Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Rangel EM, Mendes IA, Cárnio EC, Marchi Alves LM, Godoy In Brazil, nursing already benefits from VLE and its re-
S, Crispim JA. Development, implementation, and assessment of a sources for teaching themes related to medication administra-
distance module in endocrine physiology. Adv Physiol Educ 34: 70–74, tion and mood disorders, among others (17, 19).
2010; doi:10.1152/advan.00070.2009.—This study aimed to develop, Physiology is a basic science important for nurses. When it
implement, and assess a distance module in endocrine physiology in is applied in clinical practice, nursing care to clients is better
TelEduc for undergraduate nursing students from a public university and nurses’ participation in clinical decision making in multi-
in Brazil, with a sample size of 44 students. Stage 1 consisted of the
disciplinary teams becomes more frequent. This occurs be-
development of the module, through the process of creating a distance
course by means of the Web. Stage 2 was the planning of the module’s
cause nurses are more capable of asking pertinent questions,
practical functioning, and stage 3 was the planning of student evaluations. doing an efficient research on patients’ history, reading results
In the experts’ assessment, the module complied with pedagogical and of examinations, and performing appropriate nursing interven-
technical requirements most of the time. In the practical functioning tions (4).
stage, 10 h were dedicated for on-site activities and 10 h for distance Thus, professors should use teaching strategies that promote
activities. Most students (93.2%) were women between 19 and 23 yr learning, retention, and motivation of students regarding phys-
of age (75%). The internet was the most used means to remain iology, creating an environment that provides opportunities to
updated for 23 students (59.0%), and 30 students (68.2%) accessed it learn in different ways (21). VLE and its resources are an
from the teaching institution. A personal computer was used by 23 internationally used strategy to support physiology teaching in
students (56.1%), and most of them (58.1%) learned to use it alone. nursing programs (7). However, there are no studies in litera-
Access to a forum was more dispersed (variation coefficient: 86.80%) ture on the use of DE and its resources for teaching endocrine
than access to chat (variation coefficient: 65.14%). Average partici- physiology.
pation was 30 students in forums and 22 students in the chat. Students’ Hence, this study aimed to develop, implement, and assess a
final grades in the module averaged 8.5 (SD: 1.2). TelEduc was shown distance module in endocrine physiology in VLE TelEduc with
to be efficient in supporting the teaching-learning process of endo-
students from an undergraduate nursing diploma program of a
crine physiology.
public university in Brazil.
distance education; nursing
METHODS
multiple-choice and true/false questions and interactive JCROSS multiple-choice and true/false questions, which was worth 8.0 points.
crossword exercises were applied. TelEduc was the VLE used. The student’s final average grade was obtained by adding up the exam
Different digital media elements were used for the development of grade (8.0) and two points (2.0) for participation in the formative
the lessons, such as the following: text, statistical graphs, animations, evaluation activities, with a maximum final average of 10.0.
and interactive exercises. The development of the animations required The obtained data were coded to develop a data dictionary. Later,
the participation of computer science professionals and the use of two they were transcribed into Microsoft Excel worksheets using the
animation software packages, Macromedia Flash and Blender. Inter- double-entry process. After errors had been corrected, data were
active JCROSS crossword exercises were developed by the researcher, exported and analyzed with SPSS 16.0 (Statistical Package for Social
using the free software Hot Potatoes, for nonprofit institutions. Science) to calculate absolute frequencies and percentages.
Four informatics experts and four physiology experts assessed the
module using an instrument available in the literature (3). It comprised RESULTS
pedagogical aspects with items related to content, interaction, and
activities and technical aspects with items related to the response time Distance module in endocrine physiology. The general ob-
and quality of the interface. Assessed categories in each of these items jective of the module was to develop knowledge concerning
were as follows: 1) content (pertinence, intelligibility, applicability, the physiology of the endocrine system. The specific objectives
quantity, and consistency); 2) interaction (student-student, student-
are shown in Table 1.
