Professional Documents
Culture Documents
3, 2 0 0 6
ABSTRACT
188
A.S. Svanberg et al.
189
GENDER MEDICINE
Importance of having
Important Considerations in the
children, VAS,* Decision to Become a Parent
mean (SO), mm 68.8 (25.8) 69.0 (24.5) Almost all respondents regarded having a sta-
ble relationship and sharing responsibility with
Confident of having
a partner as important considerations in the
the desired no. of
decision to become a parent. Compared with
children, VAS,§ II
men, w o m e n placed significantly more impor-
mean (SO), mm 39.4 (24.4) 53.4 (29.0)
tance on having access to child care (P < 0.01)
Want children during and having children before a certain age (P <
postgraduate studies, % O.OS) (Table IV).
Yes 47 36
No 51 60
Presumed or Experienced Life Changes in
*Respondents who already had children or had an ongoing Connection with Becoming a Parent
pregnancy with their partner were excluded (n = 61). Most respondents stated that becoming a par-
t Some individuals did not respond to all questions. ent would entail personal growth, being loved,
* Visual analog scale (VAS): 0 = unimportant to 100 = very important.
§P< 0.01. and being more loving. W o m e n were signifi-
IIVAS: O = not at all confident to 100 = entirely confident. cantly more pessimistic than were m e n regard-
190
A.S. Svanberg et al.
DISCUSSION
Table III. Perceived obstacles for having children
To our knowledge, this is the first study that has
during postgraduate studies.*
investigated attitudes toward p a r e n t h o o d and
% Women % Men fertility awareness a m o n g postgraduate stu-
Obstacle (n = 141) (n = 116) P dents. One interesting finding was that post-
graduate students on average wanted to have a
Employment conditions <0.05 higher n u m b e r of children compared with the
Yes 23 14
current fertility rate of 1.75 in Swedish women.1
Partly 25 17
No 48 65 Childless female respondents wanted to have
their first child at age 31, which is 2 years older
Schedule of research
project than the mean age for Swedish first-time moth-
Yes 29 23 ers in 2004,1 and two thirds of the w o m e n
Partly 33 27 wanted their last child after the age of 35. Thus,
No 33 46 m a n y female postgraduate students are post-
Research supervisor's poning their childbearing until an age w h e n fe-
expectations <0.01 male reproductive capacity is decreased, which
Yes 16 3 jeopardizes their ability to have 2 or 3 children.
Partly 24 14
No 54 78 Women appeared aware of this dilemma, judging
by their relatively low confidence about having
Financial support for
parental leave <0.05 the desired number of children.
Yes 26 12 About half of the respondents regarded the
Partly 21 18 schedule of their research project as an obstacle
No 48 61 and did not want to have children during their
studies. This finding is comparable to that of a
*Some individualsdid not respond to all questions.
previous report on 1200 postgraduate students
in Sweden, 40% of w h o m stated they had post-
ing the impact of p a r e n t h o o d on their work life. p o n e d the decision to have children until com-
Sixty-two percent of w o m e n and 49% of m e n pletion of their studies. 19 Our findings showed
strongly agreed that p a r e n t h o o d would imply that more w o m e n than m e n considered em-
less time for work and career (P < 0.01). Whereas p l o y m e n t conditions, financial support for
38% of w o m e n strongly agreed that p a r e n t h o o d parental leave, and research supervisor's expec-
would imply poorer status in the labor market, tations as obstacles to having children during
this was true for only 9% of m e n (P < 0.001). postgraduate studies.
Parental-leave benefits in Sweden are based
Awareness of Fertility Issues on annual income from the preceding year and
One of 4 w o m e n and 1 of 3 m e n believed that the lowest a m o u n t per day is ~20 ¢ (~$25 US).
women's ability to b e c o m e pregnant decreases Postgraduate students on scholarships receive
markedly after the age of 40 (Table V). Only a the lowest a m o u n t of parental-leave benefits,
minority of respondents had realistic percep- whereas students with temporary research posi-
tions of women's fecundity at different ages. tions receive 80% of their regular salary during
About half of the w o m e n and m e n overestimat- parental leave. In the present study, w o m e n and
ed a y o u n g woman's chances of becoming preg- m e n had similar e m p l o y m e n t situations, which
nant in 1 year. In contrast, half of the respon- therefore does not contribute to our under-
dents had overly pessimistic perceptions standing of reported gender differences in per-
regarding older w o m e n ' s fertility. Further- ceived obstacles. One possible explanation for
more, approximately half of the w o m e n and these findings is that w o m e n and m e n differ in
m e n overestimated the chances of having a their perceptions of what practical impact par-
child b y means of IVE e n t h o o d has had or would have on their studies
191
GENDER MEDICINE
Table IV. Important considerations for postgraduate students' decision to have children.*t
*A comparison using the Mann-Whitney U test was performed on raw data from a response scale ranging from 1 to 5, where 1 = not
important and 5 = very important.
tTo illustrate the participants' main responses, only percentages for the response alternatives indicating high importance are presented.
