Professional Documents
Culture Documents
tography to be implemented (7). The wet chemical analysis (11). The major tenuated total reflectance technology
second is the introduction of very high- advantages of FIA are high through- in a form well suited to high-pressure,
temperature capillary columns (8), put, reliability, and precision. Howev- high-temperature, mixed-phase proc-
which will extend the use of the tech- er, an even greater range for FIA will be ess applications (13).
nique to ever more polar, high molecu- forthcoming as new technologies are In the ultraviolet-visible (UV-vis)
lar weight species and decrease the added. First is the capability to per- arena, technological developments
need for derivatization. form on-stream liquid-liquid extrac- have made scanning versions of these
Liquid chromatography (LC) has tions. Second is the incorporation of a instruments far more rugged and reli-
been used less on-line, but its advan- chromatographic step. Third is the in- able. Three key concepts are the adap-
tages are becoming apparent as more clusion of sophisticated multichannel, tation of single-beam techniques that
complex, water-soluble materials are rapid-scan spectroscopic detectors to use stored baselines rather than me-
synthesized. The advent of smaller di- provide a more robust single-compo- chanically sampled reference and sam-
ameter packing materials has led to the nent analysis or simultaneous multi- ple compartments; the use of concave
use of very short columns with excel- component analysis. As these capabili- holographic gratings that yield accept-
lent resolution and sensitivity. For bio- ties are added to FIA, it will become able stray light rejection in a single
processing applications, capillary zone more apparent that this technology is monochromator and eliminate the
electrophoresis (9) seems appealing, an appealing paradigm for developing need for collimating mirrors; and the
but new types of detectors and sample an automated universal microlabora- introduction of photodiode arrays that
introduction technologies must be de- tory that integrates the functions of eliminate mechanical scanning of the
veloped. Recently, an offshoot of this sample acquisition, clean-up, concen- grating (14). The current generation of
technique using micelles or tetraalkyl- tration, separation, sensing, and iden- low-end UV-vis spectrometers based
ammonium ions as a “pseudo reversed tification. Process engineers will find on these principles is almost cost-com-
phase” has led to greatly increased ver- the approach particularly attractive petitive with filter wheel photometers
satility for the technique and should because it so closely resembles the and is certainly more cost-effective and
provide impetus for accelerated techni- flow-stream concept used in automat- just as reliable.
cal development. The potential for ed chemical-processing lines. In-line era. The major disadvantage
eliminating expensive, unreliable high- Continuous on-line process analysis of on-line analysis is the need to con-
pressure pumps and replacing them is the first era to offer true real-time struct a separate analytical line that
with compact, solid-state, high-voltage capability. The instrumentation is properly samples the main stream and
power supplies is an important reason largely spectroscopic in nature. Until presents it to the instrument at a suit-
to explore capillary electrophoresis as recently, spectroscopic devices were able temperature and pressure. This
an on-line technique. limited by the technological con- has led to the fourth era: in-line process
The recent introduction of a process straints imposed by extreme reliability analytical chemistry. Here, chemical
supercritical fluid (SCF) chromato- requirements, the hostile nature of the analysis is done in situ, directly inside
graph (70) will provide a new dimen- plant environment, and the necessity the process line, using a probe that is
sion of versatility to on-line chroma- to remain accurate through long peri- chemically sensitive. In its ideal form,
tography. This technique yields excel- ods of inattention. In the past, such the device might resemble a typical in-
lent resolution at high speed on very constraints led to the development and dustrial temperature probe. Such an
nonvolatile polar, heat-labile mole- use of dedicated process analyzers that implementation obviously would be at-
cules. The SCF equivalent to GC tem- achieved ruggedness and reliability at tractive to process engineers.
perature programming is pressure pro- the expense of analytical power. As an It is widely believed that the key to
gramming, which provides a much fast- example, consider infrared (IR) spec- scaling down chemical sensors is to fab-
i / */
Rheodyne
THE LC CONNECTION COMPANY
CIRCLE 140 ON READER SERVICE CARD
ricate them with tools that originate in multiple points in a process line. At
the microelectronics revolution: micro- present, fiber optic sensing is limited
lithography and micromachining (3). to the UV-vis-near-IR, but new types
Virtually all of the microsensors fabri- of IR transparent glasses are rapidly
cated to date use a two-stage detection being developed.
