You are on page 1of 15

Research Manuscript

Health Environments Research


& Design Journal
1-15
Architectural Design Qualities ª The Author(s) 2023

of an Adolescent Psychiatric Article reuse guidelines:


sagepub.com/journals-permissions
Hospital to Benefit Patients DOI: 10.1177/19375867231180907
journals.sagepub.com/home/her
and Staff

Neda Norouzi, PhD1 , Antonio Martinez, M. Arch1,


and Zayra Rico, M. Arch1

Abstract
Objectives: This study is focused on how architectural design of adolescent psychiatric hospitals
could positively affect not only patients but also staff members working at the hospitals. Background:
Adolescents between the ages of 12 and 18 are among the young population with the highest per-
centage of mental illness. However, there are limited number of intentionally designed psychiatric
hospitals for adolescents. Staff who work in adolescent psychiatric hospitals may face workplace
violence. Studies on environmental impacts suggest that the built environment affects patients’ well-
being and safety as well as staff’s satisfaction, working condition, safety, and health. However, there are
very few studies that focus on adolescent psychiatric hospitals and the impact of the built environment
on both staff and patients. Methods: Data were collected through literature analysis and semi-
structured interviews with staff of three psychiatric state hospitals with adolescent patient units.
The triangulation of multiple data sources informed a set of environmental design conditions that
captures the complexity and connectedness of architectural design and the occupants of an adolescent
psychiatric hospital. Results: The results present architectural composition, atmosphere, lighting,
natural environment, safety, and security as indispensable design conditions to create an enclosed and
city-like campus that provides a serene, secure, and structured environment that benefit staff and
adolescent patients. Conclusion: The specific design strategies that need to be incorporated in the
architectural design of a safe and secure adolescent psychiatric hospital include an open floor plan that
respects patients’ autonomy and offers privacy while always providing staff with full visibility of patients.

Keywords
architecture, adolescent patients, psychiatric hospital, environmental design, evidence-based design,
mental health

Introduction 1
Department of Architecture, University of Texas at San
Adolescents between the ages of 12 and 18 are Antonio, TX, USA
among the young population with the highest per-
centage of mental illness (McGorry et al., 2013). Corresponding Author:
Neda Norouzi, PhD, School of Architecture + Planing, University
However, only 20% of the 15 million American of Texas at San Antonio, 501 W. César E. Chávez Blvd., San
adolescents with mental illness receive care with Antonio, TX 78207, USA.
less than half of them receiving proper treatment Email: neda.norouzi@utsa.edu
2 Health Environments Research & Design Journal XX(X)

(Jones, 2019). One of the main challenges con- To our knowledge, there are no articles focused
tributing to the limited services is the inadequate on the impact of the built environment on both
design of adolescent psychiatric hospitals staff and patients. To bridge this gap, the authors
(McGorry et al., 2013). The impact of the built of this study analyzed existing scholarly articles
environment on patients’ mental health was first and conducted interviews at three different state
studied in the 1950s (Evans, 2003). Today, after hospitals with adolescent patient units. Partici-
almost a century, there is still limited information pants’ responses to interviewer prompts high-
focused on the cultural and developmental needs lighted specific architectural categories that
of adolescent psychiatric patients from the built can be applied to designing adolescent psychia-
environment (McGorry et al., 2013). This study tric hospitals.
focuses on improving adolescent psychiatric hos-
pital design in a way that directly responds to
their needs. Method
There are major differences between the needs This study investigates the influence of the built
of adolescent and children or adults in a psychia- environment on the health and well-being of ado-
tric hospital. Although individuals under the age lescent patients and staff of adolescent psychia-
of 18 are considered children and may all share tric hospitals. The first author responded to a
the need of parental support, adolescents require request for proposal from one of the hospitals for
more control and peer socialization (Borg-Laufs, which she received funding. All procedures were
2013). While previous studies have proven the approved by an institutional review board (IRB).
impact of the built environment of a psychiatric The site selection began by a web search to iden-
hospital on patients’ positive interactions and tify state psychiatric hospitals that have an ado-
feeling of control and safety, there is a lack of lescent program. The first author then emailed an
focus on designing adolescent-specific psychia- invitation to the superintendent of eight hospitals
tric hospitals. This has led to many adolescents and asked for their participation. Five hospitals
getting admitted to adult or children’s units responded, three of which got approval from their
(Blumberg & Devlin, 2006; Hutton, 2005). review boards to participate in the study. These
In a psychiatric hospital, adolescents spend hospitals (Hospitals A, B, and C) are in urban
most of their time in a patient unit under strict setting of different states.
supervision by staff (Chun et al., 2016).
Although this strict supervision is necessary for
patients’ safety, it often leads to aggression and Data Collection
severely disruptive behavior (Hallman et al., The data collection for this article was conducted
2014) toward the staff member working at the through two phases of (1) literature analyzing and
hospital. Staff who work in adolescent psychia- (2) interviews. The research team searched for
tric hospitals may face multiple forms of hosti- articles published between 2000 and 2020 in the
lity, aggression, and assault, collectively databases of PubMed, PsycINFO, ScienceDirect,
referred to as workplace violence that is often Wiley Online Library, and Cambridge Core. The
triggered by patients (Hallman et al., 2014; key words included architecture of psychiatric
Ulrich et al., 2018). Studies on environmental hospitals, adolescent psychiatric hospitals, the
impacts suggest that the built environment built environment, architecture, interior design,
affects patients’ well-being and safety as well environmental design, and hospital design. The
as staff’s satisfaction, working condition, safety, article elimination process was first through the
and health (Sheehan et al., 2013; Trzpuc et al., title, followed by the relevancy of the abstract,
2016). However, most previously published arti- and finalized by the review of the full manuscript.
cles are either focused only on adolescent psy- The result was 62 articles of which 22 were ana-
chiatric hospitals (Hutton, 2005; Gubbels et al., lyzed in-depth. Studies were included if they
2016) or staff members working in these hospi- were (1) peer-reviewed and published in English,
tals (Duque et al., 2020; Hallman et al., 2014). (2) reported design aspects of the hospital
Norouzi et al. 3

