The document provides a recommendation and plan to transition Chester's learning management system from PowerSchool to Canvas. It includes an evaluation of Canvas, Blackboard, and Moodle that found Canvas to be the best option. A needs analysis was conducted through surveys and focus groups. The justification for Canvas cites its comprehensive feature set. A training plan was created with tiered trainings for students, instructors, and administrators to help with the transition.
The document provides a recommendation and plan to transition Chester's learning management system from PowerSchool to Canvas. It includes an evaluation of Canvas, Blackboard, and Moodle that found Canvas to be the best option. A needs analysis was conducted through surveys and focus groups. The justification for Canvas cites its comprehensive feature set. A training plan was created with tiered trainings for students, instructors, and administrators to help with the transition.
The document provides a recommendation and plan to transition Chester's learning management system from PowerSchool to Canvas. It includes an evaluation of Canvas, Blackboard, and Moodle that found Canvas to be the best option. A needs analysis was conducted through surveys and focus groups. The justification for Canvas cites its comprehensive feature set. A training plan was created with tiered trainings for students, instructors, and administrators to help with the transition.
01 Our Evaluation of Multiple 02 Planning our needs Learning Management analysis Systems
Why Canvas? Training
03 Justification for Canvas 04 Plan for training Students, Instructors, and Administration 01 Evaluation Comparing Systems
We began by analyzing three of
the biggest Learning Management Systems: ● Blackboard ● Canvas ● Moodle Feature Analysis We analyzed each of the system’s features using a spreadsheet, and wrote a narrative of our findings.
Our major takeaways were:
● Canvas does not have a blog feature, and Blackboard does not have Live-text chat.
● All other features were present in
each system, though there were differences in presentation- particularly with Moodle. 02 Needs Analysis ● Distributing the survey for your Needs Analysis: ○ Meetings with focus group of constituents, then digital survey will be distributed via email ● Organizing and prioritizing the Data collected: ○ Referencing Google Sheets data to determine trends ○ Trends and common responses among constituent groups organized as priorities ● Collecting additional stakeholder needs: ○ Separate Meetings: one-on-one, just teachers, just administrators, etc. ○ More specialized surveys for each group could be drafted to determine more specific priorities 03 Why Canvas? Justification for recommending Canvas You can have it all: You can send emails and announcements Create: Discussion Boards, and Assignments Setup: Notifications, Calendar Features, Web Conferences Monitor: Gradebooks, Reports and Performance Dashboards Control: Accessibility Features, Navigation and Control Panels Menus Maintain: Security Updates, Archive and Copy Courses Limitations associated with Canvas Some limitations:
● Does not provide an option to Blog
● File storage has limitations (1G per course) ● Limitations exporting content with other systems 04 Training Plan Our Plan
Tier 1 Tier 2 Tier 3
The most basic More specialized The most specialized information- general information, but would information that may overviews for all users still benefit most users. not apply to all users or based on their role. Skills within the LMS. situations. Student Tiers Tier 1: Tier 2: Tier 3: Basics for Moderate Skills Specialized Students Information Delivery: Screencast Delivery: Screencast Delivery: Screencast Topics: and Written Tutorials and Written Tutorials General Overview of Topics: Topics: the Canvas interface Completing/Submitting Incorporating external from the student Assignments, Checking tools/softwares, perspective. Instructor Feedback. accessibility. Instructor Tiers
Tier 1: Tier 2: Tier 3:
Basics for Moderate Skills Specialized Instructors information Delivery: Screencast Delivery: Screencast/ Delivery: Screencast/ Topics: Written Tutorials Written Tutorials General Overview from Topics: Topics: Instructor perspective. Creating, managing and Viewing data reports, Accessing Courses, grading assignments video lectures, other Gradebook, etc. within the LMS, using external softwares that SpeedGrader. may not apply to all instructors. System Administrator Tiers
Tier 1: Tier 2: Tier 3:
Basics for System Moderate Skills Specialized Administrators Information Delivery: Workshop + Delivery: Workshop + Delivery: Workshop + Tutorials Tutorials Tutorials Topics: Running Topics: data reports, Topics: General Reports, creating and integrating systems, and Overview of the managing student installing external tools, system + accessing and instructor monitoring updates and administrative profiles, managing security features, features like security. courses. providing training to others. Chester has a 1:1 technology initiative that has helped engage students and teach them necessary 21st Century Skills. The school currently uses Power School as its LMS.
Exposing the school to a more modern LMS such as Canvas
could be beneficial because it is also used by many other surrounding school districts that border Chester County.