:~P< 0.01.
§P < 0.05.
with regard to parental leave, for example. Al- studies, 3,12,13 having a sufficient income, proper
t h o u g h b o t h parents in Sweden are entitled to housing, and a stable relationship were salient
the same n u m b e r of cash-benefit days, fathers factors w h e n starting a family. In a previous
in 2004 only used 17% of the cash-benefit days study, ~70% of undergraduate students believed
available to a couple w h e n they have a baby. 2° that completing their studies was an important
Both w o m e n and m e n considered having a condition for parenthood. 13 In contrast, only
stable relationship and having a partner with 30% of postgraduate students in the present
w h o m they could share the responsibility of study emphasized this condition. An explana-
p a r e n t h o o d as very important to attain before tion for this m a y be the older m e a n age of the
having children. Similar to findings in other postgraduate students and the fact that a major-
192
A.S. Svanberg et al.
% Women % Men
Question (n = 141) (n = 116)
*An open response format was used; respondents were requested to state what they believed.
tpercentages may not equal 100 due to rounding.
:~lndicates the category that contains the "correct answer" according to published data.14-18
193
GENDERMEDICINE
facts 14-18 and the respondents' answers should dren. W o m e n also expressed more concerns
be interpreted with caution. Interestingly, half about future problems with balancing work and
of the postgraduate students underestimated family life. Because a substantial n u m b e r of
a woman's chances of becoming pregnant be- w o m e n overestimate not only their fertility in
tween the ages of 35 and 40, which is surpris- the late 30s but also the success rate of IVF, they
ing, considering that most female respondents m a y delay childbearing w i t h o u t knowing they
wanted to have their last child during that age risk childlessness. To address this current public
period. This overly pessimistic belief is in con- health and social problem, we suggest that in-
trast to the overestimation of the chances of f o r m a t i o n about the age-related decline in
having a child by means of IVE a m e t h o d that fecundity be provided to women, especially
was generally considered a viable solution in those who embark on a long academic path. A
the event of infertility. preferable m e t h o d of educating w o m e n engaged
Previous research has f o u n d that primary in lengthy university studies might be leaflets
infertility was related to higher levels of educa- and/or through student-oriented magazines.
tion, 24 and that female university students Our findings have clinical implications for
tended to postpone childbirth until they earned family p l a n n i n g staff w h o have the responsibil-
their degree. 3 W o m e n and m e n need to be well ity of educating patients about the influence of
informed about the declining rates of concep- age on fertility. Moreover, we believe that our
tion for w o m e n in their 30s and the limitations findings illustrate the need to assist w o m e n in
of success using assisted reproduction. In most their efforts to combine family life with higher
public IVF clinics in Sweden, w o m e n can under- education and career.
go treatment up to age 40, and in private clin-
ics, up to age 43. It is essential that w o m e n ACKNOWLEDGMENT
u n d e r s t a n d this reality so t h e y can make This study was supported by the Foundation of
informed decisions regarding their plans for Family Planning in Uppsala, Sweden.
childbearing. An argument can also be made for
public policy intervention in terms of health REFERENCES
education about fertility levels. 1. Statistics Sweden. Population statistics 2004 (in
Because we lacked a standardized instrument Swedish). Report no. BE 12SM 0501. Orebro, Sweden:
of relevance for the focus of the present study, 2005.
we developed our own questionnaire. No back- 2. Hassan MA, Killick SR. Effect of male age on fer-
ground data were available for nonresponders, tility: Evidence for the decline in male fertility
but the percentage of respondents born outside with increasing age. Fertil Steril. 2003;79(Suppl 3):
Sweden corresponds well with the national 1520-1527.
percentage of immigrants in Sweden in 2004 3. Statistics Sweden. Why so few babies? [in Swedish].
