Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Apr 2010 ASHRAE
Apr 2010 ASHRAE
Selecting DOAS
Equipment with
Reserve Capacity
By John Murphy, Member ASHRAE outdoor air is then delivered either di-
rectly to each occupied space or to local
S
afety factors are often used by engineers when designing various types HVAC equipment serving those spaces.
Meanwhile, the local equipment (such as
of HVAC systems. However, excessive use of safety factors can result in fan-coils, water-source heat pumps, pack-
aged terminal air conditioners (PTACs),
larger-than-necessary equipment, inflated installed costs, and sometimes ex- small packaged units, VAV terminals,
chilled ceiling panels, or chilled beams)
cessive energy use. This is especially true when safety factors are used during located in or near each space provide
cooling and/or heating to maintain space
several steps of the design process, which compounds their impact along the way. temperature.1,2
Treating the outdoor air separately can
However, many of the decisions made dedicated outdoor air systems (DOAS). make it easier to verify that sufficient
during the design process are based on The recommendation of this author is ventilation airflow reaches each occupied
incomplete information, assumptions to avoid applying safety factors when space and can help avoid high indoor hu-
that may turn out to be invalid, or valid calculating design outdoor airflow and midity levels. The latter is accomplished
assumptions that may no longer be valid design dehumidification capacity, and by dehumidifying the outdoor air to
one, five, or 10 years after the system or instead select the dedicated outdoor air remove the entire ventilation latent load
equipment is installed. Therefore, safety (OA) equipment with reserve capacity. and most (or all) of the space latent loads,
factors are important tools for design leaving the local HVAC equipment to
engineers allowing the HVAC system to Dedicated Outdoor Air Systems primarily handle space sensible cooling
accommodate unexpected loads and the A dedicated outdoor air system uses a
need for increased airflow or dehumidi- separate piece of equipment to condition About the Author
fication capacity. (filter, heat, cool, humidify, dehumidify) John Murphy is a senior applications engineer
This article discusses a slightly dif- all of the outdoor air brought into a with Trane Commercial Business, Ingersoll Rand
ferent approach to use when designing building for ventilation. This conditioned in La Crosse, Wis.
°F
determining the design airflow of the dedicated OA re
tu
e ra
unit occurs when accounting for future expansion p
m
Te
or a change in use of the facility. If the facility is t - B ulb qL
We
expanded in the future, and the dedicated OA unit
will be expected to serve the expansion, it would
be prudent to select a unit with some amount of
reserve (or extra) airflow capacity. Or, if the use of
the facility is likely to change in the future (from
an office space to a group of meeting rooms or a
Dry-Bulb Temperature °F
retail area, for example) the ventilation require-
ments for the zones served by the dedicated OA Figure 3: Dehumidification provided by a chilled water or direct-expansion dedi-
unit may change. Again, it would be prudent to cated outdoor air unit.
select a unit with reserve airflow capacity.
The recommendation of this author is to calculate the design Since the previous section discussed the influence of safety
airflow as accurately as possible, without using safety factors. factors on the design airflow (Vot), this section will focus on
Then select a dedicated outdoor air unit that has reserve airflow the remaining two variables in Equation 3: the humidity ratio
capacity, rather than a unit operating near its maximum allowable of the entering outdoor air (Woa) and the humidity ratio of the
airflow. The impact of this will be discussed later in this article. leaving conditioned air (Wca).
Determining Design Dehumidification Capacity Safety Factor for Woa (Humidity Ratio of the Entering Outdoor Air)
The required dehumidification capacity of a dedicated OA ASHRAE Handbook—Fundamentals7 is a popular source
unit (Figure 3, Equation 3) is dictated by the design airflow (Vot), for climatic data that represents the outdoor design conditions
humidity ratio of the entering outdoor air (Woa), and humidity for various locations. Historically, design engineers have used
ratio of the conditioned air leaving the unit (Wca): the design dry-bulb temperature and mean coincident wet-bulb
temperature when calculating the required capacity of cooling
qL = 4.5 × Vot × (Woa – Wca) / 7000 gr/lb (3) systems. However, the highest outdoor humidity ratio does
not occur at the same time as the highest outdoor dry-bulb
where temperature.
