Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Clinical Research
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Objective: To compare the clinical effect differences between western medication, acupuncture, and
Available online 7 March 2021 acupuncture combine with western medication in the treatment of diabetic peripheral neuropathy.
Keywords: Methods: Ninety-three patients were randomized into western medication group, acupuncture group,
Acupuncture and combination group, with 31 cases in each. The patients in western medication group were treated
Lipoic acid injection with lipoic acid injection and mecobalamin injection/ tablets. The patients in acupuncture group were
Mecobalamin injection/tablet treated with acupuncture, and the acupoints were selected according to the symptoms. The needles were
Diabetic peripheral neuropathy (DPN)
retained for 30 min, once a day. The patients in combination group were treated with both western med-
ication and acupuncture, specific methods as the above. The treatments were for 18 days in succession in
all of three group. The motor nerve conduction velocity (MNCV) and sensory nerve conduction velocity
(SNCV) of median nerve and common peroneal nerve, as well as the changes of symptoms and signs of
patients were observed before and after treatment. The clinical effect was evaluated.
Results: After treatment, the median nerve MNCV in the three groups, the median nerve SNCV and com-
mon peroneal nerve MNCV in acupuncture group and combination groups, and the common peroneal
nerve SNCV in acupuncture group were all higher than those of before treatment, with significantly sta-
tistical differences (all P<0.05). After treatment, the MNCV and SNCV of median nerve and common per-
oneal nerve in combination group were higher than those in western medication group and acupuncture
group, with significantly statistical differences (all P<0.05). After treatment, the number of patients in the
three groups with the symptoms and signs was lower than that of before treatment. The effective rate in
combination group was 96.8% (30/31), higher than those of western medication group, 74.2% (23/31), and
acupuncture group, 83.8% (26/31), with significantly statistical differences (both P<0.05).
Conclusion: Acupuncture combined with western medication in the treatment of diabetic peripheral neu-
ropathy can improve the nerve conduction velocity and improve the symptoms and signs of diabetic pa-
tients, with a better effect than those of western medication and simple acupuncture.
© 2021 World Journal of Acupuncture Moxibustion House. Published by Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Diabetic peripheral neuropathy (DPN) is mainly caused by long- treatment for it. At present, the clinical treatment is mostly to
term poor blood glucose control, leading to numbness and pain use the neurotrophins, antioxidants, and those drugs for improv-
in the limbs of patients, mostly manifested as needling pain or ing the blood circulation [1], such as mecobalamin and lipoic acid
burning sensation, muscle spasm, numbness and weakness, and injection, etc. These drugs have a certain effect, but give patients
even muscle atrophy in severe cases. DPN is one of the chronic a heavy economic burden, because they are slow in relieving the
complications of diabetes mellitus. There is currently no specific symptoms, thus causing longer courses of treatment. In order to
find a better way to treat DPN, we did an observation in our clin-
✩
ical practice to compare the therapeutic effect difference among
Supported by Zhangjiakou Science and Technology Research Plan: 1321111D.
∗
Corresponding author.
acupuncture, first-line western medication, and acupuncture com-
E-mail address: 1285245981@qq.com (G.-y. LI). bined with western medication groups. Here is the report.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wjam.2021.03.004
1003-5257/© 2021 World Journal of Acupuncture Moxibustion House. Published by Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
G.-y. LI, Y.-q. ZHANG, P.-y. LIU et al. World Journal of Acupuncture – Moxibustion 31 (2021) 100–104
Table 1
Comparison of general data of DPN patients in the three groups.
Groups Cases Gender (cases) Male Female Age (Mean±SD, years) Diabetes course (Mean±SD, years) DPN course (Mean±SD, years)
General information Patients failed to complete all treatment and follow-up, and
those who requested to withdraw from the study for any reason.
All 93 patients with DPN were from the outpatient and inpa-
tient of the Endocrinology Department of the 81st Group Army Termination criteria
Hospital of the PLA from January 2015 to October 2019, includ-
ing 53 males and 40 females, aged between 37 years old and 76 (1) Patients who were not able to adhere to the whole course
years old, with a disease course from one year to 16 years. Of the of treatment, those who were fainting during acupuncture or
93 patients, 86 cases were type 2 and 7 cases were type 1 dia- afraid of needling.
betes mellitus. The patients were randomized into western medi- (2) Patients had other infections or accidental injuries during treat-
cation group, acupuncture group and combination group by using ment.
the random number table method, with 31 cases in each group. (3) Patients had worsened pathological conditions during treat-
There were no statistically significant differences in age, gender, di- ment.