environment, and (3) explored the impact of the Qualitative interviews were recorded using
built environment on patients or staff. After an iPad and transcribed verbatim by the authors
potential studies were selected, the authors read into a word document. After the first author read
and analyzed the articles individually to create a and de-identified the transcriptions, each author
list of identified design qualities. analyzed the transcriptions using a grounded
Interviews included questions about the par- theory approach that included line-by-line cod-
ticipants’ use of the built environment; their ing, axial coding, and comparative theoretical
needs from different sections of the hospital; coding (Glaser, 1992). The authors first assigned
and the impact of the environment on well- a code to each relevant line of the transcriptions
being, safety, and productivity of patients and to identify ideas, thoughts, feelings, and issues
staff. After the site selection and IRB approval mentioned by respondents (Charmaz, 2008). The
from the hospital, the first author emailed each codes were then sorted and compared across the
hospital’s superintendent and used snowballing responses to draw connections between created
techniques to identify and contact other partici- codes. This axial coding formulated categories
pants. This technique is commonly used in qua- of the codes that are most responsive to this
litative research and requires a key participant study’s research question and trimmed away
to identify and contact other participants (Daly, excess codes. The next phase was comparative
2007). The interviewees of this study include theoretical coding (Halberg, 2006) among the
administrators, adolescent psychologist and sets of data collected from the three different
psychiatrist, nurses, therapists, and peer sup- hospitals. This process led to systematic connec-
port personnel. Sixty-nine individuals were tion and contextual arrangement of the cate-
interviewed as part of the larger study. For this gories. The results were initially coded and
analysis, only individuals who had daily inter- categorized by each author and then combined,
action with adolescent patients were included in checked, modified, and verified to achieve 100%
analysis (n ¼ 30). Each interview lasted agreement by all authors.
between 30 and 45 min. Adolescent patients
were not interviewed for this study. The inter-
views collected qualitative data focused on atti-
tudes toward the existing environment,
Results and Discussion
perception of safety and support, patient inter- The findings of literature analysis triangulated
action and recovery plans, and staff’s need for and juxtaposed with the results of the interview
rejuvenation and recovery. analysis informed a set of environmental design
conditions that captures the complexity and con-
nectedness of architectural design and the occu-
Data Analysis pants of an adolescent psychiatric hospital.
To establish and ensure the validity of study Colligating the data revealed a relationship
findings, the authors triangulated multiple data between the built environment and the success
sources of literature and interviews that led to of an adolescent psychiatric hospital. Findings
the development of a comprehensive under- suggest adolescent psychiatric hospitals must
standing of the findings. The analysis of the lit- offer safe and welcoming environments that sup-
erature was based on the narrative synthesis port patients’ healing and recovery as well as
method (Popay et al., 2006) with a preliminary staff’s satisfaction. In this study, the environmen-
synthesis done individually by each author to tal conditions of the hospital are divided to spe-
identify and create a list of design qualities. The cific needs of patients and staff. Table 1 presents
results were then combined, checked, modified, all categories that emerged from the data, how
and verified to achieve 100% agreement by all each category is defined in this study for adoles-
authors. Decisions of which themes should be cent patients and staff, and several subcategories
included were based on this study’s research that were developed through constant compara-
question. tive techniques.
4 Health Environments Research & Design Journal XX(X)

Table 1. Environmental Design Conditions.

Design Description (Environmental


Condition Qualities) Subcategories (Specific Design Strategies)

Architectural Adolescent Patients: A built environment  Accessibility (campus layout that avoids long
composition that offers patients freedom of distances to any patient services)
movement between spaces of different  Adjacency (visual and auditory access to various
sizes and affords different types of parts of the unit—avoid blind spots)
interactions  Efficiency (campus and interior spatial layout
Staff: A built environment that that emphasize workflow circulation)
promotes spatial efficiency for  Interior layout (physical features arranged to
emergency responses; a satisfactory support various aspects of social interaction—
workplace that offers social avoid overcrowding)
connection or separation to increase  Versatile (multipurpose spaces that can be used
productivity for different activities and easily changed by a
single user; Nanda et al., 2019)
 Wayfinding (physical indicators and spatial
layout that offer ease of movement and
navigation)
Atmosphere Adolescent Patients: A home-like  Acoustics (architectural features that transfer
rehabilitating environment that pleasant sounds and prevents negative noise for
provides patients with multiple spaces patients, as well as provides quiet spaces for
for different sensorial experiences and staff’s productivity)
the choice of which space to be in and  Autonomy (respect patients’ privacy; offer both
for how long individual and shared bedrooms)
Staff: A stress-free, aesthetically  Perception (consider subjectivity and the
pleasing work environment that influence of color and material on patients’
enhances staff well-being, satisfaction, state of mind and behavior)
and performance  Respite (private break areas that affords staff
stress reduction)
Lighting Adolescent Patients: A built environment  Artificial lighting (noninstitutional lighting
that integrates both artificial and enhances safety, supports functional tasks, and
natural lighting to improve physical and provides a pleasant work environment)
emotional well-being which results in  Natural lighting (direct and indirect natural
an accelerated recovery and regulated lighting impacts circadian rhythm, decreases
sleep cycle aggression, supports less work stress, better
Staff: A built environment that health status, and higher satisfaction; Shepley
integrates both artificial and natural et al., 2017; Ulrich et al., 2018)
lighting to minimize anxiety and stress,
as well as increase workplace
performance
Natural Adolescent Patients: A built environment  Biophilia (architectural design to include
environment with visual and physical access to biophilic design elements such as plants, natural
plants, trees, and animals material, and art for patients and staff)
Staff: Exclusive nature-centric spaces  Courtyard and gardens (outdoor spaces for
for different types of activities recreational activities, gardening, and play)
dedicated to staff
Safety and Adolescent Patients: A safe healing  Boundary (physical and social restriction)
security environment that discourages social  High risk (provide anti-ligature equipment, safe
conflict and prevents self-harm water, and sunlight access)
Staff: A safe working environment to  Visibility (reduce blind spots and maximize
reduce physical assault against staff staff’s line of sight to spaces used by patients)
Norouzi et al. 5

