Professional Documents
Culture Documents
RESEARCH ARTICLE
WMJ (Warmadewa Medical Journal), Vol. 7 No. November 2, 2022, Pg. 60-69
Antibiotic resistance is closely related to the inappropriate use of antibiotics, namely the indication, dose,
frequency, and duration of use. Permenkes No. 5 of 2014 states that acute pharyngitis is given antibiotic therapy
if it meets the diagnostic criteria using the center criteria, but this criterion is difficult to apply because doctors take
longer to diagnose. Previous research at the Klungkung I Primary Health Center used diagnosis utilizing a swab
test. It was found that 100% of bacterial pharyngitis patients were negative. The strategy of delaying antibiotics for
3 days can prevent antibiotic resistance, but in therapy, without antibiotics, it is im-portant to increase the
effectiveness of therapy, it is deemed necessary by the researchers to conduct a study to analyze the factors that
affect the recovery of patients with acute pharyngitis, which are mainly caused by vi-ruses. Analyzing the factors
that affect the recovery of viral pharyngitis patients. The design of the cross-sectional study was through
observation of the medical record data of patients who came to the Klungkung Primary Health Center I for 3
months and got diagnostic facilities using the swab test. Patients who got a nega-tive swab test were analyzed
for the factors that influenced their recovery. Anti-inflammatory variables, rest, and paracetamol significantly
affected the recovery of acute pharyngitis patients (p <0.05), and the importance index in CART analysis found
that paracetamol was the most influential, followed by rest, administration of vitamins, and anti-inflammatory.
Antibiotics, anti-allergies, and cough medicines do not affect the recovery of patients with acute pharyngitis viral.
Paracetamol has the most effect on patient recovery, followed by rest and administration of vitamins, anti-
inflammatory has very little effect on the recovery in patients of acute pharyn-gitis viral.
WMJ (Warmadewa Medical Journal), Vol.7, No.2, November 2022, p-ISSN 2527-4627
DOI: https://doi.org/10.22225/wmj.7.2.4753.60-69
Machine Translated by Google
plications such as rheumatic fever and rheumatic tient's recovery, so further research is need-ed
heart disease. The definite antibi-otics of choice to find out what factors affect the recov-ery of
are amoxicillin, penicillin v, and benzathine patients suffering from pharyngitis. an acute virus
penicillin. In patients with a history of penicillin without giving antibiotics, and can be a reference
allergy, the choice of antibiotics is cephalexin, for pharyngitis ther-apy in health centers, most
cefadroxil, clindamycin, clarithromycin, and of which are
azithro-mycin. Administration of paracetamol or caused by viruses using the binary logistic
non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) regression method. The hypothesis in this study
can be considered for the man-agement of cases was the factors studied as independ-ent variables
of pharyngitis Treatment of viral pharyngitis
(2)
does (vitamins, anti-inflammatory, and rest) affected
not require antibiotics, but the fact .
the recovery of viral pharyngitis patients at
is that in Klungkung I Primary Health Klungkung I Prima-ry Health Center.
Center, in par-ticular, almost all diseases
diagnosed as acute pharyngitis are treated with
antibiot-ics. In addition, empirical diagnosis is no METHODS
longer visible to use, considering that the history The study design used an observa-
of signs and symptoms is difficult to distinguish tional method with a cross-sectional study
between viral and bacterial pharyngitis. A large approach. The data used in this study is
amount of use of anti-biotics and their misuse is secondary data in the form of medical rec-ords
thought to be the main cause of the high number taken in October 2016 - January 2017 where the
of patho-gens and resistant commensal bacteria medical records describe the di-agnosis of acute
worldwide. Reducing the number of inap-propriate pharyngitis diagnosed us-ing laboratory tests
antibiotic use is the best way to control the through a swab test us-ing RADT (Rapid Antigen
occurrence of bacterial re-sistance. Diagnostic Test). The sampling technique used
in this study was carried out through non-
probability sampling with the type of con-secutive
sampling, in which patients aged 12-45 years
with a diagnosis of acute phar-yngitis caused by
Patient recovery factors can be clas- viruses and recorded in the medical record will
sified into 2, namely, dependent factors such as be selected as sam-ples. Then the sample was
education, work, income, medica-tion (drug divided into two large groups, namely patients
consumption), and food con-sumption (nutrition), with acute pharyngitis caused by a virus where
etc. as well as inde-pendent factors such as age, treat-ment was cured and failed. The two groups
gender, rest status, etc. In Nurmaida (2014), it collected patient data which contains the
was found that a significant factor in influenc-ing independent variables studied.
