Professional Documents
Culture Documents
FISHING PRACTISES
Ardhi University
June 2023
ACCESS TO FINANCE AND OPERATIONAL SUSTAINABILITY OF
FISHING PRACTISES
By
June 2023
CERTIFICATION
The undersigned certify that they have read and hereby recommends for acceptance by Ardhi
University of Tanzania a research entitled: Access to Finance and Operational Sustainability
of Fishing Practices, in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Bachelor of Science
in Account and Finance of Ardhi University.
…………………………………
Date……………………………
……………………………..
(Head of Department)
Date…………………………….
i
DECLARATION
I Elisheba Enael Mmbaga, hereby declare that the content of this report are the results of any
own study and findings and, the best of my knowledge, they have not been presented anywhere
for a Degree or any professional award in any Institution of Higher Learning.
Date_________________________ Signature………………………………………….
ii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I would like to extend my sincere gratitude to the Almighty God for His boundless grace,
blessings, and guidance, which provided me with the strength to persevere through this
Research even during moments when I contemplated giving up.
I am deeply thankful to my supervisor Dr. Rosemary Mnongya and the head of the department.
Dr Samwel Alananga for their invaluable support and guidance. They dedicated their time to
assist me in formulating the title, collecting data, and navigating the entire data analysis
process. I wholeheartedly acknowledge and appreciate their significant contributions.
I cannot adequately express my gratitude to my family, particularly my Aunt Nsia Massele, for
her unwavering moral and financial support throughout my university education. Her
comforting words and encouragement provided me with the determination to complete this
project within the stipulated timeframe.
Lastly, I would like to express my appreciation to all my friends, classmates, and respondents
who participated in this project. Their willingness to provide crucial information was
instrumental in justifying the significance of this research. Without their valuable
contributions, this project would lack purpose and meaning.
iii
DEDICATION
This work is dedicated to my beloved parents and my supportive Aunt Nsia Massele and Uncle
Justin Mmbaga for all the prayers, encouragement, love and emotional support to my
endeavours.
iv
ABBREVIATIONS AND ACRONYMS
v
ABSTRACT
Previous studies have shown that despite access to finance that has been offered to local
fishermen to finance their general activity there is still a controversial argument as to why their
operational activity has not been improved over the years , their method has not modernized
so the study aimed at identifying what is association between access to finance and operational
sustainability of operational fishing practice , moreover the one possible reason that could have
hindered their progress is cultural belief , so the study was design to explain between these
three variables , which are access to finance , operational sustainability, and cultural belief, the
specific objectives where to examine association between operational sustainability of fishing
practice and cultural belief, to determine effect of access to finance on operational practice of
fishing practices and to determine the effect of cultural belief on access to finance.
Methodology used was research design was case study that was conducted at Kivukoni Ferry,
research method was quantitative technique where close ended questionnaire was used as data
collection tool, excel and SPSS was used for data analysis .and the outcomes it was seen that
there is a greater associations between access to finance and sustainability of fishing practices
moreover there is no associations between access to finance and culture belief , and also culture
belief does not affect operational sustainability of local fishermen. General recommendations
are that Improving the terms and conditions of access to finance, establish sustainable finance
mechanisms, encourage public-private partnerships, Promote financial literacy and capacity
building. Overall, this study contributes to understanding the relationship between access to
finance, cultural belief, and the operational sustainability of fishing practices. By implementing
the recommended measures, stakeholders can support local fishermen in adopting sustainable
practices and enhancing the economic viability of the fishing industry.
vi
TABLE OF CONTENTS
DECLARATION .......................................................................................................................ii
DEDICATION .......................................................................................................................... iv
ABSTRACT .............................................................................................................................. vi
vii
2.3.2Financial Inclusion and Fishermen's Access to Finance:................................................. 11
viii
4.0 Introduction ........................................................................................................................ 22
REFERENCES ........................................................................................................................ 36
APPENDIX .............................................................................................................................. 39
ix
LIST OF TABLES
Table 3.1 Name of variables and measurement scale .............................................................. 19
Table 4.1: Description on Access to finance ........................................................................... 22
Table 4.4: Description on Cultural Beliefs .............................................................................. 23
Table 4.3: Description on Age Categories ............................................................................... 24
Table 4.4:Case Processing Summary....................................................................................... 25
Table 4.5 Chi-Square Tests ...................................................................................................... 25
Table 4.6: Symmetric Measures .............................................................................................. 25
Table 4.7: Case Processing Summary...................................................................................... 26
Table 4.8 Chi-Square Tests. ..................................................................................................... 26
Table 4.9 Symmetric Measures................................................................................................ 26
Table 4.10 Goodness-of-Fit ..................................................................................................... 27
Table 4.11 Parameter Estimates. .............................................................................................. 28
Table 4.12 Goodness of Fit ...................................................................................................... 29
Table 4.11 Parameter Estimates ............................................................................................... 29
x
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 2.1 Conceptual framework ........................................................................................... 15
Figure 4.1 Cultural belief practise ........................................................................................... 23
xi
CHAPTER ONE
INTRODUCTION
This highly diverse sector operates in various social, economic, and ecological contexts
worldwide, The fishing industry contributes significantly to global food security, with over 3
billion people relying on fish as their primary source of animal protein (FAO,
2018)Approximately 59.5 million people are engaged in the primary sector of the global
fisheries and aquaculture industry, including fishing and fish farming. n 2018, global fish
production reached 179 million tones, with a value of USD 401 billion, highlighting its
economic significance.
