You are on page 1of 8

Children Coping with Impaired Appearance: Social

and Psychologic Influences


Ann Hill-Beuf, Ph.D.
Professor of Sociology and Anthropology, Cedar Crest College, Allentown, Pennsylvania

Judith D. R. Porter, Ph.D.


Professor of Sociology, By/n Mawr College, By/n Mawr, Pennsylvania

Abstract: Coping with impaired appearance presents difficul- ease that involves depigmentation of the skin.
ties for children. This study is based on interviews of children Patches of skin on exposed areas such as the face
with vitiligo, a disfiguring disorder that involves depigmenta- and hands, as well as other body areas, turn com-
tion of the skin, and focuses on social and psychologic factors that pletely white, leaving the patient visibly disfigured
predict effectiveness of coping. Age plays an extremely impor- by uneven color. The disease affects l%-2% of the
tant part in adjustment, with the junior high school years
population. Its cause is unknown, but once it be-
especially traumatic. Change of location or situation also is a
gins, it generally continues to spread [l]. In the
predictor of stress. Children who develop other competencies
that build self-esteem cope well with the disorder. These and majority of cases, there is no other detectable pa-
other factors are explored in depth, and strategies for helping thology; the person suffers no physical discomfort,
child patients with disfiguring disorders are suggested. lessened energy level, or fear of mortality [2]. For
this reason, vitiligo has been dismissed by many
physicians as “only a cosmetic disorder.” Yet, it
presents an excellent opportunity to focus directly
Introduction on the effect of impaired appearance alone on the
Although an increasing number of psychosocial lives of individuals. The present study examines
studies of the physically handicapped have been psychologic and social factors that affect the man-
conducted in recent years, these investigations ner in which the children in our sample reacted to
have focused primarily on the problems of adults this impairment.
who are physically incapacitated to some degree.
Less attention has been given to children and to the
victims of cosmetic disfigurement alone, whose Theoretical Considerations and
personal problems may equal those of individuals
Hypotheses
with other physical disabilities. Although there is
no organic or functional inability to perform normal American society has been described as a society
activities, impaired appearance may in itself have oriented toward a very narrow standard of beauty.
important consequences for the psychology of chil- Much research indicates that appearance has a
dren because of the social significance of ap- great deal to do with the personality traits people
pearance and the attitudes and prejudices of society will attribute to a stranger, believing physically at-
toward one whose appearance is atypical. tractive people [3] to have more socially desireable
For the past five years, we have investigated traits than others. Studies show that good-looking
psychologic and social factors causing variation in persons of both sexes are presumed to be kinder
response to cosmetic impairment in a study of adult and more intelligent than others [4,5], to have
and child patients with vitiligo, a disfiguring dis- greater internal control, competence and achieve-

General Hospital Psychiatry 6, 294-301, 1984


294 8 Elsevier Science Publishing Co., Inc. 19&p
ISSN~O163-8743/S4/!$3.00 52 Vanderbilt Avenue, New York, NY 11X17
Children Coping with Impaired Appearance

