Professional Documents
Culture Documents
APT Volume 2 Issue 1 Pages 29-38
APT Volume 2 Issue 1 Pages 29-38
Clinical trial
Abstract
ARTICLEINFO
The prevalence of Coronavirus disease (COVID-19) has been associated with many
psychological problems and concerns. This study aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of
Received: 04/25/2022 virtual acceptance and commitment group therapy on mental health in women undergoing
Accepted: 08/12/2022 Covid-19 treatment. This study was a randomized controlled trial and a quasi-experimental
with a pre-test and post-test design. The statistical population included women undergoing
Covid-19 treatment living in Ardakan, Yazd, Iran. Eighteen participants were randomly and
equally divided into two groups of 9 cases, including the experimental and control groups.
The participants answered the Lovibond Psychological Questionnaire (1995) in the pre-test
and post-test stages. The experimental group received virtual-based acceptance and
commitment group therapy intervention in 8 one-hour sessions, two sessions per week.
In contrast, the control group did not receive any intervention during the study. Finally, the
Corresponding author data were analyzed by the covariance analysis method at the significance level of 0.05. The
Department of
results showed that the mean score of mental health and its dimensions (depression,
Pharmacology, School of
Pharmacy, Main Campus anxiety, and stress) in the experimental group compared to the control group decreased
of Shahid Sadoughi significantly in the post-test stage (P<0.001). According to the research results, virtual
University of Medical acceptance and commitment to group therapy can effectively reduce the psychological
Sciences, Shohadaye
Gomnam St, Yazd, Iran. problems of people suffering from COVID-19.
Tel: +983538243419-20
E-mail
mzabihi100@gmail.com
Keywords: COVID-19, Mental health, Acceptance and Commitment, Group therapy, Depression, Anxiety, Stress
Citation: Shomali Ahmadabadi M, Barkhordari Ahmadabad A, Zabihi M. The Effectiveness of Virtual Acceptance and Commitment Group
Therapy on Mental Health in Women with Corona Anxiety undergoing Covid-19 Treatment. Adv Pharmacol Ther J. 2022;2(1): 29-38.
Adv Pharmacol Ther J. 2022;2(1) Shomali Ahmadabadi et al.
patients of Covid-19 may be concerned about the group with random assignment. The statistical
side effects of Covid-19 drugs, which may population included women undergoing Covid-19
increase their mental health problems (20). treatment suffering from psychological disorders
Increased mental health in the quarantine in Ardakan, Yazd, Iran. Research participants
conditions of COVID-19 indicates the need for were patients infected with Covid-19 based on
the use of a therapeutic intervention. One recently positive results of PCR tests during the fourth
considered therapy is acceptance and commitment peak of the Coronavirus outbreak and were under
therapy (ACT) (18). ACT, introduced by Steven the common treatment. In terms of the severity of
Hayes (21), is the only intervention in which the disease, the patients had mild symptoms and
commitment and mindfulness strategies and were able to receive the education. The evocation
behavioral change strategies are used to increase announcement of Coronavirus anxiety and virtual
psychological resilience (22). Many people in Psychological Questionnaire distribution
stressful conditions, such as the outbreak of recognized qualified people. One hundred thirteen
COVID-19, have made great efforts to eliminate participants answered the virtual questionnaire.
their unpleasant psychological symptoms (23). The research tools were designed to invite
Various studies have shown the effectiveness and participants would be invited to participate in an
efficiency of ACT in improving the mental health online survey if they scored sufficiently (point
components in outbreaks (24, 25). Different above %50 on the Corona Virus Anxiety Scale
studies show that treatment based on ACT would and receiving Covid-9 treatment). They were
be effective for depression and anxiety (26, 27), given a link to join a virtual group in the
stress (23, 28, 29), and can reduce psychological Telegram application. Thirty-four participants
distress (30-32). Despite the benefits of ACT, its were entered into the research through this
use in situations such as the outbreak of COVID- channel. Eighteen people of participants with high
19 has received less attention. Moreover, most of scores on the Covid-19 anxiety scale were asked
the research conducted in terms of method, type with other research criteria to participate in the
of intervention, and research community differ next step. Selected ones were randomly and
from the present study. Therefore, according to equally divided into two groups of 9, including
the existing research gap, this study was the experimental and control groups. The
conducted on the effectiveness of virtual participants answered the pre-test of depression,
acceptance and commitment group therapy on Anxiety and Stress Questionnaire (DASS-21).