Various fishing methods are used worldwide, including trawling, long lining, purse seining,
gillnetting, and traps/pots. The selection of methods depends on target species, location, and
environmental considerations. Trawling is the most common fishing method, particularly for
capturing demersal (bottom-dwelling) species, while purse seining is often employed for
schooling fish like tuna. China is the world's largest fishing nation, accounting for the highest
annual marine capture and aquaculture production. (FAO, 2018)Other prominent fishing
nations include Indonesia, the United States, Russia, Japan, Peru, India, Vietnam, the
Philippines, and Norway. Aquaculture, or fish farming, has overgrown to meet the increasing
global demand for fish. It involves cultivating fish, shellfish, and aquatic plants in controlled
1
environments. In 2018, aquaculture accounted for approximately 46% of global fish
production, significantly contributing to the fishing industry
Fisheries and aquaculture contribute significantly to Africa's food security and nutrition,
providing millions of people with a vital source of animal protein. The fisheries sector is a
source of employment and income for millions of Africans, particularly in coastal communities
where fishing is a primary economic activity. (world bank, 2017)In Sub-Saharan Africa, fish
accounts for about 22% of animal protein intake and supports the livelihoods of over 12 million
people engaged in the sector. (world bank, 2017), African countries with significant fishing
industries include Senegal, Mauritania, Morocco, Ghana, Nigeria, Angola, South Africa,
Namibia, Tanzania, and Mozambique. Senegal is known for its vibrant artisanal fishing sector,
while Morocco has a large industrial fishing fleet. Ghana and Nigeria have excellent coastal
fisheries, while Angola and Namibia have rich offshore fisheries resources. Regional
cooperation plays a vital role in managing shared fisheries resources in Africa.
Organizations like the African Union Inter-African Bureau for Animal Resources and the
Regional Fisheries Bodies work towards sustainable fisheries management and development.
Initiatives such as the Africa Blue Economy Strategy and the African Fisheries Reform
Mechanism aim to promote sustainable fisheries, combat IUU fishing, and enhance value chain
development in the fishing sector. (United Nation, 2016), Africa's fishing industry employs a
range of fishing practices, including small-scale artisanal fishing, commercial trawling, long
lining, and fish farming., Overfishing and illegal, unreported, and unregulated (IUU) fishing
are significant challenges in African waters, leading to the depletion of fish stocks and
ecological imbalances. Climate change impacts, such as rising sea temperatures and changes
in ocean currents, affect fish distribution and productivity, posing additional challenges for
African fisheries. (world bank, 2017).
Access to finance plays a big role in supporting local fishermen in Africa as one of the
challenges that this local fisherman faces them is capital to run the business and to support
them in their daily fishing activities, one of the studies conducted (Bene, Newsham, Davies,
Ulrichs, & Goodfrey-Wood, 2014), one of the method that has been used to support local
fishermen is the establishment of community based microfinance institutions , these institutions
provide financial services tailored to the needs of small scale fishermen and help improve their
access to credit and other financial resources , and this enhances resilience of fishing
communities in coastal area of Ghana, Senegal and Tanzania , the microfinance institutions
2
they offer access to finance such as free loans , saving accounts, insurance services designed
specifically for fishermen. Another financing option that has been done in Africa for local
fishermen is establishment of revolving loan funds specifically designed for fisheries or small
scale fisheries enterprises , these fund provide access to capital for investment in fishing
equipment, infrastructure , and business development , another include is utilization of grants
example such grant program is the sustainable fisheries fund (SFF), implemented by the
African development Bank , the aim was to enhance the sustainability and productivity of
fisheries in Africa by providing grants to small scale fishing communities, other grants are
typically provided by government agencies , international organizations , and philanthropic
foundations.
The major lakes in Tanzania are Victoria, Tanganyika, and Nyasa, which support significant
fisheries. Additionally, few lakes, dams, and rivers have smaller fishery contributions. The
inland fishing is primarily artisanal, with fishers using small boats, canoes, and dhows powered
by outboard engines. The main target species in inland waters include Nile perch, tilapia,
catfish, and various sardine species. The post-harvest use of fish in Tanzania involves fresh
consumption and various processing methods such as smoking, sun-drying, and salting. While
fresh fish, especially Nile perch, is used for filleting, processed fishery products are exported,
3
including fillets, crabs, lobsters, octopus, shrimps, and squids. Fishmeal production is limited,
mainly utilizing the remains of Nile perch filleting and low-quality sardines (Ministry of
Livestock and Fisheries, 2022). The fishery sector in Tanzania plays a significant economic
role, contributing to animal protein consumption and employment generation. It provides full-
time employment for approximately 150,000 artisanal fishermen and supports about 2.0
million people through various fisheries-related activities. Moreover, the sector serves as a
source of government revenue, which is utilized for sector development, management, training,
and resource monitoring. (Peart, et al., 2021). However, the demand for fish in Tanzania
remains high due to the growing population, surpassing the available fisheries resources.
To address this challenge, the government encourages aquaculture to improve food security
and ensure the sustainability of the capture fishery. Several efforts have been made to support
this fishing industry among small-scale fishers, and several funding options have been made.
They may include the following, The World Bank Fisheries Development Project: This project
provides funding to support the sustainable management and development of the fishing
industry in Tanzania. It aims to increase the productivity and profitability of small-scale fishers,
improve infrastructure and facilities for fish processing and storage, and strengthen the capacity
of government institutions to manage the sector. (World Group, 2021)
4
With all the effort made by the government and non-government institution to give grants and
loan, access to finance in general there is still a question on the relationship between access to
finance and how the sustainability to local fishermen
5
1.5 Scope of the Study.
The study covered local fishermen at kivukoni at UWAWAKI organization (Umoja wa wavuvi
wadogo kivukoni). The targeted group was the individuals who have been able to have access
to finance through different loan program to finance fishing activities.
The study aimed at examine the relationship between access to finance and operation
sustainability of fishing practices in which quantitative approach was adopted and
questionnaires were used as the tool of data analysis. The scope covered the effect of tradition
practise in operation sustainability of local fishermen and moreover the effect of tradition
practices in access to finance, and what exactly are those traditional practices that are associated
with fishing practices.
