Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Darrow 1959
Darrow 1959
ESTIMATING REqUIREMENTS
From the Department of Pediatrics, University of Kansas, and the Children's Mercy
Hospital, Kansas City.
30 BASIS FOR ESTIMATING REQUIREMENTS FOR PARENTERAL FLUIDS
teral fluid therapy.s, 14, 19 Certain difficulties with this assumption are
mentioned later. The insensible loss is about 43 gm. per 100 calories in
the absence of sweat. About one third is contained in expired air, and
the rest leaves the body by diffusion through the skin when there is no
sweat. Usually about 20 gm. of sweat are formed. 12 The stools contain a
small and relatively constant amount of water when there is no diarrhea,
and during fluid therapy the amount may be practically nought. Urine
volume can vary considerably in response to the requirements for
regulation of body water and electrolytes. It is the possibility of varying
urine water that permits variation in the water intake.
Based on the data of Du Bois,9 Figure 4 represents diagrammatically
the physiologic responses of the skin in the regulation of heat losses
when environmental temperature varies. Between 80 and 84 0 F. (26.6
Insensible:
Lungs ......................................... 14
Skin ......................................... 28
Sweat ......................................... 20
Stool. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 8
Urine ......................................... 80
The loss of sodium, chloride and potassium is about 2-3 mEq. each.
The requirement per square meter of surface area is about 10 times these figures.
and 28.8 0 C.) the quiet nude subject is able to maintain body and skin
temperature without sweating. The regulation is attained largely by
alterations in skin circulation. Below this environmental temperature
skin and body temperatures tend to fall. When body temperature de-
creases about 1.5 0 C., heat production increases, owing to a chill. Above
the zone of comfortable adjustment, loss of heat by evaporation of
sweat maintains skin and body temperatures. As environmental tem-
perature approaches body temperature, all heat loss is accomplished by
evaporation of water. Except at high humidity and temperatures, the
rate of evaporation of water is not so diminished as seriously to inter-
fere with heat dissipation except when metabolism is increased. In the
absence of sweat, diffusion of water through the skin is dependent on
the difference between vapor tension of the skin and that of the
surrounding air. The vapor tension of the skin varies directly with skin
temperature, while that of the air depends on environmental temperature
and humidity. The air entering the lungs becomes 95 per cent saturated
at close to body temperature. Cold air always contains relatively little
moisture, while hot air is likely to have a low humidity. Consequently
DANIEL C. DARROW 31
Rectal Temperature
~ 36
..
~34
Skin Temperature
e
..
E
t32
t- 30
100 172
Metabolic .,;
E
80 138 (!)
II) $
.~
.5!
840
60
69 ~
c
..
~
0
20
Heat
I58ficit
~.atBala~
i
Witho~~.at I
Heat Balance
with Sweat
~ Lungs) 35 g.
>
ILl
0 0
24 26 28 30 32 34 36
Temperature °C.
Fig. 4. Diagram of heat balance at different temperatures in nude adults.
(7 per cent per degree F.). Activity and other factors alter metabolism.
Table 4 shows the probable metabolism per kilogram per day during
parenteral fluid therapy. .
It is usually stated that basal metabolism correlates best with surface
area. Nevertheless basal metabolism is lower per square meter in the
newborn period and rises in infants weighing 6 to 10 kg. to levels higher
than that characteristic of adults. Actually TalboP8 found that metab-
olism correlated best with weight during the first year. Holliday and
Segar13 pointed out the high metabolic rates per kilogram or surface
area in infants weighing 6 to 10 kg. However, they recommend 100 ml.
of water per 100 calories metabolized, but they fail to take into account
the reduction of metabolism during the fasting accompanying parenteral
fluid therapy. By using their data and calculating total metabolism at
levels more nearly correct, fluid requirement is about 140 ml. per 100
calories, or 150 if water of oxidation is included.
Oliver, Graham and Wilson 17 reject the whole concept of computing
fluid requirements from surface area. In addition to the awkwardness of
computing surface area from weight, the implied relationship between
surface area and metabolism is considered unwarranted. First, sufficient
34 BASIS FOR ESTIMATING REQUIREMENTS FOR PARENTERAL FLUIDS
SODIUM
Although one cannot estimate precisely the deficits of water and electro-
lytes in a clinical situation, the probable maximal deficits can be
calculated for water and sodium. The calculations involve a number of
approximations and the assumption that the changes in serum sodium
concentration result from a change in extracellular sodium without
alteration of body water, or a change in body water without alteration in
body sodium. The reader is referred elsewhere" for a discussion of body
composition and the factors determining serum sodium concentration.