mental health in women with anxiety of the Covid Inclusion criteria were the patient under Covid-19
19 under the medical treatment of it. treatment, obtaining at least 21 points from the
Anxiety Questionnaire, suffering from stress and
Methods
depression, interest in attending meetings, and not
The present study was a quasi-experimental one attending another study simultaneously. Exclusion
with a pre-test and post-test design and a control criteria were considered unwillingness to continue
participation and non-compliance with the rules. Lovibond's anxiety, stress, and depression
Ethical considerations were observed using questionnaire (DASS-21) was used to measure
anonymous questionnaires, the confidentiality of psychological anxiety. The short form of this
the questionnaires, and the right of the participant scale has 21 items, prepared in 1995 by Lovibond.
to withdraw from the study. The items are shown on 4 degrees Likert scale
from zero (never) to three (very much), and the
Research Tools higher score indicates much more severe
symptoms. Depression, anxiety, and stress are
The Corona Virus Anxiety Scale
each estimated by seven items. The reliability and
This questionnaire is prepared and validated by viability of this research for the Iranian samples
Alipour et al. to evaluate the anxiety of were reported to be appropriate. Retail correlation
Coronavirus prevalence in Iran. The final version of depression scale with Beck Depression test was
of this tool includes 18 items and 2 components. computed at 0.7, retail correlation of anxiety scale
This tool is organized into 4 choices from never with Zank, anxiety Self-Assessment scale 0.67,
(1) to always (3). Items 1 to 9 are related and retail correlation of Stress scale with
components to psychological symptoms, and perceived stress scale 0.49 (33).
items 10 to 18 are related to physical symptoms.
Procedure
Total Corona anxiety score is achieved by adding
each item. Total number changes between 0 to 54. After selecting experimental and control groups,
Higher scores in this questionnaire show a higher explanations about the time and way of the
level of anxiety in people. Alipour et al. reported meeting were presented virtually to each
the reliability of this questionnaire by using experimental group participant. Furthermore, the
Cronbach's alpha for psychological factor (0.879), control group was guaranteed to participate in
physical factor (0.861), and total questionnaire teaching meetings after the experimental group
(0.919). The ƛ-9 Guttman earned 0.882 for the meetings were finished. The experimental group
first factor, 0.864 for the second factor, and 0.992 received virtual ACT in two sessions per week;
for the whole questionnaire. The reliability was each session was 1 hour. The meetings were held
computed by correlating this tool with GHQ-12. twice a week, from 9 pm to 10 pm, on the
Corona Virus anxiety questionnaire correlation Skyroom platform. Experimental group
with a total score of GHQ-12 and anxiety participants received some teaching methods
components, physical symptoms, society, and according to an organized teaching protocol. The
depression dysfunction was reported as 0.48, 0.52, participants' questions were replied to in private
0.42, 0.33, and 0.27, respectively (5). after the meeting. The control group did not
receive any training at that time. Both groups
Anxiety, Stress, and Depression
virtually answered the research questionnaire after
Questionnaire Conclusion the sessions finished. The data were analyzed
statistically by SPSS-25 software and the based in the book Embracing your demons (33). A
Covariance Analysis test. The researcher designed summary of acceptance and commitment therapy
the group therapy protocol based on the ACT sessions is provided in Table 1.
Table 1. A summary of acceptance and commitment therapy
Sessions Description of Sessions(meetings)
Expressing the goals, building trust and treatment relation, negotiating about COVID-19 disease, participants' beliefs
First and behavior survey, participants' expectations from meetings, setting rules & commitments, negotiating for
treatment, acceptance & commitments and goals.