The study has got a significance in determining the relationship between access to finance and
operational sustainability and the understanding the effect of traditional practices in having
access to finances and the effect it has on operational sustainability of fishing practices , this
may help the government to know on where to put much efforts so that their effort on provision
of fund may not run into vain , but also the study is applicable to investors who have shown
interest in investing in fishing practices to know what exactly is to be done to improve better
ways of fishing practices which may be sustainable and which may increase the level of
productions rates .
Also the provision and improvement of targeted policies that may enhance in promotion of
sustainable operation of fishing activities , also the study contribute to the existing academic
literatures on fishery sector in Tanzania, the study has a significance of raising awareness
among stakeholders and the general public about the importance of the fishery sector in
Tanzania and the need for sustainable practices and policies to support the livelihoods of local
fishermen together with their fishing practices, and lastly the study has a great contribution in
achievement of my bachelor of degree as the part of the fulfilment of my study.
6
addressed the real-world problem of fishing practices and access to finance together with the
effect of traditional practice in sustainability of fishing practices in Tanzania. By identifying
the factors that hinder the progress and sustainability of fishermen despite having access to
finance, the study also to contribute to the existing academic literature on the fishery sector in
Tanzania and raise awareness among stakeholders and the general public about the importance
of sustainable practices and policies to support the livelihoods of local fishermen. Ultimately,
the study seeks to inform the development of targeted policies and interventions to promote
sustainable livelihoods for local fishermen in the fishery sector in Tanzania.
The other limitation was illiteracy most of local fishermen did not know how to read and write
this was resolved through taking part in reading for them and filling the gap for them according
to what they see and perceive as the answer. And the last limitation was the respondent who
know how to read and write they hard poor knowledge on English language therefore the
questionnaire where prepared in English language and then translated to Swahili language so
as it can easily be understood by the respondent.
7
CHAPTER TWO
LITERATURE REVIEW.
2.0 Introduction
In this chapter contain several literatures which have covered relationship existing between
access to finance and operational sustainability of fishing practises, access to finance and
cultural belief and lastly the effect of cultural belief on operational sustainability of fishing
practises.
8
2.1.5 Local fishermen:
Refers to individuals who engage in fishing activities within a specific locality or community.
Local fishermen typically have close ties to the fishing area, possess local knowledge, and rely
on fishing as their primary livelihood source. (Fulton, Smith, Smith, & Putten, 2011)
Assumptions.
9
Assumptions:
Financial Inclusion Theory explores the importance of providing access to financial services
for marginalized populations. This theory can be applied to analyse how the inclusion of fishing
communities in formal financial systems or the development of alternative financial
mechanisms influences their economic resilience, livelihood diversification, and operational
sustainability (Allen, Demirgus -kunt, Klapper, Soledad, & Peria, 2016)
Assumptions:
i. Access to affordable and appropriate financial services is essential for individuals and
communities to improve their economic well-being.
ii. Financial inclusion promotes resilience, poverty reduction, and inclusive economic
growth.
iii. Closing the financial access gap requires addressing barriers such as affordability,
proximity, trust, and regulatory frameworks.
10
2.3.2Financial Inclusion and Fishermen's Access to Finance:
Financial inclusion, which encompasses access to formal financial services, is crucial for local
fishermen in Tanzania. A study by (Demirguc-Kunt, Klapper, Singer, Ansar, & Hess, 2017)
examined the financial inclusion landscape in fishing communities along Indian Ocean. They
found that limited access to formal banking services and lack of collateral hindered fishermen's
ability to obtain loans for investment in fishing equipment and working capital. Financial
inclusion initiatives that promote mobile banking and innovative financial products could
enhance fishermen's access to finance.
11
2.3.6 Operational Sustainability of Fishing Practices and Cultural Beliefs.
Understanding the relationship between cultural beliefs and the operational sustainability of
fishing practices is crucial for effective fisheries management. This literature review aims to
explore existing research on the association between cultural beliefs and the operational
sustainability of fishing practices. By examining relevant studies, this review seeks to provide
insights into how cultural beliefs influence fishing practices and their sustainability.
12
2.3.10 Sacred Sites and Conservation:
Cultural beliefs associated with sacred sites and protected areas can play a significant role in
promoting the operational sustainability of fishing practices. A study by (Mathooko J. M.,
2005) examined the influence of cultural beliefs and sacred sites on the conservation of sea
grass meadows in Australia. They found that Indigenous cultural beliefs and practices related
to sacred sites facilitated the protection of sea grass habitats, supporting sustainable fishing
practices by ensuring the availability of key fish species.
Religious beliefs and practices can also influence individuals' financial behaviours and their
access to finance. A study by (Mathooko J. M., 2005)explored the relationship between
religiosity and financial inclusion in predominantly Muslim communities in Indonesia. They
found that religious beliefs, such as adherence to Islamic principles of finance, affected
individuals' financial behaviours and preferences. Islamic finance principles, which prohibit
interest-based transactions, led to the development of Sharia-compliant financial products and
institutions, providing alternative avenues for accessing finance.
13
2017) analysed the impact of cultural beliefs on individuals' trust in banks across different
countries. They found that cultural factors, such as collectivism and trust in interpersonal
relationships, influenced individuals' willingness to engage with formal financial institutions.
Cultural beliefs that prioritize community ties over formal institutions can create barriers to
accessing finance through traditional banking channels.
From the previous studies most researchers have address the challenge of access to finance that
is one problem that hinder the growth of sustainability business, because of that there have
been effort made to deal with that, but the left part the extent to which that access to finance
has impact on sustainability of fishing practises.
14
OPERATIONAL
SUSTAINABILITY OF
FISHING PRACTISES.
.