The findings of literature analysis life outside of the hospital,” said one of the psy-
triangulated and juxtaposed with the chologists interviewed for this study.
results of the interview analysis informed
a set of environmental design conditions The architectural composition of an
that captures the complexity and adolescent psychiatric hospital should
connectedness of architectural design and respond to adolescents’ psychological
the occupants of an adolescent psychiatric needs and healing process to prepare
hospital. Colligating the data revealed a them for life outside the hospital.
relationship between the built
environment and the success of an
adolescent psychiatric hospital. Accessibility. The interview results presented that
adolescents’ access to different services is one of
the main concerns in state hospitals. These hos-
Architectural Composition pitals generally serve both adolescents and
adults on the same campus but are required to
The architectural composition of an adolescent keep the two populations completely separated
psychiatric hospital should respond to adoles- for safety and security reasons. Therefore, ado-
cents’ psychological needs and healing process lescent units are built in a separate building and
to prepare them for life outside the hospital. It is
often far away from the adults’ units and the
important to design the hospital in a way that
treatment mall, where the medical and therapeu-
patients can freely and safely move between
tic services are centralized. Funding limitations
spaces, participate in different types of thera-
often lead to building one treatment mall to be
peutic activities, and interact with each other
shared by both populations but placed closer to
and staff (Jovanović et al., 2019; Liddicoat,
adult units due to the higher number of patients.
2019). One of the participants of this study told
A social worker from Hospital A said that “it’s
the interviewer that “it is important to offer ado-
difficult to bring the children [to the treatment
lescents control over their environment and
mall] from all the way on the other end of the
activities [ . . . ] to builds up their self-esteem
and help them make friends.” Some of the major hospital campus,” and the music therapist from
concerns for adolescents with mental illness are the same hospital suggested that adolescents
academic difficulties, low educational achieve- “need to have their own therapy spaces, a music
ment, low employment, social exclusion, and room, art room, physical activities and a gym so
possible homelessness (Preyde et al., 2018). The they can stay active.” The adolescent unit at
director of patients’ rights described an ideal Hospital B was close to the rest of the campus
adolescent psychiatric hospital as a small town and separated only by a courtyard, allowing
where buildings surround a courtyard and there patients to share all campus resources by using
is a residential unit, a school, and a therapy mall them at different times. The director of environ-
that includes various therapy rooms, a movie mental services from this hospital said, “the kids
theater, a pharmacy, a gift store, and a restaurant have their own playground, but all the sports are
to resemble a typical community outside of the shared and that works when we have enough
hospital. This enclosed and city-like campus staff.” While staffing is a challenge that
setting provides a serene, secure, and structured designers do not have control over, they can
environment where adolescents can move on the address campus layout and access to a treatment
path of recovery and benefit from the residential mall. One solution is to build a smaller treatment
setting, academic programming, and recrea- mall with specific programs only for adolescent
tional activities. These components contribute patients, while keeping some of the larger activ-
to the “overall success of the patients’ diagnos- ities such as a basketball court in the main treat-
tic process, treatment plan, and the adolescents’ ment mall for everyone to share.
6 Health Environments Research & Design Journal XX(X)

. . . build a smaller treatment mall with an adolescent psychiatric hospital in a way that
specific programs only for adolescent serves both patients and staff. An open floor plan
patients, while keeping some of the larger is more preferred as it increases face-to-face com-
activities such as a basketball court in the munication, team interaction, and interdisciplin-
main treatment mall for everyone to share. ary collaboration (Jovanović et al., 2019;
Liddicoat, 2019). The nurse manager from Hos-
pital C said, “an open floor plan gives adolescents
Adjacency. Participants expressed the need for the freedom of moving in different spaces while
staff’s visual and audible access to patients from monitored by staff without being told they can or
the nurse station as a necessity of the hospital cannot go somewhere. It is just easier for every-
design. Adjacency of communal spaces with the one.” Adolescents often have difficulties with
nurse stations offers patients an increased feeling interpersonal relationships, social situations,
of freedom and security (Jovanović et al., 2019) managing psychiatric symptoms, stigma, and bul-
which can help adolescents develop indepen- lying (Preyde et al., 2018). A physician at Hospi-
dence, provides a safe space for them to gather tal A talked about the importance of replicating
around (Shepley et al., 2016) to increase oppor- family life and social activity in the community to
tunities for positive interaction, and have a higher encourage positive interactions with peers and
level of connection with staff (Shattell et al., improve adolescent patients’ sense of self-
2008). This also allows staff to monitor patients worth. An adolescent psychologist from Hospital
more closely and offer “comfortable seating for C emphasized on the importance of active and
quiet activities near the nurse stations,” said a passive behaviors for adolescent patients and said
nurse at Hospital A. While staff have varying “there needs to be a place where they can run, be
opinions on open or closed nurse stations, loud, be teenagers. But they also need a place to
“patients mostly prefer open without any barrier practice being calm.” Examples of interior spaces
such as a plexiglass panel,” said one of the activ- that promote active interaction include exercise
ity nurses at Hospital C. A nurse manager of the and play areas for patients to get engaged in pos-
adolescent unit at Hospital B stated “instead of a itive movement and exert physical energy
glass bubble, we have an open desk in front where (Trzpuc et al., 2016) and “supervised woodshop
patients gather to talk, read, or work on a puzzle. to express creativity with hands-on craft” said the
The nurses’ offices are in the back of the hub.” director of vocational services in Hospital A.
Spaces that inspire passive interactions include
Efficiency. To better serve patients, staff need clear a library, a greenhouse, indoor plants, a spiritual
and quick access to different sections of the ado- room (interviewees), quiet rooms, sensory rooms,
lescent unit as well as different buildings of the dayrooms, and patient rooms with front porches
hospital. Circulation and campus planning impact (Shepley et al., 2016). Offering different types of
both functional and psychological aspects of the spaces provide adolescents a variety of privacy
workflow by providing fundamental support to and opportunities to come together, socialize, and
ease the hardship of everyday routines (Jiang, & bond (Hutton, 2005).
Verderber, 2016). It is important to consider the
fastest and safest path for staff to move between Versatility. Versatility is defined as a multipurpose
essential locations for patient care and self-care. space that includes built-ins with multiple uses
Multiple staff members in Hospital A voiced their and can be changed by a single user within min-
concerns about unnecessary distance and wasted utes (Nanda et al., 2019). Flexible spaces provide
time between the adolescent unit and other units options for spatial configuration and cater to a
of the hospital when they need to respond to wide range of social activities for adolescent
emergencies. patients. Participants of this study asked for flex-
ible interior spaces that can offer different activ-
Interior layout. It is important to recognize the ities such as “reading, relaxing, playing games,
appropriate spatial layout and physical spaces of and watching TV” to help adolescents avoid
Norouzi et al. 7

