You are on page 1of 10

1

IoT-based Wearables: A comprehensive Survey


Yahuza Bello ∗ , Emanuel Figetakis ∗
∗ University of Guelph, Ontario, Canada.

Abstract—A substantial amount of growth is being achieved by databases, or the cloud. Based on the analysis performed on
businesses through IoT-based services. The emergent of small elec- the collected data, specific actions are taken according to the
tronic devices capable of computing, which are commonly known as services that are required. There are a variety of IoT sensors,
wearables in IoT domain has proven to have huge impact in people’s
life. Theses wearables are capable of collecting vital information including smart sensors, actuators, and wearable sensors. We will
about a person’s activities and behaviours regularly. This makes discuss sensors in the context of wearable devices in section
them suitable for many applications in health monitoring, fitness, IV. Using multiple communication technologies, heterogeneous
arXiv:2304.09861v1 [cs.HC] 12 Apr 2023

sports, education and some industry related applications. To this IoT objects can be connected to provide specific smart services.
end, in this paper, we aim to provide a general review on IoT-based The different communication technologies used in the context
wearables, the sensors adopted for several categorized wearables, the
communication technologies adopted and the most widely adopted of wearable devices will be discussed in detail in section V. In
data processing techniques for wearables. Furthermore, we present IoT, processors, microcontrollers, System-on-Chips (SoCs), and
the challenges faced for wide adoption of wearables and the future Field-Programmable Gate Arrays (FPGAs) comprise the ”brain”
research directions. and computational power. Arduino, UDOO, FriendlyARM, Intel
Index Terms—Internet of things, wearables, communication tech- Galileo, Raspberry PI, Gadgeteer, BeagleBone, Cubieboard, Z1,
nologies, data analytic WiSense, Mulle, and T-Mote Sky are some of the hardware
platforms designed to run IoT applications.
The emergent of small electronic devices capable of computing,
I. I NTRODUCTION
which are commonly known as wearables in IoT domain has

I N today’s modern era, several applications are developed with


the need of connectivity to the internet to function effec-
tively. The Internet of Things (IoT) is the concept of having
proven to have huge impact in peoples life [4]. Theses wearables
are capable of collecting vital information about a person’s ac-
tivities and behaviours regularly. This makes them suitable for
embedded systems interconnected together and communicating many applications in health monitoring, fitness, sports, education
through the Internet [1]. This provides the required connectivity and some industry related applications. Wearables are often worn
to the internet for such applications. The IoT domain has been as additional accessories on individual’s clothing, as implants on
thoroughly investigated in both academia and industry and its certain part of the body, or even tattooed to the skin. Being part
development through the years was rapid because of its wide of the IoT ecosystem, wearables are connected to the Internet
range of applications in various fields such as health, IoT-enabled in order to gather and transmit vital information. Additionally,
sports, IoT-enabled factories, agriculture, IoT-enabled cities, traffic the mobility of people and animals makes wearable devices
management, smart supply chain and smart grid to name a few as increasingly important since they can collect, send, and receive
depicted in Figure 1. data from the Internet in real time, and thus help us to make
A substantial amount of growth is being achieved by businesses better decisions to improve our lifestyle.
through IoT-based services. For example, the biggest economic A wide variety of wearable products such as smart jewelleries,
impact will be from healthcare and manufacturing applications. smart wristbands, smart watches, smart glasses, smart shoes and
The global economy is expected to generate about 1.1−2.5 trillion smart belts are already available in the markets as illustrated in
US dollars in growth annually by 2025 as a result of IoT- Figure 4. According to International Data Corporations (IDC),
based healthcare applications and services, such as mobile health the global shipments of wearable products are projected to grow
(mHealth) and telecare services that improves diagnosis, treatment from 66.5 million units as reported in 2019 to 105.3 million
and other monitoring services. IoT is estimated to generate a units by the end of 2024 [5]. Wearable devices first emerged
total economic impact amounting to $2.7 trillion - $6.2 trillion as fitness activity trackers, then comes other applications such
annually by 2025 [2]. In Figure 2, dominant IoT applications as Bluetooth headsets, smartwatches, and web-enabled glasses
(i.e., applications in healthcare, manufacturing, electricity, urban shortly [6]. Afterwards, virtual reality headsets and augmented
infrastructure, security, resource extraction, agriculture, retail and reality headsets were introduced in the gaming industry. However,
vehicles) are shown with their projected market share [3]. health monitoring and medical usage cases are the most important
A typical IoT consists of 6 building blocks as shown in Figure 3. life-changing applications of IoT-based wearable technologies.
These buildings blocks are identification, sensing, communica- Wearable devices are a rapidly developing field with the po-
tion, computation/processing, services and semantics. By knowing tential to open up new applications. This review is motivated
these building blocks, you can gain a deeper understanding of how by the potential of wearable devices to be able to open up
IoT works and what it means. Identifying services and matching new applications in various fields. Specifically, in this review,
them with customer demands is crucial for IoT. Electronic product we will focus mainly on identifying the different wearables in
codes (EPCs) and ubiquitous codes (uCodes) are two most adopted the IoT domain, discuss the different sensors adopted for these
identification methods for the IoT systems. Sensors in the IoT wearables and then cover the different data processing techniques
gather data from related objects and send it to data warehouses, and communication technologies that are widely used for the IoT-
2

Fig. 1: Internet of things Applications [7]

based wearables. most of them focused on specific application such as applications


in fitness and health monitoring neglecting the sensors behind
each wearable, the various communication techniques adopted
and data processing techniques that are commonly used for IoT-
based wearables. To this end, in this paper, we aim to provide
a general review on IoT-based wearables, the sensors adopted
for several categorized wearables, the communication technologies
adopted and the most widely adopted data processing techniques
for wearables.
The rest of the paper is structured as follows: Section II presents
the relevant survey papers published in the literature. Section III
introduces IoT-based wearables and categorized them according
to the targeted application. In section IV, the most commonly
used sensors for IoT-based wearables are discussed. Section V
discusses the various communication technologies adopted for
wearables and the various data analytic techniques used for data
processing. Section VI presents the challenges faced for wide
adoption of wearables and the future research directions. Section
VII concludes the paper.