Negotiating about familiarity with symptoms, transmission ways & prevention ways, also the reasons for COVID-19
anxiety, to survey
Second
participants' beliefs and behavior related to efforts for COVID-19' stress and anxiety & its consequences, to introduce
treatment based on acceptance & commitments, to get the feedback & to deliver the assignments
To check the assignments, To teach 0 strong beliefs that invite the individual to a challenge will never success,
Third Beliefs against humanism beliefs, To derivate creation of negative thoughts & feelings, To negotiate about how
individual learn controlling hallucination? , to get the feedback & to deliver the assignments
To check the assignments about how feelings control cause new problems, to survey the ways humans use to escape
Fourth
or avoid awkward feelings(fight or flight), to get feedback & to deliver the assignments
To check the assignments, to teach six arranged phenomena based on acceptance & commitments, division, to make
Fifth space or being disclosed, connection, self- sighting, commitments & values, to teach different techniques: 0.
Division:
mindfulness+ values+ commitments- psyco_flexibility , 9. Musical mind technique, 3. To name mind stories, to get
Sixth
the feedback & to deliver the assignments
To check the assignments, to negotiate around how to understand & believe in mind stories, Not to stick to present
Seventh beliefs, to focus on everything is happening now instead of attention for auto-beliefs that mind says, To teach 2 ways
to lessngetting serious the minds, 1. Mind gratitude, 2. Crazy noise, to get the feedback & to deliver the assignments
To check the assignments, To negotiate around this if a thought is serious what will occur? To survey whether this
Eights thought is effective. To explain the real meaning of acceptance in the view based on acceptance & commitments, To
make preparedness for ending the sessions, to get the feedback & to deliver the assignments
Ninth To check the assignments, to add up, to answer the participants' questions, and to complete them after the test.
Table 2. The average and deviations of variable scores for test phases and experimental & control groups separately
Group Stage Minimum Maximum Mean Std. Deviation
Findings showed that the average and deviation and stress. While, both groups had different scores
scores for participants in the experimental and in the post-test (Table 2). The covariance analysis
control groups in the pre-test did not show a high defaults are shown in Table 2.
difference in mental health, depression, anxiety
Table 2. The covariance analysis defaults
Variable Group Shapiro-Wilk Homogeneity of Levene's Test2 Box's Test1
Regression Slopes
1
.Box's Test of Equality of Covariance Matrices 2. Levene's Test of Equality of Error Variances
The results showed that all the assumptions of the correctly (P> 0.05), and the use of this test was
analysis of covariance have been observed allowed (Table 3,4).
Page 34 DOI: https://doi.org/10.18502/aptj.v2i1.10656
Adv Pharmacol Ther J. 2022;2(1) Mental Health in Covid-19
Group Pillai's Trace 0.838 18.931b 3.000 11.000 .000 0.838 1.000
Roy's Largest Root 5.163 18.931b 3.000 11.000 .000 .838 1.000
Tables 3 and 4 show Covariance analysis results under the medical treatment of it. The results
to survey the significance of average differences showed that implementing group therapy virtually
in depression, anxiety and stress variables. After based on the ACT has significantly reduced
controlling the pre-test, the post-test differences depression, anxiety, and stress scores in the
between the experimental and control groups were experimental group.
significant in all variables (P<0.001).