scheme. In the first stage, chemical se- Thus far, we have confined our
lectivity is obtained by a chemical thinking about chemical microsensors
transformation or by physisorption or to the one-sensor/one-analyte concept.
chemisorption to a chemically selective These microsensors, however, offer
surface. Table II lists various schemes many other possible applications, and
that have been used to obtain chemical we find it useful to think in terms of a
selectivity for microsensing. In the sec- hierarchical complexity of devices that
ond stage, some physical consequence the microelectronics paradigm pro-
of the chemically selective stage, such vides. Simple single sensors are at the
as release of heat or change of optical first level.
absorption, is converted to an electrical The second level in the hierarchy is
signal by a suitable microtransducer. the sensor array. Here, the ability to
Table III lists the various physical use microlithography to fabricate mul-
properties that can be sensed and the tiple sensors on one chip is an obvious
types of transducers that have been way to avoid having multiple probes for
employed. Together Tables II and III versions of these devices will require multiple analytes. The straightforward
form a matrix of possibilities for chemi- considerable progress in encapsulation approach to implement a multifunc-
cal sensing. Virtually all entries in the and packaging. tion sensor is to devote one sensor to
tables have been explored. In the CHEMFET, the ion-selective each analyte of interest. This method,
The most noted of the microsensors membrane is replaced by a chemically however, does not address the well-
are the CHEMFET and the ISFET selective layer. For example, a palladi- known problem of interferences in the
(15). The ISFET, which was first re- um-gate FET has been developed for chemical selectivity step. An alterna-
ported by Bergveld some 15 years ago, detection of hydrogen at the parts-per- tive strategy is to use a set of relatively
arose from a desire to scale down com- million level. Janata pioneered the use unselective sensors, each of which has a
mon pH or ion-specific electrode tech- of this approach for biochemical detec- different response profile to all the an-
nology. It is therefore important to tion by developing enzyme-based (EN- alytes of interest. In this case, the array
note that such devices share all of the FET) and antibody-based (IMMUNO- generates a response pattern that may
advantages and disadvantages of po- FET) sensors. One of the major issues be analyzed by various powerful meth-
tentiometric electrochemical detec- in the design of these microsensors is ods of multivariate statistics and pat-
tors. It is now widely appreciated that the optimization of their responses. tern recognition. The combination of
the development of long-lived, reliable (See the paper by Janata and co-work- sensor array and data processing con-
ers that shows the multitude of consid- stitutes a robust analytical system that
erations involved [16].) can yield simultaneous multicompo-
A second class of microsensors takes nent analyses with the capability of
Table II. Chemical/physical advantage of the electrooptical revolu- recognizing and correcting for interfer-
transformations employed in tion: fiber optic sensors (4). With these ences and drift (18,19). The same mul-
microsensors to obtain microsensors, probe light is generated tivariate methods also may be used to
chemical selectivity remotely and conveyed to the sensor optimize specific multicomponent ana-
end by a light guide, where it interacts lyses problems, selecting the minimum
Chemical transformations with a chemical probe by absorption, number of sensors or sensing channels
• Electrochemical
scattering, fluorescence, or Raman (e.g., wavelengths) to yield optimal
•
Enzyme catalyzed emission. The light, which has been en- performance (20).
Physisorption to a surface coded with chemical information, is The third member of the microsen-
• From gas phase then returned by the same or a second sor hierarchy is the ultraminiature op-
• From liquid phase light guide to an electrooptical trans- tical spectrometer. One possible ap-
Binding to an immobilized receptor ducer that creates the desired electrical proach employs the highly successful
•
Immunoadsorption signal. Such an optical technique is optical imaging device, which is a mi-
• Ion exchange very versatile. One has the entire range crofabricated array of photosensors.
