You are on page 1of 8

Acta Neurol Scand 2011: 124 (Suppl.

191): 23–27  2011 John Wiley & Sons A ⁄ S


ACTA NEUROLOGICA
SCANDINAVICA

Haematological side effects of antiepileptic


drug treatment in patients with epilepsy
Bachmann T, Bertheussen KH, Svalheim S, Rauchenzauner M, Luef G, T. Bachmann1, K. H. Bertheussen1,
Gjerstad L, Taubøll E. Haematological side effects of antiepileptic drug S. Svalheim1, M. Rauchenzauner2,
treatment in patients with epilepsy. G. Luef3, L. Gjerstad1,4, E. Taubøll1,4
Acta Neurol Scand: 2011: 124 (Suppl. 191): 23–27. 1
Department of Neurology, Oslo University Hospital –
 2011 John Wiley & Sons A ⁄ S. Rikshospitalet, Oslo, Norway; 2Department of
Paediatrics IV, Medical University Innsbruck, Innsbruck,
Objectives – Little is known about the haematological side effects of the Austria; 3Department of Neurology, Medical University
newer antiepileptic drugs (AEDs), but recent case reports have raised Innsbruck, Innsbruck, Austria; 4Faculty of Medicine,
concerns regarding the possibility of altered thrombocyte counts or University of Oslo, Oslo, Norway
function in some patients during levetiracetam (LEV) treatment. The
aim of our study was to investigate haematological changes in patients
treated with the newer AEDs, LEV and lamotrigine (LTG), compared
with the older AEDs, valproate (VPA) and carbamazepine (CBZ).
Methods – This cross-sectional study included 251 patients with
epilepsy of both genders, aged 18–45 years, using AED monotherapy:
52 patients on LEV (31 men, 21 women), 80 on LTG (37 men, 43
women), 90 on CBZ (61 men, 29 women), 29 on VPA (15 men, 14
women), and 79 healthy controls (36 men, 43 women). Haemoglobin
(Hb), white blood cells (WBC) and platelet (thrombocyte) counts were
estimated. The subjects were recruited from hospitals in south-eastern Key words: carbamazepine; haematology;
Norway and Innsbruck, Austria. Results – Significantly lower platelet haemoglobin; lamotrigine; leucocytes; levetiracetam;
counts were recorded in both men and women on LEV monotherapy. thrombocytes; valproate
In the LEV group, platelets were 14% lower (40.68 · 109 ⁄ l lower) than K. H. Bertheussen, Department of Neurology, Oslo
in the control group. There was no difference according to sex or age of University Hospital – Rikshospitalet, 0027 Oslo, Norway
the patients. Only minor changes in haematological parameters were Tel.: +4741566423
observed for the other drugs investigated. Conclusions – Both men and Fax: +4723074891
women treated with LEV monotherapy have lower blood platelet e-mail: bachmann_tanja@hotmail.com
counts than healthy controls, with no difference in Hb or WBC.
Haematological changes observed with the other AEDs were minor. Accepted for publication April 10, 2011

reported in which patients develop changes in


Introduction
thrombocyte count and function during LEV
Antiepileptic drugs (AEDs) are the cornerstone of treatment (2, 4–6).
epilepsy treatment. The goals of treatment are So far, the effect of LEV on thrombocyte count
freedom from seizures, no side effects and a good has not been investigated in larger cross-sectional
quality of life for the patient. However, AEDs are or prospective studies. Recently, Sahaya et al.
known to cause a wide range of adverse effects, (2010) reviewed medical records of 758 patients,
including haematological changes. These have been aged 18 years or older, who received LEV during
well described for the older AEDs, but clinical their stay in a university hospital. In patients with
experience for the more recent AEDs is currently thrombocytopenia (29 patients) medical records
insufficient to draw robust conclusions. were examined to identify possible causes. For
Levetiracetam (LEV) is a relatively new, broad- most cases, alternative causes were identified, but
spectrum AED that has seen extensive use during in one patient, a clear association between throm-
recent years (1). Its mechanism of action is not bocytopenia and LEV therapy was found (7).
completely known, but differs from those of other Few haematological changes have been
AEDs. LEV is described as being well tolerated (2), described during lamotrigine (LTG) treatment.
and the most common adverse effects are generally When these changes have been observed, concom-
mild (3). Nevertheless, several cases have been itant AEDs or other medication, high LTG doses,