the recovery of ARI patients who were diagnosed
empirically (the cause was not yet certain for
viruses or bacteria) was the administration of The population of this study was all
antibiotics (p = 0.041), while other factors were patients in the age group 12-45 years who came
gender (p = 0.184). ), age (p = 0.700), education to the Klungkung I Primary Health Center with
(p = 0.384), occupation (p = 0.178), marital sta- symptoms of acute pharyngitis.
tus (p = 0.700), income (p = 1,000), num-ber of In this study, there were 5 independent var-iables
hours of sleep/day (p = 0.634), habits consuming (giving antibiotics, giving paraceta-mol, giving
vitamins (p = 0.625), and food consumption anti-inflammatory, vitamins, and rest), and one
patterns (p = 0.584) were not significant in healing variable was equal to 10 patients, so the overall
ARI. In acute pharyn-gitis patients who are sample size(3)
was 60 patients Statistical analysis
included in ARI, es-pecially those caused by to see .
viruses, antibiotics in theory cannot be given so the influ-encing factors with the CART
they are not included in the factors that affect method which can describe the relationship be-
the pa- tween the response variable (dependent variable)
and one or more predictor varia-
WMJ (Warmadewa Medical Journal), Vol.7, No.2, November 2022, p-ISSN 2527-4627
DOI: https://doi.org/10.22225/wmj.7.2.4753.60-69
Machine Translated by Google
bles (independent variables). with Ladipa's research (2018) that men have a higher
risk of respiratory tract infec-tions than women
RESULT because there are envi-ronmental and behavioral
The demographics of the study sub-jects differences be-tween men and women, for example,
were determined by age and gender in table 1. such as self-awareness in terms of maintaining daily
health (4)
.
40 66.66
Male the bivariate analysis. The method used for
bivariate analysis is the chi-square method.
Female 20 34.34
Patients in this study can be seen from the Each factor is identified based on a prelim-inary
characteristics of their age and gender. As many as theory, which is then examined for
23.3 percent of pa-tients in this study were patients the significance of its effect on recovery.
from the adolescent group while 76.67 were patients The results of the effect independent varia-ble on the
from the adult group. Based on gender, in-formation dependent variable, namely the cure for viral
was obtained that 66.66 percent were male patients, pharyngitis patients can be seen in table 2.
while the remaining 34.34 percent were female
patients.
Table 2. Results of the effect of independent varia-bles on Pharyngitis.
Paracetamol Yes 43 5
. 5. 0,002
No 6 6
WMJ (Warmadewa Medical Journal), Vol.7, No.2, November 2022, p-ISSN 2527-4627
DOI: https://doi.org/10.22225/wmj.7.2.4753.60-69
Machine Translated by Google
WMJ (Warmadewa Medical Journal), Vol.7, No.2, November 2022, p-ISSN 2527-4627
DOI: https://doi.org/10.22225/wmj.7.2.4753.60-69
Machine Translated by Google
microorganism. Acute pharyngitis is caused by had a significant effect on the recovery of viral
bacteria severe headache, fever or, ma-laise, pharyngitis patients were giving para-cetamol,
painful swallowing, vomiting, and possibly rest, and vitamins. Paracetamol, which is a
coughing but rarely occurs. Phar-yngitis due symptomatic drug, is very likely to give CART,
to bacterial infection group A streptococci can it does not represent the op-portunity for rest
be estimated by using the Centor criteria, to improve recovery, but in theory and research,
namely fever, anterior cer-vical rest can increase the immune system through
lymphadenopathy, tonsillar exudate, and no stimulation of pro-inflammatory hormones
cough. Pharyngitis caused by virus-es usually wherein this con-dition the adaptive immune
has symptoms of a sore throat severe and may response is stimulated and increases so that
be accompanied by cough-ing, hoarseness, the inflam-matory response as a marker
and substernal pain. Fever, chills, malaise, increases. So the researchers can conclude
myalgia, and headache may also occur. Then, that the pro-cess of viral eradication is
symptoms of fungal phar-yngitis are sore increased, and more foreign bodies are
throat and swallowing pain. attacked and para-lyzed in the first immunity
On examination, white plaque appears hy- (initial) which correlates with an increase in the
peremic oropharynx and another pharynge-al inflam-matory response in the beginning. The
mucosa (6)
.
pro-vision of vitamins provides a great oppor-
Pharyngitis in this study has been tunity for recovery where the specific vita-mins
confirmed through a swab test, namely RADT that are given here are vitamins C and B
(Rapid Antigen Detection Test) that the cause complex, which can act as a modulating agent
is a virus, almost all patients get negative for cellular immunity, especially those related
results for bacteria, so it can be said to be to CD8 cells and NK cells.
positive due to viruses. In diseas-es caused
by viruses, it is not rational to be treated with Anti-inflammatory administration
antibiotics, where the virus that causes acute provides a chance of cure but is very small,
pharyngitis can heal by itself (self-limiting and is not illustrated in the CART tree, where
disease) for approximately one week. in theory anti-inflammatory can function to treat
pain and swelling (swelling and redness) and
Classification and Regression Trees relieve fever.
