You are on page 1of 14

Renewable Energy 145 (2020) 2130e2143

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Renewable Energy
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/renene

Numerical Optimization Study of Archimedes Screw Turbine (AST):


A case study
K. Shahverdi a, b, *, R. Loni c, B. Ghobadian c, S. Gohari a, S. Marofi d, Evangelos Bellos e
a
Department of Water Science Engineering, Bu-Ali Sina University, Hamedan, Iran
b
Department of Water Structures Engineering, Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran
c
Department of Biosystems Engineering, Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran
d
Water Research Institute, Bu-Ali Sina University, Hamedan, Iran
e
Thermal Department, School of Mechanical Engineering, National Technical University of Athens, Greece

a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t

Article history: The use of renewable energies including hydropower energy is growing throughout the world. Among
Received 8 November 2018 the existing hydropower technologies, small-scale hydropower technologies are popular due to easy
Received in revised form accessibility and availability in different locations. Recently, Archimedes Screw Turbines (ASTs) as a new
12 March 2019
technology have been considered. The main objective of this research is the structural optimization of an
Accepted 27 July 2019
Available online 29 July 2019
AST for substituting in irrigation canals instead of existing check structures. For this purpose, the AST
performance model was numerically developed for screw performance optimization in MATLAB 2013a
environment. The developed model was validated using experimental data. Different structural pa-
Keywords:
Archimedes screw turbine
rameters were optimized to design an appropriate AST for replacing instead of check drop-1 in the east
Numerical optimization Aghili canal in Khuzestan province (Iran). The canal was simulated using the ICSS hydrodynamic model.
Power generation The results of the developed model showed a good agreement with reported experimental data. The
East Aghili canal highest efficiency was obtained 90.83% for the screw length of 6 m, the inclination angle of 20 , and the
flight number of 1 at the design flow rate. Based on the findings, the suggested system can be used
instead of the canal structures without considerable change in the hydraulic and performance of the
canal.
© 2019 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

1. Introduction of these resources are small rivers, irrigation systems, drinking


water networks, wastewater networks, cooling systems, etc. In
Nowadays, producing sustainable energy is one of the main hydropower plants, the hydraulic power of water is converted to
challenges throughout the world. The fossil fuel resources mechanical power using a turbine in order to electricity genera-
decreasing, CO2 increasing, environmental pollution and global tion. Recently, inverse use of the conventional Archimedes screw
warming cause researchers to find other resources of energies pump is considered as a popular technology to be used as a tur-
([1,2]). Renewable energies such as solar, wind, geothermal and bine for electricity generation from flowing water, named Archi-
hydropower energies as popular kinds of renewable energy re- medes Screw Turbine (AST). Traditionally, the Archimedes screw
sources can be found throughout the world ([3e6]). Among the was used for pumping water from a lower to a higher level or
mentioned resources, hydropower energies have been used conveying liquid or solid materials in a horizontal or inclined
widely as large-scale hydropower plants in large dams. Although plane [7].
almost all of the large-scale hydropower opportunities have There are different types of turbine for electricity generation
already been exhausted, there is a strong potential for small-scale including Kaplan, Pelton, etc. Comparing the relative costs of an AST
hydropower (micro hydropower) resources to be exploited. Some and the more common Kaplan turbine for a small-scale hydro-
power site showed that for an energy output of about 15% more, the
AST cost is about 10% less, and its annual capital cost 22% cheaper
[8]. In addition, the AST is an environmental and fish friendly
* Corresponding author. Department of Water Science Engineering, Bu-Ali Sina structure which needs low civil works for installation in even
University, Hamedan, Iran.
E-mail address: shahverdi2006@gmail.com (K. Shahverdi).
existing structures [9]. Previous researches showed screw

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.renene.2019.07.124
0960-1481/© 2019 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
K. Shahverdi et al. / Renewable Energy 145 (2020) 2130e2143 2131