23
Bachmann et al.

or rapid dose escalation have been considered to be Department of Neurology of the University Hos-
contributory (8). pital Innsbruck, Austria. The control group was
Valproic acid (VPA) can cause several haema- recruited among hospital staff, students and people
tological changes. Onset and severity may vary, but living in close proximity to the hospitals. Pregnant
haematological adverse effects normally occur women and subjects with concomitant treatment,
when VPA serum levels are high and can be including warfarin or oral contraception, were
reversed by reducing the VPA dose. The most excluded from this study, as were severely mentally
common change is thrombocytopenia, which most retarded patients. The control group used no med-
often is mild and transient (9, 10). VPA can also ications at the time the blood samples were drawn,
affect the bone marrow directly and cause cytope- had never used AEDs or had any epileptic seizures.
nia in one or more cell lines (11).
Carbamazepine (CBZ) is known to cause a
Statistics
transient reduction in white blood cells (WBC)
during the first 3 months of treatment (12). In only Data are presented as means and standard devia-
2% of cases, the leucocytopenia persists until CBZ tions (SD). Statistical analysis was performed using
discontinuation (13). It has also been shown that Statistical Package for Social Sciences for Win-
CBZ can cause thrombocytopenia (13, 14), and dows (version 16.0; SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA).
some cases have shown clinical symptoms such as Data were normally distributed. Independent
petechiae and bleeding tendency. The most haz- sample t-tests were used for the analyses of
ardous and potentially lethal adverse effect is CBZ- continuous data, comparing treatment groups
induced aplastic anaemia. (12, 13). There is no with controls. A two-sided P £ 0.05 was consid-
known association between dosage, duration of ered statistically significant.
CBZ use or patient age (12, 14).
The aim of our study was to investigate haema-
tological changes, especially the possible occur- Results
rence of thrombocytopenia, in patients using the Thrombocytes
more recently developed AEDs, LEV and LTG.
Additionally, we investigated whether the haema- Significantly lower thrombocyte levels were mea-
tological side effects of the older AEDs, VPA and sured in all patients taking LEV compared with
CBZ, which have previously been reported, controls (240.0 vs 280.7 · 109 ⁄ l; P-value < 0.001)
occurred in our population of patients with (Table 1). The difference was also significant if the
epilepsy. results from the men and women were analysed
separately (P-values; women 0.008, men 0.015).
Among patients on LEV monotherapy, mean
Materials and methods thrombocyte levels were 14.5% lower (40.7 ·
This cross-sectional study included 251 patients 109 ⁄ l lower) than in the control group. For
with epilepsy (women ⁄ men: 107 ⁄ 144) and 79 con- women, the mean reduction in platelets was
trols (women ⁄ men: 43 ⁄ 36). The patients were 12.5%, whereas the average reduction among
treated with LEV (n = 52; women ⁄ men: 21 ⁄ 31), men was 14.4%. There were no changes in throm-
LTG (n = 80; women ⁄ men: 43 ⁄ 37), VPA (n = 29; bocyte levels for patients using LTG, VPA or CBZ
women ⁄ men: 14 ⁄ 15) or CBZ (n = 90; women ⁄ compared with the control group.
men: 29 ⁄ 61) in monotherapy for at least 6 months.
Morning blood samples were drawn before AED Leucocytes (WBC)
doses. In women, blood samples were taken 5–
7 days after their last menstrual period (follicular There was a small, but statistically significant,
phase).Haematological parameters, Hb, WBC and increase in WBC counts in women on either LEV
thrombocyte counts, were measured in the patients (P = 0.017), LTG (P = 0.006), VPA (P = 0.030)
using AEDs, and the results were compared with or CBZ (P = 0.039) compared with controls
corresponding measurements from healthy con- (Table 2). For men alone, and for women and
trols. men together, no increase could be identified.
The participants were aged between 18 and
45 years (mean age 31.5 years;, SD = 8.397) with
Haemoglobin (Hb)
no differences in age between the four study groups
(patients treated with either LEV, LTG or CBZ or Hb was slightly, but significantly, higher in women
controls) or sexes and were recruited from hospi- using LEV (P = 0.011) and lower in men taking
tals in the south-eastern part of Norway and the CBZ (P = 0.034) compared with that in controls

