You are on page 1of 8

Photo: DCAF

Strategy for Asia-Pacific


2021 - 2024
Introduction Key security challenges
The Asia-Pacific region is characterized by a and opportunities
great diversity of national experiences with,
and approaches to, security sector governance. Many countries in the Asia-Pacific region face
As everywhere in the world, in all countries of challenges that stand in the way of developing
the region there is room for improvement. The security sectors that embrace the principles of
Asia-Pacific region is vast and, for geographic, good governance in the provision of security
historic and socio-cultural reasons, can be as a public service to all members of society.
further divided into several sub-regions: South DCAF’s contributions will build on numerous
Asia, Southeast Asia, East Asia, and Oceania. positive developments that create a conducive
To capture similarities and differences in environment for sustainable SSG/R, as well
security sector experiences and approaches as on our expertise and experience developed
across this vast area, DCAF organizes its work during previous support in the region.
in three distinct contexts: the Asia-Pacific
region overall; four sub-regions; and individual Democratic governance
countries. While project-based SSG/R activities
tend to take place in national contexts and are We can learn from several established
developed by DCAF and its national partners, democracies with professional security
SSG/R experience-sharing and learning are institutions, strong civilian control of security
facilitated along sub-regional and regional agencies, and good governance principles
lines. This approach has guided DCAF’s being well appreciated in the public sector,
activities throughout the previous strategy and from relatively young democracies that
and has proven to be an effective way to are experiencing democratic transitions.
generate meaningful and sustainable steps Several national partners in DCAF’s regional
towards improving SSG in all countries. SSG Network include representatives from
various oversight actors in their national
SSG working groups, which is often the first
time these institutions have had a chance
While project-based SSG/R to gather around the same table to discuss
activities tend to take place the challenges in their countries. DCAF has
also managed to engage partners from
in national contexts and societies with less enthusiasm for democratic
governance in discussions on the value of
are developed by DCAF good SSG, such as China.
and its national partners,
Security institutions themselves are asking
experience-sharing and to learn more about international standards,
learning are facilitated principles, and experiences in other parts of
the region. For several years DCAF has been
along sub-regional responding to such calls from the military and
police, for example in the Philippines, where
and regional lines. despite setbacks and internal sensitivities
about institutional and attitudinal reforms, Increasing interest in SSG/R
exposure to international standards and Through frequent discussions among DCAF’s
practises have been valued amongst those network partners, entry points have been
interested in reform. identified for SSG/R support by DCAF and
its regional network. There is considerable
Civil society and media need and demand for assistance, particularly
in South and Southeast Asia. There are also
Several countries in the region have fast- considerable possibilities for intra-regional
growing economies with a growing middle support. In some countries in Southeast Asia,
class and politically-educated population, for instance, SSG/R is now a well-known
and vibrant civil societies and influential civil subject and the development of think tanks
society organisations (CSOs) that do not and other research centres focussing on
hesitate to ask for political reforms (South and various aspects of governance has steadily
Southeast Asia). For instance, several years of increased since the 2000s. Harnessing such
engagement with community radio stations experiences and allowing other countries
in southern Thailand and with academic to benefit from them is a key task of DCAF’s
institutions and CSOs in Mindanao have network activities.
illustrated strong interest in building capacities
to conduct oversight of security institutions. In other countries, few institutions focus on
In those two contexts, such activities are also SSG/R, and the inclusion of experts in DCAF’s
important contributions to ongoing peace network and activities offers opportunities
processes. In several countries, strong CSOs to build such capacities from the ground
have been calling for gender equality in the up. In East Asia, SSG/R has been seen less
security sector (Cambodia, India, Malaysia, as an internal challenge, and more of a
Nepal, Philippines and South Korea). DCAF’s development task. Nevertheless, during
support of CSO actors in Thailand to mobilize DCAF’s engagement in the region, there
support for better access to justice by women has also been growing recognition of the
and LGBTIQ communities has triggered further importance of SSG/R even within one’s own
demands for such support. borders, as new threats and challenges – such
as the COVID-19 pandemic – have emerged.