boredom and afford them control over the type of material, texture, and form that influence spatial
activity they want to participate in. The Perfor- intimacy (Zumthor, 2006), privacy, and auton-
mance Program Supervisor of Hospital B omy (Norouzi et al., 2019). It is important to
expressed the need for larger rooms that can be consider the atmosphere of an adolescent psy-
easily divided and used for different therapy ses- chiatric hospital as it enhances staff and patients’
sions at the same time. The music therapist of satisfaction (Jovanović et al., 2019) and well-
Hospital A said “musical instruments are expen- being (Sheehan et al., 2013), increases social
sive, and we cannot afford buying multiple of the engagement (Trzpuc at al., 2016), and reduces
same instrument for different units. So, we need a stress (Ulrich et al., 2018).
versatile space that allows the equipment in the
same place to be used at different times.” There- Acoustics. Sound and noise can range from stress-
fore, it is important to design versatile spaces with ful to soothing and therapeutic and impact staff,
socio-petal furniture arrangements to promote patients, and visitors of a hospital. An appropriate
positive social interaction, decrease isolation acoustic environment benefits staff’s well-being
(Jovanović, 2019), facilitate personal space regu- and patients’ therapy process (Zhou et al., 2020).
lation, and provide occupants control of their However, appropriate acoustic design has not
environment (Shepley et al., 2016; Ulrich et al., been a priority in psychiatric hospitals (Shepley
2018) in adolescent psychiatric hospitals. et al., 2017). Unwanted sounds and noise such as
traffic, trains, airports, and community noise
Wayfinding. The ability for adolescent psychiatric within a hospital unit can hinder staff’s work pro-
patients to successfully navigate through a care ductivity and communication quality with
center is crucial for their daily routine activities. patients while causing psychological distress and
Wayfinding should be recognized as a high pri- helplessness among patients (Shepley et al.,
ority when designing psychiatric hospitals as it 2017; Ulrich et al., 2018). The director of admis-
can be a challenge in large hospital campuses sions in Hospital B said, “we need a quiet ther-
with several buildings that lack distinctive apeutic space as staff break room in each unit so
appearance (Devlin, 2014). Inadequate wayfind- they can relax and unwind but available to
ing and signage can cause aggression or abusive respond to emergencies when needed.” A physi-
behavior among patients (Liddicoat, 2019). The cal therapist from Hospital C said, “the breeze
adolescent psychologist from Hospital A empha- through the trees, birds chirping, and sound of
sized the importance of wayfinding by saying water create a calm environment for patients and
“these are kids, and they have less patience than staff. [ . . . ], there needs to be a way to have plea-
adults [ . . . ] they need to go where they want and sant sound both inside and outside the unit.”
get what they want as quickly as possible.” A Incorporating acoustic floor and ceiling tiles, wall
wayfinding system needs to be a navigable panels, movable partition panels, and solid core
and readable environment (Shepley et al., 2017) doors can mitigate unwanted noise transmissions
and avoid “long corridors, repetitive elements, (Liddicoat, 2019). Providing single bedrooms in
and changes of direction within the circulation adolescent psychiatric hospitals enhances privacy
system” (Devlin, 2014, pp. 425–426). and reduces noise levels from adjacent patient
neighbors (Ulrich et al., 2018). Indoor sensory
rooms can provide opportunities for patients to
Atmosphere listen to music or pleasant nature sounds.
Atmosphere is defined as an emotional reaction to
a specific space and therefore cannot be directly Autonomy. Autonomy, as independence or free-
constructed but emerges from the built environ- dom of choice, is an element often forgotten in
ment and its impact on the occupants (Norouzi, psychiatric hospitals and even more so for ado-
2016). Different architectural characteristics cre- lescents. Respecting patients’ autonomy starts by
ate different atmospheres (Norouzi et al., 2019). providing privacy options. Lack of privacy results
Examples of these characteristics are noise, color, in heightened anxiety levels, stress, and
8 Health Environments Research & Design Journal XX(X)

aggression (Liddicoat, 2019). A way to provide a comfortable place with “bright colors, familiar
privacy is through offering single bedrooms for items from home, a way to listen to music and
patients. Single bedrooms with private bathrooms podcasts, natural light, comfortable flooring, nice
encourage social engagement (Trzpuc et al., variety of indoor plants, and outdoor gardens.”
2016); offers therapeutic security and comfort, However, the concept of comfort was not defined
expression of ownership, opportunity to persona- by any of the participants.
lize and decorate the space (Shepley et al., 2017), Another controversial subject related to per-
and freedom to withdraw when feeling unwell ception is color. A music therapist interviewed
(Jovanović et al., 2019); and improve the dignity for this study, said “bright colors could be very
and safety of patients (Sheehan et al., 2013). Pri- over stimulating because some folks have sensory
vate bedrooms can provide a greater “sense of deficits.” Yildirim et al. (2011) confirms this by
personal control and security,” said one of the stating that warm colors provoke active feelings
interviewees. This can be provided by offering and, in some cases, increase anxiety. Contrary to
access to technology such as television for enter- these statements, the chief of psychiatry in Hos-
tainment, phone, or computer to stay connected pital B suggested that “warmer colors are better
with family, control over the temperature of their than cool blues for the common areas because
room for comfort, private lockers to store their they encourage interaction and communication.”
belongings in their bedroom, and most impor- One staff member interviewed for this study said,
tantly options in the type of activities to be “anything but light blues and greens [ . . . ] that
involved in. feels like an asylum from the old movies; very
institutionalized, not homey at all,” but Yildirim
Perception. Offering choices increases an individ- et al. (2011) suggest that cool colors make the
ual’s sense of control and can provide opportuni- space feel peaceful, relaxing, and calm.
ties for patients to modify and personalize their
environment based on personal perceptions (Ber- Respite. In response to a highly stressful work
gamin et al., 2022; Pasha & Shepley, 2017). environment of a psychiatric hospital and to con-
While this is important and possible for personal tribute to the staff’s reduction of stress, burnout,
spaces, perception is based on interpretation of and fatigue, while offering them opportunities to
experiences (Pasha & Shepley, 2017) and varies relax, focus, and concentrate (Nejati et al., 2015),
for different people. Therefore, it is difficult to it is important to create indoor and outdoor
accommodate in designing public spaces. One of relaxation and rejuvenation areas specific to staff.
the most recognized topics in relation to psychia- Interviewees of this study asked for a balance
tric hospitals is creating a deinstitutionalized and between passive and active respite such as a med-
homelike environment. Previous studies pre- itation room and a basketball court. Areas of
sented homelike environments can be created respite serve as a place to withdraw and seek
through light and soothing colors, cheerful and refuge from patients and families along with
welcoming facade and entrances, use of local allowing privacy and socialization with cowor-
materials and design characteristics (Li, 2018), kers (Liddicoat, 2019). The staff break area
clean floors and comfortable furniture (Shepley should include artwork, indoor plants, windows
et al., 2017), nontextured interior walls (Wang with outdoor views and access to nature by offer-
et al., 2020), view of nature and landscape paint- ing opportunities to walk through gardens,
ing (Evans, 2003), and indoor plants (Duque receive direct sunlight, and listen to the sound
et al., 2020) to improve patients and staff’s satis- of birds or water (Nejati et al., 2015). Intervie-
faction. Although these points are agreed upon in wees of this study described the importance of
most research studies, the perception of the space incorporating access to covered patios, fitness
is influenced by individuals’ associational mean- areas, and outdoor walking trails and asked for
ing of the surrounding environment (Wang et al., centralized break rooms near work areas, so they
2020) and can be different for many individuals. can step away from a hectic work environment,
Participants described a homelike environment as think and regroup their thoughts.
Norouzi et al. 9

