Professional Documents
Culture Documents
II. Explanation
II. Discussion
1. Is it possible for an act of man to become human act? Explain how, if possible.
Not every act that a human being does is a distinctively human act. Some acts that
human beings do are performed also by animals, such as vegetative acts and acts of
perception and emotion. When a human does such behaviours, they are referred to as
acts of man rather than human acts. Man's actions are done without knowledge,
without consent, and involuntarily, and hence cannot be considered human acts.
2. Explain the distinction between elicited act and commanded act.
Elicited Acts are essentially will-acts that begin and end in the will. For example,
wish is the simple love of anything, intention is the will's purposive tendency towards
a thing, consent is the acceptance by the will of the means necessary to carry out
intention, election is the will's selection of the precise means to be employed in
carrying out an intention. Commanded acts, on the other hand, are actions carried out
by the mind and body that are ordered by the will. Those acts that, while originating
in the will, are carried out by other internal or external powers of man directed by the
will. Internal Acts, for example, are performed by the MIND under the command of
the will. External Acts - performed by the BODY under the command of the will.
Acts performed by both the body and the mind are referred to as mixed acts.
3. What are the constituent elements of human act and explain the importance of each
element to human act.
The underlying causes or constituting factors that cause a human person to perform a
specific act are referred to as constituent elements of the human act. The idea of the
human act implies that there are two key aspects that comprise a human act:
knowledge which refers to human act that proceeds from the deliberate free will; it
requires deliberation. Freedom where human act is determined as (elicited or
commanded) by the will and nothing else. It is an act, therefore, that is under control
of the will, an act that will can do or leave undone. And lastly the voluntariness,
human act must be voluntary or must have voluntariness simply mean to say that it
must be a will-act.
4. Discuss the distinction between direct and indirect voluntariness. Give an example.
Direct Voluntariness is an act is directly voluntary when it is performed for its own
sake, either as a means or an end. For instance, a person has direct intended influence
over whether he or she is thinking about a favourite song at any given point in time.
Indirect voluntariness is defined as an act that is not meant for its own sake but
rather occurs as an undesired result of a willed action. For example, an untrained
musician has indirect voluntary control over whether he or she would perform a song
on a violin.
5. Explain why the five modifiers of human acts are considered “impairments of human acts.”
Modifiers of human acts are also known as obstacles. are also called as barriers.
These impediments affect people's understanding of and freedoms associated with
their actions; thus, modifiers of human acts are the factors that affect the essential
qualities and thus lessen the moral character of a human act, and thus diminish the
agent's responsibility, namely knowledge, freedom, and voluntariness.
6. Explain and illustrate with examples, the distinction between End of the Act and End of the
Agent.
The end of the action is the natural purpose of an act; or that is which the act in its
very nature terminates or results, thus, the end of the action of studying is learning.
For example, some people read a book for enjoyment, while others read it for
instruction, and yet others read it to practice obedience: the act is the same, but the
goals are different.
The end of the agent is the intention or aim of the doer of the action. This should be
distinguished from the conclusion of the action. The end of the agent varies depending
on the individual, although the conclusion of the act is always the same. For example,
knowledge; it is called an extrinsic end when its benefit is felt outside the agent, such
as the doctor's healing felt in the patient.
7. Distinguish Objective Ultimate End and Subjective Ultimate End. Give an example
The objective or material end is the object aimed at; the subjective or formal end is
the achievement of that object. The term subjective is given to this aim to signify its
possession by a subject (one who has it/strives to have it). The absolute final end of
human acts with regard to their subject is perfect happiness, which consists in the
possession of the boundless good.