Contributions to UN Peacekeeping Regional and sub-regional


Operations cooperation
Some countries in the region are historically DCAF’s SSG Network engagement since
large troop contributors to UN Peace 2017 in Southeast Asia and engagement
Operations (China, India, Indonesia, Pakistan, overall in the Asia-Pacific region have shown
Bangladesh, and Nepal), while others have greater commitment amongst partner
provided financial assistance (China, South institutions to promote good security sector
Korea, and Japan). This carries the potential governance within a framework of democratic
for UN Peace Operations’ training as an entry governance, the rule of law, and respect for
point for promoting international standards human rights. DCAF’s regional SSG network
and SSG/R discussions and activities. helps channel effective support and capitalize
on the numerous openings for meaningful
assistance, drawing on joint analyses of
regional, sub-regional and national needs and
opportunities.

DCAF’s regional SSG


network facilitates support
and capitalizes on the
numerous openings for
meaningful assistance,
drawing on joint analyses
of regional, sub-regional
Nepalese Peacekeepers in the United Nations Operation
in Burundi (ONUB) Special Forces from Nepal arrive in and national needs
the town of Isale in the Bujumbura Rural Province of
Burundi to check the security situation. and opportunities.
Photo: United Nations.

2
Instability and fragile assistance a very sensitive area of interaction
that requires confidence-building measures
democratization and the slow nurturing of trust. DCAF’s SSG
Particularly in South Asia, Southeast Network is designed to facilitate the latter
Asia, and Oceania conflict-affected and thus fill a particular need that may be
societies suffer from internal instability unique: the absence of regional platforms
and fragile democratization processes. that allow for exchanges and collaboration
The sustainability of peace processes is on security sector-related issues that may be
hampered by difficulties in successfully rooted in the national context, but have cross-
embedding SSR efforts in peace agreements regional consequences.
and post-conflict peacebuilding and in
addressing disarmament, demobilization,
and reintegration (DDR) of armed non-state
groups, transitional justice and power- Colonial experiences
sharing among former conflict parties.
Numerous young and transition/hybrid have triggered strong
democracies, particularly in South and resistance to foreign
Southeast Asia, are faced with political
instability, severe backsliding of democratic intervention, which makes
transitions (including military coups and
rising authoritarianism in the context of
SSG/R assistance a very
governments’ COVID-19 strategies), religious sensitive area of interaction
radicalization, domestic armed violence, and
the rise of non-reformist and reactionary that requires confidence-
politicians who neutralize successes of building measures and the
previous SSR initiatives.
slow nurturing of trust.
Weak oversight and accountability
Security institutions operate with little
accountability to civilian democratic Emerging security challenges
institutions because of weak oversight
The ability to respond to ongoing and
capacities of parliaments, independent
emerging new challenges, ranging from
oversight institutions, and civil society
maritime and cybersecurity threats to
organisations. As a consequence,
domestic violence, violent extremism,
unaccountable police services threaten
military coups, gender-based violence,
human rights and fundamental freedoms
and narcotics and human trafficking, and
and often act with impunity. For instance,
geo-political and geo-strategic regional
in several parts of the region security
competition, depend very heavily on effective
institutions play an overly dominant role
and efficient security sectors. DCAF’s sub-
in politics, strongly influenced by recent
regional network of partners and experts
histories of military and colonial governance.
helps define challenges and responses that
are relevant across each sub-region, while
Vulnerability to disasters national partners, experts and their national
Moreover, populations across the Asia-Pacific SSG working groups help identify needs and
region are highly vulnerable to natural and responses at national levels.
human-made disasters, including health
crises, as has been exemplified by the
COVID-19 pandemic. Negative consequences
of climate change across the region further DCAF’s approach
destabilize fragile societies.
DCAF recognises that national actors hold
Limited coordination mechanisms the primary responsibility for undertaking
SSR and focuses on accompanying
Multi-agency and whole-of-government
national efforts and processes in a way that
responses, including concerted actions by
reinforces local ownership. When advising
national security sectors as well as cross-
national authorities, DCAF always provides
regional cooperation, are rare and largely
a comparative perspective on international
ineffective. Sub-regional organizations are
norms and standards as well as existing good
reluctant to facilitate security – and security
practice, and tailors advice to national contexts
sector – cooperation. Most countries are wary
and needs. When advising international actors,
of external influence in their domestic affairs,
DCAF encourages coordinated engagement
especially on security-related topics. Colonial
and the inclusion of good practice in political
experiences have triggered strong resistance
and programmatic assistance.
to foreign intervention, which makes SSG/R

