Professional Documents
Culture Documents
DOI: 10.1111/vco.12681
KEYWORDS
cancer, dog, laryngectomy, larynx, tracheostomy
Vet Comp Oncol. 2021;1–7. wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/vco © 2021 John Wiley & Sons Ltd 1
2 MATZ ET AL.
F I G U R E 1 Cranial is to the bottom of the image. The epiglottis is F I G U R E 2 Cranial is to the bottom of the image. The oesophagus
retracted with an Allis tissue forceps is shown relative to the dorsal laryngeal region
MATZ ET AL. 3
were placed between the subcutis and the cartilage of several tracheal tissue sarcoma and neurofibroma. Cytology of the laryngeal mass was
rings to relocate the stoma more superficially and to minimize tension performed in 4 dogs and was diagnostic for cancer in 3. Lymph node
on the mucosal/epithelial apposition of the stoma. The tracheal cytology included evaluation of mandibular lymph nodes in 3 dogs
mucosa was then sutured to the skin with monofilament suture (both and superficial cervical lymph nodes in 2 dogs. Metastasis was not
absorbable and non-absorbable sutures were used depending on pref- found in any sample. Complete blood count and biochemistry analysis
erence) (Figure 4). was performed in all dogs and no clinically significant abnormalities
To minimize peristomal debris accumulation, the stoma was either were detected in any dog. Urinalysis was evaluated in 2 dogs and
misted with sterile saline from a spray bottle or nebulized with saline showed isosthenuria in 1 dog.
every 4 hours. A thin layer of triple antibiotic ointment was applied to Three-view thoracic radiographs were performed in all dogs and
the peristomal skin every 4 hours. Intravenous mu agonist opioids and no evidence of metastatic disease was found in any dog. Radiographs
fluids were administered for the first 24 to 48 hours after surgery. of the cervical region were obtained in 3 dogs and were consistent
Oral pain medications were administered after that time for approxi- with the presence of a soft tissue opaque mass in the laryngeal region
mately 1 week and owners were instructed to clean the peristomal in all dogs. Cervical computed tomography scans were performed in
skin as needed but to avoid contact with the mucocutaneous sutures. 3 dogs and magnetic resonance imaging in 1 dog. All cross sectional
Periodic exposure to warm, humidified air was also recommended for imaging studies were consistent with a soft tissue mass in the laryn-
the first month after surgery. geal region. Abdominal ultrasound was performed in 1 dog and was
consistent with benign prostatic hyperplasia and prostatitis.
Operative complications were not recorded for any dog. Major
4 | RESULTS immediate postoperative complications occurred in 2 dogs. In one dog,
the stoma was judged to be subjectively small. The other dog had a pre-
All dogs were presented for evaluation of a laryngeal mass causing viously performed permanent tracheostomy and the stoma position
dysphonia and variable degrees of upper airway obstruction. Total lar- changed after laryngeal excision resulting in obstruction. Revision surgery
yngectomy/permanent tracheostomy was performed in all six dogs. was necessary to enlarge the tracheostomy in both dogs during the same
Breeds included Labrador Retriever, Golden Retriever, Shar-pei, hospitalization as the initial surgery. Additional major complications
American Staffordshire Terrier, Fox Terrier and Shetland Sheepdog. There occurred after initial discharge from the hospital in 1 dog requiring stoma
were three castrated males, one intact male, one spayed female and one modification 2 additional times, 2 years after TLPT. Another dog required
intact female. Age at presentation ranged from 3 to 8 years. (Table 1). 2 stoma modifications 2 and 3 months after TLPT. Another dog required
Clinical signs included dyspnea, inspiratory stridor, increased respira- stoma modification 6 months after TLPT (Table 1). Minor complications
tory effort, choking, lethargy, disrupted sleep and stertor. The duration included gastrointestinal signs (vomiting and regurgitation) and purulent
of clinical signs prior to presentation was available for four dogs and the nasal discharge in 1 dog. Both resolved with conservative treatment.