(CART) is a method or algorithm of the decision Anti-inflammatory is a series of immuno-
tree technique. CART is a nonpar-ametric regulatory molecules that control the proin-
statistical method that can describe flammatory response of the immune pro-cess.
the relationship between the response varia- This stimulation causes the release of
ble (dependent variable) and one or more inflammatory mediators such as histamine,
predictor variables (independent variables). serotonin, bradykinin, and prostaglandins which
According to Breiman et al (1993), when the cause an inflammatory reaction such as heat,
response variable has continuously shaped the pain, redness, and swelling, and are
method used is a regression tree (regression accompanied by impaired function (8). The
trees), whereas if the response variable has a patient's recovery is strongly associated with
categorical scale the method used is the the disappearance of signs and symp-toms,
classification tree method (7) from the doctor's history, the ob-served
(classification trees) .
symptoms of inflammation can be reduced by
The response variable in this study has administering anti-inflammatory, but it is not
a categorical scale, so the method to be used certain that the causative factor, namely the
is the tree classification method. Bina-ry Trees virus has been cleared maximally, because
provide an interesting and often enlightening anti-inflammatory has something to do with
way to view data in a classifi-cation or controlling the pro-inflammatory response.
regression problem. They should not be used
to override other methods. This resulted in a relatively low correlation
Through the CART method applied in this between anti-inflammatory administration and
study, it obtained data that the things that the recovery of viral pharyngitis pa-
WMJ (Warmadewa Medical Journal), Vol.7, No.2, November 2022, p-ISSN 2527-4627
DOI: https://doi.org/10.22225/wmj.7.2.4753.60-69
Machine Translated by Google
tients on the CART method test results and ty for patient recovery.
was statistically insignificant using Chi-
square. b) Effect of Rest on the Healing of
Viral Acute Pharyngitis Patients
a) Effect of Paracetamol on the recovery of Rest had an effect on the patient's
patients with Acute Pharyngitis recovery where the results were that pa-
In this study, the results showed that tients who did rest were 89.6% healed and
paracetamol has the largest contribution and 10.4% did not recover, but on the contrary,
contributor to the opportunity to cure viral 10.4% did not recover and 89.6% recov-
pharyngitis patients. Symptoms ac- ered. Rest in this case sleep supports the
companying viral pharyngitis patients in this initiation of an adaptive immune response.
study ranged from fever 80%, dizziness The attack antigen is picked up and pro-
36.67%, cough 60%, runny nose 50%, and cessed by antigen-presenting cells (APCs)
sore throat 36.67%. Giving paracetamol as which present the antigen fragments to
symptomatic therapy, namely relieving helper T (Th) cells, with the two types of
symptoms of fever, because paracetamol cells forming 'immunological synapses'.
acts as an antipyretic. Paracetamol is the The release of interleukin (IL) -12 together
first choice in treating symptoms of fever, with APC induces a Th1 response that sup-
one of the most popular analgesics and ports antigen-specific cytotoxic T cell
most commonly used antipyretic drugs function and initiates antibody production by
worldwide, available without a prescrip-tion, B cells. This response ultimately results in
both in mono and multi-component long-lasting immunological memory for the
preparations, and the drug of choice in pa- antigen. Sleep, particularly slow wave sleep
tients who cannot be treated with anti- non- (SWS), and the circadian system play a role
steroidal inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs), such in producing a pro-inflammatory hormonal
as people with bronchial asthma, pep-tic environment with increased growth hormone
ulcer disease, hemophilia, people who are and prolactin release and decreased levels
sensitive to salicylates, children under 12 of the anti-inflammatory stress hormone
years, pregnant or breastfeeding women. cortisol. Hormonal changes support the
It is recommended as a first-line treatment initial steps in producing an adaptive immune
of pain associated with osteoarthritis. The response in the lymph nodes. It can be
mechanism of action includes peripheral analogized that the stimu-lation of B
effects (inhibition of COX), and central lymphocytes and T lympho-cytes forms a
neuronal pathways (COX, serotonergic de- memory, which supports the consolidation
scent, L-arginine on the cannabinoid sys- stage in the same attack by the same
tem pathway. Paracetamol is a drug with antigen (second infection).
