Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Polymer Testing
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/polytest
A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T
Keywords: Acupoint embedding therapy is a treatment that embeds absorbable thread into target acupoints, so as to provide
Acupoint embedding continuous stimulation to acupoints and to replace retained acupuncture. Many types of absorbable threads are
Threads available and generally can be divided into natural and synthetic polymers according to the source of material.
Review
According to the literature, the threads currently used in acupoint embedding have some limitations, and may
cause side effects in clinical practice. Bioactive threads may be used to further reduce side effects and promote
application of acupoint embedding.
Acupoint embedding therapy embeds absorbable thread into target 1. Common embedding threads
acupoints and the embedded thread can continuously stimulate the
acupuncture point, thus avoiding retained acupuncture [1]. This treat 1.1. Natural materials
ment is related to tissue therapy, intradermal acupuncture therapy, and
hypodermic acupuncture therapy [2]. It arose on the basis of tissue 1.1.1. Collagen thread
embedding therapy and acupuncture. “Suwen - Lihe Zhenxie Lun” states This category mainly includes sheep catgut and other collagen
that “acupuncture with static and longer needle-retaining time”; threads extracted from specific animal tendon through enzyme digestion
“Zhenjiu Dacheng” also reads: “retaining acupuncture to treat stagnant and other processes. In clinical practice, sheep catgut is most commonly
diseases”, which means that after needling sensation (de qi), the reten used and has a relatively long application history. It is a thread made of
tion time of the needle can be appropriately extended. Acupoint collagen from the mucosa of sheep’s small intestine, and both plain and
embedding therapy may not only work as short-term acupuncture to chromic catguts are available. However, at present plain catgut is rarely
dredge meridian, but also exert long-term stimulation on acupoints. used in China because of its high immunogenicity and poor flexibility.
Due to foreign body reaction caused by the thread, acupoint Therefore, in order to reduce tissue inflammatory reaction, catgut is
embeding may be complicated by clinical side effects such as allergy, usually treated with chromic acid to obtain chromic catgut [5].
nodule, fever, infection, pain, thread dispelling and secondary symp When acupoint embedding therapy was first introduced into clinical
toms [3,4]. Therefore, in order to successfully embed thread at acu practice in the 1970s, catgut was widely used as embedding material
points, optimal thread material is essential in reducing side effects. because of its relatively low price. However, due to its organic protein
Embedding threads commonly used in clinical practice and bioactive nature, patients’ body may experience rejection and allergic reaction to
threads that may be considered for acupoint embedding are reviewed this foreign protein, therefore symptoms such as increased temperature,
here. A brief summary of studies on different embedding threads is given redness, rash, and itching may occur at the embedding site [6]. In
in Table 1. addition, due to differences in individual patient’ body state, disease and
local blood supply, nodules, cyst or mass may be observed at the
embedding site in some patients [7–10]. Therefore, although catgut is
widely used and has lower price, due to its relatively frequent side ef
fects, and in order to promote the implementation of the standard
operating procedure of the Chinese national standard for acupoint
embedding, it is not recommended to continue using catgut for acupoint
* Corresponding author.
E-mail address: 342940190@qq.com (Y. Yang).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.polymertesting.2021.107298
Received 21 May 2021; Received in revised form 9 July 2021; Accepted 13 July 2021
Available online 14 July 2021
0142-9418/© 2021 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
J. Zhao et al. Polymer Testing 101 (2021) 107298
2
J. Zhao et al. Polymer Testing 101 (2021) 107298
response rates of the embedding group and the electro-acupuncture bioactive threads that have wide surgical application and fewer side
group were 93.0% and 88.4%, respectively. There was no statistical effects may be candidates for embedding thread.
difference. However, a follow-up six months later found that waist
circumference and BMI index of the embedding group were significantly 2. Bioactive threads
better than those of the electro-acupuncture group, demonstrating that
the clinical efficacy of PLGA acupoint embedding is better than 2.1. Antibacterial thread
electro-acupuncture.