machine, student-group, student-professor, and group-professor);
3) activities (pertinence, intelligibility, applicability, quantity, consis- Organization of the content of the distance module in endo-
tency, and educational assessment); 4) response time (accessibility crine physiology is shown in Table 2.
regarding the ease of access to pages in the environment and naviga- Module assessment. As to the module assessment, the four
tion concerning the functioning of buttons, links, and students’ ori- physiology experts addressed the items’ content, interaction,
entation in the environment); and 5) quality of the interface (colors, activities, response time, and quality of the interface. The four
space on the screen, and letters, figures, and animations). informatics experts addressed only items concerning the re-
For each of these items, each reviewer attributed a value: ⫹1 if the sponse time and quality of the interface.
characteristic was completely fulfilled, 0 if the characteristic was Regarding content and interaction, all expert answers (100%)
partially fulfilled, and ⫺1 if the characteristic was not fulfilled. If indicated that the characteristics were fulfilled. For the activi-
reviewers chose 0 or ⫺1, they included a comment and justification. ties item, one of the experts (25%) determined in the intelligi-
Stage 2: planning of the module’s practical functioning. Before the
module was put to work, a meeting was held with students to
bility category that the characteristics were partially fulfilled,
1) provide guidance about the objectives to be achieved with the due to the difficulty of understanding one statement in a
module by VLE TelEduc; 2) invite participation; and 3) clarify that, content retention exercise in lesson 7. The exercise was re-
in the case of a disagreement, the traditional teaching mode would be viewed, and the modification that the expert suggested was
offered. At the end of the meeting, all 53 students registered in the accepted.
physiology course, according to a list provided by the undergraduate For the response time, most experts [6 (75%)] considered
office, were asked for their e-mail contact information to register in that the characteristics were fulfilled. However, two of the
the module, and received a login and password to access the module. expert answers (25%) indicated that the characteristics were
Although 44 students were part of the study analysis, the module was partially fulfilled in the navigation category, justified by the
also applied to the 9 students who did not meet the inclusion criteria, fact that some pages of the material opened quickly, which, in
since none of the students refused to participate in the distance
module. In the same meeting, a questionnaire was administered to
their view, could be a source of confusion for the student.
obtain data related to sociodemographic, internet, and personal com- Regarding the quality of the interface, all expert answers [8
puter use characteristics. (100%)] showed that the characteristics were fulfilled.
In total, 20 h were spent on the implementation of the module, Implementation of the distance module in endocrine physi-
distributed among the following TelEduc tools: agenda, support ma- ology. The implementation of the module occurred between
terial, exercises, activities, compulsory stop (used to call students’ November 21, 2007 and December 10, 2007. Ten hours were
attention to an important item), and discussion forums, respectively. dedicated to the accomplishment of on-site meetings and 10 h
This pertained to the following: 1) schedule of the on-site and distance to carry out distance activities. During the on-site meetings,
activities, 2) content of the lessons, 3) proposed exercises for content the students became familiar with the VLE of TelEduc and
retention, 4) interactive exercises, 5) the script for the chat on diabetes discussed doubts regarding the introductory lesson and les-
mellitus used in the two sessions (sessions A and B) had the help of a
monitor in each, and 6) questions related to the theme of endocrine
sons 1–7.
physiology. To carry out distance activities, students studied the content
To perform the diabetes mellitus chat, students were divided into of the lessons, did content retention exercises, and participated
two groups: groups A and B. Two chat sessions were held, one for in discussion forums and in the chat about diabetes mellitus.
group A and one for group B, outside of class time. Both sessions Characterization of students participating in the distance
were carried out by the same instructor, who was assisted by a monitor module in endocrine physiology. Of the 44 students (100%)
in each session. who participated in the implementation of the module, most of
Stage 3: planning of student evaluations. Formative and summative the students were women (93.2%) and between 19 and 23 yr
evaluations were carried out with students. Formative evaluation was old (75%).
based on interactions between the students and professor during the Data related to the students’ use of the internet and personal
module, as measured by the “access” tool, available in TelEduc,
which considered the following: access to support material, access and
computers are shown in Table 3.