-fishing Practise method
ACCESS TO FINANCE
CULTURAL BELIEF
The literature review reveals a complex relationship between cultural beliefs and the
operational sustainability of fishing practices. While certain cultural beliefs and practices
contribute positively to sustainable fishing, others can lead to unsustainable practices.
Recognizing the influence of cultural beliefs, particularly Indigenous knowledge systems and
sacred sites, can provide valuable insights for fisheries management. Enhancing cultural
transmission and incorporating traditional knowledge into fisheries policies can contribute to
more sustainable fishing practices.
The literature review demonstrates that cultural beliefs have a significant influence on
individuals' access to finance. Cultural norms, trust in informal systems, religious beliefs, and
15
gender roles shape individuals' financial behaviours and preferences. Understanding and
addressing cultural barriers are vital for promoting financial inclusion and ensuring that
financial services are accessible and relevant to diverse cultural contexts. Culturally sensitive
approaches that consider individuals' beliefs and practices can contribute to enhancing access
to finance and supporting economic development
16
CHAPTER THREE
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY.
3.0 Introduction.
This chapter put into details the methods applied in data collection, analysis and presentation.
The approach which was adopted in this study was quantitative approach. The targeted sample
was 80 individuals where data was obtained from 52 individual. Questionnaire was used as
tool of data collection whereas excel and SPSS was used for data analysis. Several functions
such as descriptive statistics, inferential statistics, chi square and Cramer’s v and regression
were used to analyze data. Pie charts, and frequency tables were used in data presentations.
Confidentiality was also put into account as a matter of ethical consideration.
17
3.3 Area of study.
The area of study mainly covers the population and sample size which was targeted in the
study. Population is the group from which the data to be used in the research will be extracted
from (Kothari, 2017) Sample is extracted from the population which will represent the whole
population in data collection and analysis to obtain findings.
3.3.1 Population.
In this study the population used was that of the people specifically local fishermen who have
been having access to finance through different loan programs with age ranging from 18-45
years old. These local fishermen have been located at kivukoni ferry which was my area of
case study and their where registered members of about 400 members and those who have been
having access to finance are 126 members.
Primary data was mainly used in this study which were collected directly from the respondents.
To obtain data, questionnaires were used as the tool of data collection. A questionnaire is the
written list of questions which are to be answered by the respondent by writing what they
understood from the question (Sinclair, 1975). Questionnaires are useful when collecting
massive amount of data in a short period of time. (Kombo & Orodho, 2002) The questionnaire
consisted twenty questions which were divided into four parts. The first part was about personal
information such as age, gender and education status. The second part consisted of questions
concerning access to finance and operational sustainability of fishing practices. The third part
was cultural belief and operational sustainability of fishing practices the last part was about
18
access to finance and cultural belief. The questionnaire was then prepared in English and
translated to local language so as it can be easily understood by local fishermen who most of
them have little or no knowledge on English language then the questionaries’ where distributed
to local fishermen at UWAWAKI, Umoja wa wavuvi wadogowadogo kivukoni any individual
who was interested to participate to fill it. The table below indicates variables and their
measurement scale.
I. Descriptive statistics
Data was coded, summarized, and processed using SPSS statistical package. Frequency tables
and pie chart were produced to describe study variables (Fisher & Marshall, 2009)
Inferential statistics is a branch of statistics which is used to make predictions on the outcomes
and draw inference between two effects on which one is true and the other one is false. (Allua
& Thompson, 2009)
19
III. Chi-square test
Chi-square test is a formal statistical test that tests the association between two categorical
variables with two or more categories. The test was employed to determine if there is
association between dependent variable and each independent variable. (Tallarida & Murray,
1987)
𝑟 𝑐 2
(𝑓𝑖𝑗− 𝑒𝑖𝑗 )
ᵪ2 = ∑ ∑ ,
𝑒𝑖𝑗
𝑖 𝑗
Where
𝑓𝑖𝑗 = observed frequency for contigency table category in row i and column j
𝑒𝑖𝑗 = expected frequency for contigency category in i row and column j based on the assumption
of independence.
A Chi-square test has a distribution with (𝑟 − 1)(𝑐 − 1) degrees of freedom where r rows and
c columns are of contingency table provided that the expected frequencies are five or more for
all categories.
The null hypothesis for this test is that the tested variables have no association against the
alternative hypothesis that variables have association.
IV. Cramer’s V
If a dependent variable has multiple categories with a meaningful order where each
category is considered higher than the previous one, an ordinal logit regression model can
be used. This model was employed to assess the impact of independent variables on the
dependent variable. The proportional-odds model, also known as ordered logistic
regression, assumes that the odds ratio of an event remains constant across all categories,
20
making it independent of the specific categories. The most commonly used proportional
odds model was:
𝜀𝑝𝑟(𝑌≤𝑗\𝑥)
𝑙𝑛(1−𝜀𝑝𝑟(𝑌≤𝑗\𝑥))=𝛼j +𝛽𝑖 ,1
21
CHAPTER FOUR
DATA ANALYSIS AND DISUSSION OF FINDINGS
4.0 Introduction
This chapter presents both descriptive and inferential statistics from the study. In descriptive
analysis frequency tables and pie chart were produced to describe the variables of the study. In
the part of inferential analysis chi-square test was carried out to study the association between
dependent variable and each independent variable of the study, as well as ordinal logistic
regression was carried out to examine the association between variables. Ordinal model was
used to the nature of the dependent variable which is ordered measured.
Descriptive Statistics
This section presents the characteristics of the study variables by summarizing data into a
meaningful and useful way through the use of frequency tables.
Table 4.1: results show that greater number of respondent access to finance below 500000 by
the count of 19(38%) followed by respondents who access to finance Between 1000001-
2000000 by the count of 14(28%), 500000-1000000 by the count of 9(18%) %) while number
of respondents who access to finance Above 5000000 had the lowest count of 8(16%).