median duration was 7.5 weeks (range 2-52 weeks). Two dogs were Histologic diagnosis confirmed 3 benign and 3 malignant tumours.
evaluated by their primary care veterinarian and diagnosed with a laryn- Complete excision was confirmed for 5 dogs. Margin status was not
geal mass via endoscopy (1) or orolaryngeal exam (1). One dog was reported for the remaining dog. Pulmonary metastatic disease was
referred for laryngectomy after diagnosis of laryngeal sarcoma and had a later confirmed in 2 dogs. One dog was diagnosed with squamous cell
permanent tracheostomy performed by the referring veterinarian. carcinoma and the other with grade 3 soft tissue sarcoma 730 and
Diagnostic evaluation included pre-surgical biopsy in 3 dogs and 380 days after TLPT respectively. Metastasectomy was pursued for
results were consistent with squamous cell carcinoma, grade 3 soft both dogs. These dogs survived 1460 and 575 days after TLPT
4 MATZ ET AL.
(730 and 195 days after metastasectomy respectively). Survival times 5 | DI SCU SSION
for all dogs ranged from 135 to 1460 days (Table 1).
One dog reported here experienced unwitnessed death at home This is the first case series in veterinary medicine detailing cases
and this was believed but not confirmed to be because of airway treated for laryngeal neoplasms with TLPT. Additional animals with
obstruction. Another dog died under anaesthesia during an MRI and laryngeal neoplasms have been reported but few have been treated
the cause was not determined. This dog had previously been diag- with TLPT.2-4,7-9 By comparison, humans experience laryngeal cancer
nosed with a brain tumour and was being imaged after completing more commonly and more has been described about the procedure in
radiation therapy. the human surgical literature.10-16
MATZ ET AL. 5
Awareness of TLPT as a treatment option, minimizing complica- preserved, unless en bloc excision of these tissues is needed for
tions by familiarity with the procedure and knowledge of long-term tumour control. Specific locations for muscle transection and need for
tumour control rates may influence more use of the procedure. Unfor- removal of portions of the hyoid apparatus depend on tumour loca-
tunately, little is known from the veterinary literature; however, data tion and planned resection margins.
available from human literature may be adaptable to veterinary Failure to achieve adequate pharyngeal closure, or disruption of
patients. the closure, is an important and potentially serious complication
Laryngeal neoplasms occur with some frequency in humans reported in 3% to 65% of human cases.10,11
1
accounting for approximately 2% of cancers. Voice quality changes Factors associated with increased risk of fistula formation include
may be more obvious, resulting in earlier detection of lower grade/ decreased haemoglobin, presence of comorbidity, decreased albumin,
stage disease than typically encountered in veterinary medicine and need for red blood cell transfusion and lymph node metastasis.
1
good to excellent rates of disease control. The maintenance of Another study reported hypothyroidism and neoadjuvant radiation
speech is important during laryngeal cancer management in human therapy to be significant risk factors for fistula formation in human
beings and is approached with intent for preservation of laryngeal beings.11 Pharyngeal closure was accomplished with suture patterns
function. Small and histologically benign lesions are treated by local that resulted in mucosal inversion into the pharyngeal cavity. Intra-
excision and radiation therapy. With increasing grade of malignancy operative leak testing was performed and additional sutures placed if
and size of neoplasm, preservation of life becomes the principal deter- a leak occurred. The authors of the study reported here prefer to
minant and the treatment option of laryngectomy is considered as the place sutures in the pharyngeal submucosa with the needle entering
primary treatment. Veterinary patients do not follow these same con- and exiting near the wound edge for apposition and support (no direct
straints. Speech and vocal rehabilitation are of less importance in ani- mucosal closure is performed). This allows for suture placement in the
mals; however, issues related to tracheostomy management and strength layer of the tissues, slight wound eversion of the mucosa into
associated risks may be greater in animals such as inefficiency of the pharynx and avoids suturing the exceptionally thin pharyngeal
panting for cooling and accidental drowning. Other issues reported mucosa. Direct suturing of the thin mucosa may result in inaccurate
include development of aspiration pneumonia, occlusion of the tra- apposition and interposition of the mucosal edge in the wound leading
cheostomy site by adjacent skin folds, stenosis of the stoma, collapse to dehiscence or delayed healing. With slight mucosal eversion,
of the stoma, need for revision surgery and dyspnea among wound alignment is more consistent and there is greater opportunity
others.5,17,18 for direct or primary epithelial migration and first intention healing.