efficiency decreases when rotation speed increases at higher speed Refs. [25,26]. In the first work, the ideal model of an AST was
because the friction forces become unexpectedly large [10]. numerically developed. Also, the screw performance was investi-
Numeric researches on the real performance of ASTs are limited. gated experimentally. The numeric developed model was validated
Rorres [11] derived relationships using analytical and numerical using experimental data. The validated model was used for screw
analysis for the water levels, flow rates and flow leakages based on efficiency prediction. The predicted mechanical power and effi-
actual Archimedes screw pump geometry with modern computing ciency showed good agreements with associated experimental re-
techniques. Due to the importance of flow leakage of hydraulic sults. Moreover, the maximum efficiency was approximately 80%.
machinery on their performance, flow leakage of hydraulic ma- Kozyn and Lubitz [26] developed a complete power losses
chinery was investigated experimentally and numerically in model to real screw efficiency prediction. The complete model was
Refs. [12,13], and [14]. The design and optimization of hydraulic implemented in MATLAB. In that research, the ideal power and
machinery were investigated in Ref. [15] based on the flow rate, efficiency were predicted using Lubitz et al. [25] ideal model, and
head and rotational speed, and in Ref. [16] based on experimental then real mechanical power and efficiency experimentally esti-
and numerical analysis. mated. Using ideal and real mechanical power and efficiency dif-
Müller and Senior [17] presented a simple two-dimensional ference, all power losses were calculated. Finally, each power loss
theory of the Archimedes screw. They developed a model based was estimated using the developed power losses model. This model
on the geometry parameters of the Archimedes screw. They validated using an installed AST in Waterfored, Ontario, Canada.
assumed the hydrostatic pressure creates torque and causes the Most of the studies until now, on the screw performance, are
screw rotation. Questionnaire investigation on about 400 installed experimentally, and in some cases both numerically and experi-
ASTs in Europe showed that outer diameter is equal to pitch, and mentally, but they are not in a real case study and in micro hy-
the inner diameter is half the outer diameter in most of the dropower resources like irrigation canals.
installed screws. Also, the mean and max electrical efficiencies of Irrigation canals are one of the best micro hydropower resources
ASTs were calculated as 69% and 80%, respectively [18]. The effect of because they have many energy dissipater structures to reduce the
the upstream canal water level on the screw diameter was hydraulic energy of flowing water. Some of these structures are
considerable, and for the screw inclination angle of 34.8ᵒ, the AST drops, chutes, settling basin, etc. which dissipate excess energy of
electrical efficiency has reported 84% [19] which is a high efficiency. water as usually heat losses. The excess energy of flowing water in
C Zafirah and Nurul Suraya [20] investigated the helix turns and a such structures can be converted to electricity. Considering ASTs
number of flights to optimize the AST performance using CFD are an efficient, fish friendly, environmentally friendly device, and
(Computational Fluid Dynamic) method. The results showed that have low civil works for substituting in existing structures, they
the highest performance of 81% could be obtained for a screw with could be a good candidate for this purpose. East Aghili canal in
flights number of 3 and the helix turns of 3. Also, the screw with Khuzestan province (Iran) is a good case for studying and opti-
flights number of 2 has higher performance than flights number of mizing an AST performance because it has many check structures
3 for any helix turns. which may be substituted with appropriate ASTs. Also, its hydraulic
Stergiopoulos et al. [21] studied screw performance with hori- and physical data exist due to previous studies [27,28].
zontal, vertical and inclined axes using CFD and explained the Although, the use of the AST to generate electricity is growing,
methodology, but they did not present any results about screw there are no references dealing with their optimum design and
performance. Lashofer et al. [22] tested both screws with rotating application in irrigation canals throughout the world. It is necessary
trough meaning the trough is fixed to the flights and screw with the to exploit these energy sources by designing and applying an
fixed trough. They found that the screw with fixed trough has appropriate AST instead of irrigation canal structures. The main
higher efficiency than that of for rotating trough. They investigated objectives of this paper are to recognize places which have po-
screw efficiency for a wide range of geometry parameters and re- tential hydraulic energy in the east Aghili canal by ICSS (Irrigation
ported the efficiency of up to 90%. Also, the Ritz-Atro company in Canal System Simulation) hydrodynamic simulation, and to
Germany reported the screw efficiency of up to 90% (www.ritz-atro. develop a numerical model of ASTs. Finally, an optimum AST
de). However, increasing AST efficiency is being studied. instead of the first check structure (check drop-1) in east Aghili
Dellinger et al. [23] developed a theoretical model in which canal was designed using developed model.
screw performance was investigated as a function of screw geom-
etry and flow condition. The flow leakage, friction, and outlet 2. Modeling and methodology
submersion losses were all included and the fill factor was variable.
They installed an experimental device in the laboratory and con- 2.1. General modeling description
ducted some experiments on the screw used in the theoretical
model investigation. The results of the theoretical and experi- In this research, a numerical model of an AST system was
mental models showed good agreements for the calculated torque developed for the estimation of power generation in irrigation
and efficiency with those of in the experiment. Since flow motion in canals. This research was conducted for the optimization of the AST
ASTs are three-dimensional and occurred phenomena are complex, for the east Aghili canal as a case study. For this goal, in the first
Dellinger et al. investigated screw performance using CFD method, stage, ICSS hydrodynamic model was used for simulating the east
OpenFOAM software, in different flow conditions and rotation Aghili canal and then available head and hydraulic power of water
speeds of the screw. The validation data for the OpenFOAM simu- flow in the canal were calculated. In this software, experimental
lations were collected using a laboratory set up. The screw data of the east Aghili canal were used. In the next stage, an
computational domain grids were defined about 5 million meshes advance hydraulic model was developed using hydraulic relation-
used for the calculations. Initial and boundary conditions were ships in the AST systems. All of the codes were written in the
defined and simulations were then performed. They resulted in MATLAB 2013a. It should be mentioned that all of the hydraulic
that a three-dimensional simulation is a powerful tool in order to losses were assumed in the developed model and the results of the
investigate the ASTs performance. However, they suggested more modeling were validated using the reported experimental data.
studies for the different inclination angle of the screw and various Finally, the optimum structural parameters of the AST including the
flow condition [24]. flight numbers, screw length, and screw inclination angle, as well as
A more complete performance model of ASTs was described in the performance parameters including water depth and flow were
2132 K. Shahverdi et al. / Renewable Energy 145 (2020) 2130e2143

optimized for the east Aghili canal. A summary of the investigated


methodology in the current study is presented in Fig. 1.

2.2. AST components

An AST exploits the kinetic and potential energies of a liquid in


places with very low head or nearly zero head. The kinetic and the
potential energy of a liquid are transformed into mechanical work
for rotating the screw and generating a torque. A coupled generator
to the screw converts the mechanical energy into the electrical one.
The potential sites for AST installing like rivers, irrigation systems
such as canals and conduits, stormwater systems and water dis-
Fig. 2. Schematic of AST components.
tribution systems, drinking water networks, wastewater networks,
cooling systems and even a desalination plant, etc. with nearly zero
to 6.5 m head and flow rate of fewer than 6.5 m3/s are the most
common places. The schematic of AST components is shown in
Fig. 2.
Based on Fig. 2, an AST system consists of different parts
including screw, trough, upstream canal and downstream canal.
Water inflows from upstream canal to the screw inlet and causes
the screw to rotate and a torque is generated. As the water reaches
to the screw end, it inters to the downstream canal which has a
constant water level.
In the AST system, water is supplied by an upper resource to the
inlet of the inclined AST. Water moving down from upstream of the
screw to the downstream is entrapped between two adjacent screw
flights. Water level difference between the upstream and down-
stream elevation of either side of the flights creates pressure force
acting on the flights and creating a torque that causes mechanical
rotation of the screw. Finally, flow is entered into the lower reser-
Fig. 3. Geometrical parameters of an AST.
voir. The hydraulic and mechanical parameters can be used for
computing the mechanical power and efficiency. It should be
mentioned, a bucket is a volume of water trapped between two 2.3. AST model developing
successive flights. There is a gap between the flights and the fixed
trough, named as Gap width (Gw ). The gap width allows the screw As shown in Fig. 4, consider an AST with an inclination angle of b
to rotate freely within the trough, and it causes a gap leakages. (related to the horizontal axis and in a cylindrical coordinate sys-
The geometrical parameters of an AST are shown in Fig. 3. They tem) in which w is aligned with screw centerline, r is the radial
are outer diameter (Do ), inner diameter (Di ), the pitch of the screw position of the considered element from the centerline and q is the
(S), total length (L), number of flights (N), and screw inclination angular position of the element from the centerline in the w axis.
angle (b). These parameters should be optimized for any values of Steady-state flow condition (constant rotation speed u and volume
the net water head (H) and the total volume flow rate flowing flow rate Qt ) was assumed for hydraulic modeling. An individual
through the system (Qt ). bucket was considered to calculate its torque (Tb ) and volume (Vb )
using numerical integration. All buckets were assumed to have the
same behavior; therefore, total torque and volume flow rate can be
calculated using single bucket torque and volume. The flow chart of
the mechanical power and efficiency calculation is shown in Fig. 5
described as follow.