22
II. Description on Cultural Beliefs
23
Chart above show that greater number of respondent Strong Dis Agree the Cultural Beliefs by
(32%) followed by respondents Dis Agree the Cultural Beliefs by (26%), on Average by (18%),
respondents Agree the Cultural Beliefs by (16%) while number of respondents who Strong
Agree had the lowest percent by (8%).
Table 4.3: results show that greater number of respondents fall in the Age Category Above 32
by the count of 27 (54%) followed by respondents fall in the Age Category Between 26-32 by
the count of 19 (38%) while number of respondents fall in the Age Category Between 18-25
had the lowest count of 4 (8%).
24
4.2.1 Association between Operational Sustainability of fishing practice and
independent variables
This section presents the use of chi-square test to check if there is association between
Operational Sustainability of fishing practice and the independent variables which are Access
to finance and Cultural Beliefs.
Symmetric Measures
Value Approx. Sig.
Nominal by Phi .712 .003
Nominal Cramer's V .411 .003
N of Valid Cases 50
a. Not assuming the null hypothesis.
b. Using the asymptotic standard error assuming the null hypothesis.
25
Note that, Level of Significant is 0.05
Table shows that p-value (p-value< Level of Significant (0.05); p-value= 0.003) the result
reveals there is evidence that there is statistically significant association between Operational
Sustainability of fishing practice and Access to finance at 5% level of significant.
The association was further explained by Cramer’s V result i.e. V= 0.411. This result reveals
that there was a moderate association between Operational Sustainability of fishing practice
and Access to finance.
Chi-Square Tests
Value df Asymp. Sig.
(2-sided)
Pearson Chi-Square 40.865a 12 .001
Likelihood Ratio 48.380 12 .000
Linear-by-Linear
16.926 1 .000
Association
N of Valid Cases 50
a. 17 cells (85.0%) have expected count less than 5. The
minimum expected count is .08.
Table 4.9 Symmetric Measures
Symmetric Measures
Value Approx.
Sig.
Phi .904 .000
Nominal by
Cramer's
Nominal .22 .000
V
N of Valid Cases 50
26
a. Using the asymptotic standard error assuming the null hypothesis.
b. Not assuming the null hypothesis.
Note that, Level of Significant is 0.05
Table shows that p-value (p-value< Level of Significant (0.05); p-value= 0.001) the result
reveals there is evidence that there is statistically significant association between Operational
Sustainability of fishing practice and cultural beliefs at 5% level of significant.
The association was further explained by Cramer’s V result i.e. V= 0.22. This result reveals
that there was a weak association between Operational Sustainability of fishing practice and
cultural beliefs.
Results from the Ordinal Logistic Regression Analysis: for Operational Sustainability of
fishing practice and Access to finance
From the table below since p-value (=0.972) is larger (greater than 5%) therefore the null
hypothesis was rejected; this signifies that there is no significant difference between the
observed and the predicted values of the outcome. This indicates that the model is a good fit.
27
Table 4.11 Parameter Estimates.
Parameter Estimates
Estimate Std. Error Wald Df Sig. 95% Confidence Interval
Lower Upper Bound
Bound
[OperationalS
ustainabilitypr -38.996 .748 2716.412 1 .000 -40.463 -37.530
actise = 0]
[OperationalS
ustainabilitypr -37.800 .620 3721.102 1 .000 -39.014 -36.585
actise = 2]
Threshold
[OperationalS
ustainabilitypr -36.561 .542 4543.429 .000 -37.624 -35.498
1
actise = 3]
[OperationalS
ustainabilitypr 1.946 1.069 3.313 1 .069 -.149 4.041
actise = 4]
[Accesstofinan
-37.472 .699 2876.009 1 .000 -38.842 -36.103
ce=1]
[Accesstofinan
-17.376 3570.296 .000 1 .996 -7015.028 6980.275
ce=2]
Location
[Accesstofinan
-36.046 .000 . 1 .80 -36.046 -36.046
ce=3]
[Accesstofinan
0a . . 0 . . .
ce=4]
4.2.4 Interpretation
If respondent were increase Access to finance less than 500000 by one point, its ordered log
odds being in Operational Sustainability of fishing practice would decrease by 37.4 compared
to those Access to finance above 2000000 while other variable in the model are held constant,
While Access to finance less than 500000 to 1000000 and 1000001 to 2000000 are statistical
insignificant.
Results from the Ordered Logistic Regression Analysis: for Operational Sustainability of
fishing practice and Cultural Beliefs.
28
4.2.5 Goodness of fit test
The Pearson goodness-of-fit test was used to test if the model has effectively described the
outcome variable. The large p-value signifies that there is no significant difference between the
observed and the predicted values of the outcome.
From the table below since p-value (=0. 52) is larger (greater than 5%) therefore the null
hypothesis was rejected; this signifies that there is no significant difference between the
observed and the predicted values of the outcome. This indicates that the model is a good fit.
29
4.2.5 Interpretation
If there increase in number of respondents who strongly agree Cultural Beliefs, its ordered log
odds being in Operational Sustainability of fishing practice would decrease by 22.14 compared
to those who disagree Cultural Beliefs while another variable in the model are held constant.
Also, If there increase in number of respondent who agree Cultural Beliefs, its ordered log odds
being in Operational Sustainability of fishing practice would decrease by 22.10 compared to
those who disagree Cultural Beliefs while other variable in the model are held constant.
If there increase in number of respondents who are on average agree Cultural Beliefs, its
ordered log odds being in Operational Sustainability of fishing practice would decrease by
21.05 compared to those who disagree Cultural Beliefs while another variable in the model are
held constant
30
CHAPTER FIVE
5.0 Introduction.
This is the final chapter in which conclusion is drawn and recommendations are given
depending on the
observations from data analysis and findings concerning the relationship between access to
finance and operational sustainability of fishing practice in relationship to culture belief, in
general the study tried to examine the relationship existing between access to finance, cultural
belief and sustainability of fishing practice of fishing practices.