3
DCAF prioritises building trusted partnerships over the past several years, its recent focus
with national actors, emphasises the impartial has been the development of a network of
nature of its advice, applies a holistic approach SSG/R stakeholders across all sub-regions and
to SSR, and supports all security sector actors countries, with national partner institutions
– those providing, managing, controlling, and and SSG working groups representing all
overseeing security. DCAF also cooperates security sector actors. The SSG Network
with international actors with whom we provides opportunities to raise awareness
share a common objective. The choice of of SSG/R principles, share best practices and
concrete thematic areas, objectives, partners, exchange experiences in a way that respects
and approaches is shaped through ongoing the unique requirements and sensitivities
dialogue that involves the beneficiary at all in the Asia-Pacific context. The Network’s
stages of the process, from initial scoping, objective, and that of the national SSG working
through assessment, design, steering of groups, includes the development of national-
implementation, result monitoring, and level activities. These are initiated together
reporting. with DCAF, and in consultation with other
partners in the network.
DCAF always provides a DCAF’s added value in the region is based
comparative perspective particularly on its ability and capacity to
provide unique assistance in a way that is
on international norms compatible with and enhances existing reform
and standards as well as activities by other organizations. DCAF’s
added value is also expressed by the fact that
existing good practice, and its activities are welcomed by beneficiary
societies and their security sectors due to our
tailors advice to national reputation of being reliable, fair and objective.
contexts and needs. Moreover, DCAF has proven its willingness to
stay engaged despite setbacks, thus enabling
local actors to re-start reform processes once
The history, politics, and security challenges the political climate improves. DCAF’s thematic
across the region have led DCAF to take a expertise at the interface of SSG/R and
unique approach to engaging with Asia-Pacific business and human rights provides additional
partners and security sector actors. While potential entry points to address challenges
DCAF has been involved in a limited number relating to private security and the extractives
of country-specific projects in the region sector.

Objectives
Reaffirm the value of democratic governance
in addressing current and emerging security
challenges.
DCAF will promote good security sector police-community relations through
governance across the region by maintaining structural reforms, as well as strengthening
a platform for debate with key national capacities of parliaments to legislate and
stakeholders and activities in contexts oversee national security sectors, including
where SSG/R and democratic consolidation disseminating knowledge on the legal and
processes are challenged, backsliding, or institutional tools for oversight, building
even reversed. DCAF will also underline the capacities of parliamentary staff, and
importance of democratic governance in training members of security and defence
numerous countries that are on the path committees.
of democratization, a critical phase where
security sectors can have highly destabilizing
but also stabilizing effects. Health crises
In the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic, DCAF
Security sector management and teamed up with its partners in the region
to analyse the roles of security sectors in
oversight preparing for, managing, and governing
Areas of emphasis will include addressing health crisis responses, and supported joint
public mistrust of police and deteriorating response capacities by the security and
4
health sectors. Building on jointly developed institutions, and will therefore be a focus for
findings and recommendations, DCAF will DCAF in the coming years. Not all countries
produce practical guidance notes for security can draw on home-grown SSG/R capacities.
sector actors that include general guidance With the help of its regional SSG Network,
for region-wide application, as well as specific DCAF will assist emerging national think
guidance specific for security actors and tanks and CSOs in their effort to develop into
countries. centres of expertise on SSG/R.

Gender equality and security


This will be a focus in all our activities across With the help of its
the region. DCAF and its partners address regional SSG Network,
gender bias and to transform institutional
cultures at the policy, legislative and planning DCAF will assist emerging
level to promote human rights, gender national think tanks and
equality, and inclusivity. Some governments
in the region also aim to increase not only civil society organizations
the number of women in their national
armed forces, but also the number of women
to develop into centres
in UN peace operations. This provides the of expertise on SSG/R.
opportunity to promote the Women, Peace,
and Security agenda, with a focus on
impacts and special needs/protections for Private security
women in security institutions, as well as the The private security industry has become a
transformative power of including women in major actor in the security sector architecture,
decision-making. triggering the need for guidance and analysis
on existing legal frameworks and policies.
Support to civil society Development of new law, policy, and practice
Growing involvement of civil society is also needed to respond specifically to the
organisations and media in SSG stands out human rights risks posed by the work of
as a trend, which should not be seen as a the private security industry and to support
diminution of state authority, but rather as a national processes to improve oversight
way to increase transparency and thus state and accountability. Engagement with both
legitimacy. Engagement with and support for the public and private sectors will be sought
civil society and media promote a culture of to promote responsible business conduct
participation that enhances the democratic as part of SSG/R, considering concerns
nature of decision-making about security about inadequate regulation of the private
sector policies and legislation, building security industry, extractive industries, and
trust between communities and security cybersecurity.