Fig. 1. A summary of the investigated methodology in the current study. Fig. 4. Coordinate system of a rotating screw.
K. Shahverdi et al. / Renewable Energy 145 (2020) 2130e2143 2133

2.3.1. Geometric parameters calculation


According to the geometry of the screw, geometric parameters
are defined as below [26]:

wðrÞ ¼ r (1)

w
qðwÞ ¼ 2p (2)
S

Sq
z1 ¼ r cosðqÞcosðbÞ  sinðbÞ (3)
2p

Sq S Fig. 6. Position of the minimum (zmin ) and maximum (zmax ) value of the vertical point.
z2 ¼ r cosðqÞcosðbÞ  ð  ÞsinðbÞ (4)
2p N

in which z1 and z2 are the vertical positions of any point (r q) on the


0 z2 > zwl ; z1 > zwl
downstream and upstream surfaces of the flights, respectively.
Also, the minimum (zmin ) and maximum (zmax ) value of vertical z  z1 S
ð wl Þ rdrdq z2 > zwl ; z1
point occur at the downstream and upstream surfaces of the flights, dV ¼ f z2  z1 N (8)
respectively (Fig. 6). S
For a bucket, q ranges between 0 and 2p, and r ranges between rdrdq z2 < zwl ; z1 > zwl
N
Di =2 andDo =2; therefore, by substituting q ¼ p , r ¼ Do = 2 in
Equation (3), and q ¼ 2p, r ¼ Di =2 in Equation (4), zmin and zmax can
be calculated as following Equations:
2.3.2. Ideal power calculation
Do S The geometric parameters are used for calculating ideal power
zmin ¼  cosðbÞ  sinðbÞ (5) (no flow leakages or power losses) generated within an AST. The
2 2
hydrostatic pressure created at points z1 and z2 due to the weight of
water within a bucket are calculated using Equations (9) and (10),
Do S respectively, as follow:
zmax ¼ cosðbÞ  sinðbÞ (6)
2 2
0 z1 > zwl
Introducing fill factor f as relative depth in the screw section, the p1 ¼ f (9)
rgðzwl  z1 Þ z1 < zwl
actual water level can be defined as follows:
0 z2 > zwl
p2 ¼ f (10)
zwl ¼ zmin þ f ðzmax  zmin Þ (7) rgðzwl  z2 Þ z2 < zwl

If f ¼ 0 then z ¼ zmin and the bucket is empty. Whenf ¼ 1, water in which p1 and p2 are the hydrostatic pressure downstream and
level reaches to the top point of the central shaft of the screw and upstream surfaces of the flights, respectively. The bucket torque
z ¼ zmax . (Tb ) and total generated torque (T) due to the hydrostatic pressure
The volume of water in a bucket (Vb ) can be calculated by nu- are calculated using Equations (11) and (12), respectively:
merical integration of dV, Equation (8), for q between 0 and 2p, and
r between Di =2 andDo =2. ð q¼2
r¼Do=2 ðp
S
Tb ¼ ðp1  p2 Þ rdrdq (11)
2p
r¼Di=2 q¼0

NL
T ¼ Tb ð Þ (12)
S
Given a constant rotation speed (u), ideal power (Pideal ) in which
there are no flow leakages or power losses is calculated by Equation
(13):

Pideal ¼ u:T (13)


When water enters the AST, some flow leakages and some po-
wer losses are occurred reducing ideal power. The flow leakages are
gap leakage and overflow leakage, and the power losses are bearing
power loss, outlet expansion power loss, hydraulic friction power
loss and outlet submersion power loss.

2.3.3. Flow leakages calculation


Fig. 5. Flow chart of the mechanical power and efficiency calculation. The gap leakage (Qgl ) is not contributed to the screw torque
2134 K. Shahverdi et al. / Renewable Energy 145 (2020) 2130e2143

generation. Nagel (1968) suggested an empirical model as Equation water passing through it. These contacts produce some frictions in
(14) to estimate gap leakage when f ¼ 1. This model has been used the transport direction and rotational direction.
widely in previous researches. Note that the optimal performance In the transport direction, the screw flights produce no torque.
of the screw occurs when f ¼ 1; therefore, this model is used for The shear stresses of the trough (tt ) and central shaft (tcsh ) due to
screw design. Nagel model was used in this research to estimate the fluid viscosity can be calculated using Equations (21) and (22),
gap leakage. respectively:

Qgl ¼ 2:5Gw D1:5 (14) rv2t


o tt ¼ lt (21)
8
When fill factor becomes greater than 1, an overflow leakage
(Qo ) will occur. This leakage is estimated based on the relation of V-
rv2t
notch overflow defined by Equation (15) [10]. tcsh ¼ lcsh (22)
8
4 pffiffiffiffiffiffi 1
Qo ¼ m 2gð þ tanðbÞÞðzwl  zmax Þ2:5 (15) Where lt and lcsh are Darcy-Weisbach friction factor for the trough
15 tanðbÞ
and central shaft, respectively. Note that the relationship between
the two mentioned friction factor coefficients can be driven using
in which m is the flow coefficient and is equal to 0.537 according to
Darcy-Weisbach and Manning equilibrium easily. Shear forces (F)
Nuernbergk and Rorres [10].
on the wetted area of the trough (Awt ) and central shaft (Awcsh ) can
be calculated by Equation (23):
2.3.4. Power losses calculation
2.3.4.1. Bearing friction power loss. The bearing friction power loss F ¼ tt BAwt þ tcsh BAwcsh (23)
occurs due to screw rotation. At this point, it is important to state
that higher rotation speed leads to higher bearing power loss. In which, Bis number of buckets. Finally, overall head loss (hl;ht )
Typically, bearing power loss (Pl;b ) is a function of rotation speed and power loss (Pl;ht ) due to hydraulic friction in the transport di-
given by bearing manufacture. In this research, the screw material rection are given by Equations (24) and (25), respectively:
was considered as smooth steel with power loss equation as
Equation (16): rBVb g
hl;ht ¼ (24)
FL
Pl;b ¼ 0:0003u þ 0:0082 (16)
Pl;ht ¼ rgQhl;ht (25)