Membrane transport of chemistries developed over the years Previously these devices were used as
•
Electrolyte separation as spot tests to provide inspiration. electronic photographic plates in con-
Many of these can be immobilized onto junction with conventional spectro-
glass or polymer beads and encapsulat- graphs. Alternatively, extremely small
ed into microcuvettes to form optrodes solid-state spectrometers have been
Table III. Techniques for detection and of all sorts. constructed using tiny diffraction grat-
transduction employed by chemical Another use of fiber optics may ings and graded index of refraction
microsensors prove to be of even greater value as a lenses as collimators (21). Unfortu-
means of elevating optical spectrosco- nately, diffraction gratings do not scale
Physical properly Transducer(s) py to the fourth era. This is accom- down very small, because fewer and
Chemical potential Field effect transistor plished by developing various types of fewer grating lines are sampled and
Optical Photodiode fiber optic probes that substitute for lower resolution results. A different ap-
Heat Thermistor, pyroelectric the conventional sampling streams. proach is multibeam interferometry,
Mass Piezoelectric balance Still another advantage of this ap- which is widely known as the basis of
Mass Surface acoustic wave proach, as pointed out by Hirschfeld interference filters. Here, wavelength
Conduction Dielectrometer (17), is the ability to employ fiber optic analysis takes place over the dimen-
Surface resistance Chemiresistor, Taguchi multiplexing schemes so that a single sions of microns rather than centime-
Current flow Ampometer expensive instrument can be placed in ters. One suitable implementation of
a safe, convenient location to sense this concept is the linear interference
Brownlee
Labs
A division of Applied Biosystems, Inc.
CIRCLE 20 ON reader SERVICE CARD 2045 Martin Avenue Santa Clara, CA 95050 408/727-1346 800/231-4038
wedge filter in which the wavelength of materials can be made because scatter-
maximum transmission varies continu- ing coefficients are much greater than
ously along one axis. A prototype com- absorption coefficients. Consequently,
pact planar spectrometer using a wedge diffuse log inverse reflectance and dif-
filter and linear array detector gives ac- fuse absorbance measurements show
ceptable results (22). good linear correlation with composi-
The remaining member of the hier- tion variation. Diffuse reflectance is
archy is the chemical microlaboratory. particularly useful, because only a sin-
The goal is to integrate all functions of gle window into the process need be
a chemical analysis laboratory into a established. In addition, the high de-
unit no larger than a credit card. The gree of light scattering results in the
key to this development is the integra- sampling of a large volume. The hard-
tion of microconduits, microvalves, and ware is inexpensive and employs wide-
microsensors by various types of hy- ly available fiber optic components,
brid circuit fabrication techniques conventional monochromators, tung-
(23). Although this device is really a sten lamps, and silicon detectors. Fi-
third era concept, it provides a path- nally, the spectra are characterized by
way to the implementation of chemical an extremely high signal-to-noise ratio.
microsensors. These devices should Thus subtle shifts in the spectra, which
last much longer when incorporated might go undetected by the unaided
into a microlaboratory because of ex- cients in this region are very small and eye, can become the basis for highly
tensive sample conditioning and inter- allow path lengths of 0.5-20 cm for successful analytical procedures devel-
mittent use. clear solutions. Generally, absorptions oped by computer learning methods.
Non invasive era. The final era of in this region arise from the second and A second remote analysis technology
process analytical chemistry, the non- third overtones of CH, OH, and NH is IR emission spectroscopy. This ap-
invasive era, represents the ultimate in stretches together with combination proach starts from the observation that
desirability. Because the probe does bands from other vibrations. Because all bodies at a temperature higher than
not physically contact the sample, the these are highly forbidden transitions, their surroundings will emit radiation.
sampling problem is greatly alleviated. most materials are very transparent For simple black bodies the spectral
This era obviously has a great deal in (exceptions are metals and graphite distribution of radiation is very smooth
common with remote sensing and non- containing composites). At these opti- and is given by Planck’s law. For real
destructive evaluation. cal distances, a thin layer of adsorbed substances, however, discrete lines are
Near-IR spectroscopy from 700 material in the windows does not fatal- observed on top of the Planck
1100 nm has much to offer (24) in this ly degrade the results. Also, quantita- emission. These lines correspond well
regard. First, the extinction coeffi- tive measurements of highly scattering with those observed in the normal IR
absorption spectrum of the emitting
substance. Thus it is certainly possible
to obtain qualitative information. But
Laser Light obtaining quantitative information is
more difficult because most of the
emission originates at the surface, se-
Scattering Systems
for particle size analysis, molecular
vere reabsorption effects are evident,
and the lines are present on a large
background. Nevertheless, the poten-
weigh! measurement and other applications tial advantages of a truly remote in situ
The Malvern SYSTEM 4700c is an advanced modular system designed for technique justify further effort to un-
derstand the quantitative aspects.