. . . it is important to create indoor and direct effect on fatigue, insomnia, and other psy-
outdoor relaxation and rejuvenation areas chiatric diseases (Evans, 2003; Nabil & Mardal-
specific to staff. jevic, 2006; Shepley et al., 2016). Exposure to
natural lighting can impact staff and patients by
enabling performance of visual tasks (Peek-Asa
et al., 2009), affecting mood and perception (Par-
Lighting tonen & Lonnqvist, 2000), controlling the body’s
circadian system and improving sleep cycle
Exposure to light impacts the circadian rhythm
(Boubekri et al., 2014), decreasing aggression
which synchronizes the body’s internal clock and
(Ulrich et al., 2014), depression, and anxiety as
regulates the sleep cycle (Joseph, 2006). Inade-
well as facilitating wayfinding (Evans, 2003; Lid-
quate exposure to light can lead to reduced cog-
dicoat, 2019; Shepley et al., 2017). The music
nitive abilities, anxiety, drowsiness, fatigue,
therapist in Hospital A mentioned the importance
stress, and depression, along with vulnerability
of integrating natural daylight in adolescent psy-
to seasonal affective disorder (Evans, 2003;
chiatric hospitals and said, “the kids are generally
White et al., 2013). Therefore, integrating natural
happier and more willing to sit through the ther-
and artificial light in the design of an adolescent
apy session in the room with windows and
psychiatric hospital is essential for improving
sunlight.”
workplace performance for staff and enhancing
patients’ recovery process. It is necessary to
incorporate windows, and skylights allow natural Natural Environment
light into the built environment (Jiang & Verder-
ber, 2016) and select appropriate noninstitutional Connection and access to the natural environment
lighting fixtures to provide adequate light distri- can positively impact physical and mental health
bution for day and night usage. of individuals by improving cognitive abilities,
increasing the sense of belonging and self-worth
Artificial lighting. Lighting is linked with a sense of (Hammell, 2021), helping patients focus on their
comfort and well-being. Consequently, when inner healing resources, and offering staff a place
daylight is not sufficient, artificial lighting must of respite and visitors a relaxed setting to interact
compensate for and provide adequate lighting with loved ones (Marcus, 2007). Designing a con-
that extends the field of view in play areas for nection to the natural environment in an adoles-
adolescent patients and creates ideal working cent psychiatric hospital can be accomplished
conditions for staff. Electric lighting is used to through biophilic design with the goal of provid-
positively impact mood, circadian rhythm, sleep ing a healing environment that promotes well-
cycle, and task performance and decrease depres- being for staff and patients. This could be
sion and length of stay in a hospital (Shepley achieved by offering direct and indirect connec-
et al., 2017). Adequate exposure to artificial light tions to natural elements and incorporating
is essential for night-shift staff in a psychiatric nature-centric spaces with activities ranging from
hospital as it readjusts their circadian rhythm and passive to active (Marcus, 2007). Interviewees
helps with irregular sleep–wake schedules that described nature-centric environments as spaces
could lead to health problems (Joseph, 2006). that include plants, trees, natural materials, art-
Artificial lighting design considerations include work, color, water features, and animals. Intervie-
glare and shadow-free light distribution, daylight wees also mentioned Zen gardens, planters, green
sensors, dimmers, switch controllers, and high courtyards, and walking trails as examples of
and uniform luminance. places that provide opportunities for different lev-
els of activities.
Natural lighting. Daylight should be prioritized
when designing an adolescent psychiatric hospi- Biophilia. Biophilic design focuses on incorporat-
tal as it affects staff and patients’ physical and ing nature into the built environment to advance
psychological health. Inadequate light has a people’s health, fitness, and well-being.
10 Health Environments Research & Design Journal XX(X)