Hydraulic friction power loss in the rotational direction has two


2.3.4.2. Outlet expansion power loss. When water flows between components including friction between water and central shaft and
two different cross-section areas, a power loss occurs, named outlet friction between water and flights. The shaft relative velocity
expansion power loss. Moving water from trough with a lower (vshaft ), generated shear stress (tshaft ) and power loss (Pl;hshaft ) can
cross-section area to the receiving outlet canal with a greater cross- be calculated using Equations (26)e(28), respectively:
section area faces cross-section expansion power loss. The overall
Di
outlet expansion power loss (Pl;OE ) can be calculated using Borda- vshaft ¼ u (26)
Carnot relation defined as Equation (17). 2

v2t rv2shaft
Pl;OE ¼ rgQt :ðzo Þ (17) tshaft ¼ lchs (27)
2g 8
in which ris water density, g is gravitational acceleration, zo is the
rv2shaft
Borda-Carnot coefficient and vt is the transport velocity of the Pl;hshaft ¼ lchst BAshaft (28)
buckets along the screw length defined as Equations (18) and (19), 8
respectively:
in which Ashaft is the shaft wetted area.
A Determining shear stress between water and flights are rather
zo ¼ ð1  Q Þ2 (18) complex. Relative moving of water has two components; the radial
Ao
component which is orthogonal to the shaft axis and the compo-
nent parallel to the shaft which causes no friction loss. The relative
Su
vt ¼ (19) velocity between water and flights, related shear stress and power
2p
loss depend on the radial position of the considered element;
Where Ao is the cross-section area of the downstream canal, and therefore, to calculate the power loss due to flights friction
AQ is the average cross-section area within the AST calculated using (Pl;hflight ), Equation (29) must be integrated from D2i to D2o and radial
Equation (20): position from 0 to 2p.

Do Do
N ð 2ðp ð 2ðp
lf 1 r lf 2 r
2 2
AQ ¼ Vb (20)
S Pl;hflight ¼ B r 3 u3 dAf 1 þ B r 3 u3 dAf 2 (29)
8 8
Di
2
0 Di
2
0

2.3.4.3. Hydraulic friction power loss. Hydraulic friction power loss in which lf 1 and lf 2 are Darcy-Weisbach friction factor for the
(Pl;h ) occurs due to fluid motion and its viscosity when it contacts upstream surface and downstream surface of the flights, and sub-
with the screw and trough. In an AST system, a portion of the scriptions 1 and 2 are corresponding to the upstream surface and
trough, central shaft and flights are directly in contact with the downstream surface of the flights, respectively. The values of the
K. Shahverdi et al. / Renewable Energy 145 (2020) 2130e2143 2135

wetted surfaces area of the flights (dAf 1 and dAf 2 ) are calculated structures to lose the extra energy of flowing water in some places.
using Equations (30) and (31), respectively: These losses are usually as heat losses. Here, this hydraulic energy is
used for electricity generation. The ASTs can be used for this pur-
0 ; z1 > zwl pose, but the existing conditions of the canal must keep without
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
dAf 1 ¼ f 4p r þ S
2 2 2 (30) any change. In an irrigation canal, water depth should be controlled
rdrdq; z1  zwl at a dead band in order to deliver a constant volume flow rate to the
2pr
turnouts. The dead band is a margin around target depth (usually
±10%) within which water level variations are accepted. Therefore,
0 ; z2 > zwl
pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi substituting existing structures with an AST, water depth must
dAf 2 ¼ f 4p2 r 2 þ S2 (31) remain within the dead band as much as possible, and an AST in
rdrdq; z2  zwl such a condition must be designed.
2pr
The east Aghili canal, located in Aghili district in Khuzestan
The total hydraulic friction power loss is calculated using province in southwest Iran (Fig. 7) was used in this study. It has 20
Equation (32) rectangular turnouts and 11 check structures. The canal length is
16.215 km, Manning's roughness coefficient is 0.017 and trape-
Pl;h ¼ Pl;ht þ Pl;hshaft þ Pl;hflight (32)
zoidal cross-section side slopes is 1:1. The base width of the canal is
1.5 m from 0 to 9.485 km and 1 m from 9.485 to 16.215 km. The bed
slope varies along the canal between 0.0001 and 0.0004. The
turnouts are rectangular gates with width and height of 0.6 m and
2.3.4.4. Submersion power loss. To calculate the submersion power
0.6 m, respectively. Also, the width of all check structures are equal
loss (Pl;S ), an empirical equation derived from experimental results
to the canal width and their heights are 0.8 m in the first reaches
by Kozyn and Lubitz [26] was used in this research for our allowed
and 0.6 m in the last reaches.
submersion ranges defined by Equation (33).
A check structure controls water depth within the dead band at
Pl;S ¼ ð0:01765Qnd  0:1397Qnd þ 0:1989Þ:Pideal (33) the target depth. At least one turnout is located between two
successive check structures in this canal. According to the capacity
in which Qnd is the non-dimensional flow calculated using Equation of the turnouts, a fraction of water exists from canal to each turnout
(34) for supplying the farmers need; therefore, the volume flow rate
decreases along the canal. The volume of water which passes from
uS each check structure is contributed to a corresponding check
Qnd ¼ ðD2  D2i Þ (34)
2pQt o structure power generation. In some check structures location,
there is a drop from which water falls to the next reach to dissipate
extra energy of passing water.
A view of the investigated canal is shown in Fig. 8. The main
2.3.5. Mechanical power calculation parameters of the structures except turnouts are given in Table 1. To
Considering the flow leakages and power losses in the ideal exactly deliver water to the turnouts, water depth at upstream of
power, mechanical power can be calculated by Equation (35). the check structures must remain within the dead band and as
much as possible at the target depth. In this research, the first check
Qgl þ Qo Pl;b þ Pl;OE þ Pl;h þ Pl;S
Pmech ¼ Pideal :ð1  Þ:ð1  Þ (35) structure (check drop-1) is only examined to design an appropriate
Qt Pideal AST for a better explanation of the methodology.
Note that generator power loss is not included in the above In the design stage, water depth at upstream of the check
equation as well as in this research. Finally, screw mechanical ef- structure is designed exactly at the target depth (design depth);
ficiency (hmech ) is calculated using Equation (36): therefore, the total energy value upstream of the check drop-1 is
the sum of water height and water depth at this point. To calculate
Pmech water depth downstream of the check structures at the specified
hmech ¼ (36) volume flow rate, the ICSS simulations on the canal are needed. The
Pideal
net head H is the difference between the energy at upstream and
Based on the described Equations above, a mathematical model downstream of the check structure.
of AST was implemented in MATLAB 2013a environment to design
appropriate AST for any condition. As hydraulic parameters like
water depths and volume flow rate are calculated using the ICSS
model, the AST mathematical model is started to run.
To find the optimum values of the radial element (dr) and 2.5. ICSS hydrodynamic model
angular element (dq) for numerical integration, the angular
element was first assumed to be 3602p , and several radial elements
The ICSS 4 (ICSS version 4) software was used in this research as
were then investigated. The model convergence results showed an irrigation canal simulation model for simulating the east Aghili
that the volume and torque of a single bucket remain constant for canal. Using the ICSS outputs, available head and hydraulic power
dr  0:0075 ; therefore, dr ¼ 0:0075 was selected to the calcula- can be calculated. This model is a fully hydrodynamic model [29]. It
tions. About ten dr values larger than the optimum value were solves partial differential Saint-Venant Equations and simulates an
investigated. open canal water conveyance system with various structures.
Various hydraulic and hydrologic conditions are the model inputs
2.4. East Aghili canal specification and its simulation as boundary and initial conditions. This model was widely used in
many studies. The inputs to the ICSS model are physical and hy-
Irrigation canals are conveying water from places with a higher draulic parameters, described in the second paragraph of the pre-
height to those of with a lower height. Water is transformed due to vious section as well as Table 1. The ICSS outputs are water depth
its potential and kinetic energies. There are some energy dissipater profile along the canal and volume flow rate of the structures.
2136 K. Shahverdi et al. / Renewable Energy 145 (2020) 2130e2143