2.1.1. Antimicrobial coated thread
1.2.2. Polydioxanone thread This category mainly involves adding antibacterial agents to the
Polydioxanone (PDS) fiber is prepared by ring-opening polymeriza material or the thread during the preparation of the absorbable thread,
tion of p-dioxanone (poly-p-dioxanone) [27]. It has extremely high in an attempt to avoid or prevent postoperative infection. Triclosan
biocompatibility, hydrophobicity, flexibility, strength, toughness and coated absorbable thread has been relatively well studied.
impact resistance. An in vitro degradation experiment by Kimura et al. Due to its antibacterial effect and low toxicity to human body, tri
[28] showed that PDS took about 180 days to degrade, and may closan has been used in a variety of commercial products, such as soap,
compensate fast degradation of catgut. shower gel and toothpaste [33]. Multiple in vivo studies of triclosan
Ding et al. [29] compared the clinical efficacy of conventional coated thread have shown that, without compromising the mechanical
acupuncture, catgut embedding, and PDS thread embedding in the strength of the suture, the bacterial colonies around the infected site
treatment of refractory facial paralysis. The results showed that all three were significantly reduced, proving its antibacterial effect [34,35].
interventions achieved clinical response. Acupoint embedding was su However, because triclosan can be absorbed by the human body, this has
perior to acupuncture, whereas there is no significant difference in raised patients’ concern about its adverse health effects. Furthermore,
clinical efficacy between catgut embedding and PDS embedding. Feng although triclosan can inhibit the growth of bacteria, it cannot kill
et al. [30] did a comparative study among 92 patients with cervical existing bacteria. Therefore, researchers turned their eyes to antimi
spondylosis. Jiaji acupoints on both sides of the cervical spine crobial peptides with broad-spectrum bactericidal effect. Studies of the
(C3/C5/C7, in total 6 acupoints per patient) were chosen. Among them, effectiveness of a new antibacterial thread coated with poly [(amino
3 acupoints on the left received PDS thread embedding, and 3 acupoints ethyl methacrylate)-co-(butyl methacrylate)] (PAMBM) showed that
on the right received catgut embedding. Both groups experienced side PAMBM coated thread had significant bactericidal activity and could
effects such as tenderness, induration, redness and swelling immediately quickly kill Staphylococcus aureus [36,37]. In addition, researchers have
after embedding treatment, and there was no statistical difference. The developed a nanofiber thread that may induce endogenous antimicro
catgut group experienced significantly more adverse events than the bial peptides: an absorbable thread containing 25-hydroxyvitamin D3
PDS thread group 1 week and 2 weeks after treatment, including and pam3CSK4 peptide is prepared through coaxial electrostatic depo
tenderness, induration, redness and swelling. Feng et al. [31] and Ding sition and rolling process. pam3CSK4 can activate cellular toll-like re
et al. [32] also confirmed that the incidence of adverse events of PDS ceptors. Once activated, toll-like receptors induce a specific enzyme to
thread is lower than that of sheep catgut through multiple clinical ob convert 25D3 into 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D3, which in turn activates
servations, and it is an excellent implant. vitamin D receptors. As the activity of vitamin D receptor increases, the
As synthetic polymer absorbable threads, both PLGA and PDS expression of its target gene increases, thus inducing the production of
threads have adjustable degradation rate and good biocompatibility. antimicrobial peptide hCAP18/LL37, which kills microorganisms by
Moreover, acupoint embedding therapy has better clinical efficacy than destroying the bacterial cell wall [38]. In the practice of acupoint
conventional acupuncture and electro-acupuncture. While maintaining embedding, in addition to strict aseptic procedure, using antimicrobial
the same efficacy as traditional catgut, PLGA and PDS threads effectively coated thread may largely reduce the incidence of infection at the
reduce or avoid side effects in acupoint embedding therapy. They have embedding site.
certain clinical advantages over currently used natural embedding
threads. Nevertheless, all the threads described above may cause some 2.1.2. Silver nanoparticle thread
side effects in clinical use, which also limit widespread clinical appli Polymer medical devices coated or impregnated with silver nano
cation of acupoint thread-embedding to certain degree. Since almost all particle have wide antibacterial spectrum [39], which may provide an
embedding threads originated from surgical absorbable threads, insight into the development of antibacterial threads. Silver
3
J. Zhao et al. Polymer Testing 101 (2021) 107298
nanoparticle is a natural and environment friendly non-antibiotic anti with sustained-release drug also provide insight into selection and
microbial. Because of its anti-inflammatory effect [40], in addition to development of embedding threads. As new biomedical thread materials
acupoint embedding effect as with other threads, it also has the medical become available, the clinical application of acupoint thread embedding
effect of silver itself. It can effectively promote tissue repair and holds a promising future.
