Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Comparative Studies and Impact Analysis of Environmental Noise Modeling From Malaysian Industrial Projects
Comparative Studies and Impact Analysis of Environmental Noise Modeling From Malaysian Industrial Projects
Mansor,
M.J.M.Nor, M.Z.Nuawi,
WSEAS TRANSACTIONS on ENVIRONMENT and DEVELOPMENT R. Zulkifli, M.N.Ab.Rahman and K.Sopian
Abstract: - This paper presents the results obtained in a study on environmental noise pollution due to industrial project
proposals at four different places in Malaysia. The different projects included in this case study are Petronas refinery
extension project MG-3, Janamanjung power station in Perak, RCC plant in Semenyih and Co-generation plant in
Melaka. Noise level measurements and analysis for the projects were categorized in three different stages namely,
existing environmental noise level, noise scenario during construction stage and noise contours predicted during
operation stage. This paper presents typical environmental noise scenarios and impact analysis due to industrial project
activities in Malaysia.
least 15 minutes, and the noise instrument should be NML/2082/E/03National Metrology Lab.SIRIM
CALIBRATION
placed at least 1 meter away from any reflective surface. Berhad. (Date 18/11/2003)
The sound level meter was calibrated on site
before the first measurement was taken and after the final SOUND
QC-10 114dB - 1000Hz
CALIBRATORS
measurement was completed. The dBA scale was
selected for the measurements of the environmental noise
as recommended by ISO 1996/1 standard. The
‘A’-weighted measurement, are more reliable when
associated with people’s reaction for many applications.
3 Results
3.1 Project: MG-3
Table 2 is the summary of the existing baseline noise
2.1 Noise descriptors
level taken during the MG-3 Project.
Noise descriptors such as LAeq, Lmax, Lmin, LA10,
LA50 and LA90 were recorded. Baseline sound levels
were monitored for two different periods of the day, Existing Future Increase
namely: day-time and night-time readings. Definition for Stations Descriptions Leq Leq in noise
(dBA) (dBA) level
the noise descriptors are presented as follows:
Inside
N1
LAeq: The equivalent continuous dBA level which has commando- 52.4 56.9 4.5
(R7)
the same energy as the original fluctuating noise based
for the same given period of time. N2 Taman
52.6 59.1 6.5
(R12) Peruna
LAmax: Maximum noise level measured. Near
N3
Madrasah 51.6 50.7 -0.9
LAmin: Minimum noise level measured. (R1)
Al-Nuriah
N4 Kg. Tangga
LA10: A specified dBA levels which is exceeded ten 49.6 53.0 3.4
(R19) Batu
percent of the time during the whole period of
measurement. N5 Near Hualon
60.2 51.4 -8.8
(R16) Factory
LA50: A specified dBA levels which is exceeded fifty Near Kg.
N6
percent of the time during the whole period of Pantai 61.8 47.1 -14.4
(R15)
measurement. Kundor
N8 Near Kg.
47.4 56.8 9.4
LA90: A specified dBA levels which is exceeded (R18) Sungai Udang
ninety percent of the time during the whole
period of measurement. N9 Near Kg.
50.7 50.8 0.1
(R17) Tangga Batu
2.2 Equipment Sek. Keb.
N10
Pantai 57.5 50.6 -6.9
(R20)
The equipments used in this study consist of sound level Kundor
meter including with calibrator while Cadna software has
been utilized to analysis the sound propagations and Table 2 Increase in noise level at selected locations
exposure. The brief information of equipment used was surrounding the plant area.
briefly described in Table 1.
Figure 1 shows the predicted noise contours of 50, 55, 60,
Table 1 Equipment used for noise study 65, 70, 75 and 80dBA near the surrounding area of the
proposed plant during operation stage. The 60dBA noise
contour line is encroaching the boundary of Taman
ORIGIN QUEST Technologies USA
Peruna as shown in the figure.