Enhance engagement in fragile and conflict-


affected contexts.
DCAF’s work is founded on the intrinsic ability federal security sectors, and related post-
of SSG/R to make societies safer and more conflict SSG/R priorities for key stakeholders
stable, promote human security and involved in negotiating the peace agreement.
development, and alleviate injustices and DCAF will also contribute to the SSR aspects
tensions that might escalate to instability and of peace processes and stabilization efforts
armed violence. This is the case particularly in in countries including Afghanistan, Nepal, the
societies emerging from conflict that are Philippines, and Thailand.
politically and socially fragile and in need of
security sectors that play a stabilizing role
while overcoming fragility. Prevention of violent extremism
Violent extremism is a major threat, particu-
larly affecting South Asia and Southeast Asia.
SSR and peace processes Factors associated with radicalisation and
In the coming years, DCAF hopes to the spread of extremism are diverse and are
re-engage in Myanmar, building on its long- linked to SSG/R in that they often relate to a
standing contribution to the peace process by lack of security and ineffective or inequitable
providing capacity-building on SSG/R, DDR, provision of justice. Prevention of violent

5
extremism through investments in account-
able, inclusive, and representative security
institutions as well as peace processes and
SSR-embedded DDR programmes that
defuse, not antagonize inter-ethnic relations,
is therefore a priority for many partners and
is an important theme of DCAF’s work.

Business and security DCAF will build on its


In the area of private security, DCAF will build
on and further develop its work, undertaken work, undertaken jointly
jointly with the International Committee of
the Red Cross (ICRC), to promote security and
with the ICRC, to promote
human rights with Chinese companies security and human rights
operating in fragile and conflict-affected
contexts. More broadly, as governments and
with Chinese companies
private companies from East Asia operate in operating in fragile and
conflict and post-conflict zones, it is
imperative to focus on promoting responsible conflict-affected contexts.
business conduct.

Strengthen SSG/R contributions to


international policy and practice.
Partnerships with multilateral governed. Recognizing the role SSR plays
institutions in this regard, much of DCAF’s work in the
Asia-Pacific region in the coming period will
DCAF will raise awareness among multilat-
make a key contribution to the implementa-
eral and international actors and the donor
tion of SDG16.
community about the necessity to invest in
SSG/R in the Asia-Pacific region and its link to
national, regional, and international security. Sharing lessons learned in SSG/R
DCAF will reach out to regional organiza- Capturing and sharing lessons from the field
tions such as SAARC and ASEAN by actively will be a high priority for DCAF and a
including them in regional network activities, valuable contribution to international policy
partner forums and efforts to strengthen and practice. DCAF’s wide network of partners
regional capacities in SSG promotion. DCAF’s and diverse portfolio of projects facilitates
partnership with the UN, European Union, the development of unique insights which
World Bank, and other major multilateral or- can shape international policy and practice
ganisations show that it is well positioned to in areas such as women, peace, and security;
provide relevant and timely contributions. The the integration of security actors in peace
expertise that DCAF brings to SSG/R will be processes; security sectors’ roles in health
integrated into international efforts in several crisis management; and the implementation
ways, ranging from continued influence on of Agenda 2030. In the absence of active
the development of international policies, the efforts by regional organizations and mecha-
promulgation of evidence-based good nisms to facilitate experience sharing, lessons
practices in supporting SSG/R, and in learning and priority setting on SSG/R, DCAF’s
specific support to guide international donor regional SSG Network will offer opportunities
programmes and projects in the Asia-Pacific to do so at national, sub-regional and regional
region. levels.