Fig. 7. Location of the east Aghili canal in Aghili district [27].

2.6. Validation

To validate the developed Archimedes screw model, Lubitz et al.


[25] experimental data was used. The screw specification used in
Lubitz et al. [25] model is given in Table 2. The results of the Lubitz
et al. [25] experimental model and the developed model in this
research are illustrated in Fig. 9. As shown, the model results have
good agreement with the experimental data, and could accurately

Fig. 8. A view of the east Aghili canal, a) downstream and b) upstream.


K. Shahverdi et al. / Renewable Energy 145 (2020) 2130e2143 2137

Table 1
The main parameters of the east Aghili canal structures except turnouts.

Structure name Water height at upstream of the structure (m) Water height at downstream of the structure (m) Target depth (m) Passing flow

inlet (reservoir) 195.642 195.642 - 1.47


Check Drop-1 192.304 191.194 1.25 1.22
Check-1 188.945 188.937 1.25 1.07
Check-2 188.205 188.25 1.15 0.94
Check-3 187.263 187.22 1.15 0.79
Check Drop-2 185.804 183.844 1.05 0.67
Check-4 183.164 182.964 1.05 0.61
Check-5 182.404 182.254 1.05 0.55
Check-6 181.714 181.604 0.95 0.48
Check-7 180.992 180.904 0.85 0.36
Check Drop-3 179.646 179.244 0.75 0.25
Check-8 178.184 178.024 0.75 0.15

Table 2 predict the screw power specifically around optimum point, i.e. for
Lubitz et al. (2014) experimental screw specification used for validation. rotation speeds of 7e14 rad/s.
Parameter variable unit value

Outer diameter Do cm 14.6 3. Results and discussion


Inner diameter Di cm 8.03
Screw length L cm 0.584
Pitch S cm 0.146
In this section, the results of the ICSS hydrodynamic model for
Flights Number N - 3 prediction of the depth and hydropower potential are first pre-
Rotation speed u rad/s 10 sented. In the next step, the results of the screw performance under
Volume flow rate Qt l/s 1.13 variation of screw length, flight number and inclination angle are
head H cm 25
presented. Finally, the effect of canal volume flow rate and depth
Inclination angle b ᵒ 24.9
Gap width Gw cm 0.0762 are investigated on the screw efficiency.

3.1. ICSS hydrodynamic results

In this section, the results of the ICSS hydrodynamic simulation


are presented. As mentioned, when the existing structures are
replaced with the desired AST, it must be tried to do this without
any considerable changes in the existing conditions of the canal as
well as with low civil works. Designed water depths upstream of
the check structures were target depths. Water depth downstream
of the check structures was simulated for the inlet volume flow rate
of 1.47 m3/s which is the design flow of the canal inlet. The design
volume flow rate for the check drop-1 is 1.22 m3/s. Available head
and hydraulic power in different locations of the east Aghili canal
were calculated (Table 3).
As seen in Table 3, the overall hydraulic power can be produced
in the east Aghili canal is 65.9 kW. In this research, only the check
drop-1 have been considered to design an optimum AST using the
developed model. The accumulative hydraulic power in the first
five reaches of the east Aghili canal is about 77.8% of the total hy-
Fig. 9. Model validation using Lubitz et al. (2014) experimental data. draulic power due to large volume flow rates passing the corre-
sponding check structures.

Table 3
Water depths at upstream and downstream of each check structure, available head and hydraulic power.

Structure name Water depth at upstream of the structures (m) Water depth at downstream of the structures (m) Available head (m) Hydraulic power (kW)

inlet (reservoir) 0.584 0.584 - -


Check Drop-1 1.25 0.529 1.831 21.9
Check-1 1.25 0.717 0.541 5.7
Check-2 1.15 0.82 0.285 2.6
Check-3 1.15 0.528 0.665 5.2
Check Drop-2 1.05 0.588 2.422 15.9
Check-4 1.05 0.622 0.628 3.8
Check-5 1.05 0.59 0.61 3.3
Check-6 0.95 0.529 0.531 2.5
Check-7 0.85 0.388 0.550 1.9
Check Drop-3 0.75 0.295 0.857 2.1
Check-8 0.75 0.249 0.661 1.0
Sum 65.9
2138 K. Shahverdi et al. / Renewable Energy 145 (2020) 2130e2143

Fig. 10. Volume flow rate and water depth variations in check drop-1 during the third month of the winter season.

Table 4
The screw specifications for the check drop-1 in the east Aghili canal.