II. R ELATED W ORKS


A number of other research studies have examined wearable
technologies in different ways. For example, the survey paper in
[4] provides academics seeking further research topics with an
Fig. 2: Projected market share of dominant IoT applications by in-depth understanding of smart wearables concept. The authors
2025 [3] present an analysis of behavioral predictors of smart wearable
adoption and adoption intentions among people. In [8], using
Although there are several survey papers [4,8]–[13] that ad- signals and sensors, the authors examines context-based pairing
dressed the concept of wearables and the ongoing research efforts, in wearable devices. The author in [9] examine each type of IoT
3

Fig. 3: IoT components [3]

become worth their weight in gold when they are integrated into
a true IoT system. As a result, most research papers currently
published in the literature connect wearable devices to the Internet
in one of two ways. Either the wearable devices send data to the
cloud or to an Internet server for offline processing or some of
the data processing is done locally on the wearable device. Having
integrated IoT platforms and addressing many issues pertaining to
data ownership, data sharing policies, privacy, and safety will fully
realize the prevalence of wearable devices.
Smart watch Smart jewelry Smart wristband
In many cases, a mobile network is needed to support these
wearable devices. Data is also a concern when dealing with
sensors that collect many readings. In works [14]–[18] the authors
create specialized networks that can handle the needs of wearable
devices. These networks also address several concerns such as
security and data storage. In, [19] shows that edge nodes can also
Smart glasses Smart shoes Smart belts play an important role with IoT devices and data collection. It can
reduce load on the server and save storage space.

Several research works have categorized IoT-based wearables


Fig. 4: IoT-based Wearable products by considering multiple factors. As part of its ongoing effort to
standardize wearable electronic devices and technologies, Tech-
nical Commission (TC) 124 of the IEC (International Elec-
architecture as well as different methods of data transfer, data pro- trotechnical Commission) identifies four types of smart wearables:
cessing, and computing paradigms. Then the IoT-assisted wearable accessory wearables, textile/fabric wearables, patchable wearables
sensor systems and their various applications in healthcare as well and implantable wearables. For details on this categorization, refer
as the various communication technologies adopted are presented to [20]. The IEC Standardization Group (SG) 10 on wearable
in the paper. The authors in [10] reviews both scientific papers smart devices also indicated that these wearable devices can be
and commercial efforts related to wearable health care devices. categorized in accordance with their location within, on, or near
The paper focuses on the most important wearable devices that an individual. The categories are near-body wearables, in-body
directly measure health status parameters. An overview of existing wearables, on-body wearables and electronic textiles [21]. Accord-
literature on intelligent wearables is presented in [11]. The authors ing to [22], IoT-based wearable devices can be categorized into
went further to provide a review of the risks of using intelligent wrist-worn devices (such as smart watches and wrist bands), haed-
wearables and explain what risks were considered in previous mounted devices (such as smart eyewear, headset and earbuds), e-
research. The authors in [12] discuss and explore several commu- textile (such as smart garments), e-patches (such as sensor patches
nication and artificial intelligence techniques, which are suitable and e-tattoo) and others (this category covers that do not fall under
for the next generation of wearable devices. These techniques the other categories such as smart jewellery and straps).
when fully adopted will enable emergence of innovative services.
An overview of recent research on wearables and IoT technologies In this paper, we categorized wearable devices according to the
used for fitness assessment is provided in [13]. targeted applications in IoT domain similar to the work in [23].
As depicted in Figure 5, IoT-based wearbles can be classified
III. W EARABLES IN I OT according to the targeted applications as Health-based wearables,
There are many applications in the field of IoT that can be safety-based wearables, sports and activity recognition wearables
enhanced by wearable technology. However, wearable devices will and tracking and localization wearables.
4

TABLE I: Summary of the Categorized Wearables and the relavant related works

Wearable categories Description Related works


Wearable IoT devices used to monitor and treat patients
Health-based applications [23]–[29]
remotely, and in some cases for rehabilitation.
wearables in the safety category are used to provide a safe
Safety Applications [30]–[35]
environment for users.
This category pertains to applications where wearables are
Sports and activity recogni-
worn during sport activities to track different metrics of [36,37]
tion
user/athlete activity to improve their performance.
Tracking people and animals online is the most common use
Tracking and localization [38,39]
of this category.