qL = required dehumidification capacity, lb/h Since 1997, the ASHRAE Handbook has included the
Vot = design outdoor airflow, cfm design dew-point temperature and mean coincident dry-
Woa= humidity ratio of the entering outdoor air, grains/ bulb temperature for use when calculating the required
lb capacity of dehumidification systems. Table 1 lists the 0.4%
Wca= humidity ratio of the leaving conditioned air, outdoor design conditions for Jacksonville, Fla. 7 Notice
grains/lb that the outdoor humidity ratio is 32% higher at the design
0.4% Design Condition 95°F DBT, 78°F WBT 78°F DPT, 85°F DBT 80°F WBT, 90°F DBT
Space Latent Cooling Load (qLspace) 5250 Btu/h 5465 Btu/h 5697 Btu/h 5250 Btu/h
Zone Outdoor Airflow (Voz) 450 cfm 450 cfm 480 cfm 435 cfm
iti gn
4.8 hp 3.3 hp 45% 1%
Brake Horsepower
nd esi
on
50%
Co E D
55% 2%
Exhaust Fan 60%
DP RA
3.8 hp 2.5 hp 65%
Brake Horsepower
H
AS
Space Relative Humidity (Upper Limit)
Table 5: Energy-related impacts of equipment sizing.
Figure 4: Impact of Woa and Wsp on required dehumidification
engineers consider 60% RH an acceptable upper limit, capacity (qL), without total-energy recovery (Jacksonville, Fla.)
while others choose 50%, 55%, 65%, or some other limit.
2. Determine the design latent load for each zone (qLspace). 80
Dehumidification Capacity, lb/h
51.3
This is the latent load that occurs within the boundaries 49.1
60 46.8
of the zone. It typically consists of moisture generated 44.6
49.9 42.4
by people or other sources within the zone, as well as 47.7
40 45.5
infiltration or diffusion of humid air from outdoors or 43.2
48.7 41.0
from adjacent zones.9 These loads are often determined 20 46.5
44.3
with the help of load calculation software. 0.4%
0 42.0
3. Calculate the required humidity ratio of the conditioned 39.8
1%
iti gn
45%
air (Wca) delivered by the dedicated OA unit. If the 50%
nd esi
on
55% 2%
Co E D
dedicated OA system is being designed to offset the 60%
65%
DP RA
entire indoor latent load, in addition to the ventilation Space Relative Humidity (Upper Limit)
H
AS
latent load, then the conditioned outdoor air must be
dry enough to offset the latent load in each zone, such Figure 5: Impact of Woa and Wsp on required dehumidification
that the humidity ratio in every zone is maintained at capacity (qL), with total-energy recovery (Jacksonville, Fla.).
or below the desired upper limit. Equation 4 is used to
determine the required Wca for each zone. Then, the 1. For this example, the zone dry-bulb temperature setpoint
humidity ratio of the conditioned outdoor air delivered during the cooling season will be 74°F (23°C) and the
by the unit must be the lowest (or worst-case) of all the acceptable upper limit for indoor humidity is 60% RH.
zones it serves. This equates to an indoor humidity ratio (Wsp) of 75.2
grains/lb (10.8 g/kg).
Wca = Wsp – [qLspace / (0.69 × Voz)] (4) 2. Table 3 (see Page 35) lists the design latent loads (qLspace)
and required outdoor airflows (Voz) for each zone.
where 3. Equation 4 is used to calculate the required condi-
Wca= required humidity ratio of the conditioned air tioned-air humidity ratio (W ca) for each zone. For
leaving the unit, grains/lb example, the required humidity ratio of the conditioned
Wsp = desired upper limit for humidity ratio of the oc- outdoor air delivered to Classroom 102 is 57.6 grains/
cupied space, grains/lb lb (8.24 g/kg).
qLspace = design latent load in the zone, Btu/h
Voz = design zone outdoor airflow, cfm Wca= 75.2 grains/lb – [5465 Btu/h / (0.69 × 450 cfm)] =
57.6 grains/lb
To demonstrate this process, consider an example elementary
school located in Jacksonville, Fla. A dedicated outdoor air As the results in Table 3 show, Classroom 102 requires the
unit is being designed to deliver air directly to four classrooms, driest air. Therefore, for this example, the dedicated outdoor
removing the entire ventilation latent load and the entire indoor air unit must be sized to dehumidify the outdoor air to 57.6
latent load. grains/lb (8.24 g/kg), which equates to a 52°F (11°C) dew