solving of the content retention exercises, access and participation of Twenty-three of the students (59.0%) indicated that the
students in discussion forums, and access and participation of students internet was the most used means to obtain updated knowl-
in chat. Participation in these activities was worth 2.0 points in the edge, and 30 students (68.2%) accessed it predominantly from
final grade. Summative evaluation occurred during the last on-site the teaching institution. Twenty-five students (56.8%) used a
meeting of the module, through the application of an exam with personal computer every day, 23 students (56.1%) used it from
Table 1. Distribution of the specific objectives of the lessons 86.80%), followed by chat (VC: 65.14%), exercises (VC:
of the distance module in endocrine physiology 50.16%), and support material (VC: 44%).
Student average scores on content retention exercises
Lessons and Specific Objectives (lessons 1–7) are shown in Fig. 1. Figure 1 also shows the
variation in average scores on the content retention exer-
Introductory lesson: the endocrine system
cises (lessons 1–7).
1. To define hormones The average participation in the discussion forums was 30
2. To identify the endocrine glands
3. To describe the hormonal regulation mechanisms students.
The average participation in chat sessions A and B was 22
Lesson 1: physiological aspects of the hypothalamus-hypophyseal axis
students.
1. To identify the hormones synthesized by the hypothalamus and With regard to the summative evaluation, the students’
hypophysis
2. To describe the role of the hypothalamus in the control of hypophyseal average exam score was 6.5 (SD: 1.1).
secretion Students’ final grades in the module averaged 8.5 and the
Lesson 2: physiology aspects of the thyroid gland standard deviation 1.2.
1. To identify the hormones released by the thyroid gland
2. To describe the action of the thyroidal hormones
3. To explain the regulation mechanism of thyroidal hormone secretion
4. To describe the clinical manifestations of hyperthyroidism and Table 2. Distribution of the organization of the contents of
hypothyroidism the lessons of the distance module in endrocrine physiology
Lesson 3: physiological aspects of the adrenal gland
Lessons and Contents
1. To identify the hormones secreted by the adrenal gland
2. To describe the actions of hormones secreted by the adrenal gland
3. To describe the clinical manifestations of Addison’s and Cushing’s Introductory lesson
disease ● Hormones and glands
Lesson 4: physiological aspects of the parathyroid gland ● Hormonal regulation
● Positive feedback
1. To identify the hormone secreted by the parathyroid gland ● Negative feedback
2. To describe the actions of the hormone secreted by the parathyroid gland
3. To explain the regulation mechanism of the hormone secreted by the Lesson 1
parathyroid gland ● Hypothalamus-hypophyseal control
4. To describe the clinical manifestations of hypoparathyroidism and ● Anterior and posterior hypophysis
hyperparathyroidism ● Hormones of anterior hypophysis
Lesson 5: physiological aspects of the pancreas ● Hormones of posterior hypophysis
Students
In activities in which the professor was not present, not even qualifying nursing students undertaking a human anatomy and physiology
virtually, student participation was lower. This compares with module. Nurse Educ Today 26: 388 –395, 2006.
8. Guyton AC, Hall JE. Fisiologia Médica (10th ed.). Rio de Janeiro:
traditional education, in which students are learners and the Guanabara Koogan, 2002.
professor is the coordinator of the process. 9. Kibble J. Use of unsupervised online quizzes as formative assessment in
The teaching strategies that students are routinely exposed to a medical physiology course: effects of incentives on student participation
need to be reviewed. Thus, this generation of students can be and performance. Adv Physiol Educ 31: 253–260, 2007.
supplied the competencies expected for their professional per- 10. Moore M, Kearsley G; translated by Galman R. Educação a Distância:
uma Visão Integrada. São Paulo, Brazil: Thomson Laerning, 2007.
formance. Since physiology is one of the basic sciences to 12. Paschal CB. Formative assessment in physiology teaching using a wire-
support nursing care, this course needs to be taught in an less classroom communication system. Adv Physiol Educ 26: 299 –308,
innovative way, and further studies need to be developed that 2002.