ment, to be better liked, and to lead happier and severity of deformity, but there is disagreement on
better adjusted lives [4,6-lo]. the effects of severity of the deformity on psychol-
People with visible physical handicaps or defor- ogic response. Some findings suggest that severe
mities have an appearance clearly at odds with this deformities lead to choice of “succumbing” reac-
social norm of beauty, and a number of studies tions [15,22,30]. Other studies find that the severity
indicate that handicapped persons may indeed face of the deformity is not a good predictive factor of
an atmosphere of prejudice or rejection due to their emotional response [11,33,34]. The relationship be-
physical appearance. There is a consensus among tween social factors, emotional response, and feel-
investigators that, although sometimes traits at- ings of competency has not been thoroughly inves-
tributed to the handicapped may be positive tigated for many types of handicaps, but especially
[11,12], attitudes toward the visibly handicapped for those that result only in impaired appearance.
are more frequently negative in direction [11,13,14]. The special importance of appearance during
The social problems faced when the handicapped youth, especially during adolescence, is a hallmark
attempt to interact with the nonhandicapped have of American society [35]. Further, the strained in-
been delineated by a number of investigators. In- teractions that can result when a visibly disfigured
teractions are often strained and tension-producing child encounters others may have implications for
and marked by stilted and artificial communication, the development of overall sense of self in the child
both verbal and nonverbal, especially with strang- [35-371.
ers or casual acquaintances [15-201. In addition, While Coopersmith did not find a relationship
impaired individuals themselves may exhibit dis- between appearance and self-esteem, other re-
comfort and strain or inhibition in social rela- searchers have maintained that feelings about
tionships with those who are nonimpaired and may oneself, especially when appearance is impaired,
anticipate discriminatory interaction with the non- do influence the child’s feelings of self-worth
handicapped [12,21]. [15,16,38]. Douvan stresses the importance of body
Although much of the existing research deals image in self-esteem during puberty [35].
with problems of the physically disabled, less atten- Coopersmith’s notion of the dimensions of self-
tion has been given to people with cosmetic dis- esteem itself can be linked indirectly to appearance.
figurements involving the skin or face, which are Coopersmith states that self-esteem rests on four
not connected with an organic disability [11,22]. characteristics:
Existing research in this area, in fact, suggests that
1. a child’s feelings of being loved by others
the cosmetically or facially disfigured may have
2. a sense of competency or personal efficiency
problems that equal or exceed those with other
3. a positive regard for his or her own ethics
body afflictions because of the social significance of
4. a feeling that he or she has control over their
the skin or face [11,22-251. Facial disfigurements
own lives or other people [38].
are ranked among the least desireable handicaps by
both children and adults [17,26]. Adults are less
likely to help a facially disfigured than a non-
Competency
disfigured victim [27]. Facially disfigured indi-
viduals are well aware of negative social attitudes Certainly, the negative reaction of others to im-
toward them and either experience or anticipate paired appearance could diminish a child’s sense of
discrimination in a number of realms [21,23]. As a being loved. Coopersmith’s second and fourth di-
result, many people with either facial or skin im- mensions of self-esteem suggest the importance of
pairments experience psychologic problems such feelings of competency and control in personal abil-
as self-consciousness, feelings of inferiority, and ity to respond to impaired appearance.
withdrawal that become more grave than the phys- Erikson also notes the importance of such com-
ical impairment [11,23,25,28-301. Adjustment in petency feelings. In the stages of Industry and Ini-
these cases varies by personality, social factors, and tiative as well as later, adolescent and young adult
type of disorder [23,24,31,32]. stages stress the importance of developing interests
and skills [39]. This focus suggests that children
who have a sense of competency will be better able
Visibdity of Deformity to cope with impaired appearance: they are likely to
One factor that has been studied with regard to the have higher self-esteem to begin with and their self-
emotional impact of impaired appearance is the esteem does not rest on appearance. Also, such