24
Haematological side effects of AEDs

Table 1 Effects of antiepileptic drugs on thrombocyte counts (measured as number in the LEV group was 240 · 109 plate-
109 ⁄ l)
lets ⁄ l, which is well above the level at which an
increased bleeding tendency might be anticipated
Mean SD 95% CI P-value Range
in otherwise healthy patients, a decrease in platelets
Levetiracetam may turn out to be clinically significant in certain
Women 253.7 49.7 10.2, 62.7 0.008 167–361 cases. For example, this decrease could be of
Men 230.7 65.6 7.8, 69.7 0.015 126–407
All 240.0 50.3 20.2, 61.2 0.000 126–407
clinical significance in patients who are using
Lamotrigine additional medications, as well as LEV, which
Women 282.2 79.7 )20.6, 61.2 0.597 92–500 might affect the platelets and ⁄ or the blood clotting
Men 261.1 45.1 )16.5, 33.4 0.503 159–379 system (i.e. Warfarin, non-steroidal anti-inflamma-
All 272.6 66.5 )10.9, 27.0 0.402 92–500
tory drugs or selective seretonin reuptake inhibi-
Valproate
Women 266.6 70.7 )19.1, 66.1 0.261 136–411 tors) (15). As the use of concomitant medications
Men 270.0 69.1 )42.9, 41.7 0.976 128–388 increases with age and our population was an
All 268.4 68.7 )16.2, 40.8 0.389 128–411 otherwise healthy population aged 18–45 years, we
Carbamazepine recommend that this study should be extended to
Women 279.7 98.7 )29.5, 50.2 0.602 177–605
Men 258.4 71.7 )16.0, 38.1 0.420 58–559
include elderly people and patients with polyphar-
All 265.3 81.4 )5.4, 36.1 0.145 58–605 macy. It could also be interesting to know the
Controls levels of haematological parameters in patients
Women 290.1 60.3 N ⁄A N ⁄A 204–384 with epilepsy who are not taking any AEDs or
Men 269.5 46.6 N ⁄A N ⁄A 151–376
All 280.7 53.9 N ⁄A N ⁄A 151–384
other medications, to evaluate whether the changes
in Hb, WBC or tbc might be associated with the
N ⁄ A, not applicable. P-values are from comparison with controls. disease itself. However, this comparison may not
be valid because patients taking no AEDs at all are
normally far healthier than those needing contin-
Table 2 Effects of antiepileptic drugs on white blood cell counts (measured as
109 ⁄ l) uous AED treatment to control seizure frequency.
There is to our knowledge no discrepancy in Hb,
Mean SD 95% CI P-value Range WBC or tbc levels between patients with epilepsy
before commencing AED treatment and otherwise
Levetiracetam
Women 6.5 1.8 )2.1, )0.2 0.017 3.4–10.8
healthy persons, and haematological changes are
Men 6.1 1.8 )0.8, 0.9 0.847 3.7–12.5 observed immediately after start of AED treatment
All 6.3 1.8 )1.2, 0.1 0.081 3.4–12.5 (12). It is therefore no reason to believe that the
Lamotrigine epilepsy itself affects haematological parameters,
Women 6.4 2.0 )1.9, )0.3 0.006 3.7–12.1
although it cannot be excluded.
Men 6.3 2.7 )1.2, 0.9 0.834 3.4–14.5
All 6.4 2.3 )1.3, )0.0 0.046 3.4–14.5
Valproate Table 3 Effects of antiepileptic drugs on haemoglobin concentrations (Hb)
Women 6.9 2.4 )3.0, )0.2 0.030 2.7–11.1 (measured as g ⁄ 100 ml)
Men 6.1 1.9 )1.1, 1.2 0.878 4.0–11.3
All 6.5 2.1 )1.7, 0.1 0.079 2.7–11.3 Mean SD 95% CI P-value Range
Carbamazepine
Women 6.3 2.2 )2.0, )0.1 0.039 3.6–11.5 Levetiracetam
Men 5.8 1.6 )0.2, 1.2 0.174 2.5–10.5 Women 13.9 0.9 )1.1, )0.2 0.011 11.7–15.6
All 5.9 1.8 )0.1, 0.3 0.435 2.5–11.5 Men 15.3 1.0 )0.4, 0.5 0.847 12.9–17.0
Controls All 14.8 1.2 )1.0, )0.1 0.024 11.7–17.0
Women 5.3 1.5 N ⁄A N ⁄A 3.0–10.2 Lamotrigine
Men 6.6 1.7 N ⁄A N ⁄A 3.4–10.2 Women 13.4 1.5 )0.7, 0.4 0.557 6.7–15.5
All 5.7 1.6 N ⁄A N ⁄A 3.0–10.2 Men 15.1 0.9 )0.1, 0.8 0.145 12.6–17.3
All 14.2 1.5 )0.4, 0.5 0.806 6.7–17.3
N ⁄ A, not applicable. P-values are from comparison with controls. Valproate
Women 13.1 1.0 )0.5, 0.7 0.663 10.5–14.3
Men 14.8 1.6 )0.1, 1.3 0.110 10.3–17.1
(Table 3). There were no other statistically signif- All 14.0 1.6 )0.4, 0.9 0.496 10.3–17.1
icant changes in Hb for the other AEDs. Carbamazepine
Women 13.5 0.7 )0.6, 0.1 0.149 12.5–15.6
Men 15.0 0.9 0.0, 0.8 0.034 11.9–17.4
Discussion All 14.5 1.1 )0.7, 0.1 0.146 11.9–17.4
Controls
The most important finding of our study was that Women 13.2 0.8 N ⁄A N ⁄A 11.6–14.5
Men 15.4 1.0 N ⁄A N ⁄A 13.3–17.2
blood platelet counts were significantly lower in
All 14.2 1.4 N ⁄A N ⁄A 11.6–17.2
patients treated with LEV compared with those in
healthy controls. Although the mean platelet N ⁄ A, not applicable. P-values are from comparison with controls.