Integrating biophilia in the design of an adoles- an outdoor environment that includes greenery
cent psychiatric facility can promote passive and (Gubbels et al., 2016). Patients with the opportu-
active interactions. Marcus (2007) lists these nity to walk in a garden, be around diverse plants
interactions as viewing the garden through a win- and flowers, listen to the sound of water, and
dow, sitting outside, dozing/napping/meditating, receive direct sunlight are reported to be less
gentle rehabilitation exercises, walking to pre- stressed (Nejati et al., 2015). The interviewees
ferred spots, raised bed gardening, and participat- of this study expressed interests for walking trails
ing in sports. Designing passive connections to that are close to buildings where both patients and
nature can create a temporary escape from an staff can go on daily walks. They also asked for
oppressive atmosphere, offering hope of rapid outdoor areas that are set up for sports, relaxation,
recovery, along with experiencing the change in weight training, play structure, running, and bik-
time, throughout the day and improving the qual- ing, and outdoor shaded seating areas for staff.
ity of daily routines for staff and patients (Nejati Although there were inquiries for different
et al., 2015). An intervention coach from Hospital types of gardens, the most requested green spaces
C said, “more open spaces with outdoor visibility were therapeutic and vegetable gardens. Most
and decorative paneling or paintings of nature in interviewees indicated that attributes of a healing
different spaces will help patients feel at peace.” environment as spending time with plants and
Nature art presents distinct synergistic benefits water features. These activities can reduce anxi-
that can impact the psychosocial well-being of ety, provide positive distractions for patients, and
patients by increasing self-esteem and decreasing offer them opportunities to be involved in their
social isolation (Thomson et al., 2020). Display- own recovery and healing process (Liddicoat,
ing nature art can reduce patient anxiety and agi- 2019). This can also allow staff to cope with
tation (Shepley et al., 2017) and decrease the use bereavement, process stressful work situations,
of anxiety medication (Nanda et al., 2019). The spend quality time, and work with adolescent
dentist in Hospital A said, “there’s a mural in our patients outside of the hospital building (Marcus,
main walkway that has trees, koala bears, gir- 2007). Therapeutic gardens should provide views
affes, and many patients love it” and “it makes to the sky and changing cloud formations, a plen-
them happy; it makes them think of something tiful supply of plant materials with distinctive
besides their delusions. It’s relaxing.” An adoles- seasonal changes, subtleties of color and texture,
cent patient who had learned about architects with leaves or grass that move with the slightest
interviewing members of the hospital wrote a breeze (Marcus, 2007), as well as safe water fea-
message and asked a nurse to deliver it to the tures where patients can see and hear the water
research team. The note read, but not drink it. Interviewees talked about the
benefits of gardening and planting vegetables to
I like to see artwork that is made by some of us. be tremendous for patients as it could help them
There are people here, like this guy in my unit who practice acceptance, understanding the process of
draws very nicely. We can have his drawings on the growth, living in the moment, and eating healthy.
wall. The big sculptures in the garden are nice too;
specially to look at and relax on a sunny day.
Safety and Security
Courtyard. Courtyards, outdoor spaces surrounded Safety is a major factor in adolescent psychiatric
by buildings, can provide opportunities for hospitals, as patients can become violent and
recreational activities, play, and gardening. Inter- aggressive when irritated. Tense or escalating
viewees of this study requested having multiple situations often arise between patients in psychia-
small courtyards accessible to patients for differ- tric hospitals in which staff members need to
ent types of activities. It is important for adoles- intervene. Design features such as efficient visi-
cent patients to have a place to exert their energy bility and circulation that maximizes line of sight
throughout the day (Shepley et al., 2016), and throughout the facility, reduces blind spots from
they are most likely to be physically active in corridor nooks, and provides multiple exit points
Norouzi et al. 11

that improve accessibility, as well as anti-ligature provides additional security and can increase
equipment, durable and heavy furniture, and shat- patients’ choice about monitoring options, it can
terproof windows (Carr, 2017). have adverse effects on patients’ well-being and
cause symptoms of fear, distrust, and paranoia
Boundary. Physical indicators that define the use (Appenzeller et al., 2019). These dubious facts
of space can allow for different types and levels are due to lack of imperial evidence and lead to
of interaction by determining separations or difficulty in considering video surveillance ben-
offering connections (Norouzi et al., 2019). A eficial or hindering. We recommend that future
nurse in Hospital C said, “boundaries are for con- studies to consider representing adolescents in the
nection as much as they are for separation [ . . . ], design of psychiatric hospitals by including them
windows connect the patients to the outdoors in the interviews or surveys for data collection.
even on a hot day when they can’t go outside.”
The nurse continued by saying: Windows from
the patients’ room to the hallway offer safety and
Conclusion
privacy by allowing staff to check on patients The design of an adolescent psychiatric hospital
without entering the room. Boundaries for separa- from identifying the client needs to architectural
tion are essential for safety and security to keep programming and design must be researched
adolescents in their own healing environment and based. This study has evaluated the impact of the
away from adult patients and the public. built environment on staff and patients in an ado-
lescent psychiatric hospital and identified a set of
High risk. Equipment that can be used by patients important design conditions of architectural com-
for self-harm are considered high-risk factors. position, atmosphere, lighting, natural environ-
These can be eliminated with the appropriate use ment, safety, and security. Incorporating these
of durable building materials, damage-resistant conditions into architectural design of adolescent
furniture, and anti-ligature equipment (Carr, psychiatric hospitals will benefit staff, patients,
2017; Shepley, 2017). The head nurse in Hospital and their family members. The specific design
A described the importance of avoiding sharp cor- strategies that need to be incorporated in the
ners and objects used throughout the unit in which architectural design of a safe and secure adoles-
patients can use to harm themselves or others. cent psychiatric hospital include an open floor
plan that respects patients’ autonomy and offers
Visibility. Patient visibility and efficient circulation privacy while always providing staff with full
are imperative when designing an adolescent psy- visibility of patients. Adolescents’ needs from the
chiatric hospital, as it has a direct influence on the built environment is connected to their social and
safety of staff and patients. A central nurse station developmental needs of control, opportunities for
within an adolescent unit is crucial for providing individual growth, and positive peer-
staff with maximum patient visibility (Shepley socialization. A campus with a residential unit,
et al., 2016). Although open nurse stations pro- a school, and a therapy mall where buildings sur-
vide better visibility and support staff capability round courtyards and play spaces provides a safe
to anticipate and prevent aggressive behavior and secure environment for adolescent patients’
(Ulrich et al., 2018), most staff members at Hos- self and academic growth as well as socialization
pitals A and C said that they feel safer in enclosed and friendship. These design elements can also be
stations. In other studies, decentralized nurse sta- implemented in the renovation of existing adoles-
tions positively influenced proximity to patients cent psychiatric hospitals.
in a larger design footprint as well as time spent
with patients (Fay et al., 2017). Another impor-
tant factor to consider are blind spots that can be
Implications of Practice
created by walls or furniture. Interviewees sug-  Architectural composition: When configur-
gested the use of convex mirrors or cameras to ing the layout of an adolescent psychiatric
offer visibility. Although video surveillance hospital, flexibility is important to promote
12 Health Environments Research & Design Journal XX(X)