Case selection is important and the surgical dose should be tai- An alternative to hand-suturing the pharyngeal closure is the
lored to the patient. The author's opinion is that neoplasms contained use of a linear stapler. In a study of 21 TLPTs in human beings,
within the luminal structures or within the intrinsic muscles would be tumour free margins were reported in all cases and fistula formation
optimally treated by TLPT. These criteria would also likely result in was reported in one patient.12 The stapler was placed prior to
removal of an appropriate soft tissue envelope to effect local control. mucosal incision and the authors' speculated intraoperative contam-
Tumours extending beyond the extrinsic laryngeal muscle might also ination to be less as the pharyngeal cavity was not directly opened.
be considered for TLPT but tumour free margins would be more diffi- The fistula was reported to have occurred in a patient who had
cult to achieve and complication risk would increase. Extension recurrence following radiation therapy, consistent with another
beyond the extrinsic laryngeal muscles, involvement of the cricoid car- report, and the fistula closed in 2 weeks with conservative manage-
tilage caudally or invasion of the pharyngeal mucosa would require ment. There are no reports of stapled pharyngeal closure in the
reconstructions that would be more likely to suffer from stoma col- veterinary literature.
lapse, oesophageal dysfunction, tension and potentially pharyngeal Modified supracricoid laryngectomy has been reported in people
dehiscence. with the primary goal of speech maintenance.13 Preservation of barking
TLPT is divided into three components: (1) Laryngeal excision, (2) function or phonation is of much less importance in dogs and most
Water-tight pharyngeal reconstruction and (3) Permanent tracheos- dogs with tracheostomy lose vocal ability even without laryngectomy.19
tomy creation. When local control is achieved, and no adjuvant However, noted above, the authors recommend preservation of the cri-
therapy is indicated, the primary continued patient management is for coid cartilage or a portion of the cartilage if possible. Preservation of all
the tracheostomy. or some of the cricoid cartilage maintains the tubular rigidity of the
With minor differences, the cases reported here were treated proximal trachea possibly allowing for a more rigid tracheostomy.
with similar laryngeal excision techniques. This portion of the proce- The sternohyoideus muscles are closed as the most ventral layer of the
dure may require modification depending on tumour location relative muscular portion of the wound. The trachea is then rolled
to the larynx and tumour behaviour (eg, degree of local invasion). The cranioventrally to the skin surface. Approximating sutures can be
point of tracheal transection seems to have the most inconsistency placed from the subcutis to the cartilage circumferentially around the
resulting in varying types of tracheostomy. For example, tran- trachea to help relocate the trachea superficially. This modification to
section locations could be through a portion of the cricoid cartilage or the technique has several advantages. The need to close the proximal
through the proximal trachea depending on the location of the trachea (as previously reported) is eliminated because the proximal tra-
tumour. Moreover, the thyroparathyroid blood supply should be chea is rolled and anastomosed to the skin. This eliminates the proximal
6 MATZ ET AL.
tracheal closure as a potential access point to the tracheal lumen, effec- substantial follow-up with all dogs and owners and 5/6 were satisfied
tively eliminating this as a potential entry to the airway, thereby sepa- with the capabilities of their pet.
