EVALUASI INDEKS STABILITAS STRUKTUR

Nilai Drift yang dipeoleh dari analiis gaya orde-1 (Etabs)

TABLE: Story Drift Response Load Combination = 3

Story Elevation Location X-Dir Y-Dir Hi
Di,3
m (MM)
Story6 19.75 Top 0.0041 0.0000 3250 13.3
Story5 16.5 Top 0.0052 0.0000 3250 16.9
Story4 13.25 Top 0.0054 0.0000 3250 17.6
Story3 10 Top 0.0056 0.0000 3250 18.3
Story2 6.75 Top 0.0053 0.0000 3250 17.2
Story1 3.5 Top 0.0023 0.0000 3500 8.1
Base 0 Top 0 0

TABLE: Story Drift Response Load Combination = 4

Story Elevation Location X-Dir Y-Dir Hi
Di,3
m (MM)
Story6 19.75 Top 0.0041 0.0000 3250 13.3
Story5 16.5 Top 0.0052 0.0000 3250 16.9
Story4 13.25 Top 0.0054 0.0000 3250 17.6
Story3 10 Top 0.0056 0.0000 3250 18.3
Story2 6.75 Top 0.0053 0.0000 3250 17.2
Story1 3.5 Top 0.0023 0.0000 3500 8.1
Base 0 Top 0.0000 0.0000

TABLE: Story Drift Response Load Combination = 5

Elevation X-Dir Hi
Story Location Y-Dir Di,5
m (MM)
Story6 19.75 Top 0.0041 0.0000 3250 13.3
Story5 16.5 Top 0.0053 0.0000 3250 17.2
Story4 13.25 Top 0.0056 0.0000 3250 18.1
Story3 10 Top 0.0055 0.0000 3250 17.8
Story2 6.75 Top 0.0051 0.0000 3250 16.5
Story1 3.5 Top 0.0024 0.0000 3500 8.2
Base 0 Top 0.0000 0.0000

TABLE: Story Drift Response Load Combination = 6

Elevation Hi
Story Location X-Dir Y-Dir Di,6
m (MM)
Story6 19.75 Top 0.0041 0.0000 3250 13.3
Story5 16.5 Top 0.0053 0.0000 3250 17.2
Story4 13.25 Top 0.0056 0.0000 3250 18.1
Story3 10 Top 0.0055 0.0000 3250 17.8
Story2 6.75 Top 0.0051 0.0000 3250 16.5
Story1 3.5 Top 0.0024 0.0000 3500 8.2
Base 0 Top 0.0000 0.0000
Nilai Pu dan Vu Kombinasi 3, 4,5 dan 6 dari analisis gaya orde-1 (ETABS)

TABLE: Story Forces : PU & VU Load Combination = 3

Output P VX
Story Case Type Step Type Location
Case kN kN
Story6 Comb3 Combination Max Bottom 913.0 122.4
Story5 Comb3 Combination Max Bottom 1954.9 184.7
Story4 Comb3 Combination Max Bottom 2996.9 215.4
Story3 Comb3 Combination Max Bottom 4482.1 256.9
Story2 Comb3 Combination Max Bottom 6031.8 314.8
Story1 Comb3 Combination Max Bottom 8055.2 373.3

TABLE: Story Forces : PU & VU Load Combination = 3

Output P VX
Story Case Type Step Type Location
Case kN kN
Story6 Comb4 Combination Max Bottom 913.0 122.4
Story5 Comb4 Combination Max Bottom 1954.9 184.7
Story4 Comb4 Combination Max Bottom 2996.9 215.4
Story3 Comb4 Combination Max Bottom 4482.1 256.9
Story2 Comb4 Combination Max Bottom 6031.8 314.8
Story1 Comb4 Combination Max Bottom 8055.2 373.3

TABLE: Story Forces : PU & VU Load Combination = 5

Output P VX
Story Case Type Step Type Location
Case kN kN
Story6 Comb5 Combination Max Bottom 304.2 122.4
Story5 Comb5 Combination Max Bottom 654.9 184.7
Story4 Comb5 Combination Max Bottom 1005.7 215.4
Story3 Comb5 Combination Max Bottom 1501.6 256.9
Story2 Comb5 Combination Max Bottom 2020.9 314.8
Story1 Comb5 Combination Max Bottom 2712.8 373.3