The results of this research are in line with the
Accordingly, it can be said that treatment group
findings obtained from Kakavand et al. (29),
that was based on acceptance and commitment to
Polakanahu et al. (2019), Azemi et al. (30), and
virtual method had affected depression, anxiety
Alavi et al. (31). Zemestani et al. evaluated the
and stress of women with Corona anxiety under
effectiveness of ACT on depression and anxiety
the medical treatment of Covid-19 (Table 3, 4)
of mothers with children with attention deficit
al. concluded that ACT reduced psychological be spent on achieving goals instead of eliminating
flexibility by improving psychological resilience. his thoughts and emotions, which is the goal of
There are some psychological problems. Thus, life. Psychotherapy with ACT first teaches people
these interventions can improve psychological that trying to stop negative thoughts and emotions
flexibility and decrease psychological issues such will increase psychological distress. They learn to
as depression, anxiety, and stress by altering accept these thoughts and emotions and try to
individuals' perceptions of not threateningly restore and achieve their values in a committed
recognizing the symptoms of psychological way.
disorders and changing their relationship to their The most important limitations of the present
thoughts and feelings (32). study were the small number of samples, the
impossibility of holding face-to-face meetings due
Pirhayati and Barghi Irani evaluated the
to the prevalence and risk of Covid-19, the lack of
effectiveness of ACT on mental health and
follow-up period, and the lack of control over
cognitive function in the elderly with age-related
interfering variables. It is suggested that virtual
macular degeneration. They concluded that ACT
acceptance and commitment-based therapies
is a substitute for modern life education (33). As a
should be used to reduce psychological problems
context and effort to revive values, it increases
in the risky outbreak of diseases such as Covid-
individuals' psychological well-being and mental
19, where it is not possible to hold face-to-face
health. In acceptance and commitment training
training sessions. It is also suggested that other
sessions, individuals were taught to practice based
components related to pathogens such as quality
on functional contextualism, which is an essential
of life, lifestyle, and life expectancy be examined
theoretical basis of the acceptance and
in future research.
commitment approach, instead of changing
painful feelings and thoughts (traumatic Conclusion
symptoms such as stress, anxiety, and depression).
Acceptance and commitment-based psycho-
This is a fundamental obstacle to a rich and
educational protocol training significantly reduces
meaningful life; move towards creating a new
the components of psychological distress, i.e.,
form of life, that is, creating a rich life by taking
depression, anxiety, and stress, in women
steps toward their values. People have learned to
undergoing Covid-19 treatment. Therefore, this
make changes in their lives instead of trying to
method can be used as an effective combined
improve their mental health. The result is a intervention with medications in pandemics.
reduction in depression, anxiety, and stress
symptoms, not a goal. Conflict of interests: The authors have no
ACT therapy, unlike traditional cognitive conflict of interest.
Ethical considerations: Ethical considerations 13. Huang Y, Zhao N. Generalized anxiety disorder,
depressive symptoms and sleep quality during COVID-
were observed using anonymous questionnaires, 19 outbreak in China: a web-based cross-sectional
survey. Psychiatry research. 2020;288:112954.
the confidentiality of the questionnaires, and the 14. Organization WH. The World Health Report 2001:
right of the participant to withdraw from the Mental health: new understanding, new hope. 2001.
15. Wu Z, McGoogan JM. Characteristics of and
study. important lessons from the coronavirus disease 2019
(COVID-19) outbreak in China: summary of a report
Authors' contribution: All authors have of 72 314 cases from the Chinese Center for Disease
Control and Prevention. jama. 2020;323(13):1239-42.
participated in preparation of this article and 16. Moharreri F, Rezaeitalab F, Sarjamei S. The
comparison of anxiety and depression among patients
approved the submission. with bronchial asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary
disease and lung tuberculosis. Journal of Fundamentals
References of Mental Health. 2013;15(58):82-90.
17. Shultz JM, Baingana F, Neria Y. The 2014 Ebola
outbreak and mental health: current status and
1. Lu H, Stratton CW, Tang YW. Outbreak of recommended response. Jama. 2015;313(6):567-8.
pneumonia of unknown etiology in Wuhan, China: The 18. Sianturi R, Keliat BA, Wardani IY. The
mystery and the miracle. Journal of medical virology. effectiveness of acceptance and commitment therapy
2020;92(4):401. on anxiety in clients with stroke. Enfermeria clinica.