The following method of calculation is seldom justified in patients be-
cause dehydration almost always involves both water and sodium. The
calculation merely indicates how the order of magnitude of deficits may
be estimated for simplified conditions and provides a physiologic basis
for the probable maximal deficits of water and sodium in patients. The
figure for water is essentially the one found in observations on man
under heat stress,1 and the one for sodium is essentially the one found
DANIEL C. DARROW 35
for dogs deprived of extracellular electrolyte without change in body
water.7
Assuming osmotic equilibrium between extracellular and intracellular
fluids,
(osm r t osm. ). = (osmr t osmd) ,
where osm is osmotically active substances in body water and subscripts
rand d refer respectively to osmols restricted to one compartment and
those freely diffusible in body water. Subscripts e and i indicate extra-
cellular and intracellular compartments. W is water in liters. Because
osmols that are freely diffusible exist at the same concentration in all
body water, osmtJ, may be omitted from the equation describing the
factors determining serum sodium concentration and distribution of
body water. Because the anions neutralizing sodium are predominantly
univalent in extracellular fluids, the restricted osmols of extracellular
fluid are approximately 2 Nae and the restricted osmolar concentration
is approximately twice the concentration of sodium in serum water,
which is represented as 2[Na]e
Hence
2[Na]. = (Ow
smr ), _ (2Na. + osm r )
- w.+w,
Using simultaneous equations with a serum sodium value of 140 for
normal concentration,
6. (Na). = ([Na]. - 140) W t
where W t is total body water. The equation indicates that the deficit of
sodium producing a serum sodium concentration of llO mEq. per liter
is 18 mEq. per kilogram when body water is 0.6 and remains constant.
This estimate is probably too large, because intracellular osmols decrease
when serum sodium concentration diminishes. 15 It is likely that the
deficit is about 15 mEq. per kilogram-the amount of sodium in 100 m1.
of physiologic saline.
Developing a similar equation when extracellular sodium is constant
and water varies,
6. w= ( 1- [Na]_
140)
W,
For a rise in serum sodium to 170 mEq. per liter, owing to change in
body water alone, about 120 m1. of water per kilogram would have to be
removed from the body. Owing to increase in intracellular osmols, this
is probably an overestimateY; It is likely that loss of 100 m1. per kilo-
gram would produce this rise in serum sodium concentration.
Balance studies4 • 8 indicate that about o.ne third of extracellular
sodium and water is lost in isotonic dehydration of severe degree. This
36 BASIS FOR ESTIMATING REQUIREMENTS FOR PARENTERAL FLUIDS
r
I
is equivalent to about 80 mI. per kilogram of saline in infants and 60 in
children and adults.
Accordingly, the physiologic evidence indicates that deficits of water
seldom are greater than 100 ml. per kilogram; the deficits of sodium are
likely to be less than the amount contained in this volume of saline, i.e.,
6 to 8 mEq. per kilogram. One is justified as a rule of thumb in assuming
that severe dehydration involves loss of about 100 ml. of water that
should be replaced; the deficit of sodium that should be replaced is
usually contained in about 0.6 of this volume of saline. In hypotonic
states the deficit of sodium is greater, and the deficit of water is much
less. The deficiency of sodium may be as great as 15 mEq., particularly
when there is practically no true deficit of water. In hypertonic dehydra-
tion the deficit of sodium may be negligible. If excessive sodium has
been given, there may be an excess of sodium in hypertonic states, and
the deficit of water is in part a deficit relative to the excess of sodium.
Moderate dehydration should be considered to involve smaller deficits.
It is true that rapid losses of weight indicate that replaceable deficits of
water are frequently greater than 100 ml. per kilogram. To some extent
losses of weight involve losses of cytoplasmic structures due to starvation
and tissue injury. These losses of water are replaced more slowly and.
only when food can be given. The foregoing estimates merely indicate
the magnitude of the replacements that should be given rapidly, within
one or possibly two days. Occasionally the deficits of water which
should be rapidly replaced are greater than 100 ml. per kilogram.
Fortunately successful therapy does not depend on precise, rapid
correction of disturbances in concentration, though the evidence indi-
cates that the volume of extracellular fluid, particularly decreases in
blood volume, should be rapidly replaced. For example, the shock
accompanying severe isotonic dehydration due to loss of extracellular
water and electrolytes should be rapidly corrected by restoring the vol-
ume of extracellular fluids with 60 to 80 ml. per kilogram of saline or
Hartmann's lactate Ringer solution. Also the disturbances accompany-
ing .a notable decrease in serum sodium concentration due to loss of
sodium are greatly benefited by rapidly increasing serum sodium con-
centration by injecting 15 mEq. per kilogram of sodium in a solution
2 to 3 times as concentrated as physiologic saline. It is advisable to give
only half this amount immediately and, if the effect is favorable, repeat
the injection after a few hours. However, it is not advisable rapidly to
reduce serum sodium concentration in hypertonic states by injecting
large amounts of glucose in water. Convulsions have accompanied this
type of treatment while serum sodium concentration was still high. The
reaction seems to be analogous to the water intoxication observed when
serum sodium is rapidly reduced below normal, owing to excessive
retentions of water relative to sodium. In hypertonic states it suffices to
r DANIEL C. DARROW 37
give fluids that contain enough sodium to replace the probable deficits
of sodium during the first 24 hours and sufficient water to replace water
deficits in the same period. In this way the kidneys adjust serum con-
centrations gradually. The important consideration in administering
solutions containing sodium salts is not to change rapidly the electro-
lyte pattern, but to restore deficits with a mixture permitting renal
regulation of volume and concentrations except for special indications
mentioned above.