5.1 Conclusion.
The study was backed up with three research questions which aimed at assessing the
relationship between access to finance, cultural belief and operational sustainability of fishing
on which the dependent variable was operational sustainability of fishing practices and
independent variables which are access to finance and culture ,Throughout data analysis the
research questions were answered by the observations which showed that the independent
variable access to finance do affect the depend variables which is operational sustainability to
a great extent, moreover the independent variable cultural belief have a little impact on
operational sustainability and there is no relationship between the two independent variables
that is access to finance and culture belief The conclusion will be drawn answering the research
questions.
Research question one: What is the relationship between access to finance and
operational sustainability of fishing practices?
Access to finance and operational sustainability of fishing practice have great association
where it was observed that the local fishermen who have obtain a little amount of fund , they
hardly improve in their fishing practices, on the other side those who obtain average fund most
of them have not improved in their fishing practices , but also those who received high amount
of fund above two million have been able to improve their method of fishing , from the research
questions it has been clear that the is directly relationship between access to finance and
sustainability of fishing practices .
31
Research question two: What impact do access to finance have on operational
sustainability of local fishermen?
Access to finance and operational sustainability of local fishermen have a great relationship
from the range of strong disagreed to strong agree , most local fishermen argued that access to
finance have a very high impact on operational sustainability and does not affect much on the
improvement to their fishing practice, and since most of them they strongly disagree on practice
of cultural belief, while few of them who opt for agree they argue that it does not affect their
fishing practice sustainability.
Research question three: What effect does cultural belief have on access to finance?
Cultural belief and access to finance have no any relationship that most of the respondent argue
that the issue of access to finance has not been interfered with cultural belief with the fact that
most individual local fishermen do not practice cultural belief, therefore majority respondent
with the optioned that there is no a direct relationship between access to finance and cultural
belief.
Overall conclusion.
The study aimed at assessing the relationship between access to finance and operational
sustainability of local fishermen, and what effect do cultural belief has on operational
sustainability and access to finance, from the result it can be concluded that access to finance
has a great impact on improvement of fishing practices , because the improvement t has been
measured the individual who obtained higher amount of fund and their improvement was
observable however the fact that one of the possible reason that could have hindered the
progress of operational sustainability was cultural belief but it turn out that cultural belief has
very lower or no significance in sustainability of fishing practices, more so cultural belief
does not have any impact to access to finance.
32
5.2 Recommendations
33
Ensure transparency and accountability:
Establish mechanisms to ensure the transparent and accountable use of funds provided to local
fishermen. Regular monitoring and evaluation processes should be in place to assess the impact
of financial support on fishing practices and sustainability outcomes. This will help identify
areas for improvement and ensure that funds are used effectively and responsibly.
34
they can make informed decisions, effectively utilize funds, and improve their overall financial
sustainability.
Improving the terms and conditions of access to finance requires collaboration among financial
institutions, policymakers, and fishing communities. By addressing the unique needs and
challenges of local fishermen, financial support can be better tailored to promote sustainable
fishing practices and enhance the economic viability of the industry.
35
REFERENCES
Allen, F., Demirgus -kunt, A., Klapper, L., Soledad, M., & Peria, M. (2016). The
Foundations of Financial inclusion:Understanding ownership and use of formal
accounts. Journal of Financial Intermediation, 27, 1-30.
allison, & ellis. (2001). the livelhoods approach and managemnt of small scale fisheries .
Allua, S., & Thompson, C. B. (2009). Inferential Statistics. Air Medical Journal, 28(4), 168-
171.
arara, k., & oyugi. (2014). a review of the empirical evidence . sustainable developement in
Africa .
Bene, C., Newsham, A., Davies, M., Ulrichs, M., & Goodfrey-Wood, R. (2014). Resilience,
Poverty and Development. International Development, 26(5), 598-623.
Bradford, K., & Katikiro, R. E. (2019). Fighting the Tides :A review of Gender and Fisheries
in Tanzania. Fisheries Research, 216, 79-88.
Danstun, N., & Harun, M. (2020). The Effect of Credit Collection Policy on Portifolio at Risk
of Microfinance Institutions in Tanzania. 14(3), 131-144.
Demirguc-Kunt, A., Klapper, L., Singer, D., Ansar, S., & Hess, J. (2017). The Global Findex
Database : Measuring Financial Inclusion and The Fintech Revolution.
Dosu, G. (2017). Perceptions of Socio -cultural beliefs and taboos Amoung the Ghanaian
Fishers and Fisheries Authorities .A Case Study of the Jamestown Fishing
Community in the Greater Accra. The Arctic University of Norway .
FAO. (2018). The State of World Fisheries and Aquaculture (SOFIA). Meeting The
Sustainable Development Goals, 227.
36
Fulton, E. A., Smith, A. D., Smith, D. C., & Putten, I. V. (2011). Human Behaviour: the Key
Source of Uncertainity in Fisheries Management. Fish and Fisheries, 12(1), 2=7.
guest , g., namey, E., & Mckenna. (2021). how many interviews are enough? an experiment
with data saturation and variability . field method.
J, S. (2018). fishing activities and coast sustainability a case study of the dares salam region.
journal of coast research.
johnson , R., onwuegbuzie, A. J., & Turner, L. A. (2020). toward a definition of a mixed
methods research . journal of mixed methods research.
Kombo, K., & Orodho, J. (2002). Research Methods. Nairobi: Kenyatta University , Institute
of Open Learning .
Kunt, A. D., Klapper, L., Singer, D., Ansar, S., & Hess, J. (2017). Measuring Financial
Inclusion and the Fintech Revolution . The Global Findex Database.