Parameter variable unit value

Outer diameter Do m 1.5


Inner diameter Di m 0.75
Pitch S m 1.5
Gap width Gw mm 0.762
Fill factor f - 1
Volume flow rate Qt m2/s 1.22
Head H m 1.831
Water density r kg/m3 1000
Gravitational constant g m/s2 9.81

Volume flow rate changes during the cultivation season because


of different water requests of the farmers. According to the Author
investigation and simulations by ICSS, these variations are impor-
tant in the third month of the winter season, 2011 (Fig. 10), in which
crop water requirement and consequently flow variations in the Fig. 11. The screw performance for variation of screw length, and inclination angle at
check drop-1 is high. As shown, water depth is always within the N ¼ 1.

dead band by regulating check drop-1 while flow is varying.


3.3. Structural parameters
3.2. Design criteria
In this section, the AST performance under variation of different
To design an appropriate AST for substituting instead of the structural parameters including screw length, flights number and
check drop-1, some considerations were made. Since the canal inclination angle was considered and optimized. Fig. 11 shows the
geometry changes must remain minimum, the outer diameter of screw efficiency variation under the screw length and inclination
the canal was set to be equal to the base width of the canal, i.e. angle variations with the flight number of 1.
Do ¼ 1.5 m. Based on [18] questionnaire survey on almost 400 As shown, with an increase of the inclination angle, the screw
installed commercial screws in Europe, the pitch and the outer efficiency increases for all lengths until it reaches the peak point
diameter of the investigated screws were nearly equal, and the and then it decreases quickly. Since the volume flow rate is con-
inner diameters were half the outer diameters. So, this accepted stant, the screw rotation speed must increase with the increase of
values for the commercial structures were used for the pitch and inclination angle and consequently mechanical power will be
inner diameter values. The last ratios, i.e. S ¼ 1.5 m and Di ¼ 0.75 m, increased as well as efficiency. After peak point, both hydrostatic
were taken in this research. Also, the optimum performance of the pressure and therefore generated torque decrease and friction po-
ASTs in term of fill factor reported f ¼ 1 was used [25]. The screw wer losses increase which cause efficiency decreases quickly. Since
parameters for the check drop-1 in the east Aghili canal are pre- upstream and downstream water depths are constant, the mini-
sented in Table 4. mum value of the inclination angle differs for each screw length.
Several simulations were performed based on the various The minimum value of inclination angle for the shorter screw is
inclination angles, flights number, and screw lengths to obtain the higher than that of for larger screw; therefore, curves move to the
optimum structure of an AST for using instead of the check drop-1 left hand with a screw length increase.
in the east Aghili canal. The same methodology can be used for In case of peak point on the curves, peak point for screw length
designing the optimum structure of an AST for generating with the of 4 m is 44.3%. As screw length increases, bucket numbers and
highest mechanical power in the other structures of the canal. All consequently torque, mechanical power and efficiency all increase
power losses existed in an AST system were taken into account in as well as friction power losses. In screw length of 6 m produced
the modeling.
K. Shahverdi et al. / Renewable Energy 145 (2020) 2130e2143 2139

mechanical power is highest and friction power losses are not yet
dominant in the system. Increasing screw length to the 7 m, me-
chanical power is still increasing but the values of the friction po-
wer losses are very high (friction power loss in the rotational
direction is a function of rotation speed with the order of 3), and
therefore peak point falls down. As seen in Fig. 11, the highest ef-
ficiency was obtained 90.83% for the screw length of 6 m, inclina-
tion angle of 20 and flight number of 1. This is the best
performance compared to the other investigated screw lengths.
Such a high efficiency in the AST system was reported in Ref. [22]
and by Ritz-atro company in Germany (www.ritz-atro.de). Since
screw length and net head are constant during each modeling,
therefore minimum value of the inclination angle for each length is
different.
For the optimum screw length, efficiency variation under the
screw inclination angle and flights number variations were shown
in Fig. 12. Inclination angle ranges between 17O and 45O, and flight Fig. 13. Variation of the mechanical power under variation of flight numbers, and
numbers change from 1 to 5. The Archimedes screw with the flight inclination angles at screw length of 6 m.
number of 1 resulted in the best performance of 90.83% atb ¼ 20+ .
When flights number increases at a specific screw length, friction
losses increase and cause the efficiency to be decreased. Fig. 15a, b, and c show variation of efficiency investigated under
Fig. 13 depicts a variation of the mechanical power under vari- variation of inclination angles, flight numbers for screw length of
ation of flight numbers and inclination angles at the screw length of 4 m, screw length of 5 m, and screw length of 7 m, respectively.
6 m. The mechanical power of the point with peak efficiency is Also, Fig. 16a, b, and c show those of for the mechanical power.
19.9 kW for N ¼ 1 and b ¼ 20+ as efficiency diagram (Fig. 12). Since These behaviors are the same as those of for screw length 6 m, and
the hydraulic power is constant and is equal to 21.9 kW, values of the same discussion and reasons may be presented. It may only be
the efficiency and mechanical power have the same behavior. noticed that for screw lengths of 4 and 5 m, efficiency corresponded
Fig. 14 shows the variation of power losses, mechanical power, to the flight number of 3 are higher. For screw lengths 7 m, this
rotational speed, and torque under variation of inclination angle at occurred at N ¼ 2.
L ¼ 6 m and N ¼ 1. It could be seen in Fig. 14 that as the inclination
angle increases the screw rotation speed also increases in order to 3.4. Performance parameters
stay a constant volume flow rate passing under the check drop-1 at
the design value of 1.22 m3/s. Also, as the inclination angle in- Effect of volume flow rate on the AST performance was
creases, the screw end is submerged within the outlet receiving considered in this section. As said, analysis of the volume flow rate
canal because screw length and water levels at the upstream canal of the canal and the ICSS simulations showed that the water flow
and downstream receiving canal are all constant. Increasing screw ranges between 1.06 and 1.35 m3/s at the check drop-1. Considering
rotation and screw submersion cause bearing power loss, friction the target depth and the dead band values, water depth deviation is
power loss and submersion power loss increase and to be dominant between 1.125 and 1.375 m (±10% of the target depth) which are
in the system. Therefore, efficiency decreases after inclination angle upper and lower limit of the dead band, respectively.
ofb ¼ 20+ . While power losses are increasing, the mechanical po- In Fig. 17, efficiency and mechanical power of the AST were
wer is decreasing. At b ¼ 25:5+ , the mechanical power and sum of considered under volume flow rate variations. The optimized AST
all power losses are equal and then power losses are become have the flight number of 1, screw length of 6 m, and the inclination
greater than mechanical power, meaning all powers converted to angle of 20, the rotation speed of 9.54 rad/s, upstream water depth
the power losses. of 1.25 m and design flow of 1.22 m3/s. The effect of the flow vari-
ations was investigated for the optimized AST (Fig. 17).
There are some important points in Fig. 17 as volume flow rate
was changed between its maximum (1.35 m3/s) and minimum
(1.06 m3/s) values. As an AST is substituted in the canal, water depth
upstream of the AST is controlled by AST mechanism. Water depth
at the downstream canal is always constant because there is a weir
at the end of the downstream canal. As volume flow rate to the
check drop-1 is increasing from the lower flow and since rotation
speed is constant, the resultant pressure and torque values in-
crease. This fact increases produced mechanical power. Also, the
volume flow rate increase causes the hydraulic power to be
increased. In this condition, efficiency decreases because the vol-
ume flow rate has more impact on the mechanical power than
hydraulic power.
For lower volume flow rate, the efficiency is higher, but the
mechanical power is 17.24 kW. The mechanical power at the opti-
mum point is 19.90 kW and corresponding efficiency is 90.83%. As
the maximum point is reached, optimum efficiency and maximum
produced mechanical power are reached. Also, the water level is
Fig. 12. Efficiency variation as a function of screw inclination and flights number for reached to the highest point of the inner cylindrical shaft means fill
screw length of 6 m. factor is 1. After this point, the hydraulic power increase will
2140 K. Shahverdi et al. / Renewable Energy 145 (2020) 2130e2143

