Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 5.3-BPWF Case AHP Model Up To 6X6

    Uploaded by

    Scott
    2 views43 pages
    The document contains pairwise comparison matrices and calculated weights for criteria in evaluating waste management companies. It compares criteria like cost, location, management quality, and companies like UK Waste, CleanUpInc, and DorsetServices on those criteria to determine how important each criterion and company is relative to the others. The calculated weights show the relative importance or priority of each based on the pairwise comparisons.

    Original Description:

    case model 2

    Original Title

    5.3-BPWF Case AHP Model Up to 6X6

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    XLS, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document
    The document contains pairwise comparison matrices and calculated weights for criteria in evaluating waste management companies. It compares criteria like cost, location, management quality, and companies like UK Waste, CleanUpInc, and DorsetServices on those criteria to determine how important each criterion and company is relative to the others. The calculated weights show the relative importance or priority of each based on the pairwise comparisons.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as XLS, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    2 views43 pages

    5.3-BPWF Case AHP Model Up To 6X6

    Uploaded by

    Scott
    The document contains pairwise comparison matrices and calculated weights for criteria in evaluating waste management companies. It compares criteria like cost, location, management quality, and companies like UK Waste, CleanUpInc, and DorsetServices on those criteria to determine how important each criterion and company is relative to the others. The calculated weights show the relative importance or priority of each based on the pairwise comparisons.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as XLS, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    of 43

    Comparing Criteria: Pairwise Comparison Matrix

    Wet and Dry


    Wet and Dry 1.000
    Accredited 5.000
    Location 1.000
    Financial (stability) 5.000
    Cost 9.000
    Mgmt quality 1.000
    TOTAL 22.000

    Comparing Criteria: Calculating Criteria Weights

    Wet and Dry


    Wet and Dry 0.045
    Accredited 0.227
    Location 0.045
    Financial (stability) 0.227
    Cost 0.409
    Mgmt quality 0.045
    e Comparison Matrix

    Accredited Location Financial (stability)


    0.200 1.000 0.200
    1.000 7.000 1.000
    0.143 1.000 0.200
    1.000 5.000 1.000
    0.167 7.000 0.333
    0.333 4.000 0.250
    2.843 25.000 2.983

    ing Criteria Weights

    Accredited Location Financial (stability)


    0.070 0.040 0.067
    0.352 0.280 0.335
    0.050 0.040 0.067
    0.352 0.200 0.335
    0.059 0.280 0.112
    0.117 0.160 0.084
    Cost Mgmt quality
    0.111 1.000
    6.000 3.000
    0.143 0.250
    3.000 4.000
    1.000 2.000
    0.500 1.000
    10.754 11.250

    Cost Mgmt quality Weights


    0.010 0.089 0.054
    0.558 0.267 0.336
    0.013 0.022 0.040
    0.279 0.356 0.291
    0.093 0.178 0.188
    0.046 0.089 0.090
    Comparing Criteria: Pairwise Comparison Matrix

    Wet and Dry UK Waste (all)


    UK Waste (all) 1.000
    CleanUpInc (small biz) 0.200
    DorsetServices (only dr 0.200
    PreserveAll (all) 1.000
    CoolClean (only wet wa 0.200
    TOTAL 2.600

    Comparing Criteria: Calculating Criteria Weights

    Wet and Dry UK Waste (all)


    UK Waste (all) 0.385
    CleanUpInc (small biz) 0.077
    DorsetServices (only dr 0.077
    PreserveAll (all) 0.385
    CoolClean (only wet wa 0.077
    #REF! #REF!
    Comparing Criteria: Pairwise Comparison Matrix
    3.000
    Accredited UK Waste (all)
    UK Waste (all) 1.000
    CleanUpInc (small biz) 1.000
    DorsetServices (only dr 1.000
    PreserveAll (all) 1.000
    CoolClean (only wet wa 1.000
    TOTAL 5.000