test these strategies. 13. Rodrigues RC, Peres HH. Panorama brasileiro do ensino de enferma-
gem. Rev Esc Enferm USP 42: 298 –304, 2008.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS 14. Romanowski JP, Wachowicz LA. Avaliação formativa no ensino supe-
rior: que resistências manifestam os professores e os alunos? In: Processos
Statistical analysis was performed by Jesusmar Ximenes Andrade (Depart- de Ensinagem na Universidade: Pressupostos para as Estratégias de
ment of Accounting and Administration, Centro de Ciências Humanas e Trabalho em Aula, LG, Alves LP. Joinvile, SC: Univille, 2007, p.
Letras, Federal University of Piauı́ and PhD candidate in Controlling and 130 –150.
Accounting, Faculty of Economics, Administration and Accounting, Univer- 15. Schlemmer E. Metodologias para educação a distância no contexto da
sity of Sao Paulo). formação de comunidades virtuais de aprendizagem. In: Ambientes Vir-
tuais de Aprendizagem, edited by Barbosa RM. Porto Alegre: Artmed,
REFERENCES 2005, p. 29 – 49.
1. Aires MM. Fisiologia (2nd ed.). Rio de Janeiro: Guanabara Koogan, 16. Severo CL, Cogo AL. Acesso e conhecimento dos acadêmicos de enfer-
1999. magem acerca de recursos computacionais. Rev Gaúcha Enferm 27:
2. Alves RH, Cogo AL. Vivência de estudantes de licenciatura em enfer- 516 –523, 2006.
magem em disciplina na modalidade a distância. Rev Gaúcha Enferm 17. Silva EC. Educação a Distância: Ambientes Digitais para o Processo
Porto 29: 626 – 632, 2008. Ensino-Aprendizagem em Enfermagem Psiquiátrica (PhD Dissertation).
3. Caetano KC. Desenvolvimento e Avaliação de um Ambiente Virtual de São Paulo, Brazil: Escola de Enfermagem de Ribeirão Preto/USP, 2007.
Aprendizagem em Administração em Enfermagem (Master’s Thesis). São 18. Taradi SK, Taradi M, Radic K, Pokrajac N. Blending problem-based
Paulo, Brazil: Escola de Enfermagem/USP, 2006. learning with Web technology positively impacts student learning out-
4. Chummun H. Understanding changes in cardiovascular pathophysiology. comes in acid-base physiology. Adv Physiol Educ 29: 35–39, 2005.
Br J Nurs 18: 359 –364, 2009. 19. Telles Filho PC, Cassiani SH. Ciclo de criação e avaliação do módulo
4a.de Azevedo Nacimento AC. Princı́pios de Design na Elaboração de administração de medicamentos para ensino a distância. Rev Latino-am
Material Multimı́dia para Web (online). http://rived.mec.gov.br/artigos/ Enfermagem 16: 78 – 85, 2008.
multimidia.pdf [17 February 2010]. 20. Telles Filho PC, Cassiani SH. Implementação e avaliação do módulo a
5. Falkembach GA. Concepção e desenvolvimento de um material educa- distância. Cogitare Enfermagem 12: 222–235, 2007.
tivo digital. Novas Tecnologias Educação 3: 1–15, 2005. 21. Weherwerein EA, Lujan HL, Dicarlo SE. Gender differences in learn-
6. Fetter MS. Graduating nurses’ self-evaluation of information technology ing style preferences among undergraduate. Adv Physiol Educ 31: 153–
competencies. J Nurs Educ 48: 86 –90, 2009. 157, 2007.
7. Green SM, Weaver M, Voegeli D, Fitzsimmons D, Knwles J, Harrison 22. Zaı́na LA. Acompanhamento do Aprendizado do Aluno em Curso a
M, Shephard K. The development and evolution of the use of a virtual Distância Através da Web: Metodologias e Ferramentas [Master’s thesis].
learning environment (Blackboard 5) to support the learning of pre- São Paulo, Brazil: Escola Politécnica/USP, 2002.