Agenda 2030
SDG16 commits states to achieving peaceful
and inclusive societies, providing access to Capturing and sharing
justice for all, and building effective, account-
able, and inclusive institutions. Fulfilling this lessons from the field will
goal and its targets will require states to en- be a high priority for DCAF.
sure their security sectors are democratically

6
Other thematic priorities Implementation
Several additional issues are emerging Programming and financing
as particularly important for SSG/R in the Building and expanding on its network of
Asia-Pacific region in the coming years and partner organizations throughout South,
will be addressed by DCAF and its partners on Southeast and East Asia, DCAF will pursue
an as-needed basis. financing to continue networking activities to
facilitate South-South cooperation. We will
also seek support for national-level activities
Maritime security where DCAF’s expertise can benefit security
Maritime security is an area of cooperation sector actors directly, or in cooperation with
and potential conflict, offering opportunities national partners.
to promote the concept of maritime security
sector governance.
Geographic coverage
Special efforts will be made to include coun-
Border management tries not yet represented with partner insti-
National and transnational movement of tutions, experts and national SSG working
people is common throughout the region and groups in DCAF’s Asia-Pacific SSG Network
effective border management plays an (Bhutan, Brunei, Laos and North Korea), either
important role in preventing human by inclusion in the network or by pursuing ad
trafficking, illicit smuggling, health crises hoc options for SSG/R activities directly with
and managing the entry of persons fleeing partners in these countries. The same applies
conflict or persecution. Border management to the countries of Oceania (including the Pa-
and migration is thus a significant element cific Islands), the Asia-Pacific sub-regions.
of the national security architecture of many
countries.

Climate change and security


Countries in the region are particularly hard
hit by natural disasters and this trend will
only worsen with the effects of climate
change. Here, disaster risk reduction offers
concrete entry points for SSR and opportu-
nities to bring together a range of security
sector stakeholders, government agencies,
and local communities to focus on prepared-
ness and response strategies, particularly in
countries where climate change-induced di-
sasters threaten to further destabilize fragile
and conflict-affected societies.

Cybersecurity DCAF helps build networks of security sector


actors and civil society groups to share
In an era of rising cyber capabilities among experience and best practices in reform and
security forces, to grapple with the challenge governance at the regional and sub-regional
of misinformation, disinformation, and cyber level in Asia. Photo: DCAF
threats, there is a growing interest among
partners in treating cybersecurity as an
essential aspect of security sector Strengthen partnerships
governance. Partnerships with existing national-level
institutions will be maintained, while efforts
Urban SSG/R will be made to identify partners in countries
not currently represented in DCAF’s regional
With growing urbanization, crime and vio- network. Partnerships will also be pursued
lence have shifted towards urban centres. with regional associations and organisations.
While important lessons have been learned DCAF will continue to leverage and support
on urban planning and development, less the efforts of its key international partners
attention has been paid towards promoting in the region, including the European Union,
urban safety and security in larger cities and United Nations, and World Bank. Moreover,
municipalities, which can be an important countries that are committed to DCAF’s vision
focus for future SSG/R activities. and mandate to bring security to populations

7
through investment in good SSG, will be
actively encouraged to join DCAF’s governing
Foundation Council.

Staffing and deployment


Without field offices in the region, DCAF will
continue to collaborate closely with local
partner institutions and experts associated to
its regional network initiative, unless funding
levels and project necessities justify increas-
ing DCAF’s presence by either opening a field
office or by financing personnel at partner
institutions in order to assure in-country man-
agement and guidance.

Evolution in the context of


COVID-19
Throughout the global pandemic, DCAF
adapted its operations to provide the best
possible support to partners in security insti-
tutions and oversight actors facing a rapidly
evolving situation. E-learning and remote
advising have become an increasingly import-
ant part of DCAF’s offer; these forms of
support will be further expanded and
enhanced in the coming years. DCAF is
already working with partners to capture
lessons learned and identify new
opportunities for SSR emerging because of
responses to the pandemic. This work will
remain relevant in the coming years as the
effects of COVID-19 will endure.

For more information, please contact:


Albrecht Schnabel
Head, Asia-Pacific Unit

a.schnabel@dcaf.ch

DCAF is dedicated to DCAF Geneva Headquarters


making people P.O.Box 1360
more secure through CH-1211 Geneva 1
accountable and effective Switzerland
security and justice.
info@dcaf.ch
+41 (0) 22 730 9400

www.dcaf.ch

@DCAF_Geneva

You might also like