    Comparing Criteria: Calculating Criteria Weights

    Accredited UK Waste (all)


    UK Waste (all) 0.200
    CleanUpInc (small biz) 0.200
    DorsetServices (only dr 0.200
    PreserveAll (all) 0.200
    CoolClean (only wet wa 0.200
    #REF! #REF!
    Comparing Criteria: Pairwise Comparison Matrix
    250.000
    Location UK Waste (all)
    UK Waste (all) 1.000
    CleanUpInc (small biz) 5.000
    DorsetServices (only dr 7.000
    PreserveAll (all) 5.000
    CoolClean (only wet wa 3.000
    TOTAL 21.000

    Comparing Criteria: Calculating Criteria Weights

    Location UK Waste (all)


    UK Waste (all) 0.048
    CleanUpInc (small biz) 0.238
    DorsetServices (only dr 0.333
    PreserveAll (all) 0.238
    CoolClean (only wet wa 0.143
    Comparing Criteria: Pairwise Comparison Matrix

    Financial (stability) UK Waste (all)


    UK Waste (all) 1.000
    CleanUpInc (small biz) #DIV/0!
    DorsetServices (only dr #DIV/0!
    PreserveAll (all) #DIV/0!
    CoolClean (only wet wa #DIV/0!
    #REF! #REF!
    TOTAL #DIV/0!

    Comparing Criteria: Calculating Criteria Weights

    Financial (stability) UK Waste (all)


    UK Waste (all) #DIV/0!
    CleanUpInc (small biz) #DIV/0!
    DorsetServices (only dr #DIV/0!
    PreserveAll (all) #DIV/0!
    CoolClean (only wet wa #DIV/0!
    #REF! #REF!

    Comparing Criteria: Pairwise Comparison Matrix

    Cost UK Waste (all)


    UK Waste (all) 1.000
    CleanUpInc (small biz) 5.000
    DorsetServices (only dr 7.000
    PreserveAll (all) 7.000
    CoolClean (only wet wa 3.000
    TOTAL 23.000

    Comparing Criteria: Calculating Criteria Weights

    Cost UK Waste (all)


    UK Waste (all) 0.043
    CleanUpInc (small biz) 0.217
    DorsetServices (only dr 0.304
    PreserveAll (all) 0.304
    CoolClean (only wet wa 0.130

    Comparing Criteria: Pairwise Comparison Matrix

    Mgmt quality UK Waste (all)


    UK Waste (all) 1.000
    CleanUpInc (small biz) #DIV/0!
    DorsetServices (only dr #DIV/0!
    PreserveAll (all) #DIV/0!
    CoolClean (only wet wa #DIV/0!
    #REF! #REF!
    TOTAL #DIV/0!

    Comparing Criteria: Calculating Criteria Weights

    Mgmt quality UK Waste (all)


    UK Waste (all) #DIV/0!
    CleanUpInc (small biz) #DIV/0!
    DorsetServices (only dr #DIV/0!
    PreserveAll (all) #DIV/0!
    CoolClean (only wet wa #DIV/0!
    #REF! #REF!
    mparison Matrix

    CleanUpInc (small biz)


    5.000
    1.000
    3.000
    5.000
    0.500
    14.500

    riteria Weights

    CleanUpInc (small biz)


    0.345
    0.069
    0.207
    0.345
    0.034
    #REF!
    mparison Matrix
    3.000
    CleanUpInc (small biz)
    1.000
    1.000
    1.000
    1.000
    1.000
    5.000

    riteria Weights

    CleanUpInc (small biz)


    0.200
    0.200
    0.200
    0.200
    0.200
    #REF!
    mparison Matrix
    10.000
    CleanUpInc (small biz)
    0.200
    1.000
    0.333
    0.200
    0.500
    2.233

    riteria Weights

    CleanUpInc (small biz)


    0.090
    0.448
    0.149
    0.090
    0.224
    mparison Matrix

    CleanUpInc (small biz)