good tolerance and side effects occur in the Measurement of the immune re-
gastrointestinal tract. In connection with this, sponse in adult female subjects who were
the administration of paracetamol, in this exposed to bed rest for a long time showed
case, is as a fever therapy (antipyretic), that adult female volunteers (25-40 years)
where inflammation is a natural response, (n = 24) were maintained in a quiet sleep
as a marker of the body's defense process position (6 degrees tilt) head-down bed-rest
which manifestations of symptoms in the (HDBR) for 60 days: 8 with HDBR only, 8
form of tumor, rubor, heat, and dolor. The with HDBR and regular muscle training, and
patient is declared cured, which is the loss 8 with HDBR and dietary protein sup-
of signs and symptoms, due to heat (heat) plements. The primary antibody production
being the main symptom that can be felt and rates of the HDBR plus exercise group in-
measured fever (heat) is a manifesta-tion creased more rapidly (P = .01) and to a
of the body's defense response that me- higher level than the HDBR-only group (P =
diates inflammation. So this can lead to an- .03) and the HDBR plus diet group (trend P
tipyretic administration in this case parace- = .08). The levels of secondary antibody
tamol contributes to the greatest opportuni- production between the 3 groups were sim-
WMJ (Warmadewa Medical Journal), Vol.7, No.2, November 2022, p-ISSN 2527-4627
DOI: https://doi.org/10.22225/wmj.7.2.4753.60-69
Machine Translated by Google
ilar, but the antibody levels in the HDBR plus amin C accumulates in phagocytic cells,
exercise group remained higher than in the such as neutrophils, and can increase
HDBR group (P = .03). The HDBR (P = .001) chemotaxis, phagocytosis, the formation of
and HDBR plus diet (P = .02) groups had reactive oxygen species, and ultimately kill
time-related progressive in-creases in TNF- microbes. It is also necessary for apoptosis
alpha, but the HDBR plus exercise group and clearance of neutrophils that are ex-
remained at baseline. The HDBR plus pelled from the site of infection by macro-
exercise group had an acute increase in IL-1 phages, thereby reducing potential tissue
receptor antagonist levels compared to the damage. The role of vitamin C in lympho-
HDBR (P = .02) and HDBR plus diet (P = cytes is less clear, but it has been shown to
.02) groups. increase B and T cell differentiation and
Sleep rest during the day and nor- proliferation, possibly due to its gene-
mal sleep at night can boost the immune regulatory effects. Vitamin C deficiency leads
system through the initiation of an adaptive to compromised immunity and a higher
immune response, where sleep rest can in- susceptibility to infections. In turn, infection
crease growth hormone and prolactin re- significantly impacts vitamin C levels due to
lease and decrease levels of the anti- increased inflammation and metabolic
inflammatory stress hormone cortisol sup- requirements. Furthermore, sup-plementation
porting the initial steps in producing an with vitamin C appears to be able to prevent
adaptive immune response in the lymph and treat systemic infec-tions. Vitamin C
gland. prophylaxis is required to prevent infection
which provides insuffi-cient, if unsaturated
c) Effect of Vitamins C and B on the Cure of (ie 100-200 mg/day) plasma levels, which
Viral Acute Pharyngitis Pa-tients optimizes cell and tissue levels. Conversely,
good infection treatment requires a higher
Vitamin C is known as an antioxi- vitamin dose (gram) to compensate for the
dant that helps neutralize free radicals. Vit- increased in-flammatory response and
amin C is an antioxidant because of its abil- metabolic de-mand (9)
ity to reduce several chemical reactions, one .
WMJ (Warmadewa Medical Journal), Vol.7, No.2, November 2022, p-ISSN 2527-4627
DOI: https://doi.org/10.22225/wmj.7.2.4753.60-69
Machine Translated by Google
number and circulating T-lymphocyte func-tion which can maintain an adequate immune response, especially in
be corrected by short-term (6 weeks) supplementation with elderly people who have a high percentage (up to 15%) of
50 mg of vitamin B6 / day 66. Decreased IL-2 pro-duction, T low serum B12 concentrations.
lymphocyte count, and T prolif-eration Lymphocytes were
observed in sub-jects experiencing vitamin B6 depletion,
which suggests that vitamin B6 deficiency suppresses Th1 d) Effect of Anti-inflammatory on the Cure of Viral
and increases Th2 cytokine Acute Pharyngitis Pa-tients.