TABLE: Story Forces : PU & VU Load Combination = 6

Output P VX
Story Case Type Step Type Location
Case kN kN
Story6 Comb6 Combination Max Bottom 304.2 122.4
Story5 Comb6 Combination Max Bottom 654.9 184.7
Story4 Comb6 Combination Max Bottom 1005.7 215.4
Story3 Comb6 Combination Max Bottom 1501.6 256.9
Story2 Comb6 Combination Max Bottom 2020.9 314.8
Story1 Comb6 Combination Max Bottom 2712.8 373.3
Tabel evaluasi Index Stabilitas (Qi) pada masing-masing Kombinasi Beban

Lci D0,C3 VUs,C3

Lt PU,C3 (kN) Qi,C3
(MM) (MM) (kN)
6 3250 13.3 913.0 122.4 0.030
5 3250 16.9 1954.9 184.7 0.055
4 3250 17.6 2996.9 215.4 0.075
3 3250 18.3 4482.1 256.9 0.098
2 3250 17.2 6031.8 314.8 0.101
1 3500 8.1 8055.2 373.3 0.050

Lci D0,C4 VUs,C4

Lt PU,C4 (kN) Qi,C4
(MM) (MM) (kN)
6 3250 13.3 913.0 122.4 0.030
5 3250 16.9 1954.9 184.7 0.055
4 3250 17.6 2996.9 215.4 0.075
3 3250 18.3 4482.1 256.9 0.098
2 3250 17.2 6031.8 314.8 0.101
1 3500 8.1 8055.2 373.3 0.050

Lci D0,C5 VUs,C5

Lt PU,C5 (kN) Qi,C5
(MM) (MM) (kN)
6 3250 13.3 304.2 122.4 0.010
5 3250 17.2 654.9 184.7 0.019
4 3250 18.1 1005.7 215.4 0.026
3 3250 17.8 1501.6 256.9 0.032
2 3250 16.5 2020.9 314.8 0.033
1 3500 8.2 2712.8 373.3 0.017

Lci D0,C6 VUs,C6

Lt PU,C6 (kN) Qi,C6
(MM) (MM) (kN)
6 3250 13.3 304.2 122.4 0.010
5 3250 17.2 654.9 184.7 0.019
4 3250 18.1 1005.7 215.4 0.026
3 3250 17.8 1501.6 256.9 0.032
2 3250 16.5 2020.9 314.8 0.033
1 3500 8.2 2712.8 373.3 0.017
 Tabel rekap nilai Index Stabilitas pada masing-masing Kombinasi Beban

Qi,LMT-
Lt Qi,C3 Qi,C4 Qi,C5 Qi,C6 QMAX
BRFR
6 0.030 0.030 0.010 0.010 0.05 0.101
5 0.055 0.055 0.019 0.019 0.05 0.101
4 0.075 0.075 0.026 0.026 0.05 0.101
3 0.098 0.098 0.032 0.032 0.05 0.101
2 0.101 0.101 0.033 0.033 0.05 0.101
1 0.050 0.050 0.017 0.017 0.05 0.101

ASCE 7-16 atau SNI 1726-19

Sayat P-Delta effect dapat diabaikan jika Q < 0.1, namun dalam
segala hal Q <= Qmax
0.5 b 0.9 (<=1)
𝑄𝑀𝐴𝑋 = Cd 5.5
𝛽𝐶𝑑

0.5 0.5
𝑄𝑀𝐴𝑋 = = = 0.101
𝛽𝐶𝑑 1 × 5.5

Perbandingan Index Stabilitas Bangunan

7
6
5
Lantai

4
3
2
1
0
0.000 0.020 0.040 0.060 0.080 0.100 0.120
Index Stabilitas

Qi,C3 Qi,C4 Qi,C5 Qi,C6 Qi,LMT-BRFR QMAX

Dari grafik di atas disimpulkan

1 Nilai Qi pada kombinasi 3 dan 4 melampai 0.05
2 Berdasarkan point-1 disimpulkan bahwa frame yang dialamisis dikategorikan sebagai
Portar Bergoyanga, atau Un-Brace Frame, atau Sway Frame
3 Dengan menggunakan b = 0.9 nilai Qi pada lantai ke dua khususnya untuk kombinasi
3 dan 4 sudah berada pada nilai batas Qmax
4 Pada desain geser kolom harus dipastikan bahwa (Vu,demand)/(V,Capasitas) > 0.9