rating the GI and respiratory systems. In conclusion, TLPT resulted in local tumour control, functional
In the dogs reported here, stoma care, peristomal skin hygiene patient results, acceptable quality of life and owner satisfaction with
and lifestyle changes were needed. Typically, the stoma care surgical outcome in the six dogs reported here. TLPT should be con-
decreases as the tracheostomy matures and healing is complete. sidered a treatment option for laryngeal neoplasms. Maintenance of
Despite lifestyle modifications and increased attention needed to care the cricoid cartilage, if appropriate, eliminates the need for proximal
for their pets, most owners are satisfied following permanent tracheal closure and provides for a more rigid tracheostomy.
tracheostomy.6
Tracheostomy creation with laryngectomy following at a later ACKNOWLEDG MENTS
date may seem an attractive option. This manages the emergency The authors would like to acknowledge Drs. Michael Tillson and Dan-
associated with airway obstruction. The authors' experience with this iel Linden for their assistance with proofreading the manuscript.
approach has been that the tracheostomy ultimately has required revi-
sion. It may remain optimal to perform the procedure in a single stage CONFLIC T OF INT ER E ST
so the tracheostomy can be created without proximal laryngeal The authors declare no potential conflict of interest.
attachment and without the possibility of tracheal position changes
when later divided from the larynx. DATA AVAILABILITY STAT EMEN T
Other issues of importance in the human literature include consti- Author elects to not share data because it was generated from medi-
pation secondary to inability to generate a forceful abdominal press cal records.
(lack of glottic closure), increased colonic transit times, infective
coughing, speech, smell, social/psychological issues and eating/ OR CID
swallowing problems.14,15
Brad M. Matz https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6478-9536
Closure of the glottis allows for abdominal pressure generation,
known as a Valsalva manoeuvre. Contraction of abdominal muscula- RE FE RE NCE S
ture aided by exhalation against a closed glottis aids the process of
1. Withrow SJ. Cancer of the larynx and trachea. In: Withrow SJ,
defecation. TLPT creates inability to generate a closed glottic attempt Vail DM, eds. Small Animal Clinical Oncology. 4th ed. St. Louis, MO:
at exhalation. In a study of 28 TLPT human patients, 70% reported WB Saunders; 2007:515-516.
problems with constipation and colorectal transit was significantly 2. Henderson RA, Powers RD, Perry L. Development of hypoparathy-
roidism after excision of laryngeal rhabdomyosarcoma in a dog. J Am
increased compared with the control population.15 Constipation is not
Vet Med Assoc. 1991;198(4):639-643.
known to occur following TLPT in dogs, however an awareness of the 3. Dunbar MD, Ginn P, Winter M, Miller KB, Craft W. Laryngeal
possibility is important because this would affect quality of life. rhabdomyoma in a dog. Vet Clin Pathol. 2012;41(4):590-593.
Pharyngoespohageal spasm has been reported following TLPT in 4. Block G, Clarke K, Salisbury SK, DeNicola DB. Total laryngectomy and
permanent tracheostomy for treatment of laryngeal rhabdomyosar-
human patients.16 Spasm can result in impaired speech and problems
coma in a dog. J Am Anim Hosp Assoc. 1995;31(6):510-513.
with swallowing. A small case series reported improvement of clinical 5. Grimes JA, Davis AM, Wallace WL, et al. Long-tern outcome and risk fac-
signs following injection of botulinum toxin, though some patients tors associated with death or the need for vision surgery in dogs with per-
required multiple interventions.16 Dysphagia has not been reported in manent tracheostomies. J Am Vet Med Assoc. 2019;254(9):1086-1093.