[24] presents a walker-based physiotherapy system for monitoring


and evaluating movement metrics is proposed, which sends the
Health Applications
data to the cloud for analysis, and displayed on a mobile appli-
cation in real time. In [25], a stroke rehabilitation framework that
utilizes smart wearable armbands, machine learning algorithms,
and 3-D-printed robot hands to assist stroke patients was proposed.
Sports & Activity
An IoT sensing device was integrated with textile electrodes to
Recognition Applications
IoT-based Safety Applications develop the SWA, which measures, pre-processes, and wirelessly
Wearables transmits biopotential information. The work in [26] presents a
framework for an m-Health monitoring system based on a cloud
computing platform (Cloud-MHMS) for achieving personalised
and high-quality health monitoring using new technologies, such
as mobile networks and cloud computing. A system using IoT
Tracking and Localization
Applications
data to support emergency medical services is presented as a
demonstration of how data can be collected, integrated, and inter-
operated flexibly in [27]. The authors develop a Resource-based
Fig. 5: Application-based Classification of Wearable Devices Data Accessing-IoT (UDA-IoT) method that allow access to IoT
data resources in a universal manner in order to enhance the acces-
sibility of IoT data resources. The authors in [28] propose a new
A. Health-based wearables cloud-based wheelchair assist system, which supports impaired
In the health sector, Wearable IoT devices are usually used drivers by providing safe driving conditions. The authors utilized
to monitor and treat patients remotely, and in some cases for an embedded mobile System-On-a-Chip (SoC) and android based
rehabilitation. Data about a patient’s health is collected through mobile application for the proposed system. A gaming-based
sensors, and the wearable device may perform small analysis rehabilitation system integrating wearable technology and IoT is
before sending the data to the Internet for further processing. presented in [29] in order to help stroke patients who, suffer from
Additionally, these wearables are capable of receiving additional upper limb disabilities.
inputs to aid for further analysis. Often, health-based wearable In the same fashion, health monitoring wearable systems are
devices are typically connected to smartphones for analyzing data categorized based on the kind of sensor adopted as Bio-potential
and sending it to cloud computing frameworks like Azure or Ama- sensors, motion sensors, environmental sensors and chemical
zon Web Services (AWS) for handling, storing, and processing. sensors [23]. The different kind of sensors used in most IoT-based
The use of mobile health applications can provide insight about a wearables will be discussed in detail in the next section.
patient’s health and provide a visual representation of the analysis
of the data. The wearable also can be programmed to respond
to special commands, such as heating up the body or applying B. Safety-based wearables
shocks, based on the analyzed data during treatment. The wearables in the safety category are used to provide a
Health-based applications of wearables can be broadly cate- safe environment for users. For example, mines can benefit from
gorized as health treatment and rehabilitation wearable systems the use of safety-based wearable devices that monitor air quality
and health monitoring wearable systems [23]. Several studies have to protect workers and reduce costs incurred by employers and
demonstrated the significance of health treatment and rehabilita- the workers. Safety-based wearable devices are used in many
tion wearable systems. applications to detect or prevent falls, especially in elderly people.
By using rehabilitation wearables, disabled patients can main- Several studies in the literature have investigated and proposed
tain or improve their mental or physical abilities. The authors in numerous techniques and algorithms for fall detection.
5

TABLE II: Common Communication Technologies used in IoT-based Wearables

Type of Technol-
Range Data Rates Frequency Band (s) Topology
ogy
ZigBee 10 to 100 meters 250kbps 2GHz Star, ad hoc, and mesh
WiFi 10 to 100 meters 6.75Gbps 2.4GHz, 5GHz Point Hub
2.402GHz to Point to point, point to
Bluetooth 10 to 100 meters 2.1Mbps
2.408GHz multi-point
169 MHz (Asia),
868MHz (Europe)
LoRaWan 15 to 20 Kilometers 250bps to 5.5kbps Star
91MHz (North
America)

Using pretested templates for each type of fall and comparing device can help measure and study kinematics in a sport setting.
angular velocities and angles between falls and normal activities, Examples of the sensors being used in a device can be found in
[30] propose a fall detection framework. In [31], deep learning [44] and [45] where the sensors are used for their advantages in
and activity characteristics are used to develop a novel method capturing certain ranges of motions. The data is then captured
for detecting human falls on furniture using scene analysis that and analyzed by their respective data analysis programs. Sensors
adopts Region-based Convolutional Neural Network (R-CNN). in IoT are very violate especially in Wearables, many sensors
A fall detection system incorporated tri-axial accelerometers, have more than one application, for example IMU sensors have
gyroscopes, and magnetometers to obtain fall parameters was applications in wearables outside of sports. For example, in [46]
proposed by [32]. Based on a reverse approach, the authors in [33] IMU sensors are used to create 3D maps, an application that is
propose a novel autonomous fall detection system. The proposed used outside of the scope of motion.
system uses a camera attached to the subject rather than static
sensors at fixed locations. Therefore, monitoring is not limited to
areas where the sensors are located but includes all areas where B. Sensors found in Healthcare
the subject travels. [34] presents a novel system that uses a smart When it comes to healthcare there is a long list of sensors that
camera to detect falls and classify activities around the waist. are found in wearables. Wearables in health care can be used to
An EEG-based BCI prototype is proposed [35] to detect whether monitor or treat patients, which are powered by different types
an on-site worker is sleep-deprived or not in an elegant manner. of sensors. Sensors already discussed [41][42][43] also have use
Modified safety helmets with a discreetly placed signal acquisition in healthcare since they deal with the study of motion with the
device are worn by workers to ensure their safety. Table I presents human body [40].
a summary of the categorized wearables and the relevant related Looking at table III there are many different sensors found
works published in the literature. in different wearable devices for healthcare. Many sensors are
present in many different devices, and sometimes are even com-
IV. S ENSORS IN I OT- BASED W EARABLE bined with other sensors from other categories of wearables. Look-
Sensors are a crucial part of IoT-based wearable, they allow for ing at the airflow sensor, it has a straightforward purpose within
the data collection of a certain action that can then be analyzed healthcare, to help a patient breathe. They can be found mostly
and measured. They are many different sensors, and each single in ventilators[48] as well as devices for oxygen therapy[50]. A
sensor can have multiple different applications. pressure sensor have an unexpectedly large impact on devices,
they are used in ventilators, oxygen therapy, sleep therapy[51], and
automation of drug infusion[52]. Another sensor that is common
A. Sensors found in Sports throughout healthcare is oxygen sensors, which measure a patients
Wearables that are used in sports to gain metrics and about an oxygen level. The sensor can be found in devices that attach to
athlete’s performance are categorized under Inertial Measurement a patient’s finger [54]. EEG sensors are also used in healthcare,
Unit (IMU) sensors and help with the study of motions, kinematics they are used in research for the human brain to help gain a better
[40] The sensors that are categorized under IMUs are magnetome- understanding and can also be used to help diagnose any issues.
ter, accelerometer, and gyroscopes. Magnetometer helps determine Glucose sensors mostly benefit patients with diabetes, the sensor
orientation of an object which in sports has many applications, the has become non-invasive and implemented on IoT devices such as
sensors themselves are small require low energy to power and can smartwatches that can automatically send alerts to let the patient
communicate over I2C or SPI [41]. Accelerometers can measure know any imbalances are occurring. The ECG sensor might be the
movement in a given direction, they can be as precise to measure most know sensor in healthcare, it is present in every hospital and
movement such as wrist tilt [42]. Gyroscopes measure orientation almost all smart watches/ring[59][60][61] feature an ECG sensor.
as well as angular velocity, it also has the ability to maintain The ECG measures heart rate and can collect information about a
orientation as well [43]. Combining the sensors into a single patient throughout the day to see if any irregularities are occurring.
6