abetes and diabetic peripheral neuropathy course among the three
groups (all P>0.05), as shown in Table 1. Treatment methods
According to Zhongguo Erxíng Tangniaobing Fangbing Zhinan All of patients in the three groups received the same basic
(2China Guideline for Prevention and Treat- treatment, adhered to scientific and reasonable diet and exercise,
ment of Type 2 Diabetes) [1], the diagnostic criteria were as follows. and were guided by WeChat for using oral hypoglycemic drugs or
(1) Continuous pain, numbness and/or sensory impairment in the hypodermic insulin to control blood glucose. The intervention was
four limbs or lower limbs, and any one of the 5 examinations started when the average fasting blood glucose of each group was
(ankle reflex, tingling pain, vibration sense, pressure sense, and less than or equal to 8.0 mmol/L.
temperature sense) was abnormal.
(2) The vibration sense of one thumb or both thumbs decreased. Western medication group
(3) Bilateral or one side ankle reflex decreased to disappeared.
(4) The conduction velocity of common peroneal nerve was one Patients should go through hospitalization procedures and re-
standard deviation lower than the normal value in the same ceive lipoic acid injection and mecobalamin injection/tablets af-
age group. Electromyogram showed the electrophysiological ab- ter admission. Lipoic Acid Injection 0.6 g was added into 0.9%
normalities, including delayed nerve conduction velocity, pro- sodium chloride injection 250 mL for intravenous drip, once a day.
longed latency, and decreased amplitude, etc. in both lower Mecobalamin injection (1 mL: 0.5 mg), once a day, intramuscular
limbs. injection, or mecobalamin tablet 0.5 mg, oral taking, three times a
day. The treatment lasted for 18 days.
Inclusion criteria
Acupuncture group
Those who met the diagnostic criteria of DPN, aged between 37
and 76 years old, signed the informed consent were admitted into Patients did not need to go through hospitalization procedures.
the study. Acupuncture and moxibustion were performed in the outpatient
department. The patients were in the sitting position for treat-
Exclusion criteria ment. All acupoints were disinfected with 75% medical alcohol,
and treated with 0.30 × 40 mm, 0.30 × 50 mm, 0.30 × 75 mm
(1) Patients with pregnancy, breastfeeding, severe cardiac, hepatic, Hwato brand stainless-steel needles. The needles of different spec-
and renal failure. ifications were selected according to the muscle richness of acu-
(2) Patients with severe diabetic complications (such as the blind- point location. Acupoints: Shènshū (BL23), Pı̌shū (BL20),
ness due to severe retinopathy, loss of pulse of the foot dorsal Gānshū (BL18), Guānyuán (CV4), Qìhǎi (CV6), Xuèhǎi
artery), or with other serious disease (such as stroke, myocar- ( SP10), Sányı̄njiāo ( SP6). If the upper limb symptoms
dial infarction, malignant tumor, chronic alcohol poisoning, se- were obvious, Qǖchí (LI 11), Shǒusānlı̌ (LI 10), Nèiguān
vere mental illness, etc.). ( PC 6), Wàiguān ( TE 5), Hégǔ ( LI 4), and Bāxié (
(3) Patients with diabetic coma and severe infection in recent time. Extra) were added. If the lower limb symptoms were obvious,
(4) Patients with peripheral neuropathy due to other causes (such Yı̄nlíngquán (SP9), Yánglíngquán (GB34), Zúsānlı̌ (
as infection, chemical damage, nutritional disorders, metal poi- ST36), Fēnglóng (ST40), Xuánzhōng (GB39), Zhàohǎi (
soning, lumbar disease, Guillain-Barré syndrome, etc.). KI6), Tàixı̄ (KI3), and Tàichōng (LR3) were added. For the
(5) Severe arteriovenous diseases (venous embolism, lymphangitis, numbness and pain of upper limbs, LI11, LI10, PC6, and TE5 were
etc.). added. For the numbness and pain of fingers, LI 4 and Bāxié (Ex-
(6) Damage of the nerves especially caused by neurotoxic effect of tra) were added. If the burning sensation was obvious, SP 9 and
chemotherapeutics and metabolic poison due to renal failure. KI 3 were added. If there was cold feeling and pain in the lower
101
G.-y. LI, Y.-q. ZHANG, P.-y. LIU et al. World Journal of Acupuncture – Moxibustion 31 (2021) 100–104
extremities, GB34, ST36, ST40, GB39, and KI6 were added. If there sensory nerves’ conduction velocity was significantly accelerated,
was cold feeling and being afraid of cold or muscular spasm of >5 m/s or returned to normal. 2 Effective: the clinical symptoms
hands and feet, moxibustion was applied for 15 to 20 min at SP10, were relieved and the physical signs were improved. EMG showed
LI10, ST36, PC6, TE5, SP9, GB34, and SP6. that the motor and sensory nerves’ conduction velocity was sig-
Manipulation: at BL20, needle was inserted obliquely with an nificantly accelerated, but≤5 m/s.