research and development applications. It features the 8-bit Malvern 7032
At lower energies, in the microwave
Multi-8 correlator with Variable Time Expansion (VTE) allowing up to eight and radiofrequency bands, objects be-
sampling times per measurement. Fixed and expandable configurations come rather more transparent, and
ranging from 72 up to 264 data channels are available. therefore information can be obtained
A 16-bit IBM compatible processor plus full range of software for photon from deep within. Whereas the micro-
correlation spectroscopy wave absorption spectroscopy of gas-
SYSTEM 4700c for fixed for condensed phases include the abili-
angle PCS and electro-
ty to perform spectroscopy directly in
the frequency domain with high-speed
phoretic zeta potential GaAs integrated circuitry and the abili-
measurements.
ty to sample large, well-defined vol-
umes with near-field resonators.
Yet another noninvasive technology
Malvern Instruments Inc V involves X-rays. Most analytical chem-
200 Turnpike Road. Southborough, MA 01772. USA '
ists will immediately think of X-ray
Tel (617) 480 0200
fluorescence, which has been adapted
CIRCLE 94 ON READER SERVICE CARD
Materials Analysis tor for all elements boron and heavier. (#82)
KEVEX CORPORATION
1101 Chess Orive, Foster City, CA 94404
415-573-5866 Toll Free: 1-800-227-0277
Kevex -2161
Canadj^HMI 6-731
KevexFrance(FonSs.A.) Tel33-1-34810024
Kevex UK Tel 44-582-400696
to both on-line and in situ use to yield transformation vector is produced
high-speed elemental analysis. At the that, when multiplied by the spectral
same time, it has been shown that dif- vector, yields an estimate for the prop-
ferential X-ray absorption can be used erty. Once the derived transformation
to give compositional selectivity. For- o vector has been validated with a dou-
ble-blind study of a second set of sam-
merly, tunable X-ray sources were ex-
tremely rare, but major advances in X- ples for which spectra and property
ray optical coatings, materials, and have been measured, the method is
sources will remedy this difficulty (25). ready for use.
The final, fifth era of technology to In the case of gasoline, a study of 43
consider is ultrasound. The major use samples of unleaded gasoline of known
of ultrasound has been for out-line im- octane number was made using near-
IR spectroscopy over fiber optics. By
aging of flaws, employing reflections
from index of refraction boundaries.
However, a recent paper makes a
: ( =®— o
simple step-forward multilinear re-
gression, a linear equation involving
strong case for further research on the only the absorption intensities at three
mechanisms for ultrasound absorption, wavelengths was found that correlated
which is based at least in part on chem- NONIN VASIVE to the reference octane number with a
standard error of 0.3 octane, the known
ical composition (26).
In reviewing the remote era, we can precision of the octane engine (28).
see how much commonality the field ter is measured by a knock engine that Further studies involving more sam-
has with nondestructive evaluation is extremely expensive, requires a sub- ples clearly will be required to verify
and noninvasive medical diagnosis. As jective judgment (listening for pinging) the method and to assure its robust-
an example of the use of the process to make the measurement, and must be ness. But the effort is justified because
analytical chemistry paradigm, consid- exactingly maintained (1). Even worse, the spectroscopic test takes only 20 s to
er the current practice of clinical chem- the measurement takes 20 min to per- perform, and the instrumentation costs
istry. For the most part, its status is form and consumes a full pint of gaso- far less and requires considerably less
similar to the first and second eras of line. Finally, the poor precision and maintenance than that used in other
process analytical chemistry. Blood is large interinstrument variability cost methods.