TABLE III: Sensors Found in Healthcare IOT Wearables

Sensor Product Description


Helps correct a patients irregular breathing to
Airflow Sensor[47] [48]
supply enough oxygen to the body
Regulates and creates pressure in various appli-
Pressure Sensor[49] [48][50][51][52]
cations
Measures a patients oxygen level as well as pulse
Oxygen Sensor[53] [48][54]
rate
Electroencephalography(EEG)[55]
[56] Measures a patients brain activity
Sensor
Glucose Sensor [57] Measures a patients blood sugar level
Electrocardiogram(ECG) Sensor [58] [59][60][61] Measures a patients heart rate

C. Sensors found in Safety with everything between loss prevention to navigation. For more
Wearables in the area of safety are also finding applications, local mapping that does not need communication to satellite, like
the scenarios range from at home to work environment safety. somewhere in a house or small community, accelerometers are
Wearable devices are fitted with sensors that can check the envi- used to measure distance between certain points to create a map.
ronment, make sure certain equipment is being handled properly, This comes into play in applications with smart homes, as well
and prevent and kind of injury. Taking a look at [62] the authors as mobile devices to help predict a user’s habits.
used different sensors in a wearable device to determine harmful
environmental conditions. The sensors used in their wearable are
temperature, C02, UV, and CO [63][64][65][66]. When it comes
to safety most sensors can be implemented in wearables, for
sports, health, and tracking and localization they can be added as
preventative measures. For example, in sports, accelerometers can
be used to detected impacts which can cause injuries, in healthcare
ECG sensors can be used to detect abnormal heart rates, and in
tracking sensors can be implemented to prevent someone from
getting lost.

Fig. 7: Communication Technologies for IoT-based Wearables [22]

V. DATA A NALYSIS AND C OMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGIES


FOR I OT- BASED W EARABLES
Fig. 6: Example of Safety Wearable with sensors[62] In this section, we will first introduce the various communica-
tion technologies that are widely adopted in IoT-based wearables.
Then the various data analytic techniques in the context of
D. Sensors found in Tracking/Localization wearables will be discussed.
Werables that are categorized in tracking and localization help
with determining the environment conditions by utilizing sensors
as well determining location [67]. Tracking is a category with a A. Communication Technologies
wide area of applications, it can range from actual geo-locating Various wireless communication protocols support different
to tracking a person’s movements or specific body part. From communication ranges in wearables to offer a wide range of
a medical/sport standpoint sensor like accelerometers[42] can applications, as shown in Figure 7. Bluetooth, ZigBee and ANT
track movement to help determine the kind of motion, this also belong to the short range class, Wi-Fi and cellular, LoRaWan
applies to magnetometer and gyroscopes. For determine location belongs to the long range class and the ultra short range class
via satellite location sensors are used in wearables [68], this helps consists of NFC.
7