3 Ineffective: the clinical symp-
angle of 30 ° in a direction towards the spine, to a depth about 15 toms, signs, and EMG were without changes or worse than before
to 25 mm. BL 23, needle was inserted perpendicularly to a depth treatment. Total effective rate = (number of significantly effective
about 20 to 25 mm. The two acupoints were treated with rein- cases + number of effective cases) ÷ total number of cases × 100%.
forcing method by a clockwise twisting at 20–30 r/min to make
the needle gradually deeper, till the patient had a strong sensation
and the doctor had a tight feeling under the needle. Statistical process
At BL 18, needle was inserted obliquely with an angle of 30 °
in a direction towards the spine, to a depth about 15 to 25 mm, The SPSS 19.0 statistical software was used for statistical de-
and treated with even method by a clockwise and counterclock- scription. Measurement data were expressed as mean ± standard
wise twisting at 30 r/min, till the patient had a needling sensation deviation (Mean ± SD) and analyzed by paired t-test before and
and the doctor had deqi under the needle. after treatment and inter-group comparisons; enumeration data
The rest acupoints were needled perpendicularly to a depth of were analyzed by chi-square test. The rank-sum test was adopted
25 to 30 mm, and treated with even method. The needles were to analyze ranked data. P<0.05 was considered as statistically sig-
retained for 30 min, and manipulated once every 10 min. Before nificant difference.
withdrawing the needles, proper lifting, thrusting, and rotating of
the needles would be performed. The treatment was applied daily,
Results
for 18 days in succession.
All the selected patients in this study had good compliance, ad-
Combination group
hered to the whole treatment, and could be discharged early if
they got better, according to Diagnosis of Diseases and Criteria of
Patients were treated with intervention measures in the west-
Cure and Improvement, and the patients should be classified as sig-
ern medication group and the acupuncture group respectively. The
nificantly effective, which would not be affecting the evaluation of
specific methods were the same as described above. They needed
therapeutic effect. During the trial, there were no withdrawn, elim-
to be hospitalized for a total of 18 days.
inated, or terminated cases in the three groups.
Observation of therapeutic effect
Comparison on changes of MNCV and SNCV of median nerve and
common peroneal nerve before and after treatment in the three
Observation indicators
groups of patients with DPN
102
G.-y. LI, Y.-q. ZHANG, P.-y. LIU et al. World Journal of Acupuncture – Moxibustion 31 (2021) 100–104
Table 2
Comparison of MNCV and SNCV of median nerve and common peroneal nerve in patients with DPN before and after treatment in the three groups (Mean±SD, m/s).
Western medication 31 40.7 ± 2.4 43.6 ± 2.8a , b 35.3 ± 2.6 36.7 ± 3.1b 35.7 ± 1.8 35.7 ± 1.8b 30.4 ± 2.3 31.7 ± 1.9 b
Acupuncture 31 40.5 ± 2.3 43.8 ± 3.3a , b 35.5 ± 2.4 37.6 ± 2.5 a , b 35.6 ± 1.9 37.2 ± 2.7 a , b 30.5 ± 2.2 31.9 ± 2.7 b
Combination 31 40.6 ± 2.5 47.2 ± 4.5a 34.7 ± 2.5 39.1 ± 2.7 a 35.7 ± 2.1 42.1 ± 2.6 a 30.3 ± 2.1 34.6 ± 2.7 a
Notes:.
a
Compared with the same group before treatment, P<0.05.
b
Compared with the same index in the combination group after treatment, P<0.05.
Table 3
Comparison of clinical symptoms and signs of DPN patients in the three groups before and after treatment (cases).
Groups Cases Time point Numbness Pain Muscular weakness Cold hands and feet Reduced or absent tendon reflexes
Table 4
Comparison of therapeutic effect of DPN patients in the three groups (cases).
Groups Cases Significantly effective Effective Ineffective Total effective rate (%)
Notes:.
a
Compared with the combination group, P<0.05.
b
Compared with the western medication group, P<0.05.