    1.000
    #DIV/0!
    #DIV/0!
    #DIV/0!
    #REF!
    #DIV/0!

    riteria Weights

    CleanUpInc (small biz)


    #DIV/0!
    #DIV/0!
    #DIV/0!
    #DIV/0!
    #DIV/0!
    #REF!

    mparison Matrix

    CleanUpInc (small biz)


    0.200
    1.000
    2.000
    2.000
    0.500
    5.700

    riteria Weights

    CleanUpInc (small biz)


    0.035
    0.175
    0.351
    0.351
    0.088

    mparison Matrix

    CleanUpInc (small biz)

    1.000
    #DIV/0!
    #DIV/0!
    #DIV/0!
    #REF!
    #DIV/0!

    riteria Weights

    CleanUpInc (small biz)


    #DIV/0!
    #DIV/0!
    #DIV/0!
    #DIV/0!
    #DIV/0!
    #REF!
    DorsetServices (only dry & haz)
    5.000
    0.333
    1.000
    5.000
    1.000
    12.333

    DorsetServices (only dry & haz)


    0.405
    0.027
    0.081
    0.405
    0.081
    #REF!
    3.000
    DorsetServices (only dry & haz)
    1.000
    1.000
    1.000
    1.000
    1.000
    5.000

    DorsetServices (only dry & haz)


    0.200
    0.200
    0.200
    0.200
    0.200
    #REF!
    6.000
    DorsetServices (only dry & haz)
    0.143
    3.000
    1.000
    0.500
    0.333
    4.976

    DorsetServices (only dry & haz)


    0.029
    0.603
    0.201
    0.100
    0.067
    DorsetServices (only dry & haz)

    1.000
    #DIV/0!
    #DIV/0!
    #REF!
    #DIV/0!

    DorsetServices (only dry & haz)


    #DIV/0!
    #DIV/0!
    #DIV/0!
    #DIV/0!
    #DIV/0!
    #REF!

    DorsetServices (only dry & haz)


    0.143
    0.500
    1.000
    2.000
    0.500
    4.143

    DorsetServices (only dry & haz)


    0.034
    0.121
    0.241
    0.483
    0.121

    DorsetServices (only dry & haz)

    1.000
    #DIV/0!
    #DIV/0!
    #REF!
    #DIV/0!

    DorsetServices (only dry & haz)


    #DIV/0!
    #DIV/0!
    #DIV/0!
    #DIV/0!
    #DIV/0!
    #REF!
    PreserveAll (all) CoolClean (only wet waste)
    1.000 5.000
    0.200 2.000
    0.200 1.000
    1.000 5.000
    0.200 1.000
    2.600 14.000

    PreserveAll (all) CoolClean (only wet waste)


    0.385 0.357
    0.077 0.143
    0.077 0.071
    0.385 0.357
    0.077 0.071
    #REF! #REF!
    3.000 3.000
    PreserveAll (all) CoolClean (only wet waste)
    1.000 1.000
    1.000 1.000
    1.000 1.000
    1.000 1.000
    1.000 1.000
    5.000 5.000

    PreserveAll (all) CoolClean (only wet waste)


    0.200 0.200
    0.200 0.200
    0.200 0.200
    0.200 0.200
    0.200 0.200
    #REF! #REF!
    50.000 20.000
    PreserveAll (all) CoolClean (only wet waste)
    0.200 0.333
    5.000 2.000
    2.000 3.000
    1.000 0.333
    3.000 1.000
    11.200 6.667

    PreserveAll (all) CoolClean (only wet waste)


    0.018 0.050
    0.446 0.300
    0.179 0.450
    0.089 0.050
    0.268 0.150
    PreserveAll (all) CoolClean (only wet waste)

    1.000
    #DIV/0! 1.000
    #REF! #REF!
    #DIV/0! #REF!