1) ZigBee: ZigBee technology is built on the IEEE 802.15.4 example, for tracking and localization wearable can feature an
standard. Resource-constrained environments and devices with accelerometers to track distance traveled but a wearable from
limited power provide the perfect environment for this kind of healthcare application could be using an accelerometers to track
technology to thrive. In spite of being standardized in 2003, the motion of a patient for physical therapy.
it was originally conceived in 1998 [69]. ZigBee has a range Machine learning can play an important role in data analysis
of approximately ten to a hundred meters and consumes an for wearables. It can help learn a person’s habits and find what is
insignificant amount of power. ZigBee uses the direct sequence normal for the user. In [73] it comes in the form of personalized
spread spectrum (DSSS) technique and adopts the ad hoc, mesh medicine, where a machine learning algorithm can learn about
and star topology. In ZigBee, there are three types of devices: the a patient and then keep checks on the patient for irregularities
coordinator (ZC), the router (ZR), and the end-device (ZED) [70]. outside of their normal. The same type of concept can be used in
2) Wi-Fi: A wireless communication standard based on all applications of wearables. Another example of data analysis
IEEE802.11, wireless fidelity (Wi-Fi) is one of the most popular comes from [74] where a wearable is being used to help diagnose
wireless technologies. In order to access radio channels, Wi-Fi early stages of Parkinson’s disease. The sensors collect data which
uses the CSMA/CA protocol. With a range up to 10 meters and is then analyzed and compared to the early signs of the disease.
a high -power consumption, Wi-Fi is a highly efficient wireless
network. There are four types of configurations available with this
network: infrastructure, ad hoc, bridge, and repeater, which has a
maximum data transfer rate of 6.75Gbps and 140MHz of channel
capacity for a very high price [71].
3) Bluetooth: Wireless personal area networks (WPANs) with
high security can be formed using Bluetooth, a proprietary open
standard developed for mobile and fixed devices. Using a master-
slave (client-server) model, Bluetooth is a packet-oriented protocol
that is connection-oriented, packet-based. Bluetooth were limited
by the initial specifications’ high-power consumption, long com-
munication set-up time, and high transmission latency (about 100
ms). Due to these limitations, Bluetooth Low Energy (BLE) was
developed to overcome them. BLE is designed specifically for
applications relating to health, sports, and fitness applications.
4) LoRaWan: IoT networks have become increasingly inter-
ested in LoRaWan (low-power wide-area networks) because it is
suitable for LPWAN (low-power wide-area networks). LoRaWan
is very suitable for wireless sensor networks due to its robustness
and range. Frequency Shift Keying (FSK) or Chirp Spread Spec-
trum (CSS) are the main modes of communication used in LoRa
radios. A node and a gateway are the two main types of devices
in this technology. Gateways are connected to thousands of nodes
at once, each sending and receiving information from the gateway
in a LoRaWan setup.
In the wearable device domain, Bluetooth Classic (standardized
but no longer maintained by IEEE 802.15.1), Bluetooth Smart and
Wi-Fi have become the most common standards [72] used for
connectivity to the Internet. A comparative analysis of the different
Fig. 8: System used for collecting data and analyzing data from
adopted communication technologies used in IoT-based wearables
a sensor [74]
in terms of range, data rates, frequency bands and topology is
presented in Table II.
In many of the systems, the data analysis doesn’t take place on
the device itself. The computation needed cannot be met, there
B. Data Analytics edge nodes and cloud -based systems are put in place to analyze
Data analytics has a large application within wearables in IoT, the data. However, this doesn’t come without challenges, many
since many new methods of machine learning are being developed, forms of data analytics require a large amount of data also many
they can be used within these applications. In a system there is the sensors are collecting data constantly throughout the entire day.
device with its many sensors taking constant measurements it is Over time this accumulates into terabytes of data that can fill up
the analytics that take the measurements and make them a readable storage drive quickly. Another challenge that must be addressed
output. IoT-based Wearables are classified in to four applications, in privacy, the data that is being collected about a person’s
health applications, sports applications, safety applications, track- habits/lifestyle is very detailed and can be shared between different
ing and localization applications. Wearables from each application companies, making privacy an issue. In [75] an approach is taken
can differ slightly in design and include the same sensors, it is with data analytics to unlabeled the data to help privacy. By doing
how the data is analyzed that differs from each application. For this they are not disclosing where the data is coming from and
8

keeping to anonymous, the only competent that is receiving the C. Trust-related Issues for Medical Use Cases
labelled data is the algorithm doing the analysis. There is lack of trust in the sensitive data produced by consumer
wearables in patients monitoring applications. For example, data
related to heart rate, pulse rate, and other health metrics is sensed
by wearables using consumer hardware. Therefore, physicians
are reluctant to use these data for critical diagnostics because
they much rely on the accuracy of the hardware used in making
the wearables as well as the accuracy of using it properly. A
critical challenge would therefore be to improve health-related
data accuracy cheaply.

D. Privacy-related Issues
It is possible that privacy breaches could occur as a result of
an exchange of personal data between wearables and IoT hubs,
including vital health signals, dosage, and location. It is typical for
wearable IoT devices to operate in broadcast mode so that other
network nodes can discover them easily. As a result, unauthorised
users can intercept data in the form of eavesdropping attacks,
which leads to privacy violation. A number of questions remain
unanswered concerning the effective protection of users’ privacy.
This is an interesting research problem that is on-going not only
in the wearable domain but in other security-related domains.
Fig. 9: System used for privacy data processing [75]
VII. C ONCLUSION
From fitness and sport to health monitoring, wearable devices
VI. C HALLENGES AND F UTURE R ESEARCH D IRECTIONS are becoming increasingly popular. In this paper, we provided a
There are several challenges in the domain of IoT-based wear- comprehensive review of the most important research efforts from
ables. To fully utilize the benefits of wearables devices in the the literature in IoT-based wearables. We categorized the wear-
community, these challenges need to be addressed urgently. ables according to their applicable applications. Additionally, the
sensors, communication technologies and data analytic techniques
A. Battery-related Issues adopted in the IoT-based wearables is investigated and presented
Since batteries have limited working times, wearable devices by surveying multiple papers published in the literature. Addi-
often have a short sustainable working time, which causes in- tionally. the challenges as well as the future research directions
convenience to people’s daily lives. Therefore, when designing in IoT-based wearables is presented. In terms of communication
wearables, special considerations need to be taken into account technologies, Bluetooth Classic, Bluetooth Smart and Wi-Fi are
to minimize human interaction and ensure that the batteries last the most common standards adopted for wearables connectivity
for many hours without needing to be replaced or recharged. For to the Internet.
example, there are a variety of systems available, such as those
that use low power consumption or techniques that harvest energy R EFERENCES
such as thermo-electric and piezo-electric that can be utilized in [1] L. D. Xu, W. He, and S. Li, “Internet of things in industries: A survey,”
wearable domain. IEEE Transactions on Industrial Informatics, vol. 10, no. 4, pp. 2233–2243,
2014.
[2] M. Chui, J. Manyika, and M. Miremadi, “Four fundamentals of workplace
B. Communication-related Issues automation,” McKinsey Quarterly, vol. 29, no. 3, pp. 1–9, 2015.
[3] A. Al-Fuqaha, M. Guizani, M. Mohammadi, M. Aledhari, and M. Ayyash,
Currently, most wearable devices connect to the Internet pri- “Internet of things: A survey on enabling technologies, protocols, and
marily through proxy devices such as smartphones or personal applications,” IEEE Communications Surveys & Tutorials, vol. 17, no. 4,
computers. For example, most fitness tracking wearable applica- pp. 2347–2376, 2015.
[4] N. Niknejad, W. B. Ismail, A. Mardani, H. Liao, and I. Ghani, “A
tions still communicate with clouds through smartphones. This comprehensive overview of smart wearables: The state of the art literature,
shows a gap in the adoption of direct communication with the recent advances, and future challenges,” Engineering Applications of
internet, which hinders the development of some specific delay Artificial Intelligence, vol. 90, p. 103529, 2020. [Online]. Available:
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0952197620300348
sensitive applications in the wearable domain. Potential reasons [5] Forecast unit shipments of wrist-worn wearables worldwide from 2019
for this lack of support may be the absence of secure direct to 2024. [Online]. Available: https://healthtechinsider.com/2020/10/26/
communication devices built into wearable operating systems or idc-forecasts-double-digit-weables-growth-through-2024/
[6] D. Nahavandi, R. Alizadehsani, A. Khosravi, and U. R. Acharya,
the slower development of third-party applications for wearables. “Application of artificial intelligence in wearable devices: Opportunities and
However, the demand for wearable devices capable of direct challenges,” Computer Methods and Programs in Biomedicine, vol. 213, p.
communication with the internet is on the rise [76]. This is a 106541, 2022. [Online]. Available: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/
article/pii/S0169260721006155
potential area of research to explore the design of wearable devices [7] What is the Internet of Things (IoT). [Online]. Available: https:
with such capability. //www.tibco.com/reference-center/what-is-the-internet-of-things-iot
9

