste, which definitely improves for Concrete Pavements[R]. Center for Portland Cement
the microstructure and mechanical properties of concrete. Concrete Pavement Technology, Iowa State University, 2003
In addition, the total portlandite content, PT, decreased [4] ZHU Hang. Research on Preparation of Steel Slag and Its
with the heat treatment duration. For durations longer Application in Cement and Concrete[D]. Wuhan: Wuhan
than, or equal to 1d, the content of portlandite remained University of Technology, 2004(in Chinese)
in concrete is less than 1%. This was mainly attributed to [5] LV Linnv, HE Yongjia, DING Qing-jun, et al. Study on
the sequential hydration of the compound cementitious
Super-fine Steel Slag Power Prepare C60 High-performance
system containing SF, SS and UFFA. The sequential hy-
concrete[J]. Concrete, 2004, 6: 51-53 (in Chinese)
dration of the compound system continuously consumed
[6] ZHU Hang, DING Qingjun, PENG Yanzhou, et al. Effect of
portlandite produced by hydration of cement and more hy-
Super-fine Steel Slag Powder on Mechanical Properties of
dration products (C-S-H gel) were formed. Furthermore,
Concrete[J]. Journal of Wuhan University of Technology,
unhydrated powder particles almost evenly filled in cement
2005, 27 (1):40-43 (in Chinese)
paste and enhanced the microstructure of the paste[13]. Thus
[7] Yazici H, Yigiter H, Karabulut A, et al. Utilization of Fly
the microstructure of compound system became increas-
ingly compact (Fig.4), which brought about excellent me- Ash and Ground Granulated Blast Furnace Slag as an Al-
chanical properties of concrete. ternative Silica Source in Reactive Powder Concrete[J]. Fuel,
2008, doi: 10. 1016/j. fuel. 2008. 03. 005
4 Conclusions [8] Connan H, Klimesch D, Ray A, et al. Thermal Characteri-
zation of Autoclaved Cement Made with Alumina-silica
a) Test results indicate that reactive powder concrete Rich Industrial Waste[J]. J. Therm. Anal. Calorimetry, 2006,
containing high volume binary (SF+UFFA or SF+SS) or 84: 521-525
ternary (SF+UFFA+SS) blends have no significant me- [9] Zhang CZ, Wang AQ and Tang MS. The Filling Role of Poz-
chanical performance loss. In other words, utilization of zolanic Material[J]. Cem.Concr.Res.,1996, 26(6): 943-947
UFFA and/or SS in RPC production is feasible and [10] Skalny I. Materials Science of Concrete[M]. The American
UFFA and SS can be used as alternative silica sources. Ceramic Society, USA 1991: 111-147
b) Both the SS or UFFA content and the content ra- [11] XIE Youjun, LIU Baoju, LONG Guangcheng. Study on
tio of SS-to-UFFA have an effect on strength of RPC. Dense Packing Properties of Cementitious Materials[J].
There is an optimum SS/UFFA ratio giving maximum Journal of the Chinese Ceramic Society, 2001, 29 (6):
strength for each mixture and the optimum ratio is 1.5 in 512-517 (in Chinese)
this study. The compressive and flexural strength of RPC
℃
[12] Marcel Cheyrezy, Vincent Maret, Laurent Frouin. Micro-
specimens cured in 90 water for 3 days, whose content of structural Analysis of RPC (Reactive Powder Concrete)[J].
SS, UFFA and SF is 18%, 12% and 15% respectively by Cement and Concrete Research, 1995, 25(7): 1491-1500
weight of binder and ratio of steel fiber is 2% by volume, [13] PENG Yanzhou. Study on Composition, Structure and
are impressive, 188.4 MPa and 32 MPa respectively. Properties of Reactive Powder Concrete Containing Steel
c) The microstructure analysis demonstrated that the Slag Powder [D]. Wuhan:Wuhan University of Technology,
excellent mechanical properties of RPC containing SS
2009 (in Chinese)
and UFFA mainly resulted from the sequential hydration