(12%). 1 However, the relatively low response Demographic Rep. Orebro, Sweden: 2001:1.
rate a m o n g m e n limits the conclusions that can 4. Hoem B. Entry into motherhood in Sweden: The
be drawn about the male sample. influence of economic factors on the rise and fall
in fertility, 1986-1997. April 17, 2000. Available
CONCLUSIONS at: http://www'dem°graphic-research'°rg/V°lumes/
The findings of the present study show that Vo12/4/2-4.pdf.
although most postgraduate students have posi- S. Statistics Sweden, SCB. How many children will I
tive attitudes toward having children, t h e y tend have? Fertility in a life--perspective [in Swedish].
to postpone childbearing. In comparison to men, Demographic Rep. Orebro, Sweden: 2002:5.
w o m e n perceived more obstacles to h a v i n g 6. Ronsen M. Fertility and family policy in Norway--
children during their postgraduate studies and A reflection on trends and possible connec-
appeared to have more doubts about whether tions. June 8, 2004. Available at: http://www.
t h e y would have their desired n u m b e r of chil- demographic-research.org/volumes/voll0/10/.
194
A.S. Svanberg et al.
7. Heck KE, Schoendorf KC, Ventura SJ, Kiely JL. 16. Z i n a m a n MJ, Clegg ED, Brown CC, et al.
Delayed childbearing by education level in the Estimates of h u m a n fertility and pregnancy loss.
United States, 1969-1994. Matern Child Health J. Fertil Steril. 1996;65:503-509.
1997;1:81-88. 17. Andersen AN, Gianaroli L, Felberbaum R, et al,
8. Hoem JM. Why does Sweden have such high fertil- for the European IVF-monitoring Programme
ity? Available at: http://www.demographic-research. (ELM) and the European Society of Human Repro-
org/volumes/voll3/22/. duction and Embryology (ESHRE). Assisted repro-
9. Morin P, Payette H, Moos MK, et al. Measuring ductive technology in Europe, 2001. Results gen-
the intensity of pregnancy p l a n n i n g effort. erated from European registers by ESHRE. Hum
Pediatr Perinat Epidemiol. 2003;17:97-105. Reprod. 2005;20:1158-1176.
10. Kemkes-Grottenthaler A. Postponing or rejecting 18. Swedish National Board of Health and Welfare.
parenthood? Results of a survey among female aca- Assisted reproduction--Result of treatment 2002.
demic professionals. 1 Biosoc Sci. 2003;35:213-226. Available at: http://www.sos.se.
11. L6fstr6m A. Att Lillan kom Till Jorden. Barna- 19. The Swedish Confederation for Professional
flodande och Konjunktur Under det Sena 1900-Talet Employees, TCO. Postgraduate students' life situ-
[master's thesis]. Ume~i, Sweden: Ume~i Univer- ation (in Swedish). Stockholm, Sweden. 2003.
sity; 2003. 20. FOrs~ikringskassan. RiksfOrs~ikringsverket. 2003.
12. Tyden T, Skoog Svanberg A, Karlstrom P, Lampic Available at: http://www.forsakringskassan.se.
C. Female university students' attitudes to future 21. Tyden T, Olsson S, Haggstrom-Nordin E. Im-
m o t h e r h o o d and their understanding about fer- proved use of contraceptives, attitudes toward
tility. Eur J Contracept Reprod Health Care. In press. pornography, and sexual harassment a m o n g
13. Lampic C, Svanberg AS, Karlstrom P, Tyden T. female university students. Women's Health Issues.
Fertility awareness, intentions concerning child- 2001;11:87-94.
bearing, and attitudes towards p a r e n t h o o d 22. Lalos A, Jacobsson L, Lalos O, von Schoultz B.
a m o n g female and male academics. Hum Reprod. The wish to have a child. A pilot study of infertile
2006;21:558-564. couples. Acta Psychiatr Scand. 1985;72:476-481.
14. Dunson DB, Colombo B, Baird DD. Changes with 23. Levinson W, Tolle SW, Lewis C. Women in aca-
age in the level and duration of fertility in the demic medicine. Combining career and family.
menstrual cycle. Hum Reprod. 2002; 17:1399-1403. N Engl JMed. 1989;321:1511-1517.
15. van Noord-Zaadstra BM, Looman CW, Alsbach H, 24. H/Sgberg U, Sandstr6m A, Nilsson N. Reproduc-
et al. Delaying childbearing: Effect of age on tive pattern among Swedish women born 1936-
fecundity and outcome of pregnancy. BMJ. 1991; 1960. Acta Obstet Gynecol Scand. 1992;71:207-
302:1361-1365. 214.
195