[8] J. Pourbemany, Y. Zhu, and R. Bettati, “A survey of wearable devices pairing [31] W. Min, H. Cui, H. Rao, Z. Li, and L. Yao, “Detection of human falls
based on biometric signals,” 2021. on furniture using scene analysis based on deep learning and activity
[9] S. D. Mamdiwar, A. R, Z. Shakruwala, U. Chadha, K. Srinivasan, and characteristics,” IEEE Access, vol. 6, pp. 9324–9335, 2018.
C.-Y. Chang, “Recent advances on iot-assisted wearable sensor systems [32] P. Pierleoni, A. Belli, L. Palma, M. Pellegrini, L. Pernini, and S. Valenti,
for healthcare monitoring,” Biosensors, vol. 11, no. 10, 2021. [Online]. “A high reliability wearable device for elderly fall detection,” IEEE Sensors
Available: https://www.mdpi.com/2079-6374/11/10/372 Journal, vol. 15, no. 8, pp. 4544–4553, 2015.
[10] S. R. Haghi Mostafa, Thurow Kerstin, “Wearable devices in medical [33] K. Ozcan, S. Velipasalar, and P. K. Varshney, “Autonomous fall detection
internet of things: Scientific research and commercially available devices,” with wearable cameras by using relative entropy distance measure,” IEEE
hir, vol. 23, no. 1, pp. 4–15, 2017. [Online]. Available: http://www. Transactions on Human-Machine Systems, vol. 47, no. 1, pp. 31–39, 2016.
e-sciencecentral.org/articles/?scid=1075870 [34] K. Ozcan, A. Mahabalagiri, and S. Velipasalar, “Automatic fall detection and
[11] Y. Xue, “A review on intelligent wearables: Uses and risks,” Human Behavior activity classification by a wearable camera,” in Distributed Embedded Smart
and Emerging Technologies, vol. 1, no. 4, pp. 287–294, 2019. [Online]. Cameras. Springer, 2014, pp. 151–172.
Available: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1002/hbe2.173 [35] S. R. Dhole, A. Kashyap, A. N. Dangwal, and R. Mohan, “A novel helmet
[12] R. Sanchez-Iborra, “Lpwan and embedded machine learning as enablers for design and implementation for drowsiness and fall detection of workers on-
the next generation of wearable devices,” Sensors, vol. 21, no. 15, 2021. site using eeg and random-forest classifier,” Procedia Computer Science, vol.
[Online]. Available: https://www.mdpi.com/1424-8220/21/15/5218 151, pp. 947–952, 2019.
[13] J. Passos, S. I. Lopes, F. M. Clemente, P. M. Moreira, M. Rico-González, [36] J.-L. Reyes-Ortiz, L. Oneto, A. Samà, X. Parra, and D. Anguita, “Transition-
P. Bezerra, and L. P. Rodrigues, “Wearables and internet of things (iot) aware human activity recognition using smartphones,” Neurocomputing, vol.
technologies for fitness assessment: A systematic review,” Sensors, vol. 21, 171, pp. 754–767, 2016.
no. 16, 2021. [Online]. Available: https://www.mdpi.com/1424-8220/21/16/ [37] J. Qi, P. Yang, M. Hanneghan, S. Tang, and B. Zhou, “A hybrid hierarchical
5418 framework for gym physical activity recognition and measurement using
[14] Y. Bello, E. Figetakis, A. Refaey, and P. Spachos, “Continuous integration and wearable sensors,” IEEE Internet of Things Journal, vol. 6, no. 2, pp. 1384–
continuous delivery framework for sds,” in 2022 IEEE Canadian Conference 1393, 2018.
on Electrical and Computer Engineering (CCECE), 2022, pp. 406–410. [38] R. C. Shit, S. Sharma, D. Puthal, and A. Y. Zomaya, “Location of things
[15] Y. Bello, A. R. Hussein, M. Ulema, and J. Koilpillai, “On sustained zero (lot): A review and taxonomy of sensors localization in iot infrastructure,”
trust conceptualization security for mobile core networks in 5g and beyond,” IEEE Communications Surveys & Tutorials, vol. 20, no. 3, pp. 2028–2061,
IEEE Transactions on Network and Service Management, vol. 19, no. 2, pp. 2018.
1876–1889, 2022. [39] S. Tomic, M. Beko, and R. Dinis, “Rss-based localization in wireless sensor
[16] Y. Bello, A. A. Abdellatif, M. S. Allahham, A. R. Hussein, A. Erbad, networks using convex relaxation: Noncooperative and cooperative schemes,”
A. Mohamed, and M. Guizani, “B5g: Predictive container auto-scaling for IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology, vol. 64, no. 5, pp. 2037–2050,
cellular evolved packet core,” IEEE Access, vol. 9, pp. 158 204–158 214, 2014.
2021. [40] M. Rana and V. Mittal, “Wearable sensors for real-time kinematics analysis
[17] Y. Bello, M. S. Allahham, A. Refaey, A. Erbad, A. Mohamed, and in sports: A review,” IEEE Sensors Journal, vol. 21, no. 2, pp. 1187–1207,
N. Abdennadher, “B5g: Predictive container auto-scaling for cellular evolved 2021.
packet core,” in 2021 IEEE International Conference on Communications [41] Bosch Sensortec, “BMA150-Magnetometer,” https://www.bosch-sensortec.
Workshops (ICC Workshops), 2021, pp. 1–7. com/products/motion-sensors/magnetometers-bmm150/, accessed: 2022-7-
[18] J. Singh, Y. Bello, A. R. Hussein, A. Erbad, and A. Mohamed, “Hierarchical 23.
security paradigm for iot multiaccess edge computing,” IEEE Internet of [42] ——, “BMA400-Accelerometer,” https://www.bosch-sensortec.com/
