Professional Documents
Culture Documents
is in a conspiracy against the manhood of every one of its members.” This means that people
should be themselves and not try to fit in. It also demonstrates that society is always trying to
In this quote, Emerson makes society the antagonist of man, which is always working
against individuality. He also demonstrates this idea in this part of the text: “Society is a
joint-stock company, in which the members agree, for the better securing of his bread to each
shareholder, to surrender the liberty and culture of the eater.” This means that society forces
people to give up their individuality, in order to have a better coexistence. However, this
situation makes people lose track of who they really are and want. So, society acts as a tool
for indoctrinating the actions of its members. This view is also defended by Jean-Jacques
Rousseau, who says that everyone is born a good person, but the environment changes it.
Taking into consideration both ideas it is possible to realize that men lose their natural state.
Another idea that the quote gives is that society emasculates men. This tough comes
from the belief that individuals are asked to conform, which means that they get weaker when
they aspire to be liked o get approved by others. Emerson also shows that society “whips” the
ones that are not conforming. In the book “The Catcher in the Rye”, the main character
Holden Caulfield does not act in the expectations of society, which makes him expelled from
prep. So, it is possible to see examples in real life of people suffering from being authentic
and having their own individuality, which should not happen in a free society.
every one of its members.” evidences the modem daily basis, in which people need to change
to be liked and accepted. So, human individuality and masculinity are being lost through the
years.