drawn from the patient and is either the refiner a lot of money, because the Another major advantage of on-line
sent to a remote central laboratory quality specifications must be set high spectroscopy is that a number of chem-
(off-line) or analyzed by a simpler doc- enough to allow for octane measure- ical and physical properties can be
tor’s office instrument (at-line). At the ment uncertainty, and they cause a lot measured simultaneously from one
University of Washington, we are de- of irritation, because the regulatory spectrum. For gasoline, we have been
veloping the fifth era of clinical analy- agency’s octane determinations may able to correlate the spectrum to both
sis (real-time, noninvasive) by exploit- not agree with the company’s. research and motor octane, API densi-
ing new concepts in spectroscopy and At the Center for Process Analytical ty, Reid vapor pressure, distillation
data reduction, A new role is sure to Chemistry, we have been exploring a points, and total aromatics, olefins and
emerge for the clinical chemist who be- new approach to on-line quality evalu- aliphatics—eight tests in 20 seconds!
comes a full partner in supplying criti- ation. We begin with the observation One of the most intriguing aspects of
cal data to the doctor and, with multi- that vibrational absorption spectrosco- multivariate calibration is the capabili-
variate statistics, interprets it in terms py can yield information about func- ty to generate the correlation spectrum
of the patient’s current physiological tional groups, molecular structure, and that is associated with a paticular prop-
status and prognosis. conformation, as well as intermolecular erty (29). This may prove to be an ex-
Role of chemometrics
interactions. In principle, one should tremely valuable tool in materials re-
be able to obtain chemical and physical search. For example, the correlation
We have completed an outline of some material properties from the spectrum. spectrum of tensile strength might re-
of the possibilities for chemical sensing Unfortunately, such information often veal the presence of specific supramo-
in process analysis. How does one ana- is present in subtle variations in the lecular structures or unique intermo-
lyze the data from the array of instru- spectrum and might not be recognized lecular bonds that determine the spe-
ments and sensors that have been by the naked eye, or it might be depen- cific property. Such knowledge could
placed on-line? At this point, a major dent upon an unknown relationship lead to new materials with significantly
cultural gap becomes evident between among several spectral features. Ac- improved performance.
the analytical chemist and the process cordingly, to obtain the structure- Thus far, no algorithms have been
engineer. Most analytical chemists re- property relationship, one must either formulated that use multiwavelength
gard their function as supplying chemi- develop a first principles theory, which spectroscopy in real-time process con-
cal composition information, which is, is generally impossible, or use an em- trol. A study by Wise (30), however,
after all, what they have been trained pirical method such as multivariate shows how multiple physical measure-
to do. Unfortunately, this does not al- statistical calibration (27). In the latter ments (temperature at various points,
ways meet the needs of the process en- approach, the computer is provided applied power, substrate resistance)
gineer, whose job is to provide a prod- with a training set consisting of the together with multivariate statistics
uct that meets quality specifications. spectrum of each of the samples and can be employed to prevent runaway
In some cases, especially for chemicals the property, measured by an indepen- foaming during the operation of a liq-
production, composition data suffices. dent reference method. It is important uid-fed ceramic melter.
In many situations, however, and espe- that the training set consist of repre- Another potential use for multivari-
cially for consumer products, the speci- sentative samples with variations ate calibration is to qualify incoming
fications are not obviously chemical in spanning that of the set of all samples raw materials. Many types of processes
nature. An example of this is gasoline that might reasonably be encountered are bedeviled by batch-to-batch varia-
testing. Here, the most important con- by the method. Once the data set is tions in the raw materials. A recent
sumer quality parameter is the anti- acquired, the computer searches for study (3J) showed that multiblock par-
knock property as expressed by the oc- correlations between the spectra and tial least-squares regression could be
tane number. Presently, this parame- the sought-for property. Eventually a used to form a model with which one
TO EXPLORE NEW
FRONTIERS, TO BOLDLY
GO WHERETO
CHROMATOGRAPH HAS
GONE BEFORE.
The first and only truly distributed system of
process gas and liquid chromatography that now
also allows you to use temperatured programmed
methods to analyze high-boiling materials in on-line
applications. Optichrom® Advance.