Things Journal, vol. 8, no. 7, pp. 5794–5805, 2021. products/motion-sensors/accelerometers/bma400/, accessed: 2022-7-23.
[19] E. Figetakis and A. Refaey, “Uav path planning using on-board ultrasound [43] ——, “BMG250-Gyroscope,” https://www.bosch-sensortec.com/products/
transducer arrays and edge support,” in 2021 IEEE International Conference motion-sensors/gyroscopes-bmg250/, accessed: 2022-7-23.
on Communications Workshops (ICC Workshops), 2021, pp. 1–6. [44] Zepp Labs, “Zepp-Golf,” http://www.zepplabs.com/en-us/golf/
[20] IEC TC 124 Strategic Business Plan. [Online]. Available: https://www.iec. zepp-sensor-specifications/, accessed: 2022-7-23.
ch/public/miscfiles/sbp/124.pdf [45] Kinexon, “Kinexon Perform,” https://kinexon.com/solutions/basketball/, ac-
[21] IEC TC 124 Strategic Business Plan. [Online]. Available: https://www.iec. cessed: 2022-7-23.
ch/dyn/www/f?p=103:103:0::::FSP ORG ID,FSP LANG ID:12601,25 [46] C. Li, L. Yu, and S. Fei, “Real-time 3d motion tracking and reconstruction
[22] S. Seneviratne, Y. Hu, T. Nguyen, G. Lan, S. Khalifa, K. Thilakarathna, system using camera and imu sensors,” IEEE Sensors Journal, vol. 19, no. 15,
M. Hassan, and A. Seneviratne, “A survey of wearable devices and chal- pp. 6460–6466, 2019.
lenges,” IEEE Communications Surveys & Tutorials, vol. 19, no. 4, pp. 2573– [47] Honeywell, “AWM3000 series airflow sensors,” https://sps.honeywell.
2620, 2017. com/ca/en/products/advanced-sensing-technologies/healthcare-sensing/
[23] F. J. Dian, R. Vahidnia, and A. Rahmati, “Wearables and the internet of things airflow-sensors/amplified/awm3000-series, accessed: 2022-7-23.
(iot), applications, opportunities, and challenges: A survey,” IEEE Access, [48] Hillrom, “Life 2000 Ventilation,” https://www.hillrom.com/en/products/
vol. 8, pp. 69 200–69 211, 2020. life2000-system/life2000-overview/, accessed: 2022-7-23.
[24] C. Nave and O. Postolache, “Smart walker based iot physical rehabilitation [49] NXP, “MPX-5010,” https://www.nxp.com/products/
system,” in 2018 International Symposium in Sensing and Instrumentation sensors/pressure-sensors/differential-gauge-up-to-10-kpa/
in IoT Era (ISSI). IEEE, 2018, pp. 1–6. 0-to-10kpa-differential-and-gauge-integrated-pressure-sensor:MPXx5010,
[25] G. Yang, J. Deng, G. Pang, H. Zhang, J. Li, B. Deng, Z. Pang, J. Xu, accessed: 2022-7-23.
M. Jiang, P. Liljeberg et al., “An iot-enabled stroke rehabilitation system [50] Inogen, “G3-System,” https://www.inogen.com/products/g3-systems/, ac-
based on smart wearable armband and machine learning,” IEEE journal of cessed: 2022-7-23.
translational engineering in health and medicine, vol. 6, pp. 1–10, 2018. [51] Philips, “DreamStation-2,” https://www.usa.philips.com/healthcare/product/
[26] B. Xu, L. Xu, H. Cai, L. Jiang, Y. Luo, and Y. Gu, “The design of an m- HCEUX520H15C/dreamstation-2-auto-cpap-advanced-auto-cpap, accessed:
health monitoring system based on a cloud computing platform,” Enterprise 2022-7-23.
Information Systems, vol. 11, no. 1, pp. 17–36, 2017. [52] R. Dudde, T. Vering, G. Piechotta, and R. Hintsche, “Computer-aided
[27] B. Xu, L. Da Xu, H. Cai, C. Xie, J. Hu, and F. Bu, “Ubiquitous data accessing continuous drug infusion: setup and test of a mobile closed-loop system
method in iot-based information system for emergency medical services,” for the continuous automated infusion of insulin,” IEEE Transactions on
IEEE Transactions on Industrial informatics, vol. 10, no. 2, pp. 1578–1586, Information Technology in Biomedicine, vol. 10, no. 2, pp. 395–402, 2006.
2014. [53] ProtoCentral, “NMAX30100,” https://protocentral.com/product/
[28] A. Ghorbel, S. Bouguerra, N. B. Amor, and M. Jallouli, “Cloud based pulse-pulse-ox-heart-rate-sensor-based-on-max30102/, accessed: 2022-
mobile application for remote control of intelligent wheelchair,” in 2018 14th 7-23.
International Wireless Communications & Mobile Computing Conference [54] Insignia, “NS-PSOXMW1,” https://www.insigniaproducts.com/pdp/
(IWCMC). IEEE, 2018, pp. 1249–1254. NS-PSOXMW1/6438023, accessed: 2022-7-23.
[29] M. O. Agyeman and A. Al-Mahmood, “Design and implementation of [55] NeuroSky, “MindWave,” https://www.sparkfun.com/products/14758, ac-
a wearable device for motivating patients with upper and/or lower limb cessed: 2022-7-23.
disability via gaming and home rehabilitation,” in 2019 Fourth International [56] Muse, “Muse-2,” https://choosemuse.com/muse-2/, accessed: 2022-7-23.
Conference on Fog and Mobile Edge Computing (FMEC). IEEE, 2019, pp. [57] Dexcom, “G6 CGM,” https://ca.store.dexcom.com/en-CA/
247–252. dexcom-g6/g6-sensor-single/STS-GS-008.html?gclid=
[30] M. Nyan, F. E. Tay, and E. Murugasu, “A wearable system for pre-impact fall EAIaIQobChMI967Ig6qd-QIVZYJbCh0NKASBEAQYASABEgJvRPD
detection,” Journal of biomechanics, vol. 41, no. 16, pp. 3475–3481, 2008. BwE, accessed: 2022-7-23.
10