Ministry of Livestock and Fisheries. (2022). Fishery Sector Master Plan. Dodoma: United
Republic of Tanzania.
Nayak, P. k., & Berkes, F. (2019). Interplay Between Local and Global :Change Processes
and Small -Scale Fisheries.
Ndlovu, G., & Toerien, F. (2020). The Distributional Impact of Access to Finance on Poverty
: Evidence from Selected Countries in Sub-Saharan Africa. Research in Internaional
Business and Finance, 52.
Onyango, P., & Jentoft, S. (2010). Assessing Poverty in Small Scale Fisheries in Lake
Victoria , Tanzania. Fish and Fisheries, 11(3), 250-263.
Patton, Q. (2015). Qualitative research &evaluation methods :intergrating theory and practise
.
37
peart, j., tran , n., chan, c., maskaeva, a., madalla, n., & kimirei, i. (2021). a review of fish
supply demand in tanzania.
Peart, J., Tran, N., Chan, C. Y., Maskaeva, A., Shoko, A. P., Kimirei, I. A., et al. (2021). A
Review of Fish Supply -Demand in Tanzania. Malaysia: World Fish Program.
Robert , C., & Gordon, C. (1992). Sustainable Rural Livelihoods : Practical Concepts for
21st Century. Institute of Development Studies.
United Nation. (2016). Africa's Blue Economy. Addis Ababa , Ethiopia: Economic
commision for Africa .
Wildavsky, A. B., & Douglas, M. (1983). Risk and Culture : An essay on the Selection of
Technological and Environmental Dangers. California: University of Clifornia Press.
world bank. (2017). The Sunken Billions Revisited:Progress and Challenges in Global
Marine Fisheries. washington: World Bank.
world bank group . (2019). tanzania economic update, human capital the real wealth of the
natios.
World Group. (2021). Taking Women -Owned Business to the Next Level. Anueja: Word
Bank Group.
38
APPENDIX
QUESTIONAIRES
My name is Ms. Elisheba Enael Mmbaga, a third-year student pursuing a Bachelor's degree in
Accounting and Finance at the University of Ardhi. As part of the requirements for my degree,
I am conducting a year-long research project titled "Financial Accessibility and Sustainability
of Fishing Operations in the Ferry Area." All the questions asked in this research are for the
purpose of gathering information and data for educational purposes only. I kindly request you
to provide accurate information to the best of your ability for each question.
ETHICAL CONSIDERATIONS
The research will adhere to all ethical principles governing research work. Ethics will be
ensured from data collection to presentation. The utmost importance I prioritize in this study is
to ensure that your privacy is preserved and you are protected from the information you
provide.
A. 18-24
B. 25-34
C. 35-44
D. 45 and above
A. Single
B. Married
C. Divorced
D. Widowed
3. What is your level of education?
39
A. Primary Education
B. Secondary Education
C. Vocational Training
4. What is the amount of credit you have obtained for your business?
A. Commercial bank
B. Microfinance institution
C. Cooperative society
D. Government agency
B. 2
C. 3
D. 4
E. 5 - Very important
40
7. What are the main difficulties you face when seeking financial assistance for your
fishing activities?
A. Strong agree
B. Agree
C. Average
D. Strong disagree
E. Disagree
9. Do you follow any cultural belief in your fishing activities that affect the sustainability
of fishing?
F. Strong agree
G. Agree
H. Average
I. Strong disagree
J. Disagree
41
10. Are there any customs or traditions related to fishing activities in your area? If yes,
please describe some of those customs.
A. Strong agree
B. Agree
C. Average
D. Strong disagree
E. Disagree
11. Do those cultural belief influence how fishermen manage their fishing activities?
A. Strong agree
B. Agree
C. Average
D. Strong disagree
E. Disagree
12. Are there any cultural laws or community practices related to fisheries resource
management? Please describe those laws or practices.
A. YES
B. NO
13. Do you think cultural belief can be a barrier to improving fishing activities?
A. Strong agree
B. Agree
C. Average
D. Strong disagree
E. Disagree
14. Why do you believe that fishing activities have not been improved in your area? Please
explain the main reasons.
42
Section III: Access to Finance and cultural belief.
A. Strong agree
B. Agree
C. Average
D. Strong disagree
E. Disagree
16. How important is it for local fishermen to adhere to traditional cultural practices and
beliefs when making decisions about accessing financial support? Please rate on a scale
of 1 to 5, where 1 represents "Not Important at All" and 5 represents "Extremely
Important."
A. 1
B. 2
C. 3
D. 4
E. 5
17. In your opinion, to what extent do cultural beliefs affect the trust and confidence of
local fishermen in formal financial institutions? Please rate on a scale of 1 to 5, where
1 represents "No Influence" and 5 represents "Significant Influence."
A. 1
B. 2
C. 3
D. 4
E. 5
43
18. On a scale of 1 to 5, where 1 represents "Not at all" and 5 represents "To a Great Extent,"
how much do cultural beliefs contribute to the decision-making process of local
fishermen when considering accessing financial resources?
A. 1
B. 2
C. 3
D. 4
E. 5
19. To what degree do cultural beliefs shape the perception of financial assistance as a
means to preserve traditional fishing practices? Please rate on a scale of 1 to 5, where
1 represents "Not Influential" and 5 represents "Highly Influential."
A. 1
B. 2
C. 3
D. 4
E. 5
20. How influential are cultural beliefs in shaping the decision-making process of local
fishermen when choosing ways of financing? Please rate on a scale of 1 to 5, where 1
represents "No Influence" and 5 represents "Significant Influence."