regeneration, and can eliminate human body rejection and allergic
reaction. Author statement
Ren et al. [41] investigated the difference between acupoint
embedded catgut, silver-coated PLGA thread and PLGA thread on Ying Yang: conceived and performed the manuscript. Jinrong Zhao
infrared thermogram using AGA782 infrared camera and TC-800 com and Mingming Wang wrote the manuscript and are the co-first authors.
puter. In the first 5 d after embedding, skin temperature of the sites Jun Xu: contributed equally to this work.
embedded with these three threads increased. Thereafter, the temper
ature trends of three threads varied significantly. The catgut group
maintained high temperature, peaked on day 7 and then gradually Declaration of competing interest
decreased. The temperature of the PLGA thread group gradually
returned to the baseline level before embedding, and after the first 5 The authors declare that they have no known competing financial
days, the temperature of the silver-coated PLGA thread group decreased interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence
continuously to the baseline level before embedding. It can be assumed the work reported in this paper.
that PLGA and silver-coated PLGA threads cause less rejection in human
body than catgut. Moreover, besides all the advantages of PLGA thread, References
silver-coated PLGA thread also has significant sterilization and
anti-inflammatory effects. It is a new medical material with promising [1] Natcm, Gb/t21709.10-2008: Standardized Manipulations of Acupuncture and
clinical application. However, one concern is that this material is rela Moxibustion, 2009. Part 10: thread-embedding therapy.
[2] X.Y. Wu, G.Z. Chen, Y.T. Li, Y.X. Xu, The key issues and corresponding strategy of
tively expensive and thus may not be accepted by the general
acupoint medicated catgut embedding therapy, Zhongguo zhen jiu= Chinese
population. acupuncture & moxibustion 39 (2019) 81–85.
[3] X.L. Wang, G.H. Lin, N. Xu, J.C. Zeng, D.H. Xu, S.X. Wang, Analysis of adverse
reactions of acupoint catgut embedding therapy, Zhongguo zhen jiu= Chinese
2.2. Sustained-release thread
acupuncture & moxibustion 40 (2020) 193–196.
[4] J. Liu, T. Xu, J. Liang, S. Zhao, T. Wu, S. Su, R. Yan, Adverse reactions of acupoint
Researchers developed a thread with a controllable degrading rate embedding and its treatment, Zhongguo zhen jiu= Chinese acupuncture &
moxibustion 36 (2016) 1166–1168.
and capable of releasing drug [42]. It is produced from monofilament or
[5] Y. Hu, Overview and degradation researches on non-absorbable surgical sutures,
multifilament spun from the spinning solution, which are chitin, chito China Medical Device Information 25 (2019) 53–54+168.
san and/or their derivatives, as well as their corresponding lytic en [6] W. Zhang, L. Yang, T. Jixiang, Rejection reactions after acupoint embedding with
zymes. One characteristic is that the lytic enzymes scatter on the surface chromic catgut: case report and discussion, Zhongguo zhen jiu= Chinese
acupuncture & moxibustion 35 (2015) 372–374.
and inside of the monofilament or multifilament. A composite ultrafine [7] A. Bharathi, D.D. Reddy, G.S. Kote, A prospective randomized comparative study of
fiber with at least one ultrafine fiber taking the form of a core-shell vicryl rapide versus chromic catgut for episiotomy repair, J. Clin. Diagn. Res.: J.
structure is prepared from multiple ultrafine spun fibers through coax Clin. Diagn. Res. 7 (2013) 326.
[8] J.A. Greenberg, E. Lieberman, A.P. Cohen, J.L. Ecker, Randomized comparison of
ial co-spinning technology and post-processing. The core material con chromic versus fast-absorbing polyglactin 910 for postpartum perineal repair,
tains bioactive ingredients and the shell is biodegradable. The Obstet. Gynecol. 103 (2004) 1308–1313.
biologically active ingredients can be antibacterial and [9] T. Hugh, M. Kelly, Endoscopic extraction of a calculous bile duct cast formed on a
nidus of chromic catgut, Aust. N. Z. J. Surg. 62 (1992) 975.
anti-inflammatory drugs, anti-cancer drugs, analgesics, growth factors, [10] M. Walton, Strength retention of chromic gut and synthetic absorbable sutures in a
anticoagulants, and/or coagulants. In acupoint embedding, according to nonhealing synovial wound, Clin. Orthop. Relat. Res. (1991) 294–298.
patients’ condition, by controlling the degradation rate of the thread and [11] X. Ren, Introduction to origin and mechanism of acupoint embedding, China J
Traditional Chinese Med Pharm 19 (2004) 757–759.
adding different sustained-release drugs, both acupuncture and medi
[12] W. Wu, M. Lei, H. Zhu, Efficacy of acupoint embedding with medicated thread to
cation may be achieved by a single therapy, on which further clinical treat functional constipation among 132 adolescent cases, J New Chinese Med 43
researches are granted. (2011) 98–99.