QUEST 2900 Integrating and Logging Sound
MODEL
Level Meter
R1 8
65 65
R2 5
70
60 R2 4
65 55 50
SS
43
60 S5 70S6 60
65
60
R1 7
R1 2 55 60
75 S61
S62 70
S64S63
R9 S 6S66 5 50
65 S 6 8S 6 7 S 1 0 60
65 R1 9
70 R2
S7 55
S50
SS4581 S9
R1 0 S41
S 5S34S94S7
44 S8
S56 S52
S 5 4 S 4S24R1 65
S 6S0S555 7 6 4S 1 8
S 5
SS51859 60 55
80 70 R1 6 50
SS 2127 45 50
75 SS129R5
1
S16 S20 50
S26 8 0 50
S23
R6
S 2S425 75 45
0 65
75 50
65 55
70 50
65
R3 50
R1 3 65 70
S1 S11 60
R7
S12 S14 55
65
70 S13 R2 0
S2
70 50
R2 1
S30 S 27
S28 S29
R8
R
65
60
60 55
Figure 1 Predicted future noise contours during operation stage of the proposed MG-3 project.
Figure 2 Location of the measurement station and predicted noise contours during operation of the proposed extension
project.
3.3 Project: RCC Plant Semenyih Table 4 tabulates the measured noise levels and
Noise measurements were carried out to establish the the corresponding sources at the selected monitoring
existing background noise level around the proposed stations. Dominant noise sources at the area are mainly
power project areas including Kg. Pasir Baru, Kg. Sg. due to industrial activities from the nearby factories and
Lalang Lama, Kg. Sg. Machang and Taman Sri Tanjung. also vehicle noise from the nearby road. The
Noise measurements were carried out on 8th and 9th fifteen-minute LAeq noise levels at these monitoring
September 2004. The main purpose of this survey is to stations varied from 45.2dBA to 76.2dBA during
establish the existing background noise level and also to day-time and 42.8dBA to 56.0dBA during night-time.
identify all the significant noise sources caused by the The levels are representative of the existing baseline
existing environment. noise levels at the proposed project area.
R14:. Near Kg. Sg. Machang BT. 21 about 20m from main
road.
Day Human Activities,
62.1 78.7 41.3
(12.00pm) Traffics,
Figure 3 Predicted noise contours during operation stage of the proposed RCC plant.
The typical operating condition of the proposed plant will Figure 3 presents the results from computer
inevitably increase the existing environmental noise simulation to predict noise contours generated by the
levels in the surrounding area. However, the impact is proposed RCC plant operation. Where the operation of
predicted to be localized within the plant area. the proposed RCC plant is predicted not to cause
3.4 Project: Co-Gen Melaka Table 5b Day-time Noise Level at Various Sampling
Noise measurements were carried out to establish the Stations outside the Plant area.
existing background noise levels around the plant area.
Noise measurements were carried out on 19th – 20th
February 2003. The main purpose of this survey is to Locati
on of Date
establish the existing background noise levels and also to Leq Lmax Lmin
Monito and Noise sources
identify all the significant noise sources caused by the dBA dBA dBA
ring hours
existing plant facilities. Station
A summary of the existing noise level from the
process plant area is presented in Table 5a and Table 5b.
Day-time and night-time noise levels recorded showed Human
that they were above the limit imposed by DOE 13:45 -
P1 activities,
regulations. Predicted noise contours for the proposed 14:00 56.4 69.3 48.0
Stack Flare
co-gen extension project is shown in Figure 4.
Human
Table 5a Noise level at various sampling stations inside activities,
the Plant Area. 14:15 -
P2 Distance
14:30 53.4 78.4 43.9
Traffics.
Stack Flare
Locati
Human
on of Date
Leq Lmax Lmin activities,
Monito and Noise sources
dBA dBA dBA 15:00 - Distance
ring hours P3
15:15 traffics, 58.3 79.5 45.7
Station
Air quality
sampling pump.
11:00 - Blower fan from
S1 57.0 61.2 51.5
11:15 fume ventilator Human
16:50 - activities,
P4
11:20 - Compressor 17:10 Distance 47.4 69.1 39.7
S2 69.2 75.9 67.6 Traffics, birds
11:35 unit.
Delayed Cooker Distance
11:55 -
S3 Unit, Stack 69.9 76.9 68.5 traffics, Human
12:10
Flare. . 16:10 activities, birds,
P5
- 16:25 plant operation 57.1 81.1 49.7
12:25 -
S4 Incerator unit. 73.8 77.2 71.6 from Taiko
12:40
Drums sdn. bhd.
12:45 Boiler &
S5 68.9 81.6 67.2 15:45 - Human
- 13:00 Incinerator unit.
P6 16:00 activities,
63.2 81.3 43.3
traffics, birds.
14:40 - Cooling Water
S6 84.2 87.5 82.1
14:55 unit.