6. Davis AM, Grimes JA, Wallace ML, et al. Owner perception of out-
dogs previously and was not encountered in the dogs reported here. It is
come following permanent tracheostomy in dogs. J Am Anim Hosp
reasonable to assume minor disability or decreased function likely occurs Assoc. 2018;54(5):285-290.
but may remain clinically silent. To the author's knowledge, no imaging 7. Hedlund CS, Tangner CH, Montgomery DL, Hobson HP. A procedure
studies have been performed in dogs to evaluate swallowing after TLPT. for permanent tracheostomy and its effects on tracheal mucosa. Vet
Surg. 1982;11(1):13-17.
Two dogs in this report developed pulmonary metastatic disease.
8. Crowe DT, Goodwin MA, Greene CE. Total laryngectomy for laryngeal
Both dogs were treated with lung lobectomy and their survival times mast cell tumor in a dog. J Am Anim Hosp Assoc. 1986;22:809-816.
were 575 and 1460 days. It seems that the owners felt their dogs' 9. Rossi G, Tarantino C, Taccini E, Renzoni G, Magi GE, Bottero E. Gran-
quality of life was sufficiently good that they elected additional sur- ular cell tumor affecting the left vocal cord in a dog. J Comp Pathol.
2007;136(1):74-78.
gery for disease control.
10. Erdag MA, Arslanoglu S, Onal K, Songu M, Tuylu AO. Pharyngocutaneous
Limitations to this report are those inherent to small case series. fistula following total laryngectomy: multivariate analysis of risk factors.
Limited numbers of dogs and variable postoperative adjuvant plans Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol. 2013;270(1):173-179.
limit drawing sweeping conclusions. Lymph node sampling was con- 11. White HN, Golden B, Sweeny L, Carroll WR, Magnuson JS,
ducted in a non-standardized fashion. Sentinel lymph node mapping Rosenthal EL. Assessment and incidence of salivary leak following lar-
yngectomy. Laryngoscope. 2012;122(8):1796-1799.
could be considered to direct staging tests, need for lymph node exci-
12. Zhang X, Liu Z, Li Q, et al. Using a linear stapler for pharyngeal
sion, help determine prognosis and need for adjuvant therapy. A spe- closure in total laryngectomy. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol. 2013;270
cific client survey was not used for evaluation but the authors had (4):1467-1471.
MATZ ET AL. 7
13. Allegra E, Franco T, Trapasso S, Domanico R, la Boria A, Garozzo A. laryngeal collapse secondary to brachycephalic airway obstructive
Modified supracricoid laryngectomy: oncological and functional out- syndrome. Vet Surg. 2018;47(5):648-653.
comes in the elderly. Clin Interv Aging. 2012;7:475-480. 18. Occhipinti LL, Hauptman JG. Long-term outcome of permanent tra-
14. Babin E, Blanchard D, Hitier M. Management of total laryngectomy cheostomies in dogs: 21 cases (2000-2012). Can Vet J. 2014;55(4):
patients over time: from the consultation announcing the diagnosis to 357-360.
the long term follow-up. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol. 2011;268(10): 19. Mercurio A. Complications of upper airway surgery in companion ani-
1407-1419. mals. Vet Clin North Am Small Anim Pract. 2011;41(5):969-980.
15. Ugur SS, Yuksel S, Coskun BU, Dadas B, Sirin G, Selcuk A. Does lack
of glottic closure affect quality of life as a cause of constipation in
laryngetcomized patients? Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol. 2013;270(2):
629-634. How to cite this article: Matz BM, Henderson RA, Lindley SS,
16. Kim HN, Lewin JS, Knott JK, Hutcheson KA, Dekovich A. Novel ther- Smith AN. Total laryngectomy and permanent tracheostomy in
apeutic approach to relieve pharyngoesophageal spasm after total
six dogs. Vet Comp Oncol. 2021;1–7. https://doi.org/10.1111/
laryngectomy. Gasrointest Endosc. 2012;76(1):193-196.
17. Gobbetti M, Romussi S, Buracco BV, Gatti A, Cantatore M. Long-term
vco.12681
outcome of permanent tracheostomy in 15 dogs with severe