25
Bachmann et al.

Lower platelet counts could also be clinically determined in detail, but it is known that LEV binds
important in patients with low pretreatment plate- to SV2A vesicle proteins, which are widely distrib-
let numbers or with other haematological diseases. uted throughout the CNS and also in endocrine cells
A further reduction in platelet count might result (19). To date, no information on a possible throm-
in a critically low thrombocyte level, below which bocyte expression of SV2A vesicle protein is avail-
the patient develops clinical symptoms with a able. But if so, this could be a possible mechanism
tendency to bleeding. by which LEV affects thrombocytes. Another
In addition, it is important to emphasise that in possibility was proposed by Sahaya et al. (2010),
some patients, the reduction in platelet number will who speculated that there could be an immune-
be greater than the mean decrease of 40 · 109 mediated pathogenesis, based on a few recent cases
platelets ⁄ l. Although this was not found in this of LEV-induced thrombocytopenia in immune-
study of otherwise healthy young adults, it would competent patients (i.e. patients not taking immu-
concur with previous reports (16, 17). For individ- nomodifying drugs or having immunocompromiz-
ual patients with low pretreatment platelet counts, ing illnesses) and also a case report of LEV-induced
a greater than average reduction in thrombocytes thrombocytopenia in an immunocompromised
may lead to clinically significant bleeding. individual. However, this theory currently has no
It should be noted that not only the total further support in the literature.
number of platelets might be affected by the Other statistically significant findings in this
drug, but also their function. In one case report study were small and therefore considered to be
(6), a woman developed ecchymoses and prolonged without clinical significance. They comprise a
bleeding time directly after starting LEV treatment, decrease in Hb for men using CBZ and an increase
and this persisted until discontinuation of the drug in women on LEV. It also includes increased
13 months later. She did not use any other med- leucocytes in women using either of LEV, LTG,
ication, had no known haematological disorder VPA or CBZ. Such findings have not previously
herself or in her family, and apart from the been reported. We also did not identify the
prolonged bleeding, all her haematological param- haematological changes previously described for
eters were normal (including thrombocyte counts, older AEDs. This could be attributed to the fact
clotting factors and von Willebrand factor) (6). that one of the inclusion criteria for the study was
The authors concluded that the ecchymoses and monotherapy for at least 6 months. Patients who
prolonged bleeding time were probably caused by might have experienced haematological adverse
LEV-induced thrombocytopathia (normal number, effects within the first 6 months of use (which is
but altered function of the thrombocytes). often the case) would probably have discontinued
Levetiracetam is usually relatively well tolerated, the treatment and hence would not have been
and the use of the drug is increasing (1, 18). The included in this study. This result may also reflect
concentrations used have been fairly low. In properties of the study population.
Norway, the therapeutic drug level has been 30– Additionally, platelet reduction as a major
130 lm until recently, but this has now been adverse effect in patients treated with VPA (9)
increased to 40–240 lm. In our study, mean was not identified in the current study. This may be
serum concentrations based on a subset of the because a decrease in thrombocytes on VPA
patients were 43.3 lm in women and 58.1 lm in treatment seems to occur mainly when serum
men. Higher concentrations might increase the risk levels exceed 700 lm in women and 900 lm in
of adverse effects, but clinical experience with such men (16). In addition, only patients on long-term
adverse effects is so far derived mainly from VPA treatment were included in the present study;
patients taking the drug according to earlier patients who develop lower platelet counts after
recommendations. Unfortunately, our data did starting VPA treatment would probably have
not allow a further analysis of the relation between discontinued the treatment long before eligibility
LEV concentrations and haematological changes. for the study, which included only chronically-
If LEV is going to be used in higher concentrations treated VPA patients.
in the future, and possibly also more frequently In conclusion, haematological side effects may
intravenously in treatment of status epilepticus (1), occur in patients with epilepsy using the newer
it is important that its effects on platelet number AEDs. LEV seems to have an effect on thrombo-
and function are investigated more thoroughly in cyte counts and perhaps on their function also.
these situations. Further investigations are needed with regard to
There is no information on the mechanism by the clinical implications of this observation in
which LEV might affect thrombocyte count or selected patient groups, especially elderly people
function. The mode of action of LEV has not been and patients using polypharmacy.