295
A. Hill-Beuf and J. D. R. Porter

children, being interested and active in whatever concern with appearance to fade as we move into
their “fields” may be, are likely to be much less the older teens.
concerned with appearance in general. This study focuses primarily on age, visibility of
impaired appearance, and feelings of competency
as factors that influence children’s responses to
vitiligo. Some other factors that also contribute to
childrens reactions to this condition will be noted.
There is little research on the importance of age (or These are social class, gender, family stress, and
developmental stage) on the child’s ability to cope treatment mode.
with impaired appearance. Applying the develop-
mental scheme of Erikson, we should expect the
preschool years to be devoted to the acquisition of Procedure
ego skills [39]. Here too, impaired appearance
could contribute to strained interaction within the We conducted exploratory, in-depth interviews
primary group. with 19 child patients at two northeastern medical
During the elementary school years, the central centers that were associated with our 5-year vitiligo
developmental task confronting the child is the study. Both centers have special vitiligo clinics and
mastering of the technology of his or her society- both are associated with medical schools: Clinic A,
be it bow and arrow or complicated reading and with a traditional Ivy League school, Clinic B with a
mathematical skills. It is a time of learning, of gain- prominant Black university.
ing a sense of the competence of self. Any factor Initially, we intended to obtain questionnaires
that prevents this sense of mastery, threatens the and interviews for each child. This plan was dis-
psychologic well-being of the child at this stage in missed for several reasons. First, the questionnaires
the life cycle [39]. we obtained from “children” during the first year
In addition, the importance of mastering one’s of study frequently had been filled out by parents
body-also an important aspect of this stage of and it was impossible to determine whether the
development-is being learned through sports, opinions and feelings expressed were those of the
dance, and other physical activity. Competency children or the parents. In addition, by the fourth
could, as stated above, help the child. However, year of the study the pool of child patients from the
bad experiences at school related to appearance first year had been diminished as children grew
could slow the acquisition of competency feelings. into early adulthood or moved to other parts of the
Erikson calls the adolescent years the Stage of country. Therefore, we decided to individually in-
Identity [39]. Others have noted that appearance terview each child on treatment and to include
becomes an important aspect of one’s sense of self more recent patients.
in the teens [35-371. This is true of children of both A “child patient” is defined as a person between
sexes, but is especially important for girls. Being the ages of 3 and 18 years of age who has vitiligo
like others, belonging to the group, feeling accept- and has sought medical treatment at either Clinic A
ed as a person are all key factors for the young or B. All such patients were contacted by telephone
person of this age [37,39]. Feelings of well-being and asked to be interviewed. Only the parents of
have been linked to the degree of happiness experi- these nineteen patients consented.
enced in terms of satisfaction with appearance dur- Each child was interviewed alone. She or he was
ing adolescence [36]. These feelings and the confi- asked to discuss the history of the vitiligo and the
dence they bring with them may carry over well path to treatment. We also asked the children the
into the adult years [36]. feelings they had had about vitiligo, what experi-
This suggests that while younger children may ences they had had with other people because of
be preoccupied with other concerns, the adoles- vitiligo, what kinds of situations made them anx-
cent, especially the younger adolescent for whom ious about vitiligo, and whether they thought that
body image is of great importance, would be the their reaction to vitiligo has changed over time. We
most embarrassed by impaired appearance. Older asked about support sources: to whom can the child
adolescents have to concern themselves with more turn when an unpleasant incident occurs? The use
demanding issues: whether or not to attend col- of “cover up” techniques-cosmetics, clothing-
lege, which career or occupation to pursue, the was discussed with children of an appropriate age.
selection of a mate. Thus, we might expect extreme We asked each child to consider the situation of a

296
Children Coping with Impaired Appearance

child his or her own age and sex who had just have brought them to two of the most highly spe-
experienced the onset of vitiligo. We then asked the cialized treatment centers in the country. Some-
child “What advice would you give to this per- times, parents have done this despite a laissezfaire
son?“; “What advice would you give his parents?” attitude on the part of the family physician. One
and “What advice would you give his teacher?” suspects that child.ren with the lowest family sup-
In addition, the parents of each child were inter- port are untreated children who do not fall within
viewed on the history of the disorder, the child’s our sample.
emotional response to vitiligo and the success of As we will see, the major factors associated with
treatment.l They were given an explanation of the the children’s responses to vitiligo are: (1) the exis-
social science part of the research project and reas- tence of what we shall call a “competency feeling”
sured regarding the anonymity of all subjects. as indicated by the childs consuming interest in an
The childrens’ interviews themselves suggested activity, the acquisition of a skill, or the develop-
four classifications of response to vitiligo: (1) the ment of a talent; and (2) social developmental age.
child reported some negative incidents associated Visibility actually played a less important role
with vitiligo, but the child was only mildly con- than either of these variables, though its impor-
cerned with the disorder and seemed well adjusted; tance should not be understated. To a lesser extent,
(2) the child was moderately concerned with vitiligo family stress, social class, gender, and type of treat-
and worries about appearance, but was not de- ment the child-patient receives also can influence
pressed, withdrawn, or preoccupied with it; (3) the the child’s reaction to vitiligo. The impact of race is
child was very concerned about vitiligo and ex- an important consideration. However, as our black
presses this concern through preoccupation, de- patients were also the more visibly afflicted and
pression, or withdrawal; (4) the child was very con- were also concentrated in one treatment group, it is
cerned and expressed this through hostility and difficult to separate the effect of race alone.
anger,
Visibility will be treated in this report as “face”
and “not face.” Our interviews with adults and Developmental Age
children made it clear to us that facial vitiligo is by
far the most worrisome to patients. Another reason Children of different ages experience vitiligo differ-
for using this rather simple form of classification is ently. (See Table 1.) Age often interacts with an-
the significance of the face in determining the other dimension of life, Transition, to pose crisis
nature of interpersonal interactions. points for the child.
We were also concerned with the child’s feelings The young child (3-6) seems relatively un-
of competency. This issue was explored by asking affected by vitiligo, even when the disorder is quite
the child a series of questions about interests in and visible. Children of this age are still quite centered
out of the classroom, hobbies, sports, and ac- on family and self. A loving set of parents can
tivities, and career and vocational aspirations. In- provide a fortress against the hurts that come later
formation in this area was obtained from the par- as their social worlds expand. These children are
ents in addition.
Furthermore, we asked parents about any family
strains or tensions that might have an impact on the Table 1. Age and emotional responsed vitiligo
-
child, noting as well any parental emotional re-
Emotional response
sponse to the impaired appearance of the child.
However, one cannot assess the quality of family Age Mild Moderate Very worried Anger N
life in a single interview. Therefore, we did not
attempt to classify family support. In situations 4 1 1
where extreme tension or special problems were 6 2 1 3
confided to us by the child or the parent, we did 8 1 1
9 3 3
take note of it. We must be aware, however, that
10 2 3
there is a certain homogeneity to the sample in their 13 1 1 1 3
being at the clinics at all. That is, most of the chil- 16 4 4
dren we saw have fairly supportive families who 18 1 1
N= 12 4 1 2 19
‘One child came alone.