103
G.-y. LI, Y.-q. ZHANG, P.-y. LIU et al. World Journal of Acupuncture – Moxibustion 31 (2021) 100–104
supply of the peripheral nerves, so that the impaired nerves can be [2] Tang XF. Clinical electromyography. Bejing: Beijing Medical university/China
repaired. This method is simple, but achieves a remarkable thera- Peking Union Medical University Joint Press; 1996.
[3] Sun CX. Diagnosis of diseases and criteria of cure and improvement. Beijing:
peutic effect and without side effect. It is worth to be popularized. people’s. Mil Med Press 1998:125–96.
In addition, attention should be paid to the clinical application [4] Zhang HC, Wei S. Progress in the diagnosis of diabetic peripheral neuropathy.
of acupuncture. If the blood glucose control is not satisfactory, it is Chin Med Herald 2017;14(2):45–8.
[5] Ma J, Wu DH, Liu J, Sun XH, Liang GM, Xiang Y. The clinical effect of Jinlida
easy to cause infection, ulceration, or necrosis of local tissues. Local Granule combined with mecobalamin in the treatment of diabetic peripheral
disinfection of the skin should be strictly cautious before inserting neuropathy. Chin Med 2017;12(9):1363–6.
the needles, so as to avoid infection and unnecessary trouble. [6] Wang ZM, Huang YQ, Qin YS, Xu FR, Fu GH. Research progress of traditional
Chinese medicine and western medication in diabetic peripheral neuropathy.
To sum up, it can be seen from this study that, with the appli-
Hunan J Tradit Chin Med 2017;339(2):162–4.
cation of acupuncture and western medication respectively to treat [7] You LZ, Shen GM, Wang H, He Y, Wang Q. Treatment of diabetic peripheral
DPN, either has certain effect, but if the two ways of treatment are neuropathy with traditional Chinese medicine. J Changchun Univ Chin Med
2015;31(6):1160–2.
used in combination, the clinical effect is significantly higher than
[8] Wu QL, Liang XC. The progression on the research of haem oxygenase-1 and
any one of them. This study has shown that in case these two ways diabetic peripheral neuropathy. Chin J Diab 2015;23(7):653–6.
are combined with each other for the treatment of DPN, the effect [9] Yu JF, Cui ZC. Clinical study on acupuncture treatment of diabetic peripheral
is definitely better, which is worthy of application in the future. neuropathy. Chin Acupuct Moxibust 20 0 0;20(4):203–4.
[10] Wang JJ. Clinical observation on acupuncture treatment for 19 diabetic periph-
eral neuropathy cases. Hebei J Tradit Chin Med 2001;23(7):527.
[11] Yang L. Observation on therapeutic effect of acupuncture for diabetic periph-
Declaration of Competing Interest
eral neuropathy. Sichuan J Tradit Chin Med 2003;21(2):77.
[12] Yuan HT. Acupuncture at five shu points for treatment of 126 cases of numb-
The authors declare that they have no known competing finan- ness of hands and feet induced by peripheral diabetic neuropathies. Chin
Acupuct Moxibust 2006;26(3):225–6.
cial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to
[13] Yi JC, Xu LN, Zhang S, Cao GY. Clinical observation on treatment of dia-
influence the work reported in this paper. betic peripheral neuropathy with warm needling. Hebei J Tradit Chin Med
2012;34(2):242–4.
[14] Wang HM. Electroacupuncture combined with mecobalamin in treatment
State of Human Rights of 35 cases of diabetic peripheral neuropathy. Chin J Tradit Med Sci Tech
2013;20(4):424–5.
[15] Zhang Y. Bloodletting at twelve Jing-well points for 60 cases of diabetic pe-
The intervention conformed to the ethical criteria.
ripheral neuropathy. Yunnan J Tradit Chin Med Mat Med 2016;37(10):60–1.
[16] JiangY Wang QF, Li C, Li R, Mei L, Zhang H. Electroacupuncture combined with
References intermittent pneumatic compression therapeutic apparatus for diabetic periph-
eral neuropathy and the effect on HIF-1α and VEGF levels. World J Acupunct
Moxibust 2018;28(2):9–14.
[1] Chinese Diabetes Society Chinese Medical AssociationChina guideline for pre- [17] Liu G, Tong QJ. Progress in traditional Chinese medicine treatment of diabetic
vention and treatment of type 2 diabetes (2017 Edition). Chin J Pract Intern peripheral neuropathy. Chin J Clin 2016;44(3):30–2.
Med 2018;4(4):321–3.
104