A. 1
B. 2
C. 3
D. 4
E. 5
44
PART TWO QUESTIONAIRE: SWAHILI LANGUAGE
Mheshimiwa Bibi/ Bwana
Jina langu ni Bi. Elisheba Enael Mmbaga, mwanafunzi wa mwaka wa tatu anayesoma Shahada
ya Uhasibu na Fedha katika Chuo Kikuu cha Ardhi. Kama sehemu ya mahitaji ya shahada
yangu, ninatekeleza mradi wa utafiti wa mwaka mmoja uitwao "Upatikanaji wa Fedha na
Uendelevu wa Shughuli za Uvuvi katika eneo la Ferry." Maswali yote yaliyoulizwa katika
utafiti huu ni kwa lengo la kukusanya habari na data kwa madhumuni ya elimu pekee. Naomba
sana uweze kutoa habari sahihi kulingana na uwezo wako kwa kila swali.
MAZINGIRA YA KIMAADILI
Utafiti huu utazingatia kanuni zote za maadili zinazosimamia kazi ya utafiti. Maadili
yatahakikishwa kutoka ukusanyaji wa data hadi uwasilishaji wake. Kitu muhimu kabisa
ninachozingatia katika utafiti huu ni kuhakikisha kuwa faragha yako inahifadhiwa na wewe
unalindwa kutokana na habari unazotoa.
Asante sana.
45
Sehemu II: Upatikanaji wa fedha na uendelevu wa shughuli za uvuvi.
4. Je, kiasi gani cha mikopo umepata kwa biashara yako?
A. Chini ya TZS 500,000
B. TZS 500,000 - TZS 1,000,000
C. TZS 1,000,000 - TZS 2,000,000
D. Zaidi ya TZS 2,000,000
6. Kwa kiwango cha 1 hadi 5, ambapo 1 ni "hakuna umuhimu kabisa" na 5 ni "umuhimu sana,"
je, upungufu wa rasilimali za kifedha unazuia kwa kiasi gani utulivu wa shughuli za uvuvi?
A. 1 - Hakuna umuhimu
kabisa
B. 2
C. 3
D. 4
E. 5 - Umuhimu sana
46
8. Je, serikali au taasisi za kifedha zimefanya jitihada za kutoa elimu au mafunzo juu ya
upatikanaji wa rasilimali za kifedha kwa wavuvi? Kwa kiwango cha 1 hadi 5, ambapo 1
inawakilisha "Kukubaliana Kabisa" na 5 inawakilisha "Kukubaliana Kabisa," tafadhali pima
taarifa ifuatayo:
A. Kukubaliana kabisa
B. Kukubaliana
C. Kati
D. Kutokubaliana kabisa
E. Kutokubaliana
10. Je, kuna desturi au tamaduni zozote zinazohusiana na shughuli za uvuvi katika eneo lako?
Ikiwa ndio, tafadhali eleza baadhi ya desturi hizo.
A. Kukubaliana kabisa
B. Kukubaliana
C. Kati
D. Kutokubaliana kabisa
E. Kutokubaliana
11. Je, imani hizo za kitamaduni zinaathiri jinsi wavuvi wanavyosimamia shughuli zao za
uvuvi?
A. Kukubaliana kabisa
B. Kukubaliana
C. Kati
D. Kutokubaliana kabisa
E. Kutokubaliana
47
12. Je, kuna sheria za kitamaduni au mazoea ya jamii yanayohusiana na usimamizi wa
rasilimali za uvuvi? Tafadhali eleza sheria au mazoea hayo.
A. NDIO
B. HAPANA
13. Je, unaamini kuwa imani za kitamaduni zinaweza kuwa kikwazo kwa kuboresha shughuli
za uvuvi?
A. Kukubaliana kabisa
B. Kukubaliana
C. Kati
D. Kutokubaliana kabisa
E. Kutokubaliana
14. Kwa nini unaamini kuwa shughuli za uvuvi hazijaboreshwa katika eneo lako? T
48
16. Ni kwa kiwango gani ni muhimu kwa wavuvi wa ndani kufuata desturi na imani za
kitamaduni wanapofanya maamuzi kuhusu kupata msaada wa kifedha? Tafadhali pima kwa
kiwango cha 1 hadi 5, ambapo 1 inawakilisha "Sio Muhimu Kabisa" na 5 inawakilisha
"Muhimu Sana."
A. 1
B. 2
C. 3
D. 4
E. 5
17. Kwa maoni yako, kwa kiwango gani imani za kitamaduni zinaathiri imani na uaminifu wa
wavuvi wa ndani kwa taasisi rasmi za kifedha? Tafadhali pima kwa kiwango cha 1 hadi 5,
ambapo 1 inawakilisha "Hakuna Athari" na 5 inawakilisha "Athari Kubwa."
A. 1
B. 2
C. 3
D. 4
E. 5
18. Kwa kiwango cha 1 hadi 5, ambapo 1 inawakilisha "Kabisa Sio" na 5 inawakilisha "Kwa
Kiasi Kubwa," ni kwa kiwango gani imani za kitamaduni zinachangia katika mchakato wa
maamuzi wa wavuvi wa ndani wanapofikiria kupata rasilimali za kifedha?
A. 1
B. 2
C. 3
D. 4
E. 5
19. Kwa kiasi gani imani za kitamaduni zinaunda mtazamo wa msaada wa kifedha kama njia
ya kuhifadhi mazoea ya uvuvi ya jadi? Tafadhali pima kwa kiwango cha 1 hadi 5, ambapo 1
inawakilisha "Haina Ushawishi" na 5 inawakilisha "Ina Ushawishi Mkubwa."
A. 1
B. 2
C. 3
D. 4
E. 5
49
20. Ni kwa kiwango gani imani za kitamaduni zinaushawishi uamuzi wako wa kutafuta
rasilimali za kifedha kwa shughuli zako za uvuvi?
A. Kukubaliana kabisa
B. Kukubaliana
C. Kati
D. Kutokubaliana kabisa
E. Kutokubaliana
50