Fig. 14. Variation of power losses, mechanical power, rotational speed, and torque under variation of inclination angle at L ¼ 6 m and N ¼ 1.

Fig. 15. Efficiency of the screw under variation of inclination angles, flight numbers, at a) L ¼ 4 m, b) L ¼ 5 m, and c) L ¼ 7 m.
K. Shahverdi et al. / Renewable Energy 145 (2020) 2130e2143 2141

Fig. 16. Variation mechanical power under variation of inclination angles, flight numbers, at a) L ¼ 4 m, b) L ¼ 5 m, and c) L ¼ 7 m.

Fig. 17. The screw performance for a range of volume flow rate variations.
2142 K. Shahverdi et al. / Renewable Energy 145 (2020) 2130e2143

Fig. 18. Water depth variation after the optimum designed AST installing.

Table 5
Optimum values of the screw for various flights number.

Inclination angle (ᵒ) Screw length (m) Mechanical power (kW) Efficiency (%)

N¼1 20 6 19.9 90.83


N¼2 26 6 19.23 87.8
N¼3 22 7 18.06 82.41
N¼4 26 6 15.8 71.2
N¼5 26 6 13.76 62.8

continue because volume flow rate increases and contributed water efficiency and mechanical power for other values of the flight
depth in hydraulic power generation is fixed; therefore, overflow number were acceptable (Table 5). For example, for N ¼ 3 which is a
leakage will occur and mechanical power is reducing. typical value for the flight number, the mechanical power was
Design volume flow rate and design head are equal to 1.22 m3/s obtained 18.06 kW and corresponding efficiency was 82.41%.
and 1.25 m respectively. The maximum efficiency is expected to be For real plants, financial efficiency is more important than me-
occurred at the design flow rate and design head. The maximum chanical efficiency, and these two do not usually occur simulta-
mechanical power occurred at the design flow rate, but efficiency neously. In a study like this, it is difficult to estimate financial
was not maximum at this point. The reason for this phenomena is efficiency, because the cost of parts and construction is difficult to
that a dead band must be defined in irrigation canals. This causes estimate. This work only was investigated mechanical power, but
water depth is not fixed at the target depth exactly, but it is not electrical power or financial efficiency.
established within the dead band. This causes water height
contributed to hydraulic power to be variable and between upper
and lower dead band. Depending on the water depth position 4. Conclusions
within the dead band, the hydraulic power and consequently effi-
ciency are variable. Therefore, maximum efficiency does not occur In the current study, a numerical model of screw system was
at design flow rate necessarily. The water depth variations in Fig. 17 developed in MATLAB 2013a to the optimal design of an appro-
confirm this claim. priate AST for substituting instead of irrigation canal structures.
Water depth in the presence of the AST was added to Fig. 10 and This optimization was conducted for a case study in east Aghili
illustrated in Fig. 18 to have a comparison between flow and water canal, Khuzestan province, Iran. The first check structure (check
depth variation before and after the AST application. As seen, when drop-1) was considered for this purpose, and an optimum AST was
volume flow rate variation is significantly higher than design flow, designed to be substituted instead of check drop-1. The ICSS hy-
for example, 1.35 m3/s, water depth at upstream of the dead band drodynamic model was used for simulating the canal condition
exceeded upper dead band limit; however, it does not have including water depth and flow in the structures.
considerable deviation. Also, water depth decreases for less volume To design an optimum AST, different structural parameters of
flow rate than design flow and vice versa regardless of the initially the screw turbine were considered including screw inclination
established water depth. angle, number of flights, and volume flow rate of water. Available
In could be concluded that mechanical power for the designed head and hydraulic power in different locations of the canal were
AST is between 17.24 kW and 19.90 kW and the canal mechanism calculated using ICSS. The overall hydraulic power that can be
remain almost constant for most of the volume flow rate occurred produced in the canal was obtained 65.9 kW. Hydraulic power
in the canal. There was only a small impact on the water depth for existing in check drop-1 was 21.9 kW.
high volume flow rate. Now, ASTs can be suggested to be applied in Due to existing conditions of the canal and for low civil works,
the irrigation canals guarantying high efficiency. the outer diameter of the screw was chosen equal to the canal
Although N ¼ 1 was investigated as an optimum choice, width (1.5 m). Also, the inner diameter and pitch of the screw were
selected 0.75 m and 1.5 m, respectively.
K. Shahverdi et al. / Renewable Energy 145 (2020) 2130e2143 2143