26
Haematological side effects of AEDs

Acknowledgments lamotrigine use in a patient. Epileptic Disord 2005;7:33–


5.
The first two authors have contributed equally to this article. 9. Allan RW. Myelodysplastic syndrome associated with
We thank GlaxoSmithKline, USA, for supporting the study chronic valproic acid therapy: a case report and review of
with an investigator-initiated grant. the literature. Hematology 2007;12:493–6.
10. Acharya S, Bussel J. Hematologic toxicity of Sodium
Valproate. J Pediatr Hematol Oncol 2000;22:62–5.
Conflict of interest 11. Handoko KB, Souverein PC, Van Staa TP et al. Risk of
This study was supported by an unrestricted research grant aplastic anemia in patients using antiepileptic drugs. Epi-
from GlaxoSmithKline, USA. lepsia 2006;47:1232–6.
12. Harden CL. Therapeutic safety monitoring-what to look
for and when to look for it. Epilepsia 2000;41:37–44.
References 13. Hart RG, Easton JD. Carbamazepine and hematological
monitoring. Ann Neurol 1982;11:309–12.
1. Crepeau AZ, Treiman DM. Levetiracetam: a comprehensive 14. Sobotka JL, Alexander B, Cook BL. A review of Carba-
review. Expert Rev Neurother 2010;10:159–71. mazepine‘s hematologic reactions and monitoring recom-
2. Kimland E, Höjeberg B, Von Euler M. Levetiracetam in- mendations. DICP 1990;24:1214–9.
duced thrombocytopenia. Epilepsia 2004;45:877–8. 15. Patsalos PN, Fröscher W, Pisani F, Van Rijn CM. The
3. Ben-Menachem E. Levetiracetam: treatment in epilepsy. importance of drug interactions in epilepsy therapy. Epi-
Expert Opin Pharmacother 2003;4:2079–88. lepsia 2002;43:365–85.
4. Meschede A, Runge U, Sabolek M. Thrombocytopenia 16. Nasreddine W, Beydoun A. Valproate-induced thrombocy-
during levetiracetam therapy. Epilepsy Res 2008;80:91–2. topenia: a prospective monotherapy study. Epilepsia
5. Hartmann H, Schumacher U, Seeck M. Verschlechterung 2008;49:438–45.
einer Immunthrombopenie unter Monotherapie mit Lev- 17. Tohen M, Castillo J, Cole JO, Miller MG, De Los
etiracetam. Akt Neurol 2002;29:467–8. HEROS R, Farrer RJ. Thrombocytopenia associated with
6. Herrman H, Taubøll E, Gjerstad L Levetiracetam-induced carbamazepine: a case series. J Clin Psychiatry
thrombocytopathia. American Epilepsy Society Meeting, 1991;52:496–8.
San Diego, 2006. http://www.aesnet.org/go/publications/ 18. Bauer J, Ben-Menachem E, Krämer G, Fryze W, Da Silva
aes-abstracts/abstract-search/mode/display/st/herrman%20/ S, Kasteleijn-Nolst Trenité DG. Levetiracetam: a long-
sy/2006/sb/All/id/6556 term follow-up study of efficacy and safety. Acta Neurol
7. Sahaya K, Goyal MK, Sarwal A, Singh NN. Levetirace- Scand 2006;114:169–76.
tam-induced thrombocytopenia among inpatients: a ret- 19. Lynch BA, Lambeng N, Nocka K et al. The synaptic vesicle
rospective study. Epilepsia 2010;51:2492–5. protein SV2A is the binding site for the antiepileptic drug
8. Ural AU, Avcu F, Gökcil Z, Nevruz O, Cetin T. Leu- levetiracetam. Proc Natl Acad Sci 2004;101:9861–6.
copenia and thrombocytopenia possible associated with

27
Copyright of Acta Neurologica Scandinavica is the property of Wiley-Blackwell and its content may not be
copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written
permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.
Copyright of Acta Neurologica Scandinavica is the property of Wiley-Blackwell and its content may not be
copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written
permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.
Copyright of Acta Neurologica Scandinavica. Supplementum is the property of Wiley-
Blackwell and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv
without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print,
download, or email articles for individual use.

You might also like