[13] S. Kou, L. Peters, M. Mucalo, Chitosan: a review of sources and preparation
methods, Int. J. Biol. Macromol. 169 (2020) 85–94.
3. Conclusion [14] D. Raafat, H.G. Sahl, Chitosan and its antimicrobial potential–a critical literature
survey, Microbial biotechnology 2 (2009) 186–201.
In summary, acupoint embedding therapy is widely used in clinical [15] J. Wang, W. Qu, Clinical study on treatment of lumbar spinal stenosis by acupoint
embedding with chitosan thread treated with traditional Chinese medicine and
practice because of its well-known efficacy and safety. Since both the discussion on its rationale, J Hebei Traditional Chinese Med Pharm 30 (2015)
material and prescription of thread-embedding therapy are controllable, 49–51.
and there is no need to attend to ever changing techniques [16], it may [16] D. Wang, R. Wang, Development of a novel controllable degradable surgical suture,
Letters in Biotechnology 24 (2013) 702–704.
facilitate the regulation and standardization of acupuncture research. To [17] J. Reinbold, A.K. Uhde, I. Müller, T. Weindl, J. Geis-Gerstorfer, C. Schlensak, H.
facilitate the application of thread embedding therapy, the thread ma P. Wendel, S. Krajewski, Preventing surgical site infections using a natural,
terial should be harmless to the body; foreign organic protein should be biodegradable, antibacterial coating on surgical sutures, Molecules 22 (2017)
1570.
avoided; stimulation intensity and time should be adjustable; and the [18] F.A. Sheikh, H.W. Ju, B.M. Moon, O.J. Lee, J.H. Kim, H.J. Park, D.W. Kim, D.
thread should be easy to store and use [16]. Among the threads K. Kim, J.E. Jang, G. Khang, et al., Hybrid scaffolds based on plga and silk for bone
described above, catgut is not a good choice because it contains foreign tissue engineering, Journal of tissue engineering and regenerative medicine 10
(2016) 209–221.
organic protein and may trigger intense rejection. Chitosan threads have [19] W. Sun, Z. Tan, A novel biomedical material for microinjection acupuncture
a broad-spectrum antibacterial effect, but till now preparing dedicated application, Shanghai Journal of Acupuncture and Moxibustion 29 (2010)
embedding thread with chitosan has not been well studied. Researches 131–132.
[20] J. Sun, W. He, Study on relationship of biodegradable properties of pgla film in
on combining it with collagen and synthetic polymers to develop new
vivo and in vitro, Sheng wu yi xue gong cheng xue za zhi= Journal of biomedical
embedding thread are promising. engineering 21 (2004) 717–720.
As synthetic polymer threads, PLGA and PDS have good strength, [21] H. Liu, Clinical comparison of poly-lactic-co-glycolic acid new catgut embedding
biocompatibility and controllable degradation rate, and they are better material and catgut, J. Clin. Rehabilitative Tissue Eng. Res. 16 (2012) 7185–7192.
[22] Q. Tang, H. Cai, Observational study on treating simple obesity by embedding
choices for embedding thread. Additionally, bioactive threads coated different threads through minimally invasive procedure, Jiangsu J Traditional
with antimicrobial, coated or impregnated with silver nanoparticle, and Chinese Med 45 (2013) 45–46.
4
J. Zhao et al. Polymer Testing 101 (2021) 107298
[23] Y. Pan, Efficacy and Safety of Simple Obesity Treatment by Acupoint Embedding [33] H.P. Schweizer, Triclosan: a widely used biocide and its link to antibiotics, FEMS
with Different Threads, Ph.D. thesis. Guangzhou University of Chinese Medicine, Microbiol. Lett. 202 (2001) 1–7.