297
A. Hill-Beuf and J. D. R. Porter

able to believe that they are, indeed, beautiful be- tioned by several children. This seems to be the
cause their mothers say they are, despite very visi- most difficult age for children.
ble and disfiguring cases of vitiligo. In addition, life Older teens, while still somewhat concerned
holds so many challenges and satisfactions for about appearance, seem to derive compensatory
them that they do not tend to focus much on ap- satisfaction from the acquisition of skills with which
pearance. One of the most delightful of our sub- they can later obtain a job, by sports or artistic
jects, a young boy of four with widespread and abilities, and by relationships with their peers.
visible vitiligo, exempIified this exuberance for life. An interesting example of these trends is to be
This child made friends with everyone in the wait- found in the case of “R,” a 16-year-old white male
ing room, drew many pictures during the period who was treated at Clinic A. He had had vitiligo
between the interview and his treatment, wrote the since early childhood. Both R. and his mother re-
entire alphabet several times (each time with a dif- ported little concern about vitiligo during the ele-
ferent color of ink), wrote all numbers from 1 to 20 mentary school years. However, in the year prior to
several times, looked at and commented upon all of going to junior high school and during the junior
the pictures in the hall and, in general, was quite high school years, R. became extremely self-con-
engaged with his environment throughout his visit. scious about his appearance, very shy in new social
Another 4-year old with severe facial vitiligo con- situations, and also became quite withdrawn. His
fided that she spends most of her “free” time mak- parents were very concerned. R. had other prob-
ing books. She illustrates and composes the text lems at this time and one suspects that vitiligo
with some adult help. became the lightening rod for a number of these
This pattern of minor difficulty as a result of concerns. He was not a good student and when
vitiligo seems to continue throughout most of early other boys began to mature, he still was a child
childhood. There is some evidence in the case of the physically.
6-year old that the first year of school may be an Now, at sixteen, we found a quite different
exception to this. It involves concern about meeting young man. His vitiligo is still visible, but he is little
new people, leaving the protective environment of concerned with it. In examining his new situation,
the home and having to conform to new sets of we find that he has accomplished the early resolu-
norms. Being called names or teased at school may tion of several Eriksonian psychologic tasks. The
cause the child much distress. However, this situa- child and his mother, interviewed separately, both
tion seems to abate as the child begins to feel more attribute his new adjustment to three factors. The
at ease in school and becomes known by peers. first is his transferral to a vocational school where
A more impressive change seems to occur in the he is learning carpentry. He is very excited about
prepubertal years and in some cases it endures carpentry and looks forward to spending his life at
through the early teens. This period (10-13) is it. Second, at fifteen, his physical maturation took
marked by anxiety about appearance, a greatly in- place. He has caught up to other boys in terms of
creased amount of time spent thinking about height, weight, and secondary sex characteristics.
vitiligo, efforts at cover-up, profound shyness Third, he has a steady girlfriend who “doesn’t
around new people and extreme modesty with care” about his vitiligo and with whom he has a
one’s peers. Of course, some of these factors are very warm and open relationship.
simply a part of normal adolescent development. The age-related changes in emotional response
However, in our patients, anxieties are accentuated
because they feel they have something to be Table 2. Changes in patients’ response to vitiligo
ashamed of and to hide. Nor does physiologic ado-
bY age
lescence seem to be the only factor here.
According to the children and their parents, the Change Change
change occurs in anticipation of another transi- No change for better for worse
tion-the move up to junior high or high school
Anxieties arise about the new location and larger 4-8 5
size of the school and the higher level of academic 9 2 1
expectations (which seem to heighten the sense of 10 3
13 1 1 1
visibility). Concern about dating is present.
16 4
Body/beauty concerns triggered by the high school
18 just diagnosed
practice of group showering for sports were men-