[58] Mikroe, “ECG-6,” https://www.sparkfun.com/products/19480, accessed:


2022-7-23.
[59] Apple, “Apple-Watch,” https://www.apple.com/ca/shop/buy-watch/
apple-watch, accessed: 2022-7-23.
[60] Fitbit, “Sense-SmartWatch,” https://www.fitbit.com/global/en-ca/products/
smartwatches/sense?sku=512SRSG, accessed: 2022-7-23.
[61] Oura, “Oura Ring Generation 3-Smart Ring,” https://ouraring.com/product/
heritage-silver, accessed: 2022-7-23.
[62] F. Wu, C. Rüdiger, J.-M. Redouté, and M. R. Yuce, “We-safe: A wearable
iot sensor node for safety applications via lora,” in 2018 IEEE 4th World
Forum on Internet of Things (WF-IoT), 2018, pp. 144–148.
[63] CozIR, “GC-0012,” https://datasheets.globalspec.com/ds/15/CO2Meter/
2E9DD87D-DD7B-4D2A-BCAC-1EAD9AE41EBD, accessed: 2022-7-23.
[64] Bosch Sensortec, “BM280,” https://www.bosch-sensortec.com/products/
environmental-sensors/humidity-sensors-bme280/, accessed: 2022-7-23.
[65] Adafruit, “SI1145,” https://www.adafruit.com/product/1777, accessed: 2022-
7-23.
[66] Spec Sensors, “968-001,” https://www.digikey.com/en/products/detail/
spec-sensors-llc/968-001/6136365, accessed: 2022-7-23.
[67] S. Mohanty, A. Tripathy, and B. Das, “An overview of a low energy uwb
localization in iot based system,” in 2021 International Symposium of Asian
Control Association on Intelligent Robotics and Industrial Automation (IRIA),
2021, pp. 293–296.
[68] Adafruit, “PA1616D,” https://www.adafruit.com/product/5186, accessed:
2022-7-23.
[69] ZigBee White Paper. [Online]. Available: https://www.yumpu.com/en/
document/view/65594940/zigbee-white-paper
[70] K. Lounis and M. Zulkernine, “Attacks and defenses in short-range wireless
technologies for iot,” IEEE Access, vol. 8, pp. 88 892–88 932, 2020.
[71] P. S. Henry and H. Luo, “Wifi: what’s next?” IEEE Communications
Magazine, vol. 40, no. 12, pp. 66–72, 2002.
[72] R. Gravina and G. Fortino, “Wearable body sensor networks: state-of-the-art
and research directions,” IEEE Sensors Journal, vol. 21, no. 11, pp. 12 511–
12 522, 2020.
[73] F. Ahamed and F. Farid, “Applying internet of things and machine-learning
for personalized healthcare: Issues and challenges,” in 2018 International
Conference on Machine Learning and Data Engineering (iCMLDE), 2018,
pp. 19–21.
[74] A. Balakrishnan, J. Medikonda, and P. K. Namboothiri, “Analysis of the
effect of muscle fatigue on gait characteristics using data acquired by
wearable sensors,” in 2020 IEEE International Conference on Distributed
Computing, VLSI, Electrical Circuits and Robotics (DISCOVER), 2020, pp.
137–140.
[75] Y.-T. Lee, W.-H. Hsiao, Y.-S. Lin, and S.-C. T. Chou, “Privacy-preserving
data analytics in cloud-based smart home with community hierarchy,” IEEE
Transactions on Consumer Electronics, vol. 63, no. 2, pp. 200–207, 2017.
[76] Wearable Tech Sales Explored: Just How Many Devices Have
Been Sold? [Online]. Available: https://www.wareable.com/wearable-tech/
wearable-tech-sales-explored-7456

You might also like