The document contains comments provided on a report. The comments praise the report for thoroughly explaining the proposed solution and considering limitations and improvements. Some suggestions are made to further enhance the explanation of energy transformations and to include citations from literature to support the content. Additionally, engaging with the local Kaurna people and obtaining their permission for any work is recommended to strengthen the ethical considerations. The report is assessed as worthy of a B grade.
The document contains comments provided on a report. The comments praise the report for thoroughly explaining the proposed solution and considering limitations and improvements. Some suggestions are made to further enhance the explanation of energy transformations and to include citations from literature to support the content. Additionally, engaging with the local Kaurna people and obtaining their permission for any work is recommended to strengthen the ethical considerations. The report is assessed as worthy of a B grade.
The document contains comments provided on a report. The comments praise the report for thoroughly explaining the proposed solution and considering limitations and improvements. Some suggestions are made to further enhance the explanation of energy transformations and to include citations from literature to support the content. Additionally, engaging with the local Kaurna people and obtaining their permission for any work is recommended to strengthen the ethical considerations. The report is assessed as worthy of a B grade.
Commented [MG1]: Good critiques on limitations and
how you would go about solving the problem
Commented [MG2]: If you had time, how would you have
gone about repairs and improvements? What kind of tests could be performed? Commented [MG3]: Good range of improvements, needs some explanation of how and why you would go about these improvements.
Commented [MG4]: Why didn’t it work? How could this
be improved? Commented [MG5]: What are your predictions since you were unable to test? Could they be supported by literature?
Commented [MG6]: Great explanation of your solution,
this could be enhanced by delving into the energy transformations and transference more.
Commented [MG7]: Good consideration of the Kaurna
people when it comes to ethics. To improve thought could go into what parts of their histories and culture could be affected by the CAES System. Also you would need to ask for permission as well as negotiate for use of their land.
Commented [MG8]: Great considerations and reasoning.
Commented [MG9]: This is a great supporting comment
and should be cited with literature (references).
Commented [MG10]: Good economic considerations
Commented [MG11]: Good conclusion, to improve it can be a lot more concise
Commented [MG12]: This is a new way of explaining and
should be placed elsewhere in your report. *No new information in the conclusion!
Commented [MG13]: Over the word count, try to be
more concise and picky with the content. Commented [MG14]: These references are good, and have the correct formatting. To improve cite these in text to show how they support your content Very well thought out and comprehensive report. You explained your solution very well, and had a lot of good critiques and improvements to your project. The report was well laid out and easy to follow with correct spelling and grammar. References were in the correct APA format however it could have been improved with more literature citations to support the content. More explanation on energy transfer and transformations would enhance your solution explanation. Connecting your project to the CAES System in Canada shows that you have thought about and researched technological advanced in the industry. Inclusion of the Kaurna people in your ethical considerations was very important, and well thought out. Overall this report is granted a B grade, well done