efficiency for staff and social interactions and/or publication of this article: This work was
with patients by taking into consideration supported by the Texas Health Science Center at
accessibility, interior layout, versatility, San Antonio under grant number 100000180.
wayfinding, and adjacency.
 Atmosphere: The atmosphere of a space ORCID iD
prioritizes a peaceful, home-like environ-
Neda Norouzi, PhD https://orcid.org/0000-
ment for patients and staff which enhances
0001-6553-3543
autonomy, perception, respite, and pleasant
acoustics.
 Lighting: Taking into consideration, natural References
and artificial lighting is vital in promoting Appenzeller, E., Appelbaum, P. S., & Trachsel, M.
an accelerated recovery process for patients (2020). Ethical and practical issues in video surveil-
while also increasing staff productivity. lance of psychiatric units. Psychiatric Services
 Natural environment: Introducing elements (Washington, D.C.), 71(5), 480–486. https://doi.
of the natural environment that encourage org/10.1176/appi.ps.201900397
passive or active interactions among Bergamin, Luigjes, J., Kiverstein, J., Bockting, C. L.,
patients and staff can create a therapeutic & Denys, D. (2022). Defining autonomy in psychia-
healing environment furthering well-being. try. Frontiers in Psychiatry, 13, 801415–801415.
 Safety and security: It is necessary to pro- https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyt.2022.801415
vide a safe environment that maximizes Blumberg, R. & Devlin, A. S. (2006). Design Issues in
staff visibility toward patients, utilization hospitals: The adolescent client. Environment and
of anti-ligature equipment for mitigating Behavior, 38(3), 293–317. https://doi.org/10.1177/
self-harm, and integrates appropriate 0013916505281575
boundaries throughout an adolescent psy- Borg-Laufs, M. (2013). Basic psychological needs in
chiatric hospital. childhood and adolescence. Journal of Education
and Research, 3, 41–51. https://doi.org/10.3126/
jer.v3i0.7851
Authors’ Note
Boubekri, M., Cheung, I. N., Reid, K. J., Kuo, N. W.,
Approval to conduct this study was obtained from Wang, C. H., & Zee, P. C. (2014). Impact of win-
the Ethics Committee of the University with dows and daylight exposure on overall health and
which the authors are affiliated with (ref. 18- sleep quality of office workers-A case-control pilot
209). Authorization to conduct the study was study. Journal of Clinical Sleep Medicine, 10(6),
obtained in each psychiatric hospital. Each parti- 603–611.
cipant signed a written consent form after being Carr, R. F. (2017). Psychiatric facility. WBDG Health
informed of the description and objectives of the Care Subcommittee. https://www.wbdg.org/build
study, the voluntary nature of participation, the ing-types/health-care-facilities/psychiatric-facility
ability to withdraw at any time, and that the inter- Charmaz, K. (2008). Constructionism and the
views would be audio recorded. Participation in grounded theory method. In J.A. Holstein & J. F.
the study was anonymous, and required measures Gubrium (Eds.), Handbook of constructionist
were implemented to ensure data protection. research (pp. 397–412). The Guilford Press.
Chun, T. H., Mace, S. E., & Katz, E. R., American
Declaration of Conflicting Interests Academy Of Pediatrics, Committee On Pediatric
The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of Emergency Medicine, A. A. C. O. E. P., & Pediatric
interest with respect to the research, authorship, Emergency Medicine Committee. (2016). Evalua-
and/or publication of this article. tion and management of children and adolescents
with acute mental health or behavioral problems.
Funding Part I: Common clinical challenges of patients with
The author(s) disclosed receipt of the following mental health and/or behavioral emergencies.
financial support for the research, authorship, https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27550977/
Norouzi et al. 13

Daly, K. (2007). Qualitative methods for family studies 14(5), 537–545. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-
and human development. Sage. 2702.2004.01106.x
Devlin, A. S. (2014). Wayfinding in healthcare facili- Jiang, S., & Verderber, S. (2016). On the planning and
ties: Contributions from environmental psychology. design of hospital circulation zones: A review of the
Behavioral Sciences, 4(4), 423–426. https://doi.org/ evidence-based literature. Health Environments
10.3390/bs4040423 Research & Design Journal, 10(2), 1–23. https://
Duque, M., Annemans, M., Pink, S., & Spong, L. doi.org/10.1177/1937586716672041
(2020). Everyday comforting practices in psychia- Jones, V. (2019). Youth access to mental health ser-
tric hospital environments: A design anthropology vices is an un-prioritized civil right. American Bar
approach. Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Association. Retrieved December 7, 2020, from
Health Nursing, 1–12. https://doi.org/10.1111/jpm. https://www.americanbar.org/groups/litigation/com
12711 mittees/diversity-inclusion/articles/2019/youth-
Evans, G. (2003). The built environment and mental access-to-mental-health-civil-rights/
health. Journal of Urban Health: Bulletin of the Joseph, A. (2006). Impact of light on outcomes in
New York Academy of Medicine, 80, 536–555. healthcare settings. The Center for Health Design.
Fay, L., Carll-White, A., Schadler, A., Isaacs, K. B., & Retrieved February 12, 2021, from https://www.
Real, K. (2017). Shifting landscapes: The impact of healthdesign.org/chd/research/impact-light-out
centralized and decentralized nursing station mod- comes-healthcare-settings
els on the efficiency of care. Health Environments Jovanović, N., Campbell, J., & Priebe, S. (2019). How
Research & Design Journal, 10(5), 80–94. https:// to design psychiatric facilities to foster positive
doi.org/10.1177/1937586717698812 social interaction—A systematic review. European
Glaser, B. (1992). Emergence vs. forcing: Basics of Psychiatry, 60, 49–62. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
grounded theory analysis. Sociology Press. eurpsy.2019.04.005
Gubbels, J., Kremers, S., Droomers, M., Hoefnagels, C., Li, X. (2018). How architecture can promote a sustain-
Stronks, K., Hosman, C., & de Vries, S. (2016). The able and therapeutic experience for patients in psy-
impact of greenery on physical activity and mental chiatric hospitals in China [Master’s thesis,
health of adolescent and adult residents of deprived Rochester Institute of Technology]. RIT Scholar
neighborhoods: A longitudinal study. Health & Works.
Place, 40, 153–160. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.health Liddicoat, S. (2019). Designing a supportive emer-
place.2016.06.002 gency department environment for people with self
Hallberg, L. (2006). The “core category” of grounded harm and suicidal ideation: A scoping review. Aus-
theory: Making constant comparisons. Interna- tralasian Emergency Care, 22(3), 139–148. https://
tional Journal of Qualitative Studies on Health and doi.org/10.1016/j.auec.2019.04.006
Well-Being, 1(3), 141–148. https://doi.org/10.1080/ Marcus, C. C., (2007). Healing gardens in hospitals.
17482620600858399 Design and Health, 1(1). Retrieved January 12,
Hallman, I., O’Connor, N., Hasenau, S., & Brady, S. 2021, from https://intogreen.nl/wp-content/
(2014). Improving the culture of safety on a high- uploads/2017/07/cooper_marcus.pdf
acuity inpatient child/adolescent psychiatric unit by McGorry, B., Bates, T., & Brichwood, M. (2013).
mindfulness-based stress reduction training of staff. Designing youth mental health services for the
Journal of Child and Adolescent Psychiatric Nur- 21st century: Examples from Australia, Ireland and
sing, 27(4), 183–189. https://doi-org.libweb.lib. the UK. British Journal of Psychiatry, 202(s54),
utsa.edu/10.1111/jcap.12091 s30–s35. https://doi.org/10.1192/bjp.bp.112.
Hammell, K. (2021). Occupation in natural environ- 119214
ments; Health equity and environmental justice. Nabil, A., & Mardaljevic, J. (2006). Useful daylight
Canadian Journal of Occupational Therapy illuminances: A replacement for daylight factors.
(1939), 88(4), 319–328. https://doi.org/10.1177/ Energy and Buildings, 38(7), 905–913. https://doi.
00084174211040000 org/10.1016/j.enbuild.2006.03.013
Hutton, A. (2005). Consumer perspectives in adoles- Nanda, U., Hoelting, M., & Fuassel, W. (2019, June
cent ward design. Journal of Clinical Nursing, 14). FleXX: A study of flexibility in outpatient
14 Health Environments Research & Design Journal XX(X)