NOW AVAILABLE- Programmed Temperature
Process Gas Chromatography used in the Advance
System incorporates a separate temperature-
controlled zone into the existing oven. PTPGC allows
the user to further expand gas chromatography
analysis to a wider boiling range of materials for
-
D
could use the quality control data—in proach their colleagues involved in syn-
this case, IR spectra and sonic spec- thesis concerning a collaborative effort
tra—to predict the outcome of the proc- with a goal of optimizing new synthetic
ess in terms of the performance of the approaches, using analytical instru-
final product. In the future it should be
possible to combine information about
ments to give real-time information
about how a given reaction is proceed- HPLC
the properties of incoming raw materi- ing. A recent contribution from acade-
als with a process model to adjust con- mia describes a simple mass spectrom-
ditions and accommodate variations in eter interface to reaction mixtures that Systems
raw materials, thereby producing a uses semipermeable capillary tubing
product of more consistent quality. and illustrates its use in reaction moni- For superior HPLC analyses, ESA
toring (32). provides a complete line ol HPLC
Implementing process analytical The future components and systems-pumps,
chemistry injectors, detectors, and automatic
Process analytical chemistry is a disci- sampling equipment.
In industry, process engineers and ana-
pline poised to have a major impact
lytical chemists all too often are sepa- both on industrial processing and on Use these modular components to
rate groups, each with its own goals and the parent discipline. The savings to be design an HPLC system to meet
distinct culture. Thus it is not uncom- obtained from installation of the your exact applications and
mon for the analytical group to con- budget needs. Or add high-
present generation of process analyzers performance components to your
vince managers to install a sophisticat- has been quantified (33), and it can be
ed process analyzer but to avoid the existing HPLC for analysis results
enormous. The new generation of on- you can trust.
issues of maintenance and calibration. line spectroscopic instruments and the
Frequently the shiny new instrument accompanying multivariate analysis For example, our systems-
becomes rusty while the two groups ar-
promise even more capabilities, with
gue over responsibility. We have ob- the possibility of developing new proc-
served that companies that are most
essing methods that previously could
successful in implementing process an- not be considered because of the lack of
alytical chemistry have formed inter- adequate control. Perhaps the most ex-
disciplinary working groups of engi- citing promise of process analytical
neers and scientists devoted solely to
chemistry is to make process lines so
that task.
efficient and so well controlled that ef-
Another difficulty in implementa- fluent release is decreased or even elim-
tion arises from barriers created by inated altogether. Imagine the good
horizontal integration in a company. will such efficient plants might gener-
Seldom does the bench chemist who
ate in the community.
develops a new synthetic method par- The changing practice of process an-
ticipate actively in scale-up operations. alytical chemistry is sure to influence
Even pilot plant personnel seldom mi-
the discipline as a whole. It is a leading
grate to the full-scale operation. This force behind the migration of analyti-
communication gap should be elimi- cal instruments from the protected lab-
nated by encouraging vertical move-
ment within a company. The benefits
oratory into the real world. The use of
the micro- and optoelectronics para-
of this strategy are well known in a few
instrument companies, where a re- digms is leading to a new generation of Advanced Modular HPLC System
chemistry from the University of Cali- policy development at CPAC and con- autosampler for reliable, routine
fornia at Davis and his Ph.D. in physi- tributes to its research program. processing of samples at a
cal chemistry from the University of reasonable cost.
Washington. Callis’s major research Bruce R. Kowalski (left) is professor of
interest is instrumentation for optical chemistry and co-director of CPAC.
spectroscopy. He is developing ultra- He received his B.S. with majors in
miniature spectrometers based on chemistry and mathematics (1965) Send today for our complete
novel transform principles, laser- from Millikin University and his HPLC products catalog.
based chromatography detectors, and Ph.D. in chemistry (1969) from the
noninvasive diagnostic devices. University of Washington, Seattle.
His research interests include the ap-
Deborah L. Illman (center) is associate plication of methods of multivariate
director of CPAC. She received her analysis to the resolution and calibra-
B.S. in chemistry (1976) from the Uni- tion steps in analytical instrumenta-
versity of Washington and her Ph.D. tion in order to develop new analytical ESA, Inc.
in chemistry (1982) from the State methods and improve existing ones. 45 Wiggins Avenue
University of Campinas, Brazil. She Kowalski is editor-in-chief of the Jour- Bedford, Massachusetts 01730
then accepted a lectureship and post- nal of Chemometrics. In 1974 he co- (617)275-0400
doctoral position at the University of founded the Chemometrics Society.
CIRCLE 42 ON READER SERVICE CARD