298
Children Coping with Impaired Appearance

that were noted by the parents as well as the chil- more active involvement with community and
dren confirm this pattern. The parents of elemen- work by those who cope better [40].
tary school children reported no changes; the par-
ents of pre-junior high and junior high school
students note a change for the worse as do the
Social Class
children themselves; and the parents of high school While social class was not a very powerful variable,
students and the patients themselves note a change it did appear that smaller working class and poor
for the better (Table 2). children encounter more teasing in school and in
the neighborhood. On the other hand, in adoles-
cence, the working class child seemed to have some
Feelings of Competency advantage. As the working class children planned
One of the most interesting aspects of the inter- to work directly after high school, they were al-
views was the importance of feelings of competen- ready mastering the skills with which they would
cy in the children for overcoming the negative later earn a living. As noted above, competency
impact of their impaired appearance. One can al- feelings mitigate against overconcern with ap-
ready see this, above, in the four-year-old boy excit- pearance. The middle class child is more likely to be
ed about his alphabet, the little girl who writes preparing for college and not yet acquiring the actu-
books, and the young man who is so enthusiastic al skills required for a job.
about his future as a carpenter.
There were fascinating cases in this study where
children who have severe and highly visible cases
Treatment Mode
of vitiligo on their faces are nonetheless doing very The two clinics have different modes of treatment.
well in terms of adjustment and coping. In these At Clinic A, most children are given medication and
cases, we find an avid interest in the acquisition and instructions for treatment to take home with them.
use of new skills and abilities. This indicates that It is then up to the patients to maintain the regimen.
the satisfaction of ego and competency needs can Most of those interviewed there had had summer
go a long way in compensating for the degree of treatment only-soralens plus sun. At Clinic B, the
impairment in appearance. Table 3 shows the im- children are treated weekly at the clinic with
pressive relationship between such feelings of com- soralen and P.U.V.A. (ultra-violet light).
petency and a milder emotional response to im- While it is not the charge of the social scientist to
paired appearance. Regardless of visibility, all the assess the success of treatment, what we cun report
children with competency feelings report only mild is that the Clinic B patients as a group are more
emotional response to vitiligo. likely to be optimistic about vitiligo. While several
This seems of considerable importance because it Clinic A patients had dropped out of treatment,
suggests the therapeutic power of mastering one’s only one Clinic B patient had done so.
environment. The ego strength of these children is When we put this tendency together with basic
being fortified constantly by the joy that comes child psychology we can see that, for youth, a fairly
from a sense of increased competency. (Note that firm hand and a structured routine are more effec-
the responses are similarly distributed by visibility tive modes of treatment. Children and adolescents
categories. “Face” alone does not determine re- are short on patience and the Clinic B program
sponse.) This fits with our adult data indicating literally forces them to stay on their regimen.