The best screw, with the highest efficiency, which can be of Archimides (Screw) Turbin on the Micro-hydro Power Plant, 2012.
[10] D.M. Nuernbergk, C. Rorres, Analytical model for water inflow of an Archi-
substituted instead of check drop-1 was a screw with the length of
medes screw used in hydropower generation, J. Hydraul. Eng. 139 (2012)
6 m, inclination angle of 20 , flight number of 1, and the rotation 213e220.
speed of 9.54 rad/s. The highest efficiency was obtained 90.83% for [11] C. Rorres, The turn of the screw: optimal design of an Archimedes screw,
the optimum screw, and corresponding mechanical power was J. Hydraul. Eng. 126 (2000) 72e80.
[12] Y. Liu, L. Tan, Tip clearance on pressure fluctuation intensity and vortex
obtained 19.90 kW. The mechanical power for a wide range of the characteristic of a mixed flow pump as turbine at pump mode, Renew. Energy
volume flow rate around design flow (1.22 m3/s) occurred in the 129 (2018) 606e615.
canal in the third month of the winter season, in 2011, was ranged [13] Y. Hao, L. Tan, Symmetrical and unsymmetrical tip clearances on cavitation
performance and radial force of a mixed flow pump as turbine at pump mode,
between 17.24 kW and 19.90 kW. Renew. Energy 127 (2018) 368e376.
The results showed that the optimum screw designed in this [14] T. Lei, X. Zhifeng, L. Yabin, H. Yue, X. Yun, Influence of T-shape tip clearance on
research have no considerable effect in the canal condition and can performance of a mixed-flow pump, Proceedings of the Institution of Me-
chanical Engineers, Part A: Journal of power and energy 232 (2018) 386e396.
be substituted successfully instead of the check drop-1. Substitut- [15] Y. Wang, X. Huo, Multiobjective optimization design and performance pre-
ing irrigation canals check structures with an optimum AST which diction of centrifugal pump based on orthogonal test, Advances in Materials
can be designed using this research methodology is recommended Science and Engineering 2018 (2018).
[16] M. Liu, L. Tan, S. Cao, Design method of controllable blade angle and
for future works. orthogonal optimization of pressure rise for a multiphase pump, Energies 11
(2018) 1048.
Acknowledgement [17] G. Müller, J. Senior, Simplified theory of Archimedean screws, J. Hydraul. Res.
47 (2009) 666e669.
[18] A. Lashofer, W. Hawle, B. Pelikan, State of technology and design guidelines
Reyhaneh Loni, B. Ghobadian, and G. Najafi are grateful to the for the Archimedes screw turbine, in: Meeting of Hydro, 2012.
Tarbiat Modares University (http://www.modares.ac.ir) for finan- [19] O. Dada, I. Daniyan, O. Adaramola, Optimal design of micro hydro turbine
cial supports given under IG/39705 grant for renewable Energies of (archimedes screw turbine) in arinta water fall in ekiti state, Nigeria, Res. J.
Eng. Appl. Sci. 4 (2014) 34e38.
Modares research group. [20] R. C Zafirah, A. Nurul Suraya, Parametric study on efficiency of archimedes
screw turbine, ARPN Journal of Engineering and Applied Sciences 11 (2016)
References 10904e10908.
[21] А. Stergiopoulou, V. Stergiopoulos, E. Kalkani, Towards a First CFD Study of
Innovative Archimedean Kinetic Energy Conversion Systems in Greece, Pro-
[1] K. Kusakana, J. Munda, A. Jimoh, Economic and environmental analysis of ceedings of the 5th IC-EpsMsO, 2013, pp. 634e640.
micro hydropower system for rural power supply, in: Power and Energy [22] A. Lashofer, W. Hawle, B. Pelikan, Betriebsbereiche und Wirkungsgrade der
Conference, 2008. PECon 2008, IEEE 2nd International, 2008, pp. 441e444.
Wasserkraftschnecke, Wasserkraftprojekte Band II: Ausgew€ €ge aus
ahlte Beitra
IEEE. der Fachzeitschrift WasserWirtschaft, 2014, p. 154.
[2] S. Khurana, A. Kumar, Small hydro powerda review, Int. J. Tumor Ther. 1
[23] G. Dellinger, A. Terfous, P.-A. Garambois, A. Ghenaim, Experimental investi-
(2011) 107e110. gation and performance analysis of Archimedes screw generator, J. Hydraul.
[3] J. Du, H. Yang, Z. Shen, J. Chen, Micro hydro power generation from water Res. 54 (2016) 197e209.
supply system in high rise buildings using pump as turbines, Energy 137 [24] G. Dellinger, P.-A. Garambois, N. Dellinger, M. Dufresne, A. Terfous, J. Vazquez,
(2017) 431e440. A. Ghenaim, Computational fluid dynamics modeling for the design of
[4] M.R.B. Khan, R. Jidin, J. Pasupuleti, S.A. Shaaya, Optimal combination of solar,
Archimedes Screw Generator, Renew. Energy 118 (2018) 847e857.
wind, micro-hydro and diesel systems based on actual seasonal load profiles [25] W.D. Lubitz, M. Lyons, S. Simmons, Performance model of archimedes screw
for a resort island in the South China Sea, Energy 82 (2015) 80e97.
hydro turbines with variable fill level, J. Hydraul. Eng. 140 (2014), 04014050.
[5] H. Lavric, A. Rihar, R. Fiser, Simulation of electrical energy production in [26] A. Kozyn, W.D. Lubitz, A power loss model for Archimedes screw generators,
Archimedes screw-based ultra-low head small hydropower plant considering Renew. Energy 108 (2017) 260e273.
environment protection conditions and technical limitations, Energy 164
[27] H. Savari, M. Monem, K. Shahverdi, Comparing the performance of FSL and
(2018) 87e98. traditional operation methods for on-request water delivery in the Aghili
[6] E. Tasdemiroglu, Development of small hydropower in Türkiye, Energy 18
network, Iran, J. Irrig. Drain. Eng. 142 (2016), 04016055.
(1993) 699e702. [28] K. Shahverdi, M.J. Monem, M. Nili, Fuzzy SARSA learning of operational in-
[7] A. Kozyn, S. Ash, W. Lubitz, Assessment of archimedes screw power genera- structions to schedule water distribution and delivery, Irrig. Drain. 65 (2016)
tion potential in Ontario CCTC 2015 paper number 1570095585, in: Climate 276e284.
Change Technology Conference, 2015. Montreal. [29] D.H. Manz, M. Schaaljez, Development and Application of the Irrigation
[8] REN21, Renewables 2013: Global Status Report, Renewable Energy Policy
Conveyance System Simulation Model, 1992.
Network for the 21st Century, 2013.
[9] L. Lisdiyanti, Y. Hizhar, B. Yulistiyanto, Effect of Flow Discharge and Shaft Slope

You might also like