POTASSIUM
PHOSPHATE
MAGNESIUM
CALCIUM
The indications for calcium therapy would require more space than is
warranted in this discussion. It should be mentioned that the develop-
ment of low serum calcium following treatment of infantile diarrhea
(the postacidotic state) is rare in my experience. Administration of
excessive amounts of sodium bicarbonate and failure to include potas-
sium apparently increase the likelihood of this complication. lO
* Deficit of potassium is probably greater than 3 mEq. per kilogram and cannot be
replaced in 1 day. The amount accompanied by an asterisk is the safe dose for 1 day.
SUMMARY
Fluid therapy should be based on the estimation of deficits per unit of
weight, normal expenditure on total metabolism, and abnormal losses
on the nature of the disturbance. Although expenditure may be related
to surface area, tables relating weight to calorie production give a more
accurate estimate of total metabolism than one constant metabolic rate
per square meter of surface area. Renal regulation of body water and
electrolytes is the best friend of the doctor planning fluid therapy, but
it cannot be depended on to adjust the volume and concentration of
body water if the fluids prescribed for patients of different sizes are
computed solely in relation to surface area and ignore the fact that
deficits are best related to body weight.
REFERENCES
1. Adolph, E. F., and others: Physiology of Man in the Desert. New York, Intel'
science Publishers, Inc., 1947.
2. Cooke, R. E., Darrow, D. C., and others: The Role of Potassium in Metabolic
Alkalosis. Am. J. Med., 17: 180, 1954.
3. Crawford, J. D., Terry, M. E., and Rourke, G. M.: Simplification of Drug Dosage
Calculation by Application of the Surface Area Principle. Pediatrics, 5:783,
1950.
4. Darrow, D. C.: Retention of Electrolyte during Recovery from Severe Dehydra·
tion Due to Diarrhea. J. Pediat., 28: 515, 1946.
5. Darrow, D. C., and Hellerstein, S.: Interpretation of Certain Changes in Body
Water and Electrolytes. Physiol. Rev., 38:114, 1958.
6. Darrow, D. C., and Pratt, E. L.: Fluid Therapy: Relation to Tissue Composition
and Expenditure of Water and Electrolytes. J.A.M.A., 143:355, 1950.
7. Darrow, D. C., and Yannet, H.: The Changes in Distribution of Body Water
Accompanying Increase and Decrease in Extracellular Electrolytes. J. Clin.
Invest., 14:266, 1935. -
8. Darrow, D. C., Pratt, E. L., Flett, J., Jr., Gamble, A. H., and Wiese, H.: Dis·
tribution of Water and Electrolytes in Infantile Diarrhea. Pediatrics, 3: 129,
1949.
9. Du Bois, E. F.: Heat Loss from the Human Body. Harvey Lecture. Bull. New
York Acad. Med., 15:143, 1939.
10. Finberg, L.: Experimental Studies of the Mechanisms Producing Hypocalcemia
in Hypernatremic States. J. Clin. Invest., 36:434, 1957.
11. Franks, M., Ferris, R. F., Kaplan, N. 0., and Meyers, G. B.: Metabolic Studies in
Diabetic Acidosis. II. Effect of Administration of Sodium Phosphate. Arch. Int.
Med., 81:42,1948.
12. Heeley, A. M., and Talbot, N. B.: Insensible Water Losses per Day by Hospital.
ized Infants and Children. Am. J. Dis. Child., 90:251, 1955.
13. Holliday, M. A., and Segar, W. E.: Maintenance Need for Water in Parenteral
Fluid Therapy. Pediatrics, 19:823, 1957.
DANIEL C. DARROW 41
14. Lowe, C. U.: Symposium on Parenteral Fluids, Nutrition and Electrolytes:
Pediatric Problems. Minnesota Med., 39:9, 1955.
15. McDowell, M. E., Wolf, A. V., and Steere, A.: Osmotic Volumes of Distribution.
Idiogenic Osmotic Pressure Associated with Administration of Hypertonic
Solutions. Am. ,. Physiol., 180:3, 1955.
16. Metcoff, J., and others: Intracellular Composition in Severe Malnutrition. Pedi·
atrics, 20:317, 1957.
17. Oliver, W. J., Graham, B. D., and Wilson, J. L.: The Lack of Scientific Validity
of Surface Area as Basis for Parenteral Fluid Dosage. l.A.M.A., 167:1211, 1958.
18. Talbot, F.: Basal Metabolism of Children. Physiol. Rev., 5:477, 1925.
19. Talbot, N. B., Crawford, J. D., and Butler, A. M.: Homeostatic Limits to Safe
Parenteral Fluid Therapy. New England J. Med., 248:1100, 1953.