Table 3. Visibility, competency feeling, and response

Response

Visibility competency Mild Moderate Very worried Denial

Face Yes 6
No 1 1 1
Yes 6
Non Face
No 3 1
N= 12 4 1 2

299
A. Hi-Beuf and J. D. R. Porter

What probably’happens at Clinic B is a “cycle of and 13. The girl had vitiligo on her face. Both have
success.” Treated more intensively, the children experienced recent transitions in their lives. Nei-
make some actual improvements. This rewards ther reports an avid interest, skill, or hobby. The
participation in routine treatment and perpetuates father of the male patient returned from Vietnam
it. More gains are then made and the cycle contin- with severe psychologic problems. The girl’s moth-
ues. er is over-identified with the child and cries fre-
quently at the clinic about the prospect of the girl’s
future in the marriage market because of impaired
Gender appearance. Both situations suggest the absence of
There was little difference in response by gender. very supportive family situations for the children.
Certainly, boys are as upset about vitiligo as girls. Emotional response to impaired appearance in
The notion that appearance is more important to children thus seems to be determined by no one
girls was not confirmed here. It is worth noting that variable, but by the interplay of visibility, feelings
our only two “anger/hostility” responses are male. of competency, family support, type of treatment
This suggests that while members of the two gen- program, and age.
ders are equally disturbed by impaired appearance,
this disturbance may be expresseddifferently. This is
consistent with our quantitative survey and inter- Policy Implications
view data from adults. The age of the child should be taken into account in
assessing the response to vitiligo. Prepubertal or
early adolescent onset is likely to have a more ad-
Anger and Withdrawal verse effect than others. A child with vitiligo who is
One step toward understanding the interplay of the entering new situations because of a family move or
many factors contributing to response to impaired a change in school will require special help.
appearance is to examine our three most severely The physician should realize that competency
affected children. Table 4 outlines some of the fac- and a sense of mastery can offset some of the ad-
tors at work in their lives. verse effects of vitiligo. This suggests the use of
As noted above, the pattern of male anger and occupational therapy with some youngsters, or the
female depression and withdrawal is typical of our suggestion to parents that the child be given music,
larger sample. The oldest of these patients, a black art, or other lessons. A child who is already lacking
male of 18, is a very recent case and the severity of in a sense of competency and then is afflicted with
his reaction may certainly be attributable to that, vitiligo may require emotional therapy.
partly from shock, partly from having had little It seems that a routine, year round, closely
treatment yet. In addition, it is a bizarre and visible monitored mode of therapy is more effective in
case of unilateral vitiligo. It is as if a line had been treating children. It is too much to ask of a develop-
drawn down the middle of his face leaving the right ing child that he or she monitor, organize, and be
side an almost movie-star handsome brown and the totally responsible for his or her own treatment.
left mottled and depigmented. In addition to high Laxity in treatment postpones the sense of opti-
visibility, we also note the absence of the father and mism that can come from even a minor gain and
a lack of interest in school, job, or any activity. thus leads to an even greater casualness about
Hopefully, treatment, if it is at all successful, will treatment.
begin to lift his spirits. The nurse, dermatologist, or general practitioner
The other two cases are white children, aged 10 who encounters a child in whom many “negative”

Table 4. Characteristics of the three children most disturbed by impaired appearance

Family Feelings of Dislocation


Visibility Race Gender Age stress competency or moves Response

On face Bl Male 18 N.A. No Yes Anger/denial


Not on face Wh Male 13 Yes No Yes Anger/denial
On face Wh Female 10 Yes No Yes Worry-depressed