settings. Retrieved December 30, 2020, from Psychiatric Services, 64(8), 789–795. https://doi.
https://www.hksinc.com/how-we-think/research/ org/10.1176/appi.ps.201200208
flexx-a-study-of-flexibility-in-outpatient-settings/ Shepley, M., & Pasha, S. (2017). Design for mental and
Nejati, A., Shepley, M., & Rodiek, S. (2015). Restora- behavioral health (1st ed.). Routledge. https://doi.
tive design features for hospital staff break areas: A org/10.4324/9781315646916
multi-method study. Health Environments Shepley, M., Watson, A., Pitts, F., Garrity, A., Spel-
Research & Design Journal, 9(2). https://doi-org. man, E., Fronsman, A., & Kelkar, J. (2016). Mental
libweb.lib.utsa.edu/10.1177/1937586715592632 and behavioral health environments: critical consid-
Norouzi, N. (2016). Intergenerational facilities: erations for facility design. General Hospital Psy-
Designing intergenerational space through a human chiatry, 42, 15–21. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
development lens [Doctoral dissertation, Virginia genhosppsych.2016.06.003
Tech]. Vtechworks. Shepley, M., Watson, A., Pitts, F., Garrity, A., Spelman,
Norouzi, N., Jarrott, S., & Chaudhury, H. (2019). E., Fronsman, A., & Kelkar, J. (2017). Mental and
Designing intergenerational space through a behavioral health settings: Importance & effective-
human-development lens. Journal of Architectural ness of environmental qualities & features as per-
and Planning Research, 36(1), 35–51. ceived by staff. Journal of Environmental
Partonen, T., & Lonnqvist, J. (2000). Bright light Psychology, 50, 37–50. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
improves vitality and alleviates € distress in healthy jenvp.2017.01.005
people. Journal of Affective Disorders, 57(1), Thomson, L., Morse, N., Elsden, E., & Chatterjee, H.
55–61. (2020). Art, nature and mental health: assessing the
Pasha, S., & Shepley, M. (2017). Design for mental and biopsychosocial effects of a “creative green pre-
behavioral health. Taylor & Francis. https://doi. scription” museum programme involving horticul-
org/10.4324/9781315646916 ture, artmaking and collections. Perspectives in
Peek-Asa, C., Casteel, C., Allareddy, V., Nocera, M., Public Health, 140(5), 277–285. https://doi.org/10.
Goldmacher, S., OHagan, E., Blando, J., Valiante, 1177/1757913920910443
D., Gillen, M., & Harrison, R. (2009). Workplace Trzpuc, S., Wendt, K., Heitzman, S., Skemp, S., Tho-
violence prevention programs in psychiatric units mas, D., & Dahl, R. (2016). Does space matter? An
and facilities. Archives of Psychiatric Nursing, exploratory study for a child–adolescent mental
23(2), 166–176. health inpatient unit. Health Environments
Popay, J., Roberts, H., Sowden, A., Arai, L., Rodgers, Research & Design Journal, 10(1), 23–44. https://
M., Britten, N., Roen, K., & Duffy, S. (2006). Gui- doi.org/10.1177/1937586716634017
dance on the conduct of narrative synthesis in sys- Ulrich, R., Bogren, L., Gardiner, S., & Lundin, S. (2018).
tematic reviews. Retrieved December 28, 2020, Psychiatric ward design can reduce aggressive beha-
from https://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/down vior. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 57,
load?doi¼10.1.1.178.3100&rep¼rep1&type 53–66. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvp.2018.05.002
Preyde, M., Parekh, S., & Heintzman, J. (2018). Ulrich, R., Bogren, L., & Lundin, S. (2014). Towards a
Youths’ experiences of school re-integration fol- design theory for reducing aggression in psychiatric
lowing psychiatric hospitalization. Journal of the facilities [Conference session]. In Arch 12: Archi-
Canadian Academy of Child and Adolescent Psy- tecture/research/care/health conference. Chalmers
chiatry, 27(1), 22–32. Institute of Technology, Gothenburg, Sweden.
Shattell, M., Andes, M., & Thomas, S. (2008). How Wang, C, Lu, W., Ohno, R., & Gu, Z. (2020). Effect of
patients and nurses experience the acute care psy- wall texture on perceptual spaciousness of indoor
chiatric environment. Nursing Inquiry, 15(3), space. International Journal of Environmental
242–250. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1440-1800. Research and Public Health, 17(11), 4177. https://
2008.00397.x doi.org/10.3390/ijerph17114177
Sheehan, B., Burton, E., Wood, S., Stride, C., Hender- White, M. D., Ancoli-Israel, S., & Wilson, R. R. (2013).
son, E., & Wearn, E. (2013). Evaluating the built Senior living environments: Evidence-based lighting
environment in inpatient psychiatric wards. design strategies. Health Environments Research &
Norouzi et al. 15

Design Journal, 7(1), 60–78. https://doi-org.libweb. Zhou, T., Wu, Y., Meng, Q., & Kang, J. (2020). Influ-
lib.utsa.edu/10.1177/193758671300700106 ence of the acoustic environment in hospital wards
Yildirim, H., Hidayetoglu, M. F., & Capanoglu, A. on patient physiological and psychological indices.
(2011). Effects of interior colors on mood and pre- Frontiers in Psychology, 11, 1600–1600. https://
ference: Comparisons of two living rooms. Percep- doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2020.01600
tual and Motor Skills, 112(2), 509–524. https://doi. Zumthor, P. (2006). Atmospheres. Birkhauser.
org/10.2466/24.27.PMS.112.2.509-524

You might also like