2015. [34] M.L. Storch, S.J. Rothenburger, G. Jacinto, Experimental efficacy study of coated
[24] L. Chen, Efficacy Comparison and Safety Evaluation of Simple Obesity Treatment vicryl plus antibacterial suture in Guinea pigs challenged with staphylococcus
by Acupoint Embedding with Different Threads, Ph.D. thesis. Nanjing University of aureus, Surg. Infect. 5 (2004) 281–288.
Chinese Medicine, 2014. [35] A. Gomez-Alonso, F. Garcia-Criado, F. Parreno-Manchado, J. Garcia-Sanchez,
[25] W. Sun, Y. Wang, W. Lu, Pgla embedding for the treatment of cervical spondylosis E. Garcia-Sanchez, A. Parreno-Manchado, Y. Zambrano-Cuadrado, Study of the
of nerve root type, J Clinical Acupuncture and Moxibustion 29 (2013) 43–45. efficacy of coated vicryl plus® antibacterial suture (coated polyglactin 910 suture
[26] X. Zheng, H. Ji, L. Nie, X. Zhu, Therapeutic observation of acupoint embedding with triclosan) in two animal models of general surgery, J. Infect. 54 (2007) 82–88.
with pgla thread for simple obesity, Shanghai JAcupuncture and Moxibustion 37 [36] M.N. Melo, R. Ferre, M.A. Castanho, Antimicrobial peptides: linking partition,
(2018) 391–394. activity and high membrane-bound concentrations, Nat. Rev. Microbiol. 7 (2009)
[27] S. Kim, H. Yang, T.K. Kim, J.Y. Jeong, C. Shin, S.H. Oh, In vitro and in vivo 245–250.
biocompatibility and degradability evaluation of modified polydioxanone plate, [37] M. Zasloff, Antimicrobial peptides of multicellular organisms, Nature 415 (2002)
J. Craniofac. Surg. 31 (2020) 2059–2062. 389–395.
[28] S. Kimura, K. Yasuda, N. Hara, T. Sakai, S. Mikami, A. Minami, H. Tohyama, [38] S. Chen, L. Ge, A.F. Gombart, F.D. Shuler, M.A. Carlson, D.A. Reilly, J. Xie,
Implantation sites and fiber diameters affect the rate of degradation in absorbable Nanofiber-based sutures induce endogenous antimicrobial peptide, Nanomedicine
polydioxanone fibers, Arthrosc. J. Arthrosc. Relat. Surg. 19 (2003) 68–74. 12 (2017) 2597–2609.
[29] M. Ding, H. Feng, C. Jin, L. Xu, T. Lin, Intractable facial paralysis treated with [39] F. Furno, K.S. Morley, B. Wong, B.L. Sharp, P.L. Arnold, S.M. Howdle, R. Bayston,
different acupuncture and acupoint embedding therapies: a randomized controlled P.D. Brown, P.D. Winship, H.J. Reid, Silver nanoparticles and polymeric medical
trial, Chin. Acupunct. Moxibustion 35 (2015) 997–1000. devices: a new approach to prevention of infection? J. Antimicrob. Chemother. 54
[30] H. Feng, Y. Jiang, M. Ding, T. Lin, Comparative study on adverse effects on patients (2004) 1019–1024.
with cervical spondylosis with embedding by different materials, J Nanjing Univ [40] X. Dai, X. Xu, Z. Chen, C. Zhang, X. Pei, Observation on microbicidal efficacy of
Traditional Chinese Med 28 (2012) 484–486. silver nanoparticles aqueous solution to bacteriophages and bacteria, Chinese
[31] H. Feng, M. Ding, Y. Jiang, T. Lin, Efficacy and safety study on treatment of Journal of Disinfection 25 (2008) 242–244.
cervical spondylotic radiculopathy through minimally invasive thread embedding, [41] X. Ren, S. Zhou, H. Li, Study on the difference between silver nanoparticle coated
Jiangsu JTraditional Chinese Med 44 (2012) 59–60. thread and catgut embedded at acupoints in infrared thermogram, J Beijing Univ
[32] M. Ding, H. Feng, T. Lin, Clinical observation of micro-invasive thread embedding Traditional Chinese Med (Clinical Medicine) (2009) 24–25.
with different materials for chronic facial paralysis, Shanghai J Acupuncture [42] P. Shen, A Biodegradable Suture with Bioactivity, 2015. CN201310603436.5[P].
Moxibustion 34 (2015) 1183–1185.