and 400 mg of folic acid, showed increased NK cell This Result of two randomized con-
cytotoxic activi-ty in research subjects Vitamins support trol trials has shown that corticosteroid use can reduce the
immune function so that they can increase innate immunity incidence of treatment fail-ure and shorten the time to
in the elderly. A defenseless adult (aged 65 years) with low clinical stability in patients with community-acquired pneu-
(10)
serum vitamin B12 concen- .
monia. This does not apply to patients with severe influenza
trations has an antibody response to the virus infection. Our results revealed that steroid treatment
pneumococcal polysaccharide vaccine. prolonged the duration of MV and ICU stay. The ef-fect of
steroid use on oxygenation could not be subjected to meta-
analysis, owing to the diversity of data. Several studies
report-ed that systemic corticosteroid treatment
WMJ (Warmadewa Medical Journal), Vol.7, No.2, November 2022, p-ISSN 2527-4627
DOI: https://doi.org/10.22225/wmj.7.2.4753.60-69
Machine Translated by Google
had no discernible influence on the im- Kimia Farma Teuku Umar Pharmacy.
provement of blood oxygen saturation of 2020;3(2):14–23.
patients with severe influenza (11) . 3. Dahlan MS. Sample size in Medical
and Health Research. Jakarta:
CONCLUSION Indonesian Epidemiology; 2019.
The factors are can affect the recov-
ery of viral pharyngitis patients are giving 4. Dewi R. Rationality of Antibiotic Use in
Patients with Respiratory Tract
paracetamol, rest, giving vitamins, and anti-
inflammatories. Paracetamol gives the greatest Infections at the Kampung Laut Inpatient
chance of recovery, after that rest and finally Health Center, 2019.
Medicine and health-Faculty of Medicine,
giving vitamins.
Islamic University of North Sumatra.
SUGGESTION 2022;21(1):1–9.
Based on the research that has been 5. Hartati A, Zain I, Ulama B. CART
done, some suggestions can be considered for (Classification And Regression Trees)
further research, that is: Analysis of Factors.
1) In pharyngitis caused by viruses, anti- 2012 Sep 11;1.
biotics are not related to the patient's
6. Wilandari Y, Safitri D. Analysis of
recovery, so it can be said that there is Factors That Influence the Recovery of
no benefit, therefore antibiotics for viral Bird Flu Patients Yuciana Wilandari and
pharyngitis are not recommend-ed, and Diah Safitri Teaching Staff of the
for pharyngitis whose cause is unknown, Statistics Study Program, Mathematics
Department, FMIPA UN- DIP. Media
antibiotics can be post-poned for at least
3 days considering 90% of causes of Stat. 2009;2(1):11–8.
acute pharyngitis are preceded by
7. Breiman L, Friedman J, Stone CJ,
Olshen RA. Classification and Re-
viruses.
2) The time used to assess the patient's gression Trees. 1993.
recovery can be extended for 5 or 7 days 8. Rane MA, Foster JG, Wood SK, Hebert PR,
considering that viral infections are self- Hennekens CH. Benefits and Risks of
Nonsteroidal Anti-inflammatory Drugs:
limiting diseases if they are not
accompanied by high fever. Methodologic Limitations Lead to
Clinical Uncer-tainties. Ther Innov
3) Paracetamol is very important and the
earliest therapy in the treatment of viral Regul Sci. 2019;53(4):502–5.
pharyngitis accompanied by fe-ver
9. Marcos A. Editorial: A review of
symptoms. Viral pharyngitis pa-tients
are strongly advised to take rest and micronutrients and the immune sys-tem
take vitamins to promote recov-ery. —Working in harmony to reduce the
risk of infection. Nutrients. 2021;13(11).
4) Avoiding cold weather or areas and
consuming cold water (ice water) to 10. Setiyani MS. Co-variance Structure
Analysis of Health-Related Indices in
prevent bacterial infection that causes
the Elderly at Home with a Focus on
acute pharyngitis
Subjective Health. 2020;1–9.
REFERENCES
1. Yunita Sarah Nadeak. Characteristics 11. Foti M, Shrimanker T V., Hasan UN,
of acute pharyngitis sufferers in the Hussein KI. Recurrent severe
Binjai army in 2017. J Health Bukit neutropenia following doxycycline use
Barisan. 2017;1(2):1–9. in a young healthy woman. Clin Case
2. Research Article Doctors Together Reports. 2022;10(3):1–7.
WMJ (Warmadewa Medical Journal), Vol.7, No.2, November 2022, p-ISSN 2527-4627
DOI: https://doi.org/10.22225/wmj.7.2.4753.60-69