2. Li R, Tian J, Yang F, Lv L, Yu J, Sun G, et al. 2018;28:94-7.
Clinical characteristics of 225 patients with COVID-19 19. Rubin GJ, Wessely S. The psychological effects of
in a tertiary Hospital near Wuhan, China. Journal of quarantining a city. Bmj. 2020;368.
Clinical Virology. 2020;127:104363. 20. Shahidi Dadras M, Ahmadzadeh Z, Younespour S,
3. Fahmi I. World Health Organization coronavirus Abdollahimajd F. Evaluation of anxiety and depression
disease 2019 (Covid-19) situation report. DroneEmprit. in patients with morphea taking immunosuppressive
2019. drugs during the COVID-19 pandemic. Journal of
4. Yoo J-H. The fight against the 2019-nCoV outbreak: Dermatological Treatment. 2020:1-7.
an arduous march has just begun. Journal of Korean 21. Jansen JE, Morris EM. Acceptance and
medical science. 2020;35(4). commitment therapy for posttraumatic stress disorder
5. Alipour A, Ghadami A, Alipour Z, Abdollahzadeh in early psychosis: A case series. Cognitive and
H. Preliminary validation of the Corona Disease Behavioral Practice. 2017;24(2):187-99.
Anxiety Scale (CDAS) in the Iranian sample. Quarterly 22. Herbert MS, Malaktaris AL, Dochat C, Thomas
Journal of Health Psychology. 2020;8(32):163-75. ML, Wetherell JL, Afari N. Acceptance and
6. Kong X, Zheng K, Tang M, Kong F, Zhou J, Diao L, Commitment Therapy for Chronic Pain: Does Post-
et al. Prevalence and factors associated with depression traumatic Stress Disorder Influence Treatment
and anxiety of hospitalized patients with COVID-19. Outcomes? Pain Medicine. 2019;20(9):1728-36.
MedRxiv. 2020. 23. Puolakanaho A, Lappalainen R, Lappalainen P,
7. Sadock B, Ruiz P. Summary psychiatry Kaplan and Muotka JS, Hirvonen R, Eklund KM, et al. Reducing
sadock based on the DSM-5. Gangi M 1st ed Tehran: stress and enhancing academic buoyancy among
Savalane Publication. 2015:104-6. adolescents using a brief web-based program based on
8. Lu H. Drug treatment options for the 2019-new acceptance and commitment therapy: a randomized
coronavirus (2019-nCoV). Bioscience trends. controlled trial. Journal of youth and adolescence.
2020;14(1):69-71. 2019;48(2):287-305.
9. Fischhoff B. Speaking of psychology: Coronavirus 24. Ruiz F, Beltrán DMG, Cifuentes AM, Falcón JCS.
anxiety. American Psychological Association. 2020. Single-case experimental design evaluation of
10. Fard SA, Saffarinia M. The prediction of mental repetitive negative thinking-focused acceptance and
health based on the anxiety and the social cohesion that commitment therapy in generalized anxiety disorder
caused by Coronavirus. Soc Psychol Res Q. with couple-related worry. International journal of
2020;9(36):129-41. psychology and psychological therapy.
11. Yin X, Wang J, Feng J, Chen Z, Jiang N, Wu J, et 2019;19(3):261-76.
al. The impact of the corona virus disease 2019 25. Hancock KM, Swain J, Hainsworth CJ, Dixon AL,
outbreak on Chinese residents' mental health. Available Koo S, Munro K. Acceptance and commitment therapy
at SSRN 3556680. 2020. versus cognitive behavior therapy for children with
12. Pan X, Ojcius DM, Gao T, Li Z, Pan C, Pan C. anxiety: Outcomes of a randomized controlled trial.
Lessons learned from the 2019-nCoV epidemic on Journal of Clinical Child & Adolescent Psychology.
prevention of future infectious diseases. Microbes and 2018;47(2):296-311.
infection. 2020;22(2):86-91.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.18502/aptj.v2i1.10656 Page 37
Adv Pharmacol Ther J. 2022;2(1) Shomali Ahmadabadi et al.