300
Chiidren Coping with Impaired Appearance

factors are contributing to poor response (poor fam- vention of the American Psychological Association.
ily support, high visibility, low competency feel- 3653-653, 1968
20. KIeck R: Physical stigma and non-verbal cures emit-
ings, junior high school age) should consider refer- ted in face-to-face interaction. Hum Rel 21:19-28,
ring the child for psychologic assistance. 1968
21. Kleck R, Strenta A: Perceptions of the impact of nega-
Research for this article was carried out with the support of a National
tively valued physical characteristics on social in-
Institute of Health Research Grant.
teraction. J Personal Sot Psycho1 39:861-873, 1980
22. Barker R, Wright 8, Myerson L, Gonick M: Adjust-
References ment to physical handicaps and illness: A survey of
the social psychology of disability. Bulletin #53. New
1. Lemer A: Vitiligo. J Invest Dermat. 32:285-310, 1959 York, Social Science Research Council, 1953
2. Lemer A, Nordlund J: Vitiligo. What is it? Is it impor- 23. Mcgregor F: Some psycho-social problems associ-
tant? J Amer Med Assoc. 239:1183-1187, 1972 ated with facial deformities. Amer Sot Rev. 16:629-
3. Dwyer J, Mcquiro J: Psychological effects of varia- 630, 1951
tions in physical appearance during adolescence. Ad- 24. Casileth B, Lusk E, Tenaglia A: A psychological com-
olescence 353-358, 1968 parison of patients with malignant melanoma and
4. Miller A: Role of physical attractiveness in impres- other dermatologist disorders. J Amer Acad Dermat
sion formation. Psychonom Sci 19:103-109, 1970 7~742-746, 1982
5. Dion K: What is beautiful is good. J Personal Sot 25. Nadelson T: A person’s boundaries: The meaning of
Psycho1 24:215-220, 1972 skin disease. Cutis 21:90-94, 1978
6. Cash T, Begley P: Internal-external control, achieve- 26. Goodman N, Richardson S, Dombush S, Hastorf A:
ment orientation and physical attractiveness. Psy- Variant reactions to physical disabilities. Amer Sot
chol Rep 38:1205-1206, 1976 Rev 28:429-429, 1963
7. McKelore S, Matthews J: Effects of physical attrac- 27. Piliavin I et al: Costs, diffusion, and the stigmatized
tiveness and favorableness of character on liking. victim. J Personal Sot Psycho1 32:429-438, 1975
Psycholog Rep 38:1223-1230, 1976 28. Levinski R, Kass I: Functional disturbances associ-
8. Bersheid B, Walster E: Physical attractiveness. In ated with ichthyosis. J Psycho1 13:173-177, 1942
Berkowitz L. (ed). Advances in Experimental Social 29. Whitlock F: Psychophysiological Aspects of Skin Dis-
Psychology. New York, Academic Press, vol47,1974 ease. London, W. B. Saunders, Ltd., 1976
9. Landy D, Sigall H: Beauty is talent: Task evaluation as 30. Shuster S, Fisher G, Harris E, Binnell D: The effects of
a function of the performers physical attractiveness. J skin disease on self-image. Br J Dermat 99:18-19,
Personal Sot Psycho1 39:861-873, 1974 1978
10. Cash T, Kahr J, Polyson J, Freeman V: Role of phys- 31. Brown D, Bettley: Psychiatric treatment of exzema: A
ical attractiveness in peer attribution of psychological controlled trial. Br Med J 2:729-734, 1971
disturbance. J Consult Clin Psycho1 45:987-993,1977 32. Roegnik R, Roegnik H: Sex differences in the psycho-
11. Wright B: Physical Disability: A Psychological Ap- logical effect of psoriasis. Cutis. 21:529-533, 1978
proach. New York, Harper and Row, 1960 33. Mcgregor F: Facial Deformities and Plastic Surgery.
12. Comer R, Piliavin J: The effects of physical deviance New York, Charles Thomas, 1953
upon face-to-face interactions: The other side. J Per- 34. Porter J, Beuf A, Nordlund J, Lemer A: Personal
sonal Sot Psycho1 23:33-39, 1972 response of patients to vitiligo. The importance of
13. Centers L, Centers R: Peer group attitudes toward physician-patient interaction. Arch Dermat
the amputic child. J Sot Psycho1 2333-39, 1963 114:1384-1385, 1979
14. Siller J, Ferguson L, Vann D, Holland B: Structure of 35. Douvan E: New sources of conflict in females in ado-
attitudes toward the physically disabled: The dis- lescence and early adulthood. In Bardwick J (ed).
ability factor scale: Amputation, blindness, cosmetic Feminine Personality and Conflict. Belmont, CA,
conditions. Proceedings of the 76th Annual Conven- Brooks/Cole, 1970
tion American Psychological Association, 651-652, 36. Berscheid E, Walster N, Bahensteit C: The happy
1968 american body: A survey report. Psycho1 Today.
15. Goffman E: Stigma, Notes on the Management of 7:119-131, 1973
Spoiled Identity. Englewood Cliffs, NJ, Prentice- 37. Sorenson RC: Adolescent Sexuality in Contemporary
Hall, 1963 America. New York, World, 1973
16. Davis F: Deviance disavowal: The management of 38. Coopersmith S: Antecedents of Self-Esteem. San
strained interaction by the visibly handicapped. Sot Francisco, W. H. Freeman, 1967
Prob 9:120-132, 1961 39. Erikson E: Childhood and Society. New York, W. W.
17. Richardson S, Goodman H, Hastorf A, Dombusch S: Norton, 1963
Cultural uniformity in reaction to physical dis- 40. Porter J, Beuf A: 1983 Final Report; 1979-1983: Social
abilities. Amer Sociolog Rev 26:241-247, 1961 and Psychological Effects of Vitiligo. (Unpublished)
18. Kleck R, Ono H, Hastorf A: Effects of physical de-
viance upon face-to-face interaction. Hum Rel
19:425-436, 1966 Direct reprint requests to:
19. Wolfgang, Wolfgang: Personal space: An unob-
Judith D. R. Porter, Ph.D.
trusive measure of attitudes toward the physically Bryn Mawr College
handicapped. Proceedings of the 76th Annual Con- Bryn Mawr, PA 19010

301

You might also like