    PreserveAll (all) CoolClean (only wet waste)


    #DIV/0! #REF!
    #DIV/0! #REF!
    #DIV/0! #REF!
    #DIV/0! #REF!
    #DIV/0! #REF!
    #REF! #REF!

    PreserveAll (all) CoolClean (only wet waste)


    0.143 0.333
    0.500 2.000
    0.500 2.000
    1.000 3.000
    0.333 1.000
    2.476 8.333

    PreserveAll (all) CoolClean (only wet waste)


    0.058 0.040
    0.202 0.240
    0.202 0.240
    0.404 0.360
    0.135 0.120

    PreserveAll (all) CoolClean (only wet waste)

    1.000
    #DIV/0! 1.000
    #REF! #REF!
    #DIV/0! #REF!

    PreserveAll (all) CoolClean (only wet waste)


    #DIV/0! #REF!
    #DIV/0! #REF!
    #DIV/0! #REF!
    #DIV/0! #REF!
    #DIV/0! #REF!
    #REF! #REF!
    Weights
    0.375
    0.079
    0.103
    0.375
    0.068
    #REF!
    Weights
    0.200
    0.200
    0.200
    0.200
    0.200
    #REF!
    Weights
    0.047
    0.407
    0.262
    0.113
    0.170
    Weights
    #DIV/0!
    #DIV/0!
    #DIV/0!
    #DIV/0!
    #DIV/0!
    #REF!

    Weights
    0.042
    0.191
    0.268
    0.380
    0.119

    Weights
    #DIV/0!
    #DIV/0!
    #DIV/0!
    #DIV/0!
    #DIV/0!
    #REF!
    Computation of Weights: Supplier Alternatives
    Alternatives Wet and Dry
    UK Waste (all 0.054 0.375
    CleanUpInc (s 0.054 0.079
    DorsetService 0.054 0.103
    PreserveAll (a 0.054 0.375
    CoolClean (on 0.054 0.068
    #REF! 0.054 #REF!

    Alternatives Wet and Dry


    UK Waste (all 0.020 +
    CleanUpInc (s 0.004 +
    DorsetService 0.006 +
    PreserveAll (a 0.020 +
    CoolClean (on 0.004 +
    #REF! #REF! +
    Alternatives
    Accredited
    + 0.336 0.200 +
    + 0.336 0.200 +
    + 0.336 0.200 +
    + 0.336 0.200 +
    + 0.336 0.200 +
    + 0.336 #REF! +

    Accredited Location
    0.067 + 0.002 +
    0.067 + 0.016 +
    0.067 + 0.010 +
    0.067 + 0.005 +
    0.067 + 0.007 +
    #REF! + #REF! +
    Location Financial (stabil
    0.040 0.047 + 0.291
    0.040 0.407 + 0.291
    0.040 0.262 + 0.291
    0.040 0.113 + 0.291
    0.040 0.170 + 0.291
    0.040 #REF! + 0.291

    Financial (stability) Cost


    #DIV/0! + 0.008 +
    #DIV/0! + 0.036 +
    #DIV/0! + 0.050 +
    #DIV/0! + 0.072 +
    #DIV/0! + 0.022 +
    #REF! + #REF! +
    ncial (stability) Cost
    #DIV/0! + 0.188 0.042 +
    #DIV/0! + 0.188 0.191 +
    #DIV/0! + 0.188 0.268 +
    #DIV/0! + 0.188 0.380 +
    #DIV/0! + 0.188 0.119 +
    #REF! + 0.188 #REF! +

    Mgmt quality WEIGHTS


    #DIV/0! #DIV/0!
    #DIV/0! #DIV/0!
    #DIV/0! #DIV/0!
    #DIV/0! #DIV/0!
    #DIV/0! #DIV/0!
    #REF! #REF!
    Mgmt quality
    0.090 #DIV/0!
    0.090 #DIV/0!
    0.090 #DIV/0!
    0.090 #DIV/0!
    0.090 